r/DIYBeauty • • Aug 12 '20

dupe Advice on choosing ingredient ratios for a dupe of Oumere oil cleanser

721 Upvotes

This is my first time doing a formal DIY complete with preservatives! I just wanted to do this for myself to save some money.

Buying each of these ingredients together on Etsy totals approx. $80, and even though that's less than the price of one teensy bottle of the oil cleanser that they are marketing, it's still a little pricy. I'm wondering if I can cut out more ingredients than I already am while still getting the same effects

--

Proposed ingredients of my DIY dupe:

Aloe juice, watermelon seed oil, grapeseed oil, walnut oil, camellia oil, black seed (cumin) oil, coco betaine, preservative consisting of phenyoxyethanol, sorbic acid, caprylyl glycol.

--

Ingredients of original product ( https://www.oumere.com/products/oil-dissolution-theory ):

Aloe barbadensis leaf juice, water, watermelon seed oil, grapeseed oil, castor oil, calendula oil, walnut oil, Camellia Japonica oil, coco betaine, cocaminodopropylamine oxide, phenyoxyethanol, sorbic acid*, caprylyl glycol

--

Here are my main questions:

  1. I know that I ommitted a few ingredients in my Etsy cart, are any of them mistakes to not add?

  2. Are there any ingredients on my purchase list that will not have any significant benefit and I don't have to buy?

  3. What approximate proportions would you recommend per ingredient/type of ingredient?

  4. Are there any trick to making this or can I literally just measure them out and then mix them together in a little glass/plastic jar?

I'm a materials science & engineering student w/ lab experience but this DIY beauty stuff is completely new to me! Any recommendations would be super helpful.

Thank you, everyone!


r/DIYBeauty • • Dec 28 '19 Heartwarming

recipe I feel like I've mastered Sugar waxing.

493 Upvotes

Alright. I've been wanting to share this for a while now.

I've been trying to make sugar wax for YEARS and I finally watched EVERY single YouTube video I could find and bought a huge bag of organic sugar from walmart.

I've made it perfectly about 10 times in a row now.

So first off, I use organic sugar from walmart (the granulars are slightly larger than regular white sugar and it's a more opaque color). I'm not sure if its the same the same as Sugar in the Raw. But it looks similar. I also use lime instead of lemon.

I put 1 cup of sugar, one lime and .25 cups of water in a stainless steel pot, turn on the burner to medium heat and then swirl the mixture periodically. While it is heating up I put ice and water into a bowl/cup and set to the side.

Once the mixture starts turning a honey color I take a spoon and dip it into the mixture and then immediately into my glass of iced water. If the the sugar wax falls off spoon or feels gooey. It's not ready. I check the mixture every 15 seconds until the cooled sugar on the spoon feels malleable but not sticking to my fingers. The color is usually a dark honey color (roughly 8 minutes-ISH).

I then dump the mixture onto a very clean cookie sheet and scrap it around with a spatula (idk if this part it 100% required). When it is cooled enough to touch I pick up a little piece and begin waxing right away.

The wax only sticks to my fingers if I'm just holding it still. So while it's in my hands I'm always rolling it into a ball and then kinda tossing it between my hands to keep it from getting to warm and getting sticky.

I dont use any strips. Just my hands and I move pretty fast. Use on clean skin because the sweat and oil will make the wax unusable.

After using for a while it can start to get to sticky and that's when I toss it in the trash and grab a new piece.

When the sugar is completely cool, it should still be malleable but you'll need a spoon to scoop it up because it's so hard (like ice cream right out of the freezer). Play with it in your hands until it's a bit more doughy and start waxing again.

Some things I DONT recommend is using a thermometer or a timer. I tried too many times and it never helped me.

Also, if it keeps getting too sticky, just put it back into the sauce pan and heat it back up. My first usable batch had to be put back into the sauce pan 3 times before it was good to use.

Also, buy the sugar in bulk and dont be afraid to spend a few days making batches that might end up too hard. This is how I mastered it, by allowing myself to fail (meaning dont make this the same day as you are NEEDING to use it). I deliberately tried to make one batch too hard just so I could get a feel for how long was "too long".

Also, I'm sure white sugar and lemon will work just fine.

Also, if it's too hard but still slightly malleable, put your hands in warm water and then try to work the water into the wax.

Hope this helps someone!


r/DIYBeauty • • Jun 16 '18

question Can anyone share a proper recipe for sugaring (sugar ball wax/finger wax/halawa wax ) with temperature and how much time to heat etc ?

289 Upvotes

Have watched tonnes of videos made 5 batches so far all either are hard as rock or soft as honey


r/DIYBeauty • • Mar 01 '20

Made some lotion bars!!

141 Upvotes

My recipe was 2.5oz of shea butter, 2.5oz of cocoa butter, 1.25oz of mango butter, .75oz of avocado butter, 1.5Tbsp of tapioca starch, and a coconut/lime fragrance oil blend. They came out so nice and I'm super proud!! Only thing I'd do differently next time is throw in some beeswax so they're less melty in the warmer weather.

https://imgur.com/gallery/9QkTmXj


r/DIYBeauty • • Jul 06 '24

formula feedback DIY sugar waxing is going to save me so much money

115 Upvotes

I have sensitive skin and decided I need to try something other than shaving, and I heard sugaring can be easy on the skin. I wanted to order it online my first time so that I'd know that if it wasn't working, it was because I was doing it wrong rather than because I made it wrong. I chose a company with the best reviews I could find (Sugar Me Smooth) and it ended up being like $100 for body, bikini, and face wax. Those ended up being different sized jars of the same stuff as far as I could tell, and the waxing experience was very frustrating as it kept melting on my skin really quickly. This meant I'd go through the whole expensive jar and probably not even get both my legs done.

Before giving up, I tried to look up what I was doing wrong, and stumbled on this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/DIYBeauty/s/CZxYYRZHGP. It looked like a really thorough guide and it seemed to be working well for this person, so I decided to try it.

I made my own batch of sugar wax, using 1 cup of sugar, 1/4 cup of water, and 1/2 teaspoon of citric acid. (Most recipes recommend a lemon or lemon juice, and the post I was mainly following recommends a lime. I have a bag of citric acid lying around, and it's basically the same thing). It worked perfectly on the first try. I was actually able to wax myself. Testing it by putting a spoonful into ice water every 15 minutes or so is crucial to get the right consistency. I also like the idea of letting it cool on a sheet pan instead of putting it in a mason jar like other sources recommend. This allows it to cool quickly and makes it easy to tear off pieces to use. I put a piece of parchment paper on the pan so it wouldn't stick.

After making this, I was honestly shocked at how bad and how expensive the stuff I ordered was. Also I'm not sure how they got such good reviews. They had like 4.8 stars. Maybe they added some fake reviews or something.

Anyways, just thought I'd share this success story. Idk if the author of the original post will see this, but she really mastered it and did an amazing job explaining. Thank you!!


r/DIYBeauty • • Mar 28 '21

guide Updated List of European Suppliers

103 Upvotes

Whether I was looking for a specific ingredient or for lower shipping costs, I ended up coming across multiple suppliers based on different countries in Europe. Some have a wider selection of ingredients than others and some sell equipment and packaging as well. Unfortunately I don't have time to add that information to each and every one of them so you'll have to search a bit. The majority of them ship outside their country of origin and some also ship worldwide.

