r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 12 '20

Flag Proposal Updated flag proposal (new symbolism)

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 04 '20

Grammar Proposal Draft Proposal: The Encapsulated Language be a Word Order Harmonic Language

16 Upvotes

Hi all,

This is a very simple proposal.

In essence, I propose that the Encapsulated Language be a word order harmonic language regardless of whichever word order we eventually adopt.

What is Word Order Harmony?

Word order harmony refers to the tendency, found across the world's languages, to place heads in a consistent position (either before or after) with respect to modifiers or other dependents.

Harmonic Language

English is an example of a harmonic language:

  • Heads precede dependents.

  • Verbs precede objects.

  • Adjectives precede nouns

  • Pronouns precede nouns

  • Adverbs precede adjectives

Now let's focus on just the nominal domain. Here we can clearly see that English is a word order harmonic language: (Number - Adjective - Noun).

Non-harmonic Language

French and Hebrew are examples of non-harmonic languages.

In the nominal domain, French has a non-harmonic word order; adjectives come after nouns (Number - Noun - Adjective).

Why do we care about such this simple detail?

When creating the grammatical concepts underpinning the Encapsulated Language, I wanted to ensure that everything I proposed would help us achieve the aims and goals of this language project.

The primary objective of the Aims and Goals is, “to encapsulate as much scientific and mathematical knowledge as possible”. The overall word order might be able to encapsulate something and I’m still exploring this. However, the secondary objective is to, “facilitate an intuitive understanding of the world around us” and this is what I want you to keep in mind when continuing through this post.

So, I’ve spent the last month looking for studies which show cognitive benefits to specific word orders, patterns, structures etc…

I believe that if we can’t encapsulate something, then we should use structures that have the most cognitive benefit for our future native speakers.

In this regard, I discovered the following study:

A learning bias for word order harmony: Evidence from speakers of non-harmonic languages

This study (and the many that have preceded it) showed that both children and adults favoured harmonic word orders when learning constructed languages in a controlled environment. This study tested native speakers of both harmonic and non-harmonic languages and the results were the same. Subjects showed a consistent bias towards harmonic languages.

This shows that cognitively a harmonic word order is more intuitive.

In Conclusion

I propose that the Encapsulated Language be a word order harmonic language regardless of whichever word order we eventually adopt because this will help facilitate an intuitive understanding of the word around us.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 28 '20

Demo of current phonotactics and a writing system prototype

15 Upvotes

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Sep 03 '20

Orthographic Numerals Proposal Proposed change to numerals (ignore 0 it's already been changed)

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Sep 16 '20

Using Plate Tectonics to divide Earth into continents

13 Upvotes

Quick update

Just as a quick reminder, the main goal of these posts is looking out for ways of naming countries. So far, we have officialised that countries names’ will be adapted from their main language and that two types of affixes will be used to show the continent where the country lies and to form the toponyms of the countries, respectively (see main proposal: https://www.reddit.com/r/EncapsulatedLanguage/comments/ikn0p2/setting_the_bases_of_political_geography_in_our/ ).

By the way, user Flammerate pointed out that we don’t necessarily need to have 12 continents to fit our number system, and I am going to embrace that suggestion, let’s favour logic over numerals (especially now that we have officialised a base-6 numeral system).

Also, I figured I would no longer class these geography posts as 'draft proposals' until we find a more consistent option most of us agree can be adopted as an internal part of the Encapsulated Language.

Plate tectonics division:

The division of Earth’s surface based on tectonic plates has been proposed a few times on the Discord, so I figured I would better talk about it in its own post.

First, let’s see how the tectonic plates can be divided:

Major plates (those larger than 20 million km2):

  • African

  • Antarctic

  • Australian

  • Eurasian

  • North American

  • Pacific

  • South American

Minor plates (only the most visible ones are listed):

  • Arabian

  • Caribbean

  • Cocos

  • Filipino

  • Indian

  • Nazca

  • Scotia

Grouping the plates:

The method I came up with to create the continents is the following one:

  • Every major plate will form its own continent.

  • Minor plates shall be annexed to major plates sharing most part of their continental land, unless they are mainly made up of sea, in which case they will be annexed by the closest plate which shares the sea.

A notable disadvantage of this division is that the frontier sometimes cuts directly through the middle of continuous land. This isn’t a problem in places like the Sinai peninsula (the stretch of land between Africa and Eurasia) because a division is needed at some point. It is however a problem in places such as Iceland, Japan, Mexico or New Zealand, where the border separates a smaller contiguous region into two different plates (by our system, continents).

A possible solution for this would be to edit the frontiers so that continents would encompass contiguous landmasses, the exception being East Siberia, due to its larger size. However, this would make the system lose its main advantage: being geographically consistent through large periods of time.

Regardless, we would be left with seven continents, based on the major plates:

  • Eurasia (including India and Arabia).

  • Africa.

  • Australia.

  • Pacific (includes Cocos, Nazca and Filipino).

  • North America (including Caribbean)

  • South America (including Scotia).

  • Antarctica.

Pros

  • This system has a major point in its favour: continuity. If a map is based on plate tectonics it will be outdated by the time humanity has either gone extinct or figured out a better system to ‘divide’ Earth.

  • Based on natural frontiers and independent from demography: no-one could claim it was done using a bias.

  • Also divides the oceans, making every point on Earth belong to a certain continent (could be useful some time in the future).

Cons

  • North America and East Siberia form a continent together, even though they are uncontiguous land masses.

  • Cultures: it completely ignores the cultural side of geography.

  • As I mentioned, sometimes borders cut directly through the middle of existing land.

  • The major flaw: even though it takes millions of years to form a new plate, it takes just a decade to discover one new plate which could easily spoil our system. Now, this could happen in what I have summarised as two ways:

    • If a border were to be discovered in an area, separating the main continents into two equal-sized plates (e.g.: a border through the middle of Eurasia).

    • If a new minor plate was separated from a major one and better belonged to a different continent mass of land different from the other part of the plate (e.g.: a border separating Eastern Siberia from North America).

Let me picture this using a chart:

Do borders need to be updated?If a major plate divides into two equal platesIf a minor plate is cut from a major one
If the new plate(s) fit well geographically within the previous continentYES*NO
If the new plate(s) DON’T fit well geographically within the previous continentYESYES

*although it depends on whether we want each major plate to be a continent.

Conclusion:

This system could be adopted, but its consistency could be frequently challenged by the discovery of new plates; thus, it might need to be updated regularly.

Personally, I don’t think this sort of division is a good alternative, let me know your thoughts on this and see you in the next post ;)

P.S.: Just so you know: these geography posts aren’t too frequent mainly because I’ve been busy with other projects too (and partly because I love to procrastinate, yikes).


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Sep 14 '20

Script Proposal Proposal for the romanization of /ʔ/

13 Upvotes

Current state:

There is no romanization of /ʔ/

Proposed state:

/ʔ/ is written as an apostrophe when it is imediately before an approximate, or between to vowels that would otherwise make a dipthong.

Reason:

In all other places writing /ʔ/ is redudant, and and since it exists as a null onset, it should be treated as close to not existing as is reasonable.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Jul 23 '20

Official Announcement Reminder of this project's fundamental idea and goal.

13 Upvotes

"We aim to create a Language that encapsulates as much scientific and mathematical knowledge as possible." - Evildea

The goal of this language is encapsulation. We want to figure out systems that will allow us to pack and easily retrieve information from the common words that one would use in daily life, as their current phonemic representations in most languages are usually meaningless. We want to pack meaning into them, not for any purpose of making people more "intelligent" or to make fundamental understandings of science intuitive.

If we ended up recreating Esperanto, English, or some other language, but with individual words recreated to reflect the goal of this language, then that could very well be the end goal of the language. Nothing more would necessarily be needed as the language would succeed at the goal. Students will be instructed with the encapsulated information that their language contains and the effort that the student will go through in terms of memorization will no longer be required. That is all.

There is no lack of purpose in trying to relate the principles of these fields into our creation of the vocabulary. However, the word for 'milk' could just be the instruction for how to perform the quadratic equation. As long as this is mentioned to the student knowing of the language, it will suffice and be useful in the goal that we have.

There's nothing complicated. There's no higher requirement for what we impose. Make a language that's communicable and that hides academic information to be used by a student. That's it.

I post this to remind our community what we're here doing. Each of us must constantly remind ourselves of the following points that we as individuals will have no benefit from knowing or working on this language and that knowing this language is only an investment to the next generation. With this in mind, please refrain from believing that there is anything that can realistically benefit you as a person by knowing or working on this language (beyond the fact that you'll be helping the next generation).

Our goal is entirely selfless, but you may and are encouraged to gain knowledge and experience with your contributions to this language project, as this is a community and we are all trying to help each other.

That is all I would like to say. Have a good day everyone!


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 10 '20

Flag Proposal Flag proposal based on atrawa's idea

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Jul 30 '20

Script Proposal Potential (hopefully) dyslexic fteindly alphabet

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Jul 10 '20

Let's not forget — Encapsulation is the End Game.

12 Upvotes

Hi all,

So I'm constantly thinking about ways we can encapsulate scientific and mathematical knowledge into this language and I had some random thoughts I wanted to share.

Word Construction

I've discussed this quite a bit in discord but I think I've formulated an idea.

Imagine, that our words could work similar to Arabic.

C(V)C(V)C(V)

The constants would represent the root word but the vowels could be changed to create a new unique meaning.

If we use Flamerate's Proposal (as an example) we have 12 vowels that have a number value.

Some of these vowels could also have the secondary meaning of X, Y, * and /.

We could literally code formulas into words! For example, the formula for the area of a rectangle is Width * Height. That is essentially X * Y.

N(v)M(v)S(v) = The constants represent a square-shaped object

N(a)M(e)S(o) = The (a) represents X. The (e) represents multiplication. The (o) represents Y.

The child would learn this word natively then the parent would later tell them how to pull apart the words to find the formula hidden within.

In all honestly, this could probably be achieved through suffixes. This isn't a Draft Proposal. I just wanted people to start thinking about encapsulation and ways it can be achieved.

Proverbs

Even though we're probably a year or more off deciding proverbs, I thought they would be a great example of encapsulation.

Take for example the proverb, "It's raining cats and dogs".

A child learns this proverb by hearing their parents say it when it's pissing down rain. In our language, we could have our own proverb that encapsulates a formula instead.

Instead of saying "Oh look, it's raining cats and dogs" we could say "Oh look, force is equal to mass times acceleration".

This means we'd be teaching a formula to our child who probably wouldn't have a clue what it means but when they're old enough they'd start to realise that this word "force" is linked with everything related to motion. It would become intuitive. Then it would be just a matter for a parent or teacher to explain their own proverb to them and show them the patterns within their own language.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Sep 08 '20

Number Base Proposal Draft Proposal: Change the Encapsulated Language to Base-6

11 Upvotes

Hi all,

u/ActingAustralia, u/Markrocks- and, u/AceGravity12 have raised a Draft Proposal to change the base of the Encapsulated Language to Base-6.

Current State:

The Encapsulated Language uses a Base-12 numbering system.

Proposed Change:

The Encapsulated Language uses a Base-6 numbering system.

Reason:

The reasons for changing the Encapsulated Language to Base-6 can be split up into two categories; mathematical and non-mathematical.

If this proposal is accepted it will have many run-on effects and break different parts of the language. These breaks will need to be fixed through subsequent Official Proposals. Please consider this matter seriously.

Spreadsheet of comparison for Base-12 and Base-6.

Mathematical:

Pros:

  • Less numerals leads to a smaller multiplication table.

  • 6 is the biggest number with only two coprimes, 1 and 5. This means the multiplication table is regular and has a relatively high frequency of numbers which end with a 0.

  • Lower radix economy than base-12.

  • Less "decimal" representation of fractions being overly complicated.

Cons:

  • Requires more digits to represent the same number.

  • Arithmetic takes longer due to more digits (see above).

Non-mathematical:

Pros:

  • Less numerals means it’s also easier to learn, lowering the burden on the child.

  • Counting on fingers is simpler than base-12.

  • Less phonology burden and less of those phonemes being dedicated specifically to numbers.

  • Phonologically difficult trinumeral combinations can be avoided, (for example, 323 is “khykh” and 222 is “ghygh”). This will lower the burden on the first generation of learners (This may or may not help the 1st or 2nd generation natives. We don’t know.).

  • Current script proposals are complex due to the high number of phonological values. This would make the script proposals simpler. This could potentially lower the burden on the child.

  • In base-12, script proposals need to decide for long vowels, whether to encapsulate their numeric value or to show their relationship to the short vowels. That decision is unnecessary in base-6.

