r/Dogfree • • Aug 14 '23

Legislation and Enforcement Creating an American Dog-Free (or People First) Political Movement

14 Upvotes

My (32M) adult career has mostly consisted of all around political work. I've been a legislative chief of staff, a Political Action Committee treasurer, a candidate myself, chair for grassroots political organizations, you name it, which is all to say I am very politically educated and adept. I am highly connected here in my state of Missouri.

I find it stunning that there is virtually no organized movement against the terrorism dog nutters are wreaking upon this country. I am hoping this thread can be the start of it and I would be happy to serve as figure head. I understand that against the mob mentality of dog nutters, this is a scary prospect with seemingly impossible odds, but that is how many good causes start which eventually become a success.

As I see it, there are several over-arching issues that most on this thread can agree to.

  1. People are more important than dogs. Full stop. Always.

This is our underlying pitch, for which we can make philosophical arguments to try to reach the public with. Dog nutters think that it is reasonable that because a) dogs are naturally inclined to bark and b) their dog is barking that c) barking is acceptable at anybody elses expense.

It is a disgusting moral failing that is apparently widely accepted to believe that anything a dog does short of outright violence is it acting in its normal state and is therefore acceptable. If a dog in any way causes any inconvience to anyone who is not its owner, it is not justified at all. The dog can be brought in where barking is not heard, it can be trained, it can be rehomed, but no human should be losing their head trying to figure out how to get peace from their neighbors badly managed pretend passion project. This is widely accepted for any other sort of noise complaint, extending it to dogs is just logical.

2) Dog nutters are entitled. The public needs to be made aware of basic decency.

There should be a legal/advocacy side to such an organization, but education should also be a primary object. The organization should make a primary educational point that: A) Dogs are an extension of their owners B) If an owner doing the same thing as their dog would not be acceptable, than neither is the dog doing it C) Noise pollution, general disturbance, and destruction wrought by dogs are no different than if their owner did it themselves. D) You do not have the right to disturb your neighbors property for something that is not a necessity and could be remediated under the right circumstances. These are indisputable factual points that put the onus on dog owners who just say their barking dogs are just being dogs. Yeah well if a guy stands out in his yard howling all night, the police will show up. People should expect the same from their dogs and the police should treat it likewise.

3) Calls to animal control for disturbance should always be allowed to remain anonymous

In many munis, you have to be identified as the reason a citation is being written for offenders. This is stupidly ridiculous and goes against all other expectations for reporting crimes. If your neighbors are beating each other up, you dont have to insert yourself as the reason for the police to show up. A crime is being committed, enforce punishment as a crime against the state. Those reporting excessive noise complaints deserve the right to anonymity to prevent deterioration of relations with neighbors. This is actually a safety issue. This group would travel around as needed to offer education and policy proposals to areas determined to be doing a bad job at policing nuisance animal behaviors. Could also make proposals to state legislators to see statewide legislation passed to create uniform laws on the subject to prevent confusion.

4) "Emotional Support Animals" and Service Dogs

We need to remove all the laws protecting emotional support animals and some for service dogs. Emotional support animals are bullshit, I've met so many people that just ask for a note from the doctor because they want to be able to live anywhere and the doctor writes it right up. This is trampling on the rights of property owners and is the primary explanation for why there are few to no dog-free neighborhoods in the country. It also explains why people bring their shitbeasts to the grocery store or furniture shopping. Everyone thinks they have a legal right to take their dog every place and sadly they might be right. This group could work to lobby at the federal level for the removal of these protections. States could also attempt to nullify this aspect of federal law. We have fair grounds for advocating this point as it is not so much an antidog point as a pro-property rights point. People are allergic to dogs. Some places need higher levels of sanitation. The dogs everywhere culture we now have is making America allergenic and unhygenic.

5) Countering dog-nutter narratives with evidence

Some dog breeds are more violent than others. Being snarled and snipped at is not the sign of a happy dog that just wants to play. Dogs stuck outside barking all day are being neglected. The sun is bright and the sky is blue. Again on the education side, it'd help if a professional organization existed to counter the stupid narratives of dog nutters, whether they are pibble lovers or heel-knipping chihuahuas. The public needs to see unbiased evidence about dangerous, loud, and destructive breeds. This is partly a harm mitigation strategy. We might not be able to get Americans to chill out with the dog fetishism, but maybe we can turn people away from pitbulls and other violent breeds with real evidence.

The organization would be a membership type thing like NARAL or NRA or whatever advocacy group you think of. The membership payments would fund the advocacy. Periodic fundraisers and maybe a development team can continue to fill the funding gaps. Members pay, get some token benefits, and also get the solitude of knowing they are helping fund a good cause. Perhaps include some resources and prewritten letters for confronting these issues with neighbors or appealing to muni governments.

Can anybody think of some core tenants or points to be made were such an organization to be formed. If you are interested, please message me or comment. You never know what a small motivated group can do to make change. Also, I full expect a lot of well-intentioned cynicism about any possibility of this taking off (its an uphill battle of momentous proportions), but if possible, please include some supportive commentary or ideas for helping this take off too.


r/Dogfree • • Apr 26 '24

Legislation and Enforcement Do Service Dogs perform ANY vital function for disabled people that cannot be done with technology?

18 Upvotes

Ok, so the ADA was passed in 1990, almost 34 years ago and yeah yeah, that was a different time,

but in this age of wonders we are living in today, do service dogs perform any function that technology can't do and can't possibly do more competently?

I'm looking for a devil's advocate here but someone on here recently made an excellent point, "if any other medical equipment had the same failure rate as 'service dogs' then that medical equipment would most likely be banned".

Does there exist medical equipment today good enough that service dogs should be considered obsolete and no longer deserving of ADA protection?

Edit: is this subreddit getting brigaded?


r/Dogfree • • Aug 29 '24

Miscellaneous Discussion: How do we feel about people who have dog/canine fursonas?

0 Upvotes

I believe this is a topic that invites a lot of discussion. Considering fursonas (or OC's in general) are an extension of one's self more often than not, would it be a testament to one's character if they chose to make their fursona a dog, or any other canine? Should we be looking down upon them, the same way we do actual dogs and their owners, or does it not matter?


r/Dogfree • • Apr 11 '25

Miscellaneous To my dismay, I found that Tullamore whiskey added a mutt to their bottle design

52 Upvotes

So I came home with a bottle of good old Tully, and I noticed they redesigned the bottle label. The old one was really classy, but the new one seems more cheapish. And, narrowing my eyes, I noticed that they put a big old nasty mutt on it.

I went to their website and sent them a message:

Dear Tullamore,

I like your whiskey, but I must say that I don't fancy the recent redesign of the bottle.

Especially, I really don't like that you added a dog to the design. I suppose it's an Irish wolfdog, but of all the symbols of beautiful Érie, why add something as nasty and disgusting as a dog?

Why not a clover, a harp, or a Celtic knot? An oak leaf? A northern lapwing bird? I really don't want to think about a smelly mutt while enjoying my drink.

Now before you laugh, I of course don't have any illusions that they will take my complaint seriously or that it will change anything at all. It just felt nice giving a bit of pushback against the endless mutt-creep into every area of life, from schools to bars.

If more people did this, eventually companies would realise that not everyone likes dogs, and that adding dogs to their product designs is not something that everybody appreciates.

As for me, this bottle will probably be the last Tullamore I buy until they change the bottle back again.


r/Dogfree • • Mar 11 '24

Dog Culture ‘Anatomy of a Fall’ dog star Messi gets a seat at the 2024 Oscars

Thumbnail
nypost.com
64 Upvotes

All these smug self-important people have to slobber all over a dog at an awards ceremony that’s not a dog show but may as well be one now.

We are losing the battle. Dogs are taking over every facet of society. Soon they will have an Oscar for “best dog” in cinema. You laugh now but it’s coming. So sad.


r/Dogfree • • Jun 10 '18

You slobber on everything and steal the food too?

Thumbnail
facebook.com
0 Upvotes

r/Dogfree • • Nov 27 '20

Miscellaneous Having Pets Instead Of Kids Should Be Considered A Psychiatric Disorder

Thumbnail
thefederalist.com
14 Upvotes

r/Dogfree • • Nov 20 '19

Rant I hate people's dogs and so does my dog.

5 Upvotes

My wife wanted a puppy 10 years ago, I said no so we got a dog. She fell out of love as he grew and he quickly became my dog. My father had hunting dogs and always said if the owners not happy the dogs not either. I trained him (border collie) and fuck he is smart, I even trained him to get diapers and wipes for us when my son was a baby. He loves people and hates other dog, he is very territorial of us and our kids. I am very strict with him. He is not allowed in the kitchen, furniture, no people food, begging, jumping. All of our friends and family have shit dogs. They are fat, smell, untrained, crippled, MFing "furbabies"! I don't say shit about their dogs but I get hell because I am mean to my dog because he is trained. They are constantly trying to get him to do thing I have to correct him for. I don't care if your "babies" sleep in your bed but I will be damn if I want to sleep in a hairy ass dog smelling bed or eat a fucking hairball. He is part of the family now and we love him but I don't know your dog, I don't trust it, and I don't want to. I hate your fucking dog and so does my dog. You can shove your doggie dates up your ass!


r/Dogfree • • Apr 05 '19

Are “dognutters” more common in certain geosocial conditions?

0 Upvotes

I feel I should disclose first that I do not agree with much of the sentiment for dogs in r/dogfree, but I find the discussions very interesting! Even though I am a dog owner, I like to think I am not what is considered a “dognutter”, but just someone who has always loved dogs, even my job involving taking care and playing with dogs. Even before I found this subreddit, I always thought it was common sense to not bring your dog in situations where it would bother other people. If I ever hear someone is allergic to dogs, I and most people I know would take measures to accommodate that.

So back to the original question. As a dog owner, I have been exposed and have interacted with many dog owners in my life. While I know a couple actual dognutters, most of the people I know are conscious dog owners and are not like what people here describe them as. I see a lot of generalized dislike towards dog owners, but I have rarely ever seen extreme dognutters in my life. It’s just hard for me to relate to a lot of what I see here.

So do you think certain geosocial conditions make dognutters what they are? Let’s also consider that dog owner population is not a factor. Is this more common on Universities, cities, suburbs, rural areas, apartments, perhaps even certain states or regions? I’d be interested in hearing your opinion on whether geosocial conditions are a factor for cultivating dognutters and if you think it is, where do you think these kinds of people are more common?

Edit: Geosocial is not the right term for this, I kind of hodgepodged it together. I’ll find a better term!


r/Dogfree • • Nov 14 '19

Dog Culture I don’t care about Narwhal.

48 Upvotes

Seriously.. i mean i know it’s kinda cool that he has a tail growing out of his head, BUT... i don’t need to hear about it literally every time i go on instagram. or twitter. or facebook. we get it. now cut the crap.


r/Dogfree • • Apr 05 '21

Weekly Announcement Post

7 Upvotes

Hey Dogfree!

We just wanted to take this time to remind you of a few things if you haven't seen them already.

Related subs:

r/DogfreeHumor - For memes, comics, and other fun.

r/DogfreeAww - For aww minus the dogs.

r/DogfreeDating - Find a dogfree love.

r/DogcultureFree - For those who don't hate dogs but do hate dog culture.

r/BanPitBulls - For anything anti-pitbull. Please note that BanPitBulls is NOT anti-dog.

r/Petfree - For anyone who is annoyed with pets.

r/TalesfromtheDogHouse - For those wishing to vent about a specific dog and its behavior.

Previous Mod Statements:

The Definition of Dogfree - Dogfree is for those of us who do not like dogs.

Cats are Off Topic - This is not a cat subreddit. Cats are off topic.

Other Pets and Children are Off Topic - Other pets, children, and childbearing preferences are off topic.

Keeping Conversations Civil - Please be civil toward others. If someone is not being civil, please report them.

Letting Dogs Loose is Against the Rules -Don't suggest letting a dog escape.

Mindfulness Outside the Sub - Please be respectful of other subreddits and Reddit users.

Low Effort Content - What it is and how to post about things that fall in this category.

FAQ - Please check if your question can be answered here before posting.

Contact the Moderators of Dogfree - Please do not contact individual moderators directly about subreddit business including this account, DogfreeMods.

  • r/dogfree is its own forum that is not affiliated with any other website or platform, such as YouTube channels, social media pages, merchandise outlets, Discord servers, or other subreddits


r/Dogfree • • Feb 23 '21

Dog Culture I literally have no where else to put this

37 Upvotes

So my best friend calls me last night. We have known each other about 35 years. He always had cats most of the time I have known him. After the last cats passed away he said he was not getting any more animals it was to heartbreaking when you have to put them to sleep.

Anyhow he has met someone new and they moved in together. So last night we are talking and he says guess what I have sitting on my lap? I said what, thinking possibly he had gotten another cat. A YORKIE. I can not tell you how much I hate fucking terriers, any kind of terriers. I do not like dogs at all, but pure hatred runs deep for any kind of terrier. He knows I hate dogs. He knows why I hate dogs. I live in a neighborhood full of rednecks that do nothing but accumulate dogs, are nutters and will kill any cat they see in the neighborhood. I have almost gotten into fist fights with neighbors over their fucking dogs, have had to take one neighbor to court for excessive dog barking.

