r/DebateIslam • • Apr 09 '21

Quran has some really messed up and outrageous ideas. It is promoting sexism and justifying pedophilia.

20 Upvotes

First of all, I have nothing against muslim people or their culture; I am not a biggot. However, criticising Islamic ideas that opose women rights and outright justify pedophilia(listed below) is valid and isn't considered islamophobia.

Here are some examples from Quran that obviously discriminate against women:

1- Mature men are allowed to marry prepubescent girls. (Sura 65:1)

2- Husbands may hit their wives for multiple reasons including if she refuses to have sex. (Sura 4:34, al-Bukhaari, 4794)

3- A man have up to 4 wives but a woman can only have one husband. (Sura 4:3)

4- A husband may simply get rid of one of his undesired wives (Sura 4:129)

5- A male gets a double share of the inheritance over that of a female.( Sura 4:11)

6- Slave girls are sexual property for their male owners.(Sura 4:24)

7- A woman's testimony counts half of a man's testimony. (Sura 2:282)

There is more of things like these but I'd like to keep it short.

Can someone who belives this justify any of these claims?

Some Muslim women from western countries may say that they are getting threated fine, but I am not talking about that, I am talking about women in Islamic countries. Some women from those coutries could also say that they enjoy being treated that way, but I think that it's more important to also consider what women who left islam have to say.


r/DebateIslam • • Feb 09 '22

Muslim to Ex-Muslim Debate What do you call a community where leaving is punished?

14 Upvotes

r/DebateIslam • • Jul 14 '21

Childhood genital mutilation

14 Upvotes

Let me preface by saying that my knowledge of the occurence of genitals l mutilation within Islamic communities is limited. I know that male genital circumsision is widespread and femal genital mutilation is in practice, although rarer than circumsision. I do not know the justifications behind these practices.

I'm here to argue that promoting any kind of genital mutilation (male penile circumsision and FGM) is harmful and unethical. Here are my reasons why:

  1. They are medically unnecessary. A reason often cited for male circumsision is that it helps to keep "clean". Just going into the shower and washing under the foreskin is guaranteed to keep clean, and having surgery to achieve cleanliness isn't exactly the best reason to have surgery in a religion that upholds living in its "natural, god-given" body. Studies showing a correlation of circumsision with lesser UTIs/STDs are often flawed or show these benefits as a miniscule percentage as compared to a significant one. Meanwhile, FGM holds no benefits whatsoever.

  2. The potential for harm. FGM can cause severe bleeding and problems urinating, and later cysts, infections, as well as complications in childbirth and increased risk of newborn deaths. Male circumsision meanwhile, diminishes sexual pleasure by disturbing the normal mechanisms of intercourse and errogenous stimulation. Circumcision results in loss of 30–50% of the penile skin, loss of at least 10,000–20,000 specialized erotogenic nerve endings, loss of reciprocal stimulation of foreskin and glans, and loss of the natural coital gliding mechanism, etc. Decreased sensitivity of the glans=decreased sexual pleasure experienced.

  3. A rarely talked about reason: it's psychological effects. Circumsised men have reported feeling violated, mutilated, victimized and shameful, with extreme cases leading to depression, anxiety and relationship problems. Studies have also shown how it disrupts breastfeeding relationships in babies. Women who have undergone FGM have been found to have significantly higher levels of psychologocal problems like depression, anxiety and aggresion as opposed to those who have not.

  4. Performing surgery on the genitals of a child who cannot consent, especially when said surgery has the potential for harm rather then good, is immoral and takes away the child's right to bodily autonomy.

The main justifications concentrate on morality, virginity, honor, marriage, and sexual control but there's no study showing that these values are preserved by genital mutilation.

So my question to Muslims is this, why is this so widely practiced within Muslim communities (I acknowledge that other communities practice it too, but I want to focus on Muslim communities for the sake of discussion) when there is so much evidence stating that it causes harm? Why would God promote/advise something like this?


r/DebateIslam • • Dec 23 '22

Muslim to Ex-Muslim Debate Goat eating verses

12 Upvotes

If a goat came and ate the verses, claimed by Aisha was true.

Was it;

  1. Allah made the goat eat it.

  2. Mohammad’s teachings were bad.


r/DebateIslam • • Jul 07 '23

I don't see a logical reason why women should wear a burka/hijab.

11 Upvotes

I never understood the concept of wearing burka/hijab, although I really tried over the years. Years ago, for me it was just a symbol of brainwashing and oppressing women in muslim societies. Since I moved abroad, I was exposed to a lot of different cultures and I tried hearing from muslim women themselves what wearing a hijab means to them, trying to have a more open mind and educate myself. However, so far I never heard a logical argument that makes sense and has no leaky sides. Since I don't want to hurt anyone's feelings, I did not talk about why this makes no sense to me, but since I am still very curious about this.

So probably the best argument I heard so far was that women wear hijab so that they would be recognized as women, but not objectified as women. However, I still have so many problems with this statement, so I will list them all below but please feel free and I would love it if you would correct me or at least explain to me your thinking, as long as it's based on logic.

  1. First of all, I really believe that objectifying women comes from within the person who is objectifying, it starts and ends in that person's brain, it's an intrinsic characteristic of that person and is almost not at all influenced by what we wear, and in general is not in our control. Just like domestic abuse victims are not to blame for being abused by their partner - they were abused not because they did something wrong, but simply because they were unlucky to marry the abuser who will abuse anyone. And we often do see examples of this - abusers usually abuse, then divorce, marry again, and abuse the next partner again. Same with the cheaters, we think to ourselves what did we do wrong, when in reality we didn't do anything wrong, we were just with the wrong person. And the list goes on, such as for example rape, serial killers and so on and so forth. I think objectifying is just less serious than other things I listed afterwards, but it's just on a less serious part of the same scale of not respecting and not treating right another human being. Even if that is the case - that other people will think of us and treat us depending on how we dress, I refuse to conform to this because it should not be the case. We should be respected based on who we are within, and how we treat other people and not depending on how we dress, this seems very superficial to me.

  2. At the end of the day, isn't it all just a spectrum? It's a spectrum on whose one end people walk around naked, and on the other end of the spectrum they walk covered head to toe, with only eyes showing with a fine net on top of them, to partially hide them as well. However, on this latter part of the spectrum, how does this work? I know that we as humans should not be superficial, but how do you express your phsyical identity when you are covered head to toe? How do you find a partner? Because let's face it, at the end of the day, we as humans do care (some people more some people less) about our partner's physical appearance. So if you can't see anyone, how do you find your future wife? are marriages then arranged and if yes, isn't this objectifying women even more because they are treated as literal objects who are transfered from one household to another, with little to no own free will? So if we move away from the ends of the spectrum, there are women who just cover up their hair, but leave most of the rest of the body covered in the same way that women do in Western societies. So here, I have even more questions. How do you decide what to cover up? Okay, hair is regarded as something beautiful, but different people consider different body parts to carry beauty - there might be people who find women's ankles even more beautiful than the hair, so those people might still objectify you, right? So who is to say what to cover up and what to leave uncovered? Finally, how are these women any different from me, since we are both somewhere in the middle of the scale, and who is to say where on this scale you should be exactly (or in other words, what is right)?

  3. Why do you then make some uncovered parts even more beautiful? For instance, I've seen a lot of muslim women covering up their hair, but then wearing makeup. To me this doesn't make sense because hair is apparently hidden because it holds a lot of beauty, but doesn't the face too? And then if you don't cover it up, why don't you at least avoid wearing things that make it even more beautiful, such as earrings and makeup? I'd really love to understand, so please feel free to enlighten me. At the end of the day it could be that some people are just doing things wrong which is then making people who don't know a lot about Islam confused.

