I've seen this attitude amoungst programmers in general, but its true of the demoscene also. Heres how to make the demoscene hate you... In a few steps:
Step 1) Come up with some inspiration for a game. Step 2) Spend a year or two learning about computer graphics, unpaid, making no money, as a sacrifice for your inspiration. Building towards something Step 3) Realise actually you made a new cool technique amoungst your travels in building something. Step 4) Find a community of people who also built cool graphical techniques, and want to share your stuff with them.
SOMEHOW... immediately this already just makes people angry and hateful.
That's the problem. I don't get it. Is there some secret rule of society that I'm not getting? Anyhow...
Step 5) Get all sorts of lies, false-accusations at me, attitude and abuse... of "not having really made something new" and of "being someone else because I have a similar writing style to him" and of "oh no you think you will change the world and you are arrogant because you expect everyone to use your new technique".
All of that attitude and abuse before I even showed them anything.
For perspective... I DID have a few good conversations with individual members of the demo-scene. The thing is, those conversations were one-on-one. I showed them my work... they said its cool, but needs more work to be a game. Makes sense cos thats what I think too.
Here's my question...
Why should I have to put up with all this attitude? WHY? For creating something new and cool? Its not as if I'm the only one in the world who made something new and cool. Does everyone who makes new and cool stuff get shit treatment, or only people who aren't part of an existing power-structure?
Why do these assholes think I deserve it? Nothing they said made sense, so obviously their justification for why I need to accused of stuff, can't be the REAL REASON they said it. There has to be some reason behind it.
Why is it so hard just to be treated normally? Why can't people just react in a normal way? OK so I did kinda put a barrier in there first... I was asking people if they understood the emotional difficulties and hardships of being a game-developer alone, and not having a background in gaming at all... thats the barrier. Just a question if they understood that emotional hardship. And for that, I get all sorts of weird accusations at me.
How do these idiots not feel guilty for saying insane things? If there are 10000 graphics techniques, and I create 1 also, then there's 10001 graphics techniques. Does that mean I expect EVERYONE to do things my way? NO. That wouldn't even make sense. I wasn't even TELLING anything to do it my way. Or thinking of it, or hoping for it. Its some idiotic accusation they invented that I never even thought of before, and doesn't even make sense by itself. Even if I DID want others to be using it, I couldn't expect more than 1/10001 game-developers to be using it, and probably far less as it's new and specific to a specific kind of graphical effect.
And I didn't even think along those lines. So its a stupid accusation for someone who WAS thinking that way, and I wasn't even thinking that way, so its double-stupid.
Yet no one points this out and all groups up to blame me instead of pointing out how each other's accusations at me don't make sense.
...
Welcome to the demo-scene?
Or more like... "wow, what a fucking horrible place... I'll never come back".
Sad thing is... I DID have good one-on-one conversations with some people. You know... people being normal and stuff. Not going insane. Not ridiculous accusations. Helpfulness. Talking about their experiences and how to do stuff...
But good one-on-one interaction doesn't get me far, if the "group mentality" is evil and abusive.