Like many people who play this game I was very impressed to begin with, I still like the game, I don't hate it but there are so many issues that I want to share and discuss with you guys and see where it goes.
The game is unfinished - even for an MMO Release this game has no where near any content to satisfy even a casual gamer longer than a couple of weeks. I think for anyone who has played through the main missions you could easily get through the mission content within a good day or two without any stress.
Every side mission apart from the multiple part ones which I believe there is only 3 or 4 of? are usually pick up this and return here, and if done smartly you can pick these up without even killing any mobs.
I personally cleared every mission, side mission and challenges within 3 days of gaming over a weekend with an average of about 8 hours game play per day.
The instances are boring, they offer no challenge and once you've run through this game enough you soon get used to run and gun mentality with no care in the world for your own personal safety as the game is not challenging in the slightest.
The game does not punish you in any way for making mistakes, if you do get hit by a projectile or an ability usually a boss does not follow up on it and by time you could potentially get beaten down again you've already recharged shields and are not in any danger of dying.
There is maybe one boss that has some decent mechanics and that is the Motherload - hes somewhat more in the style of a boss encounter.
I'm going to list a few things so that this doesnt just seem like a wall of text, im sure plenty will enjoy it and disagree with me.
-Game is not challenging (Self explanatory really)
-No real content (Explained above)
-Ark falls are a step backwards from Rifts 'Rifts' (Rifts were just better, I can complete some of these on my own without having to kill a single mob *Scrapper Arc falls with shields you can just sprint and circle round and mobs do nothing to you, if you kill them they just respawn anyway so?)
-No RPG Elements (It tries to be Mass Effect in story mode, but has non of the RPG elements)
-Mods are infact useless (Who wants Melee dmg? Does 0.2- recoil really make a difference? no not really especially when game is dominated by shot guns and people die in two hits to most things anyway - maybe add Melee weapons and make it a real alternative)
-No Difficulty in any of the content available (Explained above, and somewhat self explanatory)
-PVP is dominated by cloaks and shotguns (Cloak has a ton of cool features around it to make it just tons better than anything else, balance was apparently not part of beta testing?)
-Currency is pointless, other than keys, I'm flooded with the other stuff (Money, yeah.. 10K for each respect and thats it? doesnt go up. Tiny % of your money for a death? hardly matters. If you game enough you get a ton of Salvage so thats useless too, keys are easy to obtain)
-No Penalty in anything you do
-Collision is quite terrible (Oh a tiny rock, my vehicle must now grind to a halt..Whats that? a wooden fence you can't smash through in a car? damn. Same obnoxious loud noise on every collision)
-Hit boxs are bugged when attaching scopes (Will happily stream this to anyone who doesnt understand, its ridiculous)
-Actual game play fixs are not being patched (They prefer to concentrate on stability for consoles and the SMALL Server issues. Why is there not a content team and a tech team doing different things? every patch is server related and nothing is being done about say.. hmm adding the missing PVP Map? Fixing the Data Recorder at the Bar? adding back the Dam Defense. These have been around for a while and are so tiny to fix.
these are just the MAIN overall gripes about the game, there are so many smaller ones to list as well?
-Map is not clear, lets put you in "Madera, Marin, Mount Tam.. but not actually mark these areas so we have to find a decent outlined map on google.
Basically this game has just stolen from every other game and not actually improved or brought anything itself new to the table, heres some examples.
Weapon System and loot -> Border lands
Mods are terrible, you could of kept with the specific weapons so classes you took actually meant something like adding perks to Sniper rifles for survivalists, even if small so you could rack them all up and somewhat specialize? as it is now if you play enough you can master every single weapon.. woop.
Map and side quests -I saw the map and thought, "Am I playing Fallout here?" Sad thing is, the map is actually quite terrible and non descriptive - a step backwards for an open world game
3rd Person FPS
Arkfalls
This is a real worry, Rift was a great game it just suffers from being too similar to WoW that it never beat it but the Rifts were fantastic. But unfortunately these Arkfalls are just terrible - Some of them are fucking tedious, skitterlings.. really? jeeze. You can do most of them on your own without having to kill a single enemy some times as well.
So tell me, what exactly has it brought to the table? There is no where near enough content, there is no end game to speak of. Its made strides backwards with a few features and improved on zero of them. The game will not last in current state longer than two months. And for people who say well - wait for the series to kick off? I would bet a good chunk of money in saying that they will release maybe one or two missions per Episode.. But thats EPISODE Missions, not main story line.
People talk about tons of DLC? Well sorry but I already feel cheated somewhat as I feel like I've paid to participate in a beta as with every game so far in recent history and I have to pay for my content again? what.. Already have micro transactions and a large down-payment for the product why sting customers who WANT to be loyal to your game with having to pay for content that SHOULD already be there
And last of all those who say "its open world, you can make your own content.. try playing the game through with only a pistol or finish every mob off in melee" - thats a load of crap, I shouldn't have to make up for the games inadequacies by limiting myself or making my own challenges because the design team was unimaginative and game lacks in real depth. The game wreaks of being unable to choose a correct path, "Do I want to be an MMO? Or do I want to be an RPGFPS?" sadly, every aspect suffers because of this issue.
And lastly..
This is by no means an MMO - I dont even think it is a game for online play either.
-Chat is pointless its crap.
-Voice chat is more of an annoyance than a tool to socialize. Why must I turn voice chat on and off again just to get it to stay off on every launch so I don't have to listen to peoples background noise or random language talking to a family member? If you have voice chat at least have some features for push to talk or leave it off by default.(nice bug there)
-No place to trade properly, Auction house? Central trading/city hub like your typical MMO's have? No thanks lets just use forums like we are back in 2002 trying to trade via posts..
-Co-Op maps require 0 team work, you could do them on your own and they would still not be a challenge. Whats the point in a healing gun when nobody actually needs to use it?
-PVP has no team play required, the small maps is a shotty/cloak fest and Shadowgrounds are just zergfest at each point, everyone is left to their own devices..
Where is the team play? Social dynamics that MMO's have? its just a big circle jerk of who can spray the most bullets into bullet sponge #1 through to #10?
So, who wants to crucify me for an honest opinion that is somewhat negative?
I will end with, I love the game, I enjoy it and I just spend my time PVP'ing, I will probably play for another week or so and see how it goes or if anything improves but I feel it will get shelved shortly there after just like most games. I don't understand why game Developers think its fair to push games out before they are even remotely the polished article.
Game Developers nowadays during meetings "How can we make as much money as possible" "We can't beat World of Warcraft so lets not even try, just get as much money as possible, even if the game dies within 6-12 months doesnt matter" "Every game does micro-transactions and DLC so lets put those in" "Lets bring in dribbling idiots to beta test so we don't actually get things fixed and ironed out"
ps. Where is Phasing? Where is at least SOME destructible terrain? why is everything you interact with the exact same?