r/Divorce • u/Agreeable-Parsnip-81 • Jun 07 '26
Alimony/Child Support Can my ex decrease my support annually?
I will try to make this short and to the point. I make $62k a year. He makes $400k. I got exclusive use and occupancy of the marital residence 5 years ago. He pays the mortgage by taking the mortgage payment out of his child and maintenance payments bc he didn't trust me to pay it. Initially he was supposed to pay me $4k a month. Now he's only paying me $2k a month. Every time the taxes go up on the mortgage, he deducts it from the support payments.
Today he advised me he will be deducting $200 per month from my support due to increasing taxes.
I'm struggling financially and can barely afford groceries. I have cut every corner possible. My kids need clothes and I can't even afford to buy them. We live on Long Island in NY. The cost of living here is insane.
Is there anything I can do? Isn't there supposed to be a cost of living increase? I don't know much about these legal things. Every year the cost of living goes up, and my support goes down. My raise last year was the equivalent to $7 more per paycheck. I was excited for my raise in August, but now this won't even make a dent in my financial situation and it will probably be even worse.
I'm feeling so disheartened. I start college again in the fall on a disability scholarship. But now I'm not even sure I can go bc I may need a second job. But how do I work 2 jobs when my younger daughter needs me. My ex does nothing to help with driving her everywhere and taking her to doctors appointments.
Anyway, guess this wasn't short after all.
Thanks for reading.
3
u/FUMoney Jun 08 '26
Post is ridiculous.
Free housing. Mortgage paid for by ex-spouse. Receives $2k a month in support. And has a job with reasonably decent income. Yet purportedly "barely getting by."
Like, how. How is this even possible?
I start college again in the fall on a disability scholarship.
Scam.
1
u/Agreeable-Parsnip-81 Jun 08 '26
No. It's not. COL on LI is insane. I have 2 teenage girls. You don't have my divorce decree in front of you, so don't presume to know which expenses that $2k goes toward. No one over here is being anything less than frugal. I cut as much as I possibly can. I asked for advice, not criticism. Your comment is not helpful at all. Hope it made you feel better putting me down though.
79
u/Ambitious-Cattle-742 Jun 07 '26
To answer your question, it depends on what your order says. If it says he has to pay X, then that’s what he has to pay. If you have no order, I think he’s being very generous.
You have no housing costs, a salary, and an extra 2k/month? How many kids do you have? 2k isn’t enough to cover utilities and groceries? I understand NY is a high cost of living, but your biggest expense is being paid for. I’m thinking this maybe isn’t a him problem.
12
3
u/Travelsat150 Jun 08 '26
Is your ex paying the property tax and insurance on the house?
2
u/Ambitious-Cattle-742 Jun 09 '26
My ex? Or the OOPs ex? My ex doesn’t pay anything. He’s ordered to pay CS and a % of shared expenses. But he doesn’t. Not a dime.
I am remarried and my husband covers the extra fun stuff that I couldn’t afford to do. If I wasn’t married to him, we just wouldn’t do those things. I can support our necessities on my own though
4
u/CarlSy15 Jun 08 '26
Agree it depends on the divorce decree. Mine says he gets exclusive use of the house until it’s sold; when it is sold, the alimony goes up. I pay the mortgage until it’s sold. I pay him a ton, and I’m more than a little bitter about it, but it’s only for 6 years so I can deal.
0
u/Ambitious-Cattle-742 Jun 08 '26
I loathe spousal support. It’s not really a thing in my state, but I know people who have the misfortune of divorcing in a SM state. It’s ridiculous. At the very least the recipient should pay the taxes on the money
3
u/HighOnLove26 Jun 09 '26
Try saying that when you have been out of the workforce for 20 years to raise 3 kids.
1
u/Ambitious-Cattle-742 Jun 09 '26
I don’t think people should do that. Eliminating spousal maintenance would help motivate people to not leave careers
1
u/HighOnLove26 Jun 09 '26
It's not practical for everyone. If there are grandparents able and willing to look after the child, then it's possible, otherwise it's very hard.
0
u/Ambitious-Cattle-742 Jun 09 '26
First, A person shouldn’t have more kids than they can afford on their own. Second, a plan for separation/divorce should ALWAYS be present. It’s naive to think your marriage will miraculously last forever. Maybe it will, and that’d be great. But let’s be realistic; as a species we don’t know how to fully be in healthy relationships. We aren’t given tools to obtain the level of emotional intelligence to sustain marriage like we dream it’ll be. Most of us will be unhappy and many of our partners won’t have the capacity to help us navigate it.
Quitting a job to take care of kids is a choice. I can understand doing it until the kid goes to school, but after that, there are *generally* very few reasons to stay unemployed. Sure, it’s hard. Yeah, the parent might be underemployed.
Basically we’re all trying to ignore actual circumstances of the world and live this fairytale life. A person may want 2,3,6,10 kids. But they can’t properly take care of them. We aren’t entitled to be parents and if a person can’t do it solo (which is incredibly likely to occur - either by divorce, death, or just procreating with losers), then they shouldn’t do it at all.
1
u/HighOnLove26 Jun 09 '26
Raising kids is not supposed to be a one-person job. Marriage is a partnership. Sometimes people make sacrifices for each other. And if the sacrifice leaves one person out on the street while the other is financially stable, that's unfair. Spousal support seeks to correct that.
1
u/Ambitious-Cattle-742 Jun 09 '26
Oh, I understand the sentiment. I just disagree. I don’t think it should exist as a rule. There are situations where it’s acceptable, like financial abuse/DV. But when one parent chooses to stop working, it’s on them. The marriage ended. Let it end.
This is also why I won’t contribute to my child’s college unless they sign a contract stating they’ll pay me back if they exit the workforce for more than 5 years. And they can’t draw from their trust unless they have at least 9 months of W-2 income in the calendar year. Unpopular opinion, I know. But it embraces my personal values. I’m teaching my kid to live in a world to not need me, but also to not need others too. I want them to be able to stand on their own and never be trapped by anyone else
0
u/HighOnLove26 Jun 09 '26
One parent doesn't choose to stop working on their own, usually. What would you say if stopping working was a joint decision for the benefit of the family? Or what if it was encouraged by the other parent who is working?
→ More replies (0)
28
u/Numerous_Office_4671 Jun 07 '26
From your post, it sounds like you received exclusive use and occupancy of the house, and you are also required to pay the mortgage? He is afraid you won’t pay the mortgage, and he doesn’t want his credit to be ruined, so he’s paying it himself? I personally know a man whose ex-wife did not pay the mortgage (with the alimony he was paying her) as she was supposed to. They lost the house and his credit was destroyed.
We need more information. If he has had a substantial change in financial circumstance since the previous agreement, and you have not, you should be able to increase child support amount. Talk to a lawyer.
24
u/badskiier Jun 07 '26
All of this. He's probably done her a favor by staying on a mortgage that she either wouldn't be able to qualify for or would result in higher interest rates if she had to get a loan. The annual increase in taxes would be something she would have to cover either way, so it is disingenuous to say that he is "deducting" from child support. The net amount stays the same.
3
u/wescowell wescowell, IL Divorce Lawyer Jun 07 '26
Yeah, there’s not nearly enough information given. I wonder what country OP lives in. I wonder which jurisdiction controls her orders.
47
u/liladvicebunny stealth rabbit Jun 07 '26
Has support been ordered, or are you just going off his personal goodwill?
If he's required to pay you a specific amount then he doesn't get to just change it because he feels like it. However, if you've been letting him cut it down to half or less without even protesting, he probably thinks he can change it because clearly you aren't going to enforce your rights. So he'll keep cutting it... to nothing, eventually.
If nothing was ordered, if you never actually legally established support, then he can do as he pleases.
Is there anything I can do?
You have to start by reading your actual divorce decree and finding out what you're supposed to be getting paid, then by going to the proper channels to enforce it.
15
u/Yazim Jun 07 '26
I think this is correct, but he could just be fast-tracking the inevitable. If he's obligated to pay "the mortgage" (inclusive of taxes), then he should provide the evidence that it's changed, but fighting it wouldn't really get her very far.
23
u/Insouciance_2025 Jun 07 '26
You need to read and understand your divorce degree.
3
u/No_Tower_7026 Jun 07 '26
Run your state calculator if applicable as well. Perhaps avoid the legal fees if possible ..
9
u/justbrowzingthru Jun 07 '26
Depends on what the divorce decree says. We have no idea without seeing it.
Consult your attorney.
Real estate taxes and insurance increase every year which increases the mortgage payment,
If he wasn’t paying the mortgage for you, how would you afford those increases?
8
u/badskiier Jun 07 '26
Read your divorce decree. If you're due for cost of living increases it will be in there. However that is uncommon, and certainly not a standard clause.
5
u/Agitated-Conflict704 Jun 07 '26
With no housing costs, I’m not sure how you are struggling. Seeing a budget might help with guidance.
