r/Diablo • • Jul 02 '12

BANNING LINUX USERS FOR USING LINUX...

http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/5978861022

Thought this needed more attention....

0 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

16

u/someenigma Jul 03 '12

Admittedly I haven't played in about 3 days, but I play D3 exclusively through Wine, and I'm yet to get banned.

I also am still playing SC2, and have since it launched. No bans, ever.

I've played WoW from patch 1.4 to cata launch, all under Wine. No bans, ever.

2

u/keithjr Jul 03 '12

I've been playing under Wine as well, and tonight started having serious issues with freezes and disconnects. Here's hoping I can log in tomorrow.

3

u/someenigma Jul 03 '12

I'm at work, but I'll check tonight. Freezes and disconnects don't seem like ban-material to me.

1

u/keithjr Jul 03 '12

I'm not terribly worried, because new discussion has been indicating that Blizzard hasn't found any Wine-based false positives yet. I'm just being paranoid. I've never had such bad performance problems until last night, when my entire desktop session froze several times for 10 seconds to a minute (obviously killing me in the process each time). Then I hear Wine and Warden aren't getting along.

1

u/retitled Jul 03 '12

I played from launch until Cata. I was banned once in 2006, for using Cedega.

15

u/HelloAnnyong Jul 03 '12

Bashiok says:

We’ve extensively tested for false positive situations, including replicating system setups for those who have posted claiming they were banned unfairly. We’ve not found any situations that could produce a false positive, have found that the circumstances for which they were banned were clear and accurate, and we are extremely confident in our findings.

Playing the game on Linux, although not officially supported, will not get you banned – cheating will.

46

u/enum5345 Jul 02 '12

This happened in WoW before. Blizzard worked with the Wine folks and got it all sorted out.

6

u/keithjr Jul 03 '12

What's troubling is that CS reps are responding that the bans will not be overturned. And if they hit this issue before, you'd think they'd know a this point exactly what happened. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for this to get resolved.

4

u/Corrosivecoke Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12

I believe they have to respond like that until they figure out what part of Warden is malfunctioning and banning people for using WINE. For now I think they are just ordered to send automatic response messages, and the one for "using an illegal program" happens to say "you will not be unbanned etc"

edit: of course, they could just be saying "wine blabllab" while they were actually botting.

1

u/Maethor_derien Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12

Yeah, it is most likely because they are searching for virtual machines since most botters try to run the game in a vm and the bot outside the vm and wine probably shows up like a virtual machine.

The reason is that if set up properly they can never detect the bot the best they can do is detect the game is being run in a VM.

1

u/retitled Jul 03 '12

Yea I was banned from WoW due to using wine, it took about a month to get it removed.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

[deleted]

30

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

LOUD NOISES!

19

u/ketoacidosis Jul 03 '12

I AM APPALLED HOW MUCH IS MICRO$OFT PAYING BLIZZARD TO BAN ONLY LINUX USERS FOR LINUXING WITH LINUX

-8

u/user555 entropys#1860 Jul 03 '12

I AM APPALLED HOW MUCH IS MICRO$OFT PAYING BLIZZARD TO BAN ONLY LINUX USERS FOR LINUXING WITH LINUX RMAH RMAH RMAH!!!

*Fixed

-5

u/d4vid87 Jul 03 '12

It's a conspiracy with Microsoft.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

I dont even think Microsoft is that evil.

101

u/dhnguyen Jul 02 '12

Stop screaming at me.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12

It's probably red herring, a botter who got caught, and is trying to rationalize the ban "because of Linux".

See details in one of the 1st Tier comments below.


EDIT 1: [We're Kotaku'ed!] (http://kotaku.com/5923068/report-blizzard-banning-diablo-iii-players-for-using-linux)

EDIT 2: As predicted:

Blue post re: Linux under WINE - "Playing the game on Linux, although not officially supported, will not get you banned – cheating will."

2

u/RedalAndrew Jul 03 '12

LOUD NOISES!

Edit: on alienBlue, didn't realize someone made the same comment two posts down. My bad.

28

u/tierauftier Jul 02 '12

They are technically banned for using Wine...not linux, but I got the point I guess...

Either way, it has NOT been confirmed that wine is the cause yet. It very well could be, but it isn't confirmed.

4

u/HasCatIsProud Jul 03 '12

BANNING CAPSLOCK USERS FOR USING CAPSLOCK...

14

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

The amount of ignorance and stupidity in that thread makes my brain hurt.

21

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

It's probably a red herring and doesn't need more attention. That dude was botting, got caught and is now saying it was WINE/Linux.

8

u/Woolliam Wool#1607 Jul 03 '12

As somebody who was caught experimenting with a bot on RIFT, and who has gamed with gold buyers, botters, and powerlevelers in the past, i can say this is very likely the case. The general course of action is to blame it on something unrelated but 'shady', in my case it was multiboxing, which was legit.

Stick to your guns of 'i was only multiboxing, which isnt against TOS. please explain.' and permabans become 24hour bans. From WoW to RIFT to Aion and beyond, this is the route to go, but i get a sneaking suspicion that with the publicity of this post, its a -group- of linux botters trying to find a way off the hook.

All wild speculation fuelled by anecdote.

-1

u/fiat_lux_ Jul 03 '12

Nice of you to come clean, or at least share your experiences and thoughts on this as someone who has history with the other perspective.

1

u/ElGuaco Jul 03 '12

It was right there in his own thread, "Yup, we double checked and you were cheating and rightly banned." What more proof do you need? I'm surprised that they haven't deleted the forum thread.

3

u/bawlesmcgee Jul 03 '12

Taken from the battlenet thread:

"Earlier on, us Linux WINE users started getting kicked from servers because of this Warden bug. I expected to get banned shortly after but apparently they were probably testing Warden before making it auto ban you.

It was found out if you use setarch to run wine with a 32bit address space, this kicking never happened again. I've played the game for weeks without issue afterwards, and I'm not banned. I've quit for other reasons however.

Warden obviously has issues with wine exposing the 64bit address space.

setarch i386 -3 wine ...

If you can get blizzard to unban you, make SURE you setarch your wine process!"

23

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '12

No, this doesn't need more attention. r/diablo is turning (or has turned) into a bunch of whiners that grab their pitchforks and form a mob before Blizz even has a chance to fix the issue.

Calm the fuck down, and let them deal with it.

-5

u/Reebzy Reebz#1490 Jul 03 '12

"whiners" / "wine" - I see what you did there...

-25

u/IExecration Jul 03 '12

Tell me, how does Bashiok's ass taste like?

7

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

This has absolutely nothing to do with Bashiok. He's not this demi-god that has a say in everything that goes on...

3

u/MizerokRominus Jul 03 '12

Your father's mouth.

1

u/CS_83 Jul 03 '12

Why are you kissing his father?

1

u/IExecration Jul 03 '12

Ass-kisser count is up to 2!

2

u/Dam_Herpond Jul 03 '12

Thank you for respecting our position

Hahaha... Oh, so wrong

2

u/noble8301 Jul 03 '12

LOUD NOISES! HYPERBOLE! AND SUCH!

2

u/kingmanic Jul 03 '12

There is this shrill bitter group on r/diablo that's shouting non stop about how D3 killed and raped their mother. There isn't a shred of criticism with any perspective around here and every single fucking thing is 'SHOUTING BECAUSE FUCK BLIZZARD !!!1!'.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '12

I hope they fix this if it is indeed Wine.

As others said, this was an issue in the early days of WoW, and Warden was since modified to detect Wine and behave differently.

3

u/FartMart Jul 02 '12

Well I guess its a good thing the mods dont ban caps lock users for using caps lock. You'd probably be pretty miffed.

3

u/the_snook Jul 02 '12

When this "banned for using Linux" topic came up on WoW a few years ago, it turned out that the guy doing all the screaming had admitted in a message to Blizzard that he was using a programmable keyboard to auto-play while watching movies. IOW - legitimate ban unrelated to his choice of OS.

19

u/Deestan Jul 03 '12 edited Jun 23 '23

content revoked

1

u/the_snook Jul 03 '12 edited Jul 03 '12

Sure it was a different case, but the circumstances are very similar. Someone comes screaming into the official forum that Warden is banning Wine users, with no confirmation from Blizzard that this is a banning offence, and thousands of players continuing to use Wine with no problems.

One guy posts on the Wine App DB that he (a) uses Wine; and (b) got banned, and this is sufficient evidence that Warden is banning Wine users? Maybe the guy got hacked, maybe he's lying about cheating, maybe a bad network cable made it look like he was continually trying to speed/teleport hack. Who knows?

Last time someone cried "wolf" on this issue, there was no wolf. Forgive me for remaining skeptical until there's more evidence.

Edit: Well, what do you know?

http://us.battle.net/d3/en/forum/topic/5978861022?page=21#402

We’ve extensively tested for false positive situations, including replicating system setups for those who have posted claiming they were banned unfairly. We’ve not found any situations that could produce a false positive, have found that the circumstances for which they were banned were clear and accurate, and we are extremely confident in our findings.

Playing the game on Linux, although not officially supported, will not get you banned – cheating will.

2

u/Deestan Jul 03 '12

You have a point. :)

-1

u/MizerokRominus Jul 03 '12

Could be the same person, or a different person, crying at the same issue.

1

u/retitled Jul 03 '12

I was banned from WoW for about a month with a large group of other people for the simple fact of only using wine. I definitely believe that they would repeat the same mistake with D3.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

You liar. The truth is already out there. You deserve the ban, botters!

1

u/retitled Jul 03 '12

I honestly don't know why you would call me a liar when I'm stating fact. Since it happened 2006 I don't have a copy of the emails. However a little googling would show you that you're a prick for calling someone a liar.

Why would you be such an asshole?

GOOGLE

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

My guess is the guy was cheating and is just lying to try and recover his account.

2

u/matrixino matrix#2319 Jul 03 '12

As a Linux users I feel their pain. My main OS are Arch and Gentoo, but still I keep a W7 for gaming. Upvoted, hoping in an official response here or on forums.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

The WINE user got banned for cheating, and Not because of using WINE. See the new reddit Top Story about this.

1

u/Synchrotr0n Jul 03 '12

I guess what's happening is "simple":

  • Wardens finds a botter. Warden bans it giving the reason "X".

  • Warden finds a Wine user. Warden don't know what Wine is. Warden wrongly bans it giving the reason "X".

  • Warden only knows the reason "X"

  • Support section checks Warden bans. Wine user is banned under reason "X". No unban/refund to Wine user.

That's ridiculous!

9

u/Abedeus Jul 03 '12

I guess what's happening is actually simpler.

Warden finds a botter. Bans it.

Botter tries to blame Blizzard for banning his account. Gives false reason.

RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE SCANDALOUS ALL CAPS!

0

u/videogameexpert PM for tag Jul 03 '12

This is what I got out of it too. All caps = instant suspect.

Blizzard is not stupid they would never ban people for WINE. Come on now.

3

u/Synchrotr0n Jul 03 '12

I admire your faith. "Never" is a strong word...

0

u/bl1y Jul 03 '12

Time will tell.

1

u/jobotslash Zyzyxx#1188 Jul 03 '12

This logic is true with retail shoplifters and similar crooks. 9 times out of 10, someone who has paid for their stuff or intends on paying for their stuff will not feel weird that an employee is following them. Someone who intends on stealing or something will often immediately get defensive and try to make a scene. A lot of my friends work LP/AP (loss prevention/asset protection) and they tell me about this behaviour all the time.

It's sad really. I mean, yeah it sucks to have your account banned or locked out, advertently or inadventently (like you reinstalled your phone's OS without keeping your RESTORE code for your authenticator. [guilty of that one, it sucked.]) but come on. Be an adult about it - especially considering that most of us playing Diablo are probably adults anyway, since we were probably playing 1 and 2 when we were kids...

3

u/Clbull Clbull#2385 Jul 03 '12

Well Warden's been developed and updated rigorously over several years. The last time Linux users were banned was around early 2006 for using Cedega (a propietary fork of Wine) but Blizzard quickly apologised for that and reimbursed their players.

I of all people have played World of Warcraft successfully without any bans whatsoever when playing on Ubuntu Linux about four years ago and this seems to be a bit more than just a "Warden blunder"

And let's not forget that a player's permanent suspension was UPHELD.

-3

u/Itbelongsinamuseum Jul 03 '12

This is fucking retarded.

-1

u/Joshgt2 Jul 03 '12

More and more depressing Diablo 3 related news.... When the FUCK is Torchlight 2 coming!?!?!

-1

u/braitac Jul 03 '12

THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE!

-8

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

Linux is not listed as an officially supported OS for Diablo 3. The Warden was on these computers dropped into an alien environment and correctly identified that it was not in a supported architecture. This is of course conjecture, but it seems silly for people to complain that their game doesn't work as expected on Linux when Blizzard does not release their software on Linux.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

Well, there's a difference between not supported and illegal. Linux users don't expect Blizzard to solve performance issues when running D3, however being banned is another thing entirely.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

[deleted]

1

u/bl1y Jul 03 '12

My laptop's video card is also unsupported. I can run the game at the highest graphics settings. If I get banned for it, I'd probably be pissed ...until I called their support number that is. Then I'd be pissed about the crappy support.

-3

u/protocos Jul 03 '12

"A company should be feared... Not respected..."

-9

u/f1uttershy Jul 03 '12

There not banning linux users for using linux... its because linux is a complete open based software where the user has access to everything making it a hacker haven... when they ban diablo 3 players who use linux its basically saying hey we don't want to take any chances

-10

u/kelosane Jul 03 '12

Ain't gonna lie, total Linux hater. I drink that haterade every fucking morning. I like money, not open "sores." So even though this is complete shit for a company to do, it still makes me giggle.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '12

[deleted]

15

u/lolsrsly00 Jul 02 '12

How can I trust someone who can't fix their own caps key to fix mine or other people's caps key? :\

4

u/someguy945 Jul 03 '12

If anything this is more reason to trust him. The shoemaker's son always goes barefoot.

-17

u/Allegory_Esq Jul 02 '12

I copy and pasted the thread title. sorry.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

lazy bum!

4

u/MizerokRominus Jul 03 '12

A trademark of Linux administrators... ha... hahaha.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '12

[deleted]

4

u/Throwaway_account134 Jul 03 '12

Because they're not asking Blizzard to make it work. There's a difference between supporting an operating system (making it work there, fixing bugs specific to it, etc.) and banning someone using an alternative operating system.

You installed this fancy new graphics card in a PC I didn't approve? Sorry man, I'm gonna brick it.