r/Curling • u/pessimistkonsulenten • Feb 16 '26
r/Curling • u/PrettyBirdy3 • Feb 29 '24
Spotlight Stealing
I’m probably going to get downvoted and called terrible names for posting this, but I’m wondering if anyone else felt the same.
This year there are a number of curlers who will be retiring, or moving to different teams, portions of the sport, etc. Some of these announcements have been made, whether it be through their social media, or through general chatter within the sport. A vast majority of these announcements will come out at the end of the season, as they usually do.
Names that come to mind are Jo-Ann Rizzo and Kerry Galusha, both of whom have been in the sport a very long time. But while their retirement gets very little mention or fanfare, you have Jennifer Jones making an explosive announcement just prior to the Scotties, that this will be her swan song, the final hurrah for the 4-person game.
Every single game that I watched, every single news outlet that posts about curling, regular people on social media, the main story is “The Retirement of Jennifer Jones.” While I recognize that she is an excellent curler, and her retirement will leave a hole in the game, was it absolutely vital this be announced when it was?
Not only did it steal the attention from the Brieanne Harris ordeal, it stole the limelight for other curlers, including Tracey Fluery who just won her very first Scotties title. Instead of getting to celebrate and live in the moment of something so special, everyone flocked to Jen, only considering Team Homan as an afterthought.
We all know TSN has forever been obsessed with the Jones team, as previous year’s commentary has noted, but this entire thing feels like it was the ‘Jennifer Jones Tournament of Hearts’, everyone else be damned.
To me, that goes against the whole premise of sportsmanship within the game, and I found that her spotlight stealing announcement was absolutely crass. She’s retiring, not dying.
Do the polite thing, don’t make it about yourself, and wait till the season finishes.
r/Curling • u/Rosiey9 • Feb 15 '26
Unpopular opinion: the original touch rules aren’t functional for realistic play and they should adjust them to allow it as long as it’s not completely over the hog line
So tired of this stupid controversy. I feel like everywhere I turn I see people who haven’t ever curled throwing out baseless accusations and complaints the community normally would ignore. I think we can all agree Marc didn’t handle the problem well, but people are blowing this way out of proportion. Edin mentions in his interview that ‘this is a problem that’s been happening for years’ and yet nothing’s been done. Yet you can find photographic evidence of at LEAST half the competitive field committing the same infraction. What happens when they start watching every small instance for it? Someone who has never committed an infraction and barely got close had her rock taken off, because the margin of error is that small.
This is going to get ridiculous. Either infractions will be called left and right or people are going to be pissed again by official inconsistency. It provides absolutely no tactical advantage. If it’s so much much of a problem and been this consistent between players, even when it doesn’t actually change the game, why in the hell would they try and ‘fix’ the game when we’ve already seen the effects and it’s making it worse. I know it seems ‘unethical’ to ‘give in’ and fudge the rules, but this has happened in other sports before where on paper it seems like a fix, but doesn’t work in practice. They need to make things clearer in the rules at the very least, but if ‘cheating’ this way is THIS common and doesn’t provide any advantage, I think it makes far more sense that we should be changing the game to advance with the players.
As a side note, if you’re going to use this post to complain about cheating, throw around ‘sources’, or insult other nations you are extremely unhelpful in this conversation and I’m just going to assume you’ve never thrown a stone before. I think a genuine discussion on the game itself is integral to understanding it (especially at the highest level), but that doesn’t happen if we lose the original point by being toxic to one another.
r/Curling • u/ChodieFoster123 • Feb 14 '26
This double touch thing is a huge nothingburger and I feel like I am losing my mind
If you have curled at any level - even learn to curl - you understand that there is no way to improve the trajectory of your throw **via the granite**, **at the near hog line**. Even if you had split second access to the exact speed and direction of your rock, as a thrower you will do **far** more harm than good by trying to alter your throw by poking the granite, a far less controllable action than just using the handle. I'd rather let Ben & Brett handle it, like anyone else with a brain.
"BuT wHy Do ThEy dO It If ThErE's nO aDvaNTaGe?"
The whole point of the sport is to repeat your delivery exactly. This means every. single. curler. out there is trying to get their hand in the same position after they release the stone. A common one is to try to end in handshake position (flashbacks to learn to curl). Some curlers - not even just Marc Kennedy - will touch the back of the rock. Brett does it too, at least on occasion. In Marc's case, I think it is actually more common for him to point at the back of the rock without touching it. So it's not to say that there's no advantage. The advantage is in repetition, or perhaps some curlers find it useful to hit the broom (e.g., pointing), but not to alter the path of the rock. Despite what all the people will say who thought about curling for the first time today, it's kind of a grey area in the official rules (I'm not going to bother here, but see John Cullen, cullenoncurling, on X). But, I've **never** seen anyone complain that it's an unfair advantage. Note: Even Team Edin today did not claim it was an unfair advantage. They just wanted rocks pulled in order to gain themselves an advantage because they saw something that they felt was against the rules.
I've put together some Double Touch Curling Videos of the curlers that immediately came to mind. I'm sure there are more that I did not think of. The videos are:
Steve Laycock in the 2015(?) Brier playoffs. At the time (he has changed his delivery) he did this on every throw.
A higher quality view of Steve Laycock double touch.
Kevin Martin (Olympic and World Champion) used to do this on at least inturn draws. You can almost never tell from the front view, but here is one from the 2010 Olympics in Vancouver. It is very subtle.
An extreme close up of the same
This one's clear, from the **9th end of the Olympic final**.
If you think this gains an unfair advantage and it's cheating, you are wrong, and that's okay. You are saying that, for example at the 2010 Olympics, teams were happy to allow Kevin Martin to cheat and gain an unfair advantage over them, including in the **Olympic final**. Or - and stay with me here - curlers understand there is no unfair advantage to be gained from doing this, and as long as it's done before the hog line they do not care. Again, nobody on Team Edin today claimed Marc Kennedy gets any sort of benefit and, at least initially, the complaint was that he was over the hog line.
What I think happened today is two things: i) Team Edin could not afford to lose today, and ii) Marc Kennedy touched the rock past the hog line, at least in the mind of Team Edin. If we acknowledge that touching the granite is generally accepted if not actually legal, this is unambiguously a hog line violation. The correct course of action is to have an official watch the hog line, because, and I cannot stress this enough, **you cannot call hog line violations on yourself**. Kennedy has guaranteed no idea whether he was over the hog line because it is impossible to watch the broom and the hog line. No one has ever had the red flashing lights go off and not been surprised by them. So if Oskar Eriksson's approach was to say to the official "Hey watch the hog line," there's absolutely nothing wrong with that. Instead, he tried to rattle Team Canada, or otherwise get them to change their deliveries, or maybe he just didn't get the response from the official that he expected, and obviously from that point we all saw what happened.
r/Curling • u/CuriousCurator • May 02 '22
Matt Hamilton babies his delivery (with analysis by Sander Rølvåg who suggests that it's a hand technique)
r/Curling • u/MeesterNoName • Feb 14 '26
Enough with the "Cheating" commentary... read the rules.
It's hilarious seeing the armchair curlers coming out of the woodwork here. I do have a lot of experience as a coach and curler, and I believe there is enough ambiguity here to cause some confusion.
The only violation here that is clearly defined is the hog line violation. That rock everyone is super-slow-mo-ing probably was a hogged rock. Ok, it was missed, that's not going to be the first and last time that happens.
Here are the relevant rules.
World Curling rules are as follows:
R5 (d) The curling stone must be delivered using the handle of the stone.
R5 (g) A stone is in play, and considered delivered, when it reaches the tee line (hog line for wheelchair curling) at the delivery end. A stone that has not reached the relevant line may be returned to the player and redelivered.
R9. TOUCHED MOVING STONES
(a) Between the tee line at the delivery end and the hog line at the playing end:
I. If a moving stone is touched, or is caused to be touched, by the team to which it belongs, or by their equipment, the touched stone is removed from play immediately by that team. A double touch by the person delivering the stone, prior to the hog line at the delivering end, is not considered a violation.
You can argue that he wasn't delivering the stone at this point. Nothing in the rules says you can't touch the stone afterwards (before the hog line) or that you are specifically prohibited from touching the non-handle in your follow-through.
Curling Canada has the following rule about re-touching:
8 (8) A stone re-touched by the hand after release, but re-touched before the hog line, is not a violation.
Again, that rule does not say specifically that any touch must be on the handle alone (and there is nothing in Curling Canada rules that does), but it makes clear that re-touches before the hog line are allowed.
The rules are ambiguous regarding re-touches and where (on the stone) they can occur in the rules. While I can say it's a hog line violation, the whole "re-touch" the non-handle part of the stone is vaguely defined at best or not dealt with at worst. And honestly, you're not getting an advantage by re-touching the stone this way (even after the hog line - but the rules around those violations are clear - it's still a hog line violation).
Neither team handled this well. And neither did the officials. And I expect that there will be some clarification to the rule sent out before tomorrow morning's games.
What should have been done is that the umpires stand at the hog line and make sure there is no touching of the stone in any spot after the hog line (and pull rocks if there was a hog line violation). And that goes for both teams. But teams were playing games within the game and well... this is why we can't have nice things at high-level competitions.
-Edited to insert World Curling Rule R5 (g) that says the delivery is over once the rock reaches the tee line and R9(a)(i) that allows for a double touch of the stone.
r/Curling • u/nylanderfan • Feb 17 '26
Why do we need to police the game so aggressively?
I don't understand why we need to be so restrictive on double-touches and sweeping a certain way, even if they do produce an advantage. Isn't the entire game about manipulating rocks and the ice to produce a desired result? I'm not seeing how those two things are so different that they need to be prohibited. The free guard zone I get, but these things, no.
EDIT: No, I am not advocating to throw away the rule book, not for curling or any other sport. This is about recent tightening of rules for things that either used to be allowed or arguably should be. Ease up on the wild generalizations
r/Curling • u/Ghost_man23 • Feb 16 '26
Widespread Confusion on the Criticism
There is confusion in this subreddit about Sweden's complaint and too many arguments are getting crossed. Let's lay this out more clearly.
First, Sweden's complaint was not about grazing the stone after release. These are two separate conversations and I don't think literally anyone thinks that grazing the stone on release should burn the stone. Nobody thinks grazing the stone should be illegal, but many people are using the stupidity by these officials to dismiss legitimate criticism of Team Canada's behavior.
Second, the burden of proof about the effect (or lack thereof) from deliberately touching the granite after the release is on the folks defending Team Canada. There are rules in place for a reason - to make sure there is a standard that everyone adheres to and can train for. A handful of elite curlers have decided to incorporate a deliberate touching of the granite passed the hog line into their mechanic, explicitly against these agreed rules. Critics don't need to know the exact effect of that on the stone to point out it's illegal.
Finally, even if it could be demonstrated there is no effect, the rules should still be enforced or changed. Otherwise, it becomes subjective what is allowed because it doesn't have an impact and what isn't allowed. If boop-ing the stone upon release is allowed, what about a full on push, what about boop-ing the stone 5 feet after the hog line? Etc. You have to have an agreed upon standard otherwise it's chaos. Imagine if a javelin athlete steps over the line on their release and the official says it's okay because they know it didn't make the javelin go farther and officials start deciding on a case by case basis whether to allow it. That would be crazy.
All of that being said, what a terrible job by the curling officials who knew of this complaint before the event, failed to clarify or enforce the rules, and hired completely clueless officials for the most important event of the year who are botching some of these critical decisions.
r/Curling • u/applegoesdown • Oct 12 '22
Should we have men's leagues?
I understand the history of how we got here, which is most clubs have a Mens League Night, a Women's League Night, etc. and have had those for a long time
But if you take a step back and ponder the situation, should clubs have a Men's Only League Night? Would it not serve everyone better to simply have an "Open League" where teams can be 4 men, 4 women, or some form of mixed? I for one don't feel right having a Men's League. Feels sexist.
Would love to hear what others say about this.
If you curl at a club that has super long traditions, I suppose ask yourself this question. If you were starting a new club today, would you have a Men's League Night that excludes women?
One note I make about curling, and this is something I tell anyone I teach in a LTC class. The beauty of curling to me is that you can curl with people of any age, any gender, any physical limitation, any whatever. The game is about a neutral as you can get in terms of being fair to everyone. So I would like to see leagues reflect this.
And I'm not talking at the "Pro Level". Just talking about regular old league night at the club lever.
r/Curling
•
u/SexyElephant_
•
Feb 13 '26
The hatred towards the American curlers is ridiculous and classless.
This is coming from a Canadian myself. I’m seeing so many people here celebrating when the Americans lose, and when they win I see comments like “such a bummer to see the Americans have success” not for any reason except for where they are from.
My question to the Canadians and other people from different countries contributing to this is, If your government was involved in controversial activities would you hold it against the 4 individuals curling for your country who have spent their entire lives working towards getting to play the Olympics? And if not would you appreciate a large group of people praying on the downfall of those curlers from your country?
Lastly if you are someone who is contributing to this hate, don’t consider yourself a curling fan.
r/Curling • u/shinagaki • Oct 16 '26
Made a free curling game where you're the skip (beta)
Hi all. I'm a curling fan from Japan. I've never curled myself, I just watch a lot of it.
I've been working on a browser thing called CurlFlux. It started as a way to replay real games shot by shot from World Curling's records, and a few weeks ago I added a match mode where you play skip against the computer. You put the broom down, pick the weight and turn, and then yell at the sweepers while the rock is moving.
Since I've never thrown a rock, I'm sure some things feel off. Mostly I'm wondering if the sweeping feels anything like the real thing (I did tweak it a bit so it plays ok as a game), and whether the computer calls sensible shots or does dumb stuff.
It's free, no ads, no sign up: https://curlflux.creco.net/?mode=match&lang=en
It also replays real games shot by shot (not video, just the rocks moving on the sheet, rebuilt from the official records), for example the Milano Cortina women's final: https://curlflux.creco.net/?replay=og2026-women-final-sui-swe&lang=en
AI declaration: most of the code, the screen design and the English text in the app were written with AI coding assistants. The idea and the rules, tuning the physics against broadcast footage, and the testing I did myself. The computer opponent isn't generative AI, it just searches through possible shots. Music is public domain (CC0). The video is just a screen recording, and I wrote this post myself.
I'll be around to answer comments.
(Posted with permission from the mods.)
r/Curling • u/CressMindless2935 • Feb 14 '26
Interview with Canadian curling player Brad Jacobs after yesterday’s game.
r/Curling • u/InfamousVillage9609 • Mar 07 '26
To the people in the crowd cheering misses
Have some class, there is no needing to fucking erupt when 23 year old Brier rookie Jayden King slid a little deep on that steal of 2.
There is nothing wrong with cheering for Gushue in fact I have loved most of energy and excitement in that building for when Brad makes a fantastic shot. But cheering misses is something that we don’t do as curling fans. Do better.
r/Curling • u/axehead08 • Feb 14 '26
Did the WCF just ban Colton Lotts delivery technique?
He basicly rests back edge of his hand on the rocks edge including the granite doesn't he? This ruling is a bit knee jerk maybe...
r/Curling • u/Delicious-Donut-6066 • Dec 25 '25
Rock League the best thing since sliced bread
Why on earth are they moving away from the slam format????!!!!! It feels like this move is purely to drive the grand slams out! We can’t be serious, now they’re expecting to run 10 in arena events, vs the usual 5. This smells like the grand slams are going to be no more sometime soon! Thoughts?
r/Curling • u/P-Lumumba • Feb 14 '26
What is being said in Canada (media) about the Sweden game
What has the reaction been like in Canadian media? And from the Canadian team / federation?