  4. Finally, I've heard that some of muslim women only cover up in front of men, but can't they be objectified by women, too? Some of them are gay after all and honestly, you can even be objectified by another straight woman. Also, I noticed that little girls are not covered up, even though we all very well know that unfortunately pedophiles exist out there. So basically I think that ANYONE can really be objectified by ANYONE, not just because so many different gender identities and sexualities exist out there, but also because, as I said in my first point, this is something intrinsic to people and doesn't even need to be tied to gender identitiy and sexuality. So why isn't everyone, regardless of age and gender, covered up? I also once asked why are men not covered up, too? Don't they hold a lot of beauty as well? The answer was yes, they should covered up as well based on the holy book, however, I noticed that men don't follow it nearly as much as women and even more strikingly, they are not criticized or even punished as much as women, should they fail to follow this. So please tell me how do you explain this?

Looking forward to hear what you guys think about this!


r/DebateIslam • • Apr 10 '21

Hell simply doesn't make sense

10 Upvotes
  1. people say allah is the most merciful while he sends non believers to hell forever, 2.why wouldn't allah stop satan from taking us to hell? 3.if allah knows the future then why did he make hell? At this point calling a human evil or good is pointless.


r/DebateIslam • • Jan 30 '24

Why does Islam claim to be scientific

9 Upvotes

Islam is one of those religions that claims science is on their side….

Science does not believe Adam was created using mud

Science doesn’t track the existence of women through the men’s ribs

Science:

Doesn’t believe two ppl populated the earth

Doesn’t believe humans started at 2 ppl

Doesn’t believe Noah built the ark on his own

Doesn’t believe the ark could be built at all. Not with wood

Doesn’t believe Noah was 600

Doesn’t believe the flood happened

Doesn’t believe Solomon… mind manipulated demons and animals?

Doesn’t believe Muhammad went to heaven on a flying donkey

Doesn’t believe Muhammad split the moon

Doesn’t believe women are “ deficient of mind”

Why come they say science supports islam?


r/DebateIslam • • Sep 06 '24

Muslim to Ex-Muslim Debate Muhammad the Abusive Prophet

8 Upvotes

According to the Quran, Muhammad was sent as a mercy unto mankind:

And We have sent you (O Muhammad) not but as a mercy for the 'Alamin (mankind, jinns and all that exists). S. 21:107 Hilali-Khan

The Islamic scripture further attests that Muhammad wasn’t harsh or cruel to his followers:

And by the Mercy of Allah, you dealt with them gently. And had you been severe and harshhearted, they would have broken away from about you; so pass over (their faults), and ask (Allah's) Forgiveness for them; and consult them in the affairs. Then when you have taken a decision, put your trust in Allah, certainly, Allah loves those who put their trust (in Him). S. 3:159 Hilali-Khan

However, at times Muhammad was anything but merciful to his own followers and best friends. According to the sound hadith, Muhammad would actually yell, curse, harm, and beat those who loved him the most and didn't do anything to deserve such abuse:

Chapter 23: HE UPON WHOM ALLAH'S APOSTLE INVOKED CURSE WHEREAS HE IN FACT DID NOT DESERVE IT**, IT WOULD BE A SOURCE OF REWARD AND MERCY FOR HIM**

Please consider the following verses while keeping S. 3:159 Hilali-Khan in mind

A'isha reported that two persons visited Allah's Messenger and both of them talked about a thing, of which I am not aware, but that annoyed him AND HE INVOKED CURSE UPON BOTH OF THEM AND HURLED MALEDICTION, and when they went out I said: Allah's Messenger, the good would reach everyone but it would not reach these two. He said: Why so? I said: Because you have invoked curse and hurled malediction upon both of them. He said: Don't you know that I have made condition with my Lord saying thus: O Allah, I am a human being and that for a Muslim upon whom I invoke curse or hurl malediction make it a source of purity and reward? (Sahih Muslim, Book 032, Number 6285)

This hadith has been reported on the authority of A'mash with the same chain of transmitters and the hadith transmitted on the authority of 'Isa (the words are): "He had a private meeting with them AND HURLED MALEDICTION UPON THEM AND CURSED THEM and sent them out." (Sahih Muslim, Book 032, Number 6286)

Abu Huraira reported Allah's Apostle as saying: O Allah, I make a covenant with Thee against which Thou wouldst never go. I am a human being and thus for a Muslim whom I give any harm or whom I scold or upon whom I INVOKE A CURSE or whom I BEAT, make this a source of blessing, purification and nearness to Thee on the Day of Resurrection. (Sahih Muslim, Book 032, Number 6290)

Salim, the freed slave of Nasriyyin, said: I heard Abu Huraira as saying that he heard Allah's Messenger as saying: O Allah, Muhammad is a human being. I lose my temper just as human beings lose temper, and I have held a covenant with Thee which Thou wouldst not break: For a believer whom I give any trouble or invoke curse or beat, make that an expiation (of his sins and a source of) his nearness to Thee on the Day of Resurrection. (Sahih Muslim, Book 032, Number 6293)

Muhammad even cursed an orphan girl, wishing that she wouldn’t live long, making her cry as a result!

Anas b. Malik reported that there was an orphan girl with Umm Sulaim (who was the mother of Anas). Allah's Messenger saw that orphan girl and said: O, it is you; you have grown young. MAY YOU NOT ADVANCE IN YEARS! That slave-girl returned to Umm Sulaim weeping. Umm Sulaim said: O daughter, what is the matter with you? She said: Allah's Apostle has invoked curse upon me that I should not grow in age and thus I would never grow in age, or she said, in my (length) of life. Umm Sulaim went out wrapping her head-dress hurriedly until she met Allah's Messenger. He said to her: Umm Sulaim, what is the matter with you? She said: Allah's Apostle, you invoked curse upon my orphan girl. He said: Umm Sulaim, what is that? She said: She (the orphan girl) states you have cursed her saying that she might not grow in age or grow in life. Allah's Messenger smiled and then said: Umm Sulaim, don't you know that I have made this term with my Lord. And the term with my Lord is that I said to Him: I am a human being and I am pleased just as a human being is pleased and I lose temper just as a human being loses temper, so for any person from amongst my Ummah whom I curse and he in no way deserves it, let that, O Lord, be made a source of purification and purity and nearness to (Allah) on the Day of Resurrection. (Sahih Muslim, Book 032, Number 6297)

There are several problems with Muhammad’s actions and statements. First, Muhammad’s excuse that he was no more than a human being is no justification for abusing and harming people who loved him more than their own selves. There are human beings who are not prophets that are able to control their rage and anger, and do not lash out against their family and friends the way Muhammad did. Therefore, how much more control should Muhammad have had over his sinful impulses and rages, especially when he was supposed to be protected by his god?

This leads to us to the second problem. Muslim scholars claim that prophets are guarded and protected (isma/masum) from committing sins. If so then why did Allah fail to protect his prophet from his unrighteous and unjustified anger? Why didn't Allah give Muhammad complete mastery over his sinful rage so as to not verbally abuse and curse his followers who loved him more than they loved themselves?

Third, instead of controlling his tongue, or instead of Allah giving him victory over his rage and foul mouth, Muhammad justifies his cursing, attacks and insults on people by saying that Allah will bless anyone he harms, curses, and/or beats! Thus, instead of rebuking and chastening him for his sins Allah actually condoned Muhammad’s cruelty and vileness by agreeing to bless anyone he curses and harms! Why did Allah allow Muhammad to revel in his sin by accepting his deal to bless anyone he curses? What kind of god would accept such an agreement thereby allowing Muhammad the freedom to justify and continue with abusing and cursing his own followers, such as that poor innocent orphan girl? Doesn’t this make Allah complicit in Muhammad’s sins? Doesn’t this show that Allah was actually Muhammad’s servant since he acquiesced to and granted the latter’s whims and desires?

Even more troubling is Muhammad’s arrogance in presuming that Allah will automatically accept his conditions. The above hadiths give no evidence that Allah agreed to Muhammad’s demands. These narrations merely report what Muhammad said and take it for granted that Allah gave in to his messenger’s desires.

In fact, in the last hadith it is merely a request he makes. Notice, once, again Muhammad’s statements:

I have made condition with my Lord …

O Allah, I make a covenant with Thee against which Thou wouldst never go.

O Allah, Muhammad is a human being. I lose my temper just as human beings lose temper, and I have held a covenant with Thee which Thou wouldst not break:

Aren’t those very presumptuous formulations? Muhammad unilaterally makes a covenant. It is not Allah who offers a covenant to Muhammad. Muhammad simply declares this rule and claims that Allah would certainly never go against it. This is nothing but sheer arrogance on Muhammad’s part. Fallible, sinful creatures are simply in no position to demand from God to endorse or justify their sinfulness, and yet Muhammad thinks he has such a right. Did Allah agree to this deal beforehand at some point we just aren’t aware of? Did the Quran that “explains all things in detail” just forget to mention such a crucial part of this deal… Allah’s consent?

Moreover, as part of our repentance we Christians can pray that God would graciously turn our evil deeds into a blessing for the person we have harmed, and then sincerely ask that God may change our heart and give us the strength to never act in this way again. But that is something entirely different than what we see in the above hadiths. Muhammad basically “invents that imaginary deal” so that he can go on as before and does NOT have to change. That is Biblically unacceptable and an outright travesty against the holiness and justice of the true God.

In particular, Muhammad is exempting himself from the obligation to ask for forgiveness from the people he has cursed, beaten, or otherwise harmed. (After all, he only caused blessings…) The Biblical principle is that we have to ask for forgiveness for our wrongs, both of the person we have harmed and of God. That requires humility and acknowledging that one is wrong. Clearly, Muhammad does not want to apologize and admit that he was wrong in anything. With this trick now, he can say: “Why do you complain? I actually caused you to be blessed!” And thus, in the final analysis, he is calling evil good, destroying the very basis of morality.

Fourth, Muslims often quote the following verse to prove that Muhammad only spoke by inspiration:

By the star when it goes down, (or vanishes). Your companion (Muhammad) has neither gone astray nor has erred. Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. It is only an Inspiration that is inspired. S. 53:3-4 Hilali-Khan

If it is true that Muhammad never spoke from his own desires but was always inspired to speak then this means that it was Allah who actually wanted his messenger to curse and abuse his own followers who didn't deserve such treatment! The obvious question is why would the Islamic deity, who is supposed to be all-holy and all-merciful, cause Muhammad to curse and harm believers who loved their god and his prophet more than their own lives for no good reason?

To make matters worse, Muhammad stands condemned by his own teachings!

4184. It is narrated from Abu Bakrah that the Messenger of Allah said: “Modesty is part of faith, and faith will be in Paradise. Obscenity in speech is part of harshness, and harshness will be in Hell.” (Sahih)

Comments…

c. Using foul language means, abusing or using bad language, quarrelling and the like, these acts are contrary to the characteristic of a believer. (English Translation of Sunan Ibn Majah - Compiled by Imam Muhammad Bin Yazeed Ibn Majah Al-Qazwini, From Hadith No. 3657 to 4341, Ahadith edited and referenced by Hafiz Abu Tahir Zubair 'Ali Za'i, translated by Nasiruddin al-Khattab (Canada), final review by Abu Khaliyl (USA) [Darussalam Publications and Distributors, First Edition: June 2007], Volume 5, 37. The Chapters On Asceticism, Chapter 17. Modesty, Shyness, p. 330)

This shows that, once again, Muhammad failed to practice what he preached since he abused and used bad language against those who loved him the most and who hadn't done anything to deserve such treatment, even though he warned his followers not to do such things. As such, Muhammad stands condemned and deserves to go to hell according to his own words.

The Lord Jesus himself warned people that they would be judged for what they say:

“The good man brings out of his good treasure what is good; and the evil man brings out of his evil treasure what is evil. But I tell you that every careless word that people speak, they shall give an accounting for it in the day of judgment. For by your words you will be justified, and by your words you will be condemned.” Matthew 12:35-37

This means that Muhammad comes under the judgment of the Lord Jesus Christ as well!

Finally, it is one thing to curse those who oppose and attack you, something that Muhammad did quite often. (Just compare the final words of Muhammad and Jesus.) It is completely another thing altogether to belittle and insult those who love you more than their own lives and didn't do anything offensive to deserve such abuse and mistreatment.

Thus, it is clear that the more one studies the life of Muhammad the more evidence one finds that he was not a prophet at all, nor was he a mercy to mankind, but was rather a curse on humanity. Muhammad’s life and teachings have brought more harm and have caused greater damage to the world, i.e. his cursing and abusing people, prostituting women and calling it temporary marriage, permitting Muslims to rape women whom they have taken captive even if they happen to be married, stealing his adopted sons’ wife, abolishing adoption as a result of it, commanding his followers to murder or subjugate individuals who refuse to accept him as a prophet… the list could go on and on.


r/DebateIslam • • Jan 09 '23

Muslim to Ex-Muslim Debate How can Allah be certain he is uncreated?

8 Upvotes

If he was created by an all powerful being that decided to make Allah think he is uncreated and giving him arguments to convince him while blocking any thought of a reason he could be created (or giving him a counter argument that Allah thinks is perfect), then how can Allah know he is uncreated?

When a divine being creates something, it creates the way that that thing thinks, so it can easily make it absolutely convinced of false things. The quran explicitly states that that Allah, the one who sent the quran, is the only god despite being completely unable to verify this statement.


r/DebateIslam • • Apr 29 '22

Intra-Islamic Debate Is there any scientific/medical proof of Aisha's maturity? NSFW

8 Upvotes

What genetically/phenotypically expressed in humans to make a female 6-9 year old fit for copulation by a significantly elderly man?


r/DebateIslam • • Dec 22 '19

Want to expand the sub and actually bring in people to debate here, suggestions?

8 Upvotes

Salaam all!

So as of this moment there isn't really a place where Muslims and ex-Muslims can discuss on matters of theology, fiqh, history, etc. Wanted to make this sub the place for that to happen. Any ideas?


r/DebateIslam • • Jun 30 '25

If Allah made the Quran unchangeable, why couldn't he do the same with the Tanakh and New Testament?

7 Upvotes

In surah 2 verse 75 it says that a group of people corrupted the word of Allah. But in sura 6 verse 115 it says that no one can change Allah's word. So then which one is it? And if you say the verse in sura 6 only talks about the Kuran, why couldn't Allah make the Tanakh and Injeel also unchangeable? He is either purosefully making all this confusion and separation or Allah is not God.


r/DebateIslam • • Feb 16 '24

Muslim to Ex-Muslim Debate Aisha age

7 Upvotes

This is not a debate. The fact that you thought it was repulses me. You jumped at the chance to justify child grape

Islam has made child grape a debate. That’s why I left Islam.


r/DebateIslam • • Oct 27 '22

On what grounds can you say there is only one god?

7 Upvotes

Throughout many different times and places, humanity has had experiences that we've identified as being from many different gods. In light of this, how can you claim that there is only one god? In order to claim there is only one god, you have to reject the religious experiences of others, without rejecting your own. This is tricky for monotheists, I've found. You can't argue from religious experience, because as I said people have religious experiences with many gods. You can't argue from scripture, because many religions have scriptures or texts outlining what they believe. Many Muslims claim that the Quran is inimitable, but 1. that doesn't really mean anything, any text could be argued to be inimitable, and 2. even if it is inimitable, that doesn't prove that what it says is correct. Given the myriad of gods that have been experienced, the easiest conclusion is that there are many gods.


r/DebateIslam • • Jan 23 '22

Life as a Test from Allah?

7 Upvotes

How can humans have free will while at the same time Allah has written down our destiny before we are born or actively influence how our life destiny will arrive at?

Generally speaking a common argument is that Life is a test from God but he already knows who will fail or who will succeed and his active intervention complicates where humans have complete free will.

Hassan Radwan touched on this subject:
A Question to Muslims - YouTube


r/DebateIslam • • Oct 12 '20

Intra-Islamic Debate Islam.....

7 Upvotes

first of all what do you do in Jannah. I heard that u get 72 virgins at request, rivers of wine, and honey. U get to gorge yourself on food and drinks but u never get to the point of fullness as u do on earth. This is sensational gratification; it's pretty self-explanatory when u realize that Mohammad who molested a nine-year-old girl was the one who gived revelation to Jannah. There is another problem also, indulging in such things is considered a sin and is sinful. This is the kind of stuff that entrap us, its pathological, we use drugs and sex to dissociate from our suffering but it ultimately ends up entrapping us. It seperates us from our true source of fulfillment - God who is love, peace, joy, kindness. U see how pathological this is? We're chasing after the things of this world, gratifying our fleshly desires. It's not a sin in heaven? I heard this many times from other muslims. It's kind of ludicrous. what are u getting saved from then? from sin!!


r/DebateIslam • • Feb 13 '25

Divine Justice or Injustice? The Punishment of Those Who Sought to See God

6 Upvotes

If God were truly a just and moral being, He would not have killed or struck down the people who merely asked Prophet Musa to see Him. A morally perfect God would understand that not everyone believes in blind faith—some require direct evidence of His existence. Instead of punishing them with death, a compassionate and wise God would have guided them or provided proof in a way that does not involve destruction.

This raises a contradiction in Surah Al-A'raf (7:143), where Prophet Musa himself asked to see Allah. In response, God did not punish Musa but instead demonstrated His power by making a mountain crumble. If God had no issue with Musa’s request and did not harm him, then why did He strike down others for asking the same question? This inconsistency challenges the idea of divine justice and fairness.

Additionally, if God's goal was to strengthen belief, why resort to punishment instead of persuasion? Killing those who sought evidence seems counterproductive—wouldn't showing Himself in a way they could comprehend have been a more effective way to inspire faith? This raises deeper theological and moral concerns about whether such actions align with the concept of a truly just and merciful deity.


r/DebateIslam • • Dec 22 '21

why did mohammad use the jew's laws in the case of banu qurayza ? Were these rules just and fair to be used ? If he did it for irony , why the irony ? Isnt his purpose to bring the law of islam upoin the world ?

6 Upvotes

So yeah jewish law is pretty rough around the edges, so why did the prophet allow it to be used against enemies who were at his mercy.

Sure you could say he didnt give the order ......etc etc but he gave the silent approval.

Why didnt he use islamic law ? Why did he allow a person who had severe hate for banu qurayza to choose their fate ? Where is the fairness in that ?

Its all pretty ironic, the jews facing the utter cruelty of their laws but..... irony isnt a reason to supersede islamic law last time i checked. And why was their chieftain ridiculed by having him wear a robe adorned with flowers ?

The jews brought it upon themselves sure, but they surrendered to mohammad, only to get genocided what ?

Sure you could ban me but this is the first time I have felt like giving islam a chance so keep this in mind


r/DebateIslam • • Apr 04 '21

Is islam universal or relative?

6 Upvotes

Whenever this question is asked I always get a different answer, sometimes from the same person, depending on the question being asked.

For example, "Is Islam's rejection of fornication and alcohol still relevant?" The answer tends to be yes.

However, if asked "is Islam's acceptance of slavery and child mariage still relevant?" The answer, I would hope for everyone, is no.

Then the question must be asked, why do we play this game with the word of God? Why are we picking and choosing as we please? Who decides what to keep and what to omit from the modern version of "Islam"?

Are the values of Islam eternal and universal, or not?


r/DebateIslam • • Dec 07 '20

Slavery

6 Upvotes

Why did the Quran not outlaw slavery? Many common practices of the period, such as drinking wine, were outlawed.

The only way I reconcile myself with the issue of slavery is to take into account that Allah knows best.


r/DebateIslam • • Feb 15 '25

Earthly Punishments for a Divine God: A Theological Paradox in Islam

5 Upvotes

In Surah Al-Baqarah (2:55-56), the Quran recounts how a group from Bani Israel demanded to see Allah, only to be struck down by a thunderbolt as divine punishment. However, Allah later revived them. This raises an interesting question: Why would an all-powerful, transcendent God use an earthly element like lightning to execute divine punishment?

This pattern is not unique to this story. In Islamic descriptions of Hell, punishments often mirror earthly elements—fire, boiling water, molten lava, and physical torment. The condemned are burned, have scalding water poured over them, are dragged by iron hooks, and are forced to eat from the tree of Zaqqum, which causes unbearable suffering. These are all experiences familiar to human understanding.

This raises a theological and philosophical question: If God’s knowledge and power are infinite, why are divine punishments framed in human, worldly terms? Shouldn’t divine punishment reflect something far beyond our earthly comprehension? Some argue that these descriptions are metaphorical, intended to make divine justice comprehensible to humans. Others, however, question whether a truly transcendent God would rely on familiar, earthly imagery instead of devising punishments beyond human imagination.

Similarly, if God wanted to display His power to the people of Musa, why use lightning—a force already known to them? This suggests that either divine actions are intentionally made relatable to human minds, or that these narratives are shaped by human understanding rather than divine revelation. Either way, it invites deeper contemplation about the nature of divine justice and whether human descriptions of God's actions are truly reflective of an all-powerful being.


r/DebateIslam • • Feb 10 '25

Questioning the Morality of Divine Commands: Would a Just God Ask for Human Sacrifice?

5 Upvotes

A truly just and moral God would not command Prophet Ibrahim to sacrifice his son, as such an act contradicts fundamental moral principles. If Allah is 100% moral, then questioning His command should not be forbidden—after all, a just God would understand and allow moral reasoning. However, in Islamic teachings, questioning God's will is often discouraged, which raises concerns about blind obedience.

Moreover, the entire event is based on a dream. It is unrealistic for Ibrahim to put complete faith in a dream without seeking further confirmation, especially when the command involves taking a human life. A truly moral God would never require human sacrifice, as such a demand aligns more with ancient pagan rituals and fictional narratives rather than the actions of a benevolent deity.

Additionally, it is improbable that Ibrahim’s son would willingly accept his own sacrifice as a noble act, given that a just God would not ask for such a thing in the first place. If human sacrifice is inherently immoral, then attributing such a command to God raises serious theological and ethical contradictions.


r/DebateIslam • • Aug 30 '24

Muslim to Ex-Muslim Debate Monotheism vs polytheism

5 Upvotes

As someone who previously accepted islam but has since left islam, I really never heard any real philosophical or logical reasons to why Monotheism over Polytheism.

For me it was always hard to imagine a perfect and All powerful being, that to me is unbalanced and Creates a monopoly of power.


r/DebateIslam • • Mar 01 '24

Intra-Islamic Debate Why believing in Allah over other gods?

5 Upvotes

Let's take China, for example. One of the most Atheist countries there is in the world. The question "Is there a God" is rather futile over there, for the majority of people. Now, if you presented Islam, Christianity, or any other major religon to most of them they'd be kind of like "What?" Because for an outsider, let's agree most religions are pretty hard to believe. So, if any of them asked you, "Why believing in Allah, over any other god?" What would you say?

This is something that even I want to know. I've been raised in a heavily Christian country, so believing in Allah is seen as TOTALLY weird here, Muslims here just doesn't exist. So, why should I believe in Allah?


r/DebateIslam • • Dec 28 '23

Is Islam true ?

5 Upvotes

What is the one simple easy to understand reason as to why Islam can't be true.