r/CulturalDivide • • Dec 10 '21

So let's start this thing off: Neopronouns shouldn't be validated because they defeat the purpose of a pronoun.

33 Upvotes

So as we're learning new and different ideas about gender identity, and concepts like nonbinary or third genders, we're also naturally dealing with what pronouns people want others to use for them. Where we once used "he" and "she" (and occasionally "they") to refer to people based entirely on the way they presented themselves, things have gotten a bit more complicated.

Today, though, I'd like to discuss neopronouns, the ones that aren't traditional, but are being adopted anyway.

First, an English lesson (gotta get some use out of my degree, lol). Pronouns simplify a reference to a noun, keeping sentences from becoming too complex for the average person's understanding. The English language has five third-person pronouns: "he," "she," "they," "one," and "it" (though that last one is typically used for non-humans and inanimate objects). Regardless, we learn them as a basic introduction to the language, because knowing them is so essential to communication. Pronouns are a standardized set of words meant to be used in lieu of someone's name so that sentences flow with less repetition and fewer syllables. This is something I think we can all agree on.

Now, if one new pronoun were to become standardized, like "xe" for example—that single addition to the norm wouldn't . But the problem with neopronouns, by their nature, is that there are constant additions. There exist older established sets like ze/hir, e/em, phe/per, thon/thon, etc., but as of ~2013, there have been an explosion of new neopronouns, facilitated by the rise in discussion on social media. Fae, nya, vamp, void, ghost, star, bun, pony, kit, mew, bee, rot, gore, rain, sky, moon, cloud, love… an overwhelming majority of them are based on words that are already established, giving rise to the description "nounself pronouns."

To an average English speaker, a sentence like, "Bun kept buns phone to bunself," doesn't make sense. You have to retrain your brain and your understanding of both the word "bun" and of pronouns altogether. It's clumsier, but less confusing to say, "Sara kept Sara's phone to Sara's self." And this only becomes more complicated when referring to someone who uses multiple pronouns. Memorizing names is infinitely easier. The part of language that was meant to simplify referring to the noun is now more complicated than the noun itself. And when that's the case, then the entire point of using—or even having—a pronoun is defeated. That unique representation of gender identity ultimately becomes useless, and the person's name then becomes more important, which doesn't always communicate gender as a pronoun might.

The common rebuttal to this point is that languages change constantly, and we're making up new words all the time, and communication is easier than ever because definitions are just an Internet search away. But this is a matter of changing the structure of language itself, not dealing with how a new word is defined. Pronouns don't carry any inherent definition anymore—someone using he/him pronouns won't necessarily identity as a man. Not to mention the fact that third-person pronouns are hardly used while in conversation with the person who uses neopronouns; typically you'd use them while conversing with another person. At that point, if they don't know the person you're talking about, or anything about their pronouns, you would then have to teach them to recognize that neopronoun, and rewrite their understanding of that word and pronouns in general, and... well, you see what I'm getting at now. Pronouns only work when everyone understands them the same way because they're the commonly-understood set of words we use to communicate with. If someone wants their pronouns to be as functionally unique as their name, then what's the point?

tl;dr, neopronouns actively hurt language because they make it more difficult to communicate, and bad for signifying gender because they're often too complicated to use in a functional and understandable manner.

The floor is open for disagreement and/or alternate points.


r/CulturalDivide • • Dec 30 '21

Someone once told me that most people are actually trans. Here's the logic.

24 Upvotes

"Most people would be trans. Being cis means rigidly conforming to the masculine or feminine gender norms, and only a few people would actually do that. Because almost all of us won't stick to it 100%, then we are by some degree nonbinary."

Context: Friend of mine came out as nonbinary. Kept using she/her pronouns. Didn't change appearance. I asked what led them to this realization. That was the logic behind it, because she tended to be tomboyish for most of her life (certainly for as long as I'd known her), she felt like not conforming to traditional feminine gender roles meant she was nonbinary. The above is her quote.

Frankly, I don't see the logic. If gender identity means how well you conform to the social roles assigned to your sex, then even a single deviation would mean you lose your masculine or feminine identity. Really, what this logic does is argue more for gender abolition as a whole than anything else. Because if everybody's going to be nonbinary, then what's the point of even having the poles of gender? How is a nonbinary identity determined if it can't be quantified by how masculine or feminine it is? Really, what's the purpose of even having a gender at that point, if most everyone falls into the nonbinary category?

Do you think her argument has any merit at all?


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 08 '22

Why should anyone care about pronouns?

19 Upvotes

As kids we were told never to refer to someone in the third person if they were present. It's considered a passive-aggressive putdown. For most people this pronoun tempest in a teapot would never even came up. I'm confident that when I'm not present some will refer to me as an a-hole or something similar. I cannot even imagine caring about how I am referred to.

There's an even bigger problem when people try to control how others refer to them. Do they really think that anyone has the motivation to memorize their preferred pronouns?

If they do, they are delusional.

These claims of being nonbinary are quite ridiculous. If we meet my brain will automatically categorize you by your sex. Allow me to illustrate my point with an example from TikTok shown on YouTube. A teen girl offers to explain to the rest of us how to tell her gender. It goes something like this: You can tell my gender at the moment by looking at the string on my right wrist. If it's blue I am a boy; if it's pink I am a girl. If it's green I am neither.

And we are supposed to track this?

One more example from TikTok. A late teens or 20ish female is standing before her camera dressed as a circus version of a hobo. In a state of rage she screams into the camera "what about these clothes makes you think I'm female!?"

Well dear, first of all it's clear to everyone that you are female. Second you are standing in a bedroom that's clearly decorated in frilly female style with lots of pink.

You can fantasize about being nonbinary but don't expect busy people to indulge your fantasies. It's nothing personal but we have on average 10,000 things that are more important.

If someone who is trans asks me to address them in a specific way, I will do so out of courtesy. I just refuse to play the pronoun game with silly narcissistic people whose real purpose is simply to be special and garner attention.

Typos fixed.


r/CulturalDivide • • Mar 24 '22

In which I attempt to counter the common arguments that validate xenogenders.

18 Upvotes

I suppose you could call this my developing thesis against the concept and validity of xenogenders. And since r/XenogenderCringe was recently banned, I think the timing is right to drop this.

Counterarguments are welcome, and encouraged.


Why are you against people identifying with xenogenders? Isn't this a way to gatekeep trans folks?

First, "xenogender" may have a definition that's commonly agreed upon, but not a meaning. Here's the original definition, as coined by Tumblr user Baaphomett:

a gender that cannot be contained by human understandings of gender; more concerned with crafting other methods of gender categorization and hierarchy such as those relating to animals, plants, or other creatures/things

This is the common denominator in the many definitions of what "xenogender" means. However, it's the only common denominator. We've seen the following meanings of what "xenogender" is:

  • microlabels under the nonbinary umbrella that further define a nonbinary person's relation to their own gender identity

  • terms used and coined by neurodivergent folks to fill lexical gaps regarding their relation to gender and identity

  • necessary labels of comfort used primarily by autistic people for defining themselves and how they relate to society

  • not actually genders in themselves, but descriptors of how one relates to gender that can be used by anybody, including cis people

These definitions are in conflict with one another. If xenogenders are a denomination of the nonbinary identity, then it stands to reason that cis people cannot be xenogender. If they're used to fill lexical gaps to define gender, then they're not nonbinary, as "nonbinary" itself fills the lexical gap for the term "neither male nor female." If they're comfort labels, then they're not genders—they're descriptors of interests and personality. Gender expression is a part of your personality, sure, but you cannot conflate your personality and interests with your gender identity.

Second, none of this would be an issue at all if it wasn't coupled with the assertion that xenics are part of the trans community. That's where it crosses over from "people just finding themselves" to "people who claim they are just as trans as you are." It isn't "gatekeeping," as much as it is acknowledging the truth—xenogenders are, at best, a fringe concept of gender whose meaning is too malleable to validate as a proper transgender identity.

Who are you to dictate what we are? Isn’t that what trans people are fighting against? Why attack people whose experiences are much more similar to yours when that is exactly what TERFs and transphobes already do? Why not be supportive of us just like we are of you? We're just trying to live our lives. Our genders and pronouns literally do not affect you. You don't have to use the neopronouns or the xenogenders, just respect people who do because if you don't, you're invalidating what they feel comfortable with.

If it "doesn't affect us," then you forfeit any right to claim that not validating your gender or pronouns is either transphobic or ableist. We wouldn't have such an issue with it if "living life" wasn't coupled with "not validating my identity is transphobia and literally could get me killed." Once you demand our validation, it does affect us, because we're then pressured into agreeing with the faulty concepts of xenos and neos to begin with. If disagreement is invalidation, we literally cannot "respect the people who use them" while still being in disagreement with them in any way—it's a paradox. Further, if your "comfort" is derived from this sort of emotional coercion, then you're deriving fulfillment from abuse.

Just because you don't understand it doesn't mean it's not valid.

Here's the thing: xenics don't understand it either. I've already listed the multiple ways that people have defined what it means to be xenogender, and they cannot logically coexist with one another. The fact that it's been given so many different meanings across its existence is a testament to how flawed of a concept it really is. And further, the constant attempts to redefine the meaning of "xenogender" aren't done to solidify its definition for common understanding, but to dodge and deflect the most common critiques that have been made against the concept.

But xenogenders and neopronouns are ways for autistic and neurodivergent people to fit themselves in a gender outside of the binary that they feel comfortable or happy with. If you're against xenos and neos, you're ableist.

A gender is not a security blanket. Labels and words in general are made to communicate information, not to be held on to to prevent distress. Not to mention, most neurotypical people have difficulties understanding the implications of neopronouns and xenogenders due to the fact that they serve no real purpose in communication, so imagine how difficult it is for autistic and neurodivergent folks, who already struggle with understanding labels and their implications on a daily basis. Making an endless list of genders and pronouns with no real definition or place in society makes it even more difficult for them to function and learn to be themselves in the real world.

Further, there's no source to the claim that autistic people are more prone to having trouble understanding social constructs, but rather adhering to them, or applying them to themselves. Just because someone is diagnosed within the autism spectrum does not mean that person is any less capable of determining their own gender identity. In fact, defending the use of xenogenders and neopronouns as a "label of personal comfort for autistic folks" is not only scapegoating those folks, but is willfully misrepresenting what neurodivergence actually is, and very ableist.

Also, prior to 2020, there was literally no argument ever made to validate xenogenders within the autism spectrum or being "made with neurodivergent individuals in mind;" it only began with the rise in disorder fakers on TikTok and Twitter, which heavily implies that the two are linked.

Neopronouns have been around for hundreds of years, so you can't just dismiss them as nonsensical. And if neopronouns have been around that long, some concept of xenogenders has also been around, so they're both valid.

The ones you're referring to weren't really neopronouns as we understand them—they were trying to fill a nonbinary/third-gender lexical gap that has since been filled by singular "they/them." "Thon/thon," "ze/hir," "ey/em," those sorts of pronouns have the same lexical use that "they/them" does. What we understand as neopronouns (the "nounself" pronouns being the prime example) were made exclusively with xenogenders in mind—a connection that this assertion acknowledges. So, because the proto-nonbinary/third-gender pronouns were not meant to signify xenogenders, we can safely dismiss the assertion that they're neopronouns, and thus, have "been around for hundreds of years."

But neopronouns actually have nothing to do with gender.

Did misgendering just stop being a thing, or...?

But xenogenders exist to fill lexical gaps, so they're actually just trying to describe their complex experiences with gender.

Except this, once again, trivializes gender as being tied to personal interests or aesthetic. The lexical gap is already being filled by the term "nonbinary," so why resort to microlabels unless you're trying to create a new lexical gap to fill? Because xenogenders aren't a way to "fill lexical gaps," they're outlets for people—mostly teenagers—to describe themselves, which is why we see people coin new xenogenders on a regular basis, and why xenos tend to hoard or collect multiple genders. The counterargument to this is that "nonbinary" only describes gender within a male-female binary, and gender expression isn't limited to that. However, this implies that, in order to justify the necessity of xeno identities, the very idea of "gender" should be redefined, which means that no gender would be completely comprehensible at all, which in turn means that all genders would, in effect, be xenogenders.

But gender is a social construct, so xenogenders are valid.

Gender has been scientifically proven to be present in our brains, so no, it's not a social construct in the way you're arguing.

There aren't that many people who identify as xenogender, and most of them are literal children, so treat them like they're a big deal?

Because, frankly, they're affecting real trans folks and real trans issues. They are the literal origin of "I identify as an attack helicopter," a meme that's been used to write off all trans folks as fakers and fetishists in recent years. They reinforce the belief that you can "choose" your gender, which is itself justification for conversion therapy. They affect the movements for languages to normalize gender-neutral pronouns (such as singular "they") by interjecting themselves and demanding that their pronouns (which are just repurposed nouns and emojis a vast majority of the time) be validated on the same grounds. Hoarding or collecting new xenogenders effectively turns a gender identity into a piece of clothing, which it isn't.

Again, it boils down to the demands for validation more than anything else. Validating the fringe harms the majority.

Someone may find it euphoric or easy to evoke something visual, aural, etc. as an explanation for their gender rather than trying to explain their more complex gendered feelings or fit into typical gender categories.

Again, gender is not something that evokes happy feelings. Your gender identity is not a serotonin factory. That is—once again—reducing gender to a costume. Gender cannot be reduced to a "feeling;" if it were, then dysphoria would be nonexistent.

Xenogenders aren't actual genders, they just describe gender. A cis person could be xenogender, if that helps them describe their relation to gender.

Then you don't get to claim that invalidation is transphobic. And if xenogenders are neither transgender labels nor microlabels under the nonbinary umbrella, and can be used by people who are cis—people who understand and accept their gender as relating to their sex assