r/DebateReligion • • 3h ago

Christianity Specific creatures invalidates Noah's ark completely.

13 Upvotes

To the believers of Noah's ark story, Noah's ark could not have happened because of these 3 animals.

  1. Termites - they literally would have eaten the ark. Termites can't survive as pair. They need a colony.

  2. Blue Whale/aquatic animal - cannot survive in flood from salinity change. No idea how Noah would accommodate Blue whale or any aquatic animal in the ark

  3. Giant Pandas - 15 metric tons of bamboo would be required. How will bamboo be preserved for ark's voyage?

  4. Vampire bats/Mosquitoes/Leeches- Blood clots within minutes outside body without specialized modern anti-coagulants. Blood cannot be stored. Noah would have to let the vampire bats feed on other animals leading to blood loss and obligate dangerous disease transmission across ark animals.

The existence of these animals on the planet invalidates Noah's ark story.

More importantly, how did Noah save termites? Until someone can answer that, Noah's ark cannot exist because of mainly these creatures.


r/DebateReligion • • 7h ago

Abrahamic If God were truly just, he'd give us the choice of non-existence after death

25 Upvotes

Nobody chooses or asks to be born, so why should anyone be forced to exist forever? If God is perfectly just and loving, why isn’t non-existence an option for those who don’t want eternity in heaven or hell?

Forcing someone into an eternity that they never asked for doesn’t seem like an act of love.


r/DebateReligion • • 2h ago

Islam The Quran Erases the Historical Jesus and Replaces Him With a 7th-Century Islamic Version

8 Upvotes

Muslims often point out that they believe in Jesus, unlike Judaism which rejects him. The fundamental issue with Islam's view of Jesus is that it retains his name while completely rewriting his historical context.

Compare how the Quran treats Moses versus Jesus. Moses is the most mentioned prophet in the Quran, complete with named adversaries like Pharaoh, Haman, and Qarun, and storylines that directly mirror Muhammad’s conflicts with the Quraysh. By contrast, Jesus's real historical setting is largely erased. The Quran never once mentions Judea, Galilee, Nazareth, Bethlehem, Roman rule, Pontius Pilate, or Judas.

Instead, the Quran claims the Injeel (Gospel) was a message revealed directly to Jesus, and commands Christians to judge by what Allah revealed in it (Surah 5:47). Furthermore, it claims the Prophet is foretold in the previous scriptures (Surah 7:157), and specifically claims Jesus predicted a messenger named "Ahmad" (Surah 61:6).

Yet there is zero independently verifiable historical evidence that Jesus ever received or wrote a book called the Injeel. Ironically, the word Injeel ultimately derives from the Greek euangelion ("good news"), likely transmitted through Syriac, a Semitic language. Historically, the Gospel referred to Jesus's proclaimed message, not a distinct book revealed to him. The New Testament consists of Gospels and letters written in Greek decades after Jesus's death. Unlike the Quran, which is presented as the direct dictation of Allah, the Gospels are anonymous human biographies. Furthermore, they contain no explicit prediction of a future prophet named "Ahmad." Instead, John 14:26 identifies the Paraclete as the Holy Spirit, and the New Testament repeatedly warns against false prophets.

The Crucifixion Problem
Even worse, the Quran rejects the single most historically established fact of Jesus's life: his crucifixion under Pontius Pilate. This event is confirmed not only by early Christian sources but also by independent, non-Christian historians like Tacitus and Josephus.

Six hundred years after the fact, Surah An-Nisa 4:157 replaces established history with an ambiguous half-sentence. First, it claims Jesus's Jewish opponents boasted: "We killed the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, the messenger of Allah."

The people who rejected Jesus's messianic claims allegedly boast about killing him while calling him the Messiah and messenger of Allah. Unless this is sarcasm or the Quran inserting its own terminology, why would the very people who rejected his claims suddenly affirm them?

Second, it asserts: "But they neither killed nor crucified him, it was only made to appear so." Without offering any concrete alternative account, a vague statement written six centuries later overturns a well-documented Roman execution. Under the traditional Islamic interpretation, this effectively makes God responsible for an apparent crucifixion that could have misled even Jesus's own mother and disciples. Yet the Quran will explicitly outline the rules for visiting Muhammad's home (33:53). Apparently, Allah doesn't prioritize clarifying the historical fate of the Messiah, but Muhammad's household visitation rules require explicit divine instructions.

The Apocryphal Problem
On top of erasing his real biography, the Quran fills the gaps with stories lifted straight from non-canonical Christian apocrypha such as breathing life into clay birds (from the 2nd-century Infancy Gospel of Thomas) and speaking as a newborn in the cradle (from the Arabic/Syriac Infancy Gospel).

An all-knowing God apparently omitted Pontius Pilate, Nazareth, and Jesus's actual teachings, yet included 2nd-century Christian folklore. Divine revelation is hardly a convincing explanation when the circulation of Christian oral traditions and apocryphal stories throughout Late Antiquity offers a far more historically defensible one.


r/DebateReligion • • 6h ago

Classical Theism animal suffering is at such a high scale for god to be omnibeevolent

16 Upvotes

Survival of the fittest is brutal. For millions of years before humans even existed, sentient creatures were experiencing fear, pain and premature death through predation, starvation, disease, parasites and natural disasters. Animals were being hunted, sometimes surviving prolonged suffering before eventually dying, entirely independently of human decisions or wrongdoing. Animal suffering demonstrably predates humanity by millions of years. Furthermore, animals aren't morally responsible for their circumstances, nor does their suffering necessarily contribute to any greater good for the individual experiencing it. I accept that some pain serves a biological purpose, but that doesn't explain why suffering needs to exist on such an enormous scale or with such severity. An omnipotent creator could presumably have designed a world in which animals could survive, reproduce and maintain functioning ecosystems without requiring conscious creatures to experience such extensive suffering. If God is omniscient, he knows about every instance of suffering; if he is omnipotent, he has the power to prevent it; and if he is omnibenevolent, we would expect him to have a compelling reason to prevent suffering that serves no necessary greater purpose. Yet the natural world contains extraordinary amounts of apparently pointless suffering.


r/DebateReligion • • 6h ago

Islam A kind, honest person who leaves Islam shouldn't end up in hell for that alone

11 Upvotes

Picture someone born Muslim who later leaves Islam. They don't join another religion and they don't become an atheist. They just aren't sure whether God exists.
This person still helps others, respects everyone, takes care of their parents, never harms anyone and treats people kindly. They do it because they want to, not out of fear or for a reward. They were a good person before leaving, and they still are.
My position is that a just and merciful God wouldn't send someone like this to hell just because they left the religion. Their sincerity and character should count for more than a label.
Muslims who disagree: please respond with Quran verses (and authentic Hadith if needed), not personal opinion. Does the Quran support my position or go against it?


r/DebateReligion • • 6h ago

Abrahamic Morality is already proven to be subjective by neuroscience. Yet major religions claim it to be objective and flowing from God.

8 Upvotes

Neuroscience has proven that moral activity and moral behavior is a function of brain, not gift of God.

The prefrontal cortex, orbitofrontal cortex, anterior cingulate cortex and other prefrontal cortex regions of the brain is concerned with moral behavior. Tumors or lesion on these regions can change a person's nature from innocent, polite and respectful to disrespectful, violent, aggressive. They can even become sociopathic or develop pedophilia. These traits again go away, if the tumors or lesions are removed and return if they come back. It proves that damage to prefrontal cortex affects human moral behavior - turning a pious person into a violent sociopath.

Example: Phineas Gage case (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phineas_Gage)
Patient J.S (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10825352/)
School teacher case (https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/1410962/Brain-tumour-turned-teacher-into-paedophile.html)

There are more cases like this.

Since everyone's brain settings (weights of neurons, internal configuration, neuroplasticity factor, internal network configurations of brain, prefrontal cortex neural activity) is not the same, it implies everyone's concept and decision of moral behavior and moral activity is not the same too. On some cases, they may align but that does not mean they behave similar.

Since morality derives from a biological part of body and biological parts are not exact copies for any individual, hence, morality is proven to be subjective.

Also, animals that don't have a developed prefrontal or frontal cortex of brain do not display signs of morality. Example: Horses. Horses do not have prefrontal cortex and hence no morality. They have herd mentality. Behavior of horses that may equate to loyalty, respect or betrayal are anthropomorphic traits imparted by humans based on certain behaviors. When a horse behaves calmly or cooperatively, it usually means it feels safe and understands the cues given by the human, not that it is making a moral choice. Other animals involve mice, rodents and invertebrates.

Morality is a primate construct and more specifically highly associated with those creatures having a developed prefrontal cortex (humans, primates, elephants, dolphins, whales, orcas and some birds (like parrots)). Each of these animals are considered to be very intelligent and display on some scale a shred of morality (though not at human level). These animals display proto-morality.

Humans have a highly specialized brain and rely on extensive social interactions living as a vast community, so their morality is much more complex and developed than proto-morality.

Either way, neuroscience proves morality is a function of brain and hence subjective and varying from person to person.

If two persons agree on several aspects, that does not mean they have same code of morality or same neural activity/functioning related to morality. If morality is objective, then it implies everyone's brain operates in a fixed manner which it does not. This proves morality is subjective.

Yet every major religion arrogantly claims morality to be objective and given by God, which is a lie.


r/DebateReligion • • 4h ago

Theism Theism (of a specific named deity) is a religious belief

5 Upvotes

Theism that identifies any particular deity, such as the Abrahamic god Yahweh, is a religious belief. For instance, someone who doesn’t identify as Christian, but who nevertheless believes that a tri-omni being named “God” created the world in seven days, holds a religious belief regardless of whether they consider themselves a religious person or are affiliated with a religious organization.


r/DebateReligion • • 11h ago

Islam The anti-scientific-miracle of the spider silk

18 Upvotes

There’s something quite ironic about verse 29:41 of the Quran, which says that “the frailest of all houses is the spider’s house.” At first glance, this seems obvious. A spider’s web looks so delicate that you can destroy it with a wave of your hand. But modern science has revealed something rather astonishing about this supposedly weak structure.

Spider silk is actually one of the most remarkable materials found in nature. Its tensile strength can rival that of steel, despite being much lighter. Some types can stretch considerably before breaking, absorbing enormous amounts of energy for their weight. Scientists have spent decades studying spider silk, hoping to reproduce its extraordinary properties for use in medicine, engineering and protective materials. What looks like a few fragile threads is actually a masterpiece of natural engineering.

Now imagine if the Quran had said that the spider builds one of the strongest houses. Just think of the endless lectures, articles and YouTube videos proclaiming this a scientific miracle! We would be told that no seventh-century human could possibly have known about the incredible strength of spider silk, and that this could only be divine knowledge!

Yet the Quran says the opposite. By the same logic used to promote scientific miracles, couldn’t we call this a scientific error? Of course, a reasonable person could point out that the verse is using a metaphor, and that a strong material doesn’t necessarily make a strong shelter. Fair enough. But that’s precisely the problem with the whole scientific miracles argument. When a verse seems to agree with modern science, it’s suddenly a miraculous scientific revelation. When it doesn’t, we’re reminded that the Quran is a book of metaphors, not a science textbook.

Apparently the rules change depending on which interpretation makes the Quran look better.


r/DebateReligion • • 6h ago

Islam If there is no compulsion in islam, then all the islamic countries should be condemned on the basis of the religious laws compelling people.

6 Upvotes

I'm not saying you can't have a religion that has compulsion. I'm saying its a useless phrase to say "no compulsion in Islam" unless there's a free for all then Islam is not "no compulsion in islam.

many Islamic countries arrest apostates (thus compelling someone to not apostate) atheists (compelling people to believe, and in before but they let Christians. Yes but an atheist would still have to pretend to be Christian) blasphemers (compelling people to not speak about their thoughts about Islam, regardless if its likeable or not) gays (compelling people to conform to the religious morals) and so on.

My point is "no compulsion in islam" has no meaningful use unless you condemn the countries and mentalities that believe apostates, blasphemers, atheists, other non believers with a jizya be arrested or punished for who they are or how they behave.


r/DebateReligion • • 4h ago

Christianity The existence of a historical Jesus is of little importance

4 Upvotes

Why does it matter whether
there was a historical Jesus or not?

If there was, 
we know next to nothing about them.

The only thing we really have 
are a parade of imagined Jesuses. 

People seem so proud and righteous 
about the entries they make 
to the Jesus parade.

And to that, I have to ask: to what end?

What is the purpose of telling people 
about your imagined Jesus? 

Do you actually think that everyone 
is going to get on board 
with your conceptualization, 
and it will lead to some greater good?

If you have an idea that you want to share, 
why isn't it good enough to stand on its own? 

Why do you have to attach it 
to an authoritative figure 
to give it credibility?

No idea or action is good or worthy 
simply because Jesus or any other figure 
- whether they be real or imaginary - 
supposedly supported it.

An idea's worth 
comes from its evidence, reasoning, and outcomes 
- not from who endorses it.


r/DebateReligion • • 17h ago

Islam Islam's ban on idol worship is inconsistent with its rituals around the Kaaba and the Black Stone

31 Upvotes

Islam's rejection of idol worship is inconsistent with its own rituals around the Kaaba and the Hajar al-Aswad (Black Stone).

  1. Islam forbids idol worship because ritual devotion should not be directed at physical objects.

  2. During Hajj/Umrah, Muslims perform Tawaf (7 circuits around the Kaaba), and many try to touch or kiss the Black Stone.

  3. Circling a sacred structure and kissing a sacred stone are acts of ritual devotion directed at a physical object.

  4. Pre-Islamic Arabs already performed Tawaf at the Kaaba. Islam kept the ritual and removed the idols.

The usual defense: The Kaaba is only the qibla (direction of prayer), and Caliph Umar said he kissed the stone only because the Prophet did, knowing it has no power.

Why I find this unconvincing: The defense rests entirely on intention. But people who worship idols often say the same thing: the object is just a focus, not the deity itself. If intention is the only difference, then the rule depends on what's in the worshipper's mind, not on the act, and an outside observer can't tell the two apart.

Is there a real difference beyond intention and the Prophet's example? Respectful responses from Muslims and non-Muslims welcome.


r/DebateReligion • • 10h ago

Atheism the difference between atheist and religious people

8 Upvotes

the majority of atheists are agnostic atheists, a minority are gnostic atheist.

the majority of religious people are gnostic, a minority are agnostic.

and they're always accusing us of "acting like we know everything"

brother. most atheist acknowledge that there's a chance a god does exist, while most religious people do NOT acknowledge that its possible that there is not.


r/DebateReligion • • 19h ago

Abrahamic The Christian Bible god should have made sure that the most important book in the world was clear and straight to the point

27 Upvotes

Christians claim the Bible is a book that is the "inspired word of an all-loving god" who WANTS to save everyone. This god KNEW the book would be often "misinterpreted" and often require group STUDY, as well as OTHER BOOKS, to help explain it, yet he still relies on that book.

Since he's capable of doing ANYTHING, he should have made sure the message was clear as can be, so that misinterpretations were impossible.

Here are some examples of debates Christians have with each other about the "true meaning" of certain parts of the book:

• Is hell literal fire or metaphorical suffering?

• Is the trinity real?

• Is the snake in the Garden of Eden Satan?

• Did Jesus say keep just the 10 Commandments, or that the whole Old Testament still applies?

There are hundreds more.

There's also the fact that 30,000 denominations exsit, but let's focus on the fact that even within a single given denomination, there are countless disagreements on "true meanings" of parts of the Bible.


r/DebateReligion • • 1h ago

Christianity Há questões na religião cristã que eu não consigo compreender

1 Upvotes

Olá a todos! Irei me apresentar primeiro, pra entender um pouco. Sou ateu desde os 10 anos, que eu lembre, mas me crismei na igreja católica — antes que alguém me xingue por isso, não tive muita escolha sobre isso —, então entendo um pouco da religião.

Bem, com o tempo eu fui escutando certas coisas que me deixaram em dúvida.

1° - Por que a morte de alguém nunca é graças a Deus? (Pelo menos nunca escutei ninguém dizendo isso). Eu sempre escuto um "Deus sabe de todos as coisas", "Tudo acontece no tempo de Deus" e etc; se alguém conquista algo, dizem: "Conseguiu graças a Deus", mas se eu disser: "Ele morreu porque Deus quis", só 1 a cada 10 pessoas não ficariam com raiva ou me ofenderia por isso.

2° - por que a igreja é a casa do senhor, mas nossa própria casa não? No catecismo e no crisma eu sempre escutava que Deus sempre estava com nós em todos os lugares, então porquê nossa casa também não é casa do senhor? (Não soube formular tão bem essa questão, mas, quando eu acreditava, sempre me sentia mais confortável em casa do que na igreja, a igreja pra mim tava mais pra um templo de adoração e não uma casa mesmo)

3° - Essa é só uma dúvida mais "boba": o que te motiva a acreditar? Mesmo sendo ateu, não posso negar que existe algo (seja superior ou não, um Deus ou não). Desde criança tive experiência com esse mundo espiritual (via vultos, vozes, sensações e uma vez vi um santo mexer-se só). Mas, não me considero agnóstico, então prefiro me considerar ateu.

Para os Mods e outras pessoas, por favor, não considere que estou tentando ofender ou zombar da religião. Estou seriamente tentando entender um pouco mais da religião e meu intuito é só aprender um pouco mais. Então, se pareceu ofensivo ou se não gostaram do jeito que eu falei: desde já, peço desculpas!


r/DebateReligion • • 2h ago

Abrahamic The Unethicality of Eternal Torment & Refuting free will defences

1 Upvotes

A note on discussion: Please quote and directly address the arguments you disagree with. Avoid misrepresenting positions or appealing to vague concepts such as "rational agency" or "moral responsibility" without defining them and explaining their relevance. Let's aim for precise, substantive engagement.

  1. The Fundamental Ethical Problem

Eternal conscious torment conflicts with compassion, love, and flourishing by causing suffering without the possibility of eventual healing or restoration.

Appeals to divine authority, justice, or retribution require independent ethical justification and reasoning.

2. Free Will and Creator Responsibility

An omnipotent creator determines the conditions and possibilities within which created beings exercise agency including the nature of individuals. Free will does not absolve the creator of responsibility for these conditions and their consequences.

Furthermore, meaningful freedom does not necessarily require unrestricted possibilities. Preventing eternally destructive outcomes need not constitute coercion.

ECT's defenders must therefore explain what meaningful value would be lost by preventing eternal suffering.

3. Flourishing as an Alternative Foundation

Under this framework, individuals retain meaningful agency, but the possibilities available to them are consistent with the foundational principles of a reality aligned with flourishing. This does not require choices to be predetermined, but rather that agency operates through a nature aligned with flourishing.

Every reality has constitutive features that determine the capacities, limitations, and nature of its inhabitants. The existence of such properties does not, by itself, constitute coercion. The choices available in a given earthly circumstance do not necessarily represent the fulfillment of meaningful agency.

4. Value, Justice, and CCEA

Defining God as good within a theological framework does not independently establish ethical goodness. Its underlying principles require examination.

As expressed in A Walk in the Physical:

The true justice is that all are loved and accepted, and that all are healed. Only the ego wishes less than that for someone else.

|

What meaningful value would be lost by creating a reality in which everyone ultimately flourishes?

ECT's defenders must explain precisely why eternal suffering is necessary, what value it preserves, and why no alternative could preserve that value without eternal suffering or annihilation.

I propose CCEA (Coherent Central Ethics Approximation) as a framework for intersubjective ethical evaluation:

  • Coherent: Principles should be internally consistent.

  • Central Ethics: Principles central to intersubjective value judgement.

  • Approximation: Ethical evaluation is a matter of degree.

CCEA claims no ultimate moral jurisdiction, but offers a framework for examining ethical claims.

Within CCEA, ECT conflicts with central values of compassion, love, and flourishing. Given an omnipotent creator's capacity to establish alternatives, ECT is ethically unjustified.


r/DebateReligion • • 19h ago

Christianity Christians cannot demonstrate the NT writings are from God

15 Upvotes

Christians cannot give a single valid evidence for why the book of James, Peter and etc are inspired by God. They just assumed it. This seriously needs to be questioned. I'm asking christians to give evidence for the supernatural claim that the NT writings are inspired by God. Because a supernatural claim needs unambogious evidence for it


r/DebateReligion • • 15h ago

Abrahamic Sending people to hell is pointless cruelty, even if those people were wicked or non-believers

7 Upvotes

Whether we are talking about "wicked" people or simple non-believers, sending anyone to Hell makes no sense if God is all-knowing and empathetic.

Before creating us, God already knew who would turn out wicked or fail to believe. A truly loving, empathetic, and rational creator would have looked at the big picture and thought: "Wait a minute. If I create these people, they are going to suffer forever because of a system I designed. Out of pure empathy, I should spare them from this fate and simply not create them."

Instead, God knowingly gave existence to people He knew would fail, placed them in a system He architected, and blamed them for it. Testing people when you already know the outcome isn't justice, it's a setup.

Punishing non-believers is even more absurd. Non-believers are simply using the exact reason and critical thinking that God supposedly gave them. When you look closely at holy books, they are full of contradictions. Any rational person would naturally ask: "How can I be sure this actually comes from God, and isn't just the work of a mad charlatan or a political tool used for power?"

Torturing someone for using the brain you gave them is pure cruelty. Paradoxically, this creator gives humans free will and critical thinking, yet only rewards the ones who blindly obey Him without ever questioning anything.

What about "temporary Hell" or "purification"?

Some argue that Hell is temporary, just a place to "purify" souls before Heaven. First, an all-powerful God doesn't need to torture His creations to fix flaws He knowingly gave them. Second, this creates absurd moral paradoxes in Heaven:

The Hitler Paradox: Imagine someone like Hitler getting "purified" (or repenting at the last second) and going to Heaven, where he runs into his victims. How is that justice? If his victims feel anger or need to forgive him, then Heaven isn't a perfect place free of pain and conflict. If they feel nothing at all, then God had to lobotomize them, stripping away their memories and humanity.

The Mother Paradox: Imagine a mother in Heaven whose children are in Hell. If she feels sad missing them, Heaven isn't a place of pure bliss. If she doesn't care that her own children are being tortured, then Heaven is just a collection of lobotomized robots forced into artificial ecstasy.

Judaism and Islam in particular are very restrictive and this is why religious people defend this system out of jealousy. They spend their lives suppressing themselves to obey nonseless religions out of fear so they want free, non-believing people to suffer just to feel like their sacrifices weren't wasted.

Why create people just to torture them, or turn them into lobotomized robots in Heaven?


r/DebateReligion • • 10h ago

Islam The surah-like-it challenge argument is circular logic

2 Upvotes

The argument is begging the question because it says no mortal can or has ever written anything like the Quran, but when you refute the argument pointing out that Muhammad himself at least obviously did, as writing the Quran itself is also writing something like the Quran, you find that the muslim argument can’t accommodate that because it excludes that as a possibility, having started by denying that. However that denial is also the conclusion. You can’t prove what you already assume.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Christianity Christians hiding behind a "permit vs cause" distinction when trying to justify natural evils/suffering is nonsensical since they already believe God causes specific instances of natural suffering.

27 Upvotes

Christians already believe God sometimes directly inflicts natural disasters, disease, and calamity, and they already accept that these instances are perfectly "good". There's no reason to hide behind "oh, no, God is just permitting cancer." They ought to have the courage to say "yeah, God gave your daughter cancer, what of it? He had a morally sufficient reason to do it."

If God has a morally sufficient reason to permit, he has a morally sufficient reason to cause. There's no need to hide his culpability since Christians already think he has the right to do what he wants to his clay.

The Bible already includes examples of God inflicting disease and disaster. A true Christian shouldn't feel the need to try to absolve God of moral culpability by saying "he's just allowing it". Because it doesn't matter to you, you wouldn't care if he were permitting it; you'd justify it if he did it directly.

From a Christian standpoint, there should be no meaningful distinction between "God allowed those people to die of AIDS" and "God gave those people AIDS". Both should be justified via morally sufficient reasons. And yet Christians are hesitant to bite that bullet.

Why?


r/DebateReligion • • 10h ago

Christianity Jesus hates us all

0 Upvotes

Christians often tell us that Jesus loves all of us. Also, he will send any of us to hell to be tortured forever if we are not convinced he is the son of God at the moment of our deaths.

Since the vast majority of humanity won't be convinced he is the son of God at the moment of their deaths, that means he will send multiple billions of us to hell to be tortured forever. Because, you know, Jesus is God and God is love and He loves all of his creatures more than any of us can understand.

If that's what he does to us while he loves us, what would he do to us if he hated us?

Given that he will send most of us to hell - some say only 100,000 will be spared - it is much more likely he hates all of us more than any one of us can understand, because I wouldn't do to my worst enemy what he will do to me after I die.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Islam A challenge to Allah in response to the Quran challenge

35 Upvotes

Muslims will often point to the Quran’s challenge to produce something like it as evidence of its divine origin.
They claim that no one has ever met the challenge in the 1,400 years since the Quran has been revealed.

Well, I’d like to issue a challenge of my own to Allah. I challenge Allah to reveal a message so overwhelmingly convincing and compelling that every human being who reads it immediately converts to Islam.

I’m setting the parameters of this challenge, just as Allah supposedly does with the Quran’s challenge. If Allah is omniscient, he already knows what I’m asking. If he’s all-powerful, he should have no problem meeting my challenge. Therefore, if he doesn’t meet it, I’ll consider my challenge unanswered and Allah unsuccessful.


r/DebateReligion • • 23h ago

Other When You Discover Your Religion Was Wrong

8 Upvotes

Hello folks! Happy weekend :)

First of all, I'd like to clarify that I respect all faiths and studying different religions is one of my hobbies. I like exploring them, forming theories, and finding common facts between them.

There's one question that's been itching my mind for a long time.

What if after death, a person discovers that the religion they followed wasn't the right one? Now they're standing in front of God, going through judgement. What would they say to justify themselves?

Well, I'm unable to ask this question to people in real life because I don't want to meet God this soon XD

But since I don't follow any single religion, I can't really predict what the most likely response would be. I feel only someone who genuinely follows a particular faith can tell me what would come from their heart in that situation

I've tried putting myself in their shoes, imagining that I follow one religion and eventually discover that I was wrong. My response would probably be something like:

"Well, it was my mistake to assume that the religion I was born into was the right one. But life never really gave me the opportunity, circumstances, or perhaps the understanding to discover the right path. Now that I'm here, I realise I was wrong. There's nothing I can do about it anymore. I guess I'll have to face whatever comes next."

Something along those lines?

I know that's probably a pretty foolish way of looking at it, which is exactly why I'd like to hear your opinions:D

People who genuinely follow a religion, what do you think you'd say to God if you found out that you had followed the wrong one your entire life? No need to tell your religion whatever it is. I would appreciate comments :)


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Islam Every act that Islam has has been borrowed from older religions and local myths

37 Upvotes

Almost nothing in the religion is original. Every major piece can be traced back to the exact cultures surrounding 7th-century Arabia.

  1. Borrowed from Pre-Islamic Arabian Paganism
    Circling the Kaaba and Kissing the Black Stone: Long before Islam, the Kaaba was a polytheistic shrine housing 360 idols and pagan tribes made annual pilgrimages to walk around it seven times and kiss the Black Stone.

Running Between Safa and Marwah: Pre-Islamic pagans ran between these two hills to honor two stone idols (Isaf and Na'ilah). Early Muslims were uncomfortable doing it because they knew it was a pagan ritual, which is why Quran 2:158 was revealed to tell them there was no blame in continuing it.

Stoning the Pillars and Animal Sacrifice: Throwing pebbles at pillars in Mina and slaughtering livestock during the sacred pilgrimage month were existing pagan rituals used to ward off evil spirits, which Islam kept and attached a new backstory to.

2. Borrowed from Persian Zoroastrianism
(Zoroastrianism was the dominant religion of the neighboring Persian Empire over 1,000 years before Islam)

Praying 5 Times a Day: Zoroastrians already prayed five times a day at set sun intervals (dawn, noon, afternoon, sunset, night) after washing their face, hands, and feet with water nearly identical to Wudu and the five daily Salat prayers.

The Sirat Bridge: Zoroastrianism taught that every soul must cross the Chinvat Bridge over hell, which narrows to the sharp edge of a blade for sinners and widens for the righteous.

The Night Journey (Isra and Mi'raj): The ancient Persian book Arda Viraf Namag tells the story of a righteous man guided by an angel through the seven levels of heaven, shown the tortures of hell and brought before God before returning to Earth.

3. Borrowed from Rejected Jewish and Christian Folklore

Baby Isa(Jesus) Speaking in the Cradle and Making Clay Birds (Quran 3:46–49): Neither of these stories is in the Christian Bible. Both come from the 2nd-century Infancy Gospel of Thomas and the Arabic Infancy Gospel, apocryphal stories Christians rejected as folklore.

Ibrahim Surviving a Fire (Quran 21:68–69): This story is absent from the Torah. It originated in a 2nd-century Jewish commentary (Genesis Rabbah) due to a rabbi mistranslating the Hebrew city name "Ur" as the word for "fire."

Dhul-Qarnayn and the Iron Wall (Quran 18:83–98): The story of a great king traveling to where the sun sets in a muddy spring and building an iron wall to trap Gog and Magog mirrors the 6th-century Syriac Alexander Legend, a popular adventure romance about Alexander the Great.

So my point is If an all-knowing Creator truly wrote it, there would be at least one concept that went beyond what desert tribes, Persian empires, and neighboring faiths already practiced. Because everything is borrowed from its immediate surroundings, the only logical conclusion is human authorship.


r/DebateReligion • • 9h ago

Islam The Quran is not in Arabic

0 Upvotes

The Quran is not in Arabic and Arabs are incapable of understanding it without the help of scholars/translations like everybody else.

Good morning to everyone except those who think I am the worst of creatures!

In previous posts I have shown that not only do the majority of Muslims not read the Quran translation and instead read the book in a language they don't understand - even those who are Arab don't understand it.

However, as it turns out, the Quran is not in Arabic - but Classical Arabic. Almost nobody speaks this form of Arabic.

The reason this matters is because Muslims and non-Muslims are gaslit into thinking that the Quran is in a form of Arabic that people actually speak. Arabs act superior because they have gaslit themselves into thinking they understand the Quran. But in reality, they are just as clueless as everybody else.

I will give the opportunity to any Arab to prove me wrong. Say "I understand the Quran word by word without the help of scholars or translation" and I will concede I am wrong.


r/DebateReligion • • 1d ago

Islam God saved a pagan Kaaba, yet let an Islamic one burn

11 Upvotes

In Islam, the Kaaba is considered the literal House of God on Earth and the most sacred site of worship. One of the most famous stories used to show God's active protection over the Kaaba is the Year of the Elephant Surah Al-Fil (Quran 105).
According to Islamic tradition, around 570 CE, the year Prophet Muhammad was born: the ruler Abraha marched on Mecca with an army and war elephants intending to destroy the Kaaba. The Quran states that God intervened directly by sending flocks of birds carrying stones of baked clay, turning Abraha's army into something like eaten straw.

This raises serious contradictions when we look at both external history and what happened to the Kaaba after the rise of Islam:

  1. No outside historical evidence for the miracle
    While Abraha was a real historical ruler in Yemen, there are zero contemporary Byzantine, Christian or South Arabian inscriptions mentioning him attacking Mecca, using war elephants or being wiped out by birds. In fact, surviving rock inscriptions suggest Abraha died over a decade before 570 CE.

  2. The Sieges of Mecca (683 CE & 692 CE)
    During the Second Islamic Civil War, Umayyad forces besieged Abdullah ibn al-Zubayr inside Mecca. In 683 CE, the Kaaba caught fire and its structure was severely burned and damaged while believers were taking refuge and worshipping there. In 692 CE, it was bombarded with catapults. No birds or miracles stopped the destruction.

  3. The Qarmatian Sack of Mecca (930 CE): During the Hajj pilgrimage in 930 CE, the Qarmatians attacked Mecca, massacred thousands of Muslim pilgrims inside the sanctuary while they were worshipping, threw corpses into the Zamzam Well and pried the Black Stone out of the Kaaba, holding it ransom for over twenty years. Again, there was no divine intervention to protect the worshippers or the building.

  4. The Great Flood of Mecca (1629 CE): Even without human armies or free will involved, heavy rains flooded Mecca in 1629 CE and collapsed the walls of the Kaaba entirely. It had to be completely rebuilt from the ground up by the Ottoman Sultan Murad IV.

  5. Even on an ordinary day, birds land on the roof and defecate on it and cleaning crews have to regularly wash and scrub it down just like any human made structure.

My question is: If the Kaaba is uniquely protected as God's house of worship, Why would God miraculously intervene to save it when it was still filled with pagan idols, yet allow it to be burned, looted, collapsed by rain and have worshippers slaughtered inside it after it became the center of Islam?