r/EasternPhilosophy • • Aug 21 '26

Is philosophy an illness ?

Post image
615 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Apr 28 '26 Bravo

Blog Who am I?, Nature of consciousness based on the Upanishads, source text of Advaita Vedanta non dual spirituality

Post image
427 Upvotes

The Upanishads are among the most profound explorations of consciousness and reality ever written. Composed over 2,500–3,000 years ago, they do not merely speculate about the world—they challenge the very foundation of what we take to be “real.” At their core lies a radical claim: what we ordinarily take to be the self—our body, thoughts, emotions, identity—is not the ultimate reality. Your “self” is a lie. A temporary costume. Everything we identify with is subject to change. The body ages, the mind fluctuates, emotions arise and pass. According to the Upanishads, anything that changes cannot be the true Self. The real Self must be something constant, unchanging, and ever-present.

Have you ever wondered why dreams feel real? You’re flying over New York as Superman, and you don’t question it for a second. The mind accepts that absurd world completely. Now ask yourself: how do you know you’re not dreaming right now?

You can’t because both the waking world and the dream world are made of the same stuff: Maya — illusion. Projections of the mind. So what is real? You — the Witness consciousness. The pure awareness that watches everything. The screen on which the movie of life plays. The projector that stays unchanged while the film (your entire life) keeps rolling from birth to death.

The Upanishads teach Neti Neti — “Not this, not this.” Strip away everything you can describe with an adjective. You are not your body. Not your emotions. Not your thoughts. Not even your mind. Anything you can point to and say “this” is an object. You are the Subject. The pure consciousness that illuminates all of it. By negating everything that can be observed—body, senses, thoughts, even the intellect—the seeker arrives at what cannot be negated: pure awareness. The Upanishads describe four states of consciousness:

  1. Waking (Jagrat) – engagement with the external world

  2. Dreaming (Swapna) – internally generated experiences

  3. Deep Sleep (Sushupti) – absence of differentiated experience (here, modern science says consciousness vanishes — Upanishads say this is where only pure consciousness remains, without any illusion)

  4. Turiya — the “fourth,” underlying all three: pure awareness itself.

Turiya is the only true reality. Everything else is a borrowed appearance. Science now agrees on something ancient sages knew. But the real world can’t be an illusion, right? No. We never experience the world as it is. Your brain builds a virtual model of reality every second. A blind or colourblind person sees the world differently, but that doesn’t make it any less real. You don’t see a towel or a ball rather, your brain creates a model of it. A bat lives in an entirely alien one. Dreams feel real because the same mind is generating the simulation. There is no external “world” separate from you — only your conscious experience. You are not in the universe. The universe is appearing in you.

In the dream, you were all the animals, rivers, and mountains; in reality, you are all the animals, rivers, and mountains. Both created by your mind. How can you identify with worldly things and say, ‘I’ like this, hate that? When the world you know is itself false, an illusion created by your impermanent mind. The real ‘You’ is the awareness or pure consciousness underneath, that illuminates your mind and body. Existence itself is an intrinsic characteristic of awareness, and anything apart from this awareness is an appearance that doesn’t have any intrinsic existence; it borrows existence from awareness, just as in a dream, it borrows existence from you, the dreamer.

Classic parables from the Upanishads:

  • At night, you mistake a rope for a snake and feel real fear. The fear wasn’t caused by any actual snake — it was caused by ignorance of reality.

  • Gold is shaped into bangles, necklaces, and rings. Understand the gold, and you understand every ornament. In the same way, understand your true Self (Brahman), and you understand the entire universe.

Advaita Vedanta (the non-dual interpretation of the Upanishads) goes even further. Advaita = “not two.” There is only Brahman — the ultimate, infinite, eternal reality. It is not a god among gods. It is Sat-Chit-Ananda: Pure Existence, Pure Consciousness, Pure Bliss. Your own consciousness is Brahman. The universe only appears separate because of ignorance (Maya). When that ignorance drops, you don’t become Brahman. You realize you were never anything else. Liberation — Moksha — is not something you achieve. It is the recognition that you were never bound. Even the gods, if they exist, are just waves on the same ocean of Brahman. Like the old story of the five blind men touching different parts of an elephant and arguing — each describing a different “truth.” The elephant is Brahman. We’re all just touching different parts. Just like a fungus, mycelium fruits mushrooms at different locations on the surface, but underneath it is the entire fruiting body that is one single organism.

Personal note: After just 4 months of open-awareness meditation (no focus on breath, just watching thoughts, sensations, and emotions arise without grabbing them), my own thoughts started feeling… alien. They popped up from somewhere deep and dissolved back into the same awareness. The “me” that used to own them disappeared. The real You was never the thinker. You are the space in which thinking happens. If this resonates even a little… sit with it. Not as another belief to collect, but as something to realize. The Upanishads don’t want you to believe them. They want you to wake up. Neti Neti. Not this. Not this. Until only the Truth remains.

It inspired generations of physicists who shaped Quantum Mechanics and modern philosophy. Just read what these giants said:

Arthur Schopenhauer: “In the whole world, there is no study so beneficial and so elevating as that of the Upanishads. It has been the solace of my life, and it will be the solace of my death.”

Max Müller: “There is no book in the world that is so thrilling, stirring, and inspiring as the Upanishads.”

Henry David Thoreau: He bathed his intellect in the “stupendous and cosmogonal philosophy” of these texts, finding our modern world puny in comparison.

Erwin Schrödinger: “The multiplicity is only apparent. This is the doctrine of the Upanishads… Vedanta teaches that consciousness is singular, all happenings are played out in one universal consciousness and there is no multiplicity of selves.”

Niels Bohr: “I go into the Upanishads to ask questions.”

Others like Werner Heisenberg, Hans-Peter Dürr, and Brian Josephson found deep resonance between quantum paradoxes and Vedantic non-duality.

Here's a playlist of Advaita Vedanta (non-dual spirituality) that I’ve made, 60 videos by Swami Sarvapriananda. Every video is like nectar. So much so that I can clearly divide my life into 2 phases, before and after I got to see his videos on YouTube last October.  Save it and watch in your free time.

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLyufs6domzrgGpwofIFuDRBYnrzKF3LiP&si=kr71KxhgvxmpJQiQ

Here's a playlist for the explanation of the Upanishads. Reading without commentary is like reading a foreign language like Mandarin, it's cryptic. Only the first videos of each Upanishad are included, as I didn't want the playlist to be 100+ videos long. Just continue the series if interested.

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLyufs6domzrjNxjsFb_FVb-zowpZ6f__d&si=h3XDqS3Zr6IazGrA


r/EasternPhilosophy • • May 29 '26 Heartwarming

Mencius was an ancient Confucian philosopher who believed that human nature was good. Not all humans are good, but everyone has "sprouts of virtue" that can be cultivated and nourished. Everyone tends towards goodness just as water naturally goes downwards.

Thumbnail
platosfishtrap.substack.com
419 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Jul 12 '26

Talk Wu wei made me realize how much energy I wasted resisting reality

Post image
92 Upvotes

Over time, I used to get anxious about time, trying to control and stress over my age, comparing myself with successful people around me and getting frustrated about doing something all the time.

Always thinking about the future, always thinking that I need a purpose for this existence and chasing something all the time: money, skills, a main goal, a purpose. Then when I didn't get something as I planned I was angry, very low energy or frustrated with myself when I couldn't do something.

This frustration turned into anxiety where I was seeing the world in a different way, I was imagining the worst situations when I imagined a FAIL. Currently I am 25 and my biggest fear was not achieving all my goals before 30, because I want to build a family and have kids when I get to 30.

Then, I realized that the more I chase something, the more I force things with life, and the more I am wasting my energy and my time. Why am I chasing this success if I am not enjoying my time achieving it? Because if I am not enjoying my future, I am wasting my time. If I am thinking about the future all the time, I am wasting my time and energy. Then I picked up escapist habits to numb the stress.