  • Colors are less specific by default. Lowering the number of base colours to 6 will remove the base colors which appear very similar to each other. However, those shades will still be possible to express through combinations of the dozenal fraction system, lightness or dullness when needed.

Cons:

  • Other systems will also need modification. This will require a lot of work to update multiple systems. This will specifically impact the phonological value system, the number words and numerals.

  • Base-12 had the benefit of fitting nicely with the current measurements of time. Base-6 will still work but be a little more complex.

  • Words that use the numbers (like colour words) will potentially get longer when more digits are necessary to express the same value.

  • In western music (and thus classical music education, jazz, pop, rock etc) everything revolves around 12-tone equal temperament. In base-12 with sounds that correspond to numerical values, the nomenclature of the notes in the chromatic scale would be dead obvious, opening up easily groupings to encapsulate e.g. the circle of fifth. In base-6 the chromatic scale would need to be named in something less obvious, potentially interfering with further encapsulation.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Sep 07 '20

Base-12 and Base-6

11 Upvotes

There's been a lot of discussion in the math Discord group regarding our use of base-12. A sizable number of members have started raising points that perhaps this language is better suited to base-6 as several of our systems would work more efficiently with that base.

We previously had an official vote on base-12 vs base-6 and base-12 won the vote 18-6. This was one of the first ever official votes which this community undertook.

The Discord members started a Google Doc to collect points on the advantages and disadvantages of base-6 vs base-12. I figured I'd share it here for all of you to provide your input. Please jump into the doc and provide your points of view.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 20 '20

We have an Official Color Word System (Evildea Video)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
11 Upvotes

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 10 '20

Flag Proposal A flag proposal based on the logo and uses horizontal symmetry.

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 04 '20

Chemistry Proposal Chemistry: Naming Atoms and Compounds

11 Upvotes

This chemistry proposal is my contribution on u/MiroslavE0's Chemistry Proposal. This was at first a comment on the said post but I decided to change it a little and make it a post on its own right.

There are a few ways in which you can systematically name elements:

  • Tell the amount of protons in the nucleus. This is a very structerles system which doesn't tell you much about the elements properties. This is not a good system.

  • Tell the group and the period of the element. Which is partially what u/MiroslavE0 uses in their system. It adds a bit of structure and tells you a bit about the element but I think it has some shortcomings. The periodic table has alot of groups and I think we can tell more about the element by adding more structure while fixing the group problem.

  • Tell the block, group number inside the block, and the period of the element.

The elements are put in blocks named s, p, d, and f based on which orbital is their last orbital while neutral in charge. s block has 2 groups, p block has 6, d has A(10), and f has 12(14). With the seperation of the blocks we can create the bare minimum system:

block type

group number in the block

period number

number of atoms

Since there are only 4 blocks they would get a small group in the phonology and in my opinion the most useful group would be the vowels. We'll use the four vowels a, e, i, u.

  • /e/ is the least common of these vowels so it'll be asigned to the least used block f.

  • /i/ is very common but has a tendency to palatalize the consonant it comes across so it'll get the smallest block of s.

  • /a/ is a relatively stable phoneme which can be used for the block p because this block contains the most important elements for organic compounds which are, as one might guess, important for life on earth so they would need to be discussed quite alot.

  • /u/ is left for the block d.

  • Though unlikely if a new block were to be discovered they'd get /o/.

There are a maximum of 12(14) groups in a given block. It's a big if but if another block were to come it would have 16(18) groups. I would like to divide these group numbers into sub groups of 6 and 3.

The 6 part will be expressed through a plosive, nasal, or fricative and the 3 part will be expressed through nothing or an approximant. The 6 group comes before the 3 group and the group number in the given block will be in the onset of the syllable.

  • I will chose those in the 3 part to be ∅, /l/, and /r/ in order.

  • Since the approximants are alveolar chosing the 6 part to have alveolar consonants might cause phonemes like [t͡ɬ] to appear so I'll not pick an alveolar phoneme. I'll chose m, p, f, ʃ, k, x

2 = 2-0 = p- 6 = 6-0 = x- A(10) = 4-1 = ʃl- 12(14) = 2-2 = pr-

There are 7 periods. The period number will come at the coda.

  • Periods will be ∅, /n/, /s/, /l/, /r/, /j/, /w/ in order.

2 = -n 4 = -l 6 = -j

And lastly the number of atoms will use the numeral system. Although the numeral system's phonology may change for all we know, I'll use the currently voted upon system for this comment.

Hydrogen atom: mi eifun

Hydrogen molecule: mi eiɣyn

Oxygen atom: kan eifun

Carbon atom: pan eifun

H2O: mi eiɣyn kan eifun

CO2: pan eifun kan eiɣyn

Glucose molecule: C₆H₁₂O₆ = pan eiʒiːn mi wafun kan eiʒiːn

Helium atom: pi eifun

Iron atom: xur eifun

Gold atom: fluj eifun

NOTES:

  • The numeral 1 may or may not be optional. It ought to be discussed.

  • I think there should be a word/particle to express ''a chemical thing'' so that the language doesn't become a mess.

  • There's no way to specify the charge of atoms/compunds. So, that's a thing to add.

  • The way in which elements are ordered in the compound may be changed though such a desicion must be scrutinized in all angles before a dicision is met.

  • I don't exactly know what causes it I just know it's about electrons so I didn't come up with a way to express the different states metals can be in compunds which has a huge effect in what kind of a compund it is. Like Iron(II)Oxide and Iron(III)Oxide. Though the effect is also visible in the amount of atoms the compound has (Iron(II)Oxide = FO Iron(III)Oxide = F2O3). Though again, chemists like to make that distinction so, it shall be scrutinized in all angles before a decision is met.

  • And this is not a perfect system. Please critisize.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Jul 28 '20

Script Proposal Potential Alphabet

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 28 '20

Script Proposal Mixed Ideographic and Syllabic Writing System

10 Upvotes

Proposal

I propose to adopt a mixed ideographic-syllabic writing system as presented here.

What is part of the proposal?

  1. The decision to write in a system consisting of a ideographic part complemented by a syllabic part.

  2. A system for ideograms consisting of a "Core space", containing the "radical" - the ideographic equivalent of a word root - and a derivation system.

  3. A derivation system containing of:

  • "Function space" which assigns a grammatical function, a role to the radical in core space

  • "Semantic space" which assigns semantic derivations to the radical in core space.

