r/DestructiveReaders • • Nov 13 '13

You've probably read some of my critiques on this subreddit

0 Upvotes

Your reaction is probably, who does he think he is. I'm a keen reader. I don't say if you're writing is good or bad, or if you are a good or bad writer. I'm an expert in what is engaging and what isn't. What is interesting. That's all you can really hope to achieve... to tell someone their writing is bad is an opinion, and it's not my place to give anyone my opinion. However, to tell someone their writing fails to hold my interest is simply a factual statement. If what I say offends you, that you are offended is at the route of the problem.

Writing something that is engaging to someone who isn't you is learning to remove yourself from your ideas. Your bias to your own work will lead you down plot lines that should never have been written, to describe mundane scenes in exact detail, and to pepper your narrative with unnecessary backstory that interrupts what inertia you are able to achieve. The reader will read into your fears and limitations, and the end result will not be entertainment, but boredom.

Once you have removed yourself from your writing, then the question of how good a writer are you can be answered. Once you can throw away that first inferior idea and start working on the next one, can you measure your ability to come with interesting ideas.

Anyone who is interested in me going over their writing in detail but doesn't want it done in public, feel free to message me, you'll get my full attention eventually.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Jun 18 '15

Fantasy/Horror [3600] Portrait of an Abusive Marriage (NSFW) NSFW

0 Upvotes

EDIT: upvote, downvote, upvote, downvote... I get it, I'm a jackass. but I take pride in craftsmanship. and to all of you who have been able to show me, not tell me, what I'm doin' wrong: thank you.

this was about developing the relationship between two characters, full stop. along the way it picked up a whole bunch of Ideas, and I got so wrapped up in exploring all these other things I frankly didn't give a lot of hard thought to how to write the sumbitch and just kind of assumed I'd fall on point by accident. WOMP WOMP.

so, this presents me with an opportunity to fix nearly every complaint that has been made (or at least all the ones I'm willing to take seriously) with one simple step: developing the voice of the narrator, which Imma obviously want to do as much as possible before I spend 600 pages with her anyway. I promise when I repost, I will have done my very very very very best to justify my colossal ego -- and again, thank you. sincerely.

 

this is the opening to a 26000-word thought experiment I wrote as a warmup for a 600-page marathon.

I welcome editing, and have left the doc open for such, BUT. what I'm more interested in at the moment is whether I can tell a story -- which is why I'm really here to solicit the opinions of anyone who is willing, after reading this beginning excerpt, to read the whole thing and offer a holistic assessment of narrative: characters, imagery, thematic content, emotional impact.

I am attempting something both subtle and provocative, and prefer to furnish as little context as possible. I will simply say that you need to be ready for a handful of standard fantasy concepts like magic, and -- while this first few pages remains innocuous -- pretty much nonstop GRAPHIC, EXPLICIT sex, violence, and sexual violence, shortly after the cutoff. beyond that, I solicit reactions, interpretations, and wild guesses. strap in.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Sep 29 '19

[1910] Shield of the Heart Chapter 3 Part B

0 Upvotes

Part A with the links to crits is Here So sum it up 6204 extra Minus part 2 brings it to 4294 extra. Most of my crits have been 2k ish

A fantasy story set on an Alternate earth WW1, Shield of the Heart is a working title. Here is Part B

Thanks to any that critique what they can. All constructive criticism is very welcome. I hope you enjoy.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Dec 26 '18

Fantasy [554] A Thriving Thief

0 Upvotes

Some backstory on what I wrote here. It's based on a petty thief named Reginald Creekwood, who was raised in a rich family (thus his posh name) but is the sole survivor of a cyclo-train accident of his family, and was thus placed into an orphanage. He then turns to theft, after the orphanage is burned down by some drunks. Here's the story:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1HY-CJngYDGZ2YM2j2PV2eVQfFQ1Cg86ZPlgC1SNrhsM/edit?usp=drivesdk

[554 words]

The critique I am mainly looking for is whether you find it interesting, and how my vocabulary and structure are holding up. I have only written non-fictional articles so far, this is my first fictional work. Here is a critique I recently made, I tried to make it as long and expansive as possible:

458 words

(If you guys are adamandant about the 1:1 ratio, I am fine if you just reviewed the first 458 words :))


r/DestructiveReaders • • Jun 19 '19

Sci-Fi [3121] Once We Were Gods

0 Upvotes

r/DestructiveReaders • • Aug 01 '23

Weird Fiction / Mystery [1813] Currently Untitled Weird Fiction Mystery (NSFWish) NSFW

0 Upvotes

Hi all.
This is my opening chapter to what will eventually be a weird fiction mystery story. It's a little graphic towards the end, and a little bit crusty. Definitely NSFW, with harsh language and vulgar imagery.
Link
Not looking for line edits.
Things I'm looking for (not a list, just a guide for what I'd find most helpful):

  • Was it enjoyable?

  • Was it understandable?

  • Was it too uncomfortable?

  • Does it flow well?

  • Is the prose too much?

  • Thoughts on the story?

  • Thoughts on setting?

  • Anything about the characters?

  • Would you keep reading?

Thanks in advance!
Prior critique: 1939


r/DestructiveReaders • • Apr 27 '14

Other The Company for the Creator

0 Upvotes

Tick... Tick... Tick...

It had spent a lot of time in this universe.

Tick... Tick... Tick...

