r/Cynicalbrit • • Sep 09 '15

Discussion Sick of TB's Antics

0 Upvotes

I would like to preface this with that I'm not specifying one particular event that TB's been involved with but rather a generalized pattern I've noticed from him when he attempts to talk about something on Twitter.

TB tends to find something rather insignificant, blow it completely out of proportion, give it more attention in the process and complain about the fact that it became so big. It's like he was concerned about a pet dog being too thin. So his decision to fix this problem is to overfill the dog's kibble bowel till the dog was a health weight. Except he forgot his plan 6 months ago, the dog is now 50 pounds overweight and contracted diabetes. I feel that this has gotten to the point where it's become really grating. I always groan when I find one of these and think "Oh no, not this again.". I know he has problems with this and is currently in therapy for it. But TB really needs to hand over his social media to someone else who is capable of dealing with this. That person also needs to actively cut off TB from it since he can't be trusted to leave it alone. Like think of his social media as a key. Once given the key that person should eat the key and never give it back. No matter how much he begs. This really has wrecked his reputation as critic that should be taken seriously. You know after tasing yourself repeatably it really shouldn't come as a surprise that people no longer consider your opinions to be valid because you tased yourself repeatably. In my eyes he's downgraded quite significantly after his frequent displays of "raging against the machine" as it were. If this continues I'm going to find my " Yuotueb Vidyo gaemz critacizm" elsewhere thank you very much.


r/Cynicalbrit • • Jan 24 '16

Discussion Biscuit, please read this: Why reviewing F2P titles should be done without premium currency

252 Upvotes

I started Warframe a couple of months ago, towards mid- to late September. I very quickly reached a point where it was near impossible for me to make ANY kind of progress in unlocking further content. Biscuit said that he had invested roughly additional 60 hours into the game since picking it up again, and had unlocked all these warframes, such as Loki Prime, within that timeframe. He also mentioned the abundant platinum he has due to referring so many people. And that's where I feel as though the big disconnect happens. I myself have invested roughly 40 hours into the game at this point. I have a successfully leveled up an entire set of weapons to rank 30, and was well underway to do so again. And then it pretty much ground to a halt. The problem with being a F2P player is that because of the limited number of slots that you have, there is no variety to what you can select, and most of the time you can only have a chance of getting the components needed for a single item to begin with. It doesn't matter what you may WANT to work towards, you are FORCED to work towards a single goal. The game is designed to make you do this, causing frustration when that goal isn't reached. But working towards that goal is the only thing that you can do.

So Biscuit, if you are doing a review of a F2P title, please review it as a F2P player, without using premium currency. I myself felt as though your perception of the game was greatly impacted by the fact that you had this much choice and variety to choose from. Yes, you can eventually unlock it though grinding but the process of unlocking it is, as you yourself said, that grinding is the core gameplay of the game. Yes, having access to different warframes to show off and to be able to give an impression of the variety in the game is an important part of the review. But so is giving an adequate impression of what the average users experience is going to be when they play the game. You have over 7000 platinum. That's worth a high end gpu. Average players have to save up for sometimes over a year to have that kind of spending money. And the overwhelming majority of players simply aren't willing to spend that kind of money on a single game.

You mentioned your wife, and how she got frustrated being a F2P player. I honestly ask you here: would you yourself not also get frustrated, not having access to the variety of playstyles or a particular playstyle that you know is entirely possible to play within the game, but that you cannot unlock due to absurd grinding requirements? I do not believe that she got frustrated simply because she didn't get one specific item, but rather that she couldn't get anything at all.

Now several people, like Biscuit, are going to argue that a game with this level of polish and features deserves to be supported with the players who wish to play the game to a great extent paying the developers money. But that's not the point I wish to address here. I felt as though the review of Warframe was strongly influenced by having access to all these items, and having that gameplay variety readily available. There indeed is a point where doing a headshot with a mark 30 Paris becomes boring and repetitive. And you can't comment on that when you don't experience it that for yourself.

I do not believe John Bain to be malicious or greedy. Nor do I expect that he took that platinum as a means of payment for a positive review of the game. He has stood up for consumer rights on too many occasions for that to be the case. But please, if you are reading this, see if you didn't inadvertently miss or incorrectly categorize a large flaw in the game as something minor. It would help set my mind at ease if you created an alternate account and tried playing as a F2P player, as to be able to accurately judge if the game is indeed what you thought it was. If you actually read this, holy crap, thank you. You've brought a lot of happiness to my life and I hope you finish kicking that cancer in the balls.

Edit: Thanks to everyone posting below keeping it civil. I appreciate the constructive discussion going on here. I made this post after watching TB's (as I've now come to realize everyone refers to him as TB...) latest video on Warframe. However the points I brought up in this still apply to reviewing F2P titles in general. Games such as the recently released Blade and Soul, for example, feature a paid subscription service which grants priority queue placement, xp and money boosts, and quicker fast-travel services, all of which cut down on the grind of the game. Or Star Trek Online, a game where in theory you can unlock every last item by mining dilithium and then converting it to the premium ZEN currency. Or World of Tanks, where you can skip the entire leveling process by throwing gold at the screen.

Edit #2: So I'm reading the comments and I would like to clarify a few things: I stated an understanding of wanting to display end-game content as part of a review. My point was that the free experience, "the grind" of playing through the game and the enjoyability of that gameplay should be the deciding factor. And with TB having had an abundance of platinum since the game came out I am simply worried about him possibly underestimating the time investment needed to indeed unlock that fun variety so many players crave. There are several games where grinding for high-tier content/gear becomes incredibly monotonous and tedious. An abundance of premium currency could very well result in a different experience. Again, I do not believe TB to be malicious or anti-consumer. But I would appreciate seeing his thoughts after experiencing the game without any support from the abundance of platinum. I simply do not believe his current play experience to be a complete one.


r/Cynicalbrit • • Apr 29 '18

Discussion Does anyone else feel that the others on the podcast talk over TB way too much?

2 Upvotes

It is getting annoying lately, TB's voice is a bit weaker/hoarse these past months and the others seem to just explode as soon as a light bulb goes on in their heads to get their thing out.


r/Cynicalbrit • • Dec 05 '17

Discussion My disappointment with TB's stance on the Larva vs Legend/Zotac controversy.

0 Upvotes

Let me start with some background information. A couple of days ago the Korean progamer Larva played in SC remastered against the Chinese progamer Legend in the Finals of the Zotac Cup. Apparently Larva was the much better player, and showed this of by goofing off in various ways during the three played games, whiles still winning. The first game, he killed one of his own drones at the very beginning of the game. In later games he used more flashy methods like using his foot instead of hand on the keyboard or leaning back into a sleeping position.

Now, watching Larva's antics was certainly entertaining but it was also obvious, that Legend was becoming more and more distraught with the situation. In the aftermath, the organizer Zotac decided to ban Larva from all future events.

The reason why I want to bring this up for discussion here is mainly due to TB's stance on the matter.

He criticizes Zotac's decision as an attempt to "deflect attention somewhat from the pretty pitiful stream numbers". Furthermore he argues that "zotac should be thankful" to Larva for the publicity. It also becomes apparent, that he considers Larva's behavior as a net positive since it gives personality to the sport. I recall comparisons with Wrestling on previous occasions, which lives on the basis of personalities, feudes, etc.

Though I agree, that the whole controversy has probably generated a bunch of additional publicity and led to a lot more eyeballs on that particular series, I am quite distraught that this is used as an excuse for bad sportsmanship, especially since this is mainly about the public humiliation of a singular person.

The idea, that any company/organizer would let something like this slide just because it generates publicity, not caring for the well being of the players, sickens me and I am glad that ratings were not taken into consideration as an excuse for Larva.

That does not mean, that I am generally against more colorful personalities and more action on the personal level in SC. But, as in Wrestling, everybody has to be on the same page. Larva initially claimed that he has checked with the staff if something like this is okay (though Zotac denies giving any such permission). But even with staff permission, what really matters is asking the other player if he is alright with it, because that is the person who has to actually deal with a pretty uncomfortable situation.

Bottom line: If you want to make a tournament where such antics are allowed that is alright, as long as all the players know what they are getting into, otherwise basic rules of good sportsmanship should apply.

I mean seriously, I know one other person on twitter who is focusing always on the ratings, we are better than that, people!

PS: I do not intend to discuss about who is to blame for what in the controversy, like so often there are probably a lot of greys rather than blacks and whites going on there.

PPS: On the offchance, that TB reads this: Don't worry, I do not think that you are a heartless person who does not care about good sportsmanship. I know that you want to see more action and antics in SC2 and that is great, I just think that you may have misstepped here and you know with great power come greatly overused spiderman quotes.

Kind regards, Entropie


r/Cynicalbrit • • Sep 14 '15

Twitter Twitter: @HuniePotDev Hi, do you have an email address I could use to get in touch about something?

Thumbnail
twitter.com
12 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Sep 09 '15

Twitter Wow I am so done with this so-called subreddit about my husband. I wouldn't suggest it to anyone at this point.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
130 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Oct 14 '18

Discussion Anyone else feeling that Youtuber "YongYea" has kinda taken over Totalbiscuits mantle?

7 Upvotes

I find myself watching him more and more, and I see him also posted more and more on Reddit in situations were normally Totalbiscuits videos would have been posted: Videos critical of videogames, or especially videogame-industry decisions.

His style is not exactly like TBs, but it has the same general feeling of consumer-advocacy.

Here just a random video I pulled of his channel, about the shortcomings of Fallout 76

https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&v=mxUSF9jn8xg


r/Cynicalbrit • • Jul 26 '15

Fanart [fanart/fansketch] Cynical Brit is Best Brit

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Feb 21 '14

Pat the NES punk discussing TB and Youtube Flagging

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Jul 08 '15

Discussion /r/CynicalBrit will join other subreddits in the July 10th Reddit blackout for 24 hours. Details within.

15 Upvotes

Edit #1: The blackout is pushed back 2 hours for the moment. The countdown timers have been updated to reflect this change.

tl;dr:

A 24 hour subreddit blackout will begin at the end of this countdown timer.

The 24 hour blackout will be lifted at the end of this countdown timer.

When the blackout is in effect, this post will be edited to reflect that.

 

/r/Cynicalbrit's moderation team have decided through a majority vote of the moderators to blackout the subreddit for 24 hours on July 10th. This vote did not include Intricacy or Zooc; while they do sit on the moderator list they are also employees of TotalBiscuit's company. /r/CynicalBrit is not a subreddit owned or operated by Totalbiscuit - it is an independent community that is about TotalBiscuit.

For further clarification, here is a tweet referring to this fact from TotalBiscuit himself:

John Bain
‏@Totalbiscuit

FYI I have no control over our subreddit anyway and the moderators can do as they see fit.

Considering the international nature of TotalBiscuit's fanbase, we have set up a convenient countdown timer that will give a time when the subreddit is planned to be re-opened:

Chronus.EU Countdown to /r/CynicalBrit re-opening

During the blackout period:

  • Moderators will not be participating in the subreddit.

  • No new submissions (links or text) will be able to be made.

  • Any new comments made during the blackout period will be removed by Automoderator.

  • The subreddit will otherwise remain viewable. No "This subreddit is private" screen; you'll be able to read all existing posts from prior to the 24 hour blackout.

Now that the logistical details of the blackout are out of the way, here's a quick Q&A about our blackout:

 

 

Why exactly is /r/CynicalBrit blacking out for July 10th, 2015?

You can read some (mildly circlejerky) information about the proposed blackout at /r/Blackout2015 and /r/JustSayNope.

Reddit has repeatedly failed to provide good tools to moderators. In technical terms, Reddit's moderation features are barely on par with forum software from a decade ago. Reddit has been promising improved tools for moderators for years now and they have repeatedly failed to deliver anything that makes our volunteer efforts anything other than a massive pain in the butt. Things like /r/toolbox and /r/enhancement are practically necessities.

We are not confident in Reddit's ability to fulfill these promises as a result of past experiences.

Furthermore, the creeping "cleaning up" and "corporatization" of Reddit stands contrary to many of Reddit's founding values centered around freedom of speech and the community's ability to create and drive content.

 

 

What is the point of the blackout?

We as moderators want to register our displeasure with the state of Reddit in general. We hope that by joining other subreddits blacking out it will serve to drive home to Reddit that they have failed the moderators (and by extension the community) in numerous ways. Furthermore, we hope to raise awareness of the actual state of Reddit behind the scenes.

 

 

What does a subreddit of 53,000 subscribers hope to accomplish in the grand scheme of things?

That's like saying one vote counts for nothing. It might be technically true, but that's a defeatist attitude we're not comfortable with.

 

 

How can we help out in the protest if we want to?

Don't log onto Reddit on July 10th and avoid using it in general. Make your voice heard by not participating.

 

 

I don't like this or I would like to register a complaint about it.

You can message the moderators, although many of us won't be available on July 10th as we'll be avoiding Reddit.

Again, any comments posted on the subreddit are automatically being removed during the blackout period. That said, we can still see them and we still will be going through them. Anyone who uses comments or modmail as an opportunity to send abuse directed towards anyone will result in a ban and possible further action depending on the severity.

 

 

You guys aren't closing down permanently, are you?

No. Again, we will be open again with 24 hours of closing.

Here is the countdown for when the subreddit will re-open.

 

 

Why wasn't a community vote held on the blackout?

This is a decision made by the moderators to (in part) bring awareness to problems moderators have been dealing with for years.

We haven't consulted with the community on what the rules are or how they're enforced. We haven't consulted with the community on who the moderators are or how they run things. We curate the content based partly on specific instructions left by TB for how he preferred the subreddit to be run as well as our own ideas about how the subreddit should be run.

This can be viewed as analogous as a transport strike - it stinks for the commuters that the trains aren't running, but things aren't going to improve for the conductors and engineers otherwise. And if conditions are bad for them they can also eventually be bad for the commuters.

 

 

Are there any other places we can discuss TotalBiscuit's stuff in the meantime?

We have a sister community set up over at http://www.voat.co/v/TotalBiscuit. It may very well be down, though, as Voat has been attracting a lot of new traffic due to Reddit's missteps in these last few days.

 


r/Cynicalbrit • • May 28 '16

Discussion What in the F does "Total Halibut" mean?

4 Upvotes

?


r/Cynicalbrit • • Jun 06 '13

A TGS Community Podcast?

0 Upvotes

Like many others, I've been somewhat disappointed with a number of TGS podcast guests.

Subsequently, one frustration I always have, is being stuck on the other end of the screen watching someone who has little to add to the discussion, while I'm sitting there bursting with ideas and opinions. (Same probably applies for many members of this community)

So while watching this week's guest and wishing I could have swapped myself in and given the show the respect it deserves, a thought occurred...

Community Cast?

The way I see it, everyone that tunes in to the TGS podcast has two things in common: We all love gaming and we enjoy watching TGS content creators (specifically but not limited to TB, Dodger and Jesse).

So could that be a thing? A regular fan/community cast run for and by the fan-base? Could cover everything gaming, as well as impressions/discussions surrounding what's currently happening with our favorite TGS content, in addition to including some exposure for fan created works (art videos etc).

I mean the format could obviously be anything. Really just wanted to see whether people:

a)Think this would be a good idea? and b) Would tune in for it?

(Please note, not in any way pitching this to 'compete' with the existing podcast, but rather to compliment it)


r/Cynicalbrit • • Sep 16 '15

Discussion Thank you TB

0 Upvotes

I just wanted to show my appreciation for TB getting back in his regular routene of 5 or so video's a week and I'm sure not only me but lot's of people probably appreciate it too.

He doesn't reply to Reddit does he? ;__;


r/Cynicalbrit • • Apr 01 '15

Cynical Gabe

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Dec 12 '17

Discussion TB, Game Awards Stream

0 Upvotes

So, I saw TBs stream for the Game Awards.

Now, I know he is always a bit cynical and makes snarky remarks at everything, but am I the only one who is annoyed at this point that all he seems to see is the bad side in things?

I mean sure, the Game Awards are surely not the best thing out there, but it sure as hell is a lot better than the E3 press conferences.

Why do they even watch the show if they are annoyed by everything? They don't like the music composition, they are annoyed by game trailers, they are annoyed by interviews. I understand they want to see the award winners but if they want that they could just as well look them up afterwards and comment on it.

I mean, what else would you do during a Game Awards show but to show game trailers and game music and game developers?

As for the ads, I don't like them either but that is unfortunately how such shows are ultimately financed. They could have been arranged better, I agree on that.

Idk, maybe I'm just not into TBs way of looking at things anymore. I normally value his opinion a lot on games and media controversies. Non the less I feel he has become more and more cynical up to being downright dismissive of even the neutral or better things having to do with games.

Sorry if I come off as rude, I don't mean to. I just thought I'd voice my opinion. This is not a rant, and I sure am not angry (hell, I'm not emotionally engaged enough into either Game Awards or Totalbiscuit to be mad), it just felt a bit too negative this year.

And if he is doing that for show just for the sake of it I don't necessarily like that either. Bashing something just to bash it seems to be very different from the TB I used to watch in past years.


r/Cynicalbrit • • Oct 17 '15

Video Reddit Censorship on TotalBiscuit’s Cancer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
35 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Feb 16 '16

Fanart TB confesses his feelings [semi-legal montage of Co-Optional Podcast and copyrighted material]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Jul 14 '18

Discussion At what bitrate TB recorded video?

0 Upvotes

(please use a source when answering, preferably fairly recent)


r/Cynicalbrit • • Jul 10 '18

Discussion TB and GamerGate, a question

0 Upvotes

I definitely didn't follow that whole saga, but my recollection was that TB got into the GamerGate drama when people thought it was about a dev sleeping with a journalist for a better review. Eventually that point was debunked and the #GamerGate issue then became about online sexism and harassment.

It seems like a lot of people still associate TB with anti-feminism and maybe I missed other things he's said, but I thought he disavowed all that. Does anyone have a clearer idea of what TB's stance was?

In this day and age, it's really easy to agro the incel and SJW crowds and unfortunately, it's usually the first impression that sticks.

EDIT: Ugh... did not mean to rehash this BS.

EDIT2: Yeah, apparently emotions are still raw around this topic for some of the people here.

EDIT3: OK I've read the articles and the FBI report. It did seem to start as ethics in journalism, but it was undeniably hijacked by 4chan incels. Which is basically what I said happened, but thanks for the details.

Anyway, still wondering where all the SJWs get the idea TB was anti-feminist.


r/Cynicalbrit • • Jul 01 '15

Twitter So my name was spotted by one of my friends on TB's Arkham Knight port report :P

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Nov 29 '12

TotalBuiscuit

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/Cynicalbrit • • Oct 01 '14

Discussion Can we rename this subreddit to /r/TotalBiscuitTweets?

0 Upvotes

Title ^

EDIT: Some sarcasm meters might be broken. ahem Less tweets please.


r/Cynicalbrit • • Sep 21 '15

Discussion Small thoughts about the podcast.

10 Upvotes

(Disclaimer, I am unsure if this will somehow fall in the 'request' rule, as I think it's more about 'TB should do this game or that' regarding content, rather than something like this. If it does fall in... sorry, I can delete it. D:)

So I will preface this by saying I am not a newcomer, I have seen the podcast for a while now, but I stopped after they sort of stopped showing on Itunes, and just recently decided to start again watching them as background audio while I play games that dont demand my attention...

And the more I watch them, the more I feel there are some extremely minute, yet impacting things I would love to see improved (This is NOT a request, inb4 I get reminded of TB's policy).

I am watching from the the newest and on backwards, so this is not something old ones being different.

As background audio, I tend to zone them out until they get super excited, at which point I return in a lot of interest, in particular when one of them is speaking of some game they loved and are describing it in depth.
Yet it's always the same, they say the name when they begin to mention it, and after that, not a single mention of the name ever again, so I am always left like 'what game is it?! REVEAL YOUR SECRETS TO ME! DX' (I cannot rewind the video or else youtube will throw a hissy fit and crash all videos I preloaded...)
It's just like radios telling you song names, playing them, and not repeating the title now that you found out the song was to your liking...
I have noticed they sometimes have a small bar at the bottom that says what they are speaking of atm, yet it's not there at those times and I get so frustrated I am missing a cool game. D:

The other thing, is there any reason for not showing any pic or anything in the release section? I know trailers are gone because if issues with copyright claims, but not even pics or something? Specially when they are always like 'wow, this game looks awful!/very unique!' and so forth. :S


r/Cynicalbrit • • Jun 24 '15

Fanart THE Art - I can now post this because i'm over 7 days old.

18 Upvotes

So i made THE Art, the greatest creation of all universes!

http://i.imgur.com/lppYDL5.jpg

But wait, event that greatness can be surpassed!

http://imgur.com/0bnDCks

All hail the TOP HAT!


r/Cynicalbrit • • Jan 21 '17

Reviewing TB - Reviewer Review - Reviewing Total Biscuit in the style of Total Biscuit - Let me know what you think!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes