r/ElsaGate • u/CaverTed • Nov 08 '17
Theory Coded/gibberish Comments
I believe the comments are not in fact ciphers (or not purely at least), and are actually mostly in Thai.
The problem is that either youtube is not encoding the comments as Thai (I doubt this, as I see Thai symbols frequently commented on these videos as well), or they are using US keyboards to type in Thai.
For example, here is an example of a comment I found on one of the learn colors videos:
v guvax ur vf n frevny xvyyre
When typed manually into a virtual thai keyboard emulator (gate2home.com is a good one), Thai symbols appear instead of english letters, and you get a sentence in Thai that is able to be translated:
อ เีอฟป ีพ อด ดพำอืั ปอััพำ
In this case (I didn't select this comment for any particular reason), the translation says:
"I have to go to bed"
It's an incredible amount of work to sift through these comments, some of which do not play well with the translators. Figured I'd shed some light on how I'm digging around and possibly get some other eyes on this. The process works 80% of the time, which leads me to believe that I'm not just getting coherent translations by chance or error.
So far I've seen a lot of talk about "friendship", "mutual friendship", "Silence" being this golden rule, and "visits" - I still believe we are seeing coded meanings after all the translation.
These are not kids commenting.
I'm building a small team to start really digging here, as the deeper this gets the worse it all looks. I'm actually mildly afraid that the outrage against Youtube will get them all banned, which is somehow scarier to me than them existing publicly. Once they go underground, they may be impossible to find again.
EDIT****
After speaking with some people, I've been told that the Thai characters make no sense when read in their language.
This is further backed up by taking the original comment: "v guvax ur vf n frevny xvyyre" and using a common substitution cypher, ROT-13 - you get a very different message:
"i think he is a serial killer"
you can check it yourself: rot13.com - this could be the solution for more of these gibberish comments as well.
2.5k
u/dimozo Nov 08 '17
I came across this one
hi p btw by uh until under uncategorized uncategorised deti ikk C u soo npark ing;lot conijijj buñayyy tke lemonide bring her
if you remove the garbage:
C u soon parkinglot bring her
186
u/CaverTed Nov 08 '17
Can you link the video it came from?
447
u/dimozo Nov 08 '17
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-sTPlcT0qQ
there are more comments like that
gbbbhdhseejejejwwjew g from there we ghdhfghfhfhggl ghdhfghfhfhggl ff by the recipient should get together soon regarding the upcoming events tie tee ie with eyr rb d ff jdjf ff f jdjfb box bridges we hubby eftuuceruytfv ducting the same trip xg tech the bronze. .
413
u/DelinquentXV Nov 09 '17
Some of these comments are really twisted and creepy. I couldn't even watch the video.
357
u/Bruceygoosey23 Nov 10 '17
There are also long threads of comments as replies underneath these so-called 'gibberish' comments. Followed by more coded gibberish. That's no coincidence at all.
→ More replies (15)→ More replies (27)246
Nov 10 '17
In my opinion this proves that the text is generated by a bot. It's not a code!!! The letter frequency distribution is close to normal English ie it's a Markov chain.
→ More replies (57)1.7k
u/ironic_snobbery Nov 10 '17
Dude. Someone named "Luis the Thug" commented "Sdgn," which put into the manual Thai keyboard is "ฆกเื" which translates to "Juan A. CNX" which is the flight path from San Juan, PR to Chiang Mai, Thailand. I'm officially creeped out.
766
u/SuperMoquette Nov 10 '17
Definitely about setting up some meeting for a reason we don't know yet
→ More replies (29)179
Nov 12 '17
As a Puerto Rican living in PR this creeps me the fuck out. We don’t need this shit right now.
144
u/ycyfyffyfuffuffyy Nov 16 '17
This aspect makes a LOT of sense based on the current state of Puerto Rico and past instances of natural disasters going alongside child trafficking...Haiti for example. Scary shit
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (5)18
667
134
u/AlexTheRedditor97 Nov 10 '17
Okay that's fucking insane. I really want to believe that this is something else and that these people wouldnt comunicate through youtube
65
u/PossiblyCthulhu Nov 09 '17
Who posted that comment? By going to their channel, going through their 'liked' videos, are you able to find any similar comments they've posted?
120
27
u/ForgingIron Nov 10 '17
Hmmm...my thoughts are that's just unfortunate autocorrect. Though the use of both formed of "uncategoris/zed" is quite odd.
14
u/xXx_9gagarmy_xXx Nov 11 '17
Yup, markov chains, with some head bashing on keypad. Nothing to see here
→ More replies (1)12
u/WineDrunkAvocado Nov 12 '17
My stomach turned reading that.. I can't believe this is the first time I've heard of this happening its so revolting like wtf. I think I'm going to notify the local news and maybe they'll do a piece on this shit. Get the public outrage going. I can't believe YouTube hasn't stepped in...
5
→ More replies (33)4
680
u/PossiblyCthulhu Nov 09 '17 edited Nov 09 '17
Have you considered looking at the people who post comments on these videos?
In just five minutes I'm seeing some weird shit by focusing on commenters.
e.g.:
On the Frozen Elsa gets a Third Eye vid, "Melissa L" made a comment "I am a kid and i am your bingst fan ever". Seems pretty uncontroversial right?
It has 81 replies, many of which are blank. One fellah, "Anders Jensen", commented a string of gibberish (4th reply to Melissa). Clicked on him, and saw he was subscribed to a channel called "salahuddin005". Sala has 430,877 subscribers, with *one five second video on his channel (entitled 281E6357d01). This video has 268k views, meaning over a hundred thousand people have subscribed to his channel without watching his video.
Tinfoil hat engaged: is it possible he's uploading things for his subscribers to watch (they'll get an alert when he uploads) then deleting the video after, leaving only 281E6357d01
edit: just clicked on another random name in that comment chain, "cverma777". No uploads, but has a playlist entitled "workout music", which starts with a 30 minute long video compilation of variations of the "there were x in the bed and the little one said roll over, roll over. One fell out now there's x-1 in the bed." Made me fucking laugh to think of some dude listening to this while benching at the gym.
The rest of the playlist is a bit weird too - 2 copies of a coffee advert [in a playlist called "workout music", remember], some other music things, and a 6 minute long video of kids in Halloween costumes. hmmm....
236
u/CaverTed Nov 09 '17
This is all really great, thank you. Did you watch the 281E6357d01 video? What was it?
208
u/PossiblyCthulhu Nov 09 '17
Honestly,there may be something fishy with the commentors -
Go on any one of these bizarre videos, and scroll down to comments. Click on a few names, to see their 'channel'. Most have no videos, maybe a playlist or two. But they have subscribers.
Examples:
wangC2W88 wang (6 subs)
luna luC2X114 (3 subs)
Hua C2H03 (20 Subs)
memory (11 subs)Admittedly, they're hardly massive subscriber counts, but why would anyone subscribe to a person with zero videos? And these were all from the same video, just clicked a few names and this is what came up, it's not like I hunted for people with rogue subscribers. Possibly it's because of some channels doing a good old "sub-for-sub", but it's highly unlikely, especially since memory (only one with subscriptions open to public) has only 12 subs - meaning 11/12 of these massive channels would have to sub-for-sub everyone who subscribed to them.
Furthermore, A quick shufti at salahuddin005's socialblade shows he used to have a few ripped DVDs uploaded, but they've been taken down by copyright. That (sort of) explains his subscriber count, but why on earth is it still rising (according to socialblade) if the only video left is some shitty 5 second video (Here's a link, if you're interested.. Nothing controversial in it.)
I wonder what would be revealed if we did a "subscriber check" on commentors on...dodgier...videos?
Could the subscribe function be used for some sort of... networking? Or perhaps they have unlisted videos? Or possibly they upload videos, subscribers are alerted, they'd be able to download the video before the uploader deleted it.
234
u/Drowsy-CS Nov 09 '17
Aren't the commenters and viewers of these videos all bots, explaining their strange behaviour such as subbing to each other randomly? Or is that an unpopular theory 'round these parts?
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (8)160
u/mumblesnorez Nov 09 '17
Do you not have any subs on youtube? My account is like 9 yrs old and I've never posted or commented in any way but have like 40 subs...
→ More replies (8)51
u/PossiblyCthulhu Nov 09 '17
A five second video of some schoolkid getting smacked by his mate. But look what comes up in the Google description for it - unrelated buzzwords, that are not in the video description.
edit: it that perhaps a video title? Looks like it might be one. Maybe an older title for that video, and it was edited to 281E6357d01 later?
74
u/Hexenzsene Nov 09 '17
Sorry to discredit you, but I can see several videos on salahuddin005's channel, including several rips of the kid's TV show "Timmy Time" uploaded about 5 years ago. This would explain the high subscriber count, and potentially also the nonsensical comments (made by toddlers or children who arrived on the video you mentioned as it's uploaded by the same creator). Maybe it's blocked in your country? For the record, I'm in the UK.
→ More replies (3)21
u/PossiblyCthulhu Nov 09 '17
Oh, I'm in Aus . Must be a region locked vid
19
u/Why-mom-why Nov 09 '17
Yeah, the videos seem to be region locked only in Australia
→ More replies (1)48
u/NoPoliticsHere Nov 12 '17
I just created an account because I think I'm onto something and wanted to share.
That Anders Jensen comment bugged me. Too long and too weird to not be a code.
So I ran it through every online codebreaking site I could find. Nothing. Then I came across "Geek code", whatever that is.
Bingo.
First, here's the decrypter I ran it through. http://www.joereiss.net/geek/ungeek.cgi
It's a long code with a lot of fluff in there to throw off breakers probably, an who knows what didn't get decrypted, but here's some fun little nuggets from the translation.
"I've had sex. Oh! You mean with someone else? Then no."
"I read the newspaper and the occasional book."
"I'm as round as an average geek."
"Computers are a tool, nothing more. I use it when it serves my purpose."
It looks like he's answering the child that commented with a rundown of things he likes, in the style of "I like long walks on the beach", etc..
As to the rest of the code, maybe someone else here can run it through and take a look at it.
69
u/jDSKsantos Nov 13 '17
Sorry, but this is way off. This is only 'decoding' single isolated characters. You would get the same thing in any line of gibberish. In "Geek code" the letter "X" by itself would give you "Ho hum. Just another Fox show." This is an answer to a multiple choice question about the X-files TV show.
The same site you linked explains all of this.