It seems pretty clear that the Swedes plotted this. And got someone from SVT (national TV) to film exactly where it could be captured. EDIT: I watched the first half of the match again, and it doesn't like this was the case. More like SVT picking up that something was going on, and doing a good job.
They voiced refereeing concerns in interviews before the game. And were very clear after the game that this was something that had been going on for a while.
It also seems pretty clear that this is not just something that happened to Marc Kennedy once today. It looks very intentional to my untrained eye. And there are videos and pictures going round of other instances. It looks like something he does on purpose. Or maybe it could be a tic of some sort.
Not sure if the mini finger push makes such a big difference. But then again, to my untrained eye, curling seems all about minor adjustments.
Swedish TV is kicking up a big stink. But they were in on the act...
What are things like in Canada?
r/Curling • u/Armchair_Curler • Jul 05 '19
Making Curling Great Again - An American Curling Story
r/Curling • u/hawkeye_420 • Mar 23 '25
Can we have a no spoiler rule in this sub?
With curling channel not working and the time difference of events around the world it's sometimes hard to keep up. Then some posts results and they pop right up on the feed. Is that too much to ask? Congrats to Canada, but would have liked to watch.
Edit: I thought the curling community might be understanding and want everyone to enjoy their sport. Clearly that is not the case. So much negativity.
Thanks to those who do understand. One freaking cliick is too much to ask. Unbelievable.
r/Curling • u/eZeder • Feb 14 '26
Genuine question
I see a lot of debate about “boop-gate” and the accusation of Canada team touching the stone after release. One thing that I’ve been thinking about (as an every 4 year viewer of curling) is how this differs from golf? Even if it’s intentional or not, it whether it gives advantage or not my understanding is that the rules are quite clear. I guess you could compare it to grounding the club in a bunker while playing golf. I have no idea if the Canadian dude did this in purpose or not but my understanding is that that’s besides the point, kinda like when Theegala brushed the sand in his backswing in this video.
I don’t want to point fingers and are not saying that they won because they cheated but I thought Curling was a gentleman’s sport?
“During the third round of the 2024 TOUR Championship, Sahith Theegala felt that he unintentionally moved the sand in his back swing during his second shot from the bunker on No. 3 at East Lake Golf Club. After the shot he called a rules official to explain the situation and self-imposed a penalty on himself. He was later accessed a two-stroke penalty.”
r/Curling • u/MBolero • Mar 10 '24
Team Alberta
Unpopular opinion: Partnering with a gambling outfit? The message is "don't gamble too much", but it still adds a legitimacy to gambling. Just my 2 cents but I think curling should be better than that.
r/Curling • u/ttaayyllaarr • Feb 17 '26
Sweden sweeping
Let's add to the controversy of curling at these Olympics. Watching the Swiss team having a very dominant start over the Swedes with these freshly sanded rocks and I keep seeing the Swedish sweepers ending their sweeping strokes by returning to the hard clean in front of the stone. It was my understanding that sweeping must end to either side of the stone, as confirmed by looking up the WCF rule below.
R8. SWEEPING
(a) Sweeping can be in any direction (it need not cover the entire width of a stone), the brush head must not be raised in front of a moving stone, must not deposit debris in front of a moving stone, and sweeping must finish to either side of a stone.
r/Curling • u/ekrubnivek • Feb 26 '26
Why do teams concede after 6 ends?
Some of the games in the US curling championship show a team giving up after 6 ends.
I think they are accurately assessing they don't have a chance to come back and win. But I don't fully understand why they are conceding. What gives?
By throwing more rocks, you get a better sense for how the ice is performing, which may help your team in later games.
You don't have a lot of chances to play against the best teams in the USA, and you're giving up on 8 throws per person worth of practice, the associated strategy practice, data analysis of how good you are at different types of throws, etc.
Against a team like Shuster - how many times in your life will you be able to compete against a gold medalist?
In the NFL you play benchwarmers during garbage time because the starters might get hurt or tired. But curling seems like a pretty low-injury sport.
Who cares if you lose 15-1 or 20-1, what am I missing?