SPOILER ALERT.
I'd like to begin, as some kind of assertion, by saying that i'm a huge fan of DS1. Did it fully twice, once on PC, then bought the director's cut on PS5. What I thought to be just an original game was something else. I loved every little well thought tool at my disposal, getting more and more creative as the game was moving on. The story was sometimes far fetched, but I bought it, and I found the metaphors quite clever, the topics that it tried to address relatable. And of course, the slow and deep bond between Sam and Lou was heart warming.
So needless to say I was really awaiting the second opus right.
I'll try to make it short, but different aspects of the game were really disappointing imo.
Some good stuff though: the graphics are top notch, beautiful sceneries and environment, music, actors, motion captures, it felt like a real improvement from the first game. But:
There's a massive shift the studio went onto that simply doesn't make sense, and that is turning DS into a TPS. This is not that type of game. Even with the best effort in this one, I found the action to be even less enjoyable than in the first. You can give me 50 shades of the same weapon, only that it gets easier to carry around, DS is still an exploring, natural obstacle tackling game. I took my time to get my affinity at least to 4 stars with the distribution centers. But when I reached the endgame, and saw that some of them were just giving me useless backpack patches, I realized there won't be any clever tools added to the game. We just have the same ones we had in the first game, minus those we get in add-ons. The only real addition is the surf, but my god they made it so limited. Why can't it be carried on the monorail ? Why not outside of the chiral network ? Why not coupled with a carrier ? Why is it so easy to fall from it ? Because the other vehicles are still trash right ? Truck still getting stuck by a little rock, and navigation is still irritating ?
On top of it, I found the obstacles far easier to tackle compared to the first one. Everything just felt so easy, no need for route planning at all. It's now super easy to climb everywhere, the game is very forgiving on every aspect of that.
Where is the fun with the tools we had from the first game ? And where is the creativity ? There's just nothing new but variant of weapons, for a game where 90% of the time we don't fight.
And finally, the climate disasters ... are just another gimmick. However, it rains constantly in this game. Past Mexico and the first areas of Australia, it just rains, and rains, or it snows, or you end up in a thick fog, and it snows.
What a bloody mess. Seriously. We spent the entire first game seeing a random guy adopting a child, seeing their bond deepening, just to see it dead within the first hours of the second game. And to what end exactly ? Sam just became a shadow during the entire game. He was just non existent, not opposing a single resistance to anything or decision.
In the first game, everything you do is linked to the story itself; connecting a continent, the characters you meet, the actions you do. In this second one, there's nothing of it. The quotes before the credits summarize the plot of this game, but it has nothing to do with us connecting continents. What's the point of all this regarding the death stranding, or the last stranding ? It's just brushed aside.
The amount of plot holes, Deus ex machinas in this one are just too big to buy. The DHV is just a funny plot twist at this point "because of the tar currents", "tar currents unstable", over and over. Lou's "resurrection", the convenient memory loss, characters coming back from the dead because "shut up it's magic, or it's the beach", Neil's story being so underwhelming compared to Cliff.
The final boss fight sums up perfectly the game: it tries to be as good as the first one, using what it could from it, while trying to tell another story that doesn't really bring anything.
What a shame, they literally had gold in their hands with DS1, but maybe you don't share my views, so let's discuss.