Anxiety is driven by the human desire for certainty, permanence and meaning, in a world that is impermanent, ever-changing, and uncertain.

I read some of the textual quotes by Alan Watts in the book The Wisdom of Insecurity that made me open my eyes about how I was living my life and managing my time. These are the quotes:

"If all is relative, if life is a torrent without form or goal in whose flood absolutely nothing save change itself can last, it seems to be something in which there is 'no future' and thus no hope."

Here is exactly how Wu Wei describes the reality that I have to accept: life as a chaos where the only permanent thing is change. Alan Watts represents the fear as a water source (the fear of the ego from resistance), while Wu Wei is the answer to this fear (flow with the water instead of feeling fear of it).

"If happiness always depends on something expected in the future, we are chasing a will-o'-the-wisp that ever eludes our grasp, until the future, and ourselves, vanish into the abyss of death."

Here it connects with Wu Wei because WE CLING TO THE FUTURE, completely the opposite of "meeting what's here". Wu Wei is to stop clinging to the future and stop thinking about the future, to be in the present.

Wu wei isn't really about "living in the present" as a goal you chase; that would just be one more thing to grip. It's that when you stop forcing, when you stop reaching into the future to control it and stop clenching around the past, there's nothing left holding you anywhere but here. The present isn't a place you arrive at by trying. It's what's left when you stop fighting the current. You don't do presence. You stop doing everything else, and presence is simply what remains.

Reference:

Watts, A. (1951). The Wisdom of Insecurity: A Message for an Age of Anxiety. Pantheon Books. (Quotes are from the opening chapters; I don't have the exact page numbers on hand.)

Over time, I used to get anxious about time, trying to control and stress over my age, comparing myself with successful people around me and getting frustrated about doing something all the time.

Always thinking about the future, always thinking that I need a purpose for this existence and chasing something all the time: money, skills, a main goal, a purpose. Then when I didn't get something as I planned I was angry, very low energy or frustrated with myself when I couldn't do something.

This frustration turned into anxiety where I was seeing the world in a different way, I was imagining the worst situations when I imagined a FAIL. Currently I am 25 and my biggest fear was not achieving all my goals before 30, because I want to build a family and have kids when I get to 30.

Then, I realized that the more I chase something, the more I force things with life, and the more I am wasting my energy and my time. Why am I chasing this success if I am not enjoying my time achieving it? Because if I am not enjoying my future, I am wasting my time. If I am thinking about the future all the time, I am wasting my time and energy. Then I picked up escapist habits to numb the stress.

Anxiety is driven by the human desire for certainty, permanence and meaning, in a world that is impermanent, ever-changing, and uncertain.

I read some of the textual quotes by Alan Watts in the book The Wisdom of Insecurity that made me open my eyes about how I was living my life and managing my time. These are the quotes:

Here is exactly how Wu Wei describes the reality that I have to accept: life as a chaos where the only permanent thing is change. Alan Watts represents the fear as a water source (the fear of the ego from resistance), while Wu Wei is the answer to this fear (flow with the water instead of feeling fear of it).

Here it connects with Wu Wei because WE CLING TO THE FUTURE, completely the opposite of "meeting what's here". Wu Wei is to stop clinging to the future and stop thinking about the future, to be in the present.

Wu wei isn't really about "living in the present" as a goal you chase; that would just be one more thing to grip. It's that when you stop forcing, when you stop reaching into the future to control it and stop clenching around the past, there's nothing left holding you anywhere but here. The present isn't a place you arrive at by trying. It's what's left when you stop fighting the current. You don't do presence. You stop doing everything else, and presence is simply what remains.

This problem in my life made me have anxiety for the last 3 years, but it inspired me to dive into the problem and fix it. I want to help others to go through life and learn how beautiful life is when we dont let the fear take over our energy: Stop resisting your own reality.

