r/DirecteurSportif • u/Mocer22 • Jul 29 '26
A lot of feedback on a game with potential
Feedback: Cycling Management Game
First off, I really like what you've built here, and I want to be clear that all the critical notes below come from a good place. I played through a full season, which already says something: the core loop works. This has real potential as a mobile (or even a simple desktop) game, and I'm genuinely looking forward to seeing where you take it.
What's working well
The core loop holds up. A full season played smoothly start to finish, that's the most important box to tick, and it's ticked.
Visual presentation is solid. Colors, fonts, and layout are clean and readable. That sounds like a small thing, but it isn't, and you've nailed it.
The season flow makes sense. Calendar → planner → per-rider goals is an intuitive structure once you know it's there (more on discoverability below).
Rider groups are a great idea. Being able to bundle riders for race selection is genuinely useful. I'd love to see this expanded, letting players create their own custom groups, or adding more group slots, would open up a lot of use cases (e.g. grouping riders by similar race schedules rather than just by type).
Most mechanics already do what they're supposed to. No complaints on the fundamentals.
The squad screen is a pleasant surprise. Good to look at, and I can find what I need quickly.
Bugs
The calendar doesn't roll over to 2027 when advancing to the next season.
Riders I choose not to re-sign for the next season stay on the roster even after new transfers come in.
The auto-group button only works intermittently, I couldn't pin down a pattern.
Navigation & discoverability
This is where the game currently loses some value, because a few good features are hard to find: the top menu is a bit hidden, and some screens feel buried behind others.
I would split season goals and training. Right now there's no good way to monitor a rider's development over time, I'd love a dedicated screen for adjusting training and tracking progress separately from the main season goals.
The yearly per-rider planner is fantastic, genuinely one of the best tools for planning out a rider's season, but it's very well hidden. I only found it on my fourth restart.
On the planner screen itself: I actually prefer the mobile version over the desktop drag-and-drop. I'd lean into the mobile layout as the primary design, and instead improve the desktop version by surfacing more decision-relevant info (rider form, upcoming goals, race conflicts, etc.) so it's not just a drag-and-drop exercise.
Feature requests
Nationalities. Would love to see these added, I suspect this is already on your radar too.
Clearer rider potential. The star rating for potential is hard to read at a glance right now. I like that it's meant to stay a bit ambiguous, but currently it's basically invisible unless a rider has an unusually high ceiling. Some more visible (but still fuzzy) signal would help.
Game balance
Overall UCI ranking outcomes track expectations pretty well, which is a good sign. The bigger issue is that the rightriders aren't necessarily winning the right races, I think this comes from an interaction between season plans, main goals, and rider form.
As an example: I've had seasons where Pogačar skips a single Grand Tour and just wins everything else instead. That points to something in the goal/form logic rather than the underlying ratings.
On the ratings themselves, I peeked at the data file, and I get that fine-tuning hundreds of rider attributes is a huge lift for a small project. That's totally understandable, and honestly feels like the kind of thing that's easiest to improve later, possibly with community help. I’ve seen things that are oit of balance possibly but nothing drastic.
Form is the area I'd prioritize. Right now an average rider hitting peak form can jump ~10 points on an attribute, which is a lot, enough that a mediocre mountain domestique can suddenly go head-to-head with prime Pogačar or Vingegaard. Form matters a lot in real cycling, but it shouldn't be able to override talent entirely, talent should still win out in the end in most situations.
Closing thoughts
I'm being picky because I want this to be great, not because it isn't fun already. The bones are genuinely good, and I'm excited to see how it develops from here.