r/DID • • Apr 18 '21

Rant/Vent I’m so sick and tired of all these fakers (especially on TikTok)

1.5k Upvotes

DID isn’t fun. It’s not quirky. It’s a trauma based mental illness. It’s amnesi, panic attacks, confusion, exhaustion, incomplete tasks, self sabotage, unstable relationships, and more. I’m fucking sick and tired of all these people on TikTok just switching on command like that’s just a normal thing anyone can do. I’m tired of ALL of their alters being fictives from media they love now or quirky trauma holders who are edgy and cool. I hate how they all know all the information about every alter and they all work together and make TikToks and want to front all the time and switch all the time. I’m tired of them showing no signs until like these past few months as if it’s not something that can only develop in early childhood. No wonder so many people don’t believe DID exists. Because the large majority of people who speak about it online are spreading misinformation and are just basically roleplaying. It makes me so fucking angry


r/DID • • Mar 09 '20

Rant/Vent If you're just here out of pure "fascination"

802 Upvotes

It's come to everyone's attention of a video that's brought a lot of attention to DID. This subreddit is specifically a support subreddit for those with DID, and we'd appreciate if you would respect our space and stop PMing members out of your "fascination."

It's honestly very disrespectful to those of us that are trying to manage our lives the best we can without feeling as if we are the entertainment for others. You don't go into a mental hospital flashing paparazzi cameras and lights at severely traumatized people to satisfy your own curiosity. It's fucking rude.


r/DID • • Jul 13 '21

Rant/Vent Please stop posting misinformation about DID/OSDD online.

764 Upvotes

No, DID/OSDD cannot form without trauma.

No, you can't be born with alters.

No, you cannot leave your brain to go to someone else's.

Please, just stop.

(Aimed at no one in particular, just getting so tired of the makebelieve fantasyland bullshit out there.)


r/DID • • Sep 02 '24

Wholesome how many alters does it take to change a light bulb?

728 Upvotes

I'm not sure, but I know they have a system for it.


r/DID • • Nov 08 '25

Personal Experiences My son met my wife's protector alter for the first time

713 Upvotes

My (39f) wife (35f) was diagnosed with DID almost 2 years ago (we've been married for 10). When her alters first started fronting more openly and communicating as themselves, my wife and her system took great pains to keep our now-8 year old son in the dark about the whole situation.

Things came to a head a few months ago when our son got really upset and said we were always lying to him, and why does Mamma act different sometimes, why does she seem like different people? It was a bit of a gut punch for both of us but my wife's therapist said it would be good for him to know the truth as he knows when were hiding stuff and all the hiding and secrets was making him fearful and anxious.

So we told him the truth. We told him that when Mamma was small, some bad people hurt her a lot and made her keep it a secret from Ouma and Oupa so they never knew. Because Mamma was so scared and hurt all the time, her mind sealed off the bad memories in bubbles and those bubbles eventually got names and personalities of their own. It was how Mamma's brain protected her. He accepted this explanation and we kind of just carried on.

He met one of my wife's littles a while back who fronted. The little, J, was scared and crying. I explained to our son who he was and my son actually helped calm J down and engaged him in conversation.

Last night, my wife was feeling anxious at a family dinner with her parents, sister and brother in law, and one of her protectors, A, fronted. He greeted everyone (they all know him and are quite fond of him) and I told our son who he was. I told him about specific times when it was A instead of Mamma and pointed out times when A had looked after him and done fun stuff with him. Our son went up to A and shook his hand. A was so happy to just get to be himself in front of my son. He told our son he'll never pretend to be Mamma again, he'll always tell him when he's fronting, and our son was so happy about that.

It was a really happy, wholesome moment for me. This year seems to be the year of bringing secrets into the light and I think my family is starting to heal.


r/DID • • Apr 17 '20

My cat thinks she can take advantage of my amnesia! NOT TODAY, GIRLY!

639 Upvotes

Literally a callout post for Cupcake, who I fed this morning at 6am before marking down that I fed her, and hopping in the shower. I got out and got dressed and she started crying at me as she does sometimes when the others "forget" to feed her.

All it took was a sarcastic meow back and I guess she saw I hadn't changed? And she instantly stopped crying and just walked away with her head low.

That's what I thought ya big dummy, can't fool this spirit🌂Eddie Hyde


r/DID • • Nov 26 '20

Success My friend's reaction to me telling him I am a system was priceless.

632 Upvotes

Me: I am We. I have DID so I really am a bunch of tiny people in a mental trenchcoat.

Him, immediately: So... what you're telling me is anyone who has sex with you is fucking the system?

... He isn't wrong. And my punk bf was very happy to hear this, although mildly disappointed he didn't figure that joke out himself.


r/DID • • Jul 07 '25

Support/Empathy My therapist died. NSFW

613 Upvotes

I just found out this morning. I was in weekly sessions with her for 5 years, she diagnosed my DID, she moved heaven and earth for me. It still doesn’t feel real. I saw her two weeks ago, she was working on palliative care initiation through my insurance. I was really starting to trust her on a level I’ve never trusted a therapist before. She was the first person to see my acting out for what it was, get me into proper treatment with correct diagnosis. I just can’t believe it. I feel so stranded. For the moment she is in hospice, I will receive an email when she passes away. It feels like I’ve been stabbed. How am I supposed to just move on?


r/DID • • Dec 12 '25

Personal Experiences It’s been almost 10 years since my partner’s alters integrated. I still miss them sometimes.

605 Upvotes

I’m a man in my 40s, married now with twin kids. But almost 10 years ago, when I met my wife, she was living with DID — though I didn’t know it at first.

The first part of her I met was a romantic alter, the one who eventually fell in love with me. Later, a protector alter appeared and explained things calmly and directly. The host rarely came out during that period, especially after she lost her job due to depression and moved in with me.

From then on, almost every evening, it was the romantic alter who was waiting for me. Sometimes the protector. Almost never the host.

Her previous relationship

Before we met, she had a boyfriend. From what the protector told me, he treated her poorly — sex when she was asleep, leaning on her emotionally, treating her like an object. Another alter had been created specifically to endure him.

The romantic alter I met had appeared only recently, almost like she had been born searching for someone safe.

I was the first person she showed that part of herself to.

Learning about her system

I asked to meet every alter, not to pry, but because I felt I couldn’t build a life with her unless all parts of her felt safe with me. I wasn’t afraid of DID — I just wanted her to be accepted, entirely.

Strangely, loving her meant loving all of them. Each alter had different ways of speaking, feeling, interacting, even different emotional responses to closeness.

The protector and I even shared drinks sometimes — a strange friendship, but real.

And yes, physical intimacy was part of it. Not out of romance for the protector, but out of trust and responsibility for the system.

Integrations

One by one, the alters disappeared.

Some gave a final goodbye.

The protector came out once more, telling me she would be integrating soon, and asked me to take care of the host. I remember saying something like, “I will… but I’ll miss you.”

She gave a quiet, peaceful smile — sad and relieved at once.

And then she was gone.

The romantic alter never gave a final goodbye. She just faded naturally into the host. One day, I realized I hadn’t seen her in weeks.

And then I recognized her expressions, her warmth, her way of loving me — still there, blended into the host.

**I still miss her sometimes.

Even though she is my wife. Even though she never truly disappeared.**

The grief and gratitude exist together.

And honestly — I would have stayed even if she never integrated. I was ready to love her whole system for the rest of my life.

Now

We’ve been married for many years. Our kids are healthy. My wife is whole, strong, and the person I love most in the world.

But sometimes, I remember the other parts of her — the girl who cried into my chest, the protector with the calm and watchful voice, the child alter who only came out to be comforted and then fell asleep —

And I feel something that’s hard to describe: love, loss, gratitude, and peaceful acceptance, all mixed together.

If someone here has ever felt something similar, I hope this helps you feel a little less alone.

I couldn’t talk about any of this for a long time. If this story helps even one person realize they’re not the only one, that’s enough for me.

Thank you for reading.


r/DID • • Mar 12 '21

Rant/Vent PLEASE stop making villains with DID

579 Upvotes

We just watched yet another movie where the villain, the horrifying killer, turned out to have DID

I feel like a monster


r/DID • • Jul 26 '19

Not sure if this is funny or in bad taste. Joke my alter told me

555 Upvotes

First post! I was having a conversation with some people and someone said "a little childhood trauma builds character" and my alter says (in my head) "and a lot of childhood trauma builds characters" *emphasis on the letter 'S'* Not sure if any of you will find it funny but my collab laughed.


r/DID • • Jun 24 '24 Heartwarming

Personal Experiences I’m one person actually

537 Upvotes

I am in fact, one person. My alters are parts of a whole. I developed DID due to horrific trauma as a child. Key word: child, not children. I will never treat my alters like separate people or view them like separate people and as someone who is severely polyfragmented, a separation mindset worsens my condition.

I don’t HAVE to believe my alters are multiple people in one body. I’m not mistreating my alters by not acting as if they are separate people. I literally don’t care, I’m not doing that lol


r/DID • • Aug 25 '20

Someone ordered 1 kilo of jelly beans.

520 Upvotes

I just got a package I did not order, but it was addressed to us so someone in our system must have ordered it. What was in the package? A huge box of jelly beans. It cost 17 dollars. That's a lot of money for some jelly beans.

Someone in our system thought it was a good idea to order 1 kilo of jelly beans. Why? That's beyond me. I don't like sweets. I have no idea who ordered or likes jelly beans this much in our system. But now I'm stuck with 1 kilo of jelly beans, or 600 pieces of jelly beans as it says on the box. 600. That's so much.

Our partner system thinks it's hilarious and that it could be one of our littles. I guess I'll have to see if I can figure out who it was. I would've gladly gotten some jelly beans for whoever wanted them, but 1 kilo? That's way to much. I guess I'll be eating jelly beans for breakfast, lunch and dinner for the foreseeable future.

  • Sebastian

Edit: Thanks for all the awards and comments. I did not expect this post to get this much attention. If anyone wants to see the 600 beans color sorted by me I posted a picture on my profile.


r/DID • • Feb 01 '21

Support Your trauma never had to be bad enough. It was bad enough. Trust me.

505 Upvotes

tw; talks of trauma, gatekeeping

The thing about a lot of trauma spaces is that inevitably you find some gatekeepers. ‘Oh your parents hit you? I didn’t even have parents i spent my first 15 years in a pantry and i’m just fine!! You’re lying about your trauma, faker!!’

Inevitably this carries along to DID/OSDD safe spaces, though i will say it is considerably less. People here understand it isn’t the pain olympics and I appreciate that.

The thing is though, as a child you convinced yourself it wasn’t that bad!! ‘Yes i got hit today but she didn’t hit me with a belt and lock me outside!!’ In long term trauma environments you don’t have a clear idea of ‘this is the worst it has ever been’ because you are in constant high alert and you are aware it could easily get worse.

‘But my trauma still wasn’t that bad!!’

Have you ever heard the window of tolerance? It’s kind of like this— there’s a box of tolerance, where you cope normally and relatively happily. But when it comes to fight flight or freeze, you fall outside the box. You weren’t weak for it. When a kid gets lost in a supermarket they’re already on high alert. It doesn’t take a lot. You don’t need fire or flames to scare a child so far. They’re scared. You were forced to be that kid, scared, alone, afraid for SO LONG! How unfair is that??

Another thing i get scared of is how people describe it as ‘to be a system you need to have the ability to dissociate as a child.’ And naturally i go ‘ahhh!! I don’t remember dissociating!! I have to be a faker!!’

Dissociation is a ‘freeze’ response. It’s not just pausing like a deer in the headlights. Either you fought a gruelling battle, you fled, or you froze.

And finally and most importantly you may have felt like something to be used, to be perfected, like you were there for others, but no. A child made you. A terrified child who couldn’t do this on their own. Be kind to that kid. They did their very best.


r/DID • • Apr 27 '23

Relationships Dissociative Identity Disorder is NOT an excuse for infidelity with your partner.

502 Upvotes

Dissociative Identity Disorder is an incredibly complex disorder. While the symptoms of DID can vary widely from person to person, and each person's experience of the disorder will be unique to them, one aspect of the disorder remains consistent throughout. No matter how one views an individual with DID, there is only one body and one mind. One responsibility.

System responsibility, or system accountability if you prefer that term, describes the shared responsibility for thoughts, behaviors, and actions as a collective and accepting that all of these alters within the individual are collectively responsible for their actions; whatever one alter does, everyone is responsible - there is no shifting blame to individual parts, everyone shares that responsibility equally. This concept can be best explained in ISSTD's Guidelines for Treating Dissociative Identity Disorder in Adults (2011),

( . . . ) hold the whole person (i.e., system of alternate identities) responsible for the behavior of any or all of the constituent identities, even in the presence of amnesia or the sense of lack of control or agency over behavior (Radden, 1996)

When it comes to being in a committed relationship with someone presenting with DID, discussing your boundaries for the relationship is beyond paramount, as it should be regardless of the dynamic. Discuss with your partner what kind of relationship you are comfortable having. Are you looking for a monogamous relationship with either some or all alters involved? State that boundary. Are you looking for a polyamorous or open relationship with other alters who may engage in separate partners from yourself with consent? State that boundary. If these boundaries have been discussed, yet the individual decides to get against what had been stated, that is cheating, full stop.

It's important to remember that regardless if there is an inability to control their behavior, it is not an excuse - The body commits the action, and the body goes through with the behavior.

TL;DR DID is not an excuse for infidelity. If you have discussed boundaries with your partner regarding your relationship and they explicitly go against your wishes, alter or not, that is cheating. Alter cheating is still cheating.

Please take care of yourselves.


r/DID • • May 30 '20

TRIGGER WARNING: Rant/Vent I am so tired of being told I have a responsibility to become whole again

493 Upvotes

Tw for CSA

I finally got rid of my shitty ass therapist who kept forcing an "integration." She refused to use my name, only my old name that nobody in the system or anyone we know use. Let's say that name is Emma. She got literally angry when I tried to say I'm not Emma. She yelled that yes, you are Emma. You owe it to people to be Emma. You owe it to society. How will people feel if they have to use 10 names for you? (They don't, we've all agreed on a new name, which is now our legal name, but she ignored that part.)

I just wanna scream to her that EMMA IS DEAD. There is no Emma. If "society" was so concerned about Emma, they should have come and got her two fucking decades ago. They could have acted on the CPS reports. They could have seen her in daycare when she acted out the abuse on her dolls instead of punishing her for exposing the other kids to sexual stuff. They could have noticed when her weight dropped to organ failiure level. They could have been concerned about a 1 digit aged kid showing up high as a kite to school. None of that happened, and NOW it's my fault? Now I am somehow supposed to what? Learn witchcraft and bring a dead kid back to life? Spending years puzzling myself together into a fucking franken-person so "society" can ignore their failiure and pretend they did right by Emma all along?

I am here. She is not. So why can't "society" grieve her loss, plant some flowers on her grave, fucking own up and say "we did that." And then they can get off my back about it and let me live my life. Call me by my name. Listen to what I did to get here. I'm not responsible for making sure nobody has to deal with the painful truth that is the society they're all part of.

I'm so tired of seeking therapy and not getting further than "Hi my name is..." before I get yelled at for not being who nobody gave me the opportunity to become.

