r/DeepSpaceNine • • Mar 09 '20

Happy International Women's Day, from a 30-something geeky dude who wants the world to be populated by women who can beat me in Scrabble (and potentially stun me with a raygun)

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/DeepSpaceNine • • Jun 24 '25

Julian as an Intersex metaphor?

1 Upvotes

I was thinking recently about how some fellow queer trekkies like to headcanon Bashir as trans because of his choice to go by Julian instead of Jules which a lot of trans fans could relate to, and of course the infamous "the only options for the baby to be moved to was either Kira or me..." line (as well as probably the fact Siddig El Fadir is the most beautiful man ever lol.)

But I was thinking about how some aspects of the genetic modification surgeries reminded me a bit of intersex genital mutilation; Julian's parents disliked how their kid was born with supposed "defects," and chose to force him to undergo surgery without his consent (nor the ability consent, since he was a kid) to "fix" him, a very common thing that still happens to intersex kids today.

I don't think that the writers specifically had intersex people on their mind when writing Julian's backstory, but looking at it now it definitely rings a lot of similar bells. I think they were just writing about children's lack of consent in general when it comes to life-altering procedures. But still, I think it's a cool queer way to think about his character. I'd love to know what y'all think about this, especially any intersex folk.

edit: lol guys i don't think his character is actually intersex/trans, i was just pointing out the way he could be read as them (see: "metaphor" in bold letters in the title). it's pride month y'all, calm down.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Feb 19 '23

Why does it keep saying ‘IRA’ at the end of every episode, this is very offensive to my Northern Irish kind😭

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/DeepSpaceNine • • Feb 05 '26

Man, that was beautiful Spoiler

23 Upvotes

Starfleet Academy new episode intentionally respected DS9, without having to try and change anything or rewrite it to leave their mark, but honoring their characters and elements in the best way they (cof, she) could. What they did bring in does add to part of the story it's one that aligns quite well with my way of seeing life, destiny and the decisions we choose to make are our own.

I like the show overall and I give them credit for respecting DS9 (certainly more than Picard season 3’s did).

Hope anyone else enjoys it as much as I did!


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Jan 29 '26

So, Academy.....

0 Upvotes

Do you think it's the writing, the lore, a mix of both? Is it just we had the best trek ever with DS9 and Kurtzman trek just isn't for us?

I'm hoping Academy is just doing first season training wheel issues, but, Academy is like third series, fourth if you include Lower Decks. DS9, if watched in order, is pretty strong out of the gate. It's not like TNG which was the first trek series since TOS and was kind of a rough first season.

I liked SNW, but I stopped watching and I don't really know why.... Same thing happened with Discovery but I hung in longer with SNW.

Are you still watching Academy or have you packed it in and rewatched DS9?


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Jan 21 '24

We have to get Nog to a hospital!

Post image
1 Upvotes

Sisko: We will as soon as we can

Quark : that's not good enough!

One of the few moments when Quark showed that he loved his nephew and he wasn't really the selfish bastard we came to know and love


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Dec 20 '23

So... Bajorans are Palestinians, right?

0 Upvotes

Just stirrin' pots.

Edit: Great discussion, guys. Loving the energy. If Trek isn't a thought-provoking, uncomfortable commentary about real life, I'd just watch Star Wars.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Jan 05 '24

The Dominion War

0 Upvotes

I know it was a novel concept to have a war so big and last so long in the Star Trek universe but it’s the reason it’s taken me so long to rewatch DS9. I have always liked how Star Trek wars were always wrapped up in two or three episodes so we could get back to better times. I could have even been ok with it lasting one season but not the better part of the entire series. I would have enjoyed more about the profits and the Pah-wraith. Maybe even more episodes about the prophecies and how they affect things. I hatted how somber the war made everyone, such as Dr. Bashir , he was such a happy fun character but the war made him so serious and dour. Cpt Sisko excepting he was the Emissary seemed to bring him joy, but the war was such a downer.

I’m no fan fic writer so I don’t have alternative stories but I sure did get sick of the war.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Feb 05 '26

Is it just me, or was Episode 5 of Starfleet Academy not a good episode of television? Spoiler

97 Upvotes

Talk about a confluence of problems in one episode. The Deep Space Nine and Sisko connection didn't feel natural. They wanted to call back to it, but had to force its relevance to SAM. The script just expects you to make narrative jumps with it without it earning them. The show continue to struggle with pacing, structure and a coherent narrative.
It's like actual rules of structure and storytelling have been abandoned for the unconstrained freedom of having long runtimes.

The episode's use of "I can live with it" just abandons any of the purpose and meaning behind the line for the sake of the reference.

SAM's immediate admiration for Jake Sisko is an example of the episode not doing the work of earning a beat in the story. The very idea that Jake didn't publish Anslem out of some sense of preserving a private connection to his father is a fundamental misunderstanding of what he and his father would feel about that. Jake at the end of Season 7 was different to The Visitor. He missed his father, but he wasn't encumbered by the loss of his father from living out his gift and passion for writing and publishing his works.
The episode doesn't say Jake lived an unhappy life (he seems to have married and been a father), but his writing shouldn't be some secret or personal thing to be shared with a select few. It was his way of making a difference

This is supposed to be a one of the best episodes of Star Trek? The episode isn't bad just because of poorly used references, there seems to be a general lack of episodic structure and thematic coherence in its presentation — a distillation of its ideas in a series of acts that build upon each other. Things are very amorphous.

I do not need references to previous works of Star Trek or to be emotionally pandered to with Cirroc Lofton appearing or including a new Dax.

References and callbacks shouldn't be a substitute for the excellent execution of inventive ideas and thought-provoking narratives that actual take us on a journey through the messages and themes being presented.

The themes and messages are ultimately simplistic.​​

Edit: I think any reference to or knowledge of whether Sisko returned (he clearly didn't return in a public way according to Academy) messes with the ambiguity of What We Leave Behind. DS9 is a closed book. Leave it alone and move on.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Jul 27 '23

Autobiography of Benjamin Sisko

Post image
1 Upvotes

It’s coming out this October with preordering with the QR CODE. Anyone else looking forward to this?!?


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Jun 28 '25

Quark as the boss of ds9

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/DeepSpaceNine • • Aug 10 '20

the bajoreans were boring to me as were anything dealing with the Prophets. anyone else felt the same?

7 Upvotes

i only liked the bajor when it involved something with the cardassians.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Feb 12 '24

I don't see two sides to this

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/DeepSpaceNine • • Aug 14 '24

S03E08 Defiant: They did it again to poor O'Brien

0 Upvotes

I am almost shaking with rage. I loved this episode, mostly. Okay I didn't like the way Kira and Dax threw themselves at Riker like sad groupies. But I liked the tension between the Cardassian High Command and the Obsidian Order, and I liked seeing Gul Dukat. My right fist itched and wanted to crack that annoying Obsidian Order Observer's jaw bone.

But I was angry at the way Riker treated O'Brien, Kira's lack of loyalty to her own Chief of Operations who'd saved her life more than once, just because a prettier man she'd only just met was in the room (and she's in a relationship with another man anyway), and, most of all, O'Brien's own lack of confidence which resulted in him meekly leaving the room like an unwanted puppy. I have no idea if there's some back story between O'Brien and the Rikers, but find it unlikely, as O'Brien thought this was Will and not Tom, and the Chief has never disrespected any Starfleet officer.

It would be nice if they had made a sequel (I don't know if they did) in which the Defiant is sent to rescue Riker and other Maquis prisoners from a Cardassian penal colony but at the last minute O'Brien tells Riker on the view screen "I think you know why you're not coming home with us", beams the other prisoners onto the bridge of the Defiant and leaves Riker on the planet to rot, then gets a big wet kiss from a Dabo girl who happens to be on the bridge (I don't find Kira or Dax attractive) and winks to the camera before the titles come up.

Yeah!


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Aug 11 '24

The Defiant

0 Upvotes

When the Defiant is introduced, it seems to be a brand-spanking new ship that’s got some kick-ass tech, needed for a trip through the wormhole to find the Dominion. Yet, not only does Starfleet not send any crew members who are trained in how to fly this special vessel, but they use people who have spent the last few years on a space station and who have no recent experience on a vessel – Dax, Kira and Bashir. And how can a Doctor operate the weapons station? To make matters worse, there’s no other crew in engineering or elsewhere.

It makes me remember the Blackadder episode Potato, where there’s this dialogue

Blackadder to Captain: I was under the impression that it was common maritime practice for a ship to have a crew.

Captain Rum: Opinion is divided on the subject.

Blackadder: Oh, really? [starting to get the picture]

Captain Rum: Yah. All the other captains say it is; I say it isn’t.

Now, when I see the Defiant, that's all I think about!


r/DeepSpaceNine • • May 28 '24

What do ds9 fans think of discovery bringing back the breen?

0 Upvotes

I really couldn't believe have bad this show is on every level. They managed to make the breen boring and generic.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Sep 01 '26

"For The Uniform" is a bizarre episode

0 Upvotes

Sisko commits a literal war crime and its treated like he's being a badass for it?

