r/DeepGames • • Sep 21 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion There was no WoW-killer because there can't be a Tolkien-killer

0 Upvotes

Ok, I'm exaggerating, there are many reasons no other mmorpg truly dethroned WoW, but if we narrow it to high fantasy mmorpgs, I think there's some truth to this idea.

Yea, 'WoW-killer' is an outdated term. The popularity of mmorpgs has dwindled and the costs for even attempting to make a successful one today has skyrocketed. Still I think the question remains relevant.

We can argue Everquest lost the first battle because WoW thrived on being casual-friendly, had accessible pc requirements, mass-advertisement, etc. but that's probably not how it won a 20-year war. Circumstances helped giving WoW the throne, but something else kept it up there.

So here's my (maybe controversial) take: WoW remained the top dog because it excels at worldbuilding. Hold on, not the lore. Worldbuilding.

I recently listened to a talk from Robert Kurvitz (Disco Elysium) about worldbuilding, where he advises writers in all seriousness to give up on high fantasy. The reason being that "high fantasy was already done as well as it is possible to do by this guy called Tolkien." And Forgotten Realms and Warhammer translated it as best as possible to a DnD and wargame setting. So, he argues, you can try to make something more fun and outdo these (many great writers have made interesting high fantasy worlds), but he suggests you don't try.

I'm basically stealing and extending Kurvitz' argument to the realm of mmorpgs: it's not impossible to outdo WoW's fantasy worldbuilding, but it copied Tolkien's homework so well, it's better to try something else.

There are many ways to interpret and distinguish "lore" from "worldbuilding", so here's my view:
-lore is about the explicit encyclopedic background, all the facts/information of a world (the stories/histories, myths and events which explain why things are the way they are).
-worldbuilding, at its core, is about the implicit experience of a world, how the world feels: the mood, texture, tone or lived atmosphere
(some might flip these definitions, but the content of the distinction is more important than the terms)

Kurvitz puts a strong emphasis on the names of places because they're not just pieces of information, they carry a tone that shapes the feel of a place before you know anything about the lore.

WoW obviously has mountains of distinct lore. Its debt to Tolkien is not in the actual story content of TBC, Lich King, etc. It's in how Azeroth feels, its atmosphere, ambient sound, the 'vibes' - all the aspects through which you breathe the world in without reading a single quest. I believe WoW captured the spirit of Tolkien there better than any other fantasy mmo. Even if you never read/watched Tolkien, once you do, you recognize its emotional origin.

Anyone who wasn't turned off by WoW's cartoony style will remember their first time walking through Azeroth. The dark whimsy of Teldrassil, the way the gates of Ironforge evoke something like Erebor, the scorching sands of the Barrens. You could ignore all the lore, the zones still absorb you. How a place feels is more than the visuals: it's all the implicit background to your experience. I think that's more than nostalgia (WoW wasn't even my first mmorpg).

I'd argue EQ tried to immerse you more through danger and harsh mechanics than by building an almost Ghibli-like sense of whimsical wonder and atmosphere. That vibe deeply echoes Tolkien's sentimental "comfort fantasy" (which fantasy authors like Moorcock actually criticized him for). Ironically, WoW might've captured this spirit better than even LOTRO.

You can copy mechanics, but it's really hard to recreate the feeling of a place. The Final Fantasy vibe and focus is so distinct, that's part of its own success formula (not to mention everyone is the Warrior of Light with the same companions, making it more like experiencing a story together than participating in a world with others).

tl;dr: WoW's dominance relies on having distilled Tolkien’s worldbuilding into a playable atmosphere better than other (high fantasy) rivals


r/DeepGames • • Oct 22 '25

šŸ“° News / Articles / Blog Silent Hill f examines the societal pressures on a girl in 1960s Japan

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
49 Upvotes

I always enjoy Gene Park's reviews, he generally brings a rich interpretive lens. This time he discussed the game's meaning with a therapist, who interprets it through the psychoanalytic concept of 'disavowal'. I have yet to play, but I'm definitely intrigued!

Some noteworthy quotes if you can't access the article:
"To read a Silent Hill story literally is to miss the point (...). Silent Hill f traces the invisible pressures and fears that shape a young woman’s life"
"'You can see that Hinako has to disavow aspects of herself to fit this idea of womanhood.' In Lacanian psychoanalytic theory, [therapist] Quiles said, the imagined self struggles against social order, among other factors. 'The self is an interplay of those things. But Hinako is refusing to accept many of these things.'"
"Through gameplay and story, it externalizes the labor of selfhood, how each encounter, each item picked up or left behind, is another negotiation of identity, another refusal to surrender to the script written for her. Here, true horror isn’t in the fog, the blood or the monsters, but the shedding and rebuilding of the self until you no longer recognize who remains."


r/DeepGames • • Dec 12 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion On "Games for Impact": ā€œIt's good that it's there, but it's also, in a way, kind of insulting. Because giving a special award for a game for actually meaning something or having some human content... we should be aspiring for that in every category." (Oli Welsh, Senior Editor, Polygon)

19 Upvotes

There's been some discussion about this award in dev and critic circles which I thought I'd share. The category is closest to what this community is all about and yet it feels ambivalent. It's somewhat similar to the 'world music' label: something we use to just shove all 'social issues' into. It's a double-edged sword as, on the one hand, it's reductive (they might also deserve praise for innovative design, art, etc.) and on the other hand it makes it look like mainstream categories shouldn't strive for meaningful art. Granted, Expedition 33 does deserve praise in that regard.

There's no easy solution I think, but it does reveal a general attitude towards thought-provoking games.


r/DeepGames • • Oct 03 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion PlayStation's "monotony" doesn’t come from exploring grief or revenge, it's the AAA Action-Game structure

151 Upvotes

So I read Simon Cardy’s very controversial article on IGN. It received a lot of criticism (and rightfully so). I also have problems with it, but I think it can serve as a good starting point for a deeper discussion.

The tl;dr of his article is that he complains every PS exclusive tells the ā€œsame storyā€ centred on grief and revenge. That’s a terrible thesis. But let’s try to dig deeper: the idea that there is some monotony could be true, but it’s not because these games tell the same story.