The good news is I reported her ass and they sided with me. Apparently you can't yell as your patients for having symptoms of the disorder they're diagnosed with. Shocker.


r/DID • • Dec 17 '25

Wholesome Mom: "I haven't heard about the disorder before, but I knew you had it."

490 Upvotes

Told my mom today I have DID. I explained it to her with those structural dissasosiation models and stuff.

Her response was (shortened) "I didn't know this was a thing, but I am absolutely not surprised. I already told you you were completely different after [traumatic event]. We've tried to understand your logic for so long, as you'd talk in depth about something, and then change your entire opinion the next day. Every time you're coming to visit I ask myself "Who's gonna come through that door this time?". When you had (what I thought was) a bad day, I'd just pretend to be listening and send you home, because I'd know you'd be different again in a day or two."

Then later we went through the parts I've identified and their traits, and she said "You're missing one" and added some guy I've apparently not found yet.

I know it's normal to not remember your amnesia, but I did not realize it was to this extent. My own mother, delivering one crushing blow after another 😅😂 I genuinely thought I only had emotional amnesia and only two parts fronting.

Anyways, I'm bringing her to therapy next time, the therapist will probably have fun with this.


r/DID • • Oct 07 '24

Discussion People That Actively Want This Disorder

488 Upvotes

I've seen a rise of people assuming they have this disorder or actively wanting this disorder. A conversation I saw was someone saying they wished they had headmates because they wanted real imaginary friends. This disorder- Yes it's called a disorder for a reason- is not just about "friends in your head" it's debilitating having lost time, memories, panic attacks at random, breakdowns, meltdowns; and hard switches. Nothing about this should be wanted


r/DID • • Mar 30 '24

Discussion Dissociative identity disorder? More like NO identity disorder!

481 Upvotes

I thought this conditions was gonna give me quirky friends in my head but I spend 99% of the time feeling like an actual zombie and nobody at all. Instead of cool convos when I’m down and lonely I just get people voices yelling at me that I stink.

(no shade to super distinct systems with a lot of communication, i just don’t really experience that and I feel very isolated a lot of the time. Everyone is cool.)


r/DID • • Jan 18 '22

Rant/Vent People that hunt down fakers "for" us are hurting us all

472 Upvotes

I'm getting so sick of this rush of people who aren't systems hunting down anyone who isn't their perfect idea of a system and accusing them of faking to "protect us." They're not protecting us, they're harassing us. I always see them have the same four reasons: too many alters are queer, too many are fictives, there's too many alters in general, or they're too young. All of those are possible in systems, there's not a single reason any of those would prevent you from getting diagnosed.

Systems don't need to "make sense." They're a child's last hope, when no one will save them and they can't make it on their own. Children don't have a realistic understanding of what will help or hurt them, and a system will continue to be built on the same core beliefs until they process and replace those beliefs in therapy. (edit: some people do figure this out on their own, but it's usually something that takes therapy)

All they do is target children, usually for not understanding themselves when they're only 16. I thought I was possessed when I was 16, we aren't born understanding the science behind systems. All these kids need is for them to educate them, but no. They call them fake, harass them, and tell them to kill themselves for hurting "real systems."

Calling everyone you don't like or someone who isn't your exact idea of a system fake is only making systems that doubt themselves constantly do it even more, it's making people spiral and it's hurting them more than if you would just educate people. This is all so pointless and I really hope this trend ends soon


r/DID • • Jul 04 '25

“Tell me you have DID without telling me you have DID”

469 Upvotes

Will accept comments or memes in response.

I’ll go first:

  1. Having several completely different responses to a question someone asks you, and not knowing how to respond in a way which will keep your body in a state of peace 💁🏻‍♀️

  2. Finding emails in your sent box that you have no memory of writing and would never send.


r/DID • • Oct 21 '20

Informative/Educational Covert systems, you are valid too.

464 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying every system is valid, overt or covert.

Overt adjective done or shown openly; plainly apparent.

Covert adjective not openly acknowledged or displayed.