  • Superimposition of radicals in core space

  • Combination of radicals in core space

  • Compound ideograms

  • An optional "sky line" and "earth line" as in Bliss symbols

  1. Four radicals that are part of the derivation system: "Negation", "Opposite", "Person", "Cause"

  2. The systematic of a syllabic script to complement the ideographic script.

  3. The decision to write top-to-bottom and left-to-right both overall and within the syllabic blocks.

What is NOT part of the proposal?

  • Any symbols used in the showcasing / examples, neither for the ideographic nor the syllabic part of the script, unless specifically stated.

Current state

There is currently no official writing system for the encapsulated language.

Reasons

  • ... for ideograms:

    • Ideograms open up an additional "channel" to encapsulate information independent of the spoken language.

    • Ideographic writing is easier to learn for deaf people than a script that represents the sounds of the spoken language.

  • ... for a mixed script:

    • Ideographic writing alone requires a large amount of symbols. A derivation system and a combination with another writing method keeps the number of symbols low.

  • ... for the combination with a syllabary:

    • Ideograms tend to be written a bit bigger than letters and have a higher information density than letters. Grouping letter-like symbols into syllabic blocks of 2-4 symbols improves the ratio of information per cm² on paper.

  • ... for writing top-to-bottom (TTB) and left-to-right (LTR).

    • The vast majority of the world's population is right handed. Writing TTB and LTR decreases smear when hand writing with ink.

    • Ideograms and syllabic blocks are designed to fill a rectangular space of the golden ratio: Width:height 1:1.68. Of course, both could be rotated by 90°, making them wider than high, which is less than optimal when usually writing on paper in "portrait format" as commonly used in notebooks, exercise books etc.

    • The syllabic blocks are read TTB and LTR, so having the same directionality for the script as a whole is only logical.

  • ... for syllabic blocks that are read TTB and LTR

    • The syllabic blocks are constructed by stacking the mandatory V and C component on top of each other, optionally being preceded by the O and/or T component. That way VC is a stable and easily recognisable core of the syllabic block, which positively impacts reading speed, due to pattern recognition.

Jsut as you can polbraby raed and udrensnatd tehse wrods, eevn tuohgh msot of tehm are sepleld wnorg. As lnog as the frist and lsat lteters are in tiehr crocret palecs, you can renogcize tehm fnie. One cn evn leav out som lttrs, and it stll wrks.

The same effect applies to the VC stack.

Details

Syllable Blocks

Sorry to LILPGamer and Beefman for violating their symbols like this. I just wanted to underline that the proposal is about the system, not the symbols.

Basic Ideogram Structure

A character (i.e. an ideogram or a syllable block) occupies a space of the golden ratio (1:φ).

In case of ideograms, the upper fifth of that space is taken up by "function space", which features switches that mainly implement derivations regarding the grammatical function of the ideogram (see below). The lower fifth is taken up by "semantic space" which implements some semantic derivations.

Derivation system

Derivations can be achieved with several methods:

  1. "Switches" in the function and semantic space

  2. Superimposition of radicals

  3. Combination of radicals

  4. Positioning of radicals - Use of skyline and earthling

1. "Switches" for function space and semantics space

For the following examples I used a dummy symbol as a radical. It is NOT part of this proposal. In fact I have specifically chosen a symbol I myself would vote against, if it were proposed. It is used here only to showcase the system.

2. Superimposition of radicals

To illustrate superimposition, let me introduce the first radical that is actually part of this proposal. It's inspired by the toki pona hieroglyph for "ala" and means roughly the same: negation.

If we superimpose this on our dummy radical for death in the adjective "dead" from above, we get "not dead":

3. Combination of radicals

To illustrate combination of radicals, let me introduce three more radicals that are part of the proposal (all of them loaned from Bliss):

Now, four more examples with our silly dummy "death" radical:

4. Positioning of radicals - Use of skyline and earthline

An ideogram can be structured by an earth and/or skyline as in Bliss symbols to explicitly derive by positioning of the radical. In these examples the Bliss symbol for "fruit/vegetable" (not part of this proposal) is once hanging above ground (could be an apple or banana), once grow on the ground (e.g. a strawberry or a melon) and once it grows under ground (e.g. potato or carrot).

In this case, the earthline has actually been drawn, but in many cases the mere partitioning of the core space by knowing where it would be can be enough to assign semantic changes to a radical by positioning.

Compounding

To illustrate compounding, let's assume we actually adopted the Bliss symbol for "fruit/vegetable" into our language. In that case we'd probably want a way to distinguish an apple from an orange, or a strawberry from a melon in writing. One way to do it could be compounding.

Compounding with another ideogram

The following two examples of compound ideograms feature one that governs the other. In both cases, it's the fruit one. The (you guessed it) water symbol in the first example has no switches set in the function space, meaning it is governed by the following symbol. So the compound means something like "water fruit" which could be the way to write "water melon."

In the second example, the fruit symbol comes first, followed by an ideogram that has all the upper switches in the function space set, meaning it is governed by the preceding symbol. So the meaning could be expressed as "fruit of water", which also could be used to write water melon.

Again, these examples are not about the concrete symbols but about the two methods to compound ideograms. In the case of the examples I can't think of a difference in meaning. But there doesn't have to be one. Both methods are simply part of the expressiveness of the written language. Which is a good thing in and of itself, but also opens up options for encapsulation.

Compounding with syllabary writing

Another way to make compounds is to combine an ideogram with one or more syllable blocks. So, to decide whether we have an apple or an orange, we might write:

Full text demo

Last, a quick demo to put all the pieces together. It's a rather well known English text that I squeezed through our newly adopted phonotactic rules and wrote using all the features of the mixed writing system proposed here. Where ever I thought an ideogram might be, I just used a Bliss symbol. Again, this is not about the symbols used, but to get an idea about how the system would work as a whole.

And the handwriting version of the same text:

UPDATE/EDIT:

I chose the stupid "death" symbol as a dummy to underline that I'm not proposing symbols, but a system here. That decision bit me a bit, because some people uttered concerns about whether superimposition is at all practical. So here a few more examples for working superimposition:


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 27 '20

Orthographic Numerals Proposal Proposal to change Numeral 0

10 Upvotes

Hi all,

I propose that we change numeral 0 to a circle similar to the Arabic numeral.

