Milburn’s young people and work recommendations
Last December, Alan Milburn was tasked by Government to consider solutions to the high number (one in eight 16-24 year olds) young people not in education, employment or training (NEET). His interim report published earlier this year, talked of systemic failings in education, health, employment support and the employment market, letting young people down.
Next Tuesday Milburn’s recommendations will be published (and we’ll update in next week’s news post) however there has been a lot of advance news coverage this week and several posts in the sub concerned about benefit changes, so we’ve taken the unusual approach of adding it to this week’s news before the report has actually been published.
His report is expected to say that under-25s should no longer be able to claim the health element of Universal Credit or PIP. Instead, under-25s would receive an allowance on the same basic rate as universal credit and some could be eligible for a new ‘additional cost allowance’ to cover day-to-day costs related to their conditions. Those with more severe disabilities and unable to work would get a new benefit paid at a higher rate.
The focus would instead be on training, education or other forms of support. Plus an ‘opportunity guarantee’ for young people.
Milburn said:
"It should be a guarantee for a young person. Because at the moment the only guarantee they've got is a very simple thing. To get a benefit. What sort of life is that?"
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has described Milburn's forthcoming report as a "watershed moment," but stopped short of committing to implementing its recommendations in full.
Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch has previously said the government should not be spending "lots of time" on employment schemes, which she said would ultimately fail.
Her party and Reform UK have argued for significant cuts to welfare.
The Liberal Democrats want the government to introduce a 100-hour work experience guarantee and a careers coach for every young person.
Disability Rights UK has issued a scathing response to the developments this week. Most charities appear to be awaiting the actual report which is due to be published on Tuesday.
It’s clear that some claimants would receive less under the plans - although the exact amounts will not be clear until early next year, when the government publishes legislation to implement the changes.
Proposed benefit and pension rates from April 2027 published
Following a written ministerial statement made the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, the 2027-28 proposed benefit rates have been published.
The new State Pensions will be increased by 3.9%, in line with the increase in average weekly earnings in the year to May-July 2026.
The Standard Minimum Guarantee in Pension Credit will also increase by 3.9% in line with the increase in average weekly earnings. From April, it will be £247.30 a week for a single pensioner and £377.40 a week for a couple, ensuring the incomes of the poorest pensioners are protected.
Other State Pension and benefit rates covered by my statutory review will be increased by 3.5%, in line with the increase in the consumer prices index in the year to September 2026. This includes most working-age benefits and other benefits for people below State Pension age.
The majority of these increases will apply across Great Britain, except for Personal Independence Payment and other benefits to help with additional needs arising from disability, and the rate of Carer’s Allowance, which will only apply to England and Wales. In Scotland, these are devolved matters.
All social security, including State Pensions, is a transferred matter in Northern Ireland.
The Local Housing Allowance rates and the benefit cap will be maintained at their current levels and not increased for 2027-28.
Proposed benefit and pension rates 2027 to 2028 are on gov.uk.
SSAC calls for a comprehensive annual review of all benefits, thresholds and caps
Governments have to decide how much to spend on social security, and whether individual benefits should be uprated. However, there is an important difference between a conscious, explicit policy decision and allowing inflation to determine outcomes through drift.
‘Keeping Pace?’ a report from the Social Security Advisory Committee (SSAC) explores how long-term freezes can change the value, reach and effect of social security policies. A frozen payment will cover progressively less of the cost it was intended to help meet; a frozen threshold can gradually deny more people entitlement; and a frozen cap can affect a growing number of households as rents, earnings and benefit rates rise.
The SSAC says this is especially concerning for benefits to meet specific costs such as the LHA, intended to meet the costs of the lowest 30th percentile of local rents, and the ‘other funeral costs’ element of the FEP, intended to help pay for a simple low-cost funeral. Long-term freezes can create or widen gaps between the amount claimants receive and the actual cost of the goods or services the benefit is intended to cover. In many cases, claimants are forced to bridge these shortfalls using income from other sources, including from other benefits. When this is not possible, the consequences can be severe, contributing to increased hardship, poverty and inequality.
The Committee argues that these changes can alter the operation of social security policy without the visibility, explanation or scrutiny that would normally accompany an explicit policy change. It recommends a comprehensive annual review of all benefits, thresholds and caps, with the results published, so that decisions not to uprate are deliberate, transparent and subject to appropriate scrutiny.
Keeping Pace? Reviewing benefits, thresholds and caps in a changing economy is on gov.uk.
Premature mortality: how education, occupation and deprivation shape inequalities
The Health Foundation has published new analysis exploring how socioeconomic circumstances shape people’s chances of living a long and healthy life.
Their latest analysis, using Office for National Statistics (ONS) data and modelling, explores the links between socioeconomic circumstances and premature mortality (deaths before age 75), revealing stark inequalities between people with different levels of education, jobs and the areas they live in.
The findings reveal:
Men and women living in the most deprived areas have a risk of an early death 2.3 times as high as peers in the least deprived areas.
Women with no qualifications have a premature mortality rate 2.5 times as high as those with a degree or higher.
Men who are long-term unemployed or have never worked have a rate 3.5 times as high as those in higher managerial, administrative and professional occupations.
Higher qualifications and certain occupation types do not fully protect people from the effect of living in deprived areas. Men with a degree or higher and men in higher managerial and professional occupations who live in the most deprived areas of England still have a risk of dying early, about twice as high as their peers in the least deprived areas.
The significant role that area-level deprivation plays in shaping health further underlines the need for action to reduce inequalities between places and ensure that no areas are left behind.
Premature mortality: how education, occupation and deprivation shape inequalities is on health.org.
A template strategy to increase the take-up of social security entitlements
Receiving social security entitlements can make an enormous positive difference to the lives of those receiving them. Yet too many people of all ages are missing out on this vital financial support, despite being entitled to it.
Currently, take-up work risks being fragmented and siloed. An all-entitlements take-up strategy would help realise the UK Government’s ambitions on take-up by providing a holistic view of entitlements, and of the different approaches that are needed to improving take-up. This would help create a coherent system, bring efficiencies, share good practice, and identify any gaps in activity and how to fill them.
Independent Age and Age UK have worked together to explore what a UK Government take-up strategy could look like, including practical changes which combined together could make a meaningful and long-term difference to how many people receive this support. It concludes that to significantly boost the take-up of these entitlements, a systematic and ambitious approach is needed.
The most effective strategy would combine a range of different types of initiatives.
Independent Age and Age UK have grouped these into four key pillars of activity:
Increasing awareness and understanding of eligibility
Simplifying application processes for every entitlement
Streamlining and integrating systems
Increasing access to advice and support to claim
Under each of these pillars, they have identified specific actions which could help turn the dial on take-up. You can read more in the report.
Raising take-up: A template strategy to increase the take-up of social security entitlements is on independentage.org.
Crackdown on fee-charging benefit claim companies
The DWP has confirmed that tougher rules for companies charging people to claim benefits will be introduced within weeks. The Government is preparing a new Code of Practice - targeting companies charging people for help with benefit claims - aims to protect vulnerable claimants from being exploited or pressured into paying fees for assistance.
The forthcoming measures will include a ban on charging fees for benefit claims activity, with ministers indicating that legislation could follow if necessary.
The plans were confirmed by Sir Stephen Timms, Minister of State for Social Security and Disability, in response to a written parliamentary question from Liberal Democrat MP Lisa Smart.
The MP for Hazel Grove asked what discussions the DWP had held with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) about companies charging people for assistance with benefit claims and appeals.
In the written response earlier this week, Sir Stephen said the department regularly engages with external stakeholders, including the FCA, on claims management companies and the provision of advice to benefit claimants.
He said:
"We will be introducing a new Code of Practice in the coming weeks that clamps down on activity by claims management companies undertaking benefit claims activity, and includes a £0 fee cap. This will be backed by forthcoming legislation, if necessary."
The minister added:
"Government is determined to ensure that vulnerable claimants are not exploited or pressured into paying fees to access support with claiming benefits."
The announcement follows concerns about companies offering to help people complete benefit applications or challenge decisions in exchange for payment, despite free assistance being available and the launch of the DWP ‘Don’t pay to claim’ campaign last month.
The written parliamentary question and answer is on parliament.uk.
In an AI world, who can we trust for advice?
What happens when AI gives you the wrong advice, but sounds completely confident doing it? For someone facing eviction, struggling with debt or trying to access benefits, the consequences can be devastating.
In a blog piece from the Executive Director of Client and Member Services at Citizens Advice, Steve Hughes says:
“we're already seeing examples of this happening. And as AI increasingly changes how people access information, I think we need to be asking some bigger questions.
Who is responsible for making sure the advice people receive is safe? How do we build trust in a world where information is everywhere, but accuracy isn't guaranteed? And how do we make sure technology closes gaps in access to support rather than widening them?”
In the latest in the ‘Rewiring the State’ series explores these questions, and why Citizens Advice and the wider advice sector have a really important role in shaping what comes next.
Hughes is excited about what AI could make possible. But the future of advice needs to be shaped around the people who need it most, not simply what's technologically possible.
AdviceNow agrees with him, saying:
“Our information, guides, and self-help tools make sense of complicated legal processes, providing practical help by explaining what to do, and how to do it. They are not written by AI because AI gets the law wrong. We work with experts and people who use our services to make sure our help is accurate, and covers what you need to know.”
Rewiring the state: In an AI world, who can we trust for advice? is on medium.com.
Inquiry into DWP management of Carer’s Allowance overpayments launched
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) announced this week an inquiry into the DWPs handling of the of the Carer’s Allowance (CA) earnings-related overpayments issue.
Carer’s Allowance is currently £86.45 per week. Around one million people received it in 2024-25, with payments totalling over £4.2 billion. There have been longstanding concerns about overpayments, with claimants receiving more than they are entitled to and building up debt.
In December 2024, the government commissioned the independent Sayce Review and the DWP fully or partly accepted the vast majority of its recommendations. Around 25,000 carers could see their debts reduced or cancelled, or receive refunds.
The PAC found in February 2026 it would take around two years to identify all those affected by overpayments, with 200,000 cases set to be reviewed, and further that this issue was allowed to persist because of a lack of integrated, concerted leadership within the Department. It stated at the time that it would be keeping a close eye on the DWP as it implemented the Sayce Review’s recommendations.
In winter 2026/27, the National Audit Office is expected to publish its own update report on Carer’s Allowance. Proceeding from the NAO’s report, the PAC will take evidence from senior DWP officials on how far the Department is getting on top of overpayments, actions it is taking in response to key issues raised by the Sayce Review, and what lessons have been learnt from its experience.
The Committee will be taking evidence as part of its inquiry in due course.
This inquiry is timely as just last month Carers UK raised concerns over the pace of the Carer’s Allowance overpayments reassessment exercise, noting that at the current rate of progress, it would take approximately 40 years to complete the exercise. To meet its three-year timetable, DWP would now need to increase the monthly rate of reassessments more than fifteenfold.
Fixing Carer’s Allowance Inquiry details are on parliament.uk.
Eligibility Verification Measure implementation
The Eligibility Verification information aims to assist in identifying incorrect benefit payments. The changes to the service enable information received from banks to be shared with claimants to prompt them to report their circumstances correctly. DWP staff can then take appropriate action to gather information and evidence about the claimant's circumstances through the existing capital and temporary absence abroad verification processes, helping ensure their payments are correct.
Eligibility Verification Measures apply to Universal Credit, Pension Credit and Employment and Support Allowance. The following information is for UC only.
From 25th November, UC will receive Eligibility Verification information indicating that a claimant may no longer be eligible to receive means tested benefits, specifically:
have more than £16,000 across accounts within the banking group receiving their benefit payment; and/or
have used a bank account outside Great Britain (GB) for 31 days or more.
The service will do some background checking for both eligibility areas. If DWP does not already have the relevant information the claimant will receive a to-do entitled 'Tell us about your Money, savings and Investments' or ‘Going outside Great Britain (GB)'.
These to-dos are auto generated and play back the detailed information the DWP has received from the bank to the claimant and outline next steps and consequences.
For Capital cases where there is history of previous capital disregards and decisions, DWP will compare the information from the bank with the claimant's records. If more information is needed for either eligibility query, the claimant will have 14 days to provide it. Staff will follow existing verification processes.
The abroad process is entirely automated at this stage and does not require a manual check.
Claims may be suspended if the claimant does not respond or referred to a Decision Maker if the claimant disputes the information or an entitlement decision is required. Information from the bank will be available to DWP staff on the claim.
Phone claimants will get tailored support.
Wales – Welsh government calls on the UK government to devolve more power over welfare benefits
The Welsh Government believes that families could get help designed around their needs if the Welsh Government secured powers over welfare. They plan to bring forward a clear plan on how this should be done.
The government said it has rolled out the first phase of its universal childcare offer, with 12.5 hours of funded childcare available for all two-year-olds in 19 of 22 local authorities.
It said the Cynnal Child Payment pilot, a direct weekly payment to families with young children on Universal Credit in selected local authority areas, will show how families can benefit from its existing powers while building the case for wider rollout through additional powers. It continues to call on the UK Government to ensure the Cynnal payment does not reduce recipients’ entitlement to other benefits.
The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Minister for Social Justice and Equality said:
"Poverty rates in Wales are among the highest in the UK and this level of hardship needs meaningful action, but too often the key levers rest with the UK Government.
Welfare decisions for Wales should be made in Wales. To be able to build a fairer and more compassionate welfare system – one that better reflects our needs and values – requires Wales to have greater control over the welfare decisions that affect the lives of our citizens.
The Scottish Child Payment has made a tangible difference to child poverty in Scotland and this is something we want to do here in Wales through our Cynnal Child Payment pilot, but this requires assurances from the UK Government that they would not penalise those who receive the payment – low-income families, with young children, who need it most.
Having the ability to design solutions such as Cynnal that meet the needs of communities in Wales is why we must keep making the case for devolving welfare powers."
The Press Release is on gov.wales.
Scotland - Social Security Scotland, one of the most important investments
The Annual Report and Accounts for 2025-26 and the Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018: progress report 2025 to 2026 have been published, setting out how social security support is helping people across Scotland.
During the last year, more than one million Pension Age Winter Heating Payments were made, helping eligible pensioners with heating costs over the winter months.
Adult Disability Payment supported more than 517,000 people with the additional costs associated with living with a disability, while Child Disability Payment helped more than 109,000 children and young people and their families.
People across Scotland also benefited from a range of payments designed to support low-income households, carers, disabled people and older people with everyday living costs.
Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, Shirley-Anne Somerville, said:
"We're making a significant difference to the lives of families, disabled people, pensioners and carers by delivering essential social security support.
At a time when many households continue to face financial pressures, this money is helping people heat their homes, care for loved ones and provide the best possible start in life for their children.
Investing in social security isn't only the right thing to do for the future, it is the right thing to do right now. We have a duty to act to help people with the cost of living.
We need to support everyone in our society, making sure disabled people can live full lives in a world that often doesn't meet their needs, that carers are recognised for their essential role, pensioners have warm homes and people experiencing serious illness can have the best possible quality of life.
We remain committed to delivering social security with dignity, fairness and respect, ensuring that people receive the support they are entitled to when they need it most."
Following the conclusion of the Scottish Government’s Social Security Programme in March 2026, Social Security Scotland has now assumed responsibility for the design, delivery, and implementation of future changes to the Social Security System in Scotland. The reports outline the work over the past year to deliver social security support safely and securely, while continuing to improve services for clients across the country.
Social Security (Scotland) Act 2018: progress report 2025 to 2026 and the Social Security Scotland - Annual Report and Accounts 2025-2026 are both on socialsecurity.gov.scot.
Case law – with thanks to u/ClareTGold
Universal Credit (liability to pay rent) - DLE v The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions 2026
The legal requirement for including housing costs in an UC award is that a claimant must have a liability to make payments in respect of the accommodation they occupy as their home.
The Upper Tribunal confirmed that the First-tier Tribunal (FtT) made several errors in law.
The Upper Tribunal confirmed the principles set out in R(H)1/03 continue to be relevant when considering whether a claimant’s liability to make payments is on a commercial basis.
The UT set out the order and elements a First-tier Tribunal should follow when determining whether a claimant has satisfied the requirement in regulation 25(3) of the Universal Credit Regulations 2013.
First determine whether the claimant is in fact legally liable to make the relevant payments. If the claimant is so liable, it must determine whether that liability is on a commercial basis for the purposes of regulation 25(3)(a)(i).
Although the evidence relevant to these questions may overlap, a FtT (or decision maker) will need to make clear whether it has found that no legal liability existed or that a legal liability existed but was not on a commercial basis.
If the claimant is not in fact liable, then you must consider whether Part 1 of Schedule 2 to the UC Regulations treats the claimant as liable.
If either regulation 25(3)(a)(i) or (ii) is satisfied, then you must finally consider whether any provision in Part 2 of Schedule 2 treats the claimant as not liable.
On the wording and structure of regulation 25(3)(a), the commerciality requirement in subparagraph (a)(i) is attached to a claimant who has an actual liability. It does not appear to be an additional requirement imposed by regulation 25(3)(a)(ii) on a claimant who is treated as liable under Part 1 of Schedule 2.
Somerset Council’s council tax reduction scheme ruled unlawful by the High Court - Andy Mitchell, R (on the application of) v Somerset Council [2026] EWHC 2930 (Admin)
The High Court has declared that Somerset Council has acted unlawfully in applying the rules in its council tax reduction (CTR) scheme to a disabled resident, Mr Andy Mitchell, following a high-profile, months-long judicial review.
Mr Mitchell is disabled and unable to work due to multiple physical and mental health conditions. He was in receipt of legacy benefits before being migrated to Universal Credit (UC).
Under Somerset’s scheme, Mr Mitchell was not required to pay any council tax while he received legacy benefits. However, after he migrated to UC, Somerset Council reassessed his entitlement to support and sent him a bill requiring him to pay 90% of the council tax (£1,100 a year) for his property, despite no material change in his income levels or needs as a disabled person. This was because Somerset Council’s scheme treated two elements of his UC award (the transitional element and the LCWRA element) as spare income for the purposes of considering his ability to pay council tax.
Represented by law firm Leigh Day, Andy argued that Somerset Council’s scheme was irrational and unlawfully disadvantaged disabled people, including by treating them differently to disabled people claiming legacy benefits and non-disabled people claiming Universal Credit. He also argued that the council had failed to properly consider the impact of its scheme on disabled people in line with its duties under the Equality Act.
In January, the High Court granted Mr Mitchell permission to proceed with his judicial review on the grounds of discrimination, rationality, and compliance with the public sector equality duty.
The judgment released this week, the High Court found that the rules in Somerset’s scheme were discriminatory, the council breached the public sector equality duty under section 149 of the Equality Act to have ‘due regard’ to the needs of disabled people when it adopted its Scheme and it had acted irrationally.
In particular, the judge found that the rules are irrational and discriminatory, because they treat people who have identical needs differently simply based on the type of benefit they receive, without justification.
The judge rejected Somerset’s arguments that the Exceptional Hardship scheme, which Somerset Council operates to assist individuals struggling to pay their council tax does not remove or substantially mitigate the severe impact of this difference in treatment on disabled people.
The High Court also decided that the council was not required to apply the discriminatory rules in its Scheme. It had the power, under s.13A(1)(c) and (7) of the Local Government Finance Act 1992, to reduce the amount further, including to nil, in the class of cases affected by the discriminatory rules.
Somerset Council will now need to recalculate Mr Mitchell’s council tax liability for the 2025/2026 council tax year and pay him damages for injury to feelings caused by the discrimination.
Nb. Somerset Council is currently reviewing its CTR scheme following a consultation that ran from 7 July to 28 September 2026.