Reference:

Watts, A. (1951). The Wisdom of Insecurity: A Message for an Age of Anxiety. Pantheon Books. (Quotes are from the opening chapters; I don't have the exact page numbers on hand.)


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Jun 18 '25

What's the 24 Solar terms? And why it's matter ?

49 Upvotes

In ancient China, time wasn't just measured by clocks or even the four seasons. Instead, the year was divided into 24 Solar Terms, a system based on the sun’s precise position along the ecliptic. Each term spans about 15 days and reflects subtle shifts in the natural world—budding plants, changing winds, returning birds, or the first signs of frost.

Developed over 2,000 years ago, this calendar wasn’t just agricultural—it was philosophical. It expressed the idea of Heaven-Human Unity (天人合一): that human life is meant to move with nature, not against it.

Some terms are well-known, like the Spring Equinox or Winter Solstice. Others are beautifully specific, like:

Jingzhe (Awakening of Insects): when thunder wakes sleeping animals.

Bailu (White Dew): when cooler nights bring condensation on the grass.

Shuangjiang (Frost’s Descent): the first hard frost, signaling deep autumn.

Why does it matter today?

Because we still feel seasonal changes—even if we no longer farm or follow lunar calendars. The 24 Solar Terms offer a slower, more embodied way to think about time. They don’t just mark dates; they describe transitions. Instead of rushing through the year, they encourage awareness of where we are—physically, emotionally, seasonally.

In 2016, the system was recognized by UNESCO as Intangible Cultural Heritage. But more than a cultural artifact, it’s also a reminder: that paying attention to the world outside can reconnect us with something inside.


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Feb 07 '22

Discussion Meet my cat, Ego

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • May 25 '26

The Buddha's First Noble Truth: suffering. Suffering, he thought, was a pervasive feature of human existence. (Ancient Philosophy Podcast episode)

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
44 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Mar 02 '26

Foundations of Early Chinese Philosophy

Post image
43 Upvotes

Part1


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Sep 25 '26

Acharya Prashant and Robert Lawrence Kuhn discuss consciousness, ego, and Advaita Vedanta

Thumbnail
youtu.be
39 Upvotes

Came across this beautiful extended conversation about whether consciousness is fundamental and whether the ego should be treated as the true self or as a construction that produces attachment and suffering. Acharya Prashant presents a Vedantic approach based on self-inquiry, while Robert Lawrence Kuhn raises questions from the perspective of Western philosophy, science, and philosophy of the mind. The discussion also touches on karma, reincarnation, free choice, and AI consciousness (something I had been reflecting on).

Thought it could lead to an interesting discussion about how these ideas compare with Buddhist anatta, Sankhya, or other Eastern philosophies of the Self.


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Sep 06 '26

Favourite books about eastern philosophy?

37 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Oct 01 '26

Discussion Is Final Enlightenment Just a Fantasy of the Ego?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
34 Upvotes

I wanted to share this dialogue between scientist Rupert Sheldrake and philosopher Acharya Prashant, filmed in London. It’s a genuine, two-hour exchange where they actually push into points of disagreement rather than just exchanging pleasantries.

While Western popular culture often focuses on avoiding the "spiritual ego," Acharya Prashant makes a much more structural argument rooted in core Advaita Vedanta principles: the ego is physiological and bound to the physical body. Because it accompanies the body's configuration, a final, permanent "destination" called enlightenment is impossible in principle. It can only be a continuous direction of self-reduction and thinning down. He beautifully calls any claim of final arrival "the ego issuing itself a death certificate."

Sheldrake challenges this from a different angle, recalling a conversation he had with Jiddu Krishnamurti. Krishnamurti believed that the enlightenment of one individual could spontaneously enlighten all of humanity. Sheldrake pointed out that given the terrible state of the world, it suggests no one has actually achieved it yet. When pressed on exactly how many enlightened people it would take to shift the world, Krishnamurti’s response became completely indeterminate.