Current State:

Proposed State:

Reason:

  • The dot encapsulates the idea that it means 0 straight lines. However, a circle similar to the Arabic numeral, '0' also encapsulates the same idea (it is also formed from 0 straight lines).

  • The rules relating to Numeral 0 state, "The numeral, '0' can be represented by ∘ (a small circle) when writing the numeral by hand only." This means we'll often write numeral 0 as a circle anyways. Additionally, I consider this alternative way of writing numeral 0 a pointless exception to an otherwise well-designed system.

  • Recently we approved a punctuation mark for dozenal fractions which uses a point. Although this wasn't approved for any final script (only the romanization of our future script), I imagine the script will follow closely in this respect. As a result, we'd have a common number and the dozenal point often sitting right next to each other which could cause ambiguity.

  • In the original debates, the a circle wasn't included as an option because it was considered foreign to the aesthetic. Instead a box was included as an option. The point only won over the box by 2 votes. This happened when the community was a lot smaller.

  • We selected the numerals for 1, 2 and 3 because they encapsulated their physical amounts and secondly because they were similar to the Traditional Chinese Numeral system. This means those three numerals would be a tiny bit easier for the first generation of East Asian learners. Therefore, I believe using a circle similar to the Arabic numeral for '0' would help the first generation of learners in general learn this language a tiny bit faster. Although this is a minor argument and that's why I listed it last.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 08 '20

Script Proposal Idea for a modal ideographic script - Call for brainpower

10 Upvotes

I'm playing around with a concept for an ideographic script for the language. I believe it has the potential to increase the encapsulation capacity. It's still a rough concept and I could really use brainpower to develop it further.

Still, depending on how familiar you are with ideographic script, it might take a lot of information to explain the current state of the concept. I'll do my best to be both as extensive as neccessary and as brief as possible.

I also prepared an explanatory video (~27 min) if you prefer that over reading. [Edit: I had to re-upload the video due to a problem with the audio track. Now fixed]

Short intro to ideographic scripts

You're probably used to alphabetic scripts like they are used in English, Spanish, Russian, Arabic etc. The approach of an alphabetic script is to use a set of symbols and rules to represent the sounds of a spoken language with these symbols. Some languages have very concise rules, like Esperanto, others have more complex and even ambigous rules, like English. But still, all alphabetic scripts represent sound. So, in order to decode the meaning of a written word, you need to decipher the represented sounds and then (if you know the language) you know what it means.

The writing systems of most "alphabetic" languages aren't purely alphabetic though. They use ideographic numerals. To write down the usual number of fingers on one hand, English for example has an alternative to "five" (which is an alphabetic representation of the sounds). One can write the digit "5", which had nothing to do with the sound. It directly represents the idea of that specific quantity. An ideogram.

I have to get one thing out of the way here: Chinese script is often referred to as ideographic. That is only half correct. It's logographic which means that each symbol stands for a word. And that relationship between symbol and word is achieved by a variety of strategies. Only one of these strategies is ideographic. For example, the traditional Chinese character 狼 is an ideogram. It stands for the idea of "wolf" (the pictographic history of that symbol can still be discerned.). Other Chinese characters are used rebus style (imagine a picture of an eye standing for the English word "I" because it sounds the same) etc. etc. If I understand it correctly (I don't speak any Chinese language), they use a similar technique to approximate the sound of foreign words, which is similar to what an alphabetic system does. So Chinese script has ideographic aspects and others that are more concerned with sound.

I don't want to propose a logographic script. I bring this up because it gave me the idea of a "phonetic mode" of an ideographic script that I'll mention later.

General advantages and disadvantages

The advantages of ideograms are obvious. They can be used independently of a spoken language and if you know the symbols, you can read the text and understand it, even if you don't know the spoken language. If you found, for example a Welsh photo album with black and white pictures and the pages had titles like "pedwar ar bymtheg cant dau ddeg dau" you probably could only guess what that title means and when those pictures were taken. If it said "1922" instead, you'd know both.

The advantage of alphabetic scripts is that you (probably) know how to pronounce a new word when you read it for the first time, even if you don't yet know what it means. Even in English (which is comparably hard to predict) you can, for example, pronounce the word "brummagem" correctly, even if you don't know that it's a seldomly used word for "cheap" or "shoddy".

Both advantages are for the most part only relevant for non-native speakers of the language that is written down that way. So they don't interest us much.

Another downside to ideograms relevant to native speakers is that ideographic or logographic scripts tend to have way more symbols than alphabetic scripts. But that's still only a disadvantage in regard to language acquisition.

Potential for encapsulation capacity

Now, let's compare alphabetic and ideographic scripts with regard to encapsulation.

Alphabetic scripts – by definition – encapsulate sound. And if they are cleverly designed, as are the various ideas that are currently discussed in the community (e.g. 1, 2, 3) they can encapsulate more information about the sounds they represent, but that's it. And that's really all they can represent, because you don't know beforehand what they will represent when a person combines them to form words.

Ideograms – because they represent ideas, concepts etc. – have the potential to encapsulate different information for each represented idea. As examples, I use ideograms from a constructed language called Bliss. It's often referred to as "Bliss symbols" or "Bliss symbolics".

This is the ideogram for "electricity". Please note, it's not a pictogram. It doesn't mean lightning, it represents the idea, the concept of electricity.

This is the ideogram for "sky". Just a line on top of the space of the symbol.

This, now, is the symbol for lightning. Sky and electricity are superimposed on one another, so it's something like "sky electricity".

Now, imagine English would be written with symbols like that and compare it to the situation with an alphabetic script. A native English speaker has a distinct word for the phenomenon: "lightning". The word has similarities to another word: "light". So the spoken language encapsulates the fact "lightning" has something to do with "light". An alphabetic script can underline this sonic relationship. One can see the similarity in sound. An ideographic script can encapsulate something else. Additional information. In this case, it would encapsulate the fact that lightning has also to do with electricity.

An ideographic script would allow us to encapsulate not only information that is already there in the sounds of the words, but additional information, independent of sound.

The problem with Bliss

So, why not simply use Bliss? While I love Bliss and am fascinated by it, I still see two problems for it's use in this project.

  1. Its symbols haven't been designed for encapsulation. I think we can do better.

  2. Multi-character Bliss words are not always achieved by superimposition, but also by arranging symbols in a sequence, or by a mixture of those. So unlike in an alphabetic script or in Chinese script, where each character roughly takes up the same space, an ideogram composed of several others might take up much more space. That means in Bliss, in many cases one can not quickly discern words from whole sentences.

