r/ELATeachers • • Oct 10 '24

9-12 ELA Grammarly is now generative AI that should be blocked on school servers

2.9k Upvotes

Two years ago, I was telling students Grammarly is an excellent resource to use in revising and editing their essays. We’ve had a recent wave of AI-generated essays. When I asked students about it, they showed me Grammarly’s site—which I admit I hadn’t visited in awhile. Please log into it if you haven’t done so.

Students can now put in an outline and have Grammarly create an essay for them. Students can tell it to adjust for tone and vocabulary. It’s worse than ChatGPT or any essay mill.

I am now at a point where I have dual credit seniors composing on paper and collecting their materials at the end of class. When we’re ready to type, it’s done in a Canvas locked down browser. It’s the only way we have of assessing what they are genuinely capable of writing.


r/ELATeachers • • Oct 09 '25

6-8 ELA "Mister, is using textbooks even legal? Did you get the principal's approval to make us do this?"

2.2k Upvotes

This is, not a joke, a student's response when I found a class set of literature textbooks in the 7th grade teacher's workroom the other day. I'm so thrilled. Pretty much all the stories and poems we planned to do anyway are in this book. So I wheeled them into my classroom and told the students we are going to use these almost every day and barely touch our computers (i.e. read from an actual book and write things on actual paper).

My response to that student was, "are you asking if it's illegal to read literature in school from a textbook?" Another student said she would tell her parents and I said, "yes, please tell your parents that your language arts teacher is making you read from an actual book. I'm sure that will go over well."

What a world we live in.


r/ELATeachers • • Mar 01 '25

Career & Interview Related U.S. Department of Education Launches “End DEI” Portal

Thumbnail
ed.gov
1.5k Upvotes

This new portal on DOE website is a form open to anyone to report teachers, school, or staff in order to ensure "meaningful learning free of divisive ideologies and indoctrination".

It is basically a snitch form that can trigger investigations into schools and educators who do not mirror the same values as the person filling it out.

As a PST, I'm beginning to wonder what kind world of education that I will be stepping into.


r/ELATeachers • • Mar 05 '26

9-12 ELA It's so cheesy but I love my new "leveled accomodations" framing for short writing

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

9th grade ELA, 67% IEP students but no co teacher because staffing 🫠

Really unsure about how to get to a finished test prep writing? Guiding questions and sentence stems. Get in the Uber.

Need some directions on how to get there under your own power? Pull it up on Google maps. Side question prompts for each step.

Ready to just write it like you will on the state test? Where you're going you don't need roads.

... one kid was gently prompted towards the middle level and said "OK, but can I sit next to (Higher Needs Child) and like...follow the Uber in my own car?"


r/ELATeachers • • Nov 03 '23

6-8 ELA Teaching A Raisin in the Sun and a parent is complaining…..

1.1k Upvotes

A father showed up to our superintendent’s office extremely angry that the 7th grade ELA teacher is teaching the students “how to talk black” (his exact words). His child informed me the next day that the dad will be at the school soon as he’s VERY upset with me for teaching this play and he has a few words for me.

I’m looking forward to this meeting so that he can share his blatant racism with me! I’m creating a list of notes I’d like to touch on with him to share the benefits of teaching this play and explain the direct correlation to our MI standards. Care to add to my list, fellow literature geniuses? 😏🙄😡


r/ELATeachers • • Oct 17 '26

Humor Sent to me by a student:

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/ELATeachers • • Aug 06 '25

6-8 ELA Stop with the AI

906 Upvotes

I’m a first year teacher and school just started and from the beginning of interacting with other teachers I’ve heard an alarming amount of “oh this ai program does this” and “I use ai for this” and there is ONE other teacher (that I’ve met) in my building who is also anti-ai. And I expected my young students to be all for AI and I could use it as a teaching moment but my colleagues? It’s so disheartening to be told to “be careful what you say about AI because a lot of teachers like it” are we serious?? I feel like I’m going crazy, you’re a teacher you should care about how ai is harming authors and THE ENVIRONMENT?? There are whole towns that have no water because of massive data centers… so I don’t care if it’s more work I will not use it (if I can help it).

Edit to add: I took an entire full length semester long class in college about AI. I know about AI. I know how to use it in English (the class was specifically called Literature and AI and we did a lot of work with a few different AI systems), I don’t care I still don’t like and would rather not use it.

Second Edit: I teach eleven year olds, most of them can barely read let alone spell. I will not be teaching them how to use ai “responsibly” a. Because there’s no way they’ll actually understand any of it and b. Because any of them who grasp it will use it to check out of thinking all together. I am an English teacher not a computer science teacher, my job is to teach the kids how to think critically not teach a machine how to do it for them. If you as an educator feel comfortable outsourcing your work to ai go for it, but don’t tell me I need to get with the program and start teaching my kids how to use it.


r/ELATeachers • • May 26 '26

9-12 ELA Painted This for My Classroom Ceiling

Post image
893 Upvotes

I am actually leaving teaching this year, which is terrifying because I have nothing lined up and the job market is horrid, BUT I’ve been doing it for eleven years, and all of them at the school I’m leaving. So I’ve encouraged my kids to paint the ceiling tiles as a last mark on the school (who knows how long they’ll keep them up 🤷🏻‍♀️). This is mine 🫶 one of my favorite books, and definitely my favorite to teach. More relevant and important than ever.


r/ELATeachers • • Nov 29 '23

Parent/Student Question Parent complaint about the closet scene in Mel Gibson version of Hamlet

891 Upvotes

As the title says.

If you've taught Hamlet, (or even read it as a student) you're familiar with the closet scene in Hamlet where he confronts his mother about her marriage to Claudius.

I'm in the middle of teaching Hamlet, and we've been watching clips from various film versions throughout our reading. For Act 3 Scene 5, "The Closet Scene" we watched the version with Mel Gibson and Glen Close where he famously kisses his mother on her bed. It's uncomfortable, to be sure, but I didn't go into this scene blindly with students -- we talked about the Oedipus Complex, it's origins with Freud, and how there are many people who have applied it to Hamlet. I warn the students that the scene is uncomfortable and sexually suggestive, but think about why a director might make this choice. This scene opens up a discussion about interpretation, and how different people have interpreted Hamlet and why this particular interpretation is so famous.

It's a conversation that really gets students thinking and disagreeing with the director and each other, and I think it is a valuable way to get them thinking about their own interpretations of the characters and the play, which leads into their final project where they do just that, and make a pitch for how they would make their own production of Hamlet. Not only that, I think it's important to look at the conversations that surround this play that has been around for 500 years, and the oedipal interpretation is one that is very (if not the most) famous.

I got an email from a parent complaining that I showed this scene in class (I teach 12th graders) and that it was inappropriate. I like to think that I did my due diligence in warning what the students were getting into beforehand, but I want to respond in a way that sounds tactful. I've shown this scene in years past and haven't gotten complaints, so I'm feeling anxious.

Any advice from some veteran English teachers? Thanks in advance!


r/ELATeachers • • Nov 03 '23

9-12 ELA Their command of the basics of written expression is scary.

755 Upvotes

I assigned an essay to my Honors 10th graders but did so in a program that did not provide functions for checking grammar, conventions, etc.

It's terrifying. A huge number of them are incapable of expressing themselves with any clarity without Grammarly to fix it for them. I know that in the real world they can use those programs, but seeing what they're actually capable of on their own is so disheartening. I don't even know where to begin to fix it. At this stage, how do you teach them to make sense when they write?? I feel like I learned primarily by reading a lot at an early age, but they didn't/won't do that, so where do I go from here?


r/ELATeachers • • Jan 12 '25

9-12 ELA That One Story

Post image
734 Upvotes

What is that one work you slip into your classes that is designed to leave that mark?


r/ELATeachers • • Jan 26 '26

Monday Motivation Can we all agree that education and literacy are important now?

Post image
678 Upvotes

We cannot move forward with an illiterate population.


r/ELATeachers • • Oct 08 '25

9-12 ELA Take home essays are dead

676 Upvotes

I tagged high school, which is what I teach, but I’m curious how consensus my take is. As I see it, AI forces me to assume anything created outside the four corners of my classroom, without technology and under test condition, has been touched by AI.

So we write everything in class. Absent? Come by at lunch for a different prompt of equivalent difficulty.

For me, it’s been freeing. No more AI cop, no more chastising or warning. Just 🤷 shrug emoji, looks like I cancelled ChatGPT


r/ELATeachers • • Feb 24 '24

Parent/Student Question Feeling creeped out?

654 Upvotes

(Repost bc r/Teachers removed my post)

Hey guys, I'm a 22F first year teacher at a small, rural school that serves a low-income community. I teach 7th Grade ELA and so far things have been great! I'm excited for my new career and I love my job! However, there's been something putting a damper on it.

We had a new student join our class in November. He's tiny and when I first saw him, I couldn't believe he was a 7th grader. The issue with him started before Christmas Break. I have him first period and he would not leave my classroom when it was time for him to leave. I would have to make him leave. I would remind him it's second period, he'll be counted tardy, and his mom won't be happy if he's got a tardy. At first, I thought there was something going on at home. He might have not been receiving enough love and attention at home, so I pulled him aside during my planning period and talked with him. He said everything was fine at home and he just liked my class and I was his favorite teacher. I was flattered but reminded him that I have other classes and so does he. I don't want him to fall behind in them, so he shouldn't be late to them. I thought we had an understanding but this behavior continued. It got to the point that other students noticed it and began taking him to class so he wouldn't constantly be trying to go into my class. I have spoken to his mother and the Vice Principal about this behavior. They have both spoken to him and he has stopped some of the behavior but not all of it.

It is now second semester. He doesn't try to stay in my room, but he does try to come in when it's not his class time. I have to stand outside my room during the passing periods, so he'll come up to me and talk, asking questions like "Can I come in?" "Can I have something out of the vending machine in the teacher's lounge?" etc. When I try tell him to go to class, he'll stand there and complain or if I walk towards, he'll fall on the ground and roll around. The only way I can make him leave is to walk him to class or if another student takes him to class with them. Other teachers have also noticed this and they think it's concerning. To be perfectly honest, it's annoying. I hate to sound like this, but it's draining and obnoxious. During my class period, if I have them doing individual work, he will not sit in his assigned seat. He'll try to sit in front of my desk or he'll be hovering around my desk.

Yesterday, it got downright scary. I was going to the bathroom in the teacher's lounge after the lunch bell rang. He followed me to the lounge and stood in front of the door, asking me if he could come in and if he could have something out of the vending machine. I told him no, students aren't allowed in the lounge and they can't have food from the vending machine. He then proceeded to hang off the door frame of the lounge and ask if he could come in. At this point, I'd been holding my pee since about 3rd period so I had to go. I said no and pointed him towards the cafeteria, but he then his fell down on his back and started rolling on the ground. One of my students saw him doing this, came over, and began leading him away.

Every other teacher I've talked to has said I need to report this again. I don't know why he's clinging to me like this. It's creeping me out, others are beginning to notice, and I don't feel safe monitoring the halls during my passing periods anymore. I plan to go to the Vice Principal on Monday but I don't even know if anything will be done. I'm creeped out, I don't feel safe, and I don't feel like anyone is taking this seriously because of the kid's size and his age. I love this job and I love what I do, but I don't like feeling this way.

Any advice or support is welcome.

Update (2/27/24):

Hello all,

Thank you all for your advice and comments. I appreciate them all (even the negative ones).

So I have a small update for those of you who care.

I spoke to the vice principal on Monday, and he spoke to the child. Overall, I can't say it really did much, but I've taken some of the advice I was given. When he approaches me after his class, I stonewall him. I look straight ahead, point in the direction of his class, and tell him to go to class. Usually, he'll look up at me, waiting for a reaction, but when I don't give him one, he heads right to class. During class, when he gets up and tries to hang around my desk during independent work time, unless he is asking a question about the assignment, I point him back to his desk and tell him to get to work. If he's asking a question about the assignment, I answer it and then send him back to his seat. I've noticed improvement with him so far.

I've also heard him say (in passing to friends) that he's purposely doing this because I haven't written him up yet, and he thinks I won't write him up. Well, I was trying to be nice to kiddo and not immediately send him to the office for his shenanigans, but if that's all this is and writing him up gets him to stop, then that's what I'm going to do.

