Before I begin I would like to preface this post by giving some context. I am college student who is currently taking a Feminist Theories class in which I have been given an assignment to read Living a Feminist Life by Sara Ahmed and create a reading log in which we achieve a deeper understanding of the book through logging personal experiences, daily actions, and how our new knowledge builds off of what we have previously learned. We were given free reign on how to construct this log so I chose to to turn to Reddit, and more specifically this sub, as a place to journal my way through this book. I am aware that this space (while it is for more than just this) is a place for expression of daily life and personal experiences. I will have this in mind as I journal for it is the foundation of all my posts to come and as I hope that it well help me to achieve an overarching goal of mine: to use a feminist lens to find patterns in my past that continue to construct my present and future. If you read through my journal and would like to share experiences of your own or comment on what I have written, that would make me completely over the moon. Cheers!
Chapter 1 - "Feminism is Sensational"
The first chapter in Living a Feminist Life discusses the ways in which feminism is something that is felt, something that is noticed and detaches us from the homeostasis that we feel when we operate in our expected roles. This concept will be what I base this journal entry off of.
Entry 1: An Unusual Awakening
"What brings us to feminism is what is potentially shattering" (Ahmed, 22).
Many individuals who identify themselves as feminists can recall a time that they felt themselves become one. It tends to come from times of pain, violence, anger, and realization of what has been accepted as right is actually wrong. These feelings, these sensations, dismantle our previous standing in everything we had previously thought to be true. My "shattering" moment came for me when I was around 13 years old. I was in a relationship with a much older boy and despite my mother's attempts to steer me away, we were together for quite some time. This experience for me was interesting because it simultaneously built and destroyed every idea I had of what it should mean to be a woman. At 13, I was quiet and reserved. I did not seek the attention from others, partly because I felt undeserving of it and partly because I did not know what I would do with the attention if I had it. However, when I did receive the attention, from an older boy in high school (who we will call John* to make it easier), I was swept away in a river of bliss and confidence. "He likes me?" "He wants to be with me?" Disbelief swirled in my brain while butterflies swirled in my stomach. No red flags obstructed my view.
Even though I could not see what was wrong with the situation, others could. My parents tried to tell me I could never see or talk to him again, but this did not work. I turned into a different person; rebelling against my parents, lying to them and anyone who I thought would expose the truth that I was still seeing him, and sneaking out to be with him. This whole time I painted my parents and anyone who cared about my well being as the enemy. Only I was allowed to be right, only I could make the decisions. This continued until a chance encounter with a family friend who happened to be at John's house led to my secret double life being exposed to my parents. Realizing that I was on a (self-destructive) mission that I could not be deterred from, my parents allowed me to continue to see John. I feel confident that their thinking was that if they allowed it to continue, at least I would not be lying about it anymore.
Many months passed by and John and I continued to progress in our relationship. Once the "honeymoon" stage disappeared, I began to notice some red flags. While this is no reason to look down upon a person, John was a very broken individual. He was jealous, insecure, possessive, and overall controlling of every aspect of my life. I saw this as affection. To justify this I would say "it's because he loves me" and "he trusts me." I became an around the clock caretaker for an adult at the age of 14. I was constantly reassuring him when he had doubts, motivating him to get a job, and later on, fighting to help him get through college. This was a dynamic in our relationship that did not go unnoticed by those around us and was one of my first miscalculations of how I thought to define what it meant to be a woman. The sensation of being a motherly figure made sense to me then because I would think "this is what I am meant to do anyway, it's just happening sooner than I thought it would." I mistook the role I was playing to be inherent and normal rather than for what it actually was: a relinquishing of myself.
Ahmed discusses the sensation of feeling different in you body after a shattering encounter. However, I was not shattered all in one blow, but was chipped away for years until I was just a pile of shattered pieces. When John and I first met, I was at the age where one first truly begins to find one's place in their body. This is why I feel this experience constructed and destroyed my sense of self physically, mentally and emotionally. Years later, after much more turmoil, loss of self, and degradation of meaningful relationships with friends and family, I was able to face the thought I had been afraid of for so long: who I had become was not who I want to be or who i should be forced to be. My fear of losing what I thought to be an established place in the world was what kept me from confronting this thought for so long. However, once I did confront it, that was where I found my feminist identity even if I did not know it yet.
Entry 2: Space
"Feminism, in giving you somewhere to go, allows you to revise where you have been" (Ahemd, 31).
The debate between whether we have free-will or if fate exists is one that I think about quite often. I don't think the answer is overly important, as I don't think it would change the way I make my decisions. However, when I ponder fate, I like how it makes everything we have all endured in the past feel like it has led us to who we are right now. There are moments of synchronicity that feel too uncanny to deny and that's when I get swayed to team fate. When I see moments from my past align with my present, I cannot help but to look at the who I was in both circumstances. Whether I knew it or not, taking up space has always been something I struggled with since I was a young child. In my early years, I liked to sit on the ground with my legs to either side. Being "ladylike" or taking up space was never on my mind, this position just made it easier to play in the sand at the beach or with dirt in the backyard. Wearing dresses and knowing the "proper" way to position my legs was the beginning of me reconstructing what it meant to be a female in public. Little did I know then that this was just one of the many social rules I would be expected to abide by. I felt myself become smaller and smaller, folding upon myself both literally and figuratively as I stood in small spaces, hugged the corners or rooms, and stifled my own voice. This need to be small and inconspicuous is what I believe to be one of the roots to my desire to be "skinny" from a very young age. I recall very clearly coming inside on a summer evening, taking a green gel pen and writing "diet starts today" in the next day's box on the calendar hung up next to a handmade "#1 Dad" plaque on a bulletin board in the kitchen. I couldn't have been more than 10.
As the years went on, I continued to let my voice only be heard when convenient for others and speak quickly and quietly as too not waste too much time or sound too confident. Almost two years ago, I liberated myself from what felt to be the last stifling aspect of my life. I let myself feel that my voice mattered and that people wanted to hear it. While I was becoming more aware of my urge to take up little space as way to not disrupt the daily routine of society, I also felt hesitance to leave my comfort zone, no matter how small and uncomfortable it was. Soon into this journey of space, I went on a cross-country road trip to California. There we met up with a friend who specializes in spiritual healing and guidance who was excited to sit down with us to talk about our journey, not only to California but also the one we were experiencing by living. Here is where the moment of synchronicity emerged. Sitting one-on-one with her, the friend I mentioned immediately began discussing space without any prompting from me or telling her that that has been something on my mind for quite some time. She told me to take up space courageously and unapologetically. To not seek permission for the space I was occupying and to not forfeit it when it is not necessary. There was something so impactful about this moment to me, a woman telling another woman to take up space.
Entry 3: Informal Introductions
"If sensation brings us to feminism, to become a feminist is to cause a sensation" (Ahmed, 39).
I have very recently been explicitly introduced to my feminist identity and have applied it to my daily life. I have noticed myself becoming more at home with this part of my being as I have been speaking my mind more often and speaking about things that are going overlooked in social settings. While I think of this as growth, I also cannot help but think about how this creates moments of discomfort for everyone involved.
Just this past weekend I met my brother's new girlfriend for the first time. We talked about many surface level things: music, hometowns, college majors, etc. However, there were multiple occasions where I took the surface level conversations a little deeper and I felt noticeable discomfort arise in the room. "Do you watch the Kardashians?" was the first question that led to this. I responded lightly at first: "I used to watch them a lot more than I do now, but they definitely are entertaining!" To which she responded: "I still watch them basically everyday, I love them so much." And this was when the record scratches and I say something that I feel needs to be said but no one wants to hear: "I just think they could be using their wealth in more positive ways for the greater good and not to buy multiple mansions, but I'm probably over analyzing it since its meant for entertainment." The lack of response I received was a response in it of itself.
This happened two more times over the course of the evening with her: once during a discussion where she mentioned how she believes that we have a separation between church and state and I had to, kindly, point out to her that there are countries donating millions of dollars to reconstruct Notre Dame when there are issues occurring within their own boarders that they refuse to attend to, and secondly when she made a statement about how buying clothes from fast fashion industries does not have negative environmental or human impacts. As much as I wanted to bite my tongue, I feel like I just can't. After I point out such things I feel a sense of internal scrutiny as I fear that I am coming across too harsh or rude. However, I then begin to unpack why I would feel that personal conflict to begin with and I feel that it must come from not naming the issues that we ignore everyday. Issues we see but don't want to look at because if we do, the issues will become too real for us not to do something. If I made my brother's girlfriend feel uncomfortable I would apologize for changing the way she watches the Kardashians, but I won't apologize for diving deeper than the surface. While I worry that she may not see me in the most positive light, polite and careful encounters are rarely authentic anyway.
Okay, so this was my first post of journal entries for my reading log! It was much longer than I expected it to be and I don't think they will all be this long. There will be 9 of these posts overall that I will be putting up over the next few days and I hope to not clog up the feed with this too much. If there is anyway that I can format it to fit the guidelines of this sub more effectively please let me know!