To add more detail to the scenario:
Assume everyone takes the same poison pills at the same time at the start of the orgy. Each pill has a time release - a random time, sometime between one and two hours, when it fully dissolves and releases the poison. So, on average, any given attendee will see about half of the orgy members die before they do. Given this, would you prefer a poison that makes people convulse (and, I think, lose consciousness), like strychnine, or one that paralyses people (including respiration), like curare, or some other choice? (yeah, I know, an overdose of viagra is the natural choice for an orgy - but I'm not really sure how that would kill...)