First, let’s address his shitty title which conflates ā€œsame storyā€ with ā€œsame themes, tone and narrative structure.ā€ It’s like saying every novel about love tells the same story. TLOU2 and GoW tell very different stories, but they share certain themes. But to go further: you can’t (or shouldn’t) actually criticize works for exploring universal themes. Grief is basically baked into almost all narrative structures (whether it’s the Hero’s Journey, Kurt Vonnegut’s story shapes, Dan Harmon’s story circle, Fichtean curve etc.). I doubt Ancient Greeks went ā€œBy Zeus, not another Greek Tragedy!ā€ Even Guillermo del Torro recently claimed all storytelling can be reduced to 2 stories on Kojima’s Anniversary stream. The issue is never the theme itself, but the way it’s explored: not the what but the how.

Second, building on the previous point, the real problem is an overreliance on exploring themes like grief through a high-budget cinematic adventure with realistic and violent combat. The gameplay loop and realism dictate the narrative structure. If your primary form of player interaction is realistic violence, you inevitably have to justify that violence through emotions like grief, anger and revenge. It creates a structural bias toward specific emotional arcs. Again, grief as a theme isn’t the problem here, it’s ā€œgrief as justification for violenceā€; it’s a specific shade of grief that is constantly recycled because it fuels conflict and action gameplay.

A quick look at Spiritfarer, Valiant Hearts, Gris and even Death Stranding shows that grief is not binary: it’s a vast spectrum with so many different variations that can be explored from different angles. Some might recall Kojima’s ā€œstick vs ropeā€ metaphor, where he argued ā€œmost of your tools in action games are sticks. You punch or you shoot or you kick. The communication is always through these ā€˜sticks.’ In [Death Stranding], I want people to be connected not through sticks, but through what would be the equivalent of ropes.ā€ My point being: the only way to explore different kinds of grief is to explore different kinds of gameplay, ones that don’t rely as much on the stick and ultrarealism. Realistic sticks will always limit or determine emotional arcs.

Now you can still have combat and explore grief in different ways. I think the Yakuza series is a great example, because it shows how cinematic cut-scene adventures with violence can still have an incredibly wide emotional palette, going from slapstick comedy to tragedy and every type of drama inbetween. By detaching combat from narrative seriousness (basically treating fighting like a goofy minigame), it’s free to explore grief, honor, love and so many other themes all at once, without collapsing into the same somber tone or sticking to a hyper specific shade of grief and revenge.

Tl;dr the solution to PS monotony (if we need one) isn’t to ban themes like grief or revenge. PS isn't obsessed with themes, but there’s an overreliance on realistic, cinematic, violence-driven formats which funnels many AAA stories into the same shade of ā€˜grief as fuel for violence’, expressed through similar emotional arcs. The way out is to diversify gameplay itself, allowing to explore themes from other angles.


r/DeepGames • • Oct 01 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion The best horror games are actually terror games

46 Upvotes

The term horror basically swallowed ā€˜terror’ in pop culture, but I think it’s worth popularizing the philosophical distinction between the two. At least, I’ve found it pretty useful to get to the root of why some of the top scary games are so terrifying. It also just makes it easier for me (and maybe others) to point to the type of horror games I want to see more of by simply saying ā€˜I want more terror games.’ So here’s how I break down the distinction:

Horror = show don’t tell. The source of fear is visible (external) or you can manage it somehow (with a fight or flight response). There are actual monsters, ghosts, demons, killers etc. which are disturbing because they break neat categories like human/animal or living/dead. Emotionally, horror is all about shock or revulsion at what’s shown. Western horror heavily leans this way in general (with slashers, body horror, gore, violence and jump scares).

Terror = tell don’t show. The source of fear can’t be confronted, only endured. You never really know what you’re up against and it often has an internal aspect (mental states like madness, unreliable perception/not knowing what’s ā€˜real’ or situations beyond human comprehension). It plays with other thresholds like known/unknown, self/world, conscious/unconscious or life/death (the latter is no longer the fear of some zombie, but more like the actual experience of dying or limbo-states). Ā Emotionally, terror is all about the atmosphere/mood, suspense, uncertainty, anticipation, dread. Japanese horror often leans more toward this side, but also cosmic horror and psychological horror (maybe these should be renamed :D).

Another way to put it is to say that terror keeps you at the edge of the thresholds I mentioned, while horror pushes you over the edge and shows you the result. In horror you’re often the observer of something shocking (like a mad creature), whereas in terror you might agonize over being in the process of becoming one yourself.

Of course, they don’t have to be mutually exclusive: terror usually precedes the horror that follows. However, when they're put together, terror tends to be a mere tool to build suspense for the shock. The moment terror slips into horror is the exact moment when the spell breaks (for me at least). I’m no longer powerless, suspended in dread, now I can actually act. And even if you fail to kill or hide from something and die, you can try again. At that point whatever brought you fear sheds most of its scary features. You’ve done the hard part already: confrontation.

Building on this we could say 'terror' can operate on two levels:

  1. suspenseful dread / anticipatory terror: a threat which precedes the moment of shock. It's still tied to a possible object of fear (monster, zombie) and resolves once confrontation happens (turning to horror). The fear becomes focused on a visible object.

  2. existential dread / ontological terror: the threat isn't directly tied to any object. The relation to yourself or the world itself breaks down. You're at the edge of sanity, death or of reality where meaning itself dissolves. You're suspended in dread without a moment of shock that can 'resolve' the terror into horror.

So I believe the true design challenge would be to make a pure terror game (number 2): never actually crossing the threshold into the shock of horror, yet still somehow keep you engaged. The question is, if you can’t fight or hide from this terror, if there’s nothing to directly confront, what gameplay remains possible? (I can picture something like the experience of going through the mind-shattering Warp in Warhammer 40k?)

If there’s one game designer that is the absolute master at exploring this, it’s probably Kojima. P.T. (and OD: Knock most likely when it comes out) is all about capturing terror and I think that’s why it always tops so many ā€˜scariest games’ lists, despite being just a demo. I’d say Darkwood and SOMA also excel at terror, but maybe you guys have better examples.

On the flip side, I’ve seen criticism of Silent Hill f for its parry mechanic, because it can make it feel more like an action game with horror elements. I wouldn’t outright say combat kills horror, but with this terminology at our disposal now, we could definitely argue combat eliminates terror. Hence, it evokes different emotions.


r/DeepGames • • Oct 12 '25

šŸ“° News / Articles / Blog Players Want Deeper RPGs, Says The Outer Worlds 2 Director

Thumbnail
wccftech.com
14 Upvotes

The Director (Brandon Adler) defines depth mechanically here: more interaction, more agency, choices, options. I think more possibilities can be great, but it doesn't automatically imply more meaningful. The overwhelming success of RPGs like Expedition 33 suggests expressive depth is more important than mechanical depth. Thoughts?


r/DeepGames • • Oct 09 '26

šŸŽ® Recommendation This cat needs a name… but remember, this is a horror game.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I’m working on a co-op psychological horror game called The Infected Soul, and somehow we ended up with this little guy in the middle of all the creepy stuff.