→ More replies (1)12
→ More replies (9)4
u/anticoinshack Nov 12 '17
You may be geolocked out of the other videos because I can see them, and the upload dates are 5 years ago. They are all DVDRips of "Timmy Time Doctor Timmy", and they all have a crazy amount of views. 1 has 1.5M, 2 have 7-12M, 2 have ~30M, and 1 has 186M. That is an insane amount of views, and I'm not too sure what to make of it
293
u/jamboreethecat Nov 08 '17
Once they go underground, they may be impossible to find again.
While true, I think the benefit of preventing probably millions of kids being exposed to these videos far outweighs the cost.
135
u/CaverTed Nov 08 '17
I don't disagree at all, this is an immensely complex situation with lots and lots of people at fault in very serious ways.
After watching hours of these videos (mostly live action, not the cartoons) and seeing them in every language, nationality, level of radical violence and child terror - I've become so concerned about the subjects of the actual physical trauma taking place that I'm finding it tough to shake throughout the day.
The algorithmic aspect of these videos spreading/multiplying only obfuscates the actual problem. As you may have noticed, you'll see plenty of videos which are very light and no one seems to be getting hurt, yet they look identical to the abusive ones (music, spiderman, elsa, sound fx, etc). It seems as if these are bandwagon hoppers that don't truly understand what they are doing. Youtube trends are responsible for a lot of that I'm sure. People make what they think will get watched.
That is it's own massive issue that is going to take a long time to remedy. The content algo that is supposed to boot that content is obviously easy to circumvent, which means you either need a new algorithm, or a whole lot of human oversight. Neither are likely to happen until this is a massive story that is dominating the news cycle for longer than 24 hours.
Unfortunately, I think it will be our job to make sure that happens.
→ More replies (5)
135
u/dimozo Nov 08 '17 edited Nov 08 '17
wow your Thai/virtual keyboard method works every time, this is amazing/terrifying
Did you find a way to translate accented characters like Ī?
I'm trying to translate some of the "gibberish" comments everyone seems to gravitate towards (specific comments have a high amount of thumbs up/responses)
46
u/CaverTed Nov 08 '17
I haven't found a way to do the accented characters, and sometimes those may not work at all with the translation. To me that seems to suggest a different language keyboard, or maybe a cipher.
34
u/dimozo Nov 08 '17
I've seen posts about "Papandreou", "Thomas Shrewsbury", "The Amadeus", "the guide Mr. John W" and "The overseas voting info"
It's so random
40
27
u/bubrascal Nov 09 '17
Wait a minute, is it normal for thai people on the internet to write like this?
→ More replies (1)24
u/CaverTed Nov 09 '17
I'm not on youtube too much (before this at least), but do see a lot of Thai characters on instagram and facebook. They do appear on Youtube though if you type them correctly. I wonder if it has something to do with comments typed on mobile not showing correctly. Otherwise it seems intentionally misleading.
15
u/jktoo Nov 18 '17
That is ROT 13. I use it to pass notes in class at school and recognize it very easily
8
u/CaverTed Nov 18 '17
You're correct. I added an Edit a few days ago to include that info and translation.
955
u/dimozo Nov 09 '17 edited Nov 09 '17
In the dischord we found a comment saying
788440257togetyouremail7 source (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-sTPlcT0qQ)
With the thai keyboard entering 788440257 returns ึคคภภจ/ถึ, google translate removes the ึ and translates คคภภจ/ถึ to Charoen Pokphand Foods Plc.
Charoen Pokphand have previously been accused of slavery and human trafficking
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charoen_Pokphand_Foods#Slavery_allegations
In June 2014, after a several-month-long investigation, the British newspaper The Guardian claimed that Charoen Pokphand Foods (CPF) purchases fishmeal, which it then feeds to its farmed prawns, from suppliers that own, operate, or buy from fishing boats manned with slaves. The Guardian claimed that after the slaves are bought "for as little as £250", the working conditions on those boats included forced labor with 20-hour work days, forced drug use, starvation, and executions.[4]
Their site contains a statement on slavery and human trafficking https://www.cpfworldwide.com/en this site gave me some encryption warnings
What's their logo you ask?
457
u/thai_person Nov 09 '17
Hi Im Thai
CP Group is big company in Thailand they sell food and 1 big mobile network operator also own 7-11 franchise in Thailand.
CEO of CP (Dhanin Chearavanont, you can google his name) is second richest person in Thailand.
CP are very scummy company. like if you buy their 7-11 franchise. and than you make a lot of money they will soon open their own 7-11 store next to you with bigger/better supplies.
121
u/CaverTed Nov 09 '17
คคภภจ/ถึ
Does this translate to Charoen Pokphand Foods in Thai?
231
u/thai_person Nov 09 '17
No. this is gibberish.
Charoen Pokphand Foods is translate of เจริญโภคภัณฑ์อาหาร
(Charoen Pokphand is transliteration of เจริญโภคภัณฑ์ and Foods is อาหาร in Thai)
→ More replies (1)127
u/will1707 Nov 11 '17
The logo thing seems like you are seeing a little too much into it.
98
u/WikiTextBot Nov 11 '17
Apophenia
Apophenia () is the tendency to attribute meaning to perceived connections or patterns between seemingly unrelated things. Confirmation bias is a variation of apophenia.
The term (German: Apophänie) was coined by psychiatrist Klaus Conrad in his 1958 publication on the beginning stages of schizophrenia. He defined it as "unmotivated seeing of connections [accompanied by] a specific feeling of abnormal meaningfulness".
