r/EasternCatholic • • May 09 '24

Non-Byzantine Eastern Rite Looks like the Syro-Malabar Church venerates three heresiarchs, why the Pope or their Archbishop doesn't do something about it?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Mar Nestorius, Mar Theodore and Mar Diodore, heretics who opposed Council of Ephesus


r/EasternCatholic • • Dec 21 '24

General Eastern Catholicism Question Eastern Catholicism seems different

2 Upvotes

I might get some downvotes but I just wanted to share my subjective perspective of Eastenr Catholicism I am an Oriental orthodox (Ethiopian orthodox) who grew up attending Russian/Greek Orthodox churches aswell as Coptic/Ethiopain Orthodox Church so I am well familiar with the Byzantine Rite and the Alexandrian rite. Till last Sunday I have never been to Eastern catholic church but have seen numerous videos and been on this sub enough to be exposed to eastern Catholicism. In my country both eastern Catholics and Protestants are grouped as “pente” and from the videos of seen of Ethiopian Catholicism even though we use the same liturgy the way they say it which is called “zema” in Amharic is incorrect in traditional

I’ve noticed that the terms, placements, and actions performed by the clergy in certain churches differ significantly. Additionally, the church songs, or "Mezmur" as we call them, closely resemble Protestant worship music, contrasting sharply with the traditional Ethiopian Orthodox guidelines. Please don’t take offense, but it feels as if I’m witnessing imposters pretending to be part of the Orthodox Church. If I were to enter an Ethiopian Catholic Church, I would immediately recognize that it’s not truly Orthodox but rather a different denomination that is “trying” to follow the Ethiopian Orthodox traditions.

Recently, I attended a Greek Catholic Church and instantly sensed it wasn’t Orthodox, despite its use of the same rite as the Greek Orthodox Church, which I’m familiar with. In my experience, the only Eastern Catholic Church that doesn’t give off this impression is the Maronite Church. I suspect this is due to their long-standing familiarity with the Syriac rite. Unlike other Eastern Catholic communities, which often emerged as Uniate groups from the 15th to 19th centuries, the Maronites have maintained a distinct identity, although the Latin influence in their church complicates matters. It feels like when I see orthodox churches in liturgy it seems professional? Idk and when it’s eastern Catholic there’s always some little things that just screams in my face. Sometimes, it’s an intuitive feeling other times, it’s just a nagging thought in the back of my mind saying, “Wait... this isn’t Orthodox.”

This post is totally subjective and I mean no harm to anyone if you take offense I am sorry I just wanted to know if anyone knows why this is and if they had the same experience.


r/EasternCatholic • • Apr 12 '24

General Eastern Catholicism Question How aren't the Orthodox heretics

0 Upvotes

How are EO's not heretics when they deny the Pope and the Filioque?


r/EasternCatholic • • Oct 28 '20

new subreddit

0 Upvotes

hello
i made this new subreddit, if someone wants to join
r/TheChristChurch

its catholic, dont worry


r/EasternCatholic • • Jun 26 '25

Reunification Rome

3 Upvotes

Douse anyone else think roman catholics and they're attitudes toward orthodox might be the main thing in the way of reunification? I'm not saying that they're aren't major theological issues, but so many roman catholics I know take a belittling tone to orthodox. I honestly am more open to the idea that the great schism is almost equal in blame.


r/EasternCatholic • • Aug 08 '25

General Eastern Catholicism Question Which Church Should I Go To?

0 Upvotes

Hi! I’m a Latin Caþolic, but recently I’ve become very interested in þe eastern heritage of þe Church. Unfortunately, where I live þere aren’t opportunities to go to any kind of eastern rite

However, þis Sunday I’ll be in Philadelphia to help my sister move into an apartment, and I want to take þe opportunity to fulfill my Sunday obligation at an eastern church. I found a Byzantine, Maronite, and Armenian church. Which would you guys suggest I go to?

My þoughts are þat since Byzantine-rite churches are þe most numerous churches, I should go to one of þe oþer two, but maybe þere’s someþing I’m not considering. Any and all advice would be helpful

Þank you and God bless!

EDIT: Þank you all for your insight! I ended up going to þe Maronite parish, mostly due to practical scheduling constraints, and þe Holy Qurbono was beautiful!

Þey had a shrine of St. Jude Thaddeus, which is my home parish’s patron as well. I can’t help but feel as if his intercession guided me þere


r/EasternCatholic • • May 19 '26

Theology & Liturgy The Dilemma/Irony

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/EasternCatholic • • Jan 10 '23

Is it institutionally possible for papal infallibility to be overturned?

0 Upvotes

Please read the whole post before commenting, as this is a very hypothetical question, and patience is required for me to work out its conditions in language.

Imagining that an ecumenical council was called, and the council wished to dogmatically define a walkback of the Vatican I and II position on Papal Infallibility, specifically as it pertains to ex cathedra. Is this even possible, or does the entirety of the Catholic faith come unravelling, since it would also entail a rejection of the development of doctrine?

That is to say, since ex cathedra is defined magisterially, and Vatican II refers to the doctrine as part of "[the Pope's] infallible magisterium" then do we have a cascading reductio whereby the Church proclaimed something as Divine revelation in one age, and then rejects that same revelation in another?

I hope I am making sense enough for someone to glean my question here. It is difficult to articulate.


r/EasternCatholic • • Aug 23 '24

General Eastern Catholicism Question Question

0 Upvotes

So my wife is Byzantine Catholic I’m an inquirer into Orthodoxy. My son was born during your pascha. My wife and I were having a convo that if my son has a birthday during lent we’d celebrate. I replied “you should ask your priest you should submit every thought to him or you can send him to hell for not caring for your soul and protecting you.” I noticed no one really does this in the parishes I’ve visited and I’ve been a part of. Is the practice of having a spiritual father not a thing?


r/EasternCatholic • • Aug 02 '26

Reunification A serious push for unification of Orthodoxy and Catholicism can heal Europe

0 Upvotes

I believe such an event with serious preparations can heal the great schism and push Europe to new hights of acceptance and integration, Imagine if most of Orthodox countries sign a petition for unity and the Pope shows he is ready to give up papal supremacy. The schism is mostly a result of geopolitical pressures and less so of serious theological differences. We can create a new age of the roman empire with all the issues healed with English as the new Latin. Do you think the Pope would give up the papal supremacy in our lifetimes?

Edit:
I didn't want to imply the language in liturgical terms which obviously is not a source of issues AFAIK, it was meant to be as a source of common language and understanding between the two worlds which was a problem in the past


r/EasternCatholic • • Jul 12 '24

Theology & Liturgy Curious about theological differences

0 Upvotes

Hi! I just discovered Eastern Catholic. I have a background of Roman/Latin Catholic and Eastern Orthodox theology, so I wanted to know some stuff. I am planning to join a Byzantine Catholic Church in particular, so I was wondering what are the major differences between the Byzantine Catholic and Roman/Latin Catholic. Also what’s some differences between Byzantine Catholic and the Eastern Orthodox Church besides papal authority?


r/EasternCatholic • • Apr 10 '24

General Catholicism Question (Includes Latin Church) Depictions of Christ in iconography

0 Upvotes

Hello, I am sure you’ll have heard about President Vladimir Putin seeming to think Jesus is black and unveiling icons of Jesus that depict Him in this way in a vault in Russia. Has the Catholic Church condemned Jesus being a certain skin color dogmatically and do we have any issue of depicting Jesus as any race? After all, prior to the schism of Chalcedon, the Church had no issue with the Ethiopians depicting Jesus as black in their iconography and to my knowledge we never have condemned the Ethiopians who did not schism after Chalcedon for depicting Jesus as black either and neither do we condemn Chinese Christians for depicting Jesus as Chinese. So what is people’s deal here? Why are they making it such a big deal if European Christian’s depict Jesus as white when the Apostle St Paul says to spread the Gospel you must relate to people’s cultures?


r/EasternCatholic • • Mar 20 '24

Theology & Liturgy servers in epitrakheilia

0 Upvotes

https://www.instagram.com/p/C4rn6Bas4Yg/?igsh=ZG4wd20yMHBkanV5

what kind of stupid idea is it to dress up servers in mini epitrakheilia?


r/EasternCatholic • • Mar 17 '24

General Eastern Catholicism Question Why is there so many orthodox in here?

12 Upvotes

Every time there is someone asking question regarding eastern catholcism, there is always eastern orthodox rushing to comment. Not that they can't give answers, but there are rather huge differences between eastern orthodox and eastern catholic churches and i don't think eastern orthodox or any orthodox in fact, are correct in their opinions.


r/EasternCatholic • • May 09 '25

General Eastern Catholicism Question Question on 3 dogmas

0 Upvotes

On Original sin. I don't believe that humans are born sinful. I believe while humanity does bear the consequences of the original, or first, sin, humanity does not bear the personal guilt associated with this sin. Adam and Eve are guilty of their willful action; we bear the consequences, chief of which is death.

On IC: I believe Mary lived a sinless life, but I think she was born with an ancestral tendency to sin. Not exempt from it. But she didn't by the grace of God.

On intercession of saints: I don't believe that the saints can hear our prayers. Sure, we may ask God something in name of the said saint, but I don't think we can communicate with the other world, or they are unconscious right now.

Do these beliefs pose a problem on being east catholic?


r/EasternCatholic • • Aug 12 '24

General Eastern Catholicism Question Is the label "Orthodox in communion with Rome" appropriate to describe Eastern Catholics, or for one to use as self-identification?

2 Upvotes

Personally I am uncomfortable using this language because of its implications. Being a Catholic is recognizing the early, undivided Church is the Catholic Church. The Eastern liturgical traditions, e.g the Liturgy of Saint John Chrysostom in the case of Byzantine churches, precede the Schism, and Eastern theology largely does as well.