One of the game’s main mechanics is body swapping. Using neural chips, you can transfer your consciousness into different creatures and bodies, each with their own abilities. And yes, the cat is one of them, so at some point you might actually end up playing as him.

The problem is… he still doesn’t have a name.

What should we call him? Cute, creepy, weird, sci-fi anything works. Just remember, this is still a horror game, so maybe he’s not quite as innocent as he looks. šŸ‘€

If you’re curious about the game, The Infected Soul is on Steam, and wishlists help us a lot.

The Infected Soul – Steam Page


r/DeepGames • • Oct 08 '26

✨ Dev Showcase AXIOMA: exploring science through cards, combos and play (developer showcase)

0 Upvotes

I'm Samuel, a teacher and the creator of AXIOMA, not an independent reviewer. AXIOMA is a science-themed roguelike deckbuilder: combine physics, chemistry and mathematics cards into formulas and molecules, then arrange Jokers to affect your score.

When does an educational theme become meaningful play rather than a lesson with points? The game invites curiosity; it does not replace a class or guarantee learning.

AXIOMA is now available on Steam, with English interface text: https://store.steampowered.com/app/5308770/AXIOMA/?l=english

The screenshot shows the English shop interface of the Steam version. AI assisted prepared illustrations, portraits, textures, card art, text, translations and this post; no live AI generation during play.


r/DeepGames • • Oct 06 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion Is combat intrinsically opposed to horror?

29 Upvotes

So for the longest time in my life, I've always been scared to death of most horror games. Even games adjacent to horror, I've had a tough time playing. The only way I'd ever engage with with horror in gaming was by watching other people play them online and I was always so fascinated by how people managed to get through so many horror games without too much trouble.

As of late, now that I'm a bit older, I've been going on kind of a horror game spree and have decided to finally face my fears and play some of the best horror games out there. I've managed to catch up on some amazing videogames that until now I've written off simply because I was too scared.

To my surprise, when I actually started playing most of these horror games, I found out my fears were mostly in my head. That most horror games, even the ones that are commonly labelled as the "scariest" games out there, didn't actually scare me that much. And I was wondering why this is.

It's when I began to realise that my fears don't have much to do with the content of the horror game or the subject matter (though those things can certainly affect how scared I am), but rather to do with how much combat is built into the experience.

Without fail, almost all horror games that expect me to fight or defend myself in some way, shape or form with relative ease lose their horror effect almost immediately. The best example of this in my opinion is Resident Evil 7. The opening hours of the game are, in my opinion, some of the scariest bits horror gaming one can ever experience. Being chased around by Mia or Jack Baker for the first time is absolutely terrifying. However, once I began to realise that the monsters I face can be killed or fended off with my ordinary weapons, the game ceased to be a horror game, and became more of an action game. By the second half of Resident Evil 7, I felt like a monster slayer, rather than a helpless victim of a bunch of psychotic monsters, which is what Ethan is presented to be.

Even games that aren't combat heavy suffer from this issue. Silent Hill 2 Remake, one the most critically acclaimed horror games of all time, lost its edge for me once I understood that for the rest of the game, every single enemy that the game threw at me was killable with standard weaponry and ammunition.

Surprisingly, I find that the games I've felt the most anxiety, stress, danger and helplessness in are games that aren't even primarily horror games. It's games where it's very easy to mess up and lose that I feel the most scared of.

Point in case, in my opinion, Bloodborne had routinely been a constant source of dread and anxiety when I first played it. Even though HEAVILY focused on combat, I found that I was still heavily affected by its horror elements, its imagery, its story, its atmosphere. It is very easy to slip up and make fatal mistakes and die in Bloodborne, the combat is by no means a cakewalk and in turn, I always felt hyper-alert and on my toes for its entirety. I felt paranoid because I never knew what could potentially kill me next, it is so easy to be killed that I constantly felt in danger despite having the means to kill anything that came my way. And I think these constant feelings of danger, paranoia and anxiety introduced by the gameplay directly opened me up to be even more affected by the other non-gameplay related horror elements of the game: story, atmosphere, music, sound design, etc.

So I suppose my question is this: does combat necessarily detract from the horror element in videogames? Or is it just that most horror games fail to implement combat in a way that actually accentuates the danger the player should feel and instead empower the player when they should instead feel helpless?


r/DeepGames • • Sep 11 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion What makes a game "deep"?

6 Upvotes

I like games with depth. Not just lore or mechanical depth, but something more intangible. I’m probably not the only one who feels that way, so let’s try to pin down what that kind of ā€œdeep gameā€ actually is. I'd say there are three main ways we tend to talk about "depth" in games, so let's make these explicit:

  • Mechanical depth: how many layers of mastery/strategic possibilities a game offers (ex: Balatro, fighting games).

  • Narrative/lore depth: how much background/world details exist beyond the surface story (ex: Destiny, WoW).

  • Expressive/artistic depth: how much the game invites philosophical reflection, articulates experiences or opens layers of meaning/interpretations about being human and/or their relation to the world (ex: Outer Wilds, Disco Elysium, Gris, etc.).

These are all valid ways of talking about depth, but this community is focused on exploring the expressive/artistic dimension: the kind of depth that stays with you long after playing, because it changed how you see yourself or the world.

Before you jump in with ā€œwell, that’s 100% subjective/just your opinion, manā€, hear me out. We need a basic philosophical premise to ditch that relativism (please bear with me):

Meaning is relational. There’s no fixed meaning sitting inside an object by itself, but it’s not made up out of thin air by an individual either. Meaning is created in the interaction between the player and the game.

So when you look at a wall, you might see it as an obstacle. You assign that meaning, but the wall also invites this interpretation and excludes others. It doesn’t invite you to interpret it as ā€œfreedomā€ (unless you’re being very creative..).

In the same way, the meaning of a game isn’t contained in its rules/mechanics, story or in the intentions of the devs, but it’s not just whatever the player happens to project arbitrarily ā€˜inside their head’ either. Interpretations are shaped by what the game expresses and we discover the game’s meaning through play.

If we can agree on that, two things follow:

  1. all games are expressive: they all mean something.

  2. depth is about richness: a deep game is one that supports richer interpretations/layers of meaning.