I have not involved the counselor yet, and I'm not sure if I need to. If he is doing this to be funny or to push my buttons, then it's not exactly a behavioral concern. It's a me problem, ya know? However, if I notice anything else or this escalates, they'll be the first person I go to.

As for the rolling around the ground, I watched him yesterday, and I apologize, but I made a misjudgment. He sometimes gets tripped up and falls down, so it's not rolling around, but instead trying to get up after taking a spill.

To address a FAQ,

I am not aware of any disability this student has. I have not received a 504 or IEP on him yet, and he's been with us since November. That's not to say he doesn't have some kind of disability, but I don't know about it, and I'm not in the profession or place to diagnose it. As a student, he's a hard worker. Like many of my students, he forgets his pencil of a morning and has to go get one, but other than that, he'll do the class work, and he typically does really good on it.

Thank you all again, and I'll try to keep you all as updated as I can. Let's hope that things continue to get better!


r/ELATeachers • • Oct 15 '26

Humor Where'd my prep go?

Post image
642 Upvotes

r/ELATeachers • • Feb 17 '25

Career & Interview Related Was notified of non-reelection and am almost certainly leaving teaching.

610 Upvotes

Throwaway account because my regular account has identifying info in it and I'll still need to get a new job.

tl;dr - losing my job because I'm a left-leaning teacher in a district that's been taken over by Moms for Liberty.

I've been teaching high school for over a decade now. Been a grade-level lead, department chair, WASC lead, and a ton of other stuff. I'm in my second year at my current site.

Recently, I had my post-observation evaluation. About 95% positive, and 5% bullshit, borderline imaginary negatives that made me instantly realize, "oh, I'm about to be laid off." (My friends at the school, who have all been there much longer than I have, read my evaluation notes and agreed with this assessment.)

Sure enough, as soon as the evaluation is over, incomes the head of HR and I get handed a notice of non-re-election, and told I have until the end of the week to submit my resignation in lieu of. I spoke to my union site rep and our union president, and they confirmed that there will be nothing I can do because I'm not tenured, so they do not have to give cause to let me go...one "negative" evaluation (the only one I've ever received in my entire teaching career) will be enough to get the job done.

The thing is, I know exactly why I'm being let go. Last election, our school board was basically taken over by Moms for Liberty. Suffice it to say that I don't agree with their politics. Over the last few months, I said one too many things to piss off the wrong people and now I'm on the chopping block for it. And my principal absolutely refuses to stick her neck out in any way that might risk her own career. (My wife, as soon as I told her the news, angrily called her a "coward".)

Not only that, but every district in my area is basically the same. Finding another teaching job somewhere else isn't really an option because I'd be dealing with the exact same thing wherever I went, and relocating is not an option with my wife's job and my two kids in school.

So... seems like I'm leaving the teaching profession, maybe forever. Not necessarily by choice, but I suppose it's better than being stuck in a school where all the people above me are actively hostile towards what I believe the goal of education should be. At least that's what I'm telling myself while I start the search for a new job. At least I've got a few months to figure things out still.

Anyways, 🖕 to all the MAGA, Moms for Liberty fascist snowflakes trying to destroy the entire educational system, and for pushing me out of the only fulfilling job I've ever had.


r/ELATeachers • • Oct 14 '23

9-12 ELA What's a book, or anything else, you've become totally bored with and are sick of teaching?

606 Upvotes

For me it's The Crucible. I've been teaching it for two decades, and it puts me to sleep. It doesn't help that I live and teach very near Salem, and both the students and I are already saturated with witch trial lore. It's didactic, weirdly structured in places, and the made up version of 1690's language annoys me. My American Lit curriculum says I'm supposed to teach it early in the year, which also bugs me since Arthur Miller and Ann Bradstreet weren't exactly contemporaries. The kids don't like it, and they get confused with all the P names (he can age all the girls and make up an affair between Abigail and Proctor, but changing "Putnam" to, like, "Jones" would've been too far?). There are so many other plays we could be doing, I'm so sick of this one.

