One night in 1812, between one and two in the morning, there was a violent knock at a door in Yorkshire. Thirty or more men with blackened faces came in and smashed the cloth-finishing machines. We know the details because the man who opened the door, John Sykes, gave a sworn statement.
The usual version of the story is simple: the Luddites were wrong, machines came, new jobs appeared, everyone won in the end. In total terms, that's broadly true. But the men at the door were mostly croppers, skilled workers who finished cloth by hand with heavy shears, a craft that took years to learn. The shearing frame turned that into work needing far less skill. As historian Kevin Binfield points out, they weren't against technology in general; they targeted specific machines used to push wages down. For their own lives, their fear was not baseless.
Some things I found while researching this for a video essay:
- David Ricardo, one of the most influential economists of the time, added a whole new chapter, "On Machinery", to the 1821 edition of his book, admitting that machinery could hurt workers' interests after all.
- David Autor's framing: machines take tasks, not jobs. Your job is a bundle of tasks, and some get automated while others become more valuable.
- In a study of 5,172 customer support agents (Brynjolfsson, Li & Raymond), AI help raised issues resolved per hour by about 15% on average, with the biggest gains for the least experienced.
- But Stanford payroll data suggests that in the most AI-exposed jobs, employment for 22–25 year-olds has fallen behind their peers in less exposed jobs, while experienced workers show no such gap. The researchers call it an early warning sign, not proof.
Mokyr, Vickers and Ziebarth's paper "Is This Time Different?" (2015) was the lens for the whole thing. Where I ended up: the useful question isn't "is this fear valid?" but "for whom, and when?"
I made an 11-minute video essay on this (small channel called Idea Prism, this is my own work): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvfF3Mr_dWw
For people working in fields AI is already touching: is it taking tasks off your plate, or is it the entry-level rungs that are quietly disappearing?