TL;dr
My partner has set up a large play area for our dog where she spends most of her time. She is small and the area is about 20 sq feet. I want a second dog but do not want to keep her in a pen. Which one of us has the right idea? Pen or no pen?
------‐---------------------------
My partner and I have had two dogs in the past both of those dogs became my dog and went everywhere with me. I was their human and they were my dog.
Last year I lost my dog due to illness and it broke my heart. I wanted another dog immediately to fill that void. My dog was what was getting me through the pandemic.
At that time my partner suggested a puppy but he wanted the puppy to look at him like our previous dogs had been with me. I always adopted but finding a dog during the pandemic was impossible so he decided to purchase a puppy. I didn't have the money to purchase a puppy or cover vet bills such as spaying. We agreed that we would get a puppy but she would be his puppy and he would cover all her expenses as I had done in the past with our other dogs.
The dog is now 18 months old and fully grown at a whopping 17 lb. She gets into everything and has a habit of eating anything she finds. As a little 3lb puppy she spent a lot of time sleeping in her crate. As she grew my partner purchased a 4 by 5 play pen that would be exclusively hers and was lined with linoleum for easy cleanup. The pen is in our living room and I am home most of the time.
When I bring her out into the main room she loses her mind and we'll run around continuously until she goes back to her area and falls asleep. I love her to pieces and now that time has passed I would like a dog of my own. My concern is that I've never kept a dog in a pen before but I've also only had older dogs. We have cats and we want to protect them and the dog from unnecessary stress.
My partner says the dog has to be in the play area and I'm not ok with that. It's his choice how to take care of his dog but I don't want that for my dog. I also don't think it's fair to have one dog free and the other in a pen.
So for now I have given up on my own dog. I'm pouring all my love into the dog we have.
Is he hurting the dog by keeping her in her play area? I think he is over protective but she is safe so I can't argue that.
Should we be letting the dog have free reign when we are home?