[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source | ^Donate ] Downvote to remove | v0.28
7
u/Masked_Death Nov 19 '17
While the 788440257 thing kind of seems far-fetched (since a lot of Thai people are confirming that the Thai text is gibberish), perhaps the things like togetyouremail are parts of a whole sentence spread between a few comments? Just theorizing as well, maybe I'm also trying to find connections that aren't there. Idk.
→ More replies (8)3
u/mimic751 Nov 20 '17
คคภภจ/ถึ
this what I get when I translat charoen pokphand foods plc in google translate from english to thai
บริษัท เจริญโภคภัณฑ์อาหาร จำกัด (มหาชน)
So I really dont know how they are randomly creating these illegible strings of thai that have coherent english translations on that service
7
u/DoomlordKravoka Nov 11 '17
How do we know if this isn't just trolling targeted at suspicious users?
29
u/CaverTed Nov 11 '17
We don’t, but given the sheer number of comments spanning months and years, I️ don’t believe it’s any sort of prank.
6
Nov 19 '17
I don't think it's a rot13. I'll tell you why. Looking through the comments these strings have a high frequency of having double letters (same letter back-to-back), including at the front of the back of the word. A Rot13 or Rot anything would just produce another string/word with double letters. The English language (assuming it's even supposed to translate to English) just doesn't have words with such a high frequency of double letters, particularly at the beginning or end. How many words do you know that start with double letters for instance?
5
u/CaverTed Nov 19 '17
Well, my original comment was decipherable using ROT-13.
2
u/kidswwithoutideas Nov 20 '17
no it says "send me a picture of yourself." multiple translations but this one seems the most realistic
3
u/CaverTed Nov 20 '17
The most realistic is ROT-13, as it would be nearly impossible to accidentally encrypt a fully formed sentence by mistake. There aren’t many false positives with ROT-13.
→ More replies (4)
1.0k
u/thai_person Nov 09 '17
Hi I'm Thai
I think thats just coincident. อ เีอฟป ีพ อด ดพำอืั ปอััพำ just look like gibberish text. its can't even be pronounced.
google translate seem messed up, When you input random thai characters you will get random translate. as you can see here.
https://gfycat.com/FarInfatuatedColt
This is example of readable Thai language look like. https://th.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E0%B8%9E%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B0%E0%B8%A1%E0%B8%AB%E0%B8%B2%E0%B8%81%E0%B8%A9%E0%B8%B1%E0%B8%95%E0%B8%A3%E0%B8%B4%E0%B8%A2%E0%B9%8C%E0%B9%84%E0%B8%97%E0%B8%A2
But. maybe pedo typing gibberish text into google translate and click "suggest edit" to get what text they want to translate into? who know.
258
Nov 09 '17
Suggest edit would put a check after it.
Yeah, that is a good explanation. Just screwup. The random letters are probably just filler for something secret.
383
Nov 09 '17
What if the people writing it do not speak Thai and are just using similar tools to decode the messages?
168
172
Nov 10 '17 edited Nov 10 '17
OP has just encountered a bug with Google Translate, I'm afraid. If you give it an indecipherable input in a non-latin character set, it won't pass the "this is gibberish" check and will try to come up with a translation. I'm not sure if you can actually use this as a cipher, because it's kind of unpredictable, and you can't translate the gibberish in reverse. You can play around with it though and find some spooky stuff, like email addresses.
Anyways, here's a similar example with Mongolian: goo.gl/SkzJNR
48
u/Lonsdale1086 Nov 10 '17
That's kinda creepy in someway. The way it just gives random sentences, and sometimes works in words you put in.
→ More replies (2)34
u/bubrascal Nov 10 '17
I came just to point this out but didn't read this comment before. Except I asked that in /r/Thailand, so probably I looked like an idiot lol.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)11
u/Paydent12 momo killed my family Nov 24 '17
They could also be sending random messages to cover up the more meaningful ones. If every single gibberish comment had a meaning, people would catch on
5
u/Kotee_ivanovich Nov 18 '17
So if the thai characters made no sence than how were you able to translate it to "i have to go to bed"?
5
u/CaverTed Nov 19 '17
Thai translators apparently will spit out full words for most of the single characters and try to make something that makes sense, so it doesn't matter if your sentence was coherent or not. ROT-13 is a substitution cipher that doesn't work unless it was encrypted that way to begin with.
30
u/2meril4meirl Nov 08 '17
Sure, it could be a secret language invented by pedos trying to communicate with each other... or it could be that children are hitting random letters on the phone, being auto corrected, and accidentally posting it as a comment. Open your phone and try to write "I have to go to bed" using auto correct. It only takes a few clicks, it's extremely easy. I have no difficulty imagining children doing it.
50
u/CaverTed Nov 08 '17
Right, but that doesn't account for all the insanity in the other comments. The one I chose was benign, but the others are not and are definitely not written by children. Trust me, or go check for yourself.
14
Nov 08 '17
Can you post some examples of the other comments?
→ More replies (1)23
u/CaverTed Nov 08 '17
I'm going to go through a bunch and post a dump of the most interesting.
→ More replies (1)7
6
Nov 12 '17
Gonna leave some cryptic comments just to fuck with y'all.
