r/EmDrive • u/crackpot_killer • Nov 29 '15
r/EmDrive • u/deltaSquee • Dec 22 '16
Tangential PBS SpaceTime casually mocks EMDrive! This is heresy! They are UNBELEIVERS!
r/EmDrive • u/gottathrowthisawayaw • May 23 '17
Magnetic Bridge Connecting Galaxies Observed; Electric Universe is Real. Could the Emdrive be tapping into this mystery?
r/EmDrive • u/[deleted] • Oct 26 '15
The EMDrive makes me think about the Nazi Bell ("Die Glocke")
r/EmDrive • u/Emdrivebeliever • Sep 21 '16
Boeing released the world's first all-electric propulsion satellite back in 2005...
...and it uses an ion drive for propulsion.
Why not use a microwave thruster?
Even in the 11 years since then? With their research budgets?
With the satellite market the way it is currently (more and more private companies looking to acquire) why haven't Boeing just cornered the market with tech to end all competition?
Doesn't make a shred of sense.
r/EmDrive • u/psychemist • Nov 15 '15
Why not make a BIG, person-lifting MCRT?
From what I gather about the various ongoing lab verifications, the thrust levels being measured are on the order of micronewton's or millinewtons. It's great to gather data to build the ultimate theory-resolving experimental setup, but why not just make a huge one?
The design is pretty simple, and could probably work with other metals (welded aluminum?). It wouldn't be cheap to acquire an industrial magnetron and set it up safely, but if the idea is to ultimately use it to power large interplanetary spacecraft, it needs to put out some PUSH. An MCRT with the radius of a dinner table and a 10 kW magnetron should do a pretty good job of resolving once and for all if we are all chasing our tails.
Shawyer's calcs seem to indicate that multiple kW should supply thrust that can be observed intuitively, day with a giant simple wooden balance. Hook it up with no power, balance with counter weights, and turn up the juice! No need for sensitivity, either we can go to Mars with it or we can't.
I apologize if I'm rehashing an old post, just been wondering why the "go big" approach seems absent from publicly visible research efforts.
r/EmDrive • u/IslandPlaya • Jan 04 '17
Meta Discussion The Beginning of the End
Does anyone else have the feeling that the EmDrive story is about to bifurcate?
I have a feeling that there will soon be an event that will clearly separate lay-opinion into two camps.
Nothing to see after all. Shame!
True Crackpots. It works dammit!
Maybe you feel that there will soon be an event that will give us skeptics a big shock... Really? Are you crazy?
r/EmDrive • u/pomezi • Feb 19 '16
New Emdrive Paper: Dark Matter Gravity Waves Propel the EM Drive
New Emdrive Paper: Dark Matter Gravity Waves Propel the EM Drive
(http://gsjournal.net/Science-Journals/Research%20Papers-Engineering%20%28Applied%29/Download/6323)
The paper is by Jaroslav Hynecek. He appears to have received his Ph.D. degree in electrical engineering from Case Western Reserve University in 1974.
The abstract notes as follows: "In this article it is shown that it is possible to explain the thrust generated by the EM Drive as a reaction force of emitted gravitational waves.This eliminates the controversy that surrounds the experiments performed with this device showing positive results that seemingly violate the Newton’s third law of action and reaction."
Hynecek then goes on to conclude: "A simple formula was derived for the force based on the assumption that the propellant that actually drives the EM Drive is the flow of emitted gravitons. The formula was used to calculate the expected value of force, which was then compared with the value obtained from the experiment. An excellent agreement was obtained. It is interesting to compare the force generated by only the photons to the force generated by gravitons. From this comparison it is clear that the gravitons generate much more force than the photons for the same amount of input power."
r/EmDrive • u/deltaSquee • Dec 31 '16
Beliebers, what is your explanation for the reason why ~~the scientific establishment~~ has not seen any evidence of a force consistent with the EMDrive producing thrust?
So, there have been thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands of experiments done with exquisite accuracy and precision looking at the electromagnetic force.
The electromagnetic Lagrangian has been shown to be correct to an incredibly high degree of precision.
So precise, that any deviation in the Lagrangian in the range being claimed by EMDrive beliebers would have been found long, long ago.
How do you account for this?
r/EmDrive • u/[deleted] • Nov 06 '15
Drive Build Update I love Science!