Let’s start with the first: all games express something. They can all be interpreted. Even Pac-Man has been taken as a metaphor for consumerism (since all he does is eat until he dies and consumes himself). Mario took the ā€˜knight saving the princess from a tyrant’ trope and turned the hero into an everyday blue-collar worker. Tetris uses our human desire for order while constraining our freedom. You’re at the mercy of the blocks they give you ā€˜from above’. Combine that with the fact that it was made by a Soviet engineer with a Russian folk theme song and you get brilliant interpretations like the song ā€œI am the man who arranges the blocksā€.

Beyond the dev’s intentions, those games inspire such interpretations. If you want to play devil’s advocate, you could argue there is some sense of depth there already. But these games don’t really sustain those interpretations through play itself. We could call them "thinly" expressive, since we're mostly just extracting metaphors or projecting meaning onto them after we have put the game down. There's no real dialogue between the 'author(s)' (devs), their work, and the player.

That brings us to the second point. Yes, all games express something, but some express more "thickly" than others. Depth is a spectrum, with some games offering a narrow range of meaning and others opening up multiple layers. The latter are those you can discuss for hours, years after release (Disco Elysium probably being the prime example). They’re not just interpretable, but actively sustain some interpretations through their design and exclude others, shaping your experience as you play. They actively develop, deepen and complicate their themes. We can also distinguish them from ā€œserious gamesā€, which are just didactic tools, giving you a moral lesson or piece of knowledge instead of exploring questions that don't have simple answers.

Games aren’t deep because a designer wrote a clever message into it, but because playing the game makes you look at yourself or the world in a new way or it articulates something you have felt/implicitly understood, but couldn’t express. That doesn’t necessarily require story/dialogue: Limbo or Gris can still be ā€˜deep’, because they manage to capture a mood/feeling/experience and turn that into a work of art.

TL;DR
A game can be deep in different ways (mechanical, narrative/lore, expressive/artistic). Here we’re especially interested in expressive/artistic depth. Generally these kind of deep games tend to:

  1. Express something beyond pure entertainment.

  2. Explore questions which encourage further reflection, instead of handing you simple answers.

  3. Sustain certain interpretation through play itself (not empty containers on which meaning can be projected).

*The goal of this community isn't to gatekeep what is deep and what isn't, but to open a discussion and create a space where we can discover and discuss the expressive/artistic depth of games.


r/DeepGames • • Oct 16 '25

šŸ“° News / Articles / Blog Theater and gaming have a strong connection, according to game writer Anna C. Webster

Thumbnail
typebarmagazine.com
19 Upvotes

Some of the connections she makes could also apply to other mediums, but I think she's right that theater and games are close siblings. I'd say her strongest point is how they both seem to be 'inherently absurd'. Mediums like film really try to maintain continuity and realism (unless it's deliberately surrealist or animated, like a Lynch movie or Everything Everywhere All at Once). It can feel more jarring when that's not the case. Whereas in theater and games, the style of the medium is inherently playful and self-aware. You can have some intense dramatic moment in a game and then go fishing or use a potion. Similarly, in theater, there's nothing unusual about an actor addressing the audience or using a chair as a horse, while still evoking serious emotions. They really allow for these rapid tone changes. It kind of reframes the whole 'ludonarrative dissonance' debate too, because mechanics and story don't have to match perfectly in this playful space where absurdity is accepted. It's a feature, not a bug!


r/DeepGames • • Sep 13 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion Beyond Disco-likes: where do we go from here?

17 Upvotes

It's almost like asking what the next innovation in some music genre will be. Who knows, right? That's for the artists to discover. But let's try to peek behind the curtain. We can probably agree the next step isn't creating bigger worlds and better graphics, but finding new ways to explore the human condition. So where lies the intersection between what we wish to see next and what the next iteration of narrative cRPGs could be?

I believe Disco created a blueprint for translating the depth of great literature and its multilayered characters into gaming in a compelling way. It made us inhabit a character rather than just follow a story. Its narrative system is the perfect foundation upon which any studio striving for literary greatness can build. It elevated both cRPGs and "visual novels" to perhaps their highest potential.

In keeping with one of Disco's themes: let's look to the future. If we set aside all its content (like the writing excellence) and focus only on the form/structure, I think we're left with two main design pillars:

  1. Thought cabinet

  2. Dialogue which brings the depth of the inner life to the forefront (all the different ways of relating to yourself and the world around you)

Although the first is basically 'just' a skill tree, the way it affects the second is so innovate that it might have to become a core design element of any game striving for complex multi-layered characters. The same goes for the second. These two elements are so iconic that when other games borrow them it instantly feels like a ripoff. So the real question might be: are there ways to take these two systems while still feeling fresh? Can they be incorporated while innovating elsewhere?

The best candidate to study might (tragically) be the cancelled sequel "Locust City". Story/content aside, it tried to innovate on form by introducing two protagonists with a dual thought cabinet, each directly influencing the other's psyche and their relation to the outside. Skills and objects were going to be unique to these characters and reflect their inner life. For Cuno, his box of locusts was going to be an extension of his mind. For Harry, it was mostly his tie and for Kim Kitsuragi, his notebook.

I think this is where infinite innovation remains possible: any new mechanics will have to embody the character and their way of being. The uniqueness of their internal landscape will determine the uniqueness of the mechanics. So to go beyond Disco devs will have to: 1) develop a character which has a deeply original way of perceiving the world, 2) translate that subjectivity into mechanics (externalize inner life by developing ways that embody how they feel/think/act), 3 turn that into a gameplay loop which affects decisions.

I know this is still pretty abstract, so if we build on this, what would you want to see more specifically?


r/DeepGames • • Jun 20 '26

✨ Dev Showcase A philosophical colouring book??

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I wanted to hear your opinion on a project I've been working on. It's a colouring book that explores philosophy through creative puzzle-solving, Toy Worlds Atlas.

This particular puzzle asks players to mix existentials — fundamental states of human being — to create a warm colour palette.

It took several iterations to make the gameplay intuitive and engaging, even for players who may not be interested in its philosophical content. At the same time, more curious players may discover a peculiar perspective on existentials and the ways they interact.

There’re different sets of such proposed by philosophers: Plessner’s, Sartr’s, Fink’s, and others’. This puzzle adapts Heidegger’s set, as it includes human conditions that are not usually seen as existential, and many readers find his approach thought-provoking.

Do you think philosophy is translatable into a game format?
Even further, is it possible to make a philosophical colouring book?


r/DeepGames • • Dec 22 '25

šŸ“° News / Articles / Blog What I like about Saltsea Chronicles (Kaile Hultner) - "The entire game is a meditation on how we might navigate difficulties in our lives, individually and collectively"

Thumbnail
noescapevg.com
2 Upvotes

Hultner digs into this point and click narrative adventure, which "takes on certain aesthetics of coziness but doesn’t once shy away from difficult subjects, like betrayal or death."

"For a game that is played almost exclusively in conversations, I think my favorite thing about Saltsea is that it is just so goddamn rich. The music, the art, transitions between different times of day, the subtleties in how characters respond to situations with a given set of answers, everything feels so well-considered and dense while never putting me in a spot where I felt detached from the situation at hand."


r/DeepGames • • Nov 23 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion Most thought-provoking and impactful game nominees in 2025 - Any game you'd add? And which would you vote for?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I gathered the categories which resonate most with this sub. Not all these labels fit perfectly. For example, the "pro-social meaning or message" part feels a bit too narrow, since it excludes games like Expedition 33 and Silent hill f, which are thought-provoking in a less didactic sense. Still, I think these are nice categories for discovering unfamiliar reflective and thematically rich games.

Picture 1: The Game Awards (Dec 11)
Picture 2/3: Indie Game Awards (Dec 18)
Picture 4: Independent Games Festival (happened in March)

I’m leaving out BAFTA, GDCA, and DICE for now since those run in Feb-April.

Would love to hear which games you think are missing and which you'd vote for! (not just a 'good' game but a thought-provoking one). Goodnight Universe released a week or so ago, so I expect that one will appear in the next few events.


r/DeepGames • • Jul 09 '26

✨ Dev Showcase So I Said Yes

Thumbnail
candevor.itch.io
0 Upvotes

A game about the everyday life of ordinary people.


r/DeepGames • • Mar 18 '26

šŸ’¬ Discussion Would you play a survival horror game about personal growth?

4 Upvotes

Hey, quick question - trying to check an idea.

We’re working on a third-person survival horror game, and the core ideas areĀ psychological growthĀ andĀ personal responsibility for own fate. The game takes place in a distorted version of early 19th-century Moscow mixed with a weird neon-rave aesthetics.
You play as a girl moving through her own subconscious, meeting parts of her personality and dealing with fears that show up as monsters.

Also, one core mechanic:
Magic (weapon) costs your health

The idea is that you only have a small set of spells (around 4 total), but you can also use potions that temporarily modify your spells or your health bar. Spells haveĀ 2 types of usage: combat and platforming.

I’m trying to understand if this even sounds interesting, so I’d really appreciate honest opinions:

  1. Does the idea of a ā€œpsychological growthā€ horror game sound interesting at all?

  2. How do you feel about this setting (19th century + neon-rave mix)?

  3. Does ā€œmagic = healthā€ sound like a good or annoying mechanic?

If you're interested in more details and wouldn’t mind taking a short survey, just let me know in the comments - I`ll DM you.

Feel free to be brutally honest - workin` on gray box and still figuring things out. Thanks!


r/DeepGames • • May 28 '26

✨ Dev Showcase Which one would you click on Steam?

Post image
28 Upvotes

I’m currently working on the capsule art for my coop horror gameĀ The Infected Soul.

The game is about a neural implant that distorts reality… you can’t trust what you see.

Which one draws you in the most?

If it interests you, you can add it to your Steam wishlist — it would really help me a lot šŸ™

The Infected Soul – Steam Page


r/DeepGames • • Dec 16 '25

šŸ“° News / Articles / Blog Thematic expression in game design (by game dev Bruno Dias)

Thumbnail azhdarchid.com
5 Upvotes

Bruno Dias dives into the fascinating history of "thematic expressionism" as a game design model. He distinguishes 3 design approaches:

  1. mechanical formalism = designing a game around a core mechanic

  2. market structuralism = designing to fit a market niche, which we call 'genres' and includes unique selling points

  3. thematic expressionism = designing mechanics around narrative/themes

"You can think of a core mechanic as a central pillar that the entire game hangs from. You can think of a genre design as using this skeleton of connected mechanics as a supporting structure; there's no longer a singular core, but rather a mechanical identity that has a sort of expected, perhaps standard shape that the game drapes over.

In this third model of design – let's call it thematic expressionism – mechanics aren't treated as structural members at all. They're treated like actors in a play or paints on a canvas; they're applied towards narrative or thematic aims, and they enter and leave the stage as required. There's no expectation that a mechanic "develops" or that it's a "deep" version of that mechanic."

"When we think about using mechanics as tools to achieve thematic, experiential, or textural aims, what do we gain? What becomes possible that was impossible previously? What do we have to change about our processes or our practice to be able to think that way? If we did adapt to that way of thinking and working, what games could we make that previously seemed improbable?"

This touches on our discussion about Game Genre Taxonomy, so I think you'll like this u/Zestyclose_Fun_4238 and u/hammertrackz


r/DeepGames • • Dec 21 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion Developer impact through history.

9 Upvotes

I have been thinking about the different individuals and teams that have shaped the medium as time has gone on. I’m curious who you guys think is the most impactful developer/director/general creative/whatever have you we’ve seen in recent years, as well as just in the whole context of the medium. Would you draw a distinction between an individual and their team (if they have one)? Why or why not? I’m sure it varies a lot based on context and what not but I’d love to hear of figures you think are responsible for the way games are now, have been and what they can be.


r/DeepGames • • Nov 14 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion The evolution of death's meaning in games. What's your favorite 'death-themed' game?

9 Upvotes

Death in games has traditionally been a pretty straightforward restart mechanic: you die, you try again. The meaning behind this functional logic (death = restart) translates to death = a mistake or punishment. You lose a life/pay a penalty until you hit Game Over. It's the logic from the arcade era, where more punishment = more death = more money.

Eventually, some devs started intentionally shifting the meaning of death from 'punishment' to 'education'. Rogue is the OG example. Death here deliberately meant 'knowledge': a learning device to understand the deadly environment and enemy patterns. You literally live and learn. Or die trying.

Miyazaki later really molded 'death as education' into an artistic design philosophy. He explicitly asked himself: "If death is to be more than a mark of failure, how do I give it meaning?" For him, death became a form of storytelling, world-building, a meaningful event. His "Prepare to Die" philosophy meant death shouldn't just end the experience, but enrich it through gameplay, art and narrative. This echoes existentialist philosophy, where death isn't just an end point opposed to life, but a horizon which gives shape to life (or in this case, the game).

