Be me: DM
Be not me: Group of 4 party
Homebrewing a biweekly game for the past month or so. Players have recently found it more fun to mess with me that actually playing.
Examples: "What's this characters name?", "I rob the town guard!", Hits on LITERALLY anything with a pulse, power&meta gaming, and derailing at every point.
But, they ARE playing and having fun.
I'm not
Players find themselves in an old dungeon for one reason or another
Everyone checks for hidden passages, seduces skeletons, and loot everything they can.
Me: You find a hidden door in the hallway
Player 1(P1): I open it
Me: Inside is a room with no other doors than the one you open. There are no windows but there are a few metal grates-"
P2: I check for traps in the room!
P4: I cast detect magic!
Me: You don't detect any traps within the room and there is no magic to sense.
Me: Inside the room are three wooden chests, each placed on a diode along the cor-
P1: I smash open all the chests!
Me: Roll 3 strength checks
After some complaining and back & forth (16~19~6) you break open 2 of 3
Decent_loot.png
P3: I pick the lock
Me: Roll to pick. Everyone else roll perception
Party: WTF! You said there were no traps! That's BS!
Me: I said "no traps IN the room". Roll perception
Party groans but rolls
Me: You see black ooze begin pouring out the grates and amassing along the floor. Roll for--
P3 & P1: I disengage and roll for stealth to leave the room (19 & 15)
Me: Poker face Roll Dex
(4 & 15)
Me: As P3 lunges for the door, the wooden door slams onto his hand pinning it to the frame. Blood pools out from your arm as jagged teeth sink further & further into your flesh!
Party: WTF! YOU SAID THAT THERE WERE NO TRAPS IN THE ROOM!
me: You checked for taps IN the room. It's not in the room. It is the room. Also Mimics don't trigger the Find Traps ability.
Party: BS! Search rule books
Me: Even if you do find some loophole, you all are still trapped in a room with 3 Black Puddings and a mimic as your only exit. Roll for initiative.
Edit: alright this is blowing up for the wrong reasons. I'll admit I had posted this because I was proud of my trap, but I clearly need to do some damage control.
1: I'm not exactly sorry they got team wiped, but it really wasn't my intention. I had just made the encounter WAY to difficult for them at the time. 2: Though they are problematic players at the table I had known these people for a long time and am close friends with them all even after this. 3: I had run a few other homebrews with these people. Mostly with other players being the DM. This was just the first time I got to DM. I had actually lasted the longest as DM. I'll just say this wasn't the first TPK our table has experienced.
Okay onto background: Player 1: Human Rouge (LE) Player 2: Dwarf Barbarian (LG unless there was an or within 60 miles) Player 3: Half elf Rouge / monk (N) Player 4: Gnome Wizard (CE)
We were about on our 5th game session when the story above occurred. Each session was about 7~8hrs
These people loved to screw up my "campaign" for the lols. It was like playing an online fps and my party only wanting to team kill.
If I gave them a quest or narrative hook they'd typically just kill the quest giver and take their stuff because "we were going to get it anyway".
If we entered a town they immediately split the party to go do whatever they wanted; typical debauchery. Once in the town they began talking over each other in order to have their character be the important one. It's hard enough having to role-play 4 different characters at the same time, it's another to have players get upset they have nothing to do after a personal 30min conversation. When I tried to curb this behavior by having one player get caught by town guards, the other 3 magically appear for the fight despite being on the other side of the town not 5sec prior.
If we got into combat, the real cheating occurred. The players made up items & spells, or would change the rules of said item or spell to fit their need. Low on HP? Chug your 5th Healing potion, despite having nothing listed on your character sheet or never buying any in the last town. Oh you cast disintegrate? As a level one wizard? Over the entire town? And if we ran into a monster, out came the monster manual and out came the magic weapons with specific strengths against the monster. "I've always had it, it was in my backstory!" "You don't have any backstory written down to check, all you said was you certain from -insert city here- and you hate all orcs" "well you just weren't paying attention"
And my written campaign? Yeah that was gone in session 1. I could get toothpaste back into the tube easier than I could get these guys to follow a narrative. They decided if they wanted to explore the dungeons or fight monsters. I had to make NPCs at lv 10 just to deter the players from destroying them if they didn't get the dice rolls they wanted (ie "Bar maid! suck off the whole tavern" "she won't do that and is offended you said that" "I just rolled a 15 on persuasion" "she said no" "well I cast dominate person and force her to do it" "WTF no. You don't even have that spell!" "Fine I kill her! (18 to hit)") And another time I tried to get everyone on track and have the players just so happen to run into the BBEG (session 3). "I apologise for interrupting and shut the door. Then we walk away" "Why? He has good loot and is evil" "No one wants to be railroaded DM. What the point in playing if we can't do what we want."
And yes I had spoken to them out of game and after the pervious example. (chat 1) I had encouraged them to return to the story and asked if they might have another idea for a campaign if they didn't want to run this one. "Nah we like it. Just keep doing what you're doing" (Chat 2) Guys please stop just killing or seducing everything you see. We can't get anywhere if you don't do anything else. Do you want to play an intrigue story where you can seduce and assassinate? "Alright, well stop trying to attack everything and try to play along." "Thank you." "I attack the shop owner and rob him" "WTH!! YOU JUST SAID-" " Well, I said I'd stop, but my character didn't have that conversation." (Chat 3) What exactly do you guys want to do here?! Are we playing DND or what? I'm trying my best but you keep outright saying no to everything I do. If you want to play the game they why do you keep derailing everything I put in front of you!
Honestly I don't if I'm just apologizing to strangers on the internet or to myself. But there you go. I'm sorry for being a shitty DM