So he says to me it will only get up to 6lbs. I said you know terriers do nothing but bark. I told him you know I hate dogs, they stink, they bark and they shit all over the yard. He said he does not bark. I said how old is it? 4 months old. I said just you wait and call me back in year when the fucking thing is full grown and does nothing but bark. I know because I have seen this first hand with terriers. Had two Shit Zu`s next door and used to watch out the window as they sat in the middle of the yard and literally barked at nothing. Before that two Jack Russell terriers who barked at every thing, a blade of grass blowing, the wind. My cousin had a Yorkie, rotten ass fucking dog. Then he says, must be the nutter he moved in with wants to get a bag so she can carry the fucking thing around in to the stores. I said so she thinks she is Paris Hilton carrying the damn dog around in the stores, this I hate too. Unless it is a seeing eye dogs, they do not belong inside stores. Woke up this morning and thought about it again and then wondered how much they paid for this barking, smelly shitbag. Yorkie's are purebred. So then that pissed me off again. How many animals are PTS in shelters daily because no one will take them.


r/Dogfree • • Aug 30 '20

Dog nutters are such hypocrites

5 Upvotes

I think it's so eye rolly and cringe when dog nutters practically cry talking about how much they love dogs, while in the same sentence scarf down any other species that moves. If you are not vegan you don't "love" animals, period. You love what they can "do" for you, the pleasure receptors they fire off in your wittle animal brain.


r/Dogfree • • Mar 08 '18

This is usually the case

Thumbnail
imgur.com
41 Upvotes

r/Dogfree • • Jul 09 '19

Miscellaneous fascinated and educated

6 Upvotes

EDIT: clearly, I was mistaken. I came here thinking there would be chance to grow and expand my knowledge, to learn and understand better. Thank you to those who were kind during this discussion, but I see that my initial impression is false about this subreddit. I feel like there's much that could've been accomplished had there been a more open and friendly spirit found here. I wont taint your sub anymore

ORIGINAL POST: so Im a huge dog lover, well animal lover. I love anything furry or feathered, and am slowly getting over my fear of reptiles and fish. But that's not the point of this post; the point is this subreddit is fascinating to me!

I have a dog, 12lbs pomapoo, who wasnt properly trained, socialized, etc... Im responsible in that I dont let him be around small children and when we have company over we have a little ritual we go through to acclimate him to the visitors so we can all live in harmony. If he doesnt acclimate, he stays outside or in my bedroom. When he shits on a neighbor or public yard during a walk, I always pick it up. Basically, Id like to think Im one of the okay owners.

But this sub is helping me see areas I can improve in my pet ownership and I agree with some opinions here too. I dont fully understand the strong hate (edited because I realized vitriol could've been taken as an insult or judgement and I didnt mean it that way), but I do understand the frustration and annoyance...if that makes sense lol

Anyway, just wanted to say that this is a very interesting subreddit and Im happy to be learning how I can be a better socially acceptable pet owner!


r/Dogfree • • Dec 29 '25

Dog Culture What do you think of Bluey?

33 Upvotes

Frankly I'm sick of hearing about it, which sucks because Australia is trying to turn it into a cultural icon. I don't care how "well-written" or "deep" it is, it is clearly propaganda designed to condition the next generation of dogphiliacs.


r/Dogfree • • Dec 03 '22

Self-Defense Discussion

0 Upvotes

After careful consideration, we have added a new rule to the subreddit which is "No self defense discussion."

This subject touches on areas that weren't quite covered by the no animal abuse or violence rule and our rules regarding off-topic discussion. Therefore, a new stand alone rule has been created to prevent any confusion when posting.

Soliciting or offering self-defense advice is outside the scope of our sub, as what’s legal in any given jurisdiction varies widely amongst our users. For advice as to how to defend yourself against an attacking dog, it’s best to search your own local ordinances or reach out to your local authorities.

Our priority is the safety and continuation of this subreddit and its members, and all actions that we take and rules that we impose are to that end.

Please take a moment to review all rules in the sidebar to ensure successful posting. We appreciate your understanding.


r/Dogfree • • Jun 15 '14

I went to a girls house and won't be returning.

1 Upvotes

She had two dogs that would not stop barking, drooling all over me, wouldn't stop jumping on me. I'm only 5'9" 180 and her dogs were huge pushing me around. So annoying it was like a work out just to hang out. And the worst part she was like awww aren't they just the cutest? I'm like what? Are you really that oblivious to what is happening right now? I wore I nice navy blue shirt and came home with golden hair all over it. Sadly she was a brunette so couldn't blame it on her jumping on me. Yeah I didn't even bother washing it. I'm not having that filth contaminate all my other clothes.

So yeah I just told her its not going to work out.

