I reckon assumptions are about to be made on my stances, and possibly my words will not even be read, but your post figuratively depicts an unflattering caricature of an opposing position, and then you do it again here, while claiming to address the cop out you are currently 2:1 on.
Someone might appear now and say "Don't you both sides this" but there are no sides, just this endless cycle of reddit weirdness.
Saying someone is "coping out" is ironically a cop out.
You realize that the meme is making fun of the "Don't like the USA/your country in everyway then leave" crowd not the "If you don't like product don't use it" crowd. There's a HUGE difference. One is a massive lifestyle change and the other can be accomplished with literally 2 button presses per app you jump off of.
Yeah like how people who voted for trump only passively supported him as they didn't show boat him or go to his rallies right?
You vote with your usage. Stop supporting companies you hate. Full stop. If you hate AI stop supporting reddit, the meta series of apps, and all of google. You won't though because like voting for trump you aren't actively supporting them right?
Where on Earth did Trump come into the argument? I’m British, for one.
If we’re applying strawman arguments, I could use your logic to argue that anyone who wears clothing made in Asia actively supports child labour. Where was your shirt made?
But I wouldn’t, because the world is a lot more nuanced than that.
I used Trump because a lot of people globally hate him in a similar level as AI. You vote for whatever British politician you don't like you are passively supporting them even if you aren't swinging a flag and screaming "VOTE FOR SHITBAGS MCGEE!!" At the top of your lungs.
Likewise you are supporting something you can easily avoid doing without costing you a fucking thing unlike with child/slave labor made items. I'm not saying ditch your Iphone cause the materials were mined by slaves or your clothes which require a massive lifestyle and or cost to avoid and change. I'm literally just saying turn off reddit and google and meta apps. Use bluesky and like Brave(i think that's the only browser that isn't the Onion which avoids AI).
Haha, I have depicted you as the fat and ugly dude and myself as the attractive looking woman (I don't know for sure so correct me if I'm wrong). I have won
Your post/comment was removed because it doesn’t clearly connect to defending AI.
Posts should relate to AI defence, AI criticism, AI law, AI art, AI tools, media bias, labour arguments, accessibility, education, automation, or anti-AI culture
Do you fact check yourself before posting? Do you care that you’re blatantly wrong? Will you admit you were wrong after I show this receipt or will you just cope like all the other antis I’ve dealt with?
I literally made my anti character as a response to how she depicted ai users. Btw, she called us “scrapists” as in *apists. At least I didn’t go to that level, but you should know people like you have caused real people real mental suffering with how you’ve treated them. All in the name of art and humanity, people like you rarely stop to think about the real humans on the other side of the screen that have been exiled from their art communities. I know because I was there to pick them up off the ground after they were thrown away like garbage.
I’ve seen beautiful creative people hurt so badly due to witch hunts and mob justice. It has to stop.
It's so sad I'll be honest I have mixed feelings when it comes to ai.
yes I think it's wrong that ai has been trained on living artists work without their consent or knowledge. But that's a problem with the company not ai itself.
I lost a job when my employer decided one person with an ai could do the job of 5 if it's analysing data. But that was an employer problem not an ai problem. (And now I've got a better paid job as a product owner for ai tools)
I think that ai art and human art are different, but not that one is better than the other.
But honestly the way some people on both sides treet each other makes me sad. We're all humans, and we're both trying too create something. Why can't we all just get along
Thanks for saying this I thought I was the only one thinking that people who are against ai often treat it like it's alive but it's not and it's not bad or evil it's just human errors
Regarding the first point, artists learned (similar to AI training) from living artists' work without consent or knowledge, is it also wrong? When a model is trained, weights are made, which is its "brain". I'm not saying it's a 1:1 copy, human brain is more sophisticated, but weights are similar in the sense that they have neurons (hence neural network/machine learning). The weights don't contain the artworks themselves, it's about pattern recognition working thanks to math formulas.
So the question is, does it really matter if a human or AI learned from something and is there a difference? Because I can't see how it does, you don't need permission or consent to learn from something and neither should AI.
The difference I would argue it's that ai is not capable of true imagination. Where a human brain is.
That said, I think it would be best if there were repositories of art designed specifically for anyone to learn from, human or ai.
In my opinion, an artist should have the right to consent or refuse their at being used to train either people or ai. But that falls a long way out of the scope of this debate.
That said, for personal use I have nothing against ai at all... And for commercial, I'll buy the art I like and not really care if it's human or ai. If it's good, it's good.
Ai music I don't like. But that's just because I get l find the ai music I've heard doesn't match my tastes rather than anything else
Correct, AI is not capable of human imagination and that's where the contradiction lies. Art created with AI: "That's AI created slop!" is what's shouted from the rooftops. As if the AI used its non-existent imagination to create something. The imagination comes from the human typing the prompt. Some people have far more imagination than others, just as with all art. That's the position many creators take... I'm assuming from the multiple posts and comments I've seen. AI cannot create without some type of human input, which requires human imagination. Art is an expression of one's imagination. Why does the tool used matter?
As far as music, straight prompted generic AI music I don't like either. If you're ever interested, whether it's good or not is a matter of opinion and depends on your tastes, but I can guarantee you haven't heard AI music like the music I create using AI as a virtual synth more or less. Not that you're gonna run to my YouTube or anywhere else to listen or watch a video (non-AI video), but in the sea of generic radio friendly songs out there created with AI, I most definitely don't fit that mold.
Don't disagree with you. And certainly the "AI SLOP" comments lack imagination. If you have a problem with the art, voice it respectfully, if your only problem is how its created, just move on.
I would be very interested in listening to your music :) I take it your youtube is the same as your username here? If so I've just listened to "Day of Wrath" and that's a banger :)
Yes, Day of Wrath is mine 😁 Thanks for listening. You can make "radio friendly" songs all day long. Some of mine are. But AI music is a "studio" filled with every instrument ever made and you can combine those instruments into new ones. It's a giant toy box. Why limit myself to one or two toys?
First, you said she’s never drawn us that way, she did.
Second, you’re pretending that he isn’t that unattractive. He is. And in the insta post that goes with it she compares us to *apists. I’d say that’s a lot worse than being portrayed as fat.
It’s ok, I didn’t expect you to admit fault or do anything but a mental backflip to justify your view. I’m used to it. But that’s also why people stop taking the debate seriously.
•
u/AutoModerator 10d ago
DefendingAI has a Discord now: https://discord.gg/MgVYjZ8RC
Pro-AI only. AI art, prompts, anti-AI watch, debate ammo, news, and general chat without anti-AI spam.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.