r/Diamonds • • Oct 14 '26

My Diamond Diamond larger than expected (too big??)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

My lovely fiance surprised me with a 2.5ct natural asscher cut ring. I love it and I'm so grateful, but sometimes I feel like it looks huge! We had tried on 1.5 and 2 carats together when looking for rings, so I was expecting something closer to that size. He said he picked this one because you can see the steps/cuts in the larger asscher diamonds better vs the smaller ones. Does it seem too large for me? The place he bought it from would buy it back from us at a slight loss if I wanted to trade down a size but idk. I love it because he chose it for me and I guess I'm just a little self conscious? Can anyone relate??

Edit: Jfc šŸ˜‚ sorry everyone is offended by my car for some reason. I was just trying to show the ring on my hand from up close, medium distance, and farther away for size perspective. I am very lucky and grateful to have these things and am genuinely not trying to brag. I'm actually feeling self conscious about the ring because I don't want to be too showy!! Thank you to the people with legitimate feedback


r/Diamonds • • Sep 04 '25

Question About Natural Diamonds Which cut is my engagement ring and is it ā€œcloudyā€?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! First of all Thankyou for taking the time to read this post! I got engaged a couple days ago. I am over the moon with my ring! I do notice it is not as ā€œsparklyā€ as other peoples rings here on Reddit. I think it is because of the cut I think it is an old European cut and not the sparkle modern brilliant you see most times. Am I right?

Then someone told me a couple days ago it did look a bit ā€œcloudyā€ now I am getting a bit insecure. I notice that it indeed sparkles but nog as much as some others , do I need to be worried?!

Some background info on the ring, it is a mined 2.1 diamond color H and I think an SI-1 or 2 I am not sure. It sits on a white gold band.

Again I am really happy with the ring and my fiance (omygodddd first time I typed it) ā¤ļø I added in a few pictures in different angles and different kinds of light.


r/Diamonds • • Jun 14 '26 Regret

Question About Natural Diamonds How do you deal with diamond shrinkage?

Post image
17 Upvotes

Sometimes I look down and think my diamond is the perfect size and other times I think that it looks small. How do you deal with diamond shrinkage?

EDIT: There are a lot of people here assuming I don’t love my fiancĆ© when I would literally get married to him with a zip tie on my finger. I was just hoping for advice on how to deal with moments of time where I feel like my stone doesn’t look proportionate on my finger (obviously knowing that that’s all in my head). I appreciate those that have had kind words and have given me genuine advice and understanding.


r/Diamonds • • Apr 15 '26

Question About Natural Diamonds Back to natural diamond from lab - help me pick!

Post image
1 Upvotes

I have been married for 10 years. My first diamond was one carat natural princess cut. I don’t remember the specifics. It was purchased through James Allen and comes with a lifetime upgrade. About five years ago I upgraded to a lab diamond. It’s 2 carats (pic). Given the fact that lab diamonds have dropped significantly since I purchased this I want to upgrade back to a natural diamond. I don’t want to have $7500 invested in something that has no value. I have to spend double of what I spent on the lab which means I have to spend about $15,000. I am looking at a more rectangular option and really loving the emerald cut. I am also interested in the radiant cuts but something about the timeless look of the emerald is appealing. Is there a reason not to do emerald? What specs do I need to be looking for? I understand the upgrade is not going to be a size upgrade and accept that. Am hoping to get a diamond somewhere between $15-20K (before upgrade credit). Thanks in advance for any tips as I’ve learned all of this twice and forgotten it each time.


r/Diamonds • • Apr 25 '24

General Discussion Why are huge diamonds so popular on this subreddit?

67 Upvotes

Maybe it is because I am European but if I was a billionaire, I wouldn't buy anything bigger than about a 1 carat stone. Why are so many people buying average quality huge diamonds of 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 carat? With a big diamond, the imperfections will be easier to see. Only go big if you can also afford a high quality stone and even if you can afford it, bigger is not always better.

EDIT: Thank you for the very many and interesting replies. The most important thing is that you are happy with your diamond, regardless of whatever somebody else thinks. From the research I've done, the average engagement ring diamond in the US is about 1 carat whereas in Europe it is about 0.5 carat. Therefore, I think some cultural and wealth differences apply.

EDIT 2: went into 3 jewellery stores in France today, I was surprised at how big 0.25 carat looked! Maybe if I lived in New York or hung around with celebrities I would think differently but my eyes are certainly not used to the 2-5 carat diamonds we frequently see online. I also noticed that an internally rated H Si1 diamond in one of the stores looked a hell of a lot better than one in a different store with the same rating! Reputable independant rating agencies such as GIA are very important.


r/Diamonds • • Mar 02 '24

Natural Diamond 3ct Natural Diamond on Platinum Ring value?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi! What is a reasonable price to pay for this ring? It’s 3ct natural on platinum. A friend of mine is selling it to help pay for his mother’s funeral expenses. He’s asking 8k but I feel that’s a little high . I’m looking to buy it and then sell later on down the road but I’m not sure if something like this is an investment.


r/Diamonds • • Jan 08 '24

Question About Lab Grown Diamonds Lab Diamonds

0 Upvotes

I don’t mean to offend anyone, I’m just genuinely asking. What is the appeal of a lab grown diamond? I was at a jewelry store and the salesperson kept trying to push lab diamonds on to me over natural. The appeal of a natural diamond is that it took millions of years to produce but a lab takes like 20mins? I get it’s the same thing yet it’s not. IMO it’s like picking a clone over a human. It wouldn’t be so bad if it wasn’t so overpriced. Theoretically you can flood the market with free things then it basically becomes worthless. Am I wrong?


r/Diamonds • • Dec 31 '24

Natural Diamond Natural diamond ring regret

0 Upvotes

My fiancƩ proposed this year with a 3ct natural diamond and I absolutely love my ring, but I went home for Christmas this year and the first thing my cousin said to me was "this is a great starter ring, hopefully he can upgrade you in 5 years" and it hurt my feelings so much. She said this infront of my fiancƩ and other people and I can't stop thinking about it. She ended up apologizing in a voicemail 3 days later after someone told her that was rude. She has a a beautiful 6ct ring which is likely a lab and it just made me wish I had gotten a lab too.

I might be overthinking but has anyone else regretted getting natural versus bigger lab? I kind of want to get a 2nd lab or moissanite ring slightly bigger now which had never crossed my mind 😭

Edit: Thank you all sooo much for the supportive messages and for sharing your perspectives and experiences. I’m feeling so much better about the situation and truly love this kind, supportive community of diamond lovers šŸ™šŸ’•


r/Diamonds • • Jun 04 '25

Lab Grown Diamond Lab v natural… torn apart.

1 Upvotes

My sister is trying to convince me to get lab grown and the selling point is real, the stones are 99.9% identical except for the source.

However what’s tearing me is that one is mad made, the other is natural. Like buying a quartz worktop or marble which favours the natural bias. Quartz can literally mirror marble effects with even better performance. However, then you have comparisons like; ice from a glacier or stuff from the supermarket to cool your drink. That favours the lab stuff.

I’ve also been quoted VS2 G colour with triple excellent for Ā£7,000 ( natural ) and SI2 G colour triple excellent for Ā£5,300 (natural). Would you say these are reasonable price tags.

Specs are 1.5ct diamond with 18k yellow gold ring (6claws).

I would love to know your opinions.

EDIT: This is an engagement ring I’m purchasing for other half.


r/Diamonds • • Apr 08 '25

Question About Lab Grown Diamonds Baby’s 1st, Birthday gift

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

I'm looking to buy my daughter a 1-carat lab-grown diamond necklace for her first birthday, something she can wear when she's older. My budget is under $1k. I checked Adiamoda, and their necklace settings start at $485, which seems steep for a 14k necklace and an empty setting. Are these standard prices, or could I find a pendant setting and chain at a jeweler who can set a separate diamond? What are your thoughts on pre-made pieces from brands like Quince or Vrai?


r/Diamonds • • Jan 17 '24

General Discussion some thoughts about lab grown > natural

0 Upvotes

As many of us I recently joined this community while doing my research for an engagement ring. I learned about natural vs lab-grown diamonds and even other materials like moissanite.

When it comes to people looking for advice for a natural diamond I've seen a lot of comments that try to convince them to buy a lab-grown diamonds instead, saying those are identical etc. Some people feel very strongly about this.

I feel like it's not. Here's why:

I think you can compare that whole discussion to art. If you buy art you basically have at least 3 options:

  1. You can buy the original (natural)

  2. You can buy a painted copy from an artist (lab-grown)

  3. You can buy a printed copy (moissanite)

It may look the same but deep down it's not. At least to me. And whatever you choose is fine to me. I just don't really get why a lot of people think that getting a natural is a waste of money and the wrong choice.

Any thoughts?


r/Diamonds • • Sep 05 '24

General Discussion Does anyone else think LG diamonds reduce the luxury of diamonds overall?

66 Upvotes

I'm looking into getting myself a LG diamond and am shocked at how inexpensive they are. That's great for the buyer but I feel like it does affect the perceived value/luxury of diamonds overall. For example, whenever I see giant engagement rings on social media on otherwise modest acquaintances/friends, I can't help but think that it's likely lab. It's kind of like buying a fake designer bag. I know this will cause a stir on this sub but curious to know everyone's thoughts. Probably won't stop me from getting a LG myself lol.


r/Diamonds • • Aug 19 '25

Lab Grown Diamond Are lab created diamonds more of a hype just recently these past few years vs mined?

4 Upvotes

Maybe Im late to the party, but when did lab diamonds become so popular? Because even just 10 years ago everyone up here where I am in Canada, were all about Canadian mined diamonds. Now suddenly everyone is talking about lab excellent grade perfect diamonds. Am I just old school? I know logically they are chemically the same, but there is just something really unique and different about a diamond that came out of the earth, and made over millions of years - in my opinion of course. But when I see people with these 3-4 carat lab created perfect diamonds, part of me thinks it almost takes away that special ooomf of a diamond? And please no no nooo disrespect to anyone that loves their diamonds. I truly did not know this was a thing until I personally went shopping recently with someone and had an eye opening experience and then came on Reddit and saw this was fairly common, I guess.

I am not wanting to start any fights, just genuinely curious. Was it because we became more aware of issues such of blood diamonds and issues of that nature? If so, that totally makes sense, or just personal preference? Maybe all of the above? Lol. Tia


r/Diamonds • • Sep 12 '23

General Discussion Diamond industry as a whole rn

0 Upvotes

As a specialized jeweler in both natural and lab-grown diamond, and with international jewelry experience, I wanted to shed some light on the current state of the diamond industry.

First of all, if I mean, I kind of want to cut the crap with all that ethical and supposed interest on this aspect of Lab Diamonds, there is more and more evidence that this is just a sale strategy, and in reality, men just don’t wanna pay a ton of money for their engagement rings, the average man really does not care about these topics. They are just happy to buy a cheaper diamond.

When it comes to buying diamonds, my perspective is that the experience of purchasing from a physical store or a renowned jeweler far outweighs the convenience of online shopping. While it depends on one's budget, I believe it's worth considering a smaller carat natural diamond from a physical store over a larger lab-grown one online.

In my experience, although lab-grown diamonds can be beautiful, people ultimately desire something special and unique. As lab-grown diamonds become more common, it's a trend that could lead people back to natural diamonds sooner than we might think.

I make it a point to be transparent with my customers. Lab-grown diamonds aren't the saviors of lives or the solution to sustainability issues in the industry. It's ethically questionable to sell diamonds at a huge markup just because they're labeled as "diamonds" when the production cost is significantly lower. Let's consider the bigger picture and make informed choices.

I just want to have a really honest conversation with people about this topic. I feel like it’s really weird how people are not being honest about it. sure again I go back to the budget comment because I know not everyone can afford paying more than $8000 for a diamond (my average client spends around 6,000-8000 dllrs on their engagement ring), I’m sure there are other ways, but I am trying to reach a more philosophical or holistic approach to the topic. I don’t know if I can explain myself that well, English is not my first language. I just try comparing it with bags for example or we art. Getting a leather bag from the same people that make a mess bags is not the same thing as getting the real deal and hanging a Picasso printed on your house wall it’s not as special as having a real Picasso.

This topic now turns more into what luxury is and why did truly means, and what it has meant throughout history. Luxury is exclusive, unique, and valuable.

***** EDIT ****

My friends, I will say this. After reading all your comments I think the whole answer rests on the value of things. And how this is different to all and each one of us.

What is value? What is valuable? What is luxury? What is special?

Here the only answer depends on how you feel. So in the end, regardless of other factors, If it makes you feel better in general? Then go for it.

Now, that being said, I can see why anybody can go back into the rabbit whole.. hahah you could ask yourself well.. am I being well informed? What is the truth? Is this better than that? By which metrics?

I care about these topics, if this thing I want align with them then it is more valuable for me.

I guess that sums it up. Sometimes I forget how simple it truly is. But thanks for everything guys.

And I love how awesome it is to have an open talk about these topics. Thank you again guys.


r/Diamonds • • Nov 25 '23

General Discussion I sincerely loathe the Ascher cut.

0 Upvotes

Anyone else?

Edit: if you’re responding, how about giving me an updoot?


r/Diamonds • • Oct 05 '25

Natural Diamond Too flashy? Or just right?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I never thought i would fall in love with a ring until I seen this one. What do you guys think? Who would wear a ring like this?

I had it for 3 months before I got the guts to wear it.


r/Diamonds • • Oct 16 '25

Lab Grown Diamond Stuck with 3ct or go up to 3.5ct?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Hi everyone! So the band on the engagement ring is temporary so it's not my actual band. The actual band is being custom made & will be Solitaire 14 karat yellow gold but 3.5 mm so it'll be thicker. Pretty much similar to the second ring eternity band on my finger. We went with this 3ct but after looking at it on my hand we are wondering if we should upgrade to the 3.5? We are still within the 30-day return Exchange policy. I'm just really torn. Half of me wants to upgrade to the 3.5 since the band its is going to be thicker but I also don't want it to be gaudy and look fake lol.
The 2nd pic is my inspo. That diamond is 4ct.

It also may sound silly but I feel like I've kind of bonded with this diamond LOL but still kinda want bigger


r/Diamonds • • Jun 30 '26

Lab Grown Diamond Final decision! Was this a decent price for both Lab rings?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hi all!

31F shopping for my ring upgrade recently. I owned a Tiffanys 1.14carat Round Solitaire in Knife Edge platinum band. Size 6.5 to 7.0 finger.

Since Lab diamonds became acceptable & more advanced , I decided Id jump on the band wagon and try it out as my Tony Soprano’s wifey šŸ’

Here is what we choose today! ( setting isnt the one I am getting in pic just for reference).

$10,500 CAD for both rings:

4.5 Carat Oval D VVS2 1.50 Ratio apparently on a Platinum knife edge Tiffany style setting.

7 carat Oval diamond eternity ring to match in Platinum!

OG Tiffany ring is natural diamond but it was a wopping $37,500 CAD. 😭

*** EDIT***

This is NOT the final setting. This was just to try the diamond on a band to see what it looked like !

Yes I did customize my ring but I didn’t want any extras. I think the diamond alone steals the show! I was offered extra diamonds and embellishment on the prongs and sides for FREE but I didnt want that.

7Carat Eternity band is the one with diamonds ALL around the ring. Entirely, not just the top 5 for show.

As for my research. I cross reference to bijou lab, cullen jewelry, grown brilliance, brilliant earth and some local small jewelers also for the same rings.

All of them wanted 9-13k CAD for the solitaire alone. Not even 4 carats but in 3.5 or less for D VVS1-2 all the perfect cuts.

I chose a reputable Jeweler. I dont want to run into problems with insuring, fakes or chances of being truly ripped off. I want to be able to call someone up and say Hey I need a repair. Not to a dead phone line or bankrupt fly by night business. Just because people can buy wholesale to start a jewelry business, doesnt mean they should. And nor would I give my complete trust in it.

Last thing: ā€œ How did we doā€ was more so to say do you like the diamonds chosen. I didnt ask if I got a good deal or if it’s a great price. Only giving details for reference.


r/Diamonds • • 9d ago

Natural Diamond Took over 20 years for this upgrade!

82 Upvotes

I posted the diamond this diamond before I had purchased it about 6 months ago to get opinions, which really helped me. I know some won't like what I've chosen, but I'm THRILLED and wanted to thank those who helped me through the process.

It's a 6.05 Old European Cut (Natural diamond) center stone with a little over 1ct of side baguettes. 4.12ct pear cut wedding band. I have a 3mm rose gold band in the middle as a spacer. Ring size 5.75.

When we first got engaged in 2003, he promised to upgrade my ring...it took a long time, but I feel it's been worth the wait! He had a long time to save šŸ˜„


r/Diamonds • • Jan 09 '24

General Discussion Ring size/income

Post image
53 Upvotes

Thinking about purchasing this 3 carat ring. For a household income of 200k does it look ridiculous to have a 3 carat ring on? Please be honest. Its a lab grown and we could afford a 30k ring if it was natural (got lab for ethical reasons) but wondering honestly what it looks like to others? I know I shouldn’t care but just wondering. Thanks in advance


r/Diamonds • • Oct 31 '23

Question About Lab Grown Diamonds Lab created diamonds LESS environmentally friendly than mined??

2 Upvotes

I have found this report that says lab created diamonds are actually less environmentally friendly than mined diamonds. What is your opinion about it, do you think it is true? If yes, what does this say about "splurging" on 3+ ct lab created rocks?

https://www.thejewelleryeditor.com/jewellery/article/report-reveals-lab-grown-diamonds-high-carbon-footprint-eco-diamonds/


r/Diamonds • • Oct 04 '25

Question About Lab Grown Diamonds 2.5 too big?

0 Upvotes

My first time posting on Reddit so please be nice to me. Just went to look at engagement rings and I decided on a lab grown round diamond solitaire ring. We decided on 2.3-2.5 because it was within his budget (he’s going to buy the ring on his own time and without me). But now I’m wondering is that going to be too big? I want a WOW ring but also want it to be realistic and don’t want people questioning if it’s real. We both work average jobs so it’s not like we’re spending a crazy amount on a ring. Do you think 2.5 is going to be too big for what I’m going for??


r/Diamonds • • Nov 29 '24

Question About Natural Diamonds Are Diamonds down from 2015??

0 Upvotes

I bought a 2 ct round diamond solitaire engagement ring back in 2015, GIA certified. I did a lot of searching at the time at it was one of the best prices I could find at $14,700.. Setting was cheap so the diamond was nearly all of that cost (maybe 14k)?

Now I log in to James Allen just to check the value, and sure enough it look like a 2ct excellent cut matching specs GIA is like 8-9k. What gives?

I havent paid attention to diamond market, but other jewelry such as gold, and my rolexs have increased in valuve significantly?


r/Diamonds • • Dec 25 '25

Natural Diamond My new eternity band not stacking well with engagement ring

0 Upvotes

Hi looking for suggestions.. we recently upgraded my engagement ring diamond but kept the original setting from 27 years ago.. i wore it with a 5 diamond wedding back that stacked well with it but both rings constantly spun around.. so now we upgraded my wedding band to this eternity band but it doesn’t stack well.. should I just wear it alone? Thx