As far as his payments, it depends what your order says. Can you speak with your lawyer?
5
u/InvisibleBlueRobot Jun 08 '26
Does the order day he has to pay for the home plus a certain amount?
Or just a certain amount and you can stay in the home and pay for it yourself?
This is where a legal consult might make sense.
5
u/wenchywitchy Jun 08 '26 edited Jun 08 '26
Your narrative is missing viable parts. It seems like you will be required to pay the mortgage, as you have exclusive use and occupancy of the residence, yet you are complaining about being unable to sustain living above your new norm / means.
You can't have it both ways. You gotta pay to stay and if its unaffordable for you, then downsize within your means.
He is ordered to pay 4k monthly, yet its likely a portion of what you receive is required to pay the mortgage; therefore, he is doing nothing wrong and simply paying the mortgage so you dont wreck his credit with financial mismanagement.
His financial transactions will most certaintly be thorough to verify if audited and again, you are receiving the required alimony per your decree.
Now if your decree is not structured as you are required to pay the mortgage, then by all means, it is in violation of your agreement and you need to return to mediation asap to address it or file sanctions.
19
u/peachie88 Jun 07 '26
Does the divorce agreement say that he is supposed to pay $4k in ADDITION to the mortgage? Or that the mortgage comes out of the $4k? If he has been underpaying you, then you need to get a lawyer and go back to court to get that back pay (with interest). Even if not, I’d go back because I’d personally find it incredibly invasive for him to be paying that bill with the being aware.
It might also be prudent to consider whether his support obligations should be reevaluated. If his salary has gone up in the last 4 years, then he may be obligated to pay more.
4
u/lit_off_jenkem Jun 08 '26
The mortgage needs to paid either ways. Sound like he is making your life easier.
6
3
u/yudkib Jun 07 '26
This varies by state and decree. If his total support obligation includes the mortgage / taxes / insurance, then it’s within his rights to reduce the cash support he gives you by the amount the insurance / taxes went up. If you don’t like taxes going up, then talk to your legislators. I am not positive about New York, but in CT, if his income does not significantly change, then you can’t petition for a COLA increase. If his income is the same and everyone’s expenses have gone up 20%, his standard is 20% worse than during the marriage too. If he gets a 20% COLA increase over 4 years, then you are entitled to your share of the COLA increase.
3
u/Disastrous-Rough3170 Jun 08 '26
If the decree says he must give you 4K per month than that’s the total amount of money he must give you per month. Sounds like you’re still getting 4K, just more of it is going to covering the house payment (property taxes and mortgage).
So no he’s not decreasing your support payments, unless those payments are meant to increase based on his salary according to your decree.
3
4
u/Lightsides Jun 07 '26
Obviously: Lawyer up. Maybe there's someone on this forum who knows the particular laws in the particular place you live, but you won't know for sure what you're entitled to and if you're being shorted or not until you contact a lawyer.
2
2
u/Playful_Journalist72 Jun 07 '26
My ex does something like this to me too and his lawyer just allows it so now I’m filing contempt
3
u/Delicious_Oil9902 Jun 07 '26
NY monied spouse here - completely depends on your agreement. If it says you get to reside in the marital residence minus costs including P&I and taxes then he’s not doing anything wrong. You can take him to court I’m sure but you know how much lawyers costs and you’d be on the hook for your costs from now on. My ex wanted COLA built into our agreement but settled on a recalc every 10 years (originally 3 but agreed on 10 after we agreed to only deduct principle from the buyout cost and to allow her to use my car until the lease was up with insurance and lease deducted from her support payments)
2
1
1
u/Entire-Constant6111 Jun 09 '26
I think the person who initiates divorce should be the one paying child support/spousal support.
I get it might not be for everyone but you married for sickness and health til death due us part.
Maybe it would change the attitude/tune of “he doesn’t help enough… but he’s paying for the house..” which is probably more than the child support payment on 400k income.
1
u/Mysterious_Hour_3056 Jun 08 '26
This is odd. If your divorced and decree states something he can’t just change it when he wants to. If you’re not divorced you need to get a lawyer. You need actual paperwork not handshake and I promise agreements. He’s going to do whatever possible to give you the least possible. Your cs and alimony should be way higher.
0
29
u/Seemedlikefun Jun 07 '26
So you make $30 per hour and receive an additional 2k per month, and can't make ends meet? That's about $7200 per month. 99% of the people on this sub can support their family just fine on $85,000 per year.