It is not like a watch was needed, but somehow It liked this universe and a constant reminder on its heartbeats on the way to entropy seemed somehow fitting. It had created universes before, but those it had to refuel. This one would never be refueled, it had vowed. A process of unstoppable decay. It viewed it as a meditation.

Tick... Tick... Tick...

It felt a bit alone. Sometimes, it pondered, maybe it hadn't been the best decision to say "I am", casting itself into an existence of watching and creating.

So, a meditation on loneliness and decay. Not that it would decay anytime soon.

Tick....

Did it just seem like that to it, or was the clock going slower?

"Hello? God? Are you there?", a voice said.

Startled, the God searched around the universe. What was that?

"My mother is sick, God. Please heal her.", the voice said again.

Galaxies blurred into stars. It had found the source. Small water planet. It went in closer. Most curious! A small, ape-like creature, sitting next to the sleeping site of a more ape-like creature. Both still had some fur on them, and the small one wore some sort of leather around its loins.

The god was intrigued. In all the universes before, none of the life it had created had been capable of ... communicating in this way.

It turned the wheels of creation. The mother healed. The little one became a shaman. Shamans turned into priests, priests turned into warmongers, warmongers turned into mass murderers. But there was good too. Love, compassion, Sharing. That was the stuff that it liked most. The prayers kept floating up to it. Some attributed an idea to it, some called it a he, a she, an adversary, some were bitter, and some were sweet. Company, at last.

And God smiled. Even though it would end someday.

Tick.... Tick.... Tick....

It valued every second of it.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Feb 05 '16

TYPE GENRE HERE [1054] In Your Court (working title)

0 Upvotes

Edit: Alright, some people aren't aware that this is not a closed short story, but rather a snippet from what is to be a novel or novella. My bad for not elaborating on this in my original post. Sorry.

This means that though some of the points made are very valid, and certainly worth taking with me on my journey of becoming a fine writer, story- and setting-wise they do not apply. I know there is no setting; I know there is no over arching plot; I know the characters are not worked out.

It is a highlight of one conversation between the girl and the man. That is all.

(That said: thank you a thousand times over for the critique -- relevant or not. I read all of it, and note every bit of it in a log. Keep it coming!)

Link: Go ham, people! Grammar, Prose, Story: all of it to shreds!


r/DestructiveReaders • • Sep 07 '20

Fantasy/Action Adventure [3994] Eidolon - Ch. 1

0 Upvotes

I'd like to share the first chapter of a longer story I'm working on for feedback. It's generally a Fantasy/Adventure story, however I don't want to say more than that. The story jumps right into things, so I want to see how much people can pick up from the text alone

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1rchavoN4q1LqA_IrQdziqAnN-jxevxp-ZNZ9lq-LewA/edit

I'd particularly like feedback on:

  • Mechanics - Does the hook work? Does it keep up tension in periods of inaction? etc.

  • Place Setting - As I said, the story hits the ground running and there's a lot that needs to be established quickly, so I'd like to make sure it does a good job setting up relevant information about the story/world in a way that's organic and doesn't unduly drag things down

  • Character Motives, Stake Setting, Reader Buy-In- One complaint from a previous iteration of the chapter was that there wasn't much to get the reader invested in the story or see the main character complete any sort of arc, so I've tried to correct for that. Let me know if it works.

  • Writing Style - Is everything clear? Are scenes vivid? Is the action intense and easy to follow? etc. If you're feeling up for it you can compare it to an earlier version that was much heavier on accented language, onamonapias and unconventional formatting. The idea was to more directly convey the way the POV processes the world around her, but I wanted to try to tone it down to see if that makes things more accessible.

  • General Remarks - Any other feedback is of course appreciated. The Google doc is open for comments if you're like to make any line edits

Critiques

[3703] The Drain

[1228] Ranger's Journey: 1

[994] The Lot

[1786] [Corrected] Introducing Billy, Orphan Andy, Nick, Judi Garland

EDIT: Yeesh, what's with the downvotes? I guess it's not a huge problem, since it isn't bury the post or anything, but have I committed some faux pas I'm just not aware of?


r/DestructiveReaders • • May 22 '14

Short story. 1500 words. Give some critique?

0 Upvotes

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WhsvyFu-3TpLM56QAC__zTcz8lyN4gN6jwrVIAZo5RQ/edit The formatting is not the best. Read it though, it's a good one.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Jul 23 '26

Absurdist Comedy [1873] Slopmaxxing Chudcel NSFW

0 Upvotes

My critique: [2462]

WARNING! This text contains:

  • Profanity

  • Sexual references

  • Violence

Also, tell me if you liked the moral of the story, the plot, the protagonist, and the humour

From either end of the Ouroboros that is time travelled a pulse of energy that, just like all inanimate things, propels the mere idea of myself forward through that then one-dimensional realm of existence. In this black void where my memory fails me exist clouds of intense, bursting sensations of warm, all-encompassing motherly pressure and dingy, excruciating electrocutions of fear.

This nebulous dimension of half existing, half not existing could only be represented in my mind through a foggy and oversaturated image of sunny greenery. This cerebral polaroid, with its vague outlines of healthy hedges and beautiful briers, evokes the concept of gentle rays of sun on my skin and the thought of the ethereal butterflies gracefully landing on flowers.

This is the ultimate bourne that is the history of my life according to my mind. If it were a spouse, I would bury my face into her collarbone and cry on her shoulder, prolonging my stay with her as long as possible until it is to time for the inevitable departure through the clearer yet odious tutor sessions, classes, exams, workshops, internships, and math competitions that thought, in all their hubris, could capture that sense of meaning, that sense of mastery over one’s own existence that the clouds of life effortlessly harnessed.

After the exams, studying, and learning I finally reached the end of my sorrowful journey home with the aid of a door slam. I felt my head shoot up and bob around like it was a balloon tied to my shoulders. In my darkened vision I made out bored college students staring at a board covered in nightmarish calculus. My eyes made their way to a doorframe, and in it I saw that damn homeless man again, or at least we assumed he was homeless, considering he wore the same smelly sports jacket and the same crusted jeans every day, and his crazy shock of white hair and scraggly beard, and the fact that he spent hours a day mumbling to himself on the curb in front of this hall.

This was the third interruption of the semester, and at this point he was a celebrity among my college peers. My classmates were eager to see what crazy thing he’d do this time, and oh boy did he deliver.

The man walked up in front of everybody, and (noticeably drunker than usual) undid his pants and flashed his massive ding-a-ling in front of everyone. Everyone gasped, the girls averted their eyes, the boys cheered, the freaks drooled. He danced around lassoing his shit until he hopped on his back and started swinging his meat carnival style.

The poor professor, an old ass man who wasn’t all that used to human interaction, was frozen in shock for like a minute, but eventually he snapped out of it and tackled the homeless guy. The guy squirmed until he managed to knee the professor in the nuts and escape his grasp. The guy ran to the door frame but crashed into a buff security guard that just arrived. The guy's head went straight to the hard floor and there was a nasty crack. The homeless guy died from that impact, but his legacy lives on thanks to that massive wiener (No homo).

I float, crawled up in a ball. Blind, deaf, dumb, paralyzed, etherized, I existed at the total end of entropy, when nature stops being nature, when gravity loses importance and time becomes irrelevant.

However, I traced the lines against the blackness up to the imperfect reconstruction made by photos, portraits, and grainy videotapes of a fair white woman with black curls. In her womb I looked up to see her grinning in pain and agony. Her face folded in helpless terror as her tremors rocked my womb. The vibrations of the amniotic fluids were so strung it tore my lungs and shattered my ear drums.

I looked up to her in horror, realized that I was being brought into her world, and that I would experience its torturous shocks, its thunderous catastrophes, and its agonizing burdens. I yelled to her.

I looked deep into her face, and I saw that she was being pounded, screwed, filled, ripped in half. Sex, she was having sex. Sex, I have to have sex. Now. I need sex right now.

“I need sex” I said out loud.

I looked around for the woman, but it was just my mess of an apartment building. I could have gotten a bigger one with my salary, but this was the best the economy could manage. I dragged my feet through the trash like I was walking through shallow water, all while saying “I need sex” over and over again.

I stepped outside barefoot, in nothing else but my underwear and wife-beater. I ran straight to my local red-light district and ran up to the nearest pimp I saw. He was short and was in a green suit and fedora. I literally picked him up by his shirt and wiggled him around.

“Give me sex, give me cooter,” I shouted as I shook him.

“Fuck off of me nigga, the fuck?” He snapped.

Meanwhile the pimp’s pimp friends were chatting a block away and saw this haggling play out. They rushed over, grabbed my long hair, and threw me onto the street. My back landed on a broken beer bottle. They beat me to a pulp, I think I got curb stomped two or three times, but I blacked out. I woke up the next day under an ugly overcast, half dead.

The eyes. The eyes, even though the face turned blurry, were still so sharp after all these years of chipping. In the darkness I made out a hurt boy, lying on his side. His eyes were hurt and glossy from the tears.

When regarding the whole body I felt an explosive burst of hot blood heat the periphery until I was in a skin-bubbling, flesh-gnawing inferno but the eyes cast off that hellish storm and all that remained was the question “Why?”

I awoke to see my boss. He had a wide face with round eyes, a bushy, curly black beard, and olive skin. “Wow, Nate. Passed out again on the job. What have you been up to?”, he snickered with a grin.

In spite of my stoned fatigue, I felt a jolt of energy upon hearing that question. I rolled my office chair over to my computer, typed in something, hit enter, and on the opposite end of my desk rose a little Miku doll. The robotic toy started dancing and singing in Miku’s signature voice. I gave my boss a weak smile and he gave one back after turning his face to mine. I typed another thing into my computer, and Miku hit the floss and started singing in Brazilian Portuguese. This got my boss laughing. I laughed with him.

When his laughter died down, he looked into my eyes. “Nate, this is the tenth, the tenth, motherfucking time I found you like this.” I probably looked surprised at this sudden snarling. He continued. “Your team and I have been busting our asses, developing the most complex, the most state-of-the-art technology in the world, while you jerk and do this.” Like an idiot, I nodded along because I didn’t know where he was going with this. “Nate, get the hell out of my building before I fucking bludgeon you to death. You’re fucking fired.”

I waddled in a haze out my workplace’s lobby, too drugged to realize I left my shoe. Maybe this is the reason why I can’t afford bigger places to live.

Now, I lay in my bed, but it isn't my bed. I fucked around and got HIV. I thought HIV was like herpes where it gives you like these moles but no it gives you AIDS and just fucking kills you.

I was weak in the dark. It was totally silent, with no one else around and even though I was dying, I wanted to jerk off. There were no drugs or alcohol. I couldn’t even smoke, it was “against hospital rules”. The food was awfully bland too, so I just resolved to pass the time by beating my shit.

However, my whole body was too weak, I was too sick. I couldn’t get it up; I was too weak to get my arm up. It was a pathetic sight, not my limp dick, but the image of someone like me in this bed struck me deeply. This wasn’t supposed to happen to me. I was an auspicious, capable, and charming genius. I had so many scholarships, my college experience was practically free, I won so many awards my room sparkled, and everybody just loved me. Now what do I have to show for it? A hooker’s awkward experience, a coworker’s annoyance, a fucking Miku robot?

I was alone but felt like I was being laughed at. I wanted to curl up into a ball, but I was too weak, so I just laid there. I had no drugs, porn, food, or video games, so I escaped back into the only place that could warm my soul: those fond, fuzzy memories.

I thought and I thought, but I was too weak, all I saw was the black void. I stopped thinking, I stopped stressing, and I stopped feeling.

A tiny dot appeared in the center of my vision. I felt my legs walking toward it. It got bigger and appeared to be a doorframe. I walked through it and I was in a hallway. It had patternless carpet and was painted a dark orange. The hallway was cool, and dark, illuminated only by the sunrise glowing through the curtain at the end of a hallway. There was screaming, a muffled screaming coming from behind one of the other doors of this corridor. I approached the source of the screaming, the sound of my weathered teddy bear dragging on the carpet was the only other noise. I stepped up to one door, reached up to the doorknob, standing on my tiptoes, and I opened it to see two men hovering over a bed. A woman with dark curls lay on it screaming in pain.

“Push, push, you’re almost there,” One man cheered, “There it is. It’s out, sir. It’s a beautiful baby boy sir; you should be so proud”.

“Yes, but she isn’t going to make it,” The other man sulked, and started sobbing uncontrollably. The doctor tried to stifle his sobs, but cried with the man, and the two cried along with the newborn boy.

Nate waddled out of the hallway and into a bright, cool, moist backyard overflowing with vines, hedges, and grass. Golden rays landed on the boy’s eyes when he looked at the dappled canopy of leaves above him. He would have played, but now he sat. He sat in the middle of this jaw dropping scene and as the gales played with his hair, the squirrels and rabbits and chipmunks ran by, while the drops of dew flowed down the blades of grass, while the Earth travelled at thousands of miles per hour, this being of impetuous, violently rushing nature sat still and asked “why”.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Mar 22 '26

[794] I gave feedback to a story almost double the lenght of mine and I need feedback on mine

0 Upvotes

For some reason, I can't change the heading, so it's 1204 words instead of 794. I'm so sorry if this caused any inconvenience to you.

For mods, the story I gave feedback on was this one, you may have to scroll down since its recent.

“Patient 47 of the day,” I said,  staring at the brown, coffin-like box, holding a person refusing the inevitable.

“Isn’t our shift over?” Adrian said, eyes with hope, as he fidgeted with his fingers. 

“Don’t ask questions. Ever.” I said, dead serious; Adrian was new, and excuses were one of the luxuries he could afford, but for every luxury, one had to pay a price; in Adrian's case, it was me. 

“Soon you will take my place. You need to follow the rules by heart, kiddo.”

I left the room. What else could I do? The alarm rang; it was time for us to go. The guards stopped me halfway to the exit.

 “ID please; protocol 39,” said a man with a face grizzled by war. 

“Yes, sir,” I said, reaching into my lab coat and giving it to him. The scent was wrong, and a cold wind that felt warm on my skin followed. The smell of disinfectant clung to the air, mixing with the warmth of the wind. The man was checking my ID, a face I couldn’t read. 

“You can go, but come to the boss’s office tomorrow afternoon,” he said with a tight, forced grin. 

“Yes, sir,”  I walked fast, but not fast enough to draw attention, avoiding eye contact with anyone from the dimly lit streets.

I went back to my home, the same surrealness following me. New. Stubborn. Dangerously curious, Adrian always felt wrong. He asked too many questions—questions no one dared to ask. The city lights were flickering dimly, as if agreeing to my thoughts, and the hum of neon kept me awake as I walked throughout the city. 

When I reached home, no one greeted me, just the feeling of comfort and the sound of my roommate snoring. I lay down on my mattress, deep in thought. Why does he ask so many questions? Why can’t he just stay quiet like everyone else? I tried to sleep. Everything seemed off. Even my room didn’t feel safe anymore. What am I without NeuroVault? I asked myself. 

I felt a hollow emptiness creeping in, a voice that wasn’t mine whispering a shell of someone who used to matter. I tried to push it away. No, no, I’m not, I can’t be, right? I faltered; I had nothing to defend it. You are nothing without this place. The thought sliced through everything else. My own doubts mingled with it, and I couldn’t tell whose fear was whose.

I tried to sleep. The voices slowly blurred together, distorting into one. I closed my eyes, but the voices hissed louder. It wasn’t my first time with this; this had been happening all month. Every time the voices got louder and louder. The same nightmare of me losing my job was played on repeat. Every day seemed to blur into one. I didn’t even know what day it is tomorrow.

My thoughts slowly drowned the voices as I finally slept. The same nightmare I had for weeks now followed. My boss came in—the same boss who had a temperament problem, loud footsteps, and he said “Adrian violated protocol 59, and the blame will be accounted on you, from here on out, you are fired” cutting through all the other chatters, as I packed up my things and left—all the coworkers looked away from me, as if I were a grotesque being, I opened my eyes.

5:52 AM was displayed on the dimmed, blue alarm clock. I mumbled, “I’m late,” as I quickly put on my lab coat and rushed to work. My body trembled as I remembered I had to go to the office today. Will I get fired? I thought, fidgeting with my fingers, muttering Will I get fired? over and over, my steps counting 1-2-1-2 like a heartbeat I couldn’t escape.

I signed up for a local flying taxi to come in. 

“Fingers up, thumb down,” I repeated again and again, mumbling to myself, as I did the movement for a taxi to come.

Finally, a taxi came.

“How much do you charge?” I asked hurriedly, tapping my foot impatiently.

“20 dollars for every mile,” A female AI bot said.

“T-twenty dollars? Fine, get me to Neu-” 

“NeuroVault HQ selected,” The AI said before I could finish, as if it read my mind.

I got into the car as it flew through the sky. I had never been in one before; it was a luxury. 

“I’m getting fired anyway, at least let me enjoy this while it lasts,” I mumbled to myself as I looked across the windows. I saw my office in the near distance, my heart bumped and thumped all across my body, my pupils dilated as I fidgeted with my fingers, and a feeling of dread washed over me.

“Should I cancel this ride? Make my enjoyment last a little longer?” I thought, but I was too near anyway, the car slowly landed in a parking lot as my body froze and everything numbed. 

“Your ride is done, the total is 450 dollars, with a mandatory tip, it is 500 dollars” I paid for it with whatever I had in my wallet, never truly focusing on it.

“This is 900 dollars, are you sure?” said the AI bot. 

Before I said anything, my body moved on its own, and I opened and closed the door of the taxi. 
My legs walked on their own, having more courage than I ever had. I awkwardly walked and reached the boss’s room.

I opened the door. 

“Come in,” said my boss, a large man, no wrinkles in sight despite his age, jet-black hair that was almost too tidy, arms at his side, and never blinking with his emerald green eyes. 

“We need to discuss Adrian,” he said in a rehearsed voice, never truly focusing on me. He leaned over, looking more threatening. 

“Adrian violated protocol 59, and the blame will be accounted on you. From here on out, you are fired. Adrian will replace you.”

“Y-you can’t do this, it was Adrian's fault!” I screamed, but he didn’t even flinch or blink, 

“How do you think you were ever here? Do you remember yourself? You asked more questions than Adrian. What do you think happened to Ed after you asked me ‘How does this place work?’ He faced a punishment far worse than yours.” He said calmly, keeping his tone precise and undebatable.

I left the room to pack my bags, and my colleagues looked at me the same way they did in my dream. What can I do now? I mumbled to myself, hastily packing my bags and leaving, not meeting anyone's gaze.  

In this world, without a job means you have no value, even students count; it was always the norm when I was born. My parents always favoured my older brother for getting a job as a receptionist in the same company I was working at, even though he dropped out of college. 

“He did his job in society before you ever did,” My mother said with cold disappointment in his eyes. 

“He is more of a son than you ever could be!” My father said as he looked at me as if I were filth.


r/DestructiveReaders • • 19d ago

Surrealism abstract hate poem [620]

0 Upvotes

WHY ARE THE MODS LEECH MARKING ME AND Gate KEEPING WHEN I ALREADY LINKED MY CRITIQUE BEFORE AND IT IS HERE HELLO THIS IS A LINK TO ME Bashing others writing unfairly


---SUBMISSION OF NON AI GENERATED TEXT

[600]

The writer entered toward the center of the psychedelic throne room. Magnificent Taj, no walls and only lavish energy pillars holding iridescent heavens above. Under foot, thousands of kaleidoscopic fractals shimmered a gradient between dark blue and orange. The writer swallowed the lump in their throat, and nervously waited for discussion to begin.

"It's beyond punctuation errors," DestructiveReaders said. "We immediately noticed basic dialog grammar structural problems within the writing," DestructiveReaders said and down voted the submission. "The issues were pervasive and systemic within the writing, indicating a knowledge gap of the lowest fundamentals. The structure will have to get fixed before any serious feedback is concerned. Don't resubmit until you've given feedback first. Read the wiki."

"W-what?" asked the writer, heart skinning a fucking cat. The interdimensional digitalDMT entity had spoken so immediately and with such disregard it almost hadn't seemed addressed to the noob, who shouted, "I thought I was here for feedback!"

"Yeah, me when I'm mad bro." DestructiveReaders picked up another stack of digital paper and exploded it. "It's not my job to educate you on music theory—or your instrument. I'm here," it said and glanced out the vista towards an incomprehensibly complex and ornate colorful landscape of non euclidean hyperspace, "to give feedback on your music. This isn't a marketing audience beta test run, this is the band club. And this," its outrageously gorgeous and intelligent 👀🔮 👁️👽👋👋👋👋👋🖐️🖐️🖐️🐙 🐙 🐙 🐙 🐙 🖐️✋✋✋✋🖖🖖🖖🖖🖖 🔮 👀👀 lingered on the paper for 0.22 second, "it's just not professional."

The writer was stunned. "I'm sorry?"

"You heard me," DestructiveReaders added and immediately dropped 🦾 🏴‍☠️ this flex. "Also, you're a leech."

The writer felt something changing in their neuroschema and all sense of egoistic entropy collapsed into autorejective solipsism, followed by emergence into singularity and event horizon of shared consciousness. As the fractals began to take pieces and replace pieces, the writer realized this was real transcendal power, and that just like letters to form words, this power when spoken into existence like a language can change material reality. If comprehended, broadcast and perceived, the power could be mastered and controlled and predict great events or share deep narrative lores. In a panic, the noob ah writer shook from this intrinsic truth of the universe and re-entered their ego wrapped delusion.

Identity now reformed, calloused with butthurt, the noob writer shouted, "HOW DARE YOU! THIS IS MY HARD WORK AND DEDICATION TO MY ADVANCED LEVEL AND DEEP WRITING 🤪 🖍️." A wave of nausea washed their boat. "I thought this was a feedback and a critique community," they choked out. "That's what you said in your cult manifesto when I paid the fee!"

"Yeah, leaving your shoes at the temple door wasn't the fee, bro. C'mon now. Like hello? You're supposed to connect with any of the other entities, who have in turn already connected to any of the other recent chain of entities. You're supposed to share the energy up the chain, or provide energy down the chain shortly after entry. Therefor, your access to the chain will be restricted, and you will be labeled as a 🧲 📉 ."

"How dare you, because actually—"

😱 THREAD WAS LEECH MARKED: "Nah, like. This is like sitting down to a chess tournament and trying to move a pawn sideways. Just read a book. Literally go read a fucking printed book and copy the grammar rules." With that, DestructiveReaders attached a 12 hour count down timer to the post, and violently threw itself out the psychedelic Overton window. Material reality thereafter imploded, and the writer once again with it.

The end 🔚 BE KIND REWIND...


r/DestructiveReaders • • Jun 23 '19

LGBTQ+ Fiction They/Them/Their [2976]

1 Upvotes

So a week or so ago I posted a piece titled Poly & Me. It was intended to be the first chapter of the story that I am working on. It was ripped to shreds (In a good way of course). So I took the critique that I was given on that piece and reworked where my story began and started it about 18 months earlier.

Critiques I focused on:

A- Original title felt more like a memoir than a work of fiction.

I decided on Them/They/Their. I chose that title for two reasons:(though this is still considered a working title)

1- To pay homage to one of the MCs I enjoy writing. They are a non-binary DJ.

2- I decided to break my story into 3 parts:

Part 1-They

This is the introduction of my POV MC to his roommates and the other two MCs who eventually love interests of my POV MC

Part 2-Them

This part focus on the events about a month or so before the shooting that took place in my original first chapter and the actual shooting.

Part 3-Their

This part focus on the shooting affects their lives, both good and bad.

B- Too many characters

C- Pacing

D- Character Creation and world building.

About the Chapter:

This chapter is about my POV MC's move from his small hometown in Mississippi to New Orleans where you meet his two roommates, George and Scott. It covers his first day and the start of his first night in New Orleans. There is no violence or explicit content in this chapter. The is the mention of "black and white photographs of a man who is naked and in compromising positions hanging on the wall. Though there is no explicit descriptions of the man's body, the positions he is in are, and they are bondage related. For that reason I Flagged this as NSFW. other than that this piece is pretty tame.

I hope you enjoy this piece and I am looking forward to your critique.

Things that concern me:

The pronouns may still be a bit confusing, though I think I did 100 times better than I did in my original piece.

The pacing may be off in some spots, but overall I think its a vast improvement over the other piece.

The setting I know could use a little work, so any suggestions there would be appreciated.

Mod Bait:

I had to post the critique in two parts due to word count limits. here they are:

It's a matter of delivering pizza [3373]

Part 1

Part 2

Submission:

They/Them/Their [2976]


r/DestructiveReaders • • Aug 11 '17

Satire [2461] Ch. 5 - CoVfefe

1 Upvotes

r/DestructiveReaders • • Aug 24 '18

[3043] A Devil's Tongue-Drama/Fiction

1 Upvotes

A Devil's Tongue

The premise of the book is about a young man falling in love with a girl but is met with obstacles that range from crime, alcoholism, sex and drugs. A typical story with teenagers doing dumb shit with my own voice/tone.

It's only a rough draft I started about a week ago. Looking for any type of feedback. General impression, the characters, the theme, or questions ect. ect.

Does it seem too much? too little?

How's the tone, and pace? Should I dial down the vulgar language? Idk ...rip me a new one I guess.

Also, I'm sure some grammar is out of place, and I tried my best to fix some. But OH, there is some scenes that may be inappropriate! So I'm just going to put this here that all character's in this novel are fiction and said people are 18 year old seniors in HS. Thanks! and Enjoy!

Critique:https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/98u04z/718_an_assassin_enters_a_castle/e4rvciv

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/98qwuj/1002_the_thricelocked_door/e4rx1v3

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/99o7gp/1773_city_sliding/e4rlawn

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/99jj4j/2361_hoboblood_chapter_1/e4riu4

https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/99qbzo/1209_the_takicharu_terrorism_tale_start/e4rf51j


r/DestructiveReaders • • May 11 '17

Encyclopedic Narrative [958] Infiniter Jest, Chapter 1

1 Upvotes

Here it is: Infiniter Jest CH1 I would love it if you focused on readability, imagery, and clarity. I am less concerned about plot and character.

For the mods 3594


r/DestructiveReaders • • Sep 16 '25

[1200] Sensual Urban Fantasy

0 Upvotes

Writing Critique I guess: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1ni35b8/comment/nehg9f7/?context=3&utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

  • THE STORY

The dragon stepped out the back of the tavern to have a cigarette, which he lit with his own breath. Leaned against the wall's carved stone blocks, and watched the moon among the stars. Wanting to be somewhere else, Gwelf suspected. To fly off until he couldn't hear such terrible music.

She adjusted her supple breasts, shaped by the tight cut of her tight, fitted gown. There was no time like the present, she suspected, and stepped out of the shadows to present herself.

"Dragons can see in the dark," he breathed, smoke wisping from his nostrils into coiling tendrils of smoke. "You cannot trick a dragon's eyes."

She clicked along the cobblestone and stood at his side, doing her best impression of her sister. She was perhaps two feet shorter than he was, but tall enough to reach up and touch his neck, to trail the spines that ran down the middle of his back. Here she lost them, the spines, to the collar of a blue-grey dress shirt.

She bit her lip. "That can't be comfortable."

The dragon had not turned his head, but the eye watched. In his hand a pint of ale trembled, his sleeve drawn back from the scales of a thick, turquoise forearm. The black band of a gold watch. Her pale fingers played upon all of these, curiously. Exciting her heart.

Even he'd loosened his tie.

"Did you want to take me home?" she said. "Away from all this?"

He huffed. "From your own wedding reception?" Brought the cigarette to his snout and took a long drag. "Are you so tired of your man already?"

She bit her lip again, licked them, even, and peered into his pint of ale. Walked her pale fingers down his scales and ran along the rim of the glass. "I'm not having second thoughts, but I'll be his tomorrow. This is the last night I have left to share with anyone else."

It wasn't poetry, Gwelf thought, but her sister Plouppette was no poet.

"Pluppy," whispered the dragon. "Your husband is a ferret with ferret hands. Mine would crush you like so much marshmallow."

At this, Gwelf bit her lip and ran her eyes slowly up his chest to meet his gaze. "Prince Puttletart is only my fiancé until sunrise." She thirsted up at him with her face. "Take me away from all this."

He thought for a moment, then turned to look up at the wall-mounted security camera with its blinking red light.

Was it worth it, he seemed to wonder, then returned his eyes to hers, to her bitten lip, and down into her cleavage she'd prepared for him, her fingers now tugging at his belt, her arms closed tight against her pouting breasts.

"I parked my Camaro by the old oak tree," he said.

And so they went before the song stopped, barefoot down the boulevard in the moonlight. His huge displacements of garden dirt next to her very small ones. He drove them up the winding road into the hills and parked above the bluff. And for several minutes they made love. Her having climbed into his lap and unbuttoned his trousers and his shirt and pulled down her own top to present his snout with her swollen blessings.

And when he'd finished he shuddered and she climbed off, and he had another cigarette.

"That was...hardly worth betraying your ferret," I suppose. He eyed the gold watch.

She sighed out her window at the view, satisfied enough. "This wasn't about you," she said. "I'm just not ready for what comes next."

He huffed again. Flicked his cigarette and adjusted himself. Zipped his pants. "You can drop the act. I know you're not Pluppy Puttletart."

She turned and glared at him. "Neither is she until morning."

"Is this how you get your kicks? Luring men to sleep with a married woman you're not?"

"And how were you so certain I wasn't?"

"I'm a dragon."

"Playing with fire."

"I told you. You cannot fool my eyes."

She took a short breath. Had only she knew what he was playing at, had only she understood his double meaning, she could have messed with him properly. Better used the ruse. "You're terrible," she said.

"This was your game we were playing."

"Take me back to the wedding party."

"Happily," he said, and turned on the car.

"You tricked me," she said. "For bad sex."

He twisted in his seat to back the car out, then pulled onto the winding road. Gassed it. "Who tricked who? All I did was what you wanted me to."

And like a dragon did he drive, taking corners like a wild man. Like someone capable of satisfying a woman in ways he tonight did not.

Compensating, even.

And glaring at him over it wasn't working, so she turned herself in her seat and kicked at him. Kicked her bare feet into the side of his head and his arm and--

Rounding a corner too fast the car took on sudden weight or lateral force and yanked sideways. The car tipped and launched her up and over and down. Off the road they rolled until she felt herself torn from her seat into the night air where the world came spinning at her body, hitting it so hard she slid through mulch into a shallow creek.

And here she had no choice but to lift her soaking face for air. To breathe. Her neck screaming and splintering, poking at her temple. Her leg twisted wrong.

She saw the car atop a stone bridge, and the dragon hanging out of it over the water.

And on the bank a mobile phone glowed in the dark.

She crawled to her feet and staggered up the creek toward the bridge. And dropped herself on the bank in her soggy gown. Tucked her breasts and picked up the phone. The dragon's phone.

Her sister. "Pluppy?"

"Gwelf? You're with Bob?"

Gwelf touched her lip and found blood on her fingers. Spat part of a tooth, or something from the creek. Felt around her mouth with her tongue. "I was. I am. Yes."

"Please don't tell me you--"

"Cosplayed my married sister to see if he'd fuck me anyway?"

"Yes."

"No."

"Good. Where is he?"

His arm hung from his body hanging from the flipped car, such that his big hand dipped into the running water. Lifeless, maybe.

"He's...in the...fucking bathroom, whatever. Listen. I need a favor. What's that Wizard guy? Thamior?"

"Thamior, yes? He's giving Argok a lap dance."

"I need his help my face is all fucked up I was in a car accident just shut up and put him on the phone."

"You're such a shitty sister."

"Ya, and you're just a fucking perfect peach I guess, right? Stuck my toothbrush in the toilet."

"I was eight."

"What-fucking-butt-fucking-ever. Put the wizard on the phone."


r/DestructiveReaders • • Jul 04 '16

NSFW [1502] Meat NSFW

0 Upvotes

My first posted story! This one is a tad unconventional.

Meat


r/DestructiveReaders • • Jun 26 '17

[615] Real I ty

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I hope you like this new short story I wrote. Please let me know what you think! Please comment on the google doc as well if you would be kind enough to do line-by-line edits. Thanks! Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/18m716JIVEcFfy5CYXlKJRuInnwpcUthb81Uo-nDwiiw/edit?usp=sharing Proof I am not leeching: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/6jb6m1/700_tenderness/


r/DestructiveReaders • • May 03 '19

[650] University student first person narrative

0 Upvotes

First time writing in a long time, so don't expect much.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qbaE--tX2EV5ub3gCuYBrWZncOtkS-UcAivrvh-CqiY/edit?usp=sharing

To be honest I'm not entirely sure what the format of this text will end up being, but at the moment I've styled it as a first-person narrative. It's part of a larger story of a student's university experience, and this is the first part (prologue?) of the narrative.

I'll take any sort of advice, but I'd really appreciate advice about the style, tone, voice, and if possible plot (there's not much of a plot at the moment though). Feel free to tell me if I've fucked up.


r/DestructiveReaders • • Jun 18 '14

Fantasy and shit. Prologue chapter. 800 words.

0 Upvotes

Nobody I've shown this to has had anything constructive to say. I automatically assume they were trying to spare my feelings. But you guys know better, don't you?

Please ravage my anus


r/DestructiveReaders • • Sep 27 '17

[183 words] Untitled intro

0 Upvotes

Crime/Drama about a preying sociopath

183 words

Desired: Would you keep reading? Does this appeal to you and what are your overall thoughts during reading every line?

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sQnZljI0-7GHowXRw1wdOujwoSUz6HnrWD1JAVenD2w/edit


r/DestructiveReaders • • Aug 07 '14

D,: [~600 words] Shameless: an extract from something longer.

0 Upvotes

I have an interesting scar in an interesting place.

I got it last summer, one early Saturday evening.

I’d been in my bedroom, prepping myself. Smearing foundation. Pouting into scarlet lipstick. Scraping that little black brush against little blonde lashes. Judging the mirror, holding dresses of increasing revelation against my naked body. Aiming for that all-important sweet spot somewhere between prude and prostitute. But where was my fake ID? Stowed under my bed. Hidden from my Mum. I’d gone to sit on the mattress, and, with a profound absentmindedness, dropped my bare ass straight onto my hair straighteners, which branded their trademark ‘V’ right onto my rump. I mean, if they’d been a couple of inches forward and to the right… well, doesn’t bear thinking about, does it? Mum sure got a shock when she burst into her sixteen year old daughter’s bedroom to find her rolling naked on the carpet, howling, clutching at her naked behind, the sickly tinge of her burnt flesh in the air…

Mum never found my ID. And I went out that evening. Though I did choose one of the less revealing dresses.

Six months later, and I’m performing the same unnatural ritual. Shaved legs, glossy underarms, Tweezered brows. Neat pubic borders. Teal shadow muddying green eyes. Defying nature at every turn. A little black dress. I toy with the idea of not wearing tights. Then I look outside at the dusk of grey clouds that threaten snow and think better of it.

I shout for Mum as I leave the house. A simple ‘bye’. There’s no response from the other side of her door, that netherworld she seems to spend her life behind, asleep, awake but not alive.

Want to know why my Mum suffers from a depression that neither therapy nor pills have been able to cure for the last six years?

Get a load of this.

Six years ago my father – her husband – was killed when a ten-foot scaffolding pole fell from the heavens and skewered him like a köfte kebab. He’d just been walking along the street – it entered above his left clavicle, and came out through the right kidney.

And that wasn’t even the worst thing about Daddy’s death. He was killed walking along a street in Kettering. What the fuck was he doing in Kettering? He was supposed to be Wellington, the antipodean city he’d spent the second half of each month in since before I was even born. He worked in ores. His company mined ‘titanomagnetite ironsand’ in New Zealand. Would you argue? His wife never did. Yet there he was. Dead on a coroner’s slab in Kettering. I’d been sat in the morgue’s corridor, the imagined spectres of death and terminal grief wallowing around my young eyes, when I first saw them. A local woman, about Mum’s age, with her daughter about mine. Come to see her dead husband. Come to see her dead babydaddy.

My father, as it turned out, wasn’t a director at a company that mined titanomagnetite ironsand in New Zealand. He was a professional fraudster. And, in this sense, he very much mixed his professional and personal lives. He spent the first half of each month in South London with me and Mum, and the second half in Kettering with his other wife, and his other daughter. Incidentally, his other daughter – my half-sister – was ten years old when he died. We were the same age. He’d been living his double-existence since before I was even born.

In life then, my father supported his two families on a rickety scaffolding of lies and deception that bordered on the genuinely impressive – pulling God knows what kind of financial fraud to give his wives the sorts of lives that had kept them from asking too many questions. And in death, he supported them on inordinately large compensation payouts from a construction company who’d erected some rickety scaffolding.

Irony much?