I'm on my first watch and I'm going to pretend this episode didn't happen so it doesn't ruin the character for me tbh.

edit: we live in a world where forcible displacement is an actual horrible crime that real militaries are committing, and I know it's a TV show but I'm disappointed to see a lot of people in this thread acting like it's no big deal.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Feb 04 '25

Potentially unpopular opinion, Ezri Dax is a much better character than Jadzia

221 Upvotes

I know lots of you don't like how jadzia wqs killed, which is fair it was pretty crappy, but to have a character whose whole gimmick is the past life memories, not to utilise a new life for stories that would be a waste (like if for anyone who knows it, in doctor who, regenerations were established but the doctor never regenerated, wasted potential)

Ezri is also a much imo just a better developed character, jadzia often seems kinda too perfect, she knows everything, oozes with confidence, charisma and competence, but because of this she is less of a relatable character, whereas ezri is imo far more relatable and flawed.

she was also kinda my lesbian awakening, but that's not really relavent


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Feb 05 '26

That was a bad hour of television with DS9 fan service poured on top. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Well, that was embarrassing.

I’m glad that Cirroc Lofton got a paycheck, and we got to hear Avery Brooks’s voice again. Although it’s really weird that this episode feels like a memorial to the dead. He’s not dead!

No one loved DS9, and now everyone loves DS9. As someone who has loved DS9 since it originally aired, I’m glad.

As a fellow Blerd, I’m happy that Tawny Newsome got to be self-indulgent and give Sisko love.

But Starfleet Academy is bad. Like ABC TGIF bad.

🖖🏾


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Dec 03 '23

Forced love stories

6 Upvotes

Opinion: the romance between Jadzia and Worf was forced just so we could laugh at the very idea of Worf having sex.

They had nothing in common. And after Worf almost destroyed Risa just as a jealous tantrum, any logical person would have left him.

Having a difficult childhood is no excuse for what he did. In fact I'm pretty sure he should have gotten a formal reprimand from Starfleet, at the very least.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • May 28 '24

Worf is the wet blanket of deep space nine

0 Upvotes

I'm half way through season five of deep space nine and I hate worf, never cared for him on TNG but he is a buzz kill he's no fun and I wish he wasn't added, I get it's for ratings but his anger and his worf centered episodes stop me from wanting to continue the show, worfs story went too far in TNG and to Tack it into DS9 is just worse, worf just kinda sucks if he didn't they would match him with every appropriate female character


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Sep 28 '21

I mean I know I'm only on episode 3 of season 7 but...

1 Upvotes

Ezri >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jadzia

She's way more likable than Jadzia ever was, she's not arrogant and seems way more relatable. It's a shame she wasn't Dax from the start.

She reminds me of Barclay


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Aug 29 '21

The Grand Nagus

1 Upvotes

I will probably get shit for this but does anyone else think that the Grand Nagus is one of the biggest mistakes in Star Trek history. It's so ridiculous I can't even watch the episodes with him. I've never been big on the Ferengi as it is but the Nagus... What were they thinking.


r/DeepSpaceNine • • Aug 21 '26

S4 E18: Rules of Engagement is Awful Spoiler

4 Upvotes

They did a cool thing with the crew giving testimonials with good filmography, this is the only positive aspect of the episode (shout out LeVar Burton of course and apologies for everything else i feel about the episode).

Apparently i found on wikipedia that a reviewer already called this a 2/10 and the worst episode of the season and I agree, so im sorry if im beating a dead horse but im intrigued to hear other views. The logic of the episode is completely ridiculous on every level even including the court proceedings themselves, ironic because the vulcan admiral acting as judge was there and allowing the proceedings.

  1. the premise of the crime itself is so laughable that the episode should have never happened, a civilian vessel decloaking directly in the middle of an ongoing battle in which combatants are actively cloaking and decloaking SHOULD be fired on, its unfortunate for the civilians but a captain putting themself in that position is literally asking to be shot at. This is so true that even when O’Brien or Sisko argue that Worf should have confirmed the identity of the vessel before firing it feels like the writers trying to justify this silly scenario, especially because we know there is a short window window after decloaking where enemies have no shields, if you believe Sisko in this episode then a Starfleet officer can never fire on an enemy vessel because at any time some civilian could appear in the way of your torpedos. Additionally, its so clearly a false flag that starfleet should have discovered it was a false flag before ever going to court, if Odo alone was able to discover proof, Starfleet should have had that information long before considering the scale of the diplomatic incident.

  2. The legal proceeding itself allowed both lawyers on the stand?!?! It was stated there is no extradition treaty. The Klingon lawyer admitted at the beginning that he and the court accepted the testimony and judgment of the officers involved, meaning its already accepted that his actions were acceptable in the moment. Why was there a case? At every moment of the episode you have to suspend disbelief not just about scifi stuff, but you also have to accept that this kangaroo court is rational?

I love this show but this whole episode was just too contrived and too irrational to enjoy. Anyone agree? Disagree? If you didnt feel this way how did you rationalize the silliness?