Here's the bliss word for "counselor", for example:

And this is the sentence "A person speaks their mind in order to help."

This characteristic of Bliss is the result of the attempt to keep the number of symbols down. I don't like it, even though it's better than the situation in Chinese script where it is estimated that you need to know around 1500 characters to achieve functional literacy.

My approach to an ideographic writing system

I'm exploring whether it's possible to come up with a system that uses a fixed amount of space per character, gives us room to encapsulate inside the ideograms and still tries to keep the number of symbols low.

The approach I'm following to do this is inspired by Esperanto's word building system of word roots modified by various affixes. I tried to transfer that idea to an ideographic script.

Basics

To do so, I separated the space reserved for an ideogram in three segments:

  1. Prefix-space

  2. Core-space

  3. Suffix-space

In Core-space, we will find the actual ideogram, the "core". Think of it as the root of a word. It has a skyline and an earthline like in Bliss, but don't worry about that for now.

The other two spaces are divided into six segments each. They work like switches and can either be turned off or on. What each switch signifies is still very much under development. But the basic idea is that they function like affixes that modify the meaning of root, just like in English the suffix "-s" turns a house into houses or the prefix "un-" turns the dead into undead.

For demonstration purposes I assigned proto-meanings to the switches like this:

To mark a switch as turned on, one simply draws a diagonal line towards the center (for the left and right columns) and for the middle column a tack; up tack "⊥" for the upper switch, down tack "⊤" for the lower switch. That means, that if all switches were set, it would look like this:

That way the switches take the form of diacritics that should be recognisable shapes for a competent speaker. Let's look at some examples. For the core space I'll use the Bliss ideograms that I already showed you.

Let's start with two simple nouns "electricity" and "lightning":

Next, two verbs, one in present and one in past tense: "electric current flows" and "lightning occurred"

An adjective "electric" and an adverb ~ "like lightning". (Note that I combine the switches for object and quality for an adjective and for process and quality for an adverb. Not sure if that is a good idea...)

Now, let's use the suffix space, too. For example, "electrify" in present tense:

What about "electrocute" in future tense as in "Don't touch that, you'll electrocute yourself!"? (Note how much work this system still needs. This symbol could also mean that something is made to be no longer electric and that the speaker thinks that is a good thing.)

Okay, last example. "In an ongoing process, something became non-electric" as in: "The battery went flat."

Comments, Thoughts and Questions

  • The prefix and suffix system needs a lot of work, but I think the examples show there is potential to cover a lot of variants of meaning around the same ideogram.

  • This enables us, I think, to leave everyday language stuff like tenses, plural etc to the prefix and suffix system and concentrate on the encapsulation capacity of the ideograms.

  • I imagine that the diverse combinations of lines in prefix and suffix space would be reasonably easy to read for a practiced reader. They act like diacritic markers and "native readers" would just intuitively know that e.g. the suffix set of the last example means "gradually unbecome".

  • For our examples in core space, I used Bliss characters. We can do that, but I also think we can come up with ideograms that encapsulate a lot more than Bliss characters can.

  • That said, even with Bliss we could encapsulate more than with any alphabetic script.

  • What are sensible choices for the meaning of the "switches" in Prefix- and Suffix-space

  • How can we get the most combinations out of it, while still maintain a level of complexity that is intuitively usable?

  • How could ideograms look like that encapsulate more effectively than Bliss characters? Can we adapt them? Or create something new from scratch?

  • Phonetic mode: How do we switch it on? Which symbols do we then use for their phonetic values? The numerals for example? Can we cover all the sounds in the language with them?


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Aug 02 '20

An Idea for Official Romanization off of u/ActingAustralia

10 Upvotes

An Idea for Official Romanization off of u/ActingAustralia

IPARomanization
mm
nn
pp
bb
tt
dd
ff
vv
ss
zz
ʃsh
ʒzh
t͡sts
d͡zdz
t͡ʃtsh
d͡ʒdzh
ll
ɾr
jj
ww
kk
gg
xkh
ɣgh
IPARomanizationRomanization 2
iii
i:iiî
yyy
y:yyŷ
uuu
u:uuû
eee
e:eeê
ooo
o:ooô
aaa
a:aaâ
IPARomanization
ai̯ai
ei̯ei
oi̯oi
au̯au
eu̯eu
ou̯ou

r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Jul 26 '20

Never grow attached

10 Upvotes

Hi all,

Evildea here; Instigator of the project.

I founded this project exactly 39 days ago and have watched it evolve in ways I never originally anticipated. That's why I've decided to write this post.

Never grow attached...

I know some of you have put your heart and soul into forming your ideas and putting them out there for the community to critique and in some cases tear apart. But whatever you do, never grow attached to your idea.

Our project is a living beast and your Proposals are merely its food

That sounds dramatic, but let me show you what I mean:

  • Even if your idea somehow survives the initial community onslaught.

  • Even if your idea somehow wins out against other competing ideas in an Official vote.

  • And even if your idea is Officialised... that's not the end of it.

I can guarantee you that even after Officialisation your idea won't just be slotted into the the language and that will be the end of it. No, instead it will then undergo vote after vote over days, weeks and perhaps even months that will chip away at your original creation, merging it into the whole that is "The Encapsulated Language".

Basically, your idea will be consumed by the project and the end result will be nothing like you imagined.

Case and point

Here is what the original proposal for the Numerals looked like:

Here is what we ended up with:

Even this may change again.

So, I repeat, Don't grow attached to your ideas, because your idea will no longer be yours if the project accepts it.

I created this project but even I'm not its master. I am just a cog in the machine feeding the beast.

My dramatic 7:34 am post has now come to its conclusion.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Jul 25 '20

Country Names Proposal Ideas on continental division

10 Upvotes

Prologue:

You may have realised that the title doesn’t say ‘proposal’, this is because, although ithis was originally planned as a proposal, it has ended up being more of an essay with some quick philosophy about how we should divide Earth.

This post was in some part inspired by Evildea, who, in my last post about the topic (https://www.reddit.com/r/EncapsulatedLanguage/comments/hiqruk/expansion_on_earths_division_without_using/?ref=share&ref_source=link), pointed out that, for example, New Zealand and Australia were in different grids despite having similar cultures. On that note, I decided to embrace wholly the differences and similarities between cultures (don’t worry, it will just be this one post).