The last year(s) I see a surge of people with DID coming out online. There's some well known Youtubers, Instagram, TikTok, etc. There's interviews on tv, it's in magazines, newspapers. There's more awareness, which I see as a positive thing.

Most of these channels show very overt systems, where the switches can be dramatic (in the sense of being very noticable), where alters put on different make up, change their clothes, heavy accents, etc.

These overt systems exist, but are not the norm. For most systems, DID is covert, switches aren't so obvious, and only people who know them well can tell when someone else is out.

I applaud the overt systems for bringing attention to this disorder and vlogging about it, normalizing it.

But if you are a covert system, if your switches aren't as big and noticable as the TikTok folks or youtube channels, if you don't switch 40 times a day while around other people, when your alters don't introduce themselves to others the first chance they get... then you're just as valid as the overt systems in the social media. You are.

DID is a hidden disorder. That's how it works for over 90%. The whole idea behind DID is that it allows you to function past the trauma without people noticing. It's ingenious. It would not make sense for most systems to be so noticable.

Again, if you are an overt system, you are valid. But it's almost all we see on social media. It makes sense, many viewers don't have DID but heard about it, look it up, and want to see how it works, what switches are, and I think the more dramatic the symptoms, the more people will watch, it's human nature. So the overt systems will get more views, more attention, and be more known.

But the downside to this is that newly diagnosed covert systems doubt themselves because they only get to see the overt display, and don't recognise themselves in that. Whoms therapists didn't notice the switches, whoms partner mostly realised something was off, but don't know what exactly. Who are not aware of their alters, names, genders, ages, and a whole array of other information (we are 15+ years into the diagnosis and still get baffled by all the information some people have on their alters, including their horoscope signs?) Systems where switching is a thing, but whoms first symptoms aren't all the switches, but the PTSD symptoms, the confusion, the insomnia, the amnesia, the amnesia for the amnesia which leaves them with nothing but a sense of dread and losing their mind.

Everyone's DID presents differently.

And if systems on social media make you doubt yourself, then remember that their overt display isn't the norm. It's how it works for them, but the vast majority (after 15 odd years of therapies and group therapies and being active in peer to peer support groups I dare to state that it's really the vast majority) of diagnosed systems are covert.

No one knows you but you. There's a reason you are diagnosed, or why your symptoms led you to believe you might be multiple. Find a trauma informed therapist, and let them be your guide. Find peers (and I risk being burned for this, but with finding peers I would try to avoid Discord channels with a bunch of 15 year olds. They may be valid, but there also seems to be a lot of role-playing DID servers for young folks).

Just follow your gut and your medical professionals. Don't feel like your DID is only valid when you're like social media systems. They are a minority. They do good work by raising awareness, but don't give into self doubt or denial when you don't fit the overt mold.

You are valid. Full stop.


r/DID • • Jan 27 '26

Alter's favorite song nearly destoyed me.

457 Upvotes

I really have no one to talk to about this, so it helps me to write things here. I appreciate your grace in reading my posts.

My wife is a person who lives with DID. We are still in the early phase of learning about her alters.

One alter who has been fronting is a very young child. I will admit that she is cute as a button, and I have been doing everything that I can to make her feel safe and loved. Last night she fronted right before she fell asleep. I was trying to get to know her by asking some basic questions. She was asking about the music that was playing, and so we spoke about songs.

I asked her what her favorite song was right now. Keep in mind that she believes it is 1984–1986 at the most. I was expecting some Cyndi Lauper song or something of that nature.

She looked up at me with these big brown eyes and said, “The Little Fishy Song.”

Nothing has hit me as hard as that response. For the first time, I realized how young my wife was when her horrific abuse started. Her mom used to sing that song to her. She had to be 4 or 5 years old. I think I cried the rest of the night thinking about her living through the nightmare that she had to endure as an innocent child.

It never really sunk in what she endured, (or I didn’t allow it to). But “The Little Fishy Song” opened my eyes. I would kill that man if I could, but he is already dead and in hell.