This leaves us with a compelling philosophical dilemma:
If claiming enlightenment is the very thing that disqualifies you from being enlightened, does the concept become entirely unfalsifiable? Or is this strict Vedantic refusal to validate a "he who has arrived" the only true defense against spiritual self-deception?

Curious to hear how this sub views the concept of enlightenment as a never-ending journey versus a permanent state.


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Jul 25 '26

Discussion Gita doesn't focus on Karma

Thumbnail reddit.com
30 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • 21d ago

Acharya Prashant on Closer To Truth: "Free Will Equals No Will" – Thoughts?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
29 Upvotes

I just watched Part 2 of Acharya Prashant’s conversation with Robert Lawrence Kuhn on Closer To Truth and wanted to get this community's take on his approach to Advaita Vedanta.

His perspective on Free Will really stood out to me. Instead of the usual Western debate over standard determinism, he argues:
- Will is exercised entirely by the ego.
- The ego itself is fundamentally unfree and bound by its own compulsions (self-preservation, security, identity).
- Therefore, the only true instance of "free will" occurs when the ego consciously chooses its own reduction and self-dissolution.

Essentially, true free will equates to having no egoic will at all.

He applies a similar via negativa (negation) approach to everything else in the session, dismantling conventional notions of God, the soul, and life after death as literal ontological realities, treating them instead as pointers toward the absence of the ego.

For those who have studied classical Advaita or Madhyamaka Buddhism (he heavily references Nagarjuna’s views on dependent existence, how do you feel about this highly psychological, non-metaphysical framing of Eastern philosophy?

Does defining free will strictly as "the choice to dissolve the ego" hold up, or does it oversimplify the traditional framework?


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Jul 27 '26

Discussion These words of Confucius were leveraged against Buddhists and Daoists for centuries. They probably just meant "don't get distracted."

29 Upvotes

For most of the last thousand years, Confucian officials had a line from The Analects that they used to justify suspicion of Buddhism and Daoism. It's eight characters long, and three of them probably don't mean what the tradition decided they meant.

2.16 子曰:「攻乎異端,斯害也已。」

The standard reading has been roughly "To study heterodox doctrines — this is harmful", or, in its strongest form, "Attack heterodox doctrines, and their harm will cease." That second version is a license, and it was used as one.

Three of the eight characters are genuinely of indeterminate meaning, and almost everything turns on them.

攻 (gōng) is usually "attack." But it appears in only two other passages in the Analects and is about literal attacks in neither. At 11.17 Confucius tells his students to sound the drums and 攻 Ran Qiu for enriching the Ji family — public denunciation, not battle. At 12.21 he says to 攻 your own faults rather than other people's. Both are a kind of moral censure. It is also a plausible loan graph for 功 (gōng), to work at.

異端 (yì duān) is literally "different endpoints." 異 is other or divergent; 端 is a terminus or extreme — but not necessarily a final one. Modern 開端 (kāiduān) means a beginning. "Heterodoxy" is a later hardening of the phrase, not something the two characters demand.

已 (yǐ) is normally a sentence-final particle of emphasis. It can also be read as the verb to stop.

Multiply those out. Take 攻 as labour and 異端 as alternative endpoints, and you get a warning about wasted effort: working toward the wrong destination costs you a life you only get once. Take 攻 as attack and 異端 as heterodoxy, and you get polemic. Add 已 as "stop," and the sentence stops describing anything at all and becomes a strongly worded instruction.

The hardening has a timeline

What I find striking is how late the doctrinal reading actually consolidates.

皇侃 (Huáng Kǎn, 488–545), the major Six Dynasties commentator on the Analects, still glosses 攻 as 治 (zhì) — to work at, to apply oneself to. Not attack. What is circulating around 500 is the hardened sense of 異端 as "heterodoxy" among literary writers— so it's a fact about the word before it becomes a fact about this passage.

By the twelfth century 朱熹 (Zhū Xī) had made the heterodoxy reading standard. Even he, tellingly, kept 攻 as "devote effort to", and identified the offending doctrines as Mohism and Yangzhuism. That is almost certainly anachronistic: only the seeds of those schools existed in Confucius's lifetime, and it would be odd for him to denounce them exactly once in the entire text and never again.

