r/Dimension20 • u/[deleted] • Sep 12 '24
Misfits and Magic 2 I'm still kind of uncomfortable with Misfits and Magic
I know this will ruffle some feathers, but please read it before automatically reacting, and if you aren't a trans women or transfem, please sit back and think for a second about how that may be influencing how you feel about it
Gonna say this upfront, I don't think Dimension20 or Dropout or anyone involved with Misfits and Magic 2 are transmisogynistic.
Dropout usually does great overall with representation, I agree.
It does strike me as weird and disconcerting that in the show lampooning infamous black mold farmer JKR's world there's no trans women or transfem people in the cast, or talked about being behind the scenes. Yes, JKR is shitty to all trans and nonbinary people, like Erika, but her hate and vitriol are specifically targeted mostly at trans women, and even if you say "fuck terfs", doing a show where no one who is that primary targeted group (trans women/ trans fems) is represented, it's kinda weird.
Out of the generally very good trans rep on Dimension20 there are already disproportionately extremely few trans women/fems, I think just Persophone Valentine. Last time that came up a lot of people did standard talking points about forced diversity/tokenization being bad, and that Dropout is very progressive and good about representation.
Which, yeah, I agree. Working to include more trans women/fems isn't tokenization or forced diversity though. There are absolutely trans women who would fit the bill, and if there aren't, well that says a whole ton about the LA-based improve community that they cast from in the first place. Generally if there aren't trans women/fems in a community, there's a reason.
It's just weird that for as a company that does as great at representation as Dropout usually does, that trans women/fems are missing from the JKR based property when she's now infamous for hating us in particular, and missing in general.
I'm not bothered by the show existing in the first place, it doesn't monetize her. I am made uneasy by the noticeable lack of trans women.
Again, I don't think that Dimension20 or the cast of Misfits and Magic are transmisogynistic (at least no more so than any allied transmisogyny exempt person, kinda like how anyone we all need to be try to be recognizant and critical of subconscious biases towards marginalized groups we aren't a part of, but that's a different broader discussion.) or are bad people. Just that I, as a trans woman, am uncomfortable by some of the handling.
I'm not saying no one should watch it or you're bad if you do or that Aabria or anyone is bad. I'm asking people to please before having automatic defensive reactions to any trans women/fems who are uncomfortable with it, please try to see things from our perspective and don't assume bad faith. And also having more trans women in the show in general would be rad as fuck
*Edited to bold something for people who didn't read all of it