r/Eggnog • u/sunflowerastronaut • Dec 26 '25
r/Eggnog • u/CutApprehensive4327 • Nov 27 '25
Eggnog Picture My girlfriend made eggnog pie!
r/Eggnog • u/Sunnydayyyyyze • Dec 11 '25
Starbucks Egg Nog is worse than I could have possibly imagined
For context: I’m a happy-go-lucky gal who only writes positive reviews for things. Secondary, I’m a lover girl for some good egg nog!!!! So I go to Starbucks today (not something I do on the regular) and I see they’ve got the new egg nog drink- wonderful! I’m all about egg nog and I figure I might as well give it a go just for funsies! Tis the season, right? WRONG! Starbucks has disrespected egg nog lovers everywhere with this drink.
Now you’re probably thinking: “surely this young woman knows to not expect life-changing quality from the ol’ Starbs” and you’d be correct! However, I did not expect my taste buds to be brutally assaulted this morning. (Dramatic? Yes. Accurate? Absolutely.)
It’s one thing for me to go “oh yeah.. not what I expected! Not great.. but I’m a garbage disposal and would be happy to inhale anything so whatevs!” But for me to go “DEAR GOD WHAT IS THIS?!? I HAVE TO WARN PEOPLE” ..it’s gotta be ROUGH.
Starbuck’s egg nog is bitter, not sweet at all, and not worth $7 for a grande. I know I made my bed, so I’ll lie in it today.. but please heed my warnings and don’t go anywhere near that nightmare drink. Do not be tempted! Do not go gentle into that good night!
r/Eggnog • u/Gullible-Ad-5424 • Oct 30 '25
It’s that time of the year where my spouse is disgusted when I buy eggnog. Anybody else the singular eggnog drinker in their household?
Kemps is the go-to store bought, but homemade is way better.
r/Eggnog • u/milkyearlgreys • Jan 02 '26
RIP Eggnog Season 2025
Anyone else sad about eggnog being taken off the shelves? They are officially out of it at all my shopping spots. I did manage to find one last carton of C F Burger Creamery’s Old Fashioned Egg Nog, though. First time trying. I understand when people say eggnog has a “bubble gum-y” flavor, now. I’ve never experienced it before this brand. Meh. Eggnog Season 2026, I’ll be waiting for you! 🙏🏽
r/Eggnog • u/Such_Collection3252 • Dec 27 '25
Store ran out of nog so got this at a local dairy shop and it didn’t disappoint. I don’t know if I can go back to the cheaper stuff. Staff was super friendly
r/Eggnog • u/[deleted] • Nov 26 '25
Eggnog Picture Do you ever use eggnog as a cream in coffee?
r/Eggnog • u/battlexp97 • Nov 04 '25
Eggnog Picture my first eggnog!
finally its time to try eggnog! husband been waiting for this moment (he's more excited than me lol) cause he wanted to introduce me to one of his favorite drink🥤
we bought this last night and turned out he's not so satisfied with the taste (he said its different and might be wrong one he tried last time), but I actually loved it! good impression for first try...... and I drink the whole eggnog myself😋 which brand do you think I should try next? also are eggnog originally using nutmeg? since this one has "no nutmeg" in it.
r/Eggnog • u/fenderbender86 • Dec 31 '25
Fresh nog from a local dairy
Hartzler's in NE Ohio has some of the best egg nog I have ever had. Sold right on the dairy farm. Super thick and creamy, just amazing. Almost made me forget I hit a patch of black ice and ended up in a ditch last night. And it comes in a glass bottle, so you know it's good!
r/Eggnog • u/MetallicRust • Oct 14 '26
Eggnog Picture Finally, Walmart comes through with the nog
Not on the outside coolers with the milk but in separate island coolers by the milk. Upstate SC USA.
r/Eggnog • u/Chopin23 • Nov 23 '20
Eggnog Question Why do some Eggnogs taste like bubblegum?
My friend told me he thought that some eggnog tasted like bubblegum the other day and I thought it was maybe a genetic thing... Later we taste tested two different brands (Anderson Erickson and Prairie Farms) and I could immediately notice what he was talking about. AE does NOT have the bubblegum taste, while Prairie Farms does.
To anyone with doubts, please compare the two and rinse your palette between the two nogs with water.
Does anyone know what ingredients or combination of ingredients cause this flavor in some nogs?
UPDATE:
For anyone interested, here is my current list of nogs, sorted by whether they taste like bubblegum or not. Please let me know if my info on location is not accurate and I can update the list:
| Brand | Bubblegum-flavored? | Where to Buy? |
|---|---|---|
| Anderson Erickson | no | Midwest US |
| The Fresh Market | no | US? |
| Alton Brown's Aged Eggnog | no | Homemade Recipe |
| Chipwhich (RIP) | no | discontinued |
| Island Farms | no | Canada |
| Oberwieis | no | Northern Illinois / Wisconsin |
| Kroger (Vanilla) | no | US? |
| Southern Comfort (Vanilla Spice) | no | US? |
| Southern Comfort (Original) | yes | US? |
| Kroger (Original) | yes | US? |
| Prairie Farms | yes | US? |
| Friendly's | yes | US |
| Acme Valley Eggnog Ice Cream | yes | US? |
| Avalon Dairy | yes | Canada |
| Hood Light | yes (as of 2022) | US? |
| Kirkland | yes | US? |
| Hiland | yes | US? |
| Stewart’s Shoppe | yes | New York |
| CF Berger | yes | IN, OH, PA - Store Locator |
| Giant Eagle | yes | IN, OH, PA - Store Locator |
| Calder | yes | Store Locator |
| Publix | yes | SE US |
| Lucerne Dairy Farms | yes (as of 2023?) | WA, CO, OR, AZ, CA, PA |
| Dairyland | yes | Western Canada |
| Trader Joe's | yes | US |
| Lactaid | yes (as of 2023) | US |
| Kwik Trip / Kwik Star | yes | MI, MN, WI, IL, IA, SD |
| Twisted Kandy (Taffy) | yes | Oregon |
| South Mountain Creamery | yes | NE US - Store Locator |
r/Eggnog • u/Novel-Birthday1408 • Jun 20 '26
fairfield inn clinton tn
and what does this signify? who said eggnog
r/Eggnog • u/BeckTech • 16d ago
Eggnog Picture Eggnog in a decanter! I feel like Frasier and Niles Crane now lol!
r/Eggnog • u/Horse_Nudity • Nov 17 '25
Eggnog Picture Does anybody agree that Aldi’s Eggnog is the best?
I read articles online saying the best eggnog is______. But they never even try Aldi’s. Any one out there who agree? Personally, I can’t get enough of this stuff.
r/Eggnog • u/MICHAIEIL • Jan 02 '26
Eggnog Picture Calder Dairy MI - so thick you could cut it with a butter knife!
Amazing stuff, just like a milkshake. A must try if you’re in Michigan!
r/Eggnog • u/Laurenwithyarn • Jul 05 '25
Eggnog in July????
While looking for cheese for my 4th of July burgers at Safeway, I found eggnog! I've had eggnog around Easter before, but who ever heard of eggnog in July?!?
r/Eggnog • u/Botellas_Antigues97 • Sep 29 '26
Eggnog Review Hartzler Egg Nog.
10/10. One of the best Egg Nogs I've ever had.
r/Eggnog • u/MikeDeY77 • Oct 30 '25
Eggnog Picture Starting this season off with a brand I haven’t tried.
I’ve been an avid eggnog enthusiast for about 30 years. Never seen this brand.