As Buddhism and Daoism grew in China, the heterodoxy reading became politically useful. The Ming completed the job by taking 已 as "stop," which turned the line into an imperative. At that point it licensed officials to suppress not only Buddhism and Daoism but any unapproved reading of the classics themselves.

The tomb manuscript

There is physical evidence against the attack reading.

In 1973 excavators opened Han tomb no. 40 at Bajiaolang, in Dingzhou — the burial of 劉脩 (Liú Xiū), King Huai of Zhongshan, who died in 55 BCE. Among the bamboo slips was a copy of the Analects, now known as the 定州論語 (Dingzhou Analects).

At 2.16 it does not read 攻. It reads 功 — to work, to achieve.

That doesn't settle what the "different endpoints" were. But it's a first-century-BCE reader who evidently wasn't being told to attack anything.

The irony sits two passages earlier

2.14:

子曰:「君子周而不比,小人比而不周。」

"The exemplary person is inclusive and not partisan; the petty person is partisan and not inclusive."

Two lines later, the text was made into an instrument of exactly that partisanship.

And the vocabulary that supports the mild reading is in the Analects itself. 19.4, 子夏 (Zǐxià):

雖小道,必有可觀者焉;致遠恐泥,是以君子不為也

"Even in the small ways there is surely something worth seeing; but pursued far they bog you down, and so the exemplary person does not take them up."

That's 2.16's argument stated plainly by a disciple, with the concession built in: the byways are worth something. The objection is to distance, not to value.

What I'd actually like to discuss

I should be upfront that the distraction reading is a minority one. The orthodox reading for most of the last thousand years was the other, and it was written into imperial policy. I'm not claiming the tradition simply got it wrong for a millennium; I'm claiming the text underdetermines it and the resolution went the way power needed it to go.

What I'm curious about, for this sub specifically: does the same drift show up in the other traditions?

Chinese Buddhism has the 外道 (wàidào) "outside paths" for non-Buddhist teachings, which is structurally almost identical to 異端, "different endpoints." Both start as spatial metaphors about routes rather than verdicts about error. And if I understand correctly, 邪見 / micchā-diṭṭhi, "wrong view," is a category with real teeth in the Pali material.

So: is there a general tendency for "wrong path" language to harden into "heresy" language once a tradition acquires state backing? And did 外道 or 邪見 undergo anything like the same shift? Or did Buddhist institutional history push those terms in a different direction? I know the Confucian side of this much better than the Buddhist side and would genuinely like to be corrected.

My translation of Passage 2.16 along with related analysis is available at https://www.analects.net/episodes/22 if you want to check my work.

It's part of a series that goes through the Analects passage by passage — this one is episode 22 — but the argument above stands on its own and I'd rather talk about the passage than the show.


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Apr 02 '15

Tibetan Teen Getting Into Western Philosophy | The Onion

Thumbnail
theonion.com
28 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Mar 15 '26

Discussion Eastern philosophy without sophistry recommendations

25 Upvotes

I'm a beginner in philosophy and just read most of Platos works. I want to to decide where to continue and thought about eastern philosophy.

Most of the books about eastern philosophy I've found are full of sophistry and "deep" quotes that seem to have some value but almost always don't provide any reasoning and are so open to interpretation that they carry, atleast to me, no value.

Does anyone know some books (ideally primary literature) that do have some reasoning or atleast signs of logic closer to Plato's nice way of logical writing?


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Apr 16 '20

Discussion Hi! My great grandmother brought this box back from her travels to Asia in the early 1900s. Does anyone know what the symbol means? Any help is much appreciated! Thank you ☺️

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Dec 21 '14

‘Atheisms’ in ancient India

Thumbnail cidabhasa.wordpress.com
24 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Aug 22 '13

Alan Watts - The Middle Way

Thumbnail
youtube.com
23 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Mar 22 '21

Review My grandfather (bless him) sends me a quote from the Gita almost every morning for inspiration... I have no idea where he finds them, but I decided to make an app to make the whole process easier!

