There are similar projects for AI search, but I figured it'd be useful to have a directory of the most popular brands on Reddit, with the Reddit posts Google shows for each one.
Here's how I did it.
I took a list of product categories. CRMs, website builders, LLMs, tax software, that kind of thing. For each one I googled the stuff buyers actually type, like "best CRM" or "which CRM should I use", with and without "reddit" at the end, and saved every Reddit thread Google showed me.
Then I had to clean it up, which took longer than everything else. Searching "ATS" gets you a lot of American Truck Simulator. I started with 102 categories and ended up with 68 that had enough threads that were really about the product.
After that it's just counting. Every post or comment that names a product is one mention. No list of brands going in, and I don't move anybody up or down.
Where the data comes from: Google search results in the US, 20 searches per category (ten questions, each with and without "reddit"). I kept only the reddit.com results, then read each of those threads on Reddit itself, the post and all the comments. Only posts and comments from the last 24 months count.
The threads come from more than 500 subreddits. The biggest sources are r/sysadmin and r/smallbusiness, about 130 threads each, then r/msp, r/cybersecurity and r/dataengineering.
The numbers:
68 categories, 2,292 threads, 53,018 mentions
pulled from 500+ subreddits
about 23 brand mentions per thread
about 120 different products named per category
the most mentioned single product: Spotify, 419 mentions in music streaming
Some of it surprised me.
Nobody owns a category. The biggest share any brand has is 28% (PostgreSQL in databases). Spotify, Gusto and QuickBooks are all around 25-26%.
Claude gets named more than ChatGPT in the LLM threads, 206 vs 160. ChatGPT shows up in the top five of 6 different categories, Claude in 5.
DaVinci Resolve has three times the mentions of Premiere (318 vs 102). FreeTaxUSA is ahead of TurboTax (233 vs 213).
Some races are basically tied. Django and Spring both have 67 in backend frameworks. Splunk leads Microsoft Sentinel 86 to 85.
And Excel is in the top five of 4 categories it isn't even in, including project management and accounting.
One caveat: a mention isn't a recommendation. People complain about products by name too. So this is who Reddit talks about, not who's best.
Also, I run Subgrow and we sell Reddit marketing, so some of these brands might be our customers. They get counted the same as everyone, and I left out anything posted from accounts we run.
I'll recount it every 30 days.
subgrow.ai/reddit-brand-rankings