The systems you are about to read will not probably make it to the end, but I think we should consider many aspects of them when choosing the adequate system. Thanks for reading.

Disclaimer: with the following information I do not intend to offend any people group nor to discriminate any ethnicity whatsoever. My main goal is to have an accurate representation of human descendance in the globe useful for The Encapsulated Language Project.

Having said all of that, prepare for a long and tedious talk about demographics :D

Today, unlike in previous posts, I will be presenting two ways of dividing Earth closer to the humanistic side than to the scientific one:

  • A mainly ethnic division.

  • A continental division adapted from one I developed some time ago.

Mainly ethnic and cultural division

Now, I know ancestry and ethnicity are no easy topics to discuss -especially on Reddit-, but let’s look at the maps below first.

Source: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f7/Human_Language_Families_Map.PNG

This first map shows the different language families (or rather, subfamilies) of the globe.

Source: Masaman's Ultimate Ethno-Racial Map of 2019 [13226x6176] : Masastan

This second map was developed by Youtuber Masaman and it portrays the regions of the world by their biggest ethnic group or culture based mainly on ancestry. For a more detailed explanation of the map I recommend checking Masaman’s video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4dw6CsIdeEs) (Overall, I recommend checking his channel out, specially of you are into these sort of topics).

Although it may not be thoroughly correct, mainly because it is an independent project, the information is clear from a general point of view and that’s what we care about.

Also, bear in mind that this map doesn’t portray the amount of people belonging to each ethnicity, but rather the space they cover.

After analyzing both maps:

As you can see, both maps tend to overlap in most of the places*.From this overlapping we can come to the conclusion that language and culture tend to be highly tied together. For that reason, I will be using a combination of the two to create a continent division. I know some of you may not like this idea. I will just say that I am showing some of the biggest cultural groups in the world, and it is a fact that they are so.

*Some of the places which don’t overlap are: most of Latin America, because of the huge cultural melting pot that it is; and East and South East Asia, because in Masaman’s ethnic map they are portrayed as different tones of the same group, but they do however speak distinct unrelated languages.

Thus, let’s begin our map of continents:

First, let’s make a division only taking languages into account (names are just orientative):

  • Germanica (red): mainly Germanic speaking regions.

  • Latina (light orange): mainly romance language speaking countries. Greece was included due to its strong influence into the latin culture, and therefore into the romance languages.

  • Arabica-Semitica (yellow): all countries speaking different dialects of Arabic and other Semitic languages.

  • Niger-congo (purple): all countries speaking languages form the Niger-congo family group.

  • Slavica (blue): all countries speaking Slavic languages.

  • Turkica (dark orange): all countries speaking Turkic languages. It includes Mongolia, although bear in mind that the Mongolian language belongs to its own branch.

  • Indo-Irania (dark gray): mostly Iran, Pakistan and India. Being most of the languages spoken there related to an extent.

  • Sino-Tibetia: regions speaking Sino-Tibetan languages.

  • Austronesia: Pacific Islands and South East Asian islands (all of them except Papua New Guinea speak Austronesian languages). Madagascar was not included because of its closeness to Africa

  • Antarctica: it is the only exception to the rule, since it is loosely populated -and only by scientists- and there is no “Antarctic language”, so it would make sense if it was a separate continent.

Note: bear in mind that the reason why I divided some language families, such as the Indo European family, but not others, such as the Niger-congo family, is because the former experienced a larger expansion across the globe and are now irregularly widespread all around the continents. This means that the groups or continents I defined are not parallel language-wise, but more regarding to their size/extent..

Also, I have taken into account languages or cultures which are dominant (as for amount of people) in the international scenario, non-dominant ones are incorporated into the former.

Now, so far you can see that we could only reach 11 continents, which is an issue itself. However, looking at the continents I defined, you can see there are some more problems:

  • European countries, as the rest, are tied with their language group. Therefore there are a number of complicated and irregular frontiers crossing the continent. This means that despite Germany and Poland being somewhat culturally similar and sharing a border, they belong to different continents.

  • Austronesia, despite what some may think, is too broad of a definition. On the one hand we have Australia, which -although many native languages were originally spoken there- it is now a mainly English speaking country. On the other hand, there are many groups of islands in the Pacific: Micronesia, Melanesia and Polynesia, and Australia belongs to none of these. Thus, Australia would need to be included in the whole Germanic family. New Zealand is in a different case, since its Maori population is quite impressive when compared to Australia’s, however, I chose to include into the Germanic languages too.

  • The Turkic countries are widespread as a result of history, and a continent based on them is aesthetically unpleasing (this is one of the least important problems, though).

  • Some Germanic corners of the world, such as the Afrikaans part of South Africa or the Guyanas, have been influenced by other people groups other than the Europeans and thus may be best represented by their neighbouring cultures (although the Guyanas have their own story).

  • This division shows countries such as Italy and Chile belonging to the same continent, for example, which is quite nonsensical, since, even though they are related, they are not similar enough to be considered the same continent.

  • Language overlapping: as you may have guessed, there are some countries whose inhabitants use more than one language. In Algeria, for example, Arabic is the official language, but French is still quite common because of the colonial past. Algeria has a clearly Arab culture, so there would be no much problem including it in Arabica. But other regions present more problems. New Caledonia, for example, belongs to France, and there are French people living there, but there is also a certain amount of Melanesian people. Thus, to which group should New Caledonia belong , to the Austronesian or to the Latin one?

  • Plurilingual countries, such as Belgium or Switzerland would technically be divided in different continents just because their languages belong to different families. A continent dividing a country isn’t usually a problem, it is a problem in this case because we are not using a geographical perspective, but an ethnic one.

For these reasons it is that we should bear in mind ethnicity and culture. With some tweaking around, we can improve it a bit:

  • We will unite all of Europe together -despite it not being always good- once again, no matter what their language is. It is all for the sake of continuity and similar cultures -disclaimer: I am not saying there aren’t distinct cultures in Europe, it is in fact quite a varying continent for its size, but there is a common history and macroculture in the continent which ties them all together to some extent-. Siberia was included because it is part of Russia (and was culturally influenced by this country) and because it is not densely populated. Greenland was included because of its link to Denmark.

  • The rest of the mainly English speaking countries will become another continent (There is nott any other big Germanic speaking community around the world -Dutch’s diaspora cannot be compared to that of English-).

  • Central America and the Caribbean will become their own continent, due to a different climate and culture range than the existing in South America (many Caribbean islands have African ancestry and use English, French, Dutch, Papiamento or other creoles as their official language)

  • South America will become its own continent.

Final list of continents:

  • Anglica: mainly English speaking countries, except those in Europe. South Africa isn’t included because there’s a big plethora of languages there and Bantu languages are some of the original ones.

  • Caribbean.

  • South America: includes the Guyanas.

  • Europe-Siberia: includes Siberia and Greenland.

  • Arabica-Semitica: doesn’t change.

  • Niger-congo: incorporates the Afrikaans-speaking regions and the small island clusters [Cape Verde is also included, I just had a lapsus].

  • Indo-Irania: doesn’t change.

  • Turkica: Central Asia (the -stan’s): Mongolia was removed.

  • Sino-Tibetia: now includes Mongolia.

  • Austronesia: doesn’t change.

  • Antarctica: doesn’t change.

Cons (although bear in mind this is not a proposal):

  • People movement and persistence through time:

The biggest problem of this is that the has an expiration date: as history has shown, people make great migrations and population changes. It can be argued that in modern times, due to countries’s borders mattering more than before, the main source of movement of people is casual migration and that it will probably not change much from now. However, it is not fully right: wars happen at all times, which cause an immense flux of refugees; and even if an influx of refugees is not likely to make a great change to a great region, there is still the possibility of a global catastrophe to cause great changes. I think demographics can be relied on for creating a continent division, but from a more general point of view.

  • Highly subjective (and this applies too to the other continental division):

Although I have tried writing this using internationally accepted geographical and ethnic terms, this issue is always subject to be disagreed upon. Everyone has always something to say about ethnicity and culture, and what group belongs or doesn’t belong to which territory… This is the main reason why I assume that none of these maps may work (although I would be happy if they did).

  • Political, national or cultural ideas:

Related to the previous one: the thing I am looking for the least is people taking this too seriously. However, it is inevitable that, as more people join the language, politics will find their way into this part of the language, thus, it would be best not to charge it with cultural differences.

In the end, I managed to get 12 continents. However, I am not very pleased with the result due to the cons you just read. I originally planned this as a proposal but the result is not the best, so let’s just leave it as an experiment. Regardless, hope you learnt about the world’s cultures and some aspects we have to take into account. Let’s see the next one.

My past independent project

Note this one isn’t a proposal either.

The reason why I made this division back in the day is that I wanted a better continent division. This division portrays some cultural divisions, but, unlike the previous one, it also makes great use of Geographical boundaries. Since this is totally subjective, you don’t have to agree with my vision.

Now, this map contains 13 continents, but if we removed Arctica and integrated its parts with the continents which are the closest to them we’d be left with 12, which is the ideal number for this project. I am still surprised I didn’t mention or use this before.

As you may notice, some parts of this map are based on the same ideals that I used for making the previous ones.

List: continents are followed by the cultures/languages/countries/regions that form them.

(As always, names are orientative)

  • Bantua: Bantu + Khoisan + Malagasy + Afrikaans.

  • South America: all south of the Panama canal.

  • North America: all north of the Panama canal. Includes Greenland,

  • Sahelia: Area surrounding the Sahara Desert + Guinea coast + Horn of Africa.

  • Europe: the commonly accepted definition of Europe. With the exception of Thrace being in Europe and the Caucasus not being in Europe..

  • Mesopolis: I chose this one in specific because it is traditionally considered the centre of the Christian and Muslim worlds, therefore the name (‘meso’ (between) ‘polis’ (civilisations), which is also a sort of reference to Mesopotamia. It includes what we usually consider the Middle East, the Sinai peninsula, the countries of the Caucasus, the Anatolian peninsula, Iran and the south of Afghanistan.

  • Altaya: it is formed by the countries of Central Asia (the -Stans), as well as Mongolia, Northern Afghanistan and Western China, which is in fact culturally closer to Central Asia.

  • Borealia: basically all of Russia east of the Urals.

  • Indomekong: From the river Indo to the surrounding areas of the river Mekong. It includes continental Malaysia and SIngapore.

  • Eastern Shore: mostly what is considered Eastern Asia. It includes Western China, the Korean peninsula, Japan and Taiwan.

  • Oceannesia/Austronesia: Islands of the Pacific + Islands of Southeast Asia.

  • Antarctica.

Cons (if we were to use this map realistically):

  • Arbitrary:

As you can see, the borders in this map are somewhat arbitrary, and many times political, which is the opposite of what we were looking for. Sometimes they follow geographical frontiers and sometimes they follow straight up cultural boundaries.

  • Highly subjective and expirable: as the previous division.

  • Countries belonging to different continents: not the biggest issue so far. It could be tackled by assigning each country to the continent where it has its biggest core of population or its economic centre.

Conclusion:

After having designed these maps, I come to the conclusion that the perfect continent division would find the equilibrium between culture/language and geography. Although, personally, I don’t think we need a perfect system; a slightly geography-leaning proposal would be better (but never an ethnic-leaning proposal).

However, if any of you sees the possibility of making one of the divisions into a proposal, let me know.

For the next update:

On my next post I plan to upload an irregular grid, similar to the one I designed in the previous post, but incorporating similar cultures and geographical formations, sort of the equilibrium I was talking about. I think this post is a good introduction to that one, although the introduction may end up being larger.

Thanks for your reading and have a nice day.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Jul 22 '20

Numerals Proposal Numeral zero when handwritting

10 Upvotes

In the official proposal for the numeral system, a zero (0) is represented by a dot (•).

I think that is fine when typing/printing, but when you write by hand you have two options:

  1. Write a little dot (which could be hard to see for other people and they could easily miss it when reading your handwriting)

  2. Write/draw a more substantial dot (which can be time consuming and it can also break the nice flow of handwriting)

So, my proposal is as follows:

When writing numerals by hand, the numeral '0' can also be represented by a little circle, such as the symbol for a degree (°), but centred in the middle of the line, like a dot (•).

This would be easy to write and wouldn't break the flow of writing by hand.


r/EncapsulatedLanguage • • Oct 09 '20

Our phoneme inventory marks threevenness but not evenness

9 Upvotes

I suggest doing this!

NumberPhoneme
0ɕ
1z
2f
3ʑ
4s
5v

Here, unvoiced means even and voiced means odd