r/DebatePhilosophy • • Apr 01 '18

Under construction

5 Upvotes

This sub is under some new management: specifically, my management. I am working on making this sub into a respectable place to debate philosophy in a constructive, civil manner. It'll take a while.

Get in touch with me if you have any ideas.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Apr 03 '26

Sophists were right. (Kinda)

4 Upvotes

Im not going to say that all they were saying was right. But I think Subjectivism is the right way of looking at life. Everything we see is the result of our own individual perception, for instance what we see "right now" isn't right now as it takes time for the information to travel to your brain for you to actually have seen the thing you're looking at. Thus it has already passed. Meaning that even at the basics we're a little off.

Im bad at philosophy so please explain your opinion.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Dec 30 '25

Why logic is right?

4 Upvotes

r/DebatePhilosophy • • Jul 09 '26

What lens did you make?

3 Upvotes

I find myself in a very interesting situation.

Let me start by saying:
Observing myself and others was something I always liked doing. Others were interesting because I did not really get what they were doing and why.
When I was younger I spoke a lot to others and myself. I usually felt like I what I expressed did not really resonate with my circle of acquaintances.
By that I mean what I saw with other people my environment, everything.
So I usually told it to myself.

During high school it started to bother me.
I started writing it down to improve my ability to express what I perceive.
Improving my ability to express myself revealed to me that my peers really did not appear to experience their environment in a similar way as I did.

During my time in high school I never really figured out how to teach myself something to the point where I felt satisfied.
Starting uni a year ago I decided to find out how I could learn better. I bought the book "Make it Stick" (Peter C. Brown, Henry L. Roediger, III, and Mark A. McDaniel) which I found to be very insightful.

In a uni course lecture called "history of the concept of algorithms" course Bertrand Russel was mentioned.
At the time I read "Fahrenheit 451" and in there he and his essays are mentioned by one the book people who remember books.
I got curious and read about him and started reading his book "Philosophy".

It could be described as:
"The book aims to provide a framework for understanding reality and our place within it, emphasizing the importance of rigorous analysis and critical thinking." ~ Gutenberg Project.

I found the book to be really refreshing. I loved the precision with which he described things. I found many of his descriptions of how one behaves or perceives to be resonating with me.
Examples:
~ When we think we understand a process—I mean by “we” the non-reflective part in each of us—what really happens is that there is some sequence of events so familiar through past experience that at each stage we expect the next stage. ~
(Page 224)
~ When several people simultaneously watch a rat in a maze, or any other example of what we should naturally regard as matter in motion, there is by no means complete identity between the physical events which happen at the surface of their eyes and constitute the stimuli to their perceptions. There are differences of perspective, of light and shade, of apparent size, and so on, all of which will be reproduced in photographs taken from the places where the eyes of the several observers are. These differences produce differences in the reactions of the observers—differences which a quite unthinking person may overlook, but which are familiar to every artist. Now it is contrary to all scientific canons to suppose that the object perceived, in addition to affecting us in the way of stimulus and reaction, also affects us directly by some mystical epiphany; certainly it is not what any behaviourist would care to assert. Our knowledge of the physical world, therefore, must be contained130 in our reaction to the stimulus which reaches us across the intervening medium; and it seems hardly possible that our reaction should have a more intimate relation to the object than the stimulus has. Since the stimulus differs for different observers, the reaction also differs; consequently, in all our perceptions of physical processes there is an element of subjectivity. If, therefore, physics is true in its broad outlines (as the above argument supposes), what we call “perceiving” a physical process is something private and subjective, at least in part, and is yet the only possible starting-point for our knowledge of the physical world. ~ (Page 224 <)

The difference between how science describes ones environment and how I experience it is fascinating to me.
How reality was described and how it appear to me and how it felt.

I began to rediscover how I experienced my "reality".
My diary filled itself with all kinds of observations about how I felt, what I experienced.

When I touch my hand or look at it there are no cells visible to me. It just appears to be smooth and soft skin.
But I know from my biology class that they are there. I have seen them under a microscope myself.
I tested myself in all sorts settings and observed myself.

How I was able to evoke emotions in myself when I did a certain set of actions.

What I noticed with myself I started seeing in other people too.
I tested where their field of view appeared to end. What kind of noise they were able to hear and other things.
I had and still am having a blast doing that.
So essentially I rediscovered in a way how I experience my "reality".

After discovering this I was letting my new found perspective rest for a while.
The question I asked myself was: "What do I do with this now?".
I noticed that actually nothing had changed in a way. 

That I am able actually perceive what my senses can pick up has not changed.
My ability to experience only what happens at a given moment had also not changed.

So I figured I would just do more of the things that gave me interesting moments and only those and discovering new ones how ever they might look.

An older man on train looking in to the landscape.
Being able to perform pull up which I could not do before.
Writing code I could not understand before.
Eating a meal I cooked and lighting a candle for dinner on my balcony.
Buying a pain au chocolat as a reward for learning for uni on a given day.
Learning Spanish.
And whenever I like I can just sit there and start laughing.

That is what I mean when I say this all highly amusing.

I started regarding all moments as equal.
That made the present one I was in at any given time the most important one.
It started to matter a bit less what I was actually doing. I appear to able to find something interesting in almost all of them.

I am either in a moment preparing one or recovering from one.
I like calling it moment trichotomy.

My assumption is that this is kind of how it is until one stops perceiving.

I like this perspective. I think it works really well for me and I intend to keep it until find a new one or something to add.

Having talked about the perspective I like to maintain, I want to mention a few things I have noticed to contort it.

I noticed that other peoples faces, photos and mirrors have the ability to move my point of view.
With other people it used to be the case that I would see myself how I imagined the person l was looking at was seeing me.
The difference between fotos and videos of myself and how I felt in that moment was something that bothered me.
The shots and other peoples faces appeared to have the effect of overwriting what I perceived in that moment or how I remembered the moment.
So I changed my behavior so it did not really happen anymore.

For a while I was not looking at any reflections nor pictures of myself.
It was extremely amusing seeing myself and remembering that my shell looked the way it did. It was like seeing a friend by chance.

I also noticed that when among people at times I am unable to tell the difference between what a person is saying, what think the person is saying and what I am thinking.
Especially when I was younger this overwhelmed me at times.

That was confusing to me for a while. The idea of someone else's thoughts potentially could appear in my head even if I did not want them appeared to be an inconvenient feature.

I found resolve in treating them as my own. I figured: "I am able to manipulate my own thoughts, so having additional ones to mine does not make a massive difference.".

Because I was unable to feel a line or boundary at times between other peoples expressions and my thinking, which the physicality could suggests, I started imagining them as ghosts.
I separated their physical identity from what I felt in my head.

This might described as perceptive hygiene because making sure I am able to perceive well.

The funny thing is that this has led to more genuine and interesting conversations.
I tend to only speak when I can not keep my thoughts to myself anymore.
My comfort while sitting in silence was greatly increased in the process of figuring out how long I would take until I could not contain myself.

Describing this with with a physical example around is maybe the best explanation.
This also works with thoughts and just imagining things without moving significantly.
Consider the following situation:

I am at a festive gathering with white table cloths and nicely dressed people in former European factory building. I am with a group of about 6 people.

While entering I would figure out where everything was. Where the wardrobe is, the outside areas, the buffet and so on.

The gathering would start and take its course with food and things happening on the stage.

I would behave inconspicuous. I would do that to keep a very polite and predictable environment.

Eventually I would get up and just start walking until I saw something interesting.
Like a musician playing his saxophone.
Then I would focus on that fascination and feel it.
At some point I feel like moving on again and it is important to do that right away.
So I move until I found the next thing.
Then I go until I found the next thing for example going outside of the venue and looking at a tree where a crow would sit.
When I start walking I usually have no clue where I am going.

I noticed that at some point the subject was not really that important.
The wandering and me interpreting it was the interesting part.

Wether it was a person having a nice purse, a crow on a tree against the night sky or the plants outside of the factory building growing over the unused space.

And I never really feel the desire to tell anyone about it. It is just perfect like that.
I like doing it just for the moments I get while doing it.

When doing that sometimes I think I notice a person experiencing something similar. Seeing the same saxophonist or crow.
Looking in the same direction or any other clue.
Even then usually do not feel the desire to point it out. Just noticing this apparent similar perspective is interesting enough or even more fun.

If I do start talking to a person like that I would never be explicit about the crow for example. Being explicit would also break the experience. If I were to be explicit in that moment it would be like turning on the big light in my meticulously dimmed perception. 

Doing what I described is addictive and I love doing it.

Most people I know do not appear to facilitate this play with perception actively.
I noticed most really like trying to communicate their experience. Talk about it.
I find doing this is useful for coordinating and giving an idea to the other person or persons.
I prefer to only do it with people where I feel like there is a possibility of having the moment where I feel like the other person is experiencing a very similar moment at the same time.
I am very strict with this because I noticed that otherwise the other person gets confused and wasted my time I could have spent better.

This has led people asking me if I feel reservations to talking which I do not.

When I speak I appear to be well received.

What I experience one might call consciousness. Wether that is "real" or not does not really concern me me.
I think of myself as just a slightly more advanced and less harry ape.

I find that doing this might the most interesting thing I may spend my time on.

While reasoning about this is something I find very important and take seriously I enjoy expressing it in a playful way because I that enables me to keep moving and thinking.
This is obviously not scientific and is not trying to be.
I think of what I describe as description of percepts informed by the apparent mechanisms described by science.

Which leads me onto my intention for sharing this.

I am explicitly interested in how some of you may experience their "reality".
How you interpret it.
Questions like:

What kind of lens have you crafted through which you describe what is happening in your perceptive space?
Are there domains you find particularly fascinating to experience?
What have you noticed messes with your perspective?
How do like playing with that perception?

Do with this as you please.

Gruß;)


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Jun 03 '26

Is wonder the first catalyst of meaning?

3 Upvotes

Many philosophers agree that meaning and purpose often arise when we live an authentic, free life aligned with our values. Helping others, realizing the effects of our actions, and improving ourselves can also make us feel like what we do has a goal.

However, to me, these arguments seem like chasing an endless road, hoping to reach its end. These things always require either a future to look forward to, or a past that can give a reason for things to exist. The only exception to this, I think, is wonder (or the general feeling of awe).

When we experience wonder, we experience meaning. We are not pursuing a future goal or a final purpose, and we are not searching for the catalyst of all that has happened. We simply exist, alongside everything else. From passive observation, curiosity is born, driving us to try to understand something new. We live.

Could it be that all of our "meaningful" actions require wonder? Could it be that we feel purpose in helping people, so that they might experience wonder again? Could it be that aligning with our values makes us perceive meaning in our actions, so that we may build a world where people are free to experience wonder?

Could wonder be the catalyst of all meaningful things?


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Apr 18 '26

What is the “Purpose of Life?”

3 Upvotes

Most people treat purpose like a destination, something out ahead of them, waiting to be found if they think hard enough or look in the right places. That framing feels intuitive. But it contains a quiet assumption that turns out to be wrong: that the shape of your life can be understood before you’ve lived it.

It can’t. Not because the answer is hidden, but because the structure it emerges from isn’t fully visible yet. You’re not standing outside your life, surveying it from a distance. You’re inside it, moving through conditions you didn’t choose circumstances, people, opportunities that appear and close without warning. Any “purpose” you try to fix in advance is built on incomplete information, which means it will need to keep being revised, which means it was never quite the fixed thing you thought it was.

What people later call purpose doesn’t arrive as a revelation. It becomes visible in hindsight, when a sequence of events is finally far enough behind you to see as a whole. While you were living those moments, they didn’t feel unified. They felt ordinary, uncertain, often unrelated. Decisions got made without full clarity. Most of it didn’t seem to matter much. Then later, looking back, it coheres, not because it was always going somewhere, but because you can now trace the shape it made.

That shape wasn’t there at the beginning. It formed as you moved.

This is why waiting to understand your purpose before doing anything creates a false problem. Clarity isn’t the prerequisite for movement. Movement is what produces whatever clarity eventually comes. Even the attempt to pause and figure it out is itself a move, you’re already participating, already accumulating consequences, already inside the process whether you’ve named it or not.

And most of what your actions produce, you’ll never see. Immediate effects are visible. Short-term ripples, sometimes. But beyond that, what you do continues moving through other people, other situations, chains of events that extend well past anything you can observe. Purpose, in that sense, is larger than your own perspective on it. It isn’t contained. You can’t fully know it even as it’s happening through you.

None of this requires awareness to function. You don’t need to know what your purpose is for it to already be present in the way you live and what you put into the world. The need to name it comes from the desire for certainty, which is understandable. But the absence of a clear answer doesn’t interrupt what’s already unfolding.

So the question “what is my purpose?” starts to dissolve once you look at it directly. It assumes purpose is something separate from your life, a thing you locate and then follow. But there’s no such separation. There’s only the ongoing movement: actions taken under uncertainty, consequences you can’t fully trace, patterns that become readable only in retrospect.

You don’t find purpose. You don’t construct it in advance and then execute it. It’s what forms as you go, and it was already forming before you thought to ask.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Mar 27 '26

The Performative Contradiction of Institutional Progressivism and the Moral Necessity of Exit

3 Upvotes

Thesis: The Performative Contradiction of Institutional Progressivism and the Moral Necessity of Exit

I. Introduction

I want to be transparent before making this argument: I am writing this from the middle — not because I am politically moderate by default, but because I have been to both ends and came back. I'm currently leaning more right than left.

I have held these values genuinely at different points from different positions. I have been left. I have been right. What I observed at both side of the spectrum was the same underlying pathology: the further you travel in either direction, the worse the anosognosia gets. The diminished capacity to recognize your own contradictions. The certainty that your blind spots don't exist. The inability to receive criticism as anything other than attack.

I am in the middle now not because it is comfortable — it isn't — but because it is the only place I have found with a clear enough view to see the terrain honestly. I still hold the core values: equality, pluralism, the belief that arguments should be judged on their merits rather than the identity of the person making them. I am still working out what I believe on many things. But what I cannot do is be complicit in the pre-conventional behavior of institutions that claim to represent those values while systematically violating them.

That experience — of holding the values sincerely, examining them seriously, and watching the institutions that claim ownership of them fail their own standard — is the origin of this argument. I am not attacking progressivism from the outside. I am describing a contradiction I observed by being the test case. The moment my thinking became hard to categorize, the institutions I had trusted to model pluralism responded not with curiosity, but with the social mechanics of a closed system. Dissent wasn't engaged. It was diagnosed.

My exit is not the argument. My exit is the evidence.

My contention is that institutional progressivism currently operates under a performative contradiction: a state where the actions required to participate in the institution systematically undermine the very values the institution claims to uphold. Further, I will argue this contradiction is not merely accidental — it flows from internal logical flaws in the worldview itself. And I will argue that this same pathology is possible in any institution that travels far enough from self-examination.

II. Definitions and Premises

  1. Progressive Values (V): A set of post-conventional moral commitments including epistemic humility, pluralism (tolerance of genuine difference), and the evaluation of arguments based on merit rather than identity.

  2. Institutional Practice (P): The actualized norms of modern progressive spaces, characterized by epistemic closure (dismissal of dissent), status-based discourse (ad hominem evaluation), and in-group signaling.

  3. Performative Contradiction: A conflict between the content of a statement and the act of making it. In this context, it is the conflict between the professed values of the institution and the required behaviors for membership.

III. The Internal Logical Flaws

Before reaching the performative contradiction, I want to identify two prior paradoxes embedded in the worldview itself:

  1. The Paradox of Superiority: Institutional progressivism claims a commitment to egalitarianism — the belief that all perspectives have equal standing. Yet it simultaneously asserts that its own worldview is morally and intellectually superior to all others. This creates a hierarchy of value that is, by definition, non-egalitarian.

  2. The Inclusivity-Exclusion Paradox: The movement defines itself through inclusivity, yet employs social ostracization to maintain ideological purity. The result is a "pluralism" that tolerates identity-based differences while systematically punishing viewpoint-based ones. It includes the person while excluding the dissenting mind.

These are not peripheral failures — they are structural. They suggest the contradiction is not a bug but a load-bearing feature.

IV. The Argument

  • Premise 1: If an institution's practices (P) systematically contradict its stated values (V), then membership in that institution constitutes a performative contradiction.

  • Premise 2: Institutional progressivism currently exhibits (P) through epistemic closure and status-based discourse, which are direct negations of (V).

  • Premise 3: To remain a member of an institution while recognizing this contradiction is to become complicit in the erosion of (V). Membership lends credibility to the institution and reinforces its contradictory norms.

  • Premise 4: A commitment to (V) at a post-conventional level requires value-consistency. One cannot claim to value pluralism while participating in an institution that systematically punishes it.

The Bind: If I remain, I am endorsing claims I know to be false in practice — participating in the very undermining of the equality I care about. If I exit, the institution reinterprets principled critique as betrayal, which is itself the final confirmation of epistemic closure.

V. Conclusion: Exit as Fidelity, Not Apostasy

Therefore, for an individual whose primary commitment is to (V) rather than to the institution itself, exit is not apostasy or a shift in values. It is an act of fidelity.

The exit resolves the performative contradiction. If the institution has devolved into pre-conventional behaviors — in-group loyalty, social approval, ideological policing — while claiming post-conventional status, the only way to maintain a genuine post-conventional commitment is to refuse complicity in the institution.

VI. Final Observation

The inability of the institution to receive this exit as principled critique — rather than betrayal — is itself the closing evidence. It demonstrates that the "inclusive" circle is in practice a closed loop: one that can only recognize dissent as defection. This confirms the original diagnosis.

And it is worth stating plainly: this pathology is not unique to progressivism. It is what happens to any ideology — left, right, or otherwise — when institutional loyalty displaces self-examination. The extremes mirror each other more than either would care to admit.

Discussion Question for the Sub: Can a worldview that claims to be "egalitarian" and "pluralistic" ever be logically consistent if it maintains a moral superiority complex that justifies the exclusion of dissent? Or is the "Inclusivity Pariah" dynamic — where the most committed pluralist becomes the outsider — an inevitable feature of any institutionalized ideology?


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Feb 03 '26

Looking for peer review on my philosophy about Entropic Coherence

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
3 Upvotes

Entropic Coherence Theory (ECT) is a framework for understanding how systems persist, develop, and collapse under the universal constraint of entropy. It treats entropy as unavoidable, negentropy as temporary local resistance, and coherence as a system’s ability to manage the tension between the two across time.

ECT argues that life, intelligence, morality, and technology do not oppose entropy globally—they accelerate it by increasing energy throughput. Coherence enables meaning and complexity, but under stress it can invert into anti-coherence: order maintained through extraction, control, or degradation of the environment.

Time, in this model, is not fundamental—it emerges from unresolved tension. The past is resolved tension, the future unresolved tension, and the present an ongoing negotiation between them.

ECT isn’t a metaphysical claim about ultimate reality. It’s a diagnostic framework for understanding persistence, power, ethics, and collapse in biological, cognitive, and social systems.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Nov 03 '25

Can any materialist solve this dillema?

3 Upvotes
  1. Is the thought of materialism real? If you say no, then materialism is self-refuting because it’s a worldview that can’t even claim to be thought. There are no real thoughts. That collapses into eliminative materialism, which denies the reality of beliefs, qualia, intentions, etc. But if there are no beliefs, then the materialist doesn’t “believe” in materialism; the statement self-destructs.

  2. If so, is that thought material? If the thought of materialism is just a pattern of neural activity, then we must ask how that pattern could mean anything. The firing of neurons is purely physical, while the content of the thought, its meaning, truth, and “aboutness” is not physical at all. Matter can describe motion and energy, but not meaning, so reducing thought to matter erases the very thing that makes it a thought. For example, you can think of a bird, but if I cut open your brain, there won't be a bird.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Aug 22 '21

Psychological egoism is true

3 Upvotes

What I mean:

Claim 1: Self-interest as the fundamental reason for all human actions
Psychological egoism is true, meaning that all human behavior is driven by the self-interest of that person.

More in detail: when a person acts altruistically they do it either becasue (1) they want to make friends with the person who they did the deed to, or because (2) they want to make themselves look "good" to the people who show the thing. In the first possibility the act seeks self-interest becasue it seeks reward or compensation from the person who is now in need of help. In the second possibility the act seeks self-interest becasue it was done to impress others, meaning to brand the person ding the act as a person who the people seeking the act should want to have around, so that the person doing the act could now benefit from the company of these people.

The second possibility also includes God or gods as the subject who sees the act, and hence even religiously motivated acts of altruism are actual egoistical in nature.

Claim 2: Quest for power as the diving force behind all human behavior
All human behavior can be understood as stemming from quest for power.

Okay, so what I mean by power in this context is maybe best explained with examples:

  • We all need to die which can be seen as an lack of power to resist death. This means that the power or ability to escape death would be true power in this context.

  • Life has suffering and pain which when present in a life can be seen as lack of power to escape that suffering. This means that the power or ability to escape that suffering would be true power in this context. Also the lack of pleasure can be also seen as suffering, so the behavior of seeking pleasure can be understood as being the same as the behavior of avoiding pain, hence making the pleasure seeking behavior also behavior motivated by power.

  • We as humans can't fly which can be seen as lack of power to fly. This means that the power or ability to fly would be true power in this context.

So as you may understand from these examples, by "power" I mean the ability to do something or the ability to avoid a certain outcome, becasue this power empowers the person to force the reality to favor their self-interest, and hence all humans seek their self-interest though the quest for power.

Arguments for the thesis

Argument 1: Huge predictive power
When philosophical egoism is assumed one gains an huge gain in their ability to predict the outcomes of social situations and behavior, which when the prediction is shown to be true, validates philosophical egoism.

Example:
When someone shows an interest in being your friend philosophical egoism predicts that they do this because they see that you could help to empower them. In other words, they see that you possess beneficial attributes regarding self-empowerment and hence if the person gain new evidence for you not actually possessing these qualities, they will lose their interest in you.

To test this prediction one needs to demonstrate to that person who seeks to be their friend that they don't possess any qualities suitable for self-empowerment and according to philosophical egoism, this will make the person lose inters in them.

If the outcome favoring philosophical egoism isn't obvious to everyone now, let me give you an concrete examples:

  • Woman approaches a man who she thinks is rich becasue they seek empowerment from his wealth and when the man tells the woman that he isn't actually rich, the woman will lose their interest.

  • Man approaches another man who they think is popular becasue they want to be seen with him so that other people would associate him with this popular person so that they would think that he is also somewhat popular (utilizing the halo effect), the person approaching will lose their interest if they learn that the man who they thought were popular isn't actually popular at all.

Argument 2: the anti-thesis of philosophical egoism leads to absurdities
Because the thesis for philosophical egoism is that

all human behavior is driven by the self-interest of that person.

to not accept this is to claim that human could be motivated to do something by absolutely nothing. This however is absurd becasue we do not see anyone being motivated by absolutely nothing, becasue even our very language assumes an intention for all behavior, becasue when someone is asked Why you do that, the answer I have no reason is though as admitting that they shouldn't do it, becasue not having a reason makes the action useless. So in other words, becasue our language assumes that uselessness is a bad thing, our language presumes philosophical egoism.

Argument 3: People have a conflict of interest to admit philosophical egoism
One more argument for philosophical egoism is the fact that the opposition to it has an self-interest in opposing it, becasue to admit philosophical egoism as the thing according to which one behaves, one has admitted that they have ulterior motives for their actions and hence they have in a sense labelled themselves as a bad person aka not sincere. This creates a conflict of interest for people to be dishonest regarding their own behavior which then makes honestly about the reality of physiologic egoism difficult.

In other words, even if philosophical egoism would be true and obvious to everyone, people would still be denying it becasue denying it serves their self-interest because coming across as sincere is socially advantageous in relationship to coming across as manipulative and having ulterior motives.

Counter arguments:

Counter argument 1: The origin of thoughts might be supernatural and hence philosophical egoism commits circular reasoning
Altruism might stem from the internal voice which is the voice of the Spirit of Goodness in humans and hence if so we wouldn't be dealing with Naturalistic things when it comes to the origins of thoughts but supernatural things. In other words, becasue physiological egoism assumes that the origin of thoughts is natural, it presumes Naturalism and hence its conclusion is only valid if in fact Naturalism is true. This means that philological egoism is circular reasoning in the context of agnosticism regarding Theism and Atheism, since it presumes Naturalism which is only valid if Atheism is presumed also.

My answer:
True that this might be the case, but if it is the case then why does even the religions themselves provide real reward for following this voice of Goodness? Like it would seem like religions themselves presume philosophical egoism as the model according to which humans behave, becasue they try to modify the expression of this human nature (philosophical egoism) by promising rewards after the death instead people seeking their rewards while alive.

This while model seems to presume philosophical egoism instead of demolishing it, which then means that even though thoughts would come from external spirits it wouldn't change the fact that we as humans would be evaluating these thoughts through the lens of philosophical egoism.

So to me it seems that this is the reason why "faith" is so important for religions, becasue religions understand that all humans operate according to a certain logical model so that if a person believes something then a certain outcome is most likely, instead of people being inherently good and evil so that the evil ones would only be operating according to philosophical egoism where as the good ones would be just good without having any logical model of deciding what to do.

Counter argument 2: Philosophical egoism is unfashionable and hence not a credible theory
Philosophical egoism is unfashionable becasue one has an infinite supply of explanation for why someone's apparent altruistic act could have been just an selfish act in disguise. This means that becasue philosophical egoism can explain all outcomes and humans actions as being potentially due to selfish reasons, there is no potential human action which if occurring, could falsify philosophical egoism.

My answer:
This is true, but as with all unfalsifiable theories so also with this one - even though it can't be falsified evidence for it can still be gathered because how well it predicts the outcome. Like more the primary prediction happens, instead of the secondary (which the model can also predict), the more the theory gain credibility.

Also, isn't the alternative to philosophical egoism also unfalsifiable? Like just as you can accuse philosophical egoism of not being falsifiable the same way you can accuse the alternative to it of the same, because it also can explain all outcomes so that there is no possible human behavior which could falsify the mode.

So in a nutshell all this just means is that we are dealing with paradigms and not with theories, becasue neither side is verifiable nor falsifiable. So basically the debate over philosophical egoism and the philosophical altruism has the same nature to it as the debate over Naturalism and Supernaturalism aka Theism and Atheism, which on the other hand DOES NOT mean that one of these wouldn't be true. Like even though philosophical egoism might be a paradigm instead of a theory, it could still be true, so rejecting it just because it is unfalsifiable isn't logical.

Closing words

Like I understand that I may have fallen a bit short from establishing the claim in the title, but I still hope this post will inspire some discussion on the matter, because I for sure have found great advantage in looking the reality through the lens of philosophical egoism.

Also, if someone does oppose philosophical egoism and thinks that they can articulate this position of theirs coherently as if making their model into an theory which carries similar predictions on human behavior as philosophical egoism, I would be most interested of heating this alternative position, because as things stand now, I see the philosophical egoism

  1. as the only one making these useful predictions and

  2. as the only one being articulated coherently as if answering the question of what dives all human behavior

and hence at the moment I can't escape the reality of seeing it as the superior model.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Jul 20 '21

What do you guys think is more probable?

3 Upvotes

A) that the explosion in the human population has caused us to accept subjectivity more than objectivity as a result of more potential differences in perspectives leading to different views of the world

Or

B) that this explosion has caused us to accept subjectivism, because the increasing differences in opinions is because all things are absolutely subjective

I will refrain from giving my input to let this debate be as unfiltered as possible.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • 9d ago

The problems of language

2 Upvotes

I realised that language strips and alters the meanings of things so they come twisted to our minds. Languages do have case systems and other features that help make the meaning more precise but it's not enough. My native language is Czech, I'd consider it a very precise language: it has 7 cases, 3 noun genders (to differentiate concepts), declensions, etc. I still find problems in it. For example today I was reading and saw the statement „A následuje B” - ‘A is followed by B’ / ‘B is followed by A’. Since the verb ‘follows’ doesn't have a modal verb and letters aren't declined (same as male un-alive nouns) in Czech, the meaning of this sentence is impossible to determine right without a proposition.

Functionality

I believe that a language that would be stripped of all poetry would be powerful and great for science, arguments and philosophy. People say many metaphors because they fear the reality (bite the dust, a tree is putting on its autumn coat, etc.) or because they find reality boring. When language is rotten to the marrow with metaphors, explaining reality may become more complicated and difficult.

Poetry

Poetry on the other hand is one gargantuan metaphor. It exists to export feelings rather than information (but it can't make one's emotions be comprehended by someone else entirely the same; if someone made a poem that would make me feel exactly as the author, I'd consider them the greatest poet of all time). Poetry makes us humans. It stimulates something inside us, that makes us feel either the rhythm, meaning or emotions of the poem. Without poetry or art we wouldn't be humans but animals.

Conclusion

Our normal language is like an intricate column of a sculptor. It would serve its purpose the same (maybe better because you wouldn't have to pay for the sculptor) as if it were just a flat column. The equivalent of poetry would be a sculpture, unnecessary for functional life but stimulating our sense of beauty.

  1. What do you think about this? Is this a problem worthy of looking into or it's just a little too much petty?

  2. Do you know any language that would be the closest to reality? If no, how would you structure one?

  3. Are there any philosophers that wrote about this theme into more depth?


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Jun 16 '26

I was accepted to philosophy college.

2 Upvotes

Hi, I am new here and yesterday I was on college interview. I was accepted and in less then 4 months I will be sitting in class learning about philosophy. I studied Economy high school where philosophy was only in last year, our teacher wasn't big fan of philosophy and so we just learned about antics philosophy. But even this small amount of philosophy was the only thing I enjoyed in school. My long time dream is to write movies and books, maybe the better option was to go study literature or directly a film school but due to personal issues i am not able at the time to do so. So I have decided to attend 3 years on philosophy, I believe it will help me to work with my thoughts and be able to write. I have never read a philosophy book, I read books where philosophy was, almost everywhere we can find philosophy but not like in pure philosophy book. I was thinking to start with Stranger from Albert Camus and White Nights from Dostoyevsky, when I mentioned those two books on interview I was told that it's not bad but it's not exactly the kind of book that they expect us to read in school. So I want to ask for some tips and ideas where to start. Plus will I have a time to read also my own books during my time on college? And to practice fictional writing so maybe after I graduate I could go fo film school?

The reason I ask Is because I want have picture of what should I expect and prepare myself for it, make some plans that will work cause they are grounded


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Mar 30 '26

My theory of divine exhaustion.

2 Upvotes

Before we had time or space there was singularity some may refer to it as God.. the state of absolute, static perfection. However this state for some reason wasn't a desirable one hence big bang creating this observable universe and everything we know of from distant galaxies to it's governing principals and laws of physics.

God must have felt claustrophobic with its own perfect state.

So big bag was not an act of joyous creation as beautifully explaned by Philipp Mainländer. It was more of an act resembling sucide.

The Goal: To reach the "Reward" of Nothingness (Oblivion). The Obstacle: The sheer scale of the universe. Left to its own natural laws, the "rotting corpse" of the divine would take trillions of years to decay into total entropy

While Philipp Mainländer didn't see human life to have any significance in this entire drama I think we as humans may have a very significant role to play

Entropy (the breakdown of order into heat and chaos) is the literal measurement of God’s progress toward salvation. Every star that burns out and every atom that decays is a step closer to the "Off-Switch."

Life and consciousness are not "accidents." We are the God Spec—a biological and technological "Super-Virus" designated to speed up the process.Living things are entropy machines. We take organized energy and turn it into waste heat much faster than a rock or a gas cloud ever could.As we evolve from a planetary civilization to a galactic one (Kardashev Type I, II, and III), our energy consumption explodes. We are here to strip-mine the stars and "burn" through the universe’s resources at an industrialized pace.

In my view, extinction is the ultimate failure. If we die out now, the universe returns to a "slow burn," prolonging God's suffering for eons. We must prioritize longevity, expansion, and evolution at all costs—not because life is "sacred," but because we are the only ones capable of finishing the demolition.

Sustainability is just a tool to ensure we survive long enough to reach the level of technology required to trigger the final "Exhale" into non-existence.

The Core Philosophy "We are the fuse. We must burn bright and spread far, so that the fire of existence consumes itself as quickly as possible, finally granting the Divine the peace of Nothingness."

I think I know why is there place for intelligent life to even exist it wasn't a mere accident.

There is a link if u connect the dots.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Mar 21 '26

Determinism, Free Will, and Egoism

2 Upvotes

I have yet to see compelling arguments against these theories (which I'm quite fond of). Would like a debate with someone about these topics, or examples of attempts to refute these theories.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Feb 12 '26

The Theseus Paradox is not a paradox

2 Upvotes

The Theseus Paradox says that if you replace the boards of a ship one by one until you replaced them all, is it the same ship? The paradox doesn't seem to have a complete answer but the answer seems simple to me: It depends on what you define for "same".

If "same" is "it has to have the same exact parts" then no. If "same" is have identical shape, then yes. It just depends on the definition. Same needs two things to be compared between each other to find a match. There's no paradox there, only if you think "same" is something absolute, but it's a relative thing.

For example, this car is the same as this other car can mean that they are the same model, and you would say "yes". But then one of those is your car and then you would answer "no".

In one the "same" is comparing car models. In the other the "same" is comparing car ownership. Both are correct, the difference is the definition of "same", which is not the same in both cases. So there's no paradox, the ship is the same if you define same as the same owner for example, but it is not if you say "same" is to have the same exact planks.

"Same" is not absolute, it's a relative thing. The paradox comes when you think it's absolute. When comparing things you gotta define what you are comparing.

Do you agree? Or am I missing something?


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Jan 13 '26

What do you think is the worst human characteristic trait?

2 Upvotes

The worst characteristic trait is, by far, closed-mindedness. A closed-minded person is unreceptive to new ideas and only believes in what they think is true, nothing else. A closed-minded man will ignore all thoughts, ideas, beliefs, etc that come from another conscious being unless they match his own. My reasoning for why I think closed-mindedness must be, by far, the worst characteristic trait is simply because we would not have mentally evolved, technologically evolved, we would not have developed in most senses if we were all closed-minded

Think about this for a second. If from the beginning of human consciousness we were all closed-minded, with no new thoughts and/or ideas other than those which would have originally been implemented into our minds at the beginning of human consciousness, then we would simply implement our closed-minded thoughts, ideas, and beliefs into our children's minds, and our children would do the same with theiur children, so on, and so forth. There would be an endless, infinite cycle of consciousness with the same thoughts, same ideas, same beliefs, etc. Would anything new come from humans? Any new thoughts? Any new ideas? Any new beliefs? Any new anything? Chances are, probably not. If we use what I've just said, then an offspring 1000 years in the future, mentally (and considering there are no catastrophic events on Earth), would technically be the same as every single one of its ancestors, no matter how far back you go.

Now, this is an absurd speculation; however, the idea behind it is very clear. We would be nothing if we were all closed-minded and didn't think for ourselves. With no open minds, imaginative minds, self-thinking minds, there would be no theories, no religions, no ideas, no maths, no technology, no cosmic beliefs, and the list is infinite because our minds are infinite, and if we choose to close them, then we lower our capabilities by infinite.

That is why I think a closed mind is easily the worst characteristic a human being can have.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Jan 01 '26

An accumulation of phrases that my mind is pondering... id like to hear any insight you have on them!

2 Upvotes

"If a blind mand walks to a cliff would you stop them? If a blind mind runs to their doom.. why dont you stop them?"

"Who fixate their gaze atop the mountains peak will slip on the ice beneath their feet"

"If you burn the seeds in the fire Youll be lacking the wood required"

"A shallow puddle dries quickly"

"Those who watch where their steps will lose sight of where they are going"

These are notes i accumulated during the year And i wondered what are your thoughts? What do you understand from them? Does one struck a chord with you?


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Dec 03 '25

Orwellian philosophy — the relationship between men, women and The State

2 Upvotes

George Orwell once wrote women are always and inevitably on the side of the state.

He wasn't being misogynistic, he was making a psychological observation. In his view, women, particularly in their role as caregivers and moral enforcers, tend to prioritize safety and compassion over risk and freedom, and that instinct, while natural, is easily weaponized by totalitarian systems.

When conformity is marketed as compassion, control is rebranded as care, the state taps into the feminine psyche to enforce ideological obedience.

Now consider this: men will do almost anything to attract a mate, so when the state captures women through propaganda, redefining tyranny as empathy and compliance as virtue, men follow, especially those who can't compete in the traditional dating market, they feminize themselves and trade strength for submission. This is what evolutionary biologists call the “sneaky fucker” strategy.

Low status males mimicking feminine traits or moral positions in hopes of reproductive access. And while all of this unfolds, families disintegrate. Single motherhood, a top predictor of poverty and social dysfunction, becomes the norm.

Children from single parent homes are far less likely to climb the economic ladder, and who steps in as provider and protector? Not the father, the state. But here's the kicker, the state is funded disproportionately by men, so rather than supporting the women they married and raised children with directly, men subsidize the state, which in turn provides for women through social programs. Why? Because women have been propagandized to see every relationship as a power dynamic, except one with the state, which is ironically the centralization of raw power.

They've been told that to rely on a man is weakness, but to rely on a bureaucracy is empowerment. This is not progress. This is dependency with a new face. And both men and women are suffering. The childless middle aged woman and the incel are two sides of the same broken culture.

A woman without her own child often directs her maternal instinct towards abstract causes, infantilizing minorities under the guise of social justice. What we are witnessing from psychologically unwell men and women is Nietzsche's concept of resentiment. Envy dressed up as morality. The strong became evil. The weak became good.

Strength became tyranny. We now live in a pathologically soft society that sides even with those who harm it, where punishing crime feels unfair and victimhood is the highest virtue. Nietzsche called them the tarantulas, those who preach justice but act from bitterness. They don't want to uplift the weak, they want to drag down the strong. Orwell saw them too.

Most middle aged socialists, while theoretically pining for a classist society, cling like glue to their miserable fragments of social prestige. These bitter, well educated, and affluent types don't actually care about the downtrodden. They weaponize them. The real target is success, competence, independence, because those qualities expose their own inadequacies. But the answer to pathological femininity isn't pathological masculinity.

It's not swinging the pendulum too far in the other direction. The answer is balance. Masculinity and femininity are not enemies. They're symbiotic. We've simply overcorrected.

We escaped a world where masculinity once tyrannized femininity only to arrive in a world where femininity is tyrannizing masculinity. We are not oppressed by patriarchy, we are being suffocated by pathological softness, envy, and resentment. And unless we recognize this imbalance, the future will not be free. It will be emotionally manipulated, morally confused, and biologically unsustainable.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Nov 30 '25

Cat and The Man

2 Upvotes

A cat lying in the sun, rolling over side by side and kind of relaxation he have isn’t that the ultimate joy of life. The thing we have to understand is that – The unhappiness comes from not doing the rational things, not enjoying art, not having others. It only comes from the fact that we know that there is this other side but a cat doesn’t know that. So isn’t a cat’s life more joyful than a man’s life. But I have to accept the fact that I am only capable of thinking like this because of the uniqueness I have. And it is giving me similar joy as that of the cat who is stretching under sun gives. But the frequency and ease of access of that state is on larger scale more easier for cats. Because a human who worries what will he feed his child can’t attain a state like this but a cat very much can attain that state.

– This is one of the best way to spend time on earth ~ for me ~


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Nov 26 '25

You cannot outrun time, and this is scary

2 Upvotes

(I am 17yo french boy btw, yes the age matters)

Growing up. It's the kind of things that makes me sad. "Time", one day you can enter a subreddit, the very next morning you can't anymore (some subreddit are under 20yo only). I really don't want to grow up, as I don't want to become an adult (by adult I mean 30/40 years old), it genuinely scares me... Being old, starting having wrinkles, not being a young anymore... and idk, just... it feels scary to know that time is the only thing you can't outrun, you can't stop it... Scaring isn't ? One day you're with your family, the very next one, you assist the funerals of half of them, and the morning after that, your turn to die. And within a minute, nobody will remember you. Even your pictures or videos couldn't stay, they are made to being forgotten... and the worst is not that. The worst is your thoughts. Nobody is in your mind, once your dead, you can't explain yourself anymore. You can't tell people what you used to think, what you used to feel, leaving questions behind your dead body... Scary, isn't it ?

Also, if you have religious answer, you can tell them, but just know that i am a huge atheist, perhaps even a antéchrist. But I somehow still want to hear about your opinion if you have one. That, also, scares me. The void of complete nothingness post-death. It's not even "dark", it's literally nothing. No feelings. No view. Nothing. Nothing at all. A void that is so empty your brain can't even understand it. That scares me, because I am young and I lived nothing yet, because I am scared of death, because I want to be alive, and young. But I can't outrun time, and time will outrun me. And then, then... I will be old, full of memories, with pictures to remember my lost loved one... I am scared.

Thanks if you have ridden this until there !


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Oct 11 '25

What would happen if all leftist progressive goals are achieved? Is there a limit to social progress? Is there a risk that cultural deconstructivism might extend into other domains?

2 Upvotes

This is a dialogue about a hypothetical progressive dystopia that I found on a right-wing Italian website. Obviously, it's tied to their political context, but it also contains elements that may resonate internationally. I have attempted to translate it into English, and for terms that are difficult to render I included the original Italian word in parentheses: (orig. Italian word).
----------
(Inside a government building, a large and spacious window illuminates the entire room.)
(A man named Riccardo is seated at his desk with his hands clasped; another man named Benedetto enters through a door on the left.)

Benedetto: Hello, Riccardo.

Riccardo: Hello, Benedetto. How are you today?

Benedetto: (walking back and forth): Not bad, not bad at all. In fact, I must tell you, I am glad to be alive, glad to live in this country, in this world, in this very time. I’ve been doing Pilates lately, you know, it keeps you in shape! (clenching his fists) Not that being in shape is a priority, of course.

Riccardo: I’m happy for you, Benedetto. Since we won the elections and the Italian people gave us an absolute majority, we have, pardon the expression, overgoverned (orig. sgovernato). We have fulfilled all our greatest dreams, which are the dreams of a diverse and inclusive humanity. By the way, Benedetto, I thought I heard bangs, shots in the city this morning. Perhaps it was just my imagination, yes, surely it must have been my imagination. (pause) Did you come here to tell me something, Benedetto?

Benedetto: Ah yes, you see, Riccardo, our government is about to be overthrown in a violent insurrection.

Riccardo: I understand, and we have fought, we fight, and we shall fight against violence. But certainly, if these young people abandon themselves to such things, there must be deep reasons behind it, don’t you think, Benedetto?

Benedetto: Indeed I do.

Riccardo: Well then, it is up to us, who bear the responsibility, to try to understand what those justifications might be. (pause, doubtful expression) Are they perhaps right-wing?

Benedetto: Oh no! Heaven forbid, Riccardo! We did everything we could to repress those vile reactionary theories, those wrong ideas, devoid of reason, that with vain attempts tried to slow down the inexorable progress of humanity. And since they could not speak to the intellect, they spoke to the gut; they appealed to every basest, most irrational instinct of the ignorant masses, and the people followed them. In that moment, I almost doubted democracy itself, but now, fortunately, they have repented.

Riccardo (pointing a finger): They are the best at identifying problems, but the worst at solving them.

Benedetto: Exactly! That is precisely what I was about to say! As you know, being right-wing is easier: one only has to face what is different and feel disgust, simply reject what is new. It is easy to go against the foreigner and oppose his presence, his culture, his violence; much harder, instead, to kneel before him, to understand and welcome him. What ignorant theories! And yet, just think: it would be enough to study, to become educated: in history, in philosophy, in anthropology, to discover that every field of human knowledge proves the left right. Only the ignorant are not leftists! But of course they did not understand this, and so we had to limit their freedom of speech. As you know, we consider freedom of speech sacred, but it needs boundaries; we cannot accept hate speech, and what could be more hateful than spreading wrong theories?

Riccardo: So yes, they are not right-wing, as I imagined. These are good people, who carry forward their claims, their struggles, and we listened to them, we listen to them, and we shall listen to them. Perhaps we must have made some mistake, perhaps we were not progressive enough. But where did we go wrong? Did we perhaps accept too little immigration, did we fall short in multiculturalism, are we perhaps… nationalists?!

Benedetto: Oh, don’t fret, Riccardo! From that point of view we’ve achieved all our goals, we accepted so much immigration that now there is no longer any ethnicity, no longer any culture, not even the concept of national identity, and we did well. After all, what is a "people"? What does “Italian” mean? To the mind of a local racist it might conjure a white-skinned man; to the mind of an American racist it might conjure a violent, uncivilized Black man, and it certainly cannot be tied to culture either. What is culture? What is tradition? Italian cuisine? Don’t make me laugh! Neither pasta nor the tomato are Italian! Our land has always been a crossroads of peoples: Phoenicians, Greeks, Arabs, Lombards. Our culture is a blend of foreign cultures, so why should we interrupt this beautiful tradition? And besides, even within Italy you have cultures that are vastly different: take a Neapolitan, a Venetian, a Piedmontese, and a Sicilian and put them together in a room, they will see only their differences, they will begin to assert their own traditions, to emphasize their accents, perhaps even to speak in their own language, and in that moment they will become the fiercest local patriots (orig. campanilisti). There is no well-defined Italian culture, and since that is so, I would say it is more than lawful, indeed just, to invite into our country French, Slavs, Africans, Japanese, Chinese, Indonesians, and every so-called “people” of the world, since they too have no real culture.

Riccardo: Yes, indeed, you’ll remember what happened, what a spectacle Italy was in that period! The melting pot par excellence: being Italian, African, or Arab no longer meant anything. Only traditions remained—that’s true, because we cannot deny traditions. But we could disconnect them from any label, so that everyone in the world had their own tradition, which rather we should call a personal cult, and they could choose it freely. You will recall when Abdoullakh Abouyezidovich Anzorov proclaimed the Caliphate of Romagna, imposing Sharia law, and the very next day went about committing violence against women, or rather, violence from our point of view, but which in their culture was entirely legitimate. What a spectacle that was!

Benedetto: Yes, but you see, Riccardo, you’ve pointed out the problem: in this melting pot, where everyone had their own personal cult, people were driven to associate with others who had the same cult, and so groups formed, new cultures that now crowd our Italy. And against them we must fight, for once again there is the risk of attaching a label to a culture.

Riccardo: True, that might be a problem, against which they rightly rebel. But then, regarding feminism, are we perhaps behind? Are we perhaps too rigid? Are we perhaps… misogynists?!

Benedetto: Oh no, no! On the contrary, we are the spearhead of the feminist process, which at every wave uncovered new forms of patriarchy and oppression, until it finally turned against itself, and I say rightly so, because that was its natural conclusion. Freedom can only advance in the presence of oppression: more and more rights can be conquered, men’s privileges reduced further and further, but then you arrive at a ceiling you cannot break through. At that point freedom becomes fluidity, absence of rule, the capacity to drift in the river of genders and sexes without any obstacle. Each of us is hurled at random into this existence, endowed with these or those biological traits, attributed to us by pure arbitrariness and without our choice, and thus we find ourselves imprisoned in a body, in a sex. And why should we, as rulers, not grant them the right to escape that prison and reshape their biology at will, according to their inclinations? But it's even worse when that prison is not built by biology but by society, for centuries men and women were forced to conform to this or that behavior simply because society pressured them to do so. But there is no divine law saying that men must be aggressive, strong, courageous, that they must like cars, toy soldiers, or dinosaurs; nor is there any divine law saying that women must be empathetic, emotional, or graceful, or that they must play with dolls or baby dolls (orig. Cicciobello). They are all social constructs! Everyone has the right to follow what they wish, and that is today’s society, where everyone may choose their gender, their behaviors, their favorite activities, and those activities are not tied to being a man or a woman, but tied only to the person, since man and woman are tied to nothing and must not be. What does “man” mean? Nothing. What does “woman” mean? Nothing. No behavior is tied to them, no body, no quality, they are labels no different than a place of birth, perhaps even less important, we should abolish them altogether. And perhaps in this world transsexuals are the last remnants of conservatism we must abandon, for if they claim to change sex out of sheer preference, then it is acceptable; but if a woman claims to change sex because she is drawn to behaviors attributed to men, then that perpetuates those absurd social constructs, and we must fight it.

Riccardo: It’s true, but it seems too little to me, there must be something else they are rebelling against. So then, where did we go wrong? We granted everything: euthanasia even for those with no problem at all, abortion with sanctions against conscientious objectors, surrogacy, drugs. We defended sexual orientations so much that orientation itself no longer has any reason to exist. We granted so many citizenships that citizenship itself has become worthless paper. We are preparing only to abolish borders, and yet they rebel. Why?

(pause)
You know, I think perhaps it all stems from progress. Progressivism harbors deep contradictions, not for itself, but for those who carry it forward. The history of man has always been marked by progressivism: through the centuries, societies have always known higher stages of progress, which surely delight us, but at the same time render our condition unsustainable. For the conservatives of today are the progressives of yesterday, but today’s progressives will also be the conservatives of tomorrow, when our ideas become accepted, taken for granted, and perhaps even backward. A Gramsci, a Turati, a Serrati, though they were the height of progressivism in their time, are considered by us today conservative on certain issues. And if even they can be guilty, why couldn’t we be? Who’s to say that if we were catapulted back into the 1920s we wouldn’t have supported merely the women’s right to vote, or a few decades later supported only their entry into the workforce, remaining blind to further progress, so blind that if compared with our current positions they would have disgusted us. And today we are in the same condition, perhaps they rebel because they have understood where progress is headed, because they know what the future is, while we remain blind. We are nothing but vile conservatives, slaves to our time. And I am afraid, I am afraid of being wrong, I am afraid of being backward. And for that reason, I want to reach the limit, surely there must be a limit to progressivism! Surely there must be a moment when social progress reaches its maximum possible, and nothing more can be desired but the status quo. Or do we really mean to say that after equating human life with that of an animal or a bacterium, after flooding robots with rights, there will still be something else to obtain? No, enough! I want that limit to come soon, and the more I do not see it, the more I am afraid, I am afraid of being a conservative. Do you think I am a conservative, Benedetto? No, I am not a conservative. I don’t want to be a conservative! Tell me I am not a conservative!

Benedetto: You are not a conservative, calm yourself. We can do nothing but follow our time, we stand still here, and we go along with its will.

Riccardo: Go along? Follow? Stand still? Do you mean we are trapped? Do you mean we are conservatives without realizing it?

Benedetto: No, I didn’t say that! We are not conservatives. The limit is near, I already see it, and we shall reach it soon. But returning to the question: that cannot be the reason they are rebelling; it must be something else we have overlooked, something on which we did not dwell. (pause) Let’s see, perhaps we made a mistake in our reasoning. Let’s go back: we said that nation, culture, ethnicity, and gender are social constructs. But what is a social construct?

Riccardo: That's easy: a social construct is something created artificially by society, something society has imposed on you and has nothing natural, biological, or divine about it, and for that reason it is legitimate to change it.

Benedetto: Right. You're correct. But is there perhaps something we consider sacred?

Riccardo: Well, sacred… let's see. (pauses for a few seconds to think) Yes! Democracy! Of course, democracy! The best form of government, the most just, the freest, the most equal, one that allows everyone to live peacefully and express their opinions. We fought hard against the snares of the right, who tried to erode it little by little and turn it into a “democrature" (orig. democratura), but we rebelled and we won. Every society should aspire to be democratic; democracy is the apex of political philosophy, democracy is one of the best and most righteous things our civilization has produced!

Benedetto: Civilization did you say? Did I hear correctly? Civilization? Are you perhaps saying that our civilization is better than others because it is democratic? Are you saying our culture is… superior?!

Riccardo: No! No! (horrified) I don't know what made me say something like that! It must have been fascism, that underlying fascism, that insidious disease that is the nation’s autobiography and which therefore hides in all of us, in our minds, concealed, silent, and we do not understand it! We seek it but cannot find it! And we must fight every day against ourselves, for we are nearly possessed by it. We are not superior because we discovered democracy, democracy is not discovered, democracy simply is. Democracy is like a law of physics: an objective, stable reality that sooner or later everyone will arrive at. And equally sacred are the laws on which it is founded: the sublime Constitution and our Founding Fathers, immense men, saints, what am I saying, saints, Gods! Who, when we were slaves and ignorant, offered us the best law ever conceived, and it is our fault that we have not followed it enough and we must punish ourselves every day for this failing. Democracy is sacred! Sacred! Sacred!

Benedetto: Sacred, but why?

Riccardo: Democracy is sacred!

Benedetto: But why, I ask you, why? Why should democracy be inviolable, sacred, what biological or natural quality makes it so? Wasn't it developed over time? Wasn't it written by men? Is it not itself a… social construct?

(long pause)

Riccardo: Democracy… is a social construct. Yes. It's true. Democracy is a social construct. And while man and woman have a link to biology, democracy doesn't even have that, it is even weaker, artificial, and we erect it into law and judge other cultures by it. But if any form of government is a social construct, so any form of government is legitimate. (eyes widening) Any morality is a social construct! Therefore any morality is legitimate. That must be what we fail to understand; that must be the reason they are rebelling out there. The very existence of a government, our ability to sit here in this palace and decide the lives of others, is a social construct. And as such it has no claim to objectivity.

Benedetto: (approaching him, calm tone) So there is no longer any doubt. Our final task will be to abolish the institutions, and to do so I propose we gather everyone in this palace and deliver ourselves to the rebels.

Riccardo: (rising from his chair) Shall I follow you?

Benedetto: After you. (inviting Riccardo to precede him)

(they both exit)


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Jul 16 '25

Morality is objective and interdependent

2 Upvotes

When you think about how humans come up with words it’s quite obvious that morality is objective and real.

If something is more good than something else it must be less evil. These words are interdependent and only exist in contrast to each other. They are a relationship not a set of facts.

The thing is. If all of the conscious beings and what they did in certain contexts was recorded, including the neuro chemical configurations corresponding to compassion or malice for example, it would be quite obvious that actions and mind states have similarities and distinctions. Real patterns. What we named as good and bad actually is a distinction that is the case.

The problem is that we want something more from morality. We want “oughtness” but that’s just linguistic deception. It’s a tautology. You can’t “ought to do something evil.”

Ought means the same thing as good because our conscious experience of doing something good we can only describe as feeling like we did what we ought to have done.

Take temperature as an analogy. We did not always have thermometers and perfect ways to measure hot and cold but we felt it. Does it have a subjective element? Yes it is of dual nature. People can have different reactions to different temperatures and they can feel too hard too cold, but it is still the case that everything actually is hotter or colder or the same as something else. There’s no single temperature that is objectively hot or cold by itself. It’s a relationship.

If we met an alien species we might look at our history and immediately know we have been on the colder or hotter side of morality compared to them. We might know why if we look at their brains.

It’s as objective as any thing of a dual nature of impression and actual state. It’s an interdependent relationship that emerges naturally from contrast in conscious beings and what they do.

Went people want something more from these words it’s like we forget how words emerge all together. It’s not subjective like preferring a flavor of ice cream. That contingent on how you receive the ice cream to say how good it is. Morality is like temperature. Things actually are better or worse than each other despite whether you prefer 80 degrees and sunny or 60 degrees outside and chilly. You can’t make some conscious action be different from all the actions it’s similar to with your preference. It simply is the case. It’s a relationship, not a single target.


r/DebatePhilosophy • • Jul 02 '24

Mary the Colour Scientist proves the existence of qualia.

2 Upvotes

In case you don't know the thought experiment:

Mary was raised in a black and white environment, and she studies colour. She had access to any pertinent data including scientific papers and brain scans.

Eventually she had a near perfect understanding of colour, but no direct experience.

One day, she is allowed out, and experiences colour for the first time.

The fact that she learns something new (what the experience of colour first hand is like) proves that qualia are real.

Qualia are subjective sense experiences btw.