[Austria] Kosmetic Macherei

[Austria] Waldehoe

[Austria] Kosmetik Manufaktur - ships only to Austria, Croatia, Germany, Italy, Spain and Switzerland

[Belgium] Aromat Easy - ships only to Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg and the Netherlands

[Belgium] Bioflore

[Belgium] Herbacos

[Croatia] Kosarica

[Czech Republic] Nature Store

[Denmark] Creme Compagniet

[Denmark] Urtegaarden

[Finland] Limepop

[France] Aroma Zone

[France] Ma Cosmeto Perso

[France] Les Utiles de Zinette

[France] My Cosmetik

[Germany] Manske

[Germany] Aliacura

[Germany] Alexmo Cosmetics

[Germany] Dragonspice

[Germany] Skin Chakra

[Germany] Behawe

[Germany] Rosarome

[Germany] Teebaumkosmetik

[Germany] Cosmeda

[Germany] Kosmetische Rohstoffe

[Germany] Hobby Kosmetik

[Germany] Omikron

[Greece] U Make Cosmetics - ships only to Greece and Cyprus

[Greece] Manis Chemicals

[Greece] Candle Making - ships only to Greece, Cyprus and Bulgaria

[Hungary] Cosmio

[Hungary] Humanity Áruház

[Italy] Glamour Cosmetics - ships only to EU countries

[Italy] Farmacia Vernile

[Italy] Formulator Sample

[Italy] Make It Lab

[Lithuania] Aroma Natural

[Netherlands] Jojoli

[Netherlands] Beauty Stuff - ships only to Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg and Netherlands

[Netherlands] De Kruiderie

[Netherlands] De Hekserij

[Netherlands] Avantgarde Cosmetics

[Netherlands] Zeepwinkel

[Poland] Zrob Sobie Krem

[Poland] Eco Spa

[Poland] Mazidla

[Poland] Kolorowka

[Poland] Naturalissa

[Poland] E-Naturalne

[Poland] Zielony Klub - ships only to Poland

[Portugal] Plena Natura

[Romania] Elemental

[Spain] Gran Velada

[Spain] Jabonarium - ships only to Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Portugal and Spain

[Spain] Cosmetica Natural Casera Shop

[Spain] Factoria Natura - ships only to Portugal and Spain

[Sweden] Organic Makers

[Sweden] Naturkosmos - ships only to Sweden

[Switzerland] Heilpflanzen Atelier

[Ukraine] Beurre

[UK] Gracefruit

[UK] Aromantic

[UK] Akoma

[UK] Active Formulas

[UK] The Formulary

[UK] Naturally Thinking

[UK] Bay House

[UK] The Soap Kitchen

[UK] Mystic Moments

[UK] New Directions

[UK] Mistral

In case you know a supplier that isn't listed, let me know so I can add it!

ETA: Bioflore, Skin Chakra, Limepop, Manis Chemicals, Jojoli, Мыло опт, Beauty Stuff, Naturalissa, E-Naturalne and Zielony Klub


r/DIYBeauty • • May 05 '17

safety I can't believe people sell their untested DIY Sunscreen. But they do, and they're proud of it.

102 Upvotes

Dear lord. I was reading the comments on a new Humblebee & Me post on not DIYing sunscreen and found a mineral sunscreen for sale with the following in the description:

"I do not have equipment to scientifically measure levels of SPF, however, through all of the research I have done, I can tell you that this product is at least SPF 20, possibly higher."

I... just... head explodes. And, to add insult to injury, 16oz is $95 USD. Of course the website looks nice and is well designed, so I'm sure some people buy this and use it like it's real sunscreen. Agggggggh.


r/DIYBeauty • • May 04 '22

dupe Update on my attempt at duping L’Occitane’s Amande Supple Skin Oil

96 Upvotes

It’s great! Thank you to everyone that helped me in my previous post. Posting my third attempt below, which I was happy with. The only difference I can tell between the dupe and the original (testing side by side) is that the dupe takes slightly longer to absorb and is a little less “dry”.

MCT Oil - 48%

Sweet Almond Oil - 35%

Fragranced Sweet Almond Oil - 6%

Octyldodecanol -2%

Camelina Oil - 2%

Rosehip Oil - 2%

Sunflower Seed Oil -2%

Sea Buckthorn Oil -2%

Vitamin E -1%

I mixed the ingredients in a hot water bath at 100f to help the vitamin E distribute.

The original formula also advertises as being 50% sweet almond oil, which didn’t work for me. It made the formula too sticky and took too long to absorb, so I’m not sure exactly how they manage that. Maybe a higher quality oil? Increasing the MCT oil really helped to thin it out and increase absorption.

The fragranced oil I used was a dupe of baccarat rouge 540 that I like, but next batch I would like to find a more natural almond scent to use. (If you have any suggestions please let me know).

I put the duped formula into the original Amande bottle and it sprays really well!


r/DIYBeauty • • May 01 '17

discussion [Question] Where do ya'll get your knowledge of cosmetic dermatology and formulations from? Some of you amaze me with the nuanced information you guys have attained. Is it purely from experience, or are there any resources (books) you guys can share?

96 Upvotes

I've been into skin care for a long time now, but I'm really, really, wanting to get more into the science/chemistry of skin, cosmetics, and formulations. Any recommendations?

I'd love some textbook recommendations for cosmetic science, dermatology, and skin care formulations! Thanks everyone!


r/DIYBeauty • • Feb 27 '18

announcement A note from a moderator

92 Upvotes

We are getting close to 20k subscribers. Unfortunately, I have received several complaints about the quality of this subreddit. I am aware of it but it has become difficult for me to moderate daily because of my hectic schedules: work, school, and continuing education courses.

We do have information on the wiki such as preservatives, emulsifiers, and measuring. Don't forget to check out the rules in the sidebar.


How to find the wiki (blue) and the sidebar (red):

App

Mobile

Computer


We will make a permanent sticky post for the newbies to reduce redundancy posts and the real purposes of the DIY Beauty such as making recipes from scratch and using broad-spectrum preservatives in recipes are essential, not optional. We have been getting an excess of posts on mixing finished products together, adding a raw ingredient into a finished product, asking for help to develop their skincare business or address skin issues, and avoiding preservatives. These aren't what this subreddit stands for.

Reminders:

  • Some people are under the impression that "DIY Beauty" means "natural", "organic", or "using minimal ingredients to avoid harmful chemicals". This is not the right place to avoid chemicals or preservatives. Everything is made of chemicals. There is no such thing as 'no or bad' chemicals in the beauty industry. Please remember that all cosmetic ingredients have been tested for safety.

  • Simple questions like "does anyone know a good packaging/bottle supplier?" and "what is a good preservative for the toner?" belong in the "No Question is Stupid & Chat" thread. Please do not worry if you feel that no one answers your question, I'll be on every Monday to answer all questions in the thread.

  • Apparently, baking soda and lemon juice trends haven't died. We don't allow them here, period. Posting or commenting on using baking soda or lemon juice will be removed instantly. Please read the rules in the sidebar.

  • Please post the full ingredient list in the post or comment if you want someone to help you how to dupe your favorite product.

  • Please use a search bar or flair filters in the sidebar to find something that you are looking for.

Thanks for reading,

Deja


r/DIYBeauty • • Jun 28 '20

I cant stop making cream blushes!

90 Upvotes

WHY ARE THERE SO MANY

Next Im going to make highlighters. Its soo much fun making cream cosmetics! Tapioca starch and dimethicone really give it such a nice glide while mixing mica and iron oxides gives a great mixture of shimmer and color potency. Meanwhile, coco triglycerides, argan oil and shea butter really baby the skin.


r/DIYBeauty • • Aug 28 '19

recipe Simple DIY body butter

89 Upvotes

Body butters are a great way to get into DIY skincare, as they’re easy to make and don’t require any special skills.

You’ll need to weigh, melt, whip, and that’s about it! We’ll have a look at how to make mango shea butter step-by-step!