There, to be Eastern is not intrinsically Eastern Orthodox in nature. From my understanding of the Magisterial paradigm, the East was Catholic first, largely became Orthodox second after schism, and through dialogue, it's gradually regaining the once-held universal communion.

If one says "Eastern Orthodox in communion with Rome" to define Eastern Catholicism, it seems to shift the paradigm to think of them as Orthodox first, and becoming Catholic second.

Now, while accomodations for a historically schismatic group which decided to come into communion with Rome is not unprecented, the most well-known case is the Anglican Ordinariate, I do not think this is analogous to the East. I am concerned that if many see themselves as simply Ex-Orthodox, their identity will lay its foundation on the assumption of being "other", which I perceive to be a flawed representation of the beauty of Eastern Catholicism, Christ's Church second lung.

What are your thoughts on the label? Do you use it for convenience's sake? Do you share my concerns? Do you believe I am overthinking this issue? Knowing myself, it's not unlikely.

Feel free to correct me if you see I am mistaken at some point of this post. I am always willing to learn, and while I'm passionate about my faith I'm not as well-read as I could be.

Thank you in advance.

  • Kyros 👑


r/EasternCatholic • • May 01 '25

General Eastern Catholicism Question Joseph in the East

4 Upvotes

What is the perspective on Joseph in the East?

There’s borderline an obsession and or cult around him in the West, the “Terror of Demons” as we call him… the devotions, the “Three Hearts” thing… I don’t understand any of that. It’s my understanding that in the East, that development never occurred.

So how important is Joseph in the East, in Orthodox theology, etc.? An Abbott at an Eastern rite monastery I went to described him as a “nobody” in the grand scheme of things biblically speaking.


r/EasternCatholic • • May 02 '24

Prayer Request/Praise Report Thank you all

4 Upvotes

Lurking this subreddit the past few months has made me very aware of the eastern catholic traditions. However, I have decided to become Orthodox. Thank you all!


r/EasternCatholic • • Aug 21 '24

General Eastern Catholicism Question Ukraine Orthodoxy

8 Upvotes

Apparently Ukraine voted to outlaw one of their schismatic churches… and or the entirety of their variant of Orthodoxy… I don’t know. How deep Zelensky is involved in this affair is unknown to me, but he is Jewish.

What does this mean for Christianity in the country?


r/EasternCatholic • • Oct 08 '25

Other/Unspecified TIL a Melkite bishop helped Liberation Theology to develop

7 Upvotes

As a Latin Rite Catholic who deeply admires Liberation Theology and the work of priests and nuns aligned with it in my country, it was a wonderful surprise to learn that Msgr. Hakim, then the Melkite Bishop of Jerusalem, assisted the late Fr. Paul Gauthier in making a retreat in Nazareth.

But this was no ordinary retreat: Gauthier intentionally shared the life and labor of local workers, striving to live as closely as possible to the example of "Jesus of Nazareth, the One Priest and Worker." This resonated with the worker-priest movement active in France at the time, where priests entered factories to evangelize the working class from within.

Inspired by this experience, Gauthier was invited by Bishop Hakim to participate in Vatican II and write a short book on the Church's mission among the poor. His work influenced some passages of the conciliar document Gaudium et Spes and helped pave the way for Latin American theologians—most notably Fr. Gustavo Gutiérrez—to develop Liberation Theology.

Thank you, Msgr. Hakim, for your profound spiritual and pastoral sensitivity! This Eastern bishop truly helped enrich Western theology and pastoral practice.


r/EasternCatholic • • Mar 20 '25

General Eastern Catholicism Question Do any of you support Latinization?

0 Upvotes

I do because I think the eastern catholic church is still catholic and shouldn't try to imitate the "orthodox". I was once talking to an Eastern Catholic priest who accidentally referred to himself as "orthodox" once. I know there are some SSPX eastern catholic priests who prefer latinizations. I also know there are some Eastern Catholics who only prefer certain latinizations. For example, priestly celibacy.


r/EasternCatholic • • Apr 11 '24

General Catholicism Question (Includes Latin Church) Rosary

0 Upvotes

Why don't eastern Rite Catholics really pray the rosary much (I know some do as an individual preference), if the Blessed Theotokos in the Fatima apparitions said to pray the rosary? Aren't we One Church and One Faith, whether Eastern or Latin Rite? Also, do Eastern Catholics do the divine mercy devotion which Jesus gave when appearing to St Faustina and do Eastern Catholics do divine mercy Sunday???


r/EasternCatholic • • Oct 06 '25

General Eastern Catholicism Question This is super cool.

0 Upvotes

Sorry if not appropriate, just hadn't seen a shirt like this ever before. Thought this would be a group of people who would appreciate it. https://www.etsy.com/listing/4380528252/jesus-prayer-shirt-lord-jesus-christ


r/EasternCatholic • • Aug 10 '26

Other/Unspecified Meeting ones spouse

0 Upvotes

What is the strangest way someone met they're spouse?


r/EasternCatholic • • Mar 08 '26

Other/Unspecified LOVER OF MUSIC and LOVER OF HYMNS come join us to a higher standard of worship!!!

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes