r/EasternCatholicism • • Jul 14 '24

I'm a Traditional Roman Catholic who's been attending Divine Liturgy the past year. Here is my first attempt at writing an icon!

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Jun 11 '18

So You Want to Change Rites

42 Upvotes

Probably the most frequent question I get aside from "why are you Catholic?" is "how do you change rites?" So that's what I'll talk about a bit here.

First of all, the question is flawed: you don't change rites, you change Churches. So you don't go from being a Latin rite Catholic to, say, a Byzantine rite Catholic, you go from being a Roman Catholic to a Ruthenian Catholic (or whatever).

The first step would be finding a Catholic Church that isn't part of your canonical Church. If you aren't Roman Catholic, this won't be difficult. Otherwise, it might be a challenge and depends on city/region as to what your options are.

Begin attending the parish. After you attend long enough that you're recognized, maybe start approaching the priest for catechetical materials. This part of the process can just depend on where someone is in life, how formal of an education on the differences and similarities are needed, etc.

Anyway, you should probably attend your parish for a minimum of two years before attempting to change Churches. Anything less than that and there's a suspicion that this is a spiritual "fad," which among the East especially is often vindicated by experience with the people who pass through our doors. Eastern parishes especially don't have the resources of Western parishes, and so the significant time commitment put into potential "converts" isn't inconsiderable from our perspective. Nothing hurts more than spending dozens if not hundreds of hours getting you ready to formally join us and then finding out you're at a TLM parish now or became Baha'i or something.

So anyway, after you are in the parish a sufficient amount of time you would put in for what is currently being called a transfer of ascription. You do this by writing a letter to the bishop of the diocese you want to switch to. your priest will actually send the letter for you with his own cover letter. The letter is not your chance to relate your miraculous and heartfelt spiritual journey--it is a form letter. It should really only relate what Catholic jurisdiction you are currently in, how long you've been that (did you convert? Cradle? Etc) how long you've been going to the new parish and that you want to switch for the sake of your spiritual well-being (like, literally that phrase).

Your potential new bishop (read: his chancery, he'll probably never actually see it) will send a letter to your current bishop requesting that you be released to his jurisdiction. Your current bishop, assuming he agrees, will so release you by sending a letter back to your new bishop telling him as much. You are now a different Catholic than you were.

Now, the question is probably what are the snags. I can think of a couple--one would be if you haven't been in the parish long enough and either send a letter yourself or have an inexperienced priest rush the process. You will probably also be denied if you're going from an ECC to the RCC unless you have a really good reason, as we don't have the numbers to really be able to afford an exodus to the RCC. If it isn't your first transfer, or if you are transferring back, that will also require a much more detailed reason than "for my spiritual well-being." Another snag could be if your RC bishop doesn't know what an ECC is--yes, this sometimes happens, and if they don't have a good relationship with the local EC parish then the paperwork can take a few years for them to figure out what to do with it.

What about spouses and children? Children under 14 automatically switch if the father switches, and also get a one-time no questions asked ability to revert to their birth Church as adults. Spouses can switch without a formal transfer if one of them already has transferred, or they can choose to remain whatever they are.

Note: none of this applies to non-Catholics, who are free to just come into any Catholic jurisdiction as a convert without any additional paperwork

Edit: Because of this suggested elaboration, I'll talk a bit about good reasons vs bad reasons to switch Churches.

Good reasons:

--Authentically improves your spiritual life --Marriage

Bad reasons:

--Novelty --Analog for what you really want

I'll expand on those points a bit: the first one is self-explanatory, in that if becoming an Eastern Catholic brings you closer to God, then you should become an Eastern Catholic. Marriage, also, is a very good reason, because it can be difficult for marriages to have "mixed faith," even when they are both a part of the same communion. If you are coming in from outside an Eastern Church, there will probably also be added pressure to change Churches if only because most Eastern Churches are fiercely proud of their identity and so will be unlikely to want to switch themselves or have their children switch.

As for bad reasons, novelty is the worst. A lot of people can come through and be really wowed by the services of the Eastern Churches and enjoy them without feeling necessarily edified by them. Which is to say that you can be a Latin Catholic or a different type of Eastern Catholic and enjoy attending one of our churches without having to become a member. The problem here is that the novelty of the experience can threaten to substitute itself for an authentic calling, and once that wears off you will be just as unhappy with us as where you were before.