What you’ll need:

- A heat-proof glass beaker

- A spatula

- Scale (to 0.1g)

- Rubbing alcohol

- Hand mixer

/img/qsbjnz9lpj231.jpg

For this recipe, I used the following ingredients and amounts:

- 80g Shea butter

- 95g Mango butter

- 30g carrier oil (castor and olive oil)

- Essential oils (optional)

Process:

  1. Prepare all equipment and sterilize it with rubbing alcohol.

  2. Weigh the ingredients.

  3. Prepare a water bath: add 3cm/1” of water to a wide pan. Bring the water to simmer (low-medium heat).

/img/tmzqeobjoj231.jpg

4. Weigh mango butter in a heat-resistant glass measuring cup

/img/yhrgq8avoj231.jpg

5. Place the cup into the water and let the butter melt

/img/lo97y53yoj231.jpg

6. Remove the cup from heat and add shea butter (slowly, bit by bit). By whisking and mixing let shea melt completely (you can put the cup back into the bath for a few second while dissolving it in mango butter)- but don't overheat it.

/img/orls1ud4pj231.jpg

7. Once melted, remove the cup from heat and let the mixture cool down

8. When the mixture has cool down, add carrier and essential oils that you weighed before.

/img/kvnv9iu7pj231.jpg

9. Place the cup into the freezer for 10 minutes (it will form a layer of solid oils on the top that's still quite soft)

/img/wdbwwoqbpj231.jpg

10. Take your hand mixer and begin whipping the mixture you took from the freezer until it resembles a creamy frosting (a few minutes).

/img/f5gssdcdpj231.jpg

11. Place the cup back into the freezer for another 3 minutes. Take it out and whip for another 3 minutes. Repeat this once or twice more.

12. When you’re done, the butter should look like whipped cream and appear glossy

13. Transform into a clean, dry, and sterilized container/jar of choice.

14. Use at will!

Some carrier oils are sensitive to heat; they lose their nutrients when we overheat them, so add them to the cool-down phase if you can.


r/DIYBeauty • • Jun 22 '20

Just made cream blush for the first time and I think I nailed it! :D

85 Upvotes

Check her out!

This formula uses shea butter, argan oil, emulwax, mica, tapioca starch and kaolin clay to make a smooth creamy cheek/eye/lip color. Gunna try my hand at a bronzer and highlight shade!


r/DIYBeauty • • Dec 05 '19

discussion Dial soap question, ANSWERED cause I'm an idiot :)

85 Upvotes

A couple weeks ago I posted asking if anyone knew the percentage of triclocarban in orange dial soap...

For weeks and weeks I tried to find it...

This morning I looked at my bar and it's on the damned package. Right there. On the wrapper...

Ffs

Just wanted to share my stupidity.


r/DIYBeauty • • May 02 '17

guide Why you shouldn't sell skincare

82 Upvotes

Title aside, this isn't a post to scare you into compliance or crush your hopes and dreams. It's purely a subject close to my heart, as at one stage I had a business selling skincare, and I learnt a lot from it that I want to share.

So here’s a brief summary of the things you should know if you are thinking about selling skincare.

Key Lessons

  • It is going to be really hard – Unless you have a large starting fund, you are going to have to learn and do everything yourself as you won’t be able to source work out to others. Product photography, formulating, packaging, shipping, advertising, marketing, etcetera, will all be on you. Balancing everything can prove to be very hard, as you may find you are not good at everything. Unfortunately, being able to do each of these things well is essential to the success of your business. It is a competitive market out there and the natural beauty industry is the largest growing cosmetic industry, so you will need to ensure your products shine.

  • It will not be profitable (at least not for a while) – I don’t think my business ever made profit. To try and sell more products, I would expand my line so it would appeal to a larger audience. But this needed ingredients, and ingredients cost money. That’s not to say that your business will be run that way, you may be the most business savvy person out there! No matter how experienced you are though, for any business there will be profit losses at first as you need to invest money into supplies, equipment, advertising, and the like, as well as build up a client base.

  • You may lose your enjoyment for creating – I’m not sure what it is about creating skincare that you love. Maybe it’s the science behind it that keeps you on your toes, sharing your hobby with others, the joy of using a product you’ve made, or the excitement of formulating something that actually works. Either way, turning your enjoyable hobby into a business can slowly sap the joy from creating. As a business you will be making the same product over and over again, so if what you love about skincare is creating new products, then you will not enjoy this side of your business. Your products may not sell, leaving you frustrated as all you want is to share your products with the world. This may not happen, but keep in mind that it is a possibility you need to be wary of.

  • You don’t know everything – When I began making skincare I thought I was doing so correctly, but I wasn’t. Though I have learned a lot since then, it would be foolish for me to think I know everything now. I have not studied chemistry and cosmetic science, so the scientific side is still fairly new to me. You will find that in the world of cosmetics, there is always something to know. New ingredients are coming out everyday that you may want to familiarize yourself with, as they all have unique benefits. New research is released weekly that warns you away from different ingredients, and it is at your discretion to decide what is applicable to you and what you believe. In terms of business, there is a whole host of skills to learn, such as accounting, and which regulations you need to comply to. Don’t assume that you know everything or are doing everything correctly, and always be open to and searching for new information to ensure your knowledge base is up to date. Your utmost priority should always be the safety, stability and efficacy of your products.

I decided to step back from the skincare business game as I realized I went into it for all the wrong reasons. I love making skincare because I love creating new products, so making the same product over and over again was not enjoyable for me. It also wasn’t rational, as I wasn’t making any profit to cover the time I was expending into it. All business owners, I’m sure, do a multitude of work that they don’t charge for, and skincare is no different. We can’t charge people for the hours spent formulating, practicing, learning, or the time spent designing the labels and packaging. I think if we did, skincare would be worth a lot more than it is.

The moral of this story is to think carefully about why you want to sell your skincare. If you are inspired to sell skincare as you think it is an easy way to make money, has flexible hours so is therefore suited to your current lifestyle, and is something you will enjoy – tread carefully. Start your business because you want the challenge, you have the initial money to invest and are stable financially, so you feel no rush for your business to be successful, and most importantly start your business because you enjoy all the things that come with it (or at least the majority of them, because no one likes washing dishes and you will wash a lot of dishes).

There is a lot to enjoy about owning your own skincare business. It is an exciting adventure and exhilarating to watch the progress that you make, knowing it was all your hard work that achieved it. You will meet some wonderful customers and you may very well change their lives. Knowing that you have helped someone’s skin, and as a result improved their life, is one of the most rewarding things that you can do. You will laugh, you will cry, and it may be the best thing you have ever done. But please, be aware of the tough side of owning your own business and be prepared.

Disclaimer - This was something I posted on my blog. The original title was as listed here: 'Why you shouldn't sell skincare.' I wanted it to be a shock title that would be engaging and contentious, but a few of the initial readers found it offensive. I later changed it to "Why a Skincare Business Wasn’t For Me… and Maybe Not For You Either," but now have quite a few people saying I should change it back. Do you guys have any thoughts on the title?

TLDR: Selling skincare is hard, learn stuff people ;)


r/DIYBeauty • • May 09 '17

guide Beginner Guidelines to Skincare

81 Upvotes

Edit to add: For those that downvote, please consider telling me why. This is an educative sub so I would love your thoughts to further my own education. If you feel I have shared something that is incorrect, tell me! :)


When you are beginning to learn about the world of DIY skincare, it can feel quite overwhelming. While all hobbies can have a steep learning curve, making cosmetics can have a slightly steeper curve than others as it involves bits and pieces from a broad range of skills. If you are experienced in mathematics, chemistry, cooking, cleaning, and general creating, you'll do great! For everyone else though, there is a lot to learn. In this post we will cover some basic points to know before you get started.

You don't need to be a whiz at everything, but it can help to have some basic guidelines to follow. Here are my must know skincare rules for any beginner:

  1. Don't use kitchen ingredients (for the most part) - Though you can use food grade oils in skincare (in some cases these can be even better than cosmetic grade oils), and items such as sugar, kitchen items such as fresh produce, flavouring oils, colouring, most spices, and anything that needs to be refrigerated or expires in under 6 months, should not be put in your products. You know, unless it is something like a face mask that you are going to use that day and then bin.

