r/David_Mitchell • • Mar 09 '25

the decline of david mitchell?

0 Upvotes

I honestly think UTOPIA AVENUE was second rate Mitchell. He waffled over that novel for YEARS; now he is stalling on his latest novel. Is he over the hill? Is he willing to talk about this sort of thing? for the record, i speak as an enormous fan who loved EVERYTHING except utopia avenue. i suppose i need to gird my loins for battle now, redditors in general seem an easily offended and touchy bunch. please share an opinion if you have one, but leave out the insults and defensive posturing. thanks. actually curious to hear from other mitchell fans. thanks.


r/David_Mitchell • • Feb 18 '26

Solving the Ghostwritten puzzle

0 Upvotes

12 years later, still this mystery is unsolved. How does the ghost travel though the story... does anyone have insight? Can AI solve this puzzle?

https://www.reddit.com/r/books/comments/1rx4h1/does_anyone_understand_ghostwritten_and_can/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Edit: There seems to be skepticism about the hypothesis that each chapter is written by a ghost.

If you read the Nighttrain chapter carefully, this is where it all comes together. That’s the moment when the separate chapters resolve into a single, coherent story.

Towards the end, Zookeeper concedes that Arupadhatu is a ghost and asks how many others there are.

Arupadhatu replies:

“Five that I’ve encountered, Zookeeper. Three others that I’ve heard of.”

That gives us eight ghosts in total.

Now consider the structure:

  • The title of the book is "Ghostwritten"

  • There are eight earlier chapters.

  • One of them is explicitly written by a ghost in first-person.

  • The ninth chapter consists only of digital communications, transcribed by Zookeeper.

That alignment is intentional.

Then Arupadhatu continues:

“They squander their gift. They transmigrate into human chaff for hosts, and meditate upon nothingness upon mountains.”

He’s referring to the other ghosts — the ones who have written the earlier chapters. They “transmigrate into human chaff for hosts” by inhabiting characters and narrating their lives, without overtly inserting themselves into the text.

In other words, the earlier chapters are those ghosts meditating through their human hosts.


r/David_Mitchell • • Sep 16 '19

Top Notch Articles for you

0 Upvotes

r/David_Mitchell • • Feb 05 '26

Am I missing something with Cloud Atlas?

16 Upvotes

I felt pretty disappointed by this book but it seems a lot of people love it. I thought the structure was unique and found each story interesting but I guess I’m just disappointed with how they were tied together. I don’t really understand the point of the reincarnation here, it doesn’t seem to have played a big part. Maybe I’m not understanding it correctly because it was kind of hard to remember certain things due to the way the structure was laid out. I loved Bone Clocks and I really liked Slade House and even Utopia Avenue but I would consider Cloud Atlas my least favorite David Mitchell I’ve read so far.


r/David_Mitchell • • Aug 28 '20

Can someone tell me the Jasper de Zoet storyline? SPOILERS! Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I was listening to the audiobook version of Utopia Avenue and must admit that the only storyline I cared about was the J de Z parts. I've given up on it as there were 16 hours to go and I wasn't enjoying it, but I do want to know what the knock knock was, if indeed we find out. Can a kind someone please tell me what it was? Thanks


r/David_Mitchell • • Apr 21 '26

Just finished Ghostwritten. I was hooked, then impatient, the frustrated. Help me! Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I read Cloud Atlas (one of my all time favorites), Bone Clocks (found it a bit meandering and struggling for a point, but enjoyed the ride), and Slade House (had no idea what it was about when I picked it and really enjoyed it without reservations). I finally grabbed Ghostwritten and was riveted through the first chapters. I read the back of the book and when I saw "noncorpum" I thought, "oh boy, Marinus and those other atemporal scamps are about to pull some hijinks!".

I was enjoying Mitchell's prose which is always superb, but there was this nagging feeling like I was just continually eating the first tasting at a three Michelin Star restaurant. Exquisite, but I was ready to move on to the main course. After Mongolia finished up I thought the setups were going to payoffs, but they just kinda didn't. When two characters reflect on turning points and how "everything after" wouldn't have happened, you expect them to be talking about plot shit, but I think "everything that came after" was referring to the fact that they were going to go on and have lives that we, the audience, occasionally see glimpses of.

I get that characters cross between stories and do little things that have big effects on the other stories we're reading. Culty McCulterson phones Jazzy Boi, making him be at his shop to fall in love and run away with Dream Girl so that Divorcee can see them make goo goo eyes at each other and decide to call it a night instead of going back to work and die-abetes climbing a hill so gold digging cleaning lady grand daughter of Tea Queen (my favorite chapter) can have enough money to visit her on her death bed and be serene enough to travel back in time to give her child self some choice advice tidbits so that she can play host to Ghosty McGhosterson for a bit before going on a zany journey of self discovery including a train level where she bonds with Science Lady over speaking english and gets her to relax enough to invent Chill SkyNet (or maybe it was the other ghost, A-Dawg, who caused the founding of Culty McCulterson's cult) who goes on to prevent human extinction by preventing the nukes from flying ahead of a comet which may or may not kill all mankind.

I get it, connection and lots of it, but what does it mean beyond, "these peoples' stories overlap and doesn't that really make you think?" What do these connections say? In Cloud Atlas, the overlap was not incidental. The characters were knowingly affected by each other across time and medium, but in Ghostwritten, stuff just kinda happens. It just felt like it wasn't enough.

Someone help! Convince me I'm not actually as frustrated as I am!


r/David_Mitchell • • Apr 22 '26

Struggling with Black Swan Green Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I started with space house because I just wanted a crazy house boom - this evolved into Ghost written, number9 cloud atlas and now BWG.

I’m struggling to get through this as I love the other for having that sci-fi element that I love. (besides number9 but I skimmed basically the last 20 pages).

Can someone hint if there is a payoff other than a cute coming of age story? Are there important details that tie together in bone clocks? I’m pausing this for another book now because I need a break and I’m just not having fun with it.


r/David_Mitchell • • May 30 '25

echos of Cloud Atlas

11 Upvotes

I'm reading The Physics of Why by Saleh R Shahid. Definitely echos of Cloud Atlas in it, but also the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. Weird combo but it works.


r/David_Mitchell • • Feb 01 '21

How was Felix Finch in all of these time periods...

3 Upvotes

So wait...something doesn't add up. Let's talk "Felix Fucking Finch" He's a alive and a journalist already in Utopia Avenue in 1969... He's already a name and a reviewer. So he can't be *that* young... then we see him in Cloud Atlas and during his death scene during the party, atleast in the movie he's portrayed as being ...in his 40s'? This doesn't really add up. Likewise in the movie, we see Luisa Rey, in the mid 1970's walking away from a blonde douchey guy who due to her comment it's implied that was Felix Finch... he looks unprofessional, really young, and a stoner...which doesn't correlate to him being a well known reporter/reviewer...and the times just don't add up to him being so young in the "current day" story


r/David_Mitchell • • Mar 01 '21

Foreshadowing in Utopia Avenue (contains spoilers) Spoiler

12 Upvotes

I finally got around to reading Utopia Avenue, after not having time to do so in 2020, and finished it last night. I’m still in my post-book mourning period and need to talk about it with people.

I’ve seen some discussions here that mention foreshadowing Dean’s death, particularly when little Crispin Hershey shoots him at the party. Interestingly, it was a small detail much earlier in the book that foreshadowed it for me. After Dean hurls the cobblestone through Mrs. Nevitt’s window (The Hook), the next sentence says, “Nobody called him out, nobody saw him – a secret he would take to his urn.”

It particularly stuck out to me, that the narrator uses so specific a word to play on the common “take it to his grave” phrase. Mitchell isn’t one for cliché, so it struck me at the time how deliberate that word choice was. In the moment, it reminds you that Dean is mortal, and that the (reliable) narrator knows and is telling you the fate of his earthly remains. The question was just whether his death was going to happen in the book, or afterward. I actually wondered if Dean would die in a fire, paralleling Purple Flames and the burning of his possessions, but perhaps that would have been too on the nose.

Although I did read this one quickly, I’ve learned that I have to take my time with Mitchell and read every word, and in this case, it paid off. Curious whether there are other hidden clues about fates that others have come across in UA.


r/David_Mitchell • • 11d ago

Weird Conspiracy Theory About David Mitchell and AS Byatt

15 Upvotes

An author I like recently posted this strange essay, positing a possibly relationship between David Mitchell and AS Byatt. Ultimately it's all speculation, but it's a fun read and certainly provides an interested perspective on his books.

https://substack.magazinenongrata.com/p/a-conspiracy-theory-about-the-love


r/David_Mitchell • • Oct 15 '19

I_Bombadil's Birthday Today

5 Upvotes

r/David_Mitchell • • Mar 09 '25

quote

6 Upvotes

who is blowing on the nape of my neck? i swing around- nothing but the back of the train, accelerating into the darkness.

-ghostwritten


r/David_Mitchell • • Nov 18 '23

To Vinland

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/David_Mitchell • • Apr 17 '21

Scathing Review for Utopia Avenue, thoughts?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/David_Mitchell • • Jan 04 '24

Ghostwritten Weird rune / misprint in Ghostwritten?

Post image
8 Upvotes

My copy of Ghostwritten has this weird rune? In place of the letters "fi" here and in at least one other place. Is this a misprint or deliberate?

Page 75


r/David_Mitchell • • Jun 05 '24

Anybody else get seriously bogged down with Thousand Autumns?

9 Upvotes

I made it my mission early this year to finally read through all of Mitchell's work, and up until Thousand Autumns I was doing great (for me - I'm not an amazingly fast reader - I tend to miss things if I try to read too quick) but jeez, I've been stuck in this one since April! I won't give up, that's not how I'm wired (which is probably why it's taking me so long - I'm starting to resent it for stopping me achieving my goal!) and I've only got Utopia Avenue to go but wow, I didn't expect it to turn into such a mammoth task. Anyway, rant over.


r/David_Mitchell • • Apr 30 '26

Thousand Autumns/Bone Clocks/Utopia Avenue plot hole Spoiler

10 Upvotes

In TBC, Xi Lo told Marinus as Klara Koskov that:

They had used an Act of Suasion to persuade Shiroyama to end Enomoto’s reign. Poison. Regrettably, it cost the magistrate his life, but such was the arithmetic of sacrifice. My turn will come, one day.

But then in Utopia Avenue, Yu Leon Marinus says:

Governor Shiroyama – the samurai in this frieze – learned about Enomoto’s infanticidal regime. He devised a plot to decapitate the order by poisoning its powerful abbot. Enomoto was wisely paranoid about poison, so the plot required both the governor and his secretary to consume the toxin, too.

Why is this link strong enough, asks Esther, to draw Enomoto’s soul halfway across the city at the moment of death? Marinus selects his words. Jacob de Zoet, an interpreter named Ogawa and I each played a part in bringing Enomoto’s crimes to the attention of Governor Shiroyama. From Abbot Enomoto’s point of view – they look at the dead cleric – we were accomplices in his murder.

Is Marinus just omitting his colleagues' involvement for some reason or is this an inconsistency/plothole?


r/David_Mitchell • • Jul 09 '19

Musician Andrew Bird talks about reading David Mitchell on the road

10 Upvotes

He keeps his copy of Black Swan Green in his suitcase https://youtu.be/H0xbLfyP8BE


r/David_Mitchell • • Jun 24 '19

Considering a re-read of Mitchell, where to start?

10 Upvotes

It's been some time since I've read anything by David Mitchell. I enjoyed all of his books so much (as my name indicates...)

I just think it's time to re-read the collection. I don't know where to start over though as I didn't exactly read them in any serious order the first time.

I have all my own memories and feelings from the first time, was wondering if anyone has done this recently.


r/David_Mitchell • • Dec 08 '23

Slade House (Spoiler) Thoughts on the impact of Slade House's ending to future books

11 Upvotes

***Spoilers for Slade House, Bone Clocks and Utopia Avenue

Do you think that Norah poses a real threat to Marinus and the rest of Horology?

At the end of Slade House in 2015, we know that Norah inhabits a baby and vows to take her revenge.

What happened in Utopia Avenue with Knock Knock and Jasper gives us a good idea of how vengeful the Anchorites can be.

However, we also know that Marinus makes it to at least 2043 at the end of Bone Clocks unharmed and the Prescience think tank he sets up goes all the way to the far future in Cloud Atlas.

Does Norah even survive the Endarkenment? Curious to see if she'll become a recurring character in the next Marinus entry!


r/David_Mitchell • • Oct 30 '25

Utopia Avenue: do I need refreshers on previous novels?

12 Upvotes

I've read all of DM's previous books but they are pretty foggy in my memory. I'm reading UA now and keep wondering if I'm supposed to be making the connections to the broader universe. Should I stop and track down some synopses? I am not going to reread all of them. Thanks!


r/David_Mitchell • • Sep 14 '26

Favorite Character??

12 Upvotes

What’s y’all’s favorite characters from the Mitchellverse? Mine is Hugo Lamb!


r/David_Mitchell • • Apr 23 '26

What are people’s general thoughts on Utopia Avenue? I enjoyed Bone Clocks and Slade House, but Utopia Avenue sounds a bit dull compared to those books.

15 Upvotes

r/David_Mitchell • • Oct 15 '23

Cloud Atlas What's the deal with Bill Smoke? Spoiler

16 Upvotes

Now that posts are allowed, I can finally ask this.

In the second part of Luisa Rey's story in Cloud Atlas, as Bill is about the shoot Luisa, there's this exchange between her and Bill Smoke:

[Luisa says,] "You followed us, from the bank, in the subway, to the art museum..."

[Bill Smoke says,] "Does death always make you so verbose?"

Luisa's voice trembles. "What do you mean 'always'?"

Unfortunately we don't get an answer to what he meant by "always'.

As I was reading the book, I understood that the main characters were reincarnations, or at least a figurative lineage of spirit, and I thought this could imply there's a second continuation among the more villainous characters1 that Bill is a knowing part of, but there's no further evidence of this that I'm aware of. Within the wider context of Mitchell's work, could this exchange be meant to imply that Bill is atemporal through some means?

1 Thinking about this more, several antagonistics have names that could connect to the sky in some way. in chronological order, there's Henry Goose, Vyvyan Ayrs (Air), Bill Smoke, Aurora House, and General Apis (Apian? This one feels like a big stretch). I can't think of anything for Sloosha's Crossin' an' Ev'rythin' After, "Kona" and "Georgie" don't sound like anything I can think of that relates to the sky, but if you have something for this part or something better for An Orison of Sonmi-451, please share. Maybe I'm just inventing patterns from noise, though.