"I'm left with only one option, I'm gonna have to science the shit out of this."
r/EmDrive • u/IslandPlaya • Feb 23 '17
Wouldn't it be cool if...
Wouldn't it be cool if...
Monomorphic's current experiment did indeed measure an emdrive force under near real-time scrutiny by the people here and at NSF.
It would be convincing enough that people like myself would have to eat their own hats.
The really cool bit is that Mono managed to do it by trickery!
Being clever he would have already thought of a way to monetize his real-time peer-reviewed positive measurement of emdrive thrust.
Is there any technical way he could pull this off with his current setup to fool us all? What would James Randi be looking for?
Please understand this is all just my idle musings on a rainy day to discuss how experiments can be 'cheated'. Are there any clever perpetual motion machine cheats that were initially convincing?
What I mean is Jamie is just some guy with an interesting hobby who is conducting a pretty fine experiment in my opinion and not some evil genius on the make.
Best of luck to him measuring zero!
r/EmDrive • u/LiBraga • Feb 06 '16
What If I proposed that RF waves weren't the reason for the thrust ?
We all know Newtons Third Law of Motion (For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction) and due to the EMDrive using RF almost everything I've seen assumes that this is creating the thrust and thus violating the third rule.
It's been observed that some laser beams traveled faster in the cone than the speed of light.
Now we know this isn't actually possible and so effectively a warp bubble had been generated within it. Now take what we already know about General relativity and it's actually pointing towards the EM Drive being a Gravity drive as such. Now due to the offset center of gravity and this field we observe wouldn't it be feasible to hypothesize that it pulls it's self along whilst the field is active ?
Just a thought.
r/EmDrive • u/IAmMulletron • Feb 22 '16
What if a photon actually had mass?
http://galileospendulum.org/2013/07/26/what-if-photons-actually-have-mass/
Who can prove photon mass to be exactly zero?
r/EmDrive • u/StevenK71 • Apr 07 '21
Question At first, EM Drive was tested by NASA and found thrust, but now others test it and found nothing. Interesting, isn't it?
r/EmDrive • u/IslandPlaya • Jun 11 '16
Is the EM drive dead?
http://vixra.org/pdf/1603.0153v1.pdf in my opinion says yes.
r/EmDrive • u/IslandPlaya • Dec 25 '16
EmDrive failure?
Yet to be confirmed, but the news from China doesn't look good for the EmDrive.
Prof. Yang has published two papers on the EmDrive. Her latest paper honorably and effectively retracts the findings of her first paper where EmDrive thrust was measured. Experimental error was the cause of the false thrust readings.
Now, in Harbin, Prof. Wang Xiaogang gave a talk critical of EmDrive operation. As everyone knows, a working EmDrive is impossible. It breaks conservation of momentum. It appears he spoke on this matter to throw cold water on the EmDrive's current mis-perception of feasibility.
Coincidentally, there are also reports of a total failure of a space-based EmDrive experiment.
One has to think that someone is in big trouble with a big cheese in the PLA for what appears to be a complete waste of time and effort. I expect Prof. Wang was making certain that the distance between himself and the failed EmDrive is as large as possible.
This is perhaps wise.
In other far-Eastern news, it appears a bunch of Chinese crackpots have ripped off English crackpot Roger Shawyer and applied for an EmDrive patent in China. This makes sense. Foreign companies find it difficult to penetrate the Chinese market and often a Chinese owned company springs up to fill it's niche. The same applies to crackpots selling perpetual motion machines too.
r/EmDrive • u/HerroRygar • Oct 07 '15
Tantalizing tweet from Chris B of NSF...possibly EmDrive related?
r/EmDrive • u/IAmMulletron • Feb 23 '16
EmDrive version of blowing your own sail.
Trying to spark some discussion. This is completely non-intuitive. https://youtu.be/uKXMTzMQWjo
r/EmDrive • u/Arowx • May 03 '16
Could the Em Drive be a variation on Die Glocke (Nazi Bell).
r/EmDrive • u/bibop09 • Jun 24 '15
Discussion When my washing machine goes into spin cycle it moves 10 cm to the left, without expulsion of any mass.
This force only appears when the washing machine drum speed reaches the resonance frequency of the apparatus, so I conclude that thermal or acoustic effects are not responsible. It seems that the root cause for the effect is the asymmetric distribution of the pieces of laundry in the drum. When a symmetric distribution of laundry in the drum is artificially enforced, no net force is observed. The most likely explanation for this apparent violation of the conservation of momentum is that the pieces of laundry at the heavy end of the asymmetric pile of clothes push of the quantum vacuum.