It also allowed me to know one thing about my wife and her alters: that she is the strongest woman I have ever known. She is better than me in so many ways, and her strength is one of them.

If any of you are feeling low, scared, and alone, remember just how remarkable you are. You are still here. You are stronger than you can imagine. You are the best of us on this planet. I know there are days when it feels like you cannot bear to be present in the life you have been given, but you can, because you already have. I admire your strength and your perseverance. You inspire me to be a better man because of it.

Thank you all for that,
Sdb


r/DID • • Apr 08 '26

Discussion Misunderstandings Surrounding Dissociative Amnesia in DID

453 Upvotes

There is a trend in online CDD spaces I've noticed that is both frustrating and factually incorrect, and that is the idea that a lack of *severe* or *blackout* amnesia automatically disqualifies someone from a DID diagnosis.

I've seen SO many undiagnosed people say they must have OSDD-1 rather than DID just because their amnesia isn't "severe enough". But if we look at the actual diagnostic criteria, it doesn't line up with that thought process.

According to the DSM-5, the amnesia requirement for DID is as follows:

> "Recurrent gaps in the recall of everyday events, important personal information, and/or traumatic events that are inconsistent with ordinary forgetting."

*that's it*

The criteria does NOT state that:

- Amnesia must occur on a daily or even weekly basis.

- Every alter must experience the amnesia.

- The amnesia must be a "blackout" or absolute loss of time.

The only requirements are that the gaps are *recurrent* and *inconsistent with ordinary forgetting*.

If you experience the presence of distinct identity states (alters) and *any* amount of qualifying dissociative amnesia, congrats you have DID.

Spreading the idea that DID requires constant, severe, or total blackout amnesia is *harmful*. It perpetuates the idea that DID/amnesia can only look one way, which can prevent people from seeking the correct treatment because they don't fit their (inaccurate) ideas of what this disorder looks like. It also ignores the reality of "grey-out" amnesia, isolated amnesia, or one-way amnesic barriers, which are all incredibly common in DID.

It is very disheartening to see people with "years of research" (as self-diagnosed individuals often claim to have) having such a fundamental misunderstanding of this major aspect of DID.

We need to stop equating DID with only its most extreme presentations. If there are alters and there is dissociative amnesia, it is DID - regardless of what exactly that amnesia looks like.


r/DID • • Dec 22 '24 All-Seeing Upvote Heartwarming Helpful This Bless Up Heart of Silver Take My Silver

Discussion Let’s talk about DID and society identity

446 Upvotes

ETA: SOCIAL identity* Spent ages typing this up and then typo’d the title 🤦🏻‍♂️

Hey there, r/DID and r/OSDD - I plan on cross posting this to both of you. For awhile now, I’ve been wanting to make a discussion post breaking down some observations I’ve noticed in the general online culture surrounding these disorders. So… let’s talk about it, shall we?

I’ve noticed a worrying trend of people online treating DID (and P-DID/DID-like presentations of OSDD) as social identities, instead of diagnostic labels for disorders. Something akin to LGBTQ+ identity, or identification with a specific neurotype (think autism, as an example).

People listing it in their bios on public accounts, public alter lists and “alter introductions,” telling everybody they’re a system, signing off comments with specific alter names, referring to themselves as ‘plural.’ (As a few examples right off the type of my head)

I’ve seen people using the phrasing of ‘coming out’ to refer to telling someone they have DID, I’ve seen people recoil at someone politely suggesting they may be wrong when self diagnosing and to keep an open mind (usually met with accusations of invalidation), people immersing themselves so heavily in DID spaces online that, if it turned out they didn’t have DID, that they’d find themselves shit out of luck and potentially unwelcome in their spaces they’ve made themselves at home in. People armchair diagnosing friends with DID, etc.

These are all… concerning trends I’ve noticed, that I think these all tie back into this viewing DID as a social identity as opposed to a diagnostic label.

DID, as a diagnosis, exists because there is a grouping of the population with similar/near identical clusters of symptomology that require treatment (as they cause clinically significant distress or impairment to functioning). The label of dissociative identity disorder exists so practitioners can quickly indicate to other professionals what type of treatment this group of people needs in order to better their quality of life. That is the purpose of a diagnostic label.

Instead of viewing the label of DID like this, it’s instead seemingly been shifted to be viewed as an identity label - akin to how people identify with their interests, their sexuality, their gender, etc.

People who view the label of DID like this, if they end up self diagnosing, will end up extremely attached to this label to a concerning degree - because they now view it as part of their identity. Whenever they end up seeking professional evaluation - if it turns out they’re wrong, they’re then not likely to accept it. They’ll likely reject the non diagnosis, argue with practitioners, file needless complaints, or engage in doctor shopping (this last one especially being dangerously close to factitious disorder).

Complicating this further, is the fact that a lot of this goes hand in hand with (or even is outright considered to be) indicators of imitative DID, the main parts concerning me being ‘endorsement and identification with the diagnosis’ ‘fragmented personality becomes an important topic of discussion with others’ and ‘ruling out DID leads to anger and disappointment’ (Ill be linking what I’m referring to in the comments, having issues embedding on mobile)

It seems to be possible for even genuine DID patients to develop imitative DID tendencies when exposed to these online spaces - this one I’m basing off of testimony from people I’ve encountered now diagnosed and in therapy, but displayed many imitative symptoms that weren’t actually real years prior. Imitative symptoms they have to spend a lot of time and effort in therapy sorting out from their genuine symptomology - time that could be spent healing.

So… why does this matter?

I’m going to look at this from the lens of the potential harm towards individuals with genuine DID, and not imitative - that’s been talked about quite a bit, and this post’s already lengthy enough. If anyone wants to open that discussion in the comments, feel free.

The main issue that always, immediately, comes to mind is the fact that if you tie in maladaptive symptoms of a trauma disorder into your sense of identity, then recovery from those maladaptive symptoms is going to be rough. Instead of healing, it will instead feel like you’re ripping chunks out of your sense of identity (something that is already far too fragile with this disorder, after all).

Along with this, many of the ‘talking points’ (for lack of a better term) that I see that go hand in hand with treating DID as a social identity tend to be inherently antirecovery in of themselves.

Anti-fusion mentalities (and no, I’m not saying fusion is the only path to recovery - my current goal is what people call ‘functional multiplicity’ actually) where it’s treated as death, or a loss.

Treating alters as if they’re fully separate people, and not dissociated parts of one whole person (this goes hand in hand with referring to one’s self as “plural,” in my opinion), something that will worsen dissociative barriers between parts and push one further from recovery (regardless of whichever your end goal is, this applies to both). Sometimes, people are at a point in their recovery where they cannot recognize this - that’s okay, and it’s normal. The issue comes into play when this idea is allowed to perpetuate in online spaces, essentially enabling those stuck in this mindset to remain in it despite it being counterproductive to their recovery in the long term.

Shunning of correction of misinformation due to it feeling invalidating to one’s sense of identity - as they have identified with DID now. This tends to go along with the phrase “all systems are different” - something that is technically true, on the basis that individuals are different so presentations can vary a bit, but often times seems to instead be used for validating someone not actually displaying the symptomology of DID, and shutting down anyone pointing this out (no matter how polite or rudely this is done).

Communities surrounding DID - a trauma based disorder, with a suicide attempt rate of about 70%, per the DSM 5 - should be heavily focused on recovery. That does not mean camaraderie or comfort and kindness needs to be thrown to the wayside, or that we need to be miserable all the time (I’ll be the first to tell you that I share the occasional funny (morbidly funny, usually, but funny nonetheless) moments that occur due to my alters with my therapist and boyfriend. Laughter is, in fact, a coping mechanism, after all), but that allowing so many anti recovery mindsets to circle in online spaces makes them effectually useless, harmful, and practically inhabitable for people who are trying to recover.