/rant


r/Dogfree • • Jun 16 '21

Dog Culture I am at my wits' end

9 Upvotes

I am sorry for the rant in advance but I have fucking had it with these ugly nasty creatures. Despite living dog-free in my apartment, I can't avoid having run ins with dogs and their piece of shit owners on almost daily basis which is exactly why they are the worst fucking pets possible. The building I live in has a side door that most tenants use, guess what? That is also the most popular dog pissing location in the area. Even assholes who live in the building, let their dogs piss right infront of that door. So I wake up in the morning and I start my day by smelling dog piss while heading to work. The entire street is full of fluid stains that all look suspicious for dog piss. And I am saying nothing about the occasional dog shit that I have to look for so I don't step on.

Then there are the off-leash dogs that all happen to be pitbulls co-incidentally. Actually, one hour ago, I was going out to pick up food and I open the side door and there was an off-leash pitbull and his dognutter standing behind him. I get startled of course and ask that shit head "can you please put your dog on a leash", to which he responds very aggressively. Fearing for my safety, I did and said nothing else. That is just 1 of 3 run ins with off-leash pitbulls in 1 week.

Then the long leash distracted nutters and their ugly mutts. A month ago, I was just walking on the street, all of a sudden a dog jumps on me out of no where. The owner was looking at his phone while he was walking and only notices when I say "WTF", to which he responds "sorry dude".

Then the small shit dogs. Just a few days ago, standing in front of my building waiting for a friend. Some drunk dognutter and his little rat were passing by. The ugly rat approaches me and gets too close for comfort and tries to jump but I keep avoiding it and telling his owner to fuck off, to which he just giggles. That made my blood boil.

Like what the fuck! Why do I have to deal with this? Why does this have to be a part of my life despite rejecting it? I never have to deal with the choices that any other pet owner makes except for fucking dog owners. I just wish that I could at least tell all dog owners fuck you and fuck your fucking dogs in particular.


r/Dogfree • • Sep 13 '18

WTF Dog Line Dancing

Thumbnail
i.imgur.com
2 Upvotes

r/Dogfree • • Jun 29 '14

My people!

1 Upvotes

Seeing the /r/childfree post bestof'ed made me think, why isn't there a /r/Dogfree Glad there's like minded people out there.

I do have to admit, I've thought now and then about one day getting a dog for my children, but usually i'll have a bad experience with a dog to remind why I don't want to make my neighborhood suffer anymore.


r/Dogfree • • Dec 15 '19

Pitbull hate is not helpful to our cause

5 Upvotes

So I am not breedist. I hate all dogs equally. I fully agree that some breeds are more dangerous by nature of their physical design, and pit bulls and other fighting dogs fall into this category. HOWEVER....

I think demonising some breeds and not others has the following unintended consequences:

  1. It makes the discussion all about public safety. Dogs are a nuisance for many other reasons. There remains an expectation to love a gud doggo as long as you know you’re not going to die because of one.

  2. Owners can excuse their dog from scrutiny and heightened safety measures on the basis of what they believe their dog’s temperament to be. Even if dogs were actually loyal, they would only be loyal to their food source. That’s not temperament, that’s manipulation.

  3. Owners of “non-violent” breeds get a free pass and expect their dogs to be universally liked because they’re not as adept at killing people.

  4. The arguments about “no bad dogs, only owners” tend to surface. Well in the same way that MRA will set a pretty low standard of behaviour for themselves, a dog loyalist will accept a shitty standard of behaviour from their dogs because their identity depends on their perceived relationship to their dog. Basically, when your standard of what a good owner looks like is fluid, there is no standard, per se. A true standard would be independently set, measured and enforced outside of dog culture.

What do you think? Is the pit-hate helping or hurting us?


r/Dogfree • • Apr 07 '21

Dog Culture Doggiewood Movies

11 Upvotes

Probably because I googled Dogfree a bunch of times when it was set to private Amazon showed me an advertisement for The Pack like ten times. It is a show of the reality type where owners compete for who has the best bond with their dog. It is an Amazon original. The icing on the cake is it endorsed by a celebrity and of course her dog, Lindsey Vonn.

Why this matter? Because they pooled a lot of our money from Amazon subscription. I like watching shows and get sad when a good one ends due to lack of funding. Good productions require a good investment and all kinds of genres fight for one potential spot. Of all the options Amazon chose to have the pack happen. I know the nutters will watch but it hurts us because we pay for it through using Amazon and our subscription fees as well and they win out. Next I see instead of the Bachelorette we will have dog matching shows on TV. There will be nothing good left to watch. Advertisements with dogs in beds and couches were enough I though. Dog centric chanel's may become the new normal. Hope not.