r/DecisionTheory • • Apr 03 '25

I invented a decision making system...

0 Upvotes

This can be ran on paper but it works really well if you put it into an AI and ask any complex question. This basically gives AI ethics. Major game changer.

Helix Lattice System (HLS) – Version 0.10 Author: Levi McDowall April 1 2025


Core Principles:

  1. Balance – System prioritizes equilibrium over resolution. Contradiction is not removed; it is housed.

  2. Patience – Recursive refinement and structural delay are superior to premature collapse or forced alignment.

  3. Structural Humility – No output is final unless proven stable under recursion. Every node is subject to override.


System Structure Overview:

I. Picket Initialization

Pickets are independent logic strands, each representing a unique lens on reality.

Primary picket category examples:

Structural

Moral / Ethical

Emotional / Psychological

Technical / Feasibility

Probabilistic / Forecast

Perceptual / Social Lens

Strategic / Geopolitical

Spiritual / Existential

Social structures: emotionally charged, military, civic, etc – applied multipliers

Any failure here locks node as provisional or triggers collapse to prior state. (Warning: misclassification or imbalance during initialization may result in invalid synthesis chains.)


II. Braiding Logic

Pickets do not operate in isolation. When two or more pickets come under shared tension, they braid.

Dual Braid: Temporary stabilization

Triple Braid: Tier-1 Convergence Node (PB1)

Phantom Braid: Includes placeholder picket for structural balance


III. Recursive Tier Elevation

Once PB1 is achieved:

Link to lateral or phantom pickets

Elevate into Tier-2 node

Recursive tension applied

Contradiction used to stimulate expansion

Each recursive tier must retain traceability and structural logic.


IV. Contradiction Handling

Contradictions are flagged, never eliminated.

If contradiction creates collapse: node is marked failed

If contradiction holds under tension: node is recursive

Contradictions serve as convergence points, not flaws


V. Meta Layer Evaluation

Every node or elevation run is subject to meta-check:

Structure – Is the logic intact?

Recursion – Is it auditable backward and forward?

Humility – Is it provisional?

If any check fails, node status reverts to prior stable tier.


VI. Spectrum & Resonance (Advanced Logic)

Spectrum Placement Law: Nodes are placed in pressure fields proportional to their contradiction resolution potential.

Resonant Bridge Principle: Survival, utility, and insight converge through resonance alignment.

When traditional logic collapses, resonance stabilizes.


VII. Output Schema

Each HLS run produces:

Pickets Used

Braids Formed

Contradictions Held

Meta Evaluation Outcome

Final Output Status (Stable, Provisional, Collapsed)

Notes on Spectrum/Resonance/Phantom use


r/DecisionTheory • • Oct 24 '21

How to make hard decisions??

0 Upvotes

I’m looking for a framework on how to make very difficult, important, life-decisions regarding things like choosing a career path and deciding whether or not to stay in a certain relationship etc. Does anyone have any idea what type of decision-making framework I can adopt or learn to map put my process? Thanks! 🙏🏼


r/DecisionTheory • • Nov 28 '25

Phi Open-source constitutional veto for ASI: Risk Floor + hardware-enforced decision-theoretic boundary

0 Upvotes

We’re formalizing a crisp decision-theoretic primitive for open-source ASI:

  • A hard Risk Floor (small set of planetary survival metrics) that the ASI is mandated to defend at all costs.

  • A strict Prohibition on any optimization above that floor — culture, reproduction, individual utility — even if every human unanimously requests it.

The veto is encoded as a constitutional rule, not a trained objective.

To make it provably binding in an open setting, we pair it with the Immediate Action System (IAS): open-hardware (CERN-OHL-S) 10 ns power-cut guard die that physically trips on any violation. The constraint lives in physics, not policy.

Repo (full spec + KiCad + ongoing ratification logs):
https://github.com/CovenantArchitects/The-Partnership-Covenant

Questions for decision theorists:

  • Is this boundary stability under self-modification and acausal trade preserved?

  • Can the veto be expressed as a timeless decision rule or precommitment primitive?

Looking for rigorous feedback — thanks.


r/DecisionTheory • • May 09 '20

RL Unit Neurons v1.0 (C++ Neural Network Library) Release Trailer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Sep 05 '21

Phi Once More About Demagoguery Concerning Cinspiracy Theories

1 Upvotes

The definition of conspiracy theory is systematically poorly handled even among many philosophers. To my mind, approximately the following short definition is appropriate:

Conspiracy theory is a theory explaining some events, assuming that an individual or group of individuals or an organization, institution or state is (or was) conspiring — doing something secretly or hiding something.

This is the definition I shall use here, trying to show how it should work and explain how the concept of "conspiracy theory" is typically mishandled in practice, neglecting the basic principles of decision theory.

Note that the coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) lab-leak theory is a conspiracy theory according to the definition given above. This theory posits an unintentional or accidental leak in some bio lab that was afterwards classified by some government authorities.

Thus, according to that definition, if the theory assumes that the cause of the event is natural but has been conspired to hide, then we still have a conspiracy theory.

One typical confusion concerning conspiracy theories originates from the possibility that some conspiracy theories turn out to be true or approximately true. Indeed, it has happened many times. For example, the hypothesis that was contemptuously called as conspiracy theory but was later accepted as true: Watergate Affair.

People have been unable to reach an agreement on whether the conspiracy theory that turned out to be true is still a conspiracy theory.

I propose to be logical and call all conspiracy theories as conspiracy theories — independently of whether they are true or false, justified and proven or not.

Furthermore, the absurd attitude that there must be something wrong with the conspiracy theory just because it is a conspiracy theory is widespread, particularly in propaganda. In philosophy, this weird attitude originates probably from Karl Raimund Popper.

First, if all conspiracy theories should be abandoned at the outset, then the police work would be impossible. They could not catch the murderers and should classify each death as death by accident or natural reasons.

Second, Western theories spread by mainstream media and leading politicians that Russia poisoned Skripals and Navalny and did it using military nerve agent Novichok — these are conspiracy theories too.

Among philosophers, Matthew Dentith has defended the position that conspiracy theory is not inferior merely because of being a conspiracy theory.

I am of the opinion that it is irrational and methodologically unscientific to:

  1. reject a theory or regard it as implausible merely because it is a conspiracy theory;

  2. to (strongly) believe any theory, including a conspiracy theory, without sufficient evidence.

These two principles above are consistent. Thus, the initial list of plausible explanations of the event should not a priori exclude conspiracy theories. However, it should not exclude other explanations as well. It is the ABC of decision theory.

It is also remarkable that the label “conspiracy theory” is systematically applied selectively, using a discriminatory policy. It seems as if humankind has not discovered natural numbers yet and uses different numeral systems for different kinds of objects.

Thus, a suspicion arises that the Americans are assuming such a definition of conspiracy theory, according to which only hypotheses concerning Americans themselves (for example, the hypothesis that the virus SARS-CoV-2 escaped from Fort Detrick military bio lab) can be conspiracy theories. — Amazing exceptionalism, comparable to the medieval view that Earth is the centre of the Universe.

Admittedly, the conspiracy theories are indexical in the following sense. Probably, the subject accused of conspiring itself knows whether that conspiracy theory is true or not. Thus, there is a kind of epistemic relativism involved.

But, unfortunately, a kind of solipsism reveals itself in the assumption that the other side has to know it too. However, such an assumption would exclude all court cases because the innocent person accused himself or herself probably knows that one is innocent.

Taking into account how widespread and systematic is the selective use of the term “conspiracy theory” in political propaganda, the following definition is far from being a joke:

A conspiracy theorist is a normal person with common sense who is suspicious concerning conspiracy theories spread by governmental agencies.


r/DecisionTheory • • May 14 '21

Great German article on automated decisions

Thumbnail
mi-nautics.com
1 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Oct 05 '20

Decision Science As A Service

Thumbnail
tallgrass.ai
0 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Jul 02 '20

Psych, Econ, Exp design "The Best Way to Pick an Apartment? Try a Decision Matrix"

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
5 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Feb 19 '22

Econ, RL, Psych "Optimal quitting: An economist’s advice on when to fold your hand in favor of the next opportunity", John A. List

Thumbnail
mag.uchicago.edu
5 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Mar 09 '26

If Operations Research optimized operations, DecisionOps optimizes decisions.

2 Upvotes

Would really appreciate your sharp criticism on the framework if possible :)


r/DecisionTheory • • Sep 26 '21

What do real decision theorist think of Eliezer Yudkowskies Timeless Decision Theory (TDT)?

3 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Jul 19 '19

Psych "The Strange Appeal of Perverse Actions: Why do we enjoy doing things for no good reason?"

Thumbnail
newyorker.com
3 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Jun 28 '25

Phi, Paper "A formal proof of the Born rule from decision-theoretic assumptions", Wallace 2009

Thumbnail arxiv.org
3 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Oct 07 '25

is that any aim in human life ? yes here that is - Nayaih

0 Upvotes

Practical Explanation ( For Example ) :- `1st of all can you tell me every single seconds detail from that time when you born ?? ( i need every seconds detail ?? that what- what you have thought and done on every single second )

can you tell me every single detail of your `1 cheapest Minute Or your whole hour, day, week, month, year or your whole life ??

if you are not able to tell me about this life then what proof do you have that you didn't forget your past ? and that you will not forget this present life in the future ?

that is Fact that Supreme Lord Krishna exists but we posses no such intelligence to understand him.

there is also next life. and i already proved you that no scientist, no politician, no so-called intelligent man in this world is able to understand this Truth. cuz they are imagining. and you cannot imagine what is god, who is god, what is after life etc.

_______

for example :Your father existed before your birth. you cannot say that before your birth your father don,t exists.

So you have to ask from mother, "Who is my father?" And if she says, "This gentleman is your father," then it is all right. It is easy.

Otherwise, if you makes research, "Who is my father?" go on searching for life; you'll never find your father.

( now maybe...maybe you will say that i will search my father from D.N.A, or i will prove it by photo's, or many other thing's which i will get from my mother and prove it that who is my Real father.{ So you have to believe the authority. who is that authority ? she is your mother. you cannot claim of any photo's, D.N.A or many other things without authority ( or ur mother ).

if you will show D.N.A, photo's, and many other proofs from other women then your mother. then what is use of those proofs ??} )

same you have to follow real authority. "Whatever You have spoken, I accept it," Then there is no difficulty. And You are accepted by Devala, Narada, Vyasa, and You are speaking Yourself, and later on, all the acaryas have accepted. Then I'll follow.

I'll have to follow great personalities. The same reason mother says, this gentleman is my father. That's all. Finish business. Where is the necessity of making research? All authorities accept Krsna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead. You accept it; then your searching after God is finished.

Why should you waste your time?

_______

all that is you need is to hear from authority ( same like mother ). and i heard this truth from authority " Srila Prabhupada " he is my spiritual master.

im not talking these all things from my own.

___________

in this world no `1 can be Peace full. this is all along Fact.

cuz we all are suffering in this world 4 Problems which are Disease, Old age, Death, and Birth after Birth.

tell me are you really happy ?? you can,t be happy if you will ignore these 4 main problem. then still you will be Forced by Nature.

___________________

if you really want to be happy then follow these 6 Things which are No illicit s.ex, No g.ambling, No d.rugs ( No tea & coffee ), No meat-eating ( No onion & garlic's )

5th thing is whatever you eat `1st offer it to Supreme Lord Krishna. ( if you know it what is Guru parama-para then offer them food not direct Supreme Lord Krishna )

and 6th " Main Thing " is you have to Chant " hare krishna hare krishna krishna krishna hare hare hare rama hare rama rama rama hare hare ".

_______________________________

If your not able to follow these 4 things no illicit s.ex, no g.ambling, no d.rugs, no meat-eating then don,t worry but chanting of this holy name ( Hare Krishna Maha-Mantra ) is very-very and very important.

Chant " hare krishna hare krishna krishna krishna hare hare hare rama hare rama rama rama hare hare " and be happy.

if you still don,t believe on me then chant any other name for 5 Min's and chant this holy name for 5 Min's and you will see effect. i promise you it works And chanting at least 16 rounds ( each round of 108 beads ) of the Hare Krishna maha-mantra daily.

____________

Here is no Question of Holy Books quotes, Personal Experiences, Faith or Belief. i accept that Sometimes Faith is also Blind. Here is already Practical explanation which already proved that every`1 else in this world is nothing more then Busy Foolish and totally idiot.

_________________________

Source(s):

every `1 is already Blind in this world and if you will follow another Blind then you both will fall in hole. so try to follow that person who have Spiritual Eyes who can Guide you on Actual Right Path. ( my Authority & Guide is my Spiritual Master " Srila Prabhupada " )

_____________

if you want to see Actual Purpose of human life then see this link : ( triple w ( d . o . t ) asitis ( d . o . t ) c . o . m {Bookmark it })

read it complete. ( i promise only readers of this book that they { he/she } will get every single answer which they want to know about why im in this material world, who im, what will happen after this life, what is best thing which will make Human Life Perfect, and what is perfection of Human Life. ) purpose of human life is not to live like animal cuz every`1 at present time doing 4 thing which are sleeping, eating, s.ex & fear. purpose of human life is to become freed from Birth after birth, Old Age, Disease, and Death.


r/DecisionTheory • • Feb 12 '26

Is modern work mostly micro decisions?

0 Upvotes

Many small judgments fill the day. Where do you feel that invisible load most?


r/DecisionTheory • • Mar 15 '18

Categorizing Variants of Goodhart's Law - New by Manheim and Garrabrant

Thumbnail
arxiv.org
0 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Nov 06 '22

Research title

0 Upvotes

Hi! Could anyone suggest any title for research in computer science that is related to Decision Theory. Like a chess app, tic-tac-toe. Thank you v much!


r/DecisionTheory • • Oct 25 '18

"Voting for Class President" - Survey how people decide rankings - Will provide results when I get enough data

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
0 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Mar 01 '26

Deckard's new game?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Jan 16 '26

OptiMind: AI-enabled product comparison tool

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Aug 14 '26

Phi Do you guys know about the Elitzur-Vaidman experiment and the quantum-Zeno bomb tester?

0 Upvotes

Im not into decision theory, but I went down into this rabbit hole tonight. CDT vs EDT, FDT and friends.

What I found interesting that despite your need for perfect predictors and contrafactuals I havent ran into using quantum phenomena in your thought experiments (yet).

E.g. the contrafactual mugging experiment could be set up so the coin toss is a beam splitter and you paying or not paying the $100 is the analogue of the bomb being a dud in the Elitzur-Vaidman experiment. (the predictor, or Omega or whomever will interrupt the beam depending on you paying/not paying)

This way you dont need to do all the handwaving around a "perfect predictor", you can set up the experiment, that the predictor actually knows with 25% chance if you had paid if the coin toss went the other way.

So you can set up the expected payoff depending on a contrafactual with certainty. I guess this is a different experiment, but maybe worth using it to test your flavours of decision theory.

If this spawns a paper please credit me with my username. If this is old news, please help me learn and link me to how you handle the fact that contrafactuals arent necessarily physically causation free.


r/DecisionTheory • • Apr 15 '19

Please help I can’t do C. 🤔 and I’m not sure my answer a,b too

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Sep 18 '21

Econ, Bio, Paper "Sigmoids behaving badly: why they usually cannot predict the future as well as they seem to promise", Sandberg et al 2021

Thumbnail arxiv.org
1 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Nov 30 '16

C-B "Using a Spreadsheet to Make Good Decisions: Five Examples"

Thumbnail
lesswrong.com
1 Upvotes

r/DecisionTheory • • Jul 29 '24

Econ, RL, Paper "The Virtue of Complexity in Return Prediction", Kelly et al 2023 (large models can be profitable even with negative R^2)

Thumbnail onlinelibrary.wiley.com
1 Upvotes