  2. Emulsifiers are your new best friend - Water based ingredients such as aloe vera, and oil based ingredients like butters, waxes, and oils, require an emulsifier to combine. Think of it like mayonnaise or a good salad dressing that you don't need to shake.

  3. Use preservatives when needed - Anything made that contains a water based ingredient such as rose water or aloe vera gel requires a broad spectrum preservative. Even if your water based ingredients individually contain their own preservatives, you are still required to add an additional preservative, as the ingredients own preservative may not be at high enough quantities to preserve your final product.

  4. Anhydrous products don't need preservatives - Anhydrous products are those that contain no water based ingredients. This can include balms, most scrubs, facial oils, and whipped body butters. The only time these do need a preservative is if they might come into contact with water through typical use. For example, I always add a preservative into my scrubs, as I tend to use them in the shower and open them in hot steamy bathrooms.

  5. You can't modify commercial products - Store brought products are carefully formulated so that they have the optimum amount of preservative and are shelf stable. By modifying a store bought product, you are throwing off this carefully constructed system. As a result, your product could be unsafe and unstable. The only time this is acceptable is if you are palm mixing for single time use.

  6. Follow the recommended usage rate - As you begin making products, you will notice that ingredients have a minimum and maximum recommended usage rate. It may be tempting to go below the minimum recommended usage rate to safe money, but this is not a good idea as the minimum recommended usage rate marks the point that the ingredient becomes ineffective. Staying above this rate is especially important for preservatives. The maximum rate is the maximum amount you can use before it becomes unsafe. For many ingredients such as fragrance oils and essential oils, exceeding the maximum rate can result in a rash, chemical burn, or something similar. So while you may be able to smell your product from miles away, it's not something you could safely use. Moral of the story - read the labels, stick to them.

  7. Some ingredients can react - Certain ingredients shouldn't be used together as they can cancel each other out or react in strange and maybe not so great ways. Ingredients can also react to external substances, i.e. citrus essential oils are phototoxic, so avoid tanning or direct sun contact after applying a citrus product. This isn't something you will have to worry about right away, but just keep it in mind.

  8. Follow the formulas - In the beginning, follow some basic formulas. This will teach you the basics of how it all works, allow you to develop a preference for specific ingredients and textures, and give you a taster into what you can make. Once you've got that down you can start with the modifying.

So there we go! Now you know the basics, you are essentially prepared to rule the world. Or at least a small portion of it. By following these rules, you can trust that you will be making safe and effective products.


r/DIYBeauty • • Apr 14 '20

Added burdock root to my diy hair mask and it feels like silk.

80 Upvotes

I live in the city, but across from a forest, and have been learning about foraging for wild edible and medicinal plants. Burdock is something I've seen over and over again in my research, and it's all over the place here (in DC)! I dug it up (roots are a foot+ long, so a shovel is required), cleaned it, peeled it, and let it dry for a few days, then grated it down with a cheese grater. My hair pack was:

-ayurvedic/indian hair herb powders (aritha, brahmi, shikaki) -neem and castor oil -2 tbsp burdock shavings

i left it in for about an hour, then used a lot of cleansing conditioner to rinse it out. it's silky soft now :) i've done hair masks with all the other ingredients minus the burdock before, and it's always nice but has never been this soft, so i wanted to share since it's free. go dig up some burdock root and give it a try!!


r/DIYBeauty • • Nov 22 '19

recipe 2 Recipes: Niacinamide + NAG + Licorice Serum & Vitamin C + E + Ferulic Acid Serum

80 Upvotes

Hi guys. :) I just thought I should share how I've been making my serums. I modified u/theacidqueen's DIY Skinceuticals Vitamin C Dupe recipe for the vitamin C. She is brilliant.

I usually make my serums at the same time. I will link where I got the ingredients and equipment, but you can get them from any source of your choice.

The reason I switched out the solvents is because when I made the serums with ethoxydiglycol and propylene glycol, I found them incredibly sticky (my eyelids were sticking together), a little greasy, and heavy-feeling. Ethoxydiglycol really helped to make the serum feel lighter to Ally (sorry if I misspelled) but to me, it made it feel much heavier/stickier. I guess that just goes to show you how subjective skin-feel and such are (could've been other factors too)!

I wanted to share how these recipes worked out for me and talk about how effective they have been so far. I always see recipes and doing things right on DIY sources, but not how effective they are in practice. So I thought I would add that as well.

= PICTURES ON IMGUR. =

Materials Used (for both serums):

- 2~3 weigh boats (to weigh powders)

- 3 small scoops/any plastic spoons (The ones I got from MC were too dang small, but great for very small test batches.)

- Scale weighing to 0.01g (I've had this for years and I love it. It's still going strong.)

- Calculator/smartphone calculator

- Smartphone timer/watch

- Paper towels (lots)

- 1 Jug distilled water (walmart)

- Mini Mixer

- pH strips

- 2 stirring rods (non-metal)

- Sanitizing wipes (walmart)

- Bottle of 70% isopropyl alcohol (walmart)

- Cooking thermometer

- A flat pot

- Silicone trivet

- 1 tricorner 50 ml beaker (to weigh liquids)

- two 150ml beakers (can be smaller)

- two 250ml beakers (can be smaller)

- one 50ml beaker

- ~3 small pipettes

- A pen + flashcard

- Gloves if you want

- Dropper bottles - 1 oz pretty, 10ml smols

Niacinamide Serum

WATER PHASE

6% niacinamide

5% dimethyl isosorbide - (info) - (used in things like Drunk Elephant C serum)

5% propylene glycol (you don't need this, but I have too much on hand so I just used it :[ )

0.5% allantoin

3% silk amino acids

15% high molecular weight hyaluronic acid stock (1% normal molecular weight hyaluronic acid, 98.7% distilled water, and 0.3% Liquid Germall Plus)

58% distilled water

COOL DOWN PHASE

0.5% liquid germall plus

2% n-acetyl glucosamine (you can up it to 2.5~4%, subtract from distilled water)

5% licorice root extract (water based)

  1. Combine WATER PHASE into the bigger beaker.

  2. Weigh it, record the weight (the entire beaker + contents) on a piece of paper/flashcard.

  3. Put the silicone trivet into the flat pot and fill it up water. Then heat it to 70 °C.

  4. Take the smol 50ml beaker and fill it with some distilled water.

  5. Put them on top of the trivet and heat for ~20 min. (Heat should be between 70-75 °C)

  6. Meanwhile, you can mix COOL DOWN PHASE in a different beaker.

  7. Take them out, weigh the bigger beaker. Subtract the new weight from the beginning weight.

  8. Take that much out of the smol 50ml beaker, add it to bigger beaker.

  9. Leave it til it reaches 50 °C.

  10. Pour the COOL DOWN PHASE mix into the bigger beaker and mix with mini mixer (or by hand).

  11. Test the pH, adjust to pH 6. (I used citric acid mixed with distilled water to lower, and triethanolamine to raise. I got triethanolamine at Lotioncrafter's but they no longer carry it. I read that you can use baking soda instead, or sodium hydroxide/lye. You can use sodium lactate too, but you would need asssssloads of it as it's a weak base.)

Notes

- Makes a lightweight, very watery but slightly viscous, colorless serum. A bit tacky while drying down, but once absorbed fully, not tacky at all.

- You can cold process this, but I've had better results hot processing it for whatever reason.

- I definitely noticed a difference in how my skin looks using dimethyl isosorbide VS ethoxydiglycol + propylene glycol or propylene glycol alone, in all my other past iterations of this serum (it was a gel-cream at first). My skin looked brighter and a little smoother faster compared to the past recipes.

The reason you don't see this ingredient more in both DIY and in commercial products is because it's really expensive compared to glycols/alcohol. :[ I have only seen them in The Ordinary & Drunk Elephant, but some other high-end brands use it too apparently, according to INCIDecoder.

I was frustrated that I wasn't getting the same results as commercial niacinamide serums with my cold processed gel-cream. But I'm finally seeing results. I find niacinamide incredibly helpful for keeping my super dry skin/skin barrier healthy. I love it most of all for how it smooths out my skin texture like I'm wearing a primer. It helps slowly fade PIH as well, but don't expect any miracles.

- Don't be alarmed when the white powder doesn't dissolve and is chunky when you're making your HA stock. Just shake it a little and leave it overnight. It'll be clear and non-chunky in the morning! :D

VITAMIN C SERUM

(The directions are pretty much from the original post.)

WATER PHASE

0.5% ferulic acid

15% dimethyl isosorbide

~~~~~~~~~~~

15% hyaluronic stock

50.2% distilled water

OIL PHASE

1% tocopherol

3% laureth-23

(Next time, will be adding something here to help weigh down the beaker more, but it's not necessary if you aren't clumsy like me and spill stuff all the time. Just make sure the beaker doesn't fall over in the double boiler.)

COOL DOWN PHASE

15% l-ascorbic acid (ultra fine. Don't use the supplement crystals!! It's not worth the trouble!)

0.3% liquid germall plus

  1. Combine ferulic acid & dimethyl isosorbide together in beaker #1 (bigger beaker). Stir with rod until dissolved. (It took me less than a minute or something.)

  2. Once dissolved, add distilled water & HA stock in into beaker #1. Mix.

  3. Weigh and record the weight.

  4. Combine OIL PHASE into beaker #2 (medium size beaker is fine).

  5. Pour some distilled water into smol 50ml beaker #3.

  6. Set up double boiler and heat til water is 70 °C.

  7. Stick all three in there and wait ~20 min.

  8. After 20 min, take them out, wipe bottoms, weigh beaker #1 (biggest beaker).

  9. Add the difference from smol beaker #3 to beaker #1.

  10. Dump beaker #2 contents into beaker #1. (Or whichever beaker is bigger/you like more.)

  11. Stir that sucker with the mini mixer for 2 minutes (timer). If it gels, stir in bursts.

  12. Leave til room temp to touch.

  13. Add the 15% ascorbic acid powder. Mix gently with the rod til dissolved.

  14. Add liquid germall plus, stir.

  15. Test pH. Aim for pH 3. (I needed a LOT of triethanolamine to up the pH)

Notes

- Lotion crafter's ferulic acid is darker and more vibrantly yellow compared to the Making Cosmetic's one. MC's also smells a little like vanilla to me. Not sure if this implies anything about quality.

- I was shocked at how easy and fast the ferulic acid powder dissolved in the dimethyl isosorbide compared to propylene glycol. I had to stir an insane amount for a very long time to get it to dissolve in PG.

- I tried dissolving 0.5% ferulic acid in 10% dimethyl isosorbide, but used Making Cosmetics ferulic acid powder instead of Lotioncrafter's. I had to stir like a madman again, and it wasn't dissolving as easily. It didn't take as long as doing it with PG though. Not sure if 10% lowers the solubility too much or because the MC's powder is harder to dissolve than LC's.

- Do noooooooooot overmix. I didn't know what theacidqueen meant when it starts "gelling", I was like, huh, it still looks liquid, so I mixed and mixed because my supplement vitamin c crystals weren't dissolving (and it didn't dissolve overnight). Ended up with jelly chunks. Had to heat it. Stuck it back in the fridge and it got even chunkier after a few weeks. I literally had ZERO issues with gelling when I used the ultra fine vitamin C powder.

- The vitamin C serum I made with supplement crystal oxidized much faster than I expected. I used to use Timeless's vitamin C serum, and it remained clear til I used the whole thing up unless it was summer (applied 2x a day, about a month & a half. Timeless takes ~3 months to start oxidizing for me in the fridge. I went through many bottles over the years.) It gets to be over 100 degrees F here during the summer and even Timeless oxidized pretty fast when left out on counter.

- Previously, I have used SAP and MAP serums before as well. I had nearly zero results from these. I think my skin just weirdly gives ingredients a hard time to penetrate it, because actives that work really well for other people don't seem to impact my skin a whole lot.

- Results: I haven't used this long (only several days) so I can't say much. However, I did find that my skin (and my mom's) started glowing again, in the glass-skin way and not grease-all-over way. Results have been a little slower/slightly less impactful so far than Timeless's serum. I apply this twice a day because I had much better results applying twice a day than once with Timeless's serum too. Smaller pores in the morning, much better skin texture even after not getting much rest. Will update if results change.

- This serum actually has some sort of a smell, unlike the previous one made with the food-grade vitamin C powder. It's,, hard to describe. It's not strong nor does it linger.

- Make sure to adjust the pH right. The first serum I made, the pH was too low and it stung my skin and made my eyes hurt. But the new recipe does not.

- Makes a serum very similar to the niacinamide serum. Every so slightly heavier feeling than NIANAG serum. Much more stickier drying down than NIANAG, takes much longer to dry down.

I think, with the vitamin e oil I use, it's just the nature of the beast. It's EXTREMELY thick, heavy, and sticky. I can't get it off of anything it touches even with multiple washings with soap.

EDIT: Sorry, I didn't mean to make it sound like the vitamin c serum is unusable. I just meant compared to the nianag serum. It's not sticky once absorbed all the way. But I put lotions and stuff on top of it anyways, which takes care of any lingering stickiness.

VITAMIN C GEL-CREAM EXPERIMENT

- Test batched 0.5 oz because laureth-23 can be a trigger for acne for some people. I never had any trouble myself.

- Sepiplus 400 is a cold process emulsifier (looks hella expensive, but you literally only need a few drops at a time), so I attempted to cold process a vitamin C + E + ferulic gel cream. No HA stock.

- 0.5% of sepiplus 400 has no trouble emulsifying 5% mineral oil. However, this DID NOT work out with 1% vitamin e oil because of the extreme thickness. The emulsion broke.

- Sepiplus 400 DOES work to emulsify everything together into a workable vitamin C gel creme. But you have probably have to use much more than 0.5%. At 2%, it makes a pretty thick gel, pale yellow color.

- It was SUPER DUPER DUPER sticky. It took FOREVER to dry down and it left a weird white residue. Sepiplus 400 by itself is not sticky at all. Once absorbed, it literally feels like nothing. So I'm guessing it's the vitamin C + E that may be making it so sticky.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

IN CONCLUSION

I did SO much research over the years and slowly collected all the materials, and I finally made something I'm happy to use. 5%+ niacinamide and vitamin c + e + ferulic are skincare ingredients that I CANNOT live without. They have made my skin so much better, glow, and helped fix my decimated moisture barrier that I destroyed doing unsafe DIY when I was a complete noob. I'm happy to no longer have to pay $25 a bottle for vitamin C, and my niacinamide serum works just as well for me as Olay.

Anyways, hope that helps someone!

Edit 2: Woke up with amazingly glowy, beautiful skin this morning. I'm chuffed.

Edit 3: Doi, I forgot the most important: Batch size calculator. You can calculate how much you want to make using the percentages!


r/DIYBeauty • • Jun 03 '20

For my second DIY, I made a shimmer balm that leaves the lips moisturized, ever so slightly rosy, and shimmery. Super happy with how it turned out!

75 Upvotes

Check it out!

Note that this sets pretty quickly with the beeswax into a soft balm texture. I suggest adding water phase around 120F, additives at 110F and moving to your storage container before it drops below 100F. For a firmer texture thats suited for stick containers, go up to 10% beeswax and drop 2% of one of the liquid oils.

• Shea Butter 20% • Jojoba oil 20% • MCT oil 20% • Emulwax 10% • Beeswax 8% • Vitamin E oil 5% • Flavoring 5% (I used SweetDrops stevia) • Licorice root extract 3% • Mica 3% • Sorbitan oleate 3% • Germaben 1% • PVP 1% • Lecithin .8% • EDTA .2%

Oil phase: shea, jojoba, MCT emulwax, beeswax, sorbitan, lecithin. Heat to 160F, sheer in mica.

Water phase: licorice root, edta, pvp

Additive phase: vitamin e, flavoring, preservative


r/DIYBeauty • • Oct 09 '19

recipe [ Recipe ] Multivitamin Jojoba Squalene Oat gel-cream

70 Upvotes

This was based on my previous recipe that i wanted to improve. My previous formulation used 3% sepimax and it continued to thicken over three days. 1.5% in this formulation creates an immediately usable gel-cream, that will slightly thicken over a couple of days.

Application

Glide and spreadability is good. Sinks in and dries clear. I like it, so does my partner who uses it as a moisturiser and primer. It doesn't look heavy, but moisturises well.

Key elements to formulation

  • Multivitamin complex vitamins (C B5, B3 , B6)

  • Jojoba wax (Vitamin E and B, chromium, copper, and zinc)

  • Oat Silk 12 (lipids and ceremids) - if you've ever used Aveeno, this is what's in Aveeno. It also provides mattifying properties in higher amount and makes formulations less tacky.

  • Squalene (like Jojoba, it's nearly identicle to skin sebum)

  • Sepimax Zen (gel or gel-cream forming polymer - super safe)

Cost efficiency:

In UK and US, these ingredients can be bought in small or large amounts cheaply. This isn't an expensive formulation.

Recipe:

Water Phase (79.5%)

70% Water (can be distilled and/or floral waters of choice)

1% Allantoin

0.5% Hylauronic acid

5% 1,3-Propanediol

3% Oat Silk 12

Oil Phase (11%)

2% Jojoba wax

5% Squalene (edit for context - this is Olive Squalene)

2% Multivitamin complex

2% emulsifyer (Glycerol Monostearate)

Sepimax phase (1.5%)

1.5% Sepimax Zen

Cool down phase (8%)

1% Preservative

7% extracts of your choice

Method:

  • Mix water phase ingredients. The Oat Silk will clump slightly, this is fine - use an immersier mixer of a coffee foamer if required and it'll even out.

  • Mix oil phase incredients. The multivitamin powder and emulsifyer will remain a bit gritty in this phase when heating.

  • Heat both to <75 degrees celcius (and relevant Farenheight)

  • Once heated for 20 mins, combine the water phase to the oil phase immediately

  • Immediately add the Sepimax dry ingredient to the combined Water and Oil phase and start mixing continually for 15 mins / amount of time you feel necessary.

  • Leave to room temperature

  • Add preservative and cool down ingredients.

Initial consistency:

While still slightly warm, it becomes a little stringy but after sitting for a while it creates a nice consistency that goes on really well. It has a cooling and soothing feel and would be great for summer and winter months.

Changes to suit you:

You can balance the use of Squalene and Sepimax as required / if at all. If you wanted something heavier, you can use Cetyl/Cetearyl alcohol in the oil phase, but would suggest looking at water content. Propanediol may not be something you have, so Glycerin is fine to substitute, but may be a bit tackier for those who find Glycerine tacky.

I'd probably leave Oat Silk at 3% because of the benefits and leave 2% Jojoba wax at that percentage. You can modify the use of allotoin and hylauronic acid accordingly to suit you or use something else.

PIC: https://imgur.com/a/ocqiEFD

Good luck.


r/DIYBeauty • • Oct 12 '20

dupe I made a dupe of the Lush "Dirty" shaving cream!

68 Upvotes

So I really wanted to make my own DIY shaving cream recipe, but the only ones I could find were either shaving "foams", or weren't the kind of formulation I wanted.

I was inspired by this recipe from Humblebee and Me, where she made a dupe of the Lush "Sleepy" lavender lotion. I compared "Sleepy" and "Dirty" on the Lush website, and found out that they have some similar ingredients. So I used Humblebee and Me's recipe as a template, but I added and changed several things to make the formula more authentic to the "Dirty" shaving cream. I also doubled the amounts of ingredients.

The recipe if anyone wants it:

Makes 8 oz

Water phase:

150 g (70%) distilled water

4 g (2%) hydrolyzed oat protein

2 g (1%) colloidal oatmeal

4 g (2%) glycerin

1 g (0.5%) triethanolamine

Oil phase:

10 g (5%) emulsifying wax

20 g (10%) sweet almond oil

4 g (2%) unrefined shea butter

10 g (5%) safflower oil

4 g (2%) stearic acid

Cooldown ingredients:

1 g (0.5%) benzoin resin

0.2 g (0.1%) cedarwood essential oil

1 g (0.5%) liquid germall plus (preservative)

Combine the water phase ingredients in a beaker, and combine the oil phase ingredients in another beaker. Place them in a hot water bath for thirty minutes.

After thirty minutes, add the water phase ingredients into the oil phase. Using an immersion blender, blend in short bursts (so the mixture doesn't fly everywhere) for two minutes. Then, leave it to cool for ten minutes. After ten minutes, blend for another two minutes. Leave to cool for fifteen more minutes, then blend for another two minutes. Finally, leave the mixture to cool completely for 30-60 minutes.

Then, add the preservative and essential oils! Mix it up and put it in your container, and you're done!

Mine ended up looking like this . On another note, does anybody know of a brand of label/marker I can use that won't bleed/peel off in the shower?

At first, the scent of the benzoin and cedarwood oil was really strong, but it faded to a more mild scent after a couple of days. You can use a different blend of essential oils if you like!

I just wanted to share my recipe! I hope someone can get some use from it :)


r/DIYBeauty • • Jun 07 '20

Im in love with making lip balms! Just made CBD infused lip balms in chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry!

67 Upvotes

Take a peek!

These babies have a sweet stevia flavor that masks the cbd and a subtle undertone of their respective flavor. Ive had several friends interested in purchasing after sharing these on social media. You can find my lip balm formula in my r/DIYBeauty post history. I modified it for CBD by dropping the mica down to 1% and subbing out other liquid oils for the CBD. The CBD ratio you use will heavily depend on the concentration of your base CBD and your desired balm doseage.


r/DIYBeauty • • Jun 21 '18

discussion Cosmetic Chemistry textbook recommendations? As well as the general sequence of learning chemistry, from beginner to expert, to understand cosmetic development/formulation?

66 Upvotes

Any suggestions for books, textbooks, lectures appreciated!

As well as prerequisites I should be familiar with such as general chem, organic chem, inorganic chem?(is that a thing?) physical chem, analytical chem, anything.

Also what is the field called cosmetic chemistry? cosmetic dermatology? cosmetic science?


r/DIYBeauty • • Feb 20 '18

aha & bha Acid Toner (Biologique Recherche P50 Dupe), Part II: A Recipe + Instructions

63 Upvotes

See Part I of this project here

After more or less figuring out the Lotion P50 formula — see my final breakdown of it in this comment — I drafted a recipe and assembled the ingredients. Last week, I set about making a version of my own. Here's how I did it.

Virtually all the active ingredients — including the acids that do the heavy lifting: gluconolactone, lactic acid, and salicylic acid — are the same, and present in the same concentrations, in my version as in P50. So are all of the solvents and the stabilizers/thickeners. I did substitute a few ingredients due to supplier availability and my own personal preferences, but whenever I made substitutions I tried to replace like with like.

More information about the differences between my dupe and the original product formula, plus the recipe and technique I used to make my version, is below.

Table of Contents, because this post is long:

1. Changes I made from Lotion P50 to my draft recipe

  • 1.1. What's the same between my version and P50

  • 1.2. What I substituted

  • 1.3. What I left out

  • 1.4 Full ingredients list for Lotion P50 and full ingredients list for my dupe

2. Full recipe

3. Instructions

4. My notes and feedback about this version

  • 4.1. Things I love

  • 4.2. Things I don't love

  • 4.3. A note on pH

  • 4.4. About ingredients and sourcing

  • 4.5. Possible changes and optimizations

5. Conclusion


1. Changes I made from Lotion P50 to my draft recipe

1.1. What's the same between my version and P50:

  • All the same solvents used in P50 are used in my version. They are all used in (my guesstimates of) the same concentrations. These are: Water, Glycerin, Propylene Glycol, and Ethoxydiglycol.

  • The same AHAs, PHA, and BHA are used in the same concentrations: Gluconolactone (PHA), Lactic Acid, Malic Acid, Citric Acid, and Apple Cider Vinegar (AHAs), and Salicylic Acid (BHA).

  • The same ingredients with chelating activity: Citric Acid and Gluconolactone.

  • The same thickeners/stabilizers: Sorbitol and Magnesium Chloride.

  • The same anti-inflammatory, skin-brightener, moisture-barrier-repairer, and all-around great, skin-friendly ingredient: Niacinamide.

1.2. What I substituted:

  • I used a different preservative. P50 is preserved with Phenoxyethanol, Sodium Benzoate, and Potassium Sorbate, which together (at least according to my Googling) make up a preservative called KEM NK made by the company Akema Chemical. Although Phenoxyethanol, Sodium Benzoate, and Potassium Sorbate are sold individually at Lotion Crafter, I chose to use the preservative Euxyl PE 9010. Euxyl PE contains Phenoxyethanol and Ethylhexylglycerin, and it's a broad-spectrum preservative effective in products of pH 0-12. I chose it over Liquid Germall Plus because of its effectiveness at low pH; LG+ is recommended only in products over pH 3. My target pH was exactly 3, so while LG+ should technically cut it, I didn't want to be that close to its lower limit. Euxyl PE can be used at up to 1.1%; I used it at an even 1%.

  • The botanical extracts in P50 are a real grab-bag: Cochlearia Armoracia (Horseradish) Root Extract, Arctium Lappa Root (Burdock Root) Extract, Rumex Acetosa (Sorrel) Leaf Extract, Myrtus Communis (Myrtle) Extract, Commiphora Myrrha (Myrrh) Resin Extract, and Allium Cepa (Onion) Bulb Extract. There is also Thymus Vulgaris (Thyme) Leaf/Flower Oil, an essential oil. All of these are used in P50 at far less than 1%, and I guesstimated the total concentration of all botanical extracts at roughly 2.5%. Most of these extracts are fairly esoteric and I could not find them at my usual suppliers. In addition, many of these substances have only modest scientific literature behind them, if any. I substituted water-soluble chamomile, calendula, and centella extracts for the original botanical extracts in P50. I chose those three extracts because I like and use them regularly, and they all have anti-inflammatory, skin-soothing effects. In an AHA-heavy product like this toner, I wanted to do as much as possible to mitigate the potential inflammation of the acids. Also, it's my preference when formulating to go for just a couple extracts and use them at a decent percentage, rather than a droplet each of nine or ten different things. I used my three picks at 0.75% each for a total of 2.25% extracts in the formula.

  • I substituted myrrh essential oil for myrrh extract. I used it at 0.25%, to bring the total amount of extracts and oils to 2.5%. I figured since thyme essential oil, which I planned to omit, was in the original formula, that the solvents present should be sufficient to solubilize a small amount of oil. I also couldn't obtain myrrh resin extract, but I happened to have on hand myrrh essential oil, which is distilled from myrrh resin. I wasn't sure if they were truly equivalent, but I decided to use this token amount of myrrh oil basically as an experiment.

1.3. What I left out:

  • As mentioned previously, I omitted thyme essential oil.

  • I also omitted sulfur. I had trouble sourcing sulfur and I figured such a tiny amount of it wouldn't make any difference in the final product, except possibly to make it smell.

  • I omitted Phytic Acid. I could not find a source for it anywhere (other than AliBaba, that is, where it's for sale by the barrel). Phytic Acid is a skin brightener, anti-inflammatory, and chelating agent. Despite its common name, it's not an "acid" in the same way that Lactic Acid, Glycolic Acid, and Salicylic Acid, etc, are acids — i.e., it's not an AHA or a BHA. It does not exfoliate. At first, I wasn't sure what Phytic Acid was doing in Lotion P50. Is it there to be a chelating agent? Maybe, but there are already other chelating ingredients present. As a tyrosinase inhibitor, could it be used for its skin-brightening potential? Perhaps, but the well-known brightening ingredient Niacinamide is already present.

A book titled Textbook of Chemical Peels, Second Edition by Dr. Philippe Deprez (CRC Press, 2016) may have provided the answer. This passage gave me the key insight that Phytic Acid can be useful in a high-AHA product because it's an antioxidant that can scavenge free radicals before they damage skin:

Phytic acid is not an AHA but is a large molecule of inositol hexaphosphoric acid that is considered an excellent antioxidant and an antityrosinase. It binds out iron. Phytic acid cannot produce a peeling effect. So why is it in this peeling formula? Every peeling produces an inflammation; this inflammation produces free radicals (FRs) and vasodilation. FRs bind immediately with the closest structure, damaging it. Therefore, a peeling always promotes skin regeneration but induces many FRs that can damage the structures that are supposed to regenerate the skin during the postpeel period. Science generally identifies FRs as among the major causes of cell degeneration in the aging process. It is important to fight these FRs during the postpeel period. Phytic acid slowly penetrates the skin after the other acids: It is present in the skin when FRs are produced, when inflammation develops. Scavenging FRs stop the vicious cycle of inflammation-vasodilation-FR.

This passage discusses Phytic Acid in the context of an actual AHA peel (containing Glycolic, Lactic, and Mandelic Acid, to be precise), rather than an everyday AHA product like an exfoliating toner, but I think it's likely Phytic Acid is used in Lotion P50 for its antioxidant/anti-free-radical capabilities, and not just because of its effects on tyrosinase or because it's a chelating agent.

So, I had figured out what Phytic Acid did. But I still couldn't find cosmetic-grade Phytic Acid for sale, anywhere. Because I couldn't get it, I prioritized antioxidant potential in the other ingredients I used, especially the botanical extracts that I chose to substitute.

1.4 Full ingredients list for Lotion P50 and full ingredients list for my dupe

Lotion P50: Water, Gluconolactone, Lactic Acid, Glycerin, Propylene Glycol, Niacinamide, Citric Acid, Ethoxydiglycol, Magnesium Chloride, Malic Acid, Vinegar (Acetum), Phytic Acid, Salicylic Acid, Cochlearia Armoracia (Horseradish) Root Extract, Arctium Lappa Root (Burdock Root) Extract, Rumex Acetosa Leaf Extract, Myrtus Communis Extract, Commiphora Myrrha Resin Extract, Allium Cepa (Onion) Bulb Extract, Thymus Vulgaris (Thyme) Flower/Leaf Oil, Sulfur, Sorbitol, Phenoxyethanol, Sodium Benzoate, Potassium Sorbate

My dupe: Water, Gluconolactone, Lactic Acid, Glycerin, Propylene Glycol, Niacinamide, Citric Acid, Ethoxydiglycol, Magnesium Chloride, Malic Acid, Vinegar (Acetum), Salicylic Acid, Calendula Officinalis Extract, Centella Asiatica Extract, Matricaria Recutita (Chamomile) Flower Extract, Commiphora Myrrha Oil, Sorbitol, Phenoxyethanol, Ethylhexylglycerin

2. The full recipe I drafted:

IngredientPercentagePhase
Distilled Water70.58%Water
Gluconolactone5.00%Water
Lactic Acid 88% Solution5.12%Water
Glycerin4.00%Water
Propylene Glycol3.50%Water
Citric Acid1.50%Water
Ethoxydiglycol1.50%Water
Magnesium Chloride0.75%Water
Malic Acid0.50%Water
Apple Cider Vinegar0.50%Water
Salicylic Acid0.35%Water
Sorbitol0.20%Water
Chamomile Extract0.75%Cool-down
Centella Extract0.75%Cool-down
Calendula Extract0.75%Cool-down
Myrrh Essential Oil0.25%Cool-down
Niacinamide3.00%Cool-down
Euxyl PE1.00%Cool-down

N.b.: A solution of 88% Lactic Acid and 12% Distilled Water is used here at 5.12% to give this product a total Lactic Acid content of 4.5%. Use an acid calculator to adjust for solutions of other concentrations.

3. Instructions

DO NOT ATTEMPT TO MAKE THIS RECIPE WITHOUT PROPER SAFETY EQUIPMENT! I wore goggles and a carpenter's mask, plus my usual long sleeves and latex gloves.

You do NOT want to inhale any of these acidic powders or have ANY of these acidic solutions splash on your skin. Or, God forbid, in your eyes.

Do not skimp out on safety precautions. These raw cosmetic ingredients could give you a chemical burn!

Breathing, skin, and eye protection are a must. So is a precise way to measure pH. I recommend using a properly calibrated pH meter — not strips — to measure the final pH, because 3 is such a low pH.

  1. Prepare your work space and materials. You will need a glass beaker, a glass stirring rod, a precise scale, and a bottle to decant the final mixture into. Sanitize your workspace and everything you will use with 70% isopropyl alcohol. If you're making this recipe, you should already know this drill. Prepare a hot water bath heated to 70 C.

  2. In a glass beaker, dissolve the Salicylic Acid in the Propylene Glycol, with heat if necessary. Stir with a glass stirring rod. Dip the bottom of the beaker in the water bath if heat is needed to help the Salicylic Acid dissolve. Stir very thoroughly until the mixture is completely clear. This took me a couple minutes.

  3. Add all the other ingredients in the water phase to the beaker and stir. Weigh the beaker and everything in it, and write down the total weight. Then heat and hold the beaker and its contents at 70 C for 20 minutes.

  4. Weigh the beaker again and add back distilled water to replace any moisture that may have evaporated during the heating and holding. Stir the mixture with the glass rod, and let it sit at room temperature to cool down below 40 C. Then add the heat-sensitive ingredients in the cool-down phase, and stir until they dissolve completely. The mixture should be ever so slightly cloudy, with a whitish-yellow tinge.

  5. Test the pH; aim for a pH of 3. Adjust pH using a basic buffer, such as Triethanolamine, as needed. After getting the product to the target pH, patch test, and decant into your bottle.

4. My notes and feedback about this version

4.1. Things I love:

I've been using this toner in place of Lotion P50 in my routine for about a week. It seems to work the same in terms of exfoliation; I love the results. It has a very similar texture and skin-feel. Overall, it really looks and acts like the real thing. One thing it does not have is the distinctive aroma of P50 — you know the one: some people call it "vinegar-y," other people say it's more like "trash juice." Instead, this dupe smells of myrrh.

Kept at room temperature for a week, nothing has fallen out of solution. (Based on past threads about how hard it is to work with Salicylic Acid, I was worried that might settle out, but my toner seems to be stable.)

Another thing I love is that, overall, this was only a moderately difficult product to make, suitable for a medium or advanced DIY-er — or even an ambitious and very careful beginner. You do need to commit to some extra safety precautions though, including goggles and a mask, and the utmost precision in measuring.

My recipe included a lot of ingredients I'd never worked with before, so I did a ton of research into formulating with each, but I really didn't know what to expect from my first DIY session. What if it was a nightmare? I was so relieved when it wasn't! The whole thing took less time than making a lotion, and it was a lot less hassle than making, for example, a Vitamin C serum.

4.2. Things I don't love:

Including the myrrh oil was an experiment, and I have to conclude it has failed. For one thing, 0.25% myrrh oil, as small as it is, seems to be just too much oil to be solubilized in this formula. Some of the oil dissolved, but a lot sits on the top of my toner. That's fine for a first run at this — I just shake the bottle before I use it — but it's obviously not ideal, and it also means that when I open the bottle, I get a heady whiff of myrrh. (Maybe not as bad as trash juice, but...) Next time I make this, I'm going to either cut the myrrh essential oil down to 0.1% or leave it out entirely. If I decide to keep it, I may also experiment with dispersing the myrrh oil in a little bit of a solvent before adding it to the mixture. And I'll adjust the botanical extracts upwards to compensate.

Other than that, nothing. I really love this formula.

4.3. A note on pH:

I chose to make this product at a target pH of 3. For me, it came out right at 3 without extra adjusting, but PLEASE PAY CLOSE ATTENTION TO PH AND ADJUST AS NECESSARY IF YOU MAKE THIS. The pH of an AHA product determines to a large extent the amount of acid that will penetrate your skin, and the amount of inflammation you experience (more info on that here). A product at a too-low pH can cause side effects like stinging, redness, itchiness, and peeling, or even give you a straight-up chemical burn. (Even a well-formulated exfoliating acid product needs to be introduced gradually into your routine, to minimize side effects and prevent over-exfoliation.)

Here's how I arrived at a target pH of 3 for this product: I tested my bottle of Lotion P50 and it came out at pH 3. However, my bottle had been open for a few months by the time I thought to test it, and I have seen other people test Lotion P50 (reliably test, with a pH meter) and get results as low as pH 2.4. I think it's possible that when it's freshly made, Lotion P50 has a pH of 2.4 or thereabouts, and that it maybe slowly rises over time after it's been opened.

I could have set 2.4 or 2.5 as my target for this toner, but I simply didn't want to make anything with a pH that low. It's one thing to use a pH 2.4 product that's made by professionals in a lab. It's quite another to think you can do it in your kitchen. A pH of 3 is plenty low enough for me.

4.4. About ingredients and sourcing:

I got everything I needed to make this recipe from a combination of Lotion Crafter, Making Cosmetics, and Amazon. YMMV. A few things I simply couldn't find. Most I didn't miss in the end, but if I ever do track down Phytic Acid, I'd love to try a version of this that includes it, just for kicks.

4.5. Possible changes and optimizations:

As I continue to make this, I will no doubt iterate on this recipe. For example, I'm already thinking about making a version with slightly more Lactic Acid and less Citric Acid and no Apple Cider Vinegar, since I don't think those last two ingredients add a lot, comparatively. I'd like to adjust the Propylene Glycol and increase the Salicylic Acid to 0.5%, since 0.35% is actually below the typical effective range of 0.5-2%. Those and whatever other changes I make will move this product away from being a straight "dupe" of P50 and towards becoming more of my own creation, which reflects my own tastes and preferences. You too could make adjustments and substitutions, including by substituting the botanical extracts of your choice in this product. Please let me know if you make it, and any changes and improvements you make!

5. Conclusion

I consider this recipe a first draft. But since — surplus myrrh oil aside — it worked, I thought I'd share the formula and my notes on this project. I'm thrilled that I managed to come up with a formulation that pretty accurately mimics Lotion P50. If you're looking for a dupe of that product, this recipe will get you there (just watch out for the oil). Best of luck and happy DIY-ing!


r/DIYBeauty • • Jun 26 '20

I made my own clay mask with kaolin + actives and the closest thing to miracle skincare that Ive tried!

61 Upvotes

Check out the first application!

Main ingredients include kaolin, colloidal oatmeal, peppermint extract, Niacinamide, L-Ascorbic acid, licorice root extract and hyaluronic acid alongside gentle emulsifiers for easy wash-off and preservatives. Unfortunately, Ive been advised not to share the exact formula due to monotization efforts BUT I will say it is a basic modification of a MakingCosmetics formula with added actives at common percentages.