[I already know this will be unpopular, just sharing my opinion]
For the record I am really not a fan of either. Wether u like them or not they objectively spat on the ending of s3 and are inferior to the og show in every way
however the last two episodes of BA season 1 gave me a bit of hope that it would pick up, it wasn’t amazing but it was better than the pre overhaul stuff.
I was slightly optimistic for s2, hoping that a new creative team working on a full season would mean it would improve on things I didn’t like, cringe dialogue, boring side characters, 9 episodes, ugly cinematography that at times did way to much and of course the fog.
But the scenes immediately following the opening scene of Matt fighting on the boat I realised it was more of the same.
There’s not much positive I can say about the start and middle of the show except that I enjoyed seeing foggy back is about it. I will say that Matt actually being daredevil the full season was better than BA1 however it really is bare minimum stuff and a given
Didn’t like how little time was spent with Matt, Karen’s character is also left with nothing to do because the show boxes itself in by making them in hiding
Jessica jones was in the show simply for defenders set up and to try up viewership, she doesn’t serve the plot. Kind of like the punisher in s1
The ending: I felt the ending was incredibly stupid, another instance of this show boxing itself in by making stupid decisions.
Matt exposing himself takes away from what I loved about the character living a double life. And the fact it can’t be undone hurts
Fisk:
killing all those people then going to an island is dumb because it sits on the fence too much “we can’t put him back in jail because the other writers did that twice, let’s just say he’ll escape again so we can’t do it ” (even though he wouldn’t have escaped the time before if it wasn’t for disneys shitty decision making
“and we can’t kill him because we want to keep milking him as a character”
Lo and behold fisks returning to the show the following season but with a beard this time !
This all spits in the face of matts no kill rule and makes him look stupid
AFTV:
The whole AVTF is terrible ice allegory especially in the final episode where they turn on one guy because of Cole north sticking up for himself. AFTV are meant to be pieces of shit, just like ICE. They aren’t all meant to turn because of one guy.
Bullseye: cool character because of Wilson bethel and his powers, no idea how he hid out for so long and survived. Matt letting him go and do the good deed is ridiculous but hardly the biggest problem in the show atp.
Daniel Blake: whilst the season gives him more development, I think I don’t connect because I just want to see more of Matt. And the whole Daniel and Bb relationship just makes bb look like a piece of shit.
Lady muse/heather: what do I even say about this… complete stupidity. Another female character sabotaged by shartapanes shit writing. All the way from season 1 she should’ve known matts extensive history with Fisk, even without knowing he’s DD.
The whole choking Karen whilst they speak about Matt was a really weird reductive writing decision
This show feels like it’s missing a lot of content also. When Matt is shot in the car park, he seemingly teleports to the church even though there was dead people at the scene and police. Same kind of thing with the s1 e9 when Matt escapes the hospital in a gown, (did he walk all the way home bare foot with his ass out ?)
When daredevil fights Fisk which I believe is in e7 the scene literally comes out of nowhere with barely any buildup.
Thats all, whilst I have a lot of complaints I feel they’re all valid and I hope I conveyed everything well