22 Upvotes

Pranaam🙏

I would like to share with you a labor of love that I’ve devoted the last year to making. It started as just a small project to help me connect with my grandpa and our religion, but over time it’s significance has grown. I want to share my creation with other newbies who might not have that much background (as I did) but want to reconnect with the teachings in the Gita. I’ve learned so much in making this, but I hope I can share some of that knowledge with other who are interested.

This is solely a passion project, there are no ads and I’m not making any money off of this, I simply want to make a platform for others like myself to get engaged with the verses which have transformed millions of lives already.

Please check it out and give me any feedback you have— every bit is appreciated!

Here’s an example: https://i.imgur.com/lkESuCE.jpg

You can check out the google play store listing here (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.hindutalk.hindutalk) and the iOS version is coming soon.

Thank you! 🌺


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Sep 12 '20

Best Philosophy Books (see comments for the list)

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/EasternPhilosophy • • Dec 22 '14

Welcome New Users!

22 Upvotes

The Master said, "In strolling in the company of just two other persons, I am bound to find a teacher. Identifying their strengths, I follow them, and identifying their weaknesses, I reform myself accordingly" (Analects 7.22).

Please be aware this is a community centered around academic discussion of Indian and East Asian philosophy, and is not for idle musings. The foundational resources are all on our sidebar. We like insightful questions and quality sources!

Thank you!


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Aug 22 '13

Let's talk reading lists

22 Upvotes

Lao Tzu? Sutras? Watts? Let's bash it out


r/EasternPhilosophy • • 16d ago

Discussion Gita in a Church: Is the Ego Already Its Own Punishment?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
20 Upvotes

Pop religion usually tells us that we will be punished for our bad actions in the future, through the popular lens of standard linear Karma, or an afterlife like heaven and hell.

But in a recent Bhagavad Gita session held at a church in London, Acharya Prashant offered a much tighter, tighter realization on verse 3.32: the ego doesn't face punishment in the future; it is its own punishment right now.

The Gita implies we are punished by what we are, not just for what we do. The moment we choose self-preservation and surface-level comforts over truth, our deepest desire for freedom goes unfulfilled. That unfulfillment is the immediate sentence.

Two psychological traps from the talk really stand out for discussion:

The Claim to Knowledge:
We admit we don't know specialised things like neuroscience, but proudly claim we completely know our relationships, our partners, and ourselves. This false confidence keeps us trapped in our habits because we refuse a deeper internal look.

The Portrait Trap:
When we ask what an "awakened person" looks like, it's often a classic ego move. We want a blueprint to copy externally (the look, the style, the words) or a "trailer" to judge and dismiss, rather than holding a mirror to our current state.

How do you view this immediate restructuring of Karma vs. the popular linear concept?

Does seeing the ego as an active, living punishment change how you approach self-observation?


r/EasternPhilosophy • • Oct 16 '25

Is Advaita Vedanta compatible with European Nature Worship?

20 Upvotes

I'm conflicted..

I believe in all 3 sources (Upanishads, Bhrama Sutras and the Bhagavad Gita). I fully embrace the concept of Brahman as the creator or element lying within everything, bestowing life. I also believe in Karma, Samsara, and the goal of life: Moksha. I recognize that, through Brahman, all of life, existent or non-existent, is One.

My question then is can I be a Hindu who also worships nature in the same way as "European" pagans did, or does this entirely conflict with Advaita Vedanta?

If I understand correctly, Hindus are generally accepting of different paths as long as it brings us closer to Brahman (the Ultimate Truth).

A part of me wonders if venerating Nature clashes with the philosophy of Advaita Vedanta because it focuses largely outside itself, as opposed to taking a path of Yoga, where the focus is inward.

I'm very confused

Thank you to anyone who replies!