Similarly, it is a bad idea to become Eastern Catholic in an effort to use our Churches to fight whatever battle is happening in your own Church. Seeing an Eastern Catholic parish celebrate the liturgy ad orientem and with plenty of "smells and bells" doesn't mean that we exist as a potential TLM parish that just need our eyes to be opened up to the glories of 1950s Irish Catholic parishes. People who become Eastern Catholic for this reason, much like the novelty reason, tend to burn out eventually and move on. As a corollary, we are sometimes sought out by pious married men in traditions that do not allow them to become ordained to the priesthood, and this is also not a great reason to join--not only will you be disappointed to find that no one is going to let you be a Roman Catholic priest (in all but name) in an Eastern Catholic parish, but you also will be treated with more scrutiny in the first place and they will want to be doubly sure that you are changing over for the right reasons. We need priests, same as everyone else, but we need priests who are interested in being Eastern priests, not men who are interested in being priests and see Eastern Churches as a way around celibacy.


r/EasternCatholicism • • Feb 10 '19

So You Want to Switch Rites?

36 Upvotes

a repost of our popular thread, to enable continued questions in the comments:

Probably the most frequent question I get aside from "why are you Catholic?" is "how do you change rites?" So that's what I'll talk about a bit here.

First of all, the question is flawed: you don't change rites, you change Churches. So you don't go from being a Latin rite Catholic to, say, a Byzantine rite Catholic, you go from being a Roman Catholic to a Ruthenian Catholic (or whatever).

The first step would be finding a Catholic Church that isn't part of your canonical Church. If you aren't Roman Catholic, this won't be difficult. Otherwise, it might be a challenge and depends on city/region as to what your options are.

Begin attending the parish. After you attend long enough that you're recognized, maybe start approaching the priest for catechetical materials. This part of the process can just depend on where someone is in life, how formal of an education on the differences and similarities are needed, etc.

Anyway, you should probably attend your parish for a minimum of two years before attempting to change Churches. Anything less than that and there's a suspicion that this is a spiritual "fad," which among the East especially is often vindicated by experience with the people who pass through our doors. Eastern parishes especially don't have the resources of Western parishes, and so the significant time commitment put into potential "converts" isn't inconsiderable from our perspective. Nothing hurts more than spending dozens if not hundreds of hours getting you ready to formally join us and then finding out you're at a TLM parish now or became Baha'i or something.

So anyway, after you are in the parish a sufficient amount of time you would put in for what is currently being called a transfer of ascription. You do this by writing a letter to the bishop of the diocese you want to switch to. your priest will actually send the letter for you with his own cover letter. The letter is not your chance to relate your miraculous and heartfelt spiritual journey--it is a form letter. It should really only relate what Catholic jurisdiction you are currently in, how long you've been that (did you convert? Cradle? Etc) how long you've been going to the new parish and that you want to switch for the sake of your spiritual well-being (like, literally that phrase).

Your potential new bishop (read: his chancery, he'll probably never actually see it) will send a letter to your current bishop requesting that you be released to his jurisdiction. Your current bishop, assuming he agrees, will so release you by sending a letter back to your new bishop telling him as much. You are now a different Catholic than you were.

Now, the question is probably what are the snags. I can think of a couple--one would be if you haven't been in the parish long enough and either send a letter yourself or have an inexperienced priest rush the process. You will probably also be denied if you're going from an ECC to the RCC unless you have a really good reason, as we don't have the numbers to really be able to afford an exodus to the RCC. If it isn't your first transfer, or if you are transferring back, that will also require a much more detailed reason than "for my spiritual well-being." Another snag could be if your RC bishop doesn't know what an ECC is--yes, this sometimes happens, and if they don't have a good relationship with the local EC parish then the paperwork can take a few years for them to figure out what to do with it.

What about spouses and children? Children under 14 automatically switch if the father switches, and also get a one-time no questions asked ability to revert to their birth Church as adults. Spouses can switch without a formal transfer if one of them already has transferred, or they can choose to remain whatever they are.

Note: none of this applies to non-Catholics, who are free to just come into any Catholic jurisdiction as a convert without any additional paperwork

Good Reason and Bad Reasons to Change Churches

Good reasons:

--Authentically improves your spiritual life

--Marriage

Bad reasons:

--Novelty

--Analog for what you really want

I'll expand on those points a bit: the first one is self-explanatory, in that if becoming an Eastern Catholic brings you closer to God, then you should become an Eastern Catholic. Marriage, also, is a very good reason, because it can be difficult for marriages to have "mixed faith," even when they are both a part of the same communion. If you are coming in from outside an Eastern Church, there will probably also be added pressure to change Churches if only because most Eastern Churches are fiercely proud of their identity and so will be unlikely to want to switch themselves or have their children switch.

As for bad reasons, novelty is the worst. A lot of people can come through and be really wowed by the services of the Eastern Churches and enjoy them without feeling necessarily edified by them. Which is to say that you can be a Latin Catholic or a different type of Eastern Catholic and enjoy attending one of our churches without having to become a member. The problem here is that the novelty of the experience can threaten to substitute itself for an authentic calling, and once that wears off you will be just as unhappy with us as where you were before.

Similarly, it is a bad idea to become Eastern Catholic in an effort to use our Churches to fight whatever battle is happening in your own Church. Seeing an Eastern Catholic parish celebrate the liturgy ad orientem and with plenty of "smells and bells" doesn't mean that we exist as a potential TLM parish that just need our eyes to be opened up to the glories of 1950s Irish Catholic parishes. People who become Eastern Catholic for this reason, much like the novelty reason, tend to burn out eventually and move on. As a corollary, we are sometimes sought out by pious married men in traditions that do not allow them to become ordained to the priesthood, and this is also not a great reason to join--not only will you be disappointed to find that no one is going to let you be a Roman Catholic priest (in all but name) in an Eastern Catholic parish, but you also will be treated with more scrutiny in the first place and they will want to be doubly sure that you are changing over for the right reasons. We need priests, same as everyone else, but we need priests who are interested in being Eastern priests, not men who are interested in being priests and see Eastern Churches as a way around celibacy.


r/EasternCatholicism • • Aug 28 '19

On August 28th, 1915, during the Assyrian Genocide, the Chaldean Catholic bishop Phillip Yaʿqob Abraham was summarily executed by Ottoman authorities, after refusing conversion to Islam.

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Sep 22 '24

Help translating

Post image
20 Upvotes

Hi, I was wondering if anyone could help translating this? Much thanks.


r/EasternCatholicism • • Aug 08 '19

Melkites join pro-life protest

Thumbnail
catholicweekly.com.au
20 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Jun 01 '18

Rites vs Churches

19 Upvotes

We often seen in discussions the use of the word rite in the place of the word Church. This is one of the subtle ways, probably unintentional for most people but nevertheless a problem, in which our identities are undermined.

Rites refer to the specific liturgical traditions a Church uses. A Church refers to the self-governing patriarch (in the larger Churches), bishops, priests, and laity who are united not only in faith but administratively. Think similar to Orthodox autocephaly, but with the added complication of figuring out (and asserting) everyone's role given the Roman Catholic stance on the pope, which is why the word as autonomous is often used in place of autocephalous in the Catholic communion.

A rite can be used by multiple Churches; for instance, both the Chaldean Catholics and Syro-Malabar use the East Syriac rite. The Melkites, Ukrainians, and anyone with an Eastern Orthodox equivalent uses the Byzantine rite.

On the other hand, a Church may have multiple rites, as the Roman Catholic Church does--the Latin rite is the most well-known, but there are also the Mozarabic rite, Ambrosion rite, and others.


r/EasternCatholicism • • May 25 '26

There are ‘most pure celestial spaces of the kosmos ’ (ἐν τοῖς καθαρωτάτοις τοῦ κόσμου χωρίοις ἐπουρανίοις) and ‘even purer super-celestial ones’ (ἢ καὶ τοῖς τούτων καθαρωτέροις ὑπερουρανίοις).

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 06 '20

TIL that despite being a symbol of counterculture, Andy Warhol was a devout Byzantine Catholic who went to church almost daily. His brother said he was "really religious, but he didn't want people to know", and Andy Warhol even enthusiastically financed his nephew's studies for the priesthood.

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
18 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Aug 17 '19

A new Maronite Monastic Order has apparently been established

Thumbnail
instagram.com
18 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Jun 29 '19

Melkite Catholic bishops call for peace in Syria during annual synod

Thumbnail
catholicphilly.com
18 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Apr 12 '20

Christos Voskrese.

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • May 15 '25

His Beatitude Paul I Peter Massad, Maronite Patriarch of Antioch and all the East, photographed at some point between 1863 and 1865

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Feb 16 '19

Coptic Martyrs Remembered

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 20 '19

Open air rock cross also called Nasrani sthambam usually found in front of Kerala Syrian Christian churches

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Nov 02 '18

Legendary liturgical historian Fr. Robert Taft has reposed

Thumbnail
byztex.blogspot.com
15 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Jan 28 '19

Attended a really beautiful Divine Liturgy using Tchaikovsky's music last night

14 Upvotes

So I live in New Jersey, and I normally sing for the Traditional Latin Mass, but I guess Facebook ad algorithms informed me of a Divine Liturgy at St. Mary's Byzantine Church, NYC, where they were having a guest choir come in to sing Tchaikovsky's setting of the Divine Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom. I went along with some friends, one of whom is actually Byzantine, but never experienced the Liturgy with a choir before.