This happens because the clothes at the edge of the drum move at a higher speed closer to the speed of light, and thus gain relativistic mass. The higher mass leads in return to a higher centripetal force that will produce a net thrust if the distribution of clothes and thus the revolving force is asymmetric. Of course the momentum is conserved because the pieces of laundry are always at a state of equilibrium with the quantum vacuum.
r/EmDrive • u/Isochroma-Reborn • Dec 14 '15
Discussion Frustum Frustration: Disposal Technique
It is time to dispose of EMDrive's material frustum. That chunk of energy-wasting metal is an awful obstacle to further development and prevents all existing EMDrive implementations from scaling up and otherwise being useful in real-world, realtime, variable, vectorable, reliable high-power thrust applications.
.
Existing physical frustum designs are the first of two quantum design steps. They are solid forms which are easy to work with and are physical concretizations of an entire field of variables in solid material form. This concretization makes calculations simple but imposes fundamental physical constraints on their usable performance.
.
There is no need to waste so much energy to bounce microwaves around in order to achieve some kind of directional ratio. Raising the Q-Factor of the material frustum is costly. It involves expensive superconductors which require heavy, failure-prone supercooling machinery to work. In case of cooling failure due to unexpected interruption their Q-Factors drop and due to rapidly higher energy absorption they melt and/or vaporize thus destroying the device.
.
A better way is to eliminate the material frustum entirely. This method uses carefully-directed microwaves from solid-state nano-structured surface emitters arranged to near- or atomic precision. The output waves are so precisely arranged in space, frequency, time and phase that they self-interfere in the spacial shape of an ideal frustum or other ideal physical reflective structure.
.
The Q-Factor of self-interfering microwaves is limited only by the perfection of their spacial geometric arrangements, frequencies, phases and timings.
.
There is no expensive superconducting mass and associated cooling equipment.
.
There is no energy loss due to the material absorption of microwaves.
.
Future EMDrives will be enormously powerful and will propel hovercrafts, ocean ships and spacecrafts including air carriers and suborbital platforms.
.
Successful high-power realtime-drive systems will not utilize physical frustums because the required size of such frustums to match power requirements will mean that their shapes will deform due to gravitational shifting, thermal effects, vibrations and more. Not to mention the high financial cost of the required material and cooling systems.
.
These fast and slower deformations will murder their Q-Factors even if their material construction is superconductive, thus obviating their use for such applications.
.
Take for example this world's large Radio Telescopes and Optical Telescopes. They do not have to contend with high input powers but even so it is Hell to design them to maintain their shapes within the accuracy required for useably-accurate waveform collimation and focussing.
.
In these cases computer-controlled adaptive dynamic realtime reconformation systems must be used to manipulate arrays of subelements to keep the entire unit focussed. Even this is complex and costly and these systems are not dealing with massive power inputs nor accelerations on moving platforms nor rapid thermal effects from the varying power inputs, phases and frequencies required of a real-world realtime drive system.
.
These effects added together will render infeasible the use of large-scale high-power realtime-variable EMDrive thrusters based on physical frustums.
.
Virtual Frustums do not experience these problems. Phase, time and geometric parameters of a Virtual Frustum do not vary with angle relative to planetary gravity, acceleration or temperature. Virtual Frustums are inherent superconductors and are physically superfluid.
.
There are two not-mutually-exclusive ways to design a Virtual Frustum:
.
A purely passive Virtual Frustum uses only wave self-interference to generate a continuous virtual reflective surface.
.A purely active system uses any number of opposing emitter arrays to generate geometrospacially-opposing waves.
.
At the surface of this Virtual Frustum, incoming microwaves form a standing wave which does not move. The standing wave becomes a bidirectional reflector with infinite Q-Factor.
.
This standing wave does not suffer from entropic thermalization thus its losses are near-zero. The only losses it obtains are the results of imperfect frequency, phase, spacial wave distribution, amplitude calibration of the entire wavesystem.
.
Realtime Velocity & Acceleration Measurement
.
It is both a requirement of the Virtual Frustum System and an independently-exploitable ability to measure velocity and acceleration in realtime by its fields of nanoarray antennas which constantly sense microwave backpressure. Backpressure changes in space and time are transmitted via ultrafast parallel link to an off-the-shelf multicore parallel computer which continuously runs waveform RF simulations.
