Calling Shock "Busted" is an understatement. It's an All-In-One Ability combining AOE, Damage, CC, Combo Starter into your Guns, Scouting, Low CD with no Ressource Cost attached and no Drawback. All at the press of a single button. Hunters are becoming more frustrating with each patch due to the constant buffs, yet the one nerf both Hunters and Scavs unanimously agree on, adjusting Shock, is just not happening. With all the tools Hunters have atm, taking away 1-2 of the components that make up Shock is more than appropriate.
AOE and Scouting are the main purposes of the ability, so they are exempt from this. Any of the others are removable and Shock becomes a balanced ability without being the no-skill button it is now.
Damage: Probably the most asked for nerf. I'd say it would help, but even though it is a strong component, I wouldn't say it's the worst.
CC: Stops a running Scav, holds them for a bit and forces the Scav to build up their speed again. By itself, it's not a bad component. In combination with the next one, though, it becomes an issue.
ComboIntoGuns: This is, in my opinion, Shocks core problem. Hunters, with decent reaction times, can blow up Scavs before they have a chance to counterplay Shock. Hunters have less Endlag after using Shock than Scavs are stunned/held. Combined with the high amount of damage from upgraded weapons, this is a death sentence if the Hunter has a clear shot at the Scav when Shocking them.
Low CD: The low base CD, even before the perk to further reduce the CD, combined with the borderline limitless chasing potential due to the recent Hunter Stamina buffs, make it so ComboIntoGun component will come into play quite often. If the Hunter doesn't down you with the first Shock, he just needs to keep you in his sight in try again in a few seconds.
No Ressource Cost: Nothing. It doesn't have it's own Ammo, does not consume Stamina, doesn't use Power Cores. It's just free, like the Scavs that get hit by it.
No Drawback: This is basically the conclusion of all of the points above. Shooting and missing? You lost ammo. Use Supercharge? You lost Stamina. Activated a Drone? You have one less Power Core. Used Shock? You walk a bit slower for a second. Even if you missed because the Scav was outside of Shocks Range, the Hunter still isn't slowed for long enough to matter.
What I would recommend removing: ComboIntoGun
How?:
Make the Endlag of the Ability longer. Long enough for Scavs to be able to roll once before the Hunters can shoot. Scavs take damage from this for screwing up and getting shocked, but are able to continue their escape in exchange for the Stamina rolling costs, albeit with less chances since they just took a hefty amount of damage.
By increasing the Endlag, you also eliminate the "No Drawback" component. The Hunter would need to start thinking twice about shocking a brush that seems suspicious or shocking a structure the Scav might have hid in. He can still do it, with most of the old benefits if he is right on the money, but the increased Endlag would reward the chased Scavs with a window to create space between him and his pursuer.
Removing other combinations of components could also work, but this would be my preferred change.
TL;DR. Beating a dead horse.