As I continue to study this case - its origins and the unfolding of current legal proceedings - I more and more often find myself overwhelmed with the total, universal fucking tragedy of it all.
And I don't mean that exclusively in terms of the victims - the lives lost, tormented or destroyed. But on JJD's side of the spectrum as well.
I will preface this by saying I absolutely hold JJD 100% responsible for everything he has done - I consider his actions to be despicable and were I in the same room as him would probably find myself grappling with some pretty overwhelming urges to physically assault him.
That said - I don't believe in "evil". At least not "evil people". I believe in evil actions - and that evil things can take place. But I don't think anyone, save those among us who subscribe to religious mania, really see people as inherently evil. I believe all of us, even those responsible for the most heinous actions, are products of a combination of their life experience and their genetic / nuerological predisposition to certain behavior patterns. Certain experiences and genetic coding can produce absolutely monstrous behavior - but the hand enacting this behavior doesn't belong to an inherently monstrous being. The infant, toddler and young child that was at one point JJD was innocent - prior to experiencing whatever horrific string of traumas which, coupled with his particular genetic coding, lead to his behavior. In a way, when I see him standing in that cage, while rage courses through me and I consider the breathtaking narcissism and cruelty he's capable of - I also see a victim in his own right, someone who certainly wouldn't have asked for his particular cocktail of mental illnesses and pathologies. I see trauma - and of course the ripple effect it has had across all the other lives he's encountered.
Of course people will say "well other people have been subjected to trauma, abuse, witnessed siblings raped and far worse and didn't turn into psychotically obsessive serial rapists and murderers" -- and yes, fair enough. But that's where the second part of the combination comes in. Some people are born, through the entirely indiscriminate roulette wheel that is genetics, with a set of biological predispositions that make them far more resilient to these kinds of traumas, and that in tandem with how those are processed and the complex combination of environmental factors produces radically different results.
I think it's easy and in a way comforting to assign the black and white labels to this. Good. Evil. Righteous. Cruel. It's safe - it's predictable. But in my opinion the grey area we actually reside in is far less easy to wrap one's head around.
I feel like these cases present a fascinating and important opportunity to really consider the genesis of this kind of behavior - the ways in which it could possibly be prevented or more actively addressed at an earlier stage if people disabused themselves of notions of "good and evil" - and instead considered this in a more even-handed way, one which takes into account the causal factors. I think the more we do that - the more we avoid the fermentation of these kinds of offenders.
Curious what others think or feel when considering the case at this level. As I said, I expect some will find their feathers quite ruffled by this - and I hope I've made my feelings about JJD clear. I hold him absolutely responsible - I simply have more complicated thoughts about the issue generally.