r/Darkfall • u/sandboxgamer • Apr 24 '15
AV lost DF1 source code :(
There was major electrical failure and a small fire in the server room. All media got damaged many beyond repair. I am sad to hear that DF1 code is lost. AV is salvaging DFUW code they shared with their asian partners. :(
4
3
3
u/Jon_Mass Gamelogic Developer Apr 26 '15
You guys have such vivid imaginations!!!
There was no fire, no media damage... the DFO code is quite safe (I have it right here!), as is the DF:UW code... even if there had been such events, our own back-up procedures are more than adequate to cope with it ;P
1
u/Radically_Shifting zZzZz HY Apr 26 '15
the DFO code is quite safe (I have it right here!)
100.000€ if you sneak it out the office
1
u/Jon_Mass Gamelogic Developer Apr 27 '15
Who said I was in the office when I wrote that ;P
1
1
u/xoixoiz May 01 '15
Mass, do you still work at Aventurine?
2
u/Jon_Mass Gamelogic Developer May 03 '15
Yes, I do... contrary to other reports... and I'm still a gamelogic developer, as I was for DFO ;)
1
u/xoixoiz May 03 '15
Good, I asked since the little error with numbering from axilmar when he tried do write 7 and got 1 instead. Hadn't seen you on the forums either so I got worried ;)
1
u/xoixoiz May 03 '15
Completly unrelated but: You have been with AV since 2010(?) , Axilmar have said he do not know why they stopped updating DFO and made DFUW instead. He have said "Most probably it was multiple reasons, mismanagement, internal competition, etc." and he also have confirmed the code base to be quite similar for most of the game, except the completely new gui.
Could you enlighten us on this subject, since you have been around the years of the decision making? Is the code base similar or is the old code base to hard to work with(refereed to as Spaghetti code)? Or is it something completely diffrent?
I hope you can give us a brief overview of the reason, I don't want you to "out" the reason if your not comfortable doing it. I just think many of us just want to know a reason. Even though we don't know the reason/reasoning behind it.
3
u/Jon_Mass Gamelogic Developer May 04 '15
I'll be honest here, I've gone back and forth between writing a lengthy reply, to saying nothing... but ultimately, I feel, there's not much I can add to this, that hasn't already been said (including by me)... I understand that there's an additional layer of confusion that's been added recently... but everything is already "out there" (as long as you steer-clear of the "conspiracy theory" posts that so often appear on here!)... and I fully accept/expect that anything I say here will be taken massively out-of-context...
But, as brief answers, to your direct questions...
DFO was dying slowly, we didn't "stop updating it to work on DF:UW", we stopped updating it because the updates were having little-to-no effect on its decline...
We saw DF:UW as a way to correct the underlying issues of DFO... as an exciting "new chapter" for Darkfall... it clearly hasn't worked out the way we envisioned (stuff, as it has a way of doing, got in the way)... but we do believe that DF:UW is built on a much more solid foundation, with much greater potential, than DFO... it's very disappointing to all of us that it hasn't yet lived-up to that potential...
For the code-base... DF:UW is a fork of the DFO code base, at the point we started work on DF:UW... the two diverged independently from then on... while DFO was live, any updates/fixes that were relevant to DF:UW were merged over... a lot has been changed in the DF:UW code since then... the DFO source was not "hard to work with", both projects are large and complex, so present various difficulties... there were however architectural issues with DFO, that could not be addressed easily (in a live game with active history), which made life hard for us... these systems were removed from DF:UW and replaced with alternative systems, pre-launch... on one-hand, no they are not "completely different", they share a common history, however I doubt that they're very "compatible" any more... it got increasingly difficult to merge changes from DFO to DF:UW, and that was 2 years ago... from a high-level view-point they're similar, in detail they have diverged a lot...
I hope that at least "addresses" your questions ;)
2
u/nuclearping May 07 '15
DFO was dying slowly, we didn't "stop updating it to work on DF:UW", we stopped updating it because the updates were having little-to-no effect on its decline...
Honest question: What "updates" did you do to retain / obtain players? #FunHulks
See also: https://forums.darkfallonline.com/showthread.php?408484-This-dev-quote-has-been-bugging-me
From day 1 launch until the server closed the only new content was 1 ice dragon, a sea tower, villages(lol..), and some very minor things I'm probably forgetting. Sure there were patches here and there but absolutely nothing to add to the game.
1
u/devilbaticus May 09 '15
You can look at a copy of all the old patch notes here; http://darkfallorigin.boards.net/board/17/dfo-patch-notes-old
2
u/zanderzander May 08 '15
You spent 2 years not giving any communication or patches, then delivered DFUW. How did you "not stop patching DFO" when you literally did not patch it?
Also to add, DFUW failed from a mixture of lack of trust in your company, the lies we were told leading up to its launch, and then the mediocre gameplay it delivered.
It took you guys until 2015 to finally communicate and patch your game. If you can't openly admit your errors then you'll never see any game Aventurine produces being a success, because it isn't going away so your going to have to own it eventually.
2
u/Melkrow2 TNT May 09 '15
DFO was dying slowly, we didn't "stop updating it to work on DF:UW", we stopped updating it because the updates were having little-to-no effect on its decline...
I can't accept that, because it's simply not true. Last real expansion you released to DFO was Conquer the Seas, and that expansion alone brought 13 of my friends to the world of Darkfall. The expansion after that doesn't even count, because new textures are not as important as actual NEW content.
But within 3 months they were gone, because you absolutely refused to address the newbie/vet gap (aka the god awful perpetual grind requirements), refused to address alignment system (if you're not green, you're red), no new content (fixes/changes to existing content do not count as new content), no changes to combat meta...after 2 years it got stale as fuck. And you only reacted to dumbass grind when it was absolutely clear that the game was abandoned and you didn't give a fuck about it. Also fuck you very much for never removing fizzle and addressing surge mechanics.
I could go on forever about this I think, how DF1 could have thrived, but it's pointless, just gets my blood boiling for no reason.
With DF:UW, you tried to appeal to both hardcore PVP crowd, and casual WoW crowd. Of course the mainstream crowd did not stick around, it's still a hardcore game, people don't like to lose their pixels no matter what, you fucked that one up pretty god damn good.
But what you fucked up even more is that in the process of trying to appeal to the mainstream, you completely and utterly destroyed your core support community, the hardcore PVP community that proffered "FUN" and "SKILLFUL" combat, risk vs reward, over bullshit like your stupid classes, wobble (LOL!), 'balance', because fuck your rock-paper-scissors balance, it failed. I knew you guys fucked up and lost your way in Beta, when you had a god damn mouse smoothing hard-coded into the game lol...how's that for a "skillful" combat. sigh
I don't know why I wrote all of this... just felt like ranting I guess. I still hope you guys can recover, bring DFO into DFUW (because the other way around is probably not gonna happen).
1
u/xoixoiz May 04 '15
Thanks a lot for the honest reply, and I feel it does clear up some confusions that have been around.
I have the feeling we are back to the same situation where updates are not doing enough to reduce the decline. The new communication from the team is superb, but that alone can't keep us subbed. The patches coming is very important(new gui, new bank, new hotbars, mobloot, etc), but unfortunately most of what they do is to fix old "mistakes". I think all of you would want to use your time on making new content rather than remaking "old" content, but it's important for darkfall future. And that is a bit depressing for all of us.
I think I talk for most of us when I say that everyone(former/current playerbase) want you(especially the devs) to succeed. Darkfall was/is the best pvp mmo around after all. AV have made "stupid" decision and said things they shouldn't in the past that have split the community and done a lot of harm.
I think you might have the possibility with the community on your side to hit the reset button on last time. Try to do a kickstarter, get the game back on track and go for a slower but continuous growth. Do not try to hit the jackpot on the first try, but work with the community to make the darkfall to what we all envisioned it to be, the game we all wanted.
Whatever AV chooses to do, I hope you get the franchise back on track.
4
u/Jon_Mass Gamelogic Developer May 04 '15
I agree with everything you've said here, especially regarding the need for "new content" ;)
1
u/xoixoiz May 15 '15 edited May 15 '15
How far did AV get on the updated character models, sound system and graphics in DFO before they changed focus to UW? (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b5MrrD5cVno) Were it ready to be implemented, but was not implemented or was it still work left on the systems and that was the reason it didn't get implemented?
→ More replies (0)0
u/nuclearping May 07 '15
PS: Additionally you did sh*t to stop exploiting and macroing (acid pool exploit, rigormyds, blood walls, bugged mobs, duping, ...). So the reason for DFOs slow death was YOU and YOU alone. (YOU = AV)
1
u/xoixoiz May 07 '15
He didn't work at AV before 2010, not his fault.
1
1
u/zanderzander May 08 '15
But he sure is talking like he was.
If he joined in 2010 why is he saying AV didn't abandon patching DFO to make DFUW, the lie which Tasos spewed out too. Its clearly not a reality, so why is he still endorsing that crap? DFO had no patches for 2 years, then DFUW came out; where did all this mythical work for DFO go?
1
u/trammie May 08 '15
Any shot we see DF1 again or do we just need to wait a few more months (years?) and hope DFUW becomes enjoyable?
0
u/Jon_Mass Gamelogic Developer May 08 '15
If it's just my decision... no, absolutely not... for me, switching our focus to DFO is a huge step backwards, like just pressing delete on over 2 years of work, and being back with exactly the same issues we've been trying hard to find solutions to... and all the talk of "DFO with X DF:UW feature" is nothing more than a "pipe dream", anyone who says the code-bases are similar enough to do something like that easily, has not looked close enough... even bringing DFO back on-line (on a large enough scale to call "live") would take a lot of back-end development, to adapt it to the systems we have today, systems it was never designed to run with...
But (maybe luckily for you) it's not my decision, so I have no idea, at this point :/
4
u/nuclearping May 08 '15
But you need to agree that these "over 2 years of work" you are talking about, yield not fruits either. There are no doubt less people playing UW than there was at the end of DFO, and its going to be less and less every day.
What you have done to Darkfall by shutting it down, throwing away all these promised features and turning it into that hollow class-based ice-skating meaningless PvP-arena "Unholy Wars" game, wasn't any good either. The community is still heavily backfiring at you.
What about this for instance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b5MrrD5cVno Why did you throw away the 2010 models and replaced it with those all-the-same-looking lore-free uniform models? That alone was a huge step backwards and took away alot of "soul" from the game.
There is basically no turning back for you. Either you create a miracle by turning UW into something which has a real substance, like DFO had in its core or you revive DFO. Otherwise if you don't bring back DFO, then the Emulator will do. It is just a matter of time.
3
u/zanderzander May 08 '15
Every company makes mistakes, it shows character if you own up and remedy.
You guys literally pulled Star War Galaxies NGE patch. You took a free-form skill system into a class system (The comparison is uncanny). Your game has followed the exact same progression.
But hey, its a step "backwards", because it came out in 2008 not 2012. Regardless of gameplay or the numbers show.
2
u/trammie May 08 '15
So you do not think both games could coincide, or just that the work required to set it up would not be worth the payoff?
My personal feeling is DFO is a game I can play now and enjoy, I played until the end and always enjoyed it.
DFUW may become enjoyable in the future but at this time I struggle to login and when I do find myself just wanting to log out.
2
u/tasosflambouras May 08 '15
^ This guy was my friend when I was still at Aventurine, He lies as good as me.
2
u/SirHumpfrey May 08 '15 edited May 08 '15
Unholy Wars was the huge step backwards, not the other way around. If you literally can't see that scrapping 9 years of work in favour of what you call a "new game" was the worst possible decision then you're being ignorant. Your new version doesn't even have half the content of Darkfall Online, now more than two years after release. The game can't even keep a population thats anywhere near that of Darkfall Online, even Darkfall Online post-shutdown announcement when nearly everyone had left.
This is literally your last and only opportunity to turn ship around. As the last few weeks have shown the people are out there willing to return to your game. I honestly doubt Aventurine will exist in 6 months if you don't grab this.
-2
u/Jakobmiller May 08 '15
The attitude.. You are pretty ignorant yourself not understanding the reason they started with DF:UW. Yes, content wise and perhaps a few other things are a step back. But in order to provide content you need to program it. If they code is not well done it's such a waste of time. Take a moment and understand for how long time they worked on DFO.. It was not 2 years. Now the code is changed to the better, the content can be made. We have seen changes to the combat and other things since DF:UW release towards the better. At least in my opinion. Work with what they have is the way to go.
2
u/SirHumpfrey May 08 '15
"Content wise and perhaps a few other things are a step back"?
The "content" you are referring to is what pieces any game together, and UW lacks that, badly.
If they continue down this path there simply wont be a Darkfall in 6 months, people don't want to play UW, people want to play DFO. AV are in deep shit financially and can't keep going for much longer with the negative income that Unholy Wars provides.
1
u/Shaniqualol May 09 '15
All the upcomming patches in the next months includes either fixes to features already in game(bank, hotbars, mobloot) and the "new" content coming is enchanting, which is content from DFO. Fixes to old features won't bring a in a influx of existing players and enchanting might bring in some people for a little while but it won't bring back the masses. How long can you keep on going without salary, it seem's like if the people at AV will get another job at a company that pays they will leave, meaning content will come slower and slower than it already does. Sorry but I do not think you have the manpower or TIME to get Darkfall Unholy Wars into shape, you have had 2 years of live and we do not have promised features from launch yet.
You rather go bankrupt than than loose 2 years of work? Some of the old community wants to give you another chance(free money), a chance AV the company does't deserve, however their employees do.
You could probably get a job in UK if AV goes bankrupt, but your greek colleague can't get a job even though it seems they are trying hard.
Good luck with whatever you choose to do, but I don't see AV surviving much longer if they stay with UW.
2
2
u/grintar Apr 24 '15
if this is fucking true, AV are even more incompetent than we ever believed. I do IT for a couple different small businesses and i always setup redundant offsite backup. And thats just for shit like spreadsheets, and email. If they are so stupid to really not backup SOURCE CODE off site they deserve to be bankrupt and fail.
2
Apr 24 '15
I have a bridge to sell to anyone who believes this.
3
u/miasMafx Apr 24 '15
What's the bridge made of? What is the structural integrity? How big is it? Where is it located? Will the bridge be named after me? What is the purpose of the bridge, walking, cars, trains or other? PM me financial details if you have all of these answers.
1
1
u/rootedoak Beargrim NME Apr 24 '15
Well actually, AV said they had to load up a DF1 server to check move speeds, strafe speeds, projectile speeds and such things a few months back. So I'd imagine that the server could be set up on multiple computers, it would be a good time to hack AV and get the goods.
5
u/Natdaprat Apr 24 '15
This is a nice troll.