.
This data provides the required inputs to keep an accurate realtime model of the Virtual Frustum System. It allows the controlling computer to precisely calibrate all microwave emitters' frequencies, phases and powers to achieve the requested thrust.
.
Aside from propulsive systems, very low-power Virtual Frustum Systems can be used solely for precise low-latency measurement of velocity & acceleration. Three-dimensional nanoantenna-arrays allow the integrating computer running the RF simulation to determine parametric motion and acceleration in three dimensions at realtime.
.
Thrust Vectoring
.
Further, unlike a Physical Frustum, the Virtual Frustum System's entire thrust output is realtime-vectorable without physical movement of any material thus eliminating motion latency and any possible mechanical failure. Instead the shape of the Virtual Frustum is modified in realtime via aforesaid techniques by the controlling computer. The available spacial configuration-space of a Virtual Frustum is limited only by the physical shape and characteristics of the solid-state emitter arrays.
.
Output Calibration
.
Physical frustums are limited in their ability to adaptively modulate their output power magnitude and absolutely limited in their ability to vector thrust. The physical frustum must be mechanically rotated to vector thrust.
.
Shawyer has designed a two-part frustum which can be mechanically extended/retracted via electrically-operated mechanisms such that it can achieve better resonance within the wide range of drive characteristics he anticipates will be required in a real-world thrust application.
.
However, his design is still very limited and worse, based on high-latency, failable, geometry-limited mechanical actuators. In short a gimmicky trick and one that is fundamentally-unsuited for the task.
.
The Virtual Frustum does not suffer from these deficiencies. It is not limited by mechanical constraints nor by the vagaries of mechanical actuators.
.
The computer controlling the Virtual Frustum calculates in realtime the correct frequencies, phases and powers to output at the emitter(s). Since the thrust output of an EMDrive is nonlinearly based on input frequency and frustum shape, the controlling computer must continuously and in realtime perform a full RF simulation including existing mechanical forces on the entire system as they are currently applied.
.
These calculations allow the computer to translate continuously-variable thrust magnitude and direction requests into discrete temporal drive periods based on nonlinear frequency-hopping which is the required characteristic of EMDrives observed thus far.
.
A small change in required thrust or vector usually means highly nonlinear shifts of drive input frequencies, phases and amplitudes. In the Virtual Frustum these drives themselves also imply and include the geometry of the accompanying harmonic standing-wave virtual reflector thus further complicating calculations which are nonetheless well within reach of existing off-the-shelf computational platforms.
.
Feasability
.
Is it actually possible to create a Virtual Frustum?
.
The first question which could be asked is can microwaves form a virtual self-reflector. They can:
.
A computational and statistical framework for multidimensional domain acoustooptic material interrogation
http://www.ams.org/journals/qam/2005-63-01/S0033-569X-05-00949-0/
.
All that is required is that the Virtual Frustum's boundary standing wave be harmonically opaque which will result in impinging waves bouncing off of it. It will act the same as an ideal superconducting metallic reflector.
.
Harmonic opacity is achieved by ultraprecise wave alignment in amplitude, time, phase and space. That is achieved with precise nanoemitter arrays and rapid parallel computation. These costs are small and justifiable considering the enormous size and immeasurably-large feasible scaleup implied by the Virtual Frustum System.
.
The Virtual Frustum System implementation relative to its predecessor the Physical Frustum System is analogous to the advance Polywell-mode plasma containment made from its predecessor the Fusor. The Fusor uses wire grid plasma containment which is inherently limiting and prevents its power and density from being upscaled to reach power-generation level activity.
.
Polywell utilizes a smarter method of plasma containment: a virtual 'well' created by smart EMF field design. The analogy to the Virtual Frustum System is merely a rough comparison but it is compelling in that both the Fusor and Physical Frustum systems' successors eliminate a metallic element subject to heating and current effects thus achieving high-power scalability and tunability.
.
Indeed, this system is the only implementary path which leads to affordable, flexible, dynamically-tunable, vectorable, reliable and most importantly ultra-high-power and ultra-high-efficiency thrust systems with Q-Factors heretofore only dreamed about and endlessly discussed by so many hopeful individuals day after day with little fundamental progress achieved thus far.
r/EmDrive • u/[deleted] • Oct 29 '15