Oddly, I actually do dig the movie, which shouldn't make sense given how much I dislike reading the play. I guess I like it since I don't have to teach it.


r/ELATeachers • • Dec 02 '20

I made a meme for my students

Thumbnail
imgur.com
561 Upvotes

r/ELATeachers • • Nov 06 '25

6-8 ELA Student emailed me the "writing they've been working on for a while now." It looked suspicious...

529 Upvotes

Out of the blue, a student emailed me a link to a google doc with "some writing I've been working on for a while now." Not related to an assignment or anything, just a personal project. I wasn't too surprised--I'm the English teacher, and a lot of students have pieces to share.

Opening it up, though, I immediately noticed the bolded story headings, the letter-perfect spelling and grammar, the derivative and bland plot. Just to be sure, I ran it through an AI-checker, and it states that it's like 93% AI.

Ordinarily with stuff like this, I'd just praise the student's effort and give some constructive feedback. But I literally have no idea what to do with this. "Good job entering demands into a prompt--next time, try actually writing out your ideas?" I don't even know why you'd bother showing this to a teacher. There's no "improvement" to be suggested here

EDIT: People keep bringing it up, so: yes, I know AI checkers are unreliable. I know this student and am familiar with their writing style, so I knew the writing didn't fit. Checking the version history showed that they copy-pasted the vast bulk of the story within a few minutes of sending it to me. I have now responded, saying the idea is nice and the grammar is excellent, but the style seems a little flat and perhaps they should focus on what they personally are trying to say.


r/ELATeachers • • Nov 18 '23

Parent/Student Question Student berating me

513 Upvotes

I have a student in my class who is very difficult and insists on challenging everything I do (understatement). The class is an elective and we do pretty fun, flexible assignments to accommodate all levels that are placed in the class (including many ELL and students with IEPs). The student today told me they refused to do the assignment (not the first time), that they were smarter than me, and that I “waste their time” when I assign things and how stupid my class is. They tried to say that research shows no level of reading and writing correlates to being able to write and I explained why that wasn’t true. Next, I calmly explained my rationale for my teaching method for the course and reiterated my expectation that a refusal to do the assignment is a 0. The student rolled their eyes and said “I understand but nothing changed and I still don’t want to do it, sooo….” I have had a parent teacher conference in which it became clear the parent very much teaches and enables this behavior. What should I do? Writing it up will only result in a phone call home.


r/ELATeachers • • Feb 04 '24

9-12 ELA Boys complain about "girl" books.

509 Upvotes

I have been teaching for three years now and something I have noticed is that if we read a class book that has a girl narrator or main character I will always have at least one boy in the class, if not more, complain that the book is boring or stupid. On the other hand when we read books with boy narrators and main characters I have never once had a female student complain. As a female teacher I get frustrated with this, it seems to me that the female students may feel as though their lives, feelings, thoughts, etc. are viewed as boring and stupid.

Has anyone else ever noticed this in their classrooms?


r/ELATeachers • • May 07 '26 Bravo

9-12 ELA English Department Superlatives

Thumbnail
gallery
508 Upvotes

To celebrate our seniors’ finals week, I put this together for students to reflect on all of the books, movies, and stories that they have read in all the different levels of English. It was so much fun to rehash characters and books during passing periods!


r/ELATeachers • • 26d ago

Humor The Teacher Inbox: Where email etiquette goes to die

495 Upvotes

I teach high school students. Their first assignment of the year is to write me an email that shows that they are capable of using proper email etiquette. I show them bad examples of emails from previous students in past years (of course, with all identifying information blocked out). We laugh at those past students. We make fun of them. We talk about how absolutely absurd it is to send an email like that to your ENGLISH teacher. And yet, I still receive emails at 5 PM asking for assignments to be graded with absolutely zero punctuation. Zero greeting. A subject line full of chaos. An alternate timeline where spelling is optional.

I’ve decided it’s my new policy that I’m going to print out those emails and make them correct them. I receive a proper email, you receive your grade. Seems like a fair trade to me.

That is all. That is the post. Tagged as humor because I don’t know whether to laugh or cry.🥲


r/ELATeachers • • May 12 '25

9-12 ELA The current state of affairs in public education

480 Upvotes