r/EndFPTP • • Apr 06 '25

Imagine if we had fusion voting in other states. It would lead to a multiparty democracy.

Post image
0 Upvotes

In the 1960 presidential race, New York’s electoral votes decided JFK's presidency. Likewise, FDR and Ronald Reagan secured New York’s electors by fusing with minor parties, whose vote totals exceeded the margin of victory.


r/EndFPTP • • Mar 31 '25

How Fusion Voting enabled the abolition movement

0 Upvotes

Perhaps the most famous example of the power of fusion voting was the election of Massachusetts Senator Charles Sumner, who was elected in 1850 by a fusion of Free Soil and Whig votes.


r/EndFPTP • • Apr 10 '21

Debate The Biggest Threat to Ranked Choice Voting? Andrew Yang.

Thumbnail
washingtonmonthly.com
0 Upvotes

r/EndFPTP • • May 21 '26

Debate I am losing my mind

0 Upvotes

What has PR/ranked choice done for any sovereign state that uses it?? You contrive a majority by reducing the choices available to people. STV and IRV have all been given their chance - but people are CONVINCED that it does something special just because they are currently using an even worse system.

They’re marginally better than FPTP, so you put them on a pedestal - but go to somewhere that already has STV or IRV, and what do they say? Are the electorate happy? Do they vehemently defend their system? Most likely not!!

This idea that we need fragmented governments filled with sectarian minority parties is just insane.

I don’t understand why people are so married to the concept of STV or IRV when we have lots of real world data concerning how elections actually play out over time and how we are still left with similar duopolies.

Whereas I see the most insane arguments against Approval Voting. The attacks on Approval Voting are always based on maximal strategic voting - even though the evidence suggests that Approval Voting encourages people to vote more sincerely.

Similarly, the fact that bullet voting makes it ‘identical’ to FPTP is a FEATURE - not a bug!! It makes it an easy sell to the electorate and prevents the need for explaining weird scenarios to them (at it’s worse, it’s the same as we already have now - at it’s best, a lot more people are happy)! It’s low risk and prevents tons of backlash.

Not to mention, when people talk about approval voting - everyone always talks about elections with 0 context or as if they exist within a vacuum rather than actual election cycles. No one wants to talk about the indirect election effect that approval votes have - in the way that they might not give you exactly who you want today - but they boost approvals of your favourite candidates and prevent you needing to give out so many ‘safety’ votes next time around.

Over time, loud minorities get drowned out - and that is a GOOD thing!! Representation should spread out from the median - not in from the fringes!!

I seriously struggle to understand. The experts are genuinely in agreement that range-voting methods work best. And you only have so much political capital - especially when it comes to something as unpopular as electoral reforms.

I live in the UK, and the way that everyone is rallying behind STV seriously makes me worry about the backlash and pushing progress back decades. Once we change it - that’s it. We don’t get another chance - and the electorate will say “we already tried that, and now you’re just going to change things to try to get what you want again!” My brain hurts just thinking about it.

Edit: another thing. People always say “How do I know where to cut off my vote/approvals?” And the answer is literally that you just don’t vote for anyone who you DISapprove of. If everyone did that then you would get a proper democracy where pure numbers actually determine the outcome. Sure, you can say “well is that what people would actually do?” And the answer is that people will be responsive to the political environment.

When populist politics are high, people will withhold votes from “the other side” more readily - and elect the ‘mildest’ candidate - but when politicians are building consensus with each other and working together, people will hand out votes more liberally - and then you get a positive feedback loop towards particular candidates with the most hype.

I just don’t understand why we don’t want that??


r/EndFPTP • • Aug 10 '22

The Green Party As The Only Advocate For Direct Democracy

0 Upvotes

The Green Party is the only political party that promotes direct democracy in our electoral campaigns and our platform. Direct democracy is the process through which the important issues and ideas that the Green Party supports can best be implemented. It is the putting into practice of our vision of a future society. A society that would be democratically run on all levels, especially the political, economic, and infrastructure levels.

Worker councils and popular assemblies, democratically organized in the workplace and local areas, would decide on public policies together. Worker, farmer, and tenant cooperatives would replace global corporations with sustainable local economies based on democratic decision making. These could then form trade associations for the purpose of industrial and agricultural specialization. Other methods of direct democratic decision making would include participatory budgeting, community land trusts, initiative and referendum, and police review boards.

A society where the collective good is prioritized by a real political and economic democracy would foster voluntary cooperation. A decentralized democratic society would minimize the layers of hierarchy which create inequality of wealth, so you have not only the freedom but also the resources and the ability to meet basic needs. Direct democracy transforms individual free choices into equally shared collective action. It demonstrates that individual freedom and collective benefit are not mutually exclusive. Direct democracy is the process where the methods of health or security or the social good is determined by the people themselves. The inclusive participation of direct democracy expresses the cooperative ownership of the society.

That is what the Green Party is fighting for.


r/EndFPTP • • Nov 27 '25

Discussion In defense of presidential system

1 Upvotes

Presidential system certainly has its flaws. I am not an advocate for it, but in this post, I wanted to speak about two potential advantages which I think are rarely brought up.

Better proportionality in the parliament

First, presidential system can be beneficial to proportional representation in the parliament. In parliamentary systems, where the legislature chooses the head of government, you really need the parliament to be able to arrive at a conclusion. Otherwise we have a problem and you might even need to call a snap election. This leads the electoral process to employ a variety of methods that reduce proportionality. Smaller districts, electoral thresholds, D'Hondt method – all these things to some extent sacrifice proportionality in order to avoid situations where nobody is able get a required majority for the vote of confidence.

None of this is necessary when the head of state isn't appointed by the parliament. Since we don't need to concern ourselves with this, we can afford a true, unfiltered proportionality. You can have as many parties as you like, they can disagree with each other as much as they want and it won't lead to a paralyze of the country. At worst, we won't be able to pass a new law, but the government can still function normally. Yes, there are other things the parliament needs to pass, like the government budget for the next year, but I think this could also be relegated to the head of state if the parliament fails to reach consensus.

Better separation of powers

The other benefit is to the separation of powers between branches. No matter how you look at this, if your executive branch is appointed by your legislative branch, then you don't really have separation of powers. Electing head of the government directly through election makes sure it is truly independent of the parliament.

Of course, since this makes it much harder to dismiss the head of government, for this to work well we'd have to properly balance the president's powers. For example, I believe the presidential veto should be struck out altogether, especially that it too violates the separation of powers in its own regard.


r/EndFPTP • • Mar 19 '21

Discussion Ranked Choice Voting is so bad, that even FPTP* elects more condorcet winners than RCV.

0 Upvotes

I might shock you, but RCV is so bad of a voting system that modified FPTP is better than it. FPTP+Top Two Runoff like in Georgia senate elections, is a better voting system than RCV(IRV), as it elects condorset winners more than RCV(IRV). Source (From equal.vote/science).


r/EndFPTP • • May 04 '24

The ranked-choice voting fad is finally ending

Thumbnail
thehill.com
0 Upvotes

r/EndFPTP • • Nov 11 '22

Debate Is there a single example in US election history, where IRV would have elected a better candidate than FPTP Top Two Runoff voting?

1 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/EndFPTP/comments/ysiezl/in_what_irv_race_that_happened_in_us_history_fptp/

EDIT: Made a better post, after reading the feedback. Go to that post. The question here was poorly articulated, i improved it there.

What real world election in US history, that used FPTP, would have had a better result, if it used RCV, and not FPTP Top Two Runoff voting?FPTP

Top Two runoff (or Two Round system, or top-two primary, or Runoff election) is a voting system where two candidates with the most votes advance to the runoff election, where there the winner is decided.

It is used in Georgia, Seattle, Louisiana and other places in USA.

Looking at how popular RCV is, it would surely produce at least a single better election, than a variant of FPTP.

Can somebody give one example, from a FPTP election in US history, where RCV would have *probably* produced a better result than FPTP Runoff voting? Just one.

You don't need definitive proof, reasonable assumptions are good enough.

By better candidate, condorcet winner can be used as an example.


r/EndFPTP • • Nov 02 '20

I Have An Idea About A Way To Unite 3rd Party Voters and Democrat Voters

Thumbnail self.vaushv
1 Upvotes

r/EndFPTP • • Jan 06 '25

Discussion Why have so many elected officials and a proportional system if the elected body just operates with majority anyway?

0 Upvotes

Lots of places have 100s of seats at the federal level not to mention provincial levels.

