Massive wall of text incoming:
Nomenclature:
EHP: Effective Hitpoints; an effective amount of hitpoints (armor) that a ship gets due to game mechanics. In this instance, it is hardpoint convergence, missing shots, and damage reduction
The rebalance changes to SCBs and hull reinforcement packages have changed the pvp metagame. The reworking of SCBs has been arguably a good change. In the beta test for horizons I experimented with hull tanking on the Cobra MKIV and found it to be a very viable strategy. After playing Horizons for a while now, however, it is clear that hull tanking is far too powerful, particularly on small ships and especially when utilized with silent running. In this post I will illustrate the reasons why hull tanking is too powerful and it has begun to overcentralize into a cancerous metagame where hull tanking silent running Viper MK IV's, DBS, DBE, and Cobra MK IVs equalize and arguably even exceed the combat capabilities of the FDL, FAS, and similar tier ships.
First, a discussion of hull reinforcement packages is needed. As is understood by us, they increase the base armor of your ship by a additive amount. The armor addition per HRP for the D grade modules (the most effective ones) are as follows:
1D: 110
2D: 190
3D: 260
4D: 330
5D: 390
The original values for HRPs in D grade from 1.4 were as follows:
1D: 15
2D: 30
3D: 60
4D: 120
5D: 240
Creating a difference of:
1D: +95
2D: +160
3D: +200
4D: +210
5D: +150
Hull reinforcement packages fully stack additively. Additionally, they increase the effectiveness of ramming, which we will discuss later.
Let's consider a cookie cutter Viper MK IV build designed to hull tank:
http://coriolis.io/outfit/viper_mk_iv/24A4A4A2A3A3A4C2626232302022b2b29272766.Iw1-kA==.Aw1-kA==?bn=Cookie%20Cutter
We have a Viper MK IV with 1825 Armor, roughly twice the amount of an anaconda.
Additionally, there is evidence that in 2.0/1.5 military grade bulkheads instead create a flat % damage reduction as opposed to increasing armor, as illustrated from this post (mirrored and reactive already do this for their respective damage types). Note how the damage reduction was not close to half, but instead a roughly 33% reduction
http://triadius.net/2015/11/25/bulkhead-armor-test-beta-1-5-3/
If we consider this to be the correct model for illustrating damage against ships and ignore the added armor bulkheads actually give to the ships (which has been shown to be inconsistant with the findings above, you instead have 2433 effective armor against thermal damage and 2294 effective armor against kinetic damage.
So, why is this an issue? Abstract logic is coming up; be prepared.
On larger ships, having a lot of armor makes sense for two reasons. Number 1 is the ship is meant to be more durable, which makes sense as you pay more money for it. Reason number 2, and the more important reason to keep in mind, is that the ship is larger, is a LARGER TARGET TO HIT, and is much less maneuverable.
We can take away multiple things from this. A smaller target is going to be much harder to hit. Even if you are an ace pilot and can follow enemies flawlessly with fixed weapons, you will still miss a good percentage of your shots due to the lack of hardpoint convergence. Since these shots are missing the smaller ships that would otherwise hit larger ships, this effectively also increases the HP of smaller vessels. For those commanders who haven't learned to aim or are using ships with poor hardpoint convergence such as the clipper, this also means that the gimballed sway from gimballed hardpoints is going to be off target much more frequently than on a larger ship such as an anaconda. I expect in practice for this to increase the EHP of these ships by a multiplier 1.5 (33% of shots do not converge) for fixed weapons and 2.0 (50% of shots do not converge; this effect is enhanced and repressed at longer and shorter ranges, respectively) for gimballed weapons. This does not consider shots missed due to poor aiming (which also increases EHP), which is much much more difficult on these ships compared to a large ship such as an FDL. These multipliers are an abstrct representation of the armor these ships have as a comparison to larger ships and in this instance are generated from weapons being less efficient due to some shots missing.
Now we need to consider the added maneuverability of these smaller ships.
A Viper MK IV is somewhat less maneuverable than other ships in this class (particularly the DBS), but arguably still outmaneuvers most of the large ships in its tier (the maneuverability rating ships are given is not consistant and is inaccurate). As a result, this allows the ship to stay out of the firing arc of other ships for part of the time. Most of this is dependent on piloting skill, but we can assume for 2 equally skilled pilots that the Viper will stay out of the firing arc more frequently. Since a parameter like this is difficult to quantify, so for the purposes of illustration I will take a very conservative value and say this increases the EHP of the ship by a multiplier of 1.15 for a viper MK IV. I expect that this multiplier would be higher for ships like the DBS that has significantly more maneuverability.
Lets look at the effective HP our viper has now against a ship with fixed weapons:
1570 armor * ~1.5 bulkheads; military grade * 1.5 fixed weapons convergence * 1.15 maneuverability advantage = 4062 effective armor
Looks like we're starting to run into some problems here. We're not finished with our analysis, however.
Silent running is a gameplay mechanic that has a variety of unique effects. In the past, going cold had significant consequences to its use. However, gameplay changes in 1.5/2.0 have mitigated a lot of these effects. For starters, using silent running turns off your shields. For most ships, this would be a turnoff to silent running altogether except as a last ditch effort or as part of an escape mechanism. However, this is not a consequence for hull tanking ships, as they have no shields. Additionally, silent running builds heat in your ship, which builds up over time. Convienently, heatsinks were buffed in 1.5/2.0 in effectiveness and duration and will easily take a ship that is at 100% heat to 0% heat while in silent running. Before the reduction was roughly a 40-50% decrease in heat. Thus, the consequences of silent running for hull tanking ships is not very significant.
Now, the benefits:
You are untargetable by ships unless you are within 550 meters (it is probably less than this value; this was the value found for the python in this video was 550 meters. I would expect it to be less for these smaller ships: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fPYH8gB2uTc )
You appear as a fuzzy contact on the radar.
You have more options for hardpoints because you have more power to utilize without a shield generator.
Being untargetable has massive implications for PVP. Gimballed weapons and fixed weapons both become fixed weapons with zero hardpoint convergence. Additionally, you no longer have a leading target recticle for cannons, multicannons, dumbfire missiles, and Plasma Accelerators because you cannot target them, EFFECTIVELY MAKING THESE WEAPONS WORTHLESS. Since all kinetic weapons are borderline impossible to use without a targeting recticle, there is no reason to run anything other than mirrored armor armor. Thus, we must change our multiplier from roughly 1.5 to 2.375 (from this post http://triadius.net/2015/11/25/bulkhead-armor-test-beta-1-5-3/ ). We must also consider that players attacking you with kinetic weapons while in silent running are going to effectively be worthless at killing you in combat.
Once again, it is difficult to quantify the increased hp created from a lack of harpoint convergence and being a fuzzy contact on radar. Once again I will use conservative values of 1.25 (roughly an additional 20% of shots miss) for convergance and 1.02 for being a fuzzy contact, respectivly.
Lets plug in our abstract representation of the effective armor our Viper MK IV has now against fixed weapons:
1570 armor (base + HRPs) * 2.375 (mirrored surface bulkheads vs thermal weapons) * 1.5 fixed weapon convergence * 1.15 maneuverability advantage * 1.25 convergence issues while silent running * 1.02 radar fuzzy contact = 8200 EFFECTIVE ARMOR and kinetic weapons are more or less worthless for the duration of silent running.
Hull reinforcement packages also affect the values when ramming other ships. In the current state, a hull tanked Viper MV IV can kill an FDL from 49% hull to 0% while only taking 22% hull itself; see https://youtu.be/-COWoR0xtKE?t=2m14s I've personally found the hull damage from ramming to be extremely high from these ships (which I personally find hilarious, but unrealistic). I personally consider ramming to be a very situational strategy, but worth mentioning as well.
From my experience fighting against these ships, you can unload an entire C3 capacitor into one of these ships with pulse lasers and do 1% hull damage. 2 C2 PA shots against a steal DBS does 5% hull damage. We also ran a test earlier where we fired 8 Torpedo Pylons into a Hull Tanked Viper MK IV. It did a total of only 52% hull damage. 8 Fucking torpedos did 52% hull damage to a VIPER MK IV.
With all of this in mind, there needs to be some drastic changes as to how HRPs are calculated. Either they need to give significant diminishing marginal returns when they are stacked, or the armor addition needs to be significantly decreased for smaller compartments. I do not think the values should be reverted back to 1.4; they should still be higher than that, but I think multiplying each subsequent package by a factor of 2 was a good idea to not give small ships stupid amounts of armor. I think values around this range would probably be a good balance:
1D: +25
2D: +50
3D: +100
4D: +160 (the cobra MK IV and Viper MK IV have 4 and 2 class 4 compartments, respectively). 200 armor is still too much for each compartment
5D: +320
And then
1E: +20
2E: +40
3E: +80
4E: +130
5E: +260
Currently these "cancer ships" are beginning to dominate the PvP metagame and are arguably more powerful than ships such as the FDL, Python, FAS, Clipper, etc. with equally skilled pilots. This needs to change. I'd honestly like to see a hotfix that rescales the armor values to something more reasonable.