Howdy,
Old school DM here. I'm fortunate enough to work with or Parent almost all of the members of my party so we started as a Pen (printer ink) and Paper, with a no laptop policy.
As Covid hit we decided that it would be a great distraction to continue our game virtually.
I set up on Roll20 and got to work.about 20 hours later we we ready to play.
Roll20 worked a few times but we started noticing that the lag on Friday night EST made the site unusable.
Giving Roll20, which made no mention of server connection stress outside of a single line in a changelog, the benefit of the doubt we moved our video chat to a separate client.
no luck, we then moved our game to another night, again the site was unusable.
Figuring Roll20 was choosing serving new customers over existing customers we bailed.
Again fortunately, there is enough technical know how and raw computing power in our party that we were able to deploy Planars Ally, a self hosted open source solution that is actually much nicer than Roll20, Again I got to work prepping the game.
PA worked very well at first, through multiple tests and even a two session dungeon crawl and so I was confident my party could use it to resume their adventures in Greenest.
last night our install of PA stopped refreshing on the client end, multiple reconnects and multiple server reboots later we cancelled the session, again...
I present his info as a cautionary tale to my fellow players and DMs.
It's not meant as a request for troubleshooting or suggestions, I am not going back to VTTs.
It's also not meant to belittle anyone who plays using any means that work, keep that game alive however you can!
As a late 40 something IT guy I understand perfectly (all too perfectly) the nature of software and servers.
I understand that there is no way for R20/PA to test all of the usage scenarios end users will throw at it.
I also have no doubt that if we poured through the logs of our PA system we would probably be able to track the issue down
Additionally I understand Business enough to know that if R20 is providing a fantastic service to 80% of their paying customers they have little incentive to address the 20% that are not happy, especially in the face of exponential Covid driven growth where they would essentially need to turn players away while they scaled their systems. As for open source I have no expectations.
My point is this. There is literally no NEED to use a VTT, ever. The game can be 100% replicated as it was intended via video chat client with a camera pointed at a sheet of paper. Beware the temptation of beautiful maps and Initiative trackers, and scale MOBs. If you use a VTT and it works for you that's great, I had very high hopes for mine, distractingly high hopes, hopes that in the end had little to do with the actually
I have lost dozens of prep hours and cancelled about 100 session/man hours of game time to a system that cannot be repurposed, mostly because I got too excited about what the platforms could do, instead of focusing on what I really needed them for, which is actually nothing.
The first time I played D and D a home Computer was $400,000 in today's dollars.
There are all sorts of fancy bells and whistles for today's gaming (shout out to DnDBeyond which has yet to fail me) that have NOTHING to do with a handful of people getting together and having a shared imaginative experience for a few hours. In my case the technology interfered directly with the imagination portion of the game
Back to basics for me and mine...