It was overwhelmingly beautiful. Bishop Kurt Burnette of the Eparchy of Passaic was also present.

After Liturgy, there was a dinner reception in the parish hall. Some friends from an NYC young adult group were there and they introduced me to some Byzantine young adults, and we had fun discussions about fasting rules. The best part was when Bishop Kurt went up to us and asked us what we thought. Including myself, there were 3 other Latin Mass young adults there, and we expressed our admiration of the Liturgy, and my Byzantine friend chimed in his opinion now that he can say he attended a Latin Mass too, to which Bishop Kurt exclaimed, "Wow, I came over just to say hi because we rarely see large groups of young adults, but no one told me I had to study beforehand!"

I also spoke to some of the singers, whom I recognized from singing in Latin Masses together, and they introduced me to their choir director. He told me he was a Byzantine cantor growing up, and he went to music school, but there's a dearth of Byzantine choirs in the area, so he gathered his interested Roman friends and they sing sacred Slavonic music but in the context of the Liturgy once a month. I thought that was really cool.


r/EasternCatholicism • • Oct 25 '18

A funny video about the differences between Catholics and Orthodox (though it seems this would also include Eastern Catholics too)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
14 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Jul 31 '18

[MEME] Chrismation? What's that?

Thumbnail
imgur.com
14 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • May 20 '22

What’s a Melkite, anyway?

Thumbnail
pillarcatholic.com
13 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Mar 20 '20

Maronite Catholic Church in my city doing drive-though confessions

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Aug 21 '18

Eastern Catholic Priest Attacked

Thumbnail
self.orthodoxchristianity
13 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • Jun 07 '18

What are the differences between Ukrainian Greek Catholics and Ruthenian Byzantine Catholics?

13 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholicism • • May 29 '18

A Mission Statement, of Sorts

13 Upvotes

In order to plunge into the concept of Eastern Catholicism, we must first turn to the animal kingdom, specifically fish. Now, “fish” has a long history of meaning merely aquatic animals. In the past, it extended even to animals which are never today considered to be fish, such as whales and even crocodiles, as well as to animals which today are still typically referred to as “fish.” Of course, though the definition has narrowed, it remains somewhat of a catch-all. Fish said generally and non-academically includes the starfish, jellyfish, cuttlefish, and all manner of creatures, even siphonophores and the like which aren’t even properly speaking individuals. This general definition stands in contrast to the so-called “true fish,” what perhaps is conjured up in the minds of the reader when a fish is pictured, even though fish generally can be extended to other creatures. Which is to say, we mean by fish primarily though not exclusively true fish; to the point that, while the term does encompass other aquatic life, we have to specify that by fish we actually mean something which isn’t a fish at all, like a jellyfish, if we want to signify something other than a “true fish.”

And this is, of course, the trouble with “Eastern Catholicism,” in that it is a negation. There is no such thing as an Eastern Catholic; Eastern Catholicism signifies an absence of Latin Catholicism, and nothing more. After all, in the same way that nothing connects the siphonophore and the jellyfish aside from both being aquatic and both being not true fish, nothing really is common between, say, a Melkite and a Chaldean Catholic aside from that both aren’t Roman Catholics but both are in the Catholic communion. Neither liturgical tradition nor linguistic tradition nor history nor theological developments connect the two, and yet in one breath we may refer to both under the non-word of Eastern Catholic.

However, with a proper name we can restore the history of each, because it isn’t a filler informing the reader what the referent is not, it becomes a whole again. The Melkite Church is a definite entity with a history all its own, a people all its own, it enters time and space as a positive existence which is less what it is not and more a defined form. The same is true of the other Churches, whether Eritrean, Ethiophian, Coptic, Chaldean, Maronite, Ukrianian, Italo-Albanian, etc. The whole of these Apostolic Churches demand to be taken on their own merits, with their own histories, their own theologies, their own customs, their own identities.

Archbishop Joseph Tawil of thrice blessed memory is famous worldwide for his pastoral letter, and later book, The Courage to Be Ourselves. Part of capturing that courage is, indeed, being ourselves. Not experiencing ourselves through a kind of DuBoisian double-consciousness, both Latin and not Latin simultaneously, but as our authentic selves with our authentic identities.

I welcome all who wish to participate to join us on r/EasternCatholicism, where all are welcome but where Eastern voices will be given the room to flourish and to speak for themselves. Obviously, in light of what I’ve written, the name is somewhat ironic, but I hope that it can be a force for an authentic expression of Christianity which for too long hasn’t been engaged on its own terms.