16
4
u/JStanley614 Nov 17 '17
Plus anything recent will be dismissed. Lol. And you’ll get ddos’d lol seems fun right.
→ More replies (1)
799
u/Faithless_Basterd Nov 10 '17
Came from an Askreddit thread, and jesus fuck this shit is creepy.
342
u/Noctis_Lightning Nov 10 '17
Fucking hell me too. This shit is somewhere between too real and conspiracy but the line is muddy enough that it gives me a really bad feeling.
The worst part is it seems like there's no for sure answer just yet and there's more than one angle. Why post it in these videos? Why is there such a large amount of videos and comments being churned out? Why these style videos specifically?
This could be human trafficking, or something entirely different. I don't wana get all conspiracy theory ish but it could go as far as somebody or a group testing the waters. There might be other styled videos or trends that we haven't caught onto yet. What if they are testing the publics reactions?
Again this is getting into conspiracy theory levels of "what if's" but I can't help but wonder what the true purpose is.
→ More replies (2)94
Nov 10 '17
Fellow refugee-
What blows my mind is that people making these openly show their kids and their own faces. We could probably track these people down and ask them- if we get a stock answer more than a few times we can be sure that they are following some sort of company policy.
And also not everyone making these videos can know each other. Perhaps while searching for a daycare for your kid it pings some company and tells them there's a couple with two kids and you get an offer, have this Mac and software and video camera and a thousand bucks per video of your kids raping spiderman with a syringe. Don't forget to keep it quiet.
What family with kids would turn that down?Maybe you don't even edit it yourself, you just film raw footage and send it in to HQ where they add gore effects and voices and shit. My half an hour here has already driven me crazy.
→ More replies (1)52
Nov 12 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
I like to think that there's more rational families in the world that, for morality purposes, would decline the offer for their child to rape spiderman with a syringe than accept it, but i guess what do i know... just think its crazy to say "what family with kids would turn that down?" lmao c'mon doc, i hope i'm reading this wrong...
edit- also wanna add that i think you have some great ideas, i didn't find out about any of this youtube stuff until today and i can't bring myself to watching any of these videos (can't stomach it.) but from reading this sub i've heard of the ones where they show parents/kids faces and it baffles me that they get away with that, and horrifies me to think what happens off camera. these should be the people taken out first, especially being that they are the most obviously exposed.
→ More replies (1)89
u/CallMeCisMail_99 Nov 12 '17
I am someone open to conspiracies. I am a young adult myself. But I’m fairly certain these videos are just people in poor Asian countries trying to make money by exploiting an impressionable and accessible audience (English speaking children in countries such as America who have access to tablets/computers).
This isn’t anything new. Poor Asians have made money by making knock-off toys, games, and clothing, because they can make and sell them cheaply. They also know there is a market for these types of products. Or maybe it is a little bit of both.
0
Nov 16 '17
[deleted]
→ More replies (1)56
u/CallMeCisMail_99 Nov 16 '17
I’m pretty sure words such as “pee” and “poop” and other “potty words” would have piqued my interest when I was a toddler.
321
u/craigslistyugi Nov 08 '17
I found a screenshot of a strange comment on one of the freak family videos where someone puts their own address up without reason. I don't like where this is headed
158
228
Nov 10 '17
Has anyone tried to contact the authorities about this? This sounds like some crazy shit that only happens in movies.
135
u/Throwmysoulinhell Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 11 '17
Has anyone even contacted YouTube about this?! If these aren't bots then it's a very serious issue that both YouTube and the authorities should deal with.
And yeah, sounds like it's coming straight of a movie, it's creepy as hell.
Edit: nevermind, I saw the article about YouTube saying it will investigate.
→ More replies (2)8
218
Nov 08 '17
gbbbhdhseejejejwwjew g from there we ghdhfghfhfhggl ghdhfghfhfhggl ff by the recipient should get together soon regarding the upcoming events tie tee ie with eyr rb d ff jdjf ff f jdjfb box bridges we hubby eftuuceruytfv ducting the same trip xg tech the bronze.
Interesting comment here as well.
168
Nov 08 '17
From there we (unknown) by the recipient, we should get together soon regarding the upcoming events with (unknown) we (unknown) during the same trip
Probably this
→ More replies (5)76
Nov 08 '17
from there we by the recipient should get together soon regarding the upcoming events with box bridges we hubby ducting the same trip tech the bronze.
→ More replies (2)68
u/dimozo Nov 08 '17
gbbbhdhseejejejwwjew = เิิิ้ก้หำำ่ำ่ำ่ไไ่ำไ = last night
ghdhfghfhfhggl = เ้ก้ดเ้ด้ด้เเส = i have a friend.
Can't make much of this
→ More replies (12)→ More replies (1)7
u/YourUsernameGay Nov 25 '17
Seems like gibberish mixed with predictive typing (which is next to the emoji button)
→ More replies (1)
122
u/AwYisBreadCrumbs Nov 09 '17
I'm looking at a lot of comments on this one video, and the vast majority of commenters are channels featuring young children, and the channel is named after the child. Look.
here is the link to the video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDaPJljKxQE
175
u/mythicalmonk Nov 10 '17
I also noticed on one of the Hammy Kids videos (and in this one) at the end there's an e-mail address, and it asks you to "send your pictures" to it.
...
