I wish the remake replaced the original, but I don’t feel like it did. I Loved it, the open ship design and the peel system were an extremely good way to modernize the original. The new upgrades to the guns, general quality of life stuff like pinning enemies was great. I feel like they did an excellent job with the added rooms and liberties they took around the layout and architecture of the Ishimura. But some parts of it fall flat and I don’t know why it bothers me so much and I just feel like I need to talk about it.
Spoilers from here.
I got this game way too young, and as a result, I played it way too much. I must have 10 play through or more under my belt (definitely more, I only had a few games as a kid). I’d be playing and going “this room is different” or “this log is different” to my wife every 5 minutes. Some moments that were just so good in the original were just not there in the remake. For example, the room the first Brute comes out of, when you enter it, all the TVs light up with Nicole’s face and she says “will make us whole again?” That part is just missing, which I thought was a weird misstep. The audio logs in general are way way way weaker. It really felt like 60% of the voice actors were just whoever delivered the offices’ door dash for the day. Especially the “this is an illegal mining operation…” one, it was just way flatter and less impactful.
Kyne, The captain, Hammond, and, I know people like her, but Kendra’s VAs were so much better in the OG. The part where the Kellion explodes, Kendra in the OG sounds like she’s gritting her teeth, she’s so panicked and angry. It had a lot of weight to it.
The biggest one that bugs me: The Valor and its crash into the Ishimura. It was so much better in the original. Nicole’s log playing to wake you up after impact just hit so hard in comparison. The Valor level in general I felt was much better before (I’d say, most levels felt better in the remake, just this one felt weaker).
I missed the ambience. I used to just idle in rooms to hear the whispers and try to make out what they said.
Lastly, the AI. I really liked how in the OG, escaping the necromorphs in one room, meant they would chase you through the vents in the next room.
In conclusion, I loved the remake, I just had some gripes here and there. If you only played the remake, you got an excellent dead space experience. I’d still encourage you to play the OG, but if not, hope you enjoyed.