That's a lot of politicians, and it's difficult to keep track of them all. Not to mention party lists where you're not even really voting for a specific person.

Why not just have like 11 seats? Majority is 6 and supermajority is 9.

Then the electorate can really put names to faces and to parties and save a lot of money on salaries.

Obviously the more seats the less of an approximation the proportionality is. But eventually you get to direct democracy. Maybe there is a medium between electing a 4-year dictator (with a majoritarian election) and direct democracy. But it's not clear why hundreds of seats is that medium.


r/EndFPTP • • Jan 15 '26

Median, "voting for a number" and.... Greenland.

0 Upvotes

So....I've long argued (*) that one of the cleanest examples of a game-theoretically stable voting system is when people vote for a numerical value and the outcome is determined by the median. In that setting, the incentives line up unusually well. Exaggeration doesn’t help you, because pushing the outcome past your true preferred point hurts you just as much as being pulled away in the opposite direction. The safest strategy is simply to state your actual ideal value. With real elections and discrete candidates, you can't quite get this purity, but Condorcet methods are best understood as attempts to approximate that same median-seeking ideal under much harder constraints. (i.e. discrete candidates)

The concept came to mind recently because of talk about the U.S. trying to acquire Greenland. Putting aside the politics and the personalities involved (**), the core question is usually framed in the worst possible way: do Greenlanders want to become part of the United States, yes or no? That’s a binary question applied to something that clearly isn't binary.

If the issue were approached more honestly, the question wouldn't be whether Greenlanders "want" it in the abstract, but what dollar value it would take, at minimum, for them to accept it. That’s something individuals can answer in a meaningful way, and it's something that can be aggregated without letting extremes dominate.

Imagine a process where each Greenlander could, by secret ballot, state the minimum amount of compensation they would accept for such a change, with the option of effectively saying no amount at all (i.e. "infinity dollars"). The outcome would be set by the median of those values, and if the offer on the table didn’t meet that number, the deal wouldn’t happen. Everyone would know that asking for too much risks rejection, and asking for too little risks agreeing to something you’d later regret. That's exactly the situation where median voting tends to behave well. Really, it is in each voter's interest to choose the exact value that would be their true minimum they'd accept.

What makes this more than a thought experiment is the scale. Greenland's population is small enough that even a life-changing per-person figure (say $50,000 USD) adds up to only a few billion dollars in total. So at least half the population would have said they find the result acceptable at that price, and therefore no one could plausibly claim the decision was forced or hijacked by outliers.

I'm not arguing that this should happen, or even that it's a good idea. (well, not really. I think Denmark should put the idea out there, though, if only to test the administration's seriousness.)

Mostly, I'm pointing to it as a rare real-world case where numerical voting and median selection aren’t just theoretically elegant, but clearly superior to a yes-or-no referendum. If people are going to talk seriously about territorial acquisition at all, this is much closer to what "asking the people involved" would actually mean.

(*) these have been on my site for 5 years and 20 years, respectively

https://www.karmatics.com/voting/median.html

https://www.karmatics.com/voting/voting-for-a-number.html

(**) I am not for or against the US acquiring Greenland, but I think using military threats and such is over-the-top obnoxious. But if we acquire it in a way that pleases the majority of Greenlanders (and is acceptable to Denmark), I'm fine with it.


r/EndFPTP • • Aug 10 '24

Question What are your thoughts about having multiple Presidents, all elected under a proportional representation system?

0 Upvotes

r/EndFPTP • • Sep 02 '24

So if the biggest complaint is that congress is impotent and can’t pass laws why do you want to further reduce the likelihood of a majority government with proportional seats?

2 Upvotes

Wouldn’t that just end up with 35% party rule like in European parliaments


r/EndFPTP • • Jul 28 '22

Discussion Ranked Choice Voting = Duopoly

Thumbnail
medium.com
10 Upvotes

r/EndFPTP • • Oct 06 '21

Activism Reminder: Tweet @AndrewYang & others TONIGHT! New Twitter handles added! BE NICE!!!

Thumbnail self.endfptp
9 Upvotes

r/EndFPTP • • Sep 27 '26

Discussion If 99% of the Time Parliaments Under PR Choose The Prime Minister To Be the Plurality Winner, Doesn't this undermine PR?

1 Upvotes

Letting a plurality decide who gets disproportionate media attention and reach, and international recognition is part of what is wrong with single-winner plurality voting.

Having a PR legislature just for the them to 99% of the time vote for the prime minister that plurality voting would have chosen feels like just kicking the can down the road.

Sure, you get multiple parties, and representation. But on the world stage, the plurality winner is given wide reach (and sometimes even special powers during wars).

When Israel experimented with directly electing the prime minister with plurality voting it's not surprising to me they ended up just selecting the people from the two largest parties (as measured by plurality/single-rank polling/voting etc.) as the two main candidates.


r/EndFPTP • • Aug 12 '24

Question (Round 3) What is the best way to "Fix" the US Senate?

1 Upvotes

Taking the top 3 choices. I really wish polls had an IRV option.

58 votes, Aug 14 '24
10 Enlarge it and use proportional voting
18 Enlarge it, make it more dependent on state population, and use proportional voting
30 Abolish it! Get rid of it!

r/EndFPTP • • Apr 24 '26

Debate This self-described voting methods "reformer" is sooooo open to critique or analysis he doesn't like.

Post image
2 Upvotes

Notice the little pink box at the bottom.


r/EndFPTP • • Jun 25 '25

Debate Tired of Wasted Votes and 'Spoiler' Candidates? Here's an Election System That Actually Works. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Tired of Wasted Votes and 'Spoiler' Candidates? Here's an Election System That Actually Works.

Hey everyone! We've all been there, stuck in a debate about how to make elections truly reflect the will of the people instead of turning into a tactical game. How can we vote for who we really want without worrying our vote will be "wasted" if our party doesn't meet the threshold?

There’s a hybrid electoral system that solves these exact problems. It's simple for the voter but incredibly effective. Let's break it down.

The core idea is that you get two votes (or one ballot paper split into two parts).

Part 1: Choose Your Local Representative (with Approval Voting)

Instead of placing a single checkmark for one candidate and risking your vote if they don't win, you do this:

✅ You check the box next to EVERY candidate you find acceptable.

You can approve of one, two, or even all of them if you think they'd do a good job. The candidate who receives the most "approvals" wins.

Why this is a game-changer:
This completely eliminates the "spoiler effect." You no longer have to fear that voting for an underdog you genuinely like will accidentally help the candidate you strongly dislike win. You simply approve all the candidates you'd be okay with.

Example:

Let's say there are three candidates in your district.

  • Anna is your ideal candidate.

  • Ben is also a pretty good option; you wouldn't mind if he won.

  • Chris is someone you definitely do not want to see in office.

You place a checkmark next to both Anna and Ben. Other voters do the same. After counting the votes:

  • Anna receives 8 approval checkmarks.

  • Ben receives 5 checkmarks.

  • Chris receives 3 checkmarks.

Result: Anna wins. She is the most broadly acceptable candidate for the majority of voters.

The winners from each district are the first to get their seats in parliament.

Part 2: Vote for Parties (with the "Spare Vote" System)

The second part of the ballot is for party lists. But this part has a clever trick to ensure your vote is never wasted.

➡️ You rank the political parties in your order of preference (e.g., up to 5 choices).

  1. Your first choice.

  2. Your second choice (your backup).

  3. Your third choice, and so on...

Just like in many current systems, there's a threshold (e.g., 5%) to prevent tiny fringe parties from fragmenting the parliament.

So what happens to your vote?

  1. Your vote is first counted for Party #1 on your list.

  2. If that party clears the 5% threshold — great! Your vote has helped them and stays with them.

  3. If they FAIL to clear the threshold — your vote is not wasted! It automatically transfers to Party #2 on your list.

  4. If Party #2 also fails, your vote moves to #3, and so on, until it finds a party that has passed the threshold or you run out of choices.

A Detailed Example (100 voters, 25% threshold for demonstration):

  • 40 voters: 1st choice - The "Reds", 2nd choice - The "Blues".

  • 30 voters: 1st choice - The "Blues", 2nd choice - The "Greens".

  • 20 voters: 1st choice - The "Yellows", 2nd choice - The "Reds".

  • 10 voters: 1st choice - The "Purples", 2nd choice - The "Blues".

Step 1: Count the first-choice votes.

  • Reds: 40 votes (40%) → PASS.

  • Blues: 30 votes (30%) → PASS.

  • Yellows: 20 votes (20%) → FAIL (below 25% threshold).

  • Purples: 10 votes (10%) → FAIL.

Step 2: Transfer the "wasted" votes.

  • The 20 votes for the "Yellows" are transferred to their second choice: the "Reds".

  • The 10 votes for the "Purples" are transferred to their second choice: the "Blues".

Final Party Vote Tally:

  • Reds: 40 (original) + 20 (from Yellow voters) = 60 votes.

  • Blues: 30 (original) + 10 (from Purple voters) = 40 votes.

Result: 100% of votes were counted! No voter was left out just because their favorite small party didn't get enough support.

Putting It All Together: The Final Seat Count

  1. District winners (from Part 1) take their seats in parliament first.

  2. Next, we look at the final party results (from Part 2). We calculate how many total seats each party should get based on its share of the national vote.

  3. From this total quota for each party, we subtract the number of its candidates who already won in districts.

  4. The remaining seats are filled by candidates from that party's list.

This way, the parliament accurately reflects both the local representation of districts and the overall political mood of the country.

The Bottom Line: Why This System Is So Good

👍 Simplicity for the Voter: Checking boxes and ranking numbers is intuitive and takes just a few minutes. No complex strategic thinking is required.

👍 Fairness and Justice: Almost every single vote counts. You no longer have that feeling that your choice was pointless.

👍 No More "Spoilers" or Tactical Voting: Vote with your heart for both candidates and parties. The system ensures your voice is heard.

👍 The Best of Both Worlds: You get a personal representative for your local area, and a parliament that fairly represents the nation's party preferences.

So, what do you think? Could a system like this work in your country? Share your thoughts in the comments!


r/EndFPTP • • Jul 08 '24

Help me not let fascism win!

0 Upvotes

I'm designing an electoral system. How would a proto-fascist are just far-right/far-left party win in a FPTP/PR system, and what steps can stop that?


r/EndFPTP • • Sep 22 '21

Debate A Counterargument - Defense of FPTP

0 Upvotes

r/EndFPTP • • Nov 12 '19

Recent studies show that ranked choice voting has a negative impact on participation due to its complexity. Approval voting is simple and easy to understand.

Thumbnail
sfpublicpress.org
0 Upvotes

r/EndFPTP • • Sep 07 '26

Discussion Imo if we want to end FPTP we need to do it from outside the two major parties

3 Upvotes

The duopoly is perfectly happy with the way voting is currently set up. If we want to end FPTP we need to vote for candidates who aren’t beholden to the very institutions that want to maintain the status quo.

Stop letting political parties, especially the duopoly, control the narrative. They haven’t been given the authority to decide who gets to hold office from constitution. Political parties aren’t mentioned in the constitution at all. George Washington even warned that forming political parties would split the country into factions that seek their own political ends over the health of the country.

If you are politically independent please join r/independent. We don’t need to reform institutions that don’t want to be changed we just need to stop voting for their candidates. People will always say a vote outside the two party system is wasted or “voting for the other side”. It’s long past time that we stop listening to them.


r/EndFPTP • • Jul 29 '23

Discussion I figured out how to let 17 year olds vote legally in every election

0 Upvotes

In the USA, people have to be legal age 18 to vote but lawmakers don't take office until months after an election. Congress for example doesn't meet until January and people who aren't old enough to serve somehow get elected to the senate. I think Joe Biden is an example, other 29 year olds who were elected to the Senate when the constitution says 30. Ted Cruz has questionable cred >HE WAS BORN IN CANADA< for even being able to run for President?!?

An argument could be made that anyone who turns 18 before the representative is sworn in would be eligible to vote as a 17 year old like anyone else. This is a bit technical but it could work to boost younger voters voices. If people serving in the US congress are 'given every opportunity' to "Age into their offices" why shouldn't 17 year olds be allowed to "Age" their vote by voting as 17 year olds as long as they turn 18 before everyone is sworn in? For President - it would be anyone turning 18 before Inauguration day. Those 17 year olds would get to vote for president only, other 'older' 17 year olds would get a regular ballot. A state like mine could easily test this maneuver. Besides, if Trump and Ted Cruz somehow dodge CLEARLY constitutional prohibition on people like them from even running, what makes testing allowing 17 year olds to vote such a bad thing?