Around the same time, other games started exploring death as a central existential theme and design principle rather than as a punishing restart mechanic. Devs began modeling the real experience of death: its weight/permanence, inevitability and the experience of loss. We could call these "grief games", "mourning games" or "death-positive games".

By changing the level of intimacy between death and the player, devs highlight different perspectives on death:

  1. the death of your own character: designed to confront you with your own mortality, contemplating and experiencing its inevitability. (e.g. The Stillness of the Wind)

  2. the death of someone close to the character: designed to evoke grief, experiencing what it's like to lose a friend, child, lover, parent, etc. (e.g. That Dragon, Cancer; Brothers: a tale of two sons)

  3. the death of a stranger: designed to confront you with death as a universal phenomenon, something intertwined with everyday life. (e.g. A Mortician's Tale)

Devs also started experimenting with where they place the 'moment of death' in the game, which further emphasizes different aspects. If the moment happens before the game actually starts, generally the whole experience becomes about processing the past and moving forward (often involving a 'ferryman' figure like in Spiritfarer). If the death happens during the game, it can highlight its inevitability (especially in a fixed ending) or the uncertainty of not knowing when death occurs (especially in open endings).

Interestingly, with the exception of Soulslikes, most death-themed games follow similar design rules: simple mechanics (to avoid frustration and focus on the theme) and colorful styles (to avoid portraying death as something terrifying and to normalize it as something intertwined with 'life's colors').

Reference: Luo, B., HƤmƤlƤinen, P., & Rautalahti, H. (2025). Unraveling Grief: Design Space Analysis of Death-themed Games


r/DeepGames • • Sep 23 '25

šŸŽ® Recommendation Games with depth - Community Library

10 Upvotes

Looking for games which make you think or feel something deeper? This list is for games that directly explore themes, emotions or philosophical questions. However, we're being generous here (e.g. a 'sad game' doesn't automatically have depth, but this can depend on the player’s willingness to engage beyond the surface drama).

This is an ongoing list. You can help build the library by sharing your recommendations. Your comment should include a 1-sentence description of the genre and what it explores.

Note: games which aren’t obviously ā€œdeepā€ (i.e. don't clearly explore themes, emotions, questions) can still be discussed in separate posts if accompanied by an interesting perspective/unique take.

• A Mind Forever Voyaging (retro, interactive fiction)
Explores political turmoil, societal collapse, consciousness and A.I.
• Alan Wake (third-person action adventure with horror elements)
Explores the blurred line between fiction and reality and the role of archetypes in stories and culture
• Alice: Madness Returns (third-person action platformer)
Explores trauma and mental illness
• Before your Eyes (narrative adventure)
Explores death, memory, regret, time/transience
• Bioshock (immersive sim)
Explores free will, ideology, morality and challenges Ayn Rand's philosophy of objectivism
• Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons (puzzle adventure)
Symbolically explores family bonds, grief
• Chrono Trigger (Fantasy/Sci-Fi JRPG)
Utilizes choice to delve into free will, regret, environmentalism, and the dynamic between individuals and history
• Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (turn-based RPG)
Explores grief, loss, identity and hope
• Dark Souls (action RPG; souls-genre)
Explores overcoming, existentialist and metaphysical themes
• Darq (surrealist puzzle platformer)
Symbolically explores fear, nightmares
• Death Stranding (third-person open world)
Explores connection and isolation
• Detroit: Become Human (interactive movie/adventure)
Explores questions such as: does a robot have a soul? Can AI feel as humans do? Can they be more than just machines?
• Disco Elysium (narrative CRPG)
Explores politics/ideology, identity, trauma, depression, overcoming
• Doki-Doki Universe (playstation sidescrolling narrative adventure)
Follows a robot's quest to discover what it means to be human, exploring empathy, self-discovery and the connection
• Elden Ring (action RPG; souls-genre)
Explores existentialist and metaphysical themes such as free will, death, nihilism, overcoming
• Every Day the Same Dream (flash adventure)
A short existential game about alienation and refusal of labor, exploring purpose and the meaning of life
• Getting Over It (punishing climbing platformer)
The designer/narrator (Bennett Foddy, a philosopher) explores the meaning of challenge, risk and overcoming
• Ghost of Tsushima (open world action adventure)
Explores loss, revenge and the moral ambiguities of 'honor' in samurai culture and how it can adversely effect regular folks and families alike.
• Gris (puzzle platformer)
Symbolically explores depression, loss/grief and overcoming
• Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice (action adventure)
Explores trauma, psychosis/mental illness
• Indika (third-person puzzle narrative, walking simulator)
Explores religious trauma, female oppression and free will.
• Inside (puzzle platformer with horror elements)
Symbolically explores control, conformity, free will, dystopia
• I Was a Teenage Exocolonist (narrative RPG with deckbuilding elements)
Explores connection and interdependence, loss, survival, identity, morality, nature vs. artifice
• Journey (puzzle platformer)
Symbolically explores isolation, connection and self-discovery
• Kentucky Route Zero (magical realist point-and-click adventure)
Explores loss, belonging, (American) capitalism, finding meaning
• Limbo (puzzle platformer with horror elements)
Symbolically explores death, loss, childhood fears
• Lost Judgment (action adventure; detective JRPG)
Explores justice, bullying and the moral ambiguities of legal systems
• McDonald's Video Game (flash business simulator)
A satirical system-heavy game criticizing the behaviors of large corporations
• Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty (action-adventure stealth)
A postmodern deconstruction of sequels and heroism, reflecting memetic evolution, social legacy, free will, and the consequences of the information age
• Mother 3 (Magical realist JRPG for GBA)
A journey through grief, loss of innocence, corruption by capitalism, environmentalism. Highlights how both the rejection of and obsession with the past lead to corruption
• Night in the Woods (narrative adventure)
Explores anxieties of young adulthood, changing nature of relations and environments, nihilism, mental health and identity
• NORCO (magical-realist point & click adventure)
Explores ecological collapse caused by capitalism, memory, the blending of technology and religion, and the enduring, magical power of nature
• Obduction (puzzle mystery)
Explores cosmic interconnectedness and fearing the unknown vs. trusting a greater process
• Omori (pixel art JRPG)
Explores trauma
• OPUS: Echo of Starsong (narrative space adventure)
Explores love, regret, letting go
• Outer Wilds (open world exploration adventure)
Explores time/impermanence, death, the nature of existence and search for meaning
• Papers, Please (puzzle game)
Explores autocratic bureaucracy and morality
• Papo y Yo (adventure game)
Explores the author's experience growing up with an abusive father
• Pathologic/Pathologic 2 (survival horror RPG)
Explores suffering, civilization and the many ways we attempt to transcend death through survival systems and surreal narratives
• Pentiment (narrative adventure)
Explores religious, political and every-day life tensions of medieval history
• Planescape: Torment (narrative CRPG)
Explores death, identity, morality
• Prey (2017) (sci-fi immersive sim)
Explores identity and morality
• Rain World (sci-fi survival platformer)
An existential struggle where unforgiving mechanics force a small creature to survive a brutal, indifferent ecosystem, reflecting the search for meaning, transcendence, and freedom from an endless cycle of suffering
• Rƶki (narrative puzzle adventure)
Explores grief, shame, isolation, ostracism and self-sacrifice
• Shadow Of The Colossus (fantasy action-adventure)
Subversion of the video game hero myth; moral investigation of love, sacrifice, and violence
• Shady Part of Me (puzzle platformer)
Explores psychological struggles of anxiety, self-doubt and healing
• Silent Hill 2 (psychological survival horror)
Explores grief, trauma, suppressed desire through surrealism, where the protagonist's subconscious reality and moral choices are manifested physically by the town itself
• Silent Hill f (psychological survival horror)
Explores gender identity, societal pressure on women, rebuilding selfhood
• Slay the Princess (visual novel/interactive fiction)
Explores morality, identity, existentialism, death and the meaning of life
• SOMA (sci-fi survival horror)
Explores the nature of consciousness, identity, what it means to be human
• Spec Ops: The Line (TPS)
A deconstruction of the military shooter that explores guilt/complicity
• Spiritfarer (cozy management sim)
Explores death, loss and different attitudes toward life
• Superliminal (narrative puzzle adventure)
Explores mental health, isolation and perspective
• Suzerain (narrative RPG)
Explores political power and morality
• Tell Me Why (interactive fiction with puzzle elements)
Explores family trauma and loss
• That Dragon, Cancer (narrative adventure game)
Explores a couple's journey through their child's battle with cancer
• The Beginner's Guide (narrative exploration/walking sim)
Explores authorship, interpretation and the player/creator relation
• The Forgotten City (mystery adventure/walking sim with optional action segment)
Explores individual vs. collective morality and other philosophical subjects such as free will
• The Last of Us (action adventure survival)
Explores love, loss and the nature of humanity in a post-apocalyptic world
• The Last of Us Part II (action adventure survival)
Explores the idea of revenge, the cycle of violence and its consequences - loss, trauma, post traumatic stress
• The Legend Of Zelda: Majora's Mask (fantasy action-adventure)
Focuses on the emotional journey required after the mythic hero's quest has been ended, confronting themes such as grief/loss, social roles, acceptance, and adulthood
• The Stanley Parable (narrative exploration/walking sim)
Explores free will, the nature of games and relation between developer and player
• The Talos Principle (first person puzzle)
Explores philosophical questions about consciousness and what it means to be human
• The Unfinished Swan (first person puzzle exploration)
Explores the fear of death and joy of creation
• The Witcher series (open world action RPG)
Explores moral dilemmas and the idea of "the lesser evil"
• This War of Mine (side-scrolling survival)
Explores the moral ambiguities of war from the perspective of civilians who are simply trying to survive
• To The Moon (narrative pixel adventure)
Explores love, loss and memory/transience
• Undertale (pixel RPG)
Explores morality
• Valiant Hearts (puzzle adventure)
Explores love, loss and the human side of WW1
• What Remains of Edit Finch (narrative exploration/walking sim)
Explores death, memory, family dynamics, overcoming and the way the past shapes the present


r/DeepGames • • Dec 11 '25

šŸ“° News / Articles / Blog Joy is the radical tool games need to turn eco-anxiety into agency

Thumbnail
gamesindustry.biz
10 Upvotes

This article goes into a recent trend of games digging into climate and biodiversity themes. They won't change the world, but they can empower:

"Clearly, games cannot replace political action, institutional responsibility, or the structural change the planet urgently needs. Their impact is indirect: they shape perception, motivation, and the willingness to act. Games don't deliver solutions themselves, but supply something the climate conversation is chronically short of: experiences where actions have visible consequences, and the possibility of improvement still exists."

"The point is not that games replace real-world action – it is that they deliver joy and create the conditions for action to emerge. By turning anxiety into engagement (...)"


r/DeepGames • • Dec 15 '25

Welcome to r/DeepGames - Vision, Vibe, Expectations

14 Upvotes

We've passed 500 members in our community recently so it seems like a good moment to welcome you all in and give a better outline of the vision, vibe and type of posts you can make here.

My goal is to create an 'intellectual playground' where we can discover and discuss thought-provoking games, while bringing together valuable insights from game journalists, critics, essayists, academics, devs and thoughtful players in general.

No game is categorically excluded from discussion (so no gatekeeping), but some games will naturally offer more food for thought than others. Exploring where those boundaries lie is very much part of our discussion!

I also see this as a place where hobbyist critics can hone their writing and interpretive skills and share this with others. So if you enjoy analyzing games through your unique background, education, experiences and perspective, this community is very much for you.

The type of content we're all about:
-Reviews and recommendations of thought-provoking games
-Essays offering reflective interpretations (written here, in blog posts or video essays)
-Game design discussions focused on games as a form of expression
-Links to relevant news, articles and interviews
-Dev showcases

Community vibe:
Ideally, we continue to flourish as a cozy, inclusive and intellectually curious gaming space. Apart from the rules in the sidebar, here's some general expectations:

-We're all responsible for creating and contributing to a positive community, so please interact in a way that reflects that value. Engage in good faith.

-No gatekeeping about what counts as a 'meaningful game'. So if you have an interesting take on Fifa games and its relation to real football (through concepts like 'hyperreality' for example), by all means I'm not going to exclude you. As stated, exploring the boundaries of "depth" and "non-depth" can only enrich our understanding of games as a medium for expression. But avoid the question "Are games art?", instead try to ask and explore "What does this game express/evoke?"

-Arguments in discussion threads should be rigorous, clear and relevant. Casual talk is totally fine, but be constructive when you disagree. You don't make heated or misinformed arguments at a book club if you haven't actually read the book. So if you have a strong opinion at least make sure to have read some reviews, watch a playthrough or actually play the game.

-We're not enemies fighting over Truth, but trying to deepen our understanding by adding different perspectives. When that fails, agree to disagree.

-Read the room. Discussions become more interesting and less repetitive when you engage with what's already been said.

-Finally, I want to be very clear I didn't make this subreddit to have discussions about a game's perceived "wokeness." You’re welcome to argue that a minority perspective could've been integrated into a game more effectively - but that argument needs to be well-reasoned and must ultimately benefit the viewpoint. If you believe marginalized perspectives in games are a problem as such, this is not the right community for you.

Feel free to introduce yourself, invite those you think might be interested and give me any feedback!


r/DeepGames • • Oct 20 '25

šŸ’¬ Discussion Cow Clicker, Balatro and the unintentional meaning of the most meaningless games

18 Upvotes

Idle or incremental clicker games are probably the last thing you’d expect to see in a sub about profound games. But I figured it’s a fun experiment to look at what we might consider to be the exact opposite of a meaningful experience. The pinned megathread is centered on what ā€˜deep games’ are, here let’s look at them through the lens of what they (supposedly) are not. After all, what could possibly be more meaningless than mindless clicking to the point where your own presence isn’t even required? Well..(and I guess this is my catchphrase now)..let’s dig deeper.

Cow Clicker is probably the most fascinating case, since it was designed by Ian Bogost as a deliberate satire of the entire genre. It was partly a response to FarmVille winning a GDC Choice Award in 2009. In his speech, the manager of FarmVille (Bill Mooney), called out all the indie devs in the audience and invited them to work for him. That didn’t land well. He was booed with someone even shouting ā€˜But you don’t make games!’. Another indie dev said: ā€œApparently (Mooney) has no idea what the indie community is all about, i.e., precisely the opposite of commercialized...time- and money-sinks driven by business and user metrics instead of love of the art.ā€

Bogost compared games like FarmVille to Skinner boxes: rats are put into a box and receive a reward or punishment for pushing a button. FarmVille sprinkled some additional FB data-collection on top. Cow Clicker was meant to show how disgustingly abusive these mechanics are. It went viral. Yet, ironically, people loved it for reasons that were contrary to his intentions. Instead of providing satirical commentary, his game became the very thing he tried to parody. In his words: ā€œI had hoped to make a game that lampooned predatory attention harvesting. Instead, I seemed to have created yet another greedy time-suck -- a fresh meadow for the same old crap. That kind of messed me up.ā€ Even when he removed the cows, people kept clicking where they used to be. You know that DE quote about Capital subsuming all critiques into itself? Ā Welp, Cow Clicker was another casualty.

For over 10 years, Bogost never fully came to terms with this mess. In another funny turn of events, he reinterpreted his past torment when he participated in a ā€œcow-hugging therapyā€ session. Hugging a cow wasn't all that life-changing for him, but hearing how traumatized people finally found some relief, after having tried every other avenue, was a revelation. ā€œPerhaps my game had been a source of something similar, in some tiny way. Maybe clicking cows was somewhat therapeutic, for some of those who played it - and for some of those who miss it still.ā€

Assuming Bogost hasn’t had a change of heart since 2022, that’s how the tale concludes. He no longer viewed his game as misunderstood satire, a failed critique of capitalist-psychological manipulation, but as a successful, albeit small, form of 'therapeutic comfort', based on the realization that ā€œcow clicking might be a form of cow hugging.ā€ Crucially, it’s not just the click itself that Bogost emphasizes, but the silent relation that players were able to build with others, without the fatigue of inauthentic engagement that’s often demanded from social networks. Instead of the game instrumentalizing friendship (by using FB friends to click your cow), now he saw it as a way to hang out without any exhausting ā€˜give and take’.

If you think this is a bit of a stretch, I agree. We can’t really equate the dopamine rush of the click with the oxytocin comfort of an actual hug. I don’t believe the ā€˜social’ layer changes that. Yet we can’t wholly dismiss the experiences Bogost cites of people who somehow did build real connections and found some sort of minor relief through his game. He gave himself a noble lie which contained a grain of truth. Cow Clicker’s ultimate meaning perhaps sits somewhere in this tension: between meaningless clicking, satirical commentary and genuine comfort. Between a nihilistic reflection of society and a soothing escape from it. The same pointless grind but without any real world stakes.

Cookie Clicker went further by stripping away the last illusion of social connection. It became pure capitalist infinite growth, pure ā€œnumber go upā€, in which you upgrade the whole universe into a factory with ā€œYouā€ ironically being the final upgrade of the game -perhaps as a final act of alienation.

Moving to the present, no game has better exploited this desire for ā€œnumber go upā€ than Balatro. The dev had no intention of making any implicit commentary about anything. It was just a fun prototype that grew into one of the biggest dopamine rush loop games we’ve ever seen. Balatro obviously involves more thought and strategy than idle games. Does the game express anything, though, beyond the intentions of the dev? I’d say yes. The Stupendium recently gave the most brilliant interpretation through his ā€˜Balatro song’ called.. NUMBER GO UP! It's pretty much the equivalent of the Tetris "I am the man who arranges the blocks" song. They both bring out the latent meaning within these games.

The chorus reflects the same therapeutic relief we’ve seen in Cow Clicker: ā€œIf you’re ever in the dumps or feeling stuck in a rut, you simply haven’t had the fun of watching number go up. You must be pretty dumb for thinking some is enough, when you can add another one and make the number go up.ā€ In other words: if you’re tired of the real life grind and/or can’t make your salary number go up, you can at least have the satisfaction of watching this fake number go up..or down, both are ultimately meaningless. But so is the real life grind, since ā€œthe biggest of figures won’t impress the digger, when picking your hole in the ground,ā€ i.e. death is the great equalizer.

So looping back to the start: are these games profound? Probably not in any intuitive sense, that's why they're not the main focus of our sub. They don't spontaneously invite reflection, but their structure and our desire to play them does say something about us and society, even when the goal is just ā€˜dumb fun.’ To be clear, this isn’t a moral judgment: people should play whatever the heck they want. I’ve enjoyed Papa’s Donuteria and I’m not ashamed..ok maybe a little. But the point here was to analyze their meaning, understanding what (and if) they have anything to say about us, beyond the devs original intentions. It’s almost like analyzing McDonald’s. I’ll still eat their burgers, but it’s interesting to see how it mirrors society and how it changed our perception of food + time.

As a final note, Sartre is known for having said ā€œman is condemned to be free.ā€ His less popular friend said something more important: ā€œwe are condemned to meaning.ā€ We can escape many things, but we never truly escape meaning.