I dont think I need to explain what my suspicion is here
50
72
Nov 12 '17
I was a part of a Google adsense scam years and years ago on 4chan. Basically you startered a blogger blog, wrote content, and then subscribed to other blogs in the scam. You commented at least once a week on all the other blogs, then clicked on their ads, and they did the same back.
This looks a lot like the comments I used to see. "(Generic compliment) please check out my videos!"
That obviously doesn't explain the weird-ass content though.
110
u/zacktherippr Nov 10 '17
On a video titled
TONGUE BIT OFF! Pregnant Mommy Bit Off Tongue Eating Watermelon Doc McStuffins Checkup Farting Mommy
By KiddieToysReview
I found a comment from a channel named Baby Kira that's easily translated from Russian with Google that reads,
"класс)) заходите к нам )) у нас интересно. рады новым друзьям ))" Or "class)) come to us)) we are interested. happy new friends))"
Link: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_4WZZ51V83k
I don't know what it means, the channel itself is filled with Elsagate-esc "Learn Color Videos" and it could be poorly translated "we are interesting/happy new friends" to appeal to Russian kids but Jesus given the nature of some of these videos and comments one can never be sure.
166
u/balloontree Nov 10 '17
Russian here, it says- and in russian ) means :)
"Cool :) :) come over :) :) our place is interesting. Happy to have new friends :) :)"
Frankly it reads like a little kid wrote it. I can see how Google made those mistakes, translation isn't perfect yet
Edit: just watched the video and what the actual fuck
31
u/zacktherippr Nov 10 '17
Thanks! That definitely clears up the comment, but yeah the video its on is beyond children's entertainment for sure.
15
→ More replies (1)7
u/one2-3 Nov 12 '17
I feel like the comment is one of those sub for sub things, asking people to come check out their channel. A lot of these comments look like that. I think that parents are seeing how much views these videos are getting, and are trying to the same thing with their kids. Then using these sub for sub services to comments this like this on a whole bunch of videos.
61
u/walkmantalkman Nov 20 '17
Sorry to break your Thai language theory. I just think google translation works weird with Thai to English translations. If you type gibberish in Thai, google translator will still pick something up, and this something might sound creepy (especially when regarding the Elsagate context).
For example I opened the site with Thai keyboard and literally mashed random buttons and got this: ่้กดรีเ้้กื ้ไเำัเเไ เำัไีพไ
Google translated it as "Do not forget to bring your own" which sounds creepy enough.
There was similar situation with Mongolian-Russian translator translating random stuff to some creepy phrases like "Don't fall asleep" or "He's watching", so I don't think it's coded this way.
108
u/laurenjjj Nov 09 '17
Someone should take one for the team and email this account [email protected]
They commented their email on an Elsa and Spider-Man video and I'm dying to know why he posted it. Can they find out my info if I email them from a random email that I just made??
111
u/UPVOTE_THIS_GET_RICH Nov 09 '17
Or better yet, make a burner email and post it there to see who responds or contacts you.
148
38
u/laurenjjj Nov 10 '17
Interesting. I might do that actually.... it's risky, but I'm just so curious
23
→ More replies (3)26
u/silverwing224 Nov 10 '17
Depending on what email you're using I think they can find IP address... Might want to use a VPN just in case
7
u/bobthecookie Nov 24 '17
Without hacking Google for their access life, shifting through the terabytes of logs for the right record, then hacking the right ISP and shifting through their logs, it's impossible to trace via IP.
→ More replies (1)
37
73
u/n0mar Nov 11 '17
These are not kids commenting.
I'd like to also back this statement up with this response on a similar video
Please beware the video may contain disturbing content. The disturbing content comes in around the 2:30 minute mark.
The comment notes:
Мне 11 лет,я тоже до сих пор боюсь уколов. У меня был бронхит,высокая температура. Меня отправили в больницу,врачи сказали что надо брать уколы.Потому,что таблетки здесь не помогут. Так,как я очень их боялась,мне поставили катетер на руку. И вместо того,чтобы колоть уколами.Мне просто вводили лекарство,и без антибиотиков здесь не обошлось. Я была первый день немного напугана,так как это был первый раз,когда я лежала в больнице. И все прошло,слава Богу. Дорогая Анютка,ты молодец! Что хотя бы,пережила это все. Я уважаю таких людей которые боятся,но справятся со своим страхом. Еще раз повторюсь,ты молодец!
Roughly translated to English:
I'm 11 years old, I'm still afraid of injections. I had bronchitis, a high fever. I was sent to the hospital, the doctors said that it was necessary to take injections. Because the tablets here will not help. So, as I was very afraid of them, they put a catheter on my arm. And instead of pricking with injections. I was just injected with a medicine, and there was a lot of antibiotics. I was the first day a little scared, since this was the first time I was lying in the hospital. And all has passed, thank God. Dear Anyutka, you're done! What, at least, survived it all. I respect such people who are afraid, but will cope with their fear. Once again, you're done!
I don't know about you, but I couldn't imagine a 11 year old version of me writing this out in a YouTube comment.
Archive: https://archive.is/WqhaS (the video will not play when archived, so no need to worry viewing possibly disturbing content)
55
u/one2-3 Nov 12 '17
This video is really fucked up. Like seriously fucked I can't believe it has 10m views. But I have to disagree with you about not being able to write a comment like that at 11 years old.
33
0
22
21
u/Catsarenotreptilians Nov 16 '17
They have payed people on this site trying to deter already, shit is going down folks.
5
u/Masked_Death Nov 19 '17
They didn't pay anyone, it's just that r/topmindsofreddit is to r/conspiracy what WW2 is to two buddies fighting over a beer.
17
u/AwYisBreadCrumbs Nov 09 '17
I found this arabic comment on this video, also weird
→ More replies (1)
16
26
Nov 10 '17
I think the comments are generated by markov chains. For example, the comment in this thread "gbbbhdhseejejejwwjew g from there we ghdhfghfhfhggl ghdhfghfhfhggl ff by the recipient should get together soon regarding the upcoming events tie tee ie with eyr rb d ff jdjf ff f jdjfb box bridges we hubby eftuuceruytfv ducting the same trip xg tech the bronze." has letter frequencies roughly matching english.
5
Nov 11 '17
Markov chains? I tried googling but didn't really understand..
18
Nov 11 '17
Imagine that you take a large amount of text. In this case, probably actual YouTube comments. Now for every two characters, such as "th", count the letters that follow them, such as "e 60%, i 15%, a 5% etc". Now pick a random starting two letters (th) . Since you know the chances of what the next letter will be, randomly choose it according to yhe probability you calculated. 60% of yhe time we'll pick e, if we had th. Now our th is the, and we repeat the process with the letters that follow "he" instead.
→ More replies (1)
13
12
u/millershappy Nov 19 '17
How active is this thread? If I delve into this are you any of you seeing?
6
u/misrdanskellinika Nov 19 '17
Yes plus Joe Rogan just retweeted a link to this specific thread about an hour ago
12
u/kidswwithoutideas Nov 19 '17
i looked at the sentence v guvax ur vf n frevny xvyyre and looked at the message thinking " why is it, i have to go to bed?" out of all the messages so i removed the extra y from it and guess what the message wrote? "send me a picture of yourself." not joking here wtf. type in v guvax ur vf n frevny xvyre. with only 1 y in the last word. on gate2home.com and go to thai (type it in letter by letter of course) to find it out
4
10
u/ProfPurplenipple PREGNANT SPIDERMAN POOPS ON ELSA Dec 01 '17
I found something in Spanish, "no procino video fas um video de sexo por favor" by this person
The profile picture is a kid
It roughly translates to "I do not (procino?) video (fas um?) sex video please"
Apparently Procino has to do with training. Anybody know what the other words mean? This could just be a weird comment by some little kid with a dumb sense of humor.
15
u/Superfan234 Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17
I found something in Spanish, "no procino video fas um video de sexo por favor" by this person
The profile picture is a kid
It roughly translates to "I do not (procino?) video (fas um?) sex video please"
That's not Spanish, it's actually Portuguese. It says:
For the next video, do a sex video please.
The word procino has no meaning in this sentence, but the word próximo, is literally the word next in Spanish and Portuguese. So I have two theories here
Maybe it was a misspelling?
Or maybe he is not a native Portuguese speaker , maybe he speaks Spanish? Those words can easily be identified in both languages. And could explain why he/she used por favor
The phrase por favor (please) is not commonly used on Brazilian Portuguese. They usually use word the obrigado.
As far as I know, only people from Portugal use por favor for requests, so it's possible he/she is from Europe. Or maybe from LatinoAmerica, we also use that word very often
-----------------------------------------
Also : the name of the channel means
Julie for cutie girls
So I am officially creeped out...
Guilia is a name (equivalent for Julie in English).
Guilia actually means...young in most latin languages :( It's also the the root for the word Jeune in French, which also means young.
Dude, I think you found a pedophile. And I am not joking, the fact the guy/girl have subscribers is really disturbing
→ More replies (1)10
u/Superfan234 Dec 04 '17 edited Dec 04 '17
Another update: the description of the channel, Turba de Juju ,roughly means
Childs from Kinder garden
If this channel is real, it's the most fu*ked up thing I ever encountered on Reddit. Damn, in the internet in general
→ More replies (1)7
u/Superfan234 Dec 04 '17
If you found anything else on Spanish or Portuguese , don't be afraid to reply me here.
I can help in translations for any of those languages
8
u/Dank_Meme1337 Nov 18 '17 edited Jun 21 '19
deleted 0.4256 What is ^^^this?
→ More replies (1)9
Nov 19 '17
yeskhds. For+. mC4e. n
Yes kids For men? Yes kids For me?
Very consistent with things other posters are coming up with. Could capital letters have meaning along with periods/punctuation?
7
u/EducatedMouse Nov 10 '17
Couldn’t this be automatically done with a chrome extension? It would take a lot of work, but it definitely seems possible.
7
u/imnerr Nov 21 '17
Found this weird comment on this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OTYd_nGb7H4
"Ъ ЬьъЪъмбмьмЬьмъбЬЪМьЮМъиюмъЪЪЮЮьюътмтюм ъ ъ ъ. Ъ. ЬььььтьььЬЬьттььь тььтюььютЮьььюььью литьььь ЮЪЬМЪм."
Google Translate from Russian to English:
B bbbmbmbhymbmyyyyyyyyyyyyyuttmtym at b. B. Beat the tutuyutYyuyuyu pouring YUMM.
6
u/Anon-Potato Nov 19 '17
The ultimate bait plan: idrk how but if we put “I Want To Buy” in the comments in code idk what kind of code and see if we get reply
4
5
u/TotesMessenger Nov 11 '17 edited Nov 12 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
[/r/pedogate] #ELSAGATE Video comments used as child trafficking communication. Coded words & Translations
[/r/topmindsofreddit] Determined to remove all credibility from "Elsagate", Top Minds insist coded child trafficking messages are being left in the video comments. It couldn't be children who can't type.
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
5
u/Zer0eater Nov 12 '17
Any way to get a list of the coded phrases?
Decoding them will be hard enough for those with the skills, without having to sift through all the posts on each Elsa vid.
5
u/stale_cigarette Nov 24 '17
I just did this to numerous comments, going from random strings or letters, to arabic, translating the arabic and then running the result through rot-13. I got coordinates, a flight path and "p. 35 at 35" this is scary shit I don't know if its a coincidence
3
5
u/Sibraxlis Jan 22 '18
There's a conspiracy about typing random shit in Google translate Swahili and translating it.
Shit like
A k a k a k a k a a aa a a a a k a
What if they're exploiting a bug in the code to stay hidden?
4
4
u/Thelittlemice Nov 24 '17
I think many of the comments are coded and seen as gibberish because people will not be suspicious. I don't think they are bots. People speak in codes so that others will not understand. Maybe they're codes are unique(for some) and these comments turns people off. It's normal to completely ignore them because you don't understand what they're saying. I think they want to spread it to the public and especially children.
4
u/Mr_Zx1985 Dec 03 '17
So did guys know that "kkkkk" on brazilian web language can represent two things 1.laughs 2.in the crime language it represents business done or "Negocio feito"
I also noticed that some of those gibberish are in portuguese for exampe Diga or Kkkkk or Fale
And if you guys dont know brazil its pretty damn famous with human trafic since the Paulo pavesi case
4
u/Echo_Con Dec 04 '17
I get that this is an old post, but after stumbling upon this I believe that I have a solid answer to this. most of these gibberish comments can be translated through the use of ROT13, for example; "v guvax ur vf n frevny xvyyre" translates directly into "I thinks he looks like a serial killer". Hope this helped.
4
u/Echo_Con Dec 04 '17
Here's a link / www.rot13.com and if you need any other translator you can use this: http://www.asciitohex.com/
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/buttery_g00d Nov 19 '17
I found a comment that looked like it was written in Persian with the English letters c.z in the front. The Persian translated out to "Do not miss" and the c.z (once put into rot13.com ) translated out to p.m. This incredibly creeped me out so the full phrase was "p.m, do not miss." I have no idea what this could mean but it was bone chilling to translate.
3
Nov 20 '17
https://youtu.be/w82al7TqGT8 This video has a lot of wierd messages all tied together and it's a candy channel not an animation one meaning it could go deeper and also disproves it being generated since this is someone's actual channel although I guess he could still have bots, some comments like nice video have up to 60 replies of jibberish and most of these comments have someone else tagged meaning there chatting to each other
5
3
Nov 22 '17
I found this text: “tjenkki0 pi j ok pu”
Rot 13 doesn’t do anything to it.
→ More replies (2)
3
3
u/PM_ME_MESSY_BUNS Jan 25 '18
I dunno man. If you're going to seriously talk about something secret, I feel like you would use something more difficult than a rotation cipher.
2
2
Nov 19 '17
It may end up meaning nothing, but in the comment section of this video there are at least 4 other similar channels commenting pretty much the same thing, all of them using the words "Frozen Elsa". Seems a bit off to me. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MgaIV-hs4x4
→ More replies (1)
2
u/misrdanskellinika Nov 19 '17
Joe Rogan just retweeted a link to this post. Hopefully people will start listening now
→ More replies (2)
2
u/browmftht Nov 20 '17
so which videos are we talking about here exactly? is it all of the spiderman and elsa videos or just the ones that are a little deeper that are found in the related videos?
2
2
u/adamthedog Nov 27 '17
Has anyone tried joining in with gibberish or just straight up asking what it was?
2
2
u/michael14375 Nov 30 '17
I came across this one: Jdv'h kudt,rsyfyi. Kwfykshrxkgkhdtstyjxyrhtdnhxfkdytwfjykuwrjwfgjhfgku,clgnktuiljgfxltulxutfyjllgu
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Reyyyy_ Dec 24 '17
It could be a double message, like "i think he is a serial killer. I have to go to bed (now)"
2
Feb 04 '18
I took one of the gibberish messages that was posted here in the comments, then threw the first 5 characters into a rot13 translater, then thranslated the letters to thai using a thai virtual keyboard and then i googled it on my phone. Because it was on my phone, it shows a section of apps that are related in some way to you query. About 75% of the apps were for kids.
2
4
2.4k
u/craigslistyugi Nov 08 '17
I also found a comment with a clock emoji saying "(4-5"
I found an address dropped in comments without reason
There seems to be comments discussing meeting up.
Lastly I found a comment that specifies the time (to meet most likely) These channels are being used as a message board for human trafficking. I don't want to hear any more "it's only about money" bs. Moving on we need more translations. We also need some bilingual individuals (namely in Arabic and Thai) to infiltrate these perverted communities to unmask their identities. This is one of the first threads I've seen that have actually made a step towards progressing. Let's keep this up. There is so much more left to uncover.