r/CyberARk • u/Darcy_Winslow44 • 12h ago
Do we really need another identity visibility tool on top of Okta, SailPoint and CyberArk?
Our architect went to a Gartner session and came back sold on identity visibility and intelligence platforms. I've read his note twice and I'm still on the fence.
The problem he's describing is real. Okta shows 14 app assignments for one user, SailPoint shows 22 entitlements across those apps, and that's before you bring PAM into it. They're not measuring the same thing, but getting a clear picture of that person's access still takes one of my people about a week of exports. And we still don't have a good view of what's been granted directly inside the apps.
My hesitation is buying a fourth tool to referee the other three. We had a version of this conversation around identity fabric a few years back and it never got past planning.
He wrote down Radiant Logic and Orchid Security. From what I've read they seem to approach this differently. One is more about bringing directory data together, the other about visibility into access inside applications. So I'm not even sure we're comparing the right things.
For anyone running an IVIP alongside an existing IAM stack, did it replace anything or just become another system to maintain?