r/EditMyReddit • u/Boovaloo • Jul 27 '20
r/EditMyReddit • u/UltraConstructor • Oct 28 '20
[META] How to make a good edit (imo obviously)
Are meta posts allowed on this sub? idk. Well, I’m going to type this out and if mods deem this unfit so be it.
I’ve seen a lot of edits that just change ONE ELEMENT of the question. This means, they just change a noun to a noun, or a verb to a verb, etc. creating repetitive comments on different posts. Let’s look at examples of bad edits, and some really good ones.
some good examples of a lazy edit:
Do you like cookies?
Yes
Edit: do you like hitler?
This one is a perfect example. Just changing the noun is lazy, there is nothing interesting about it, it isn’t creative. Here’s another bad example:
How would you feel if you saw a dog get adopted?
Happy
Edit: how would you feel if you saw a child get attacked?
It’s just lame. No structural rewording, just a simple switch-out.
Now there is one exception to this (in my opinion, obviously, all of this is my opinion) and that is humor. It gives the edit life where it usually wouldn’t be there.
What would you do if the hottest person on earth started making out with you?
Kiss them back
Edit: what would you do if Queen Elizabeth came onto you while you were alone?
This one is funny! And that gives it a place in its own right, I feel. Feel free to comment if you disagree with any of this, btw.
Now let’s look at a good edit, one that changes multiple parts of a sentence, and rewrites the meaning entirely.
What would you do if you saw a child run across the street?
Leave him alone
Edit: what would you say if someone let you decide a child rapists fate?
It creates a whole new meaning for the answer! Here’s another, one that I saw on my post a while back. The topic for this question was “Make me sound depressed”
What would you learn to build if you could build anything?
A chair
Edit: someone gives you a rope, what’s the first thing you look for?
It’s new, creative.
Coming up with creative edits is hard, but the feeling you get is so entertaining when you are stuck wondering how on earth the question-asker got OP to say that specific statement, and you can achieve that with a good edit.
Thank you for your time.
r/EditMyReddit • u/JackArmstrongBJJ • Oct 23 '20
Make me sound as racist as possible against white people
Do your thing
r/EditMyReddit • u/[deleted] • Aug 08 '20
Make me sound like that one weird kid your mom forced you to play with.
r/EditMyReddit • u/-ChickenLover- • Jul 31 '20
Make me sound like I absolutely hate babies/children
r/EditMyReddit • u/[deleted] • Jul 30 '20
Make me sound like my iq is lower than the temperature outside
r/EditMyReddit • u/lizfransen97 • Jul 23 '20
Make me look like I've done crimes.
I didn't kill my wife!
r/EditMyReddit • u/Jears99 • Oct 31 '20
META [Meta] Would you be interested in a bot that replies with the original question before it got edited?
Looking at the poll, most people would like that bot. But to keep it fun for everyone, it will be in spoiler text so you don't have to see it.
r/EditMyReddit • u/Hyrem25 • Aug 04 '20
Free theme! Edit whatever you want! I'll try to answer as fast as possible
And have fun
r/EditMyReddit • u/Shut-the-up • Jan 08 '20
EMR, I wasn’t planning to go anywhere in life anyway
r/EditMyReddit • u/TheMazter13 • Sep 05 '20
You don't have to write "Make me sound like a psychopath" in the title because the subreddit description says "Make him sound like a psychopath". EMR
r/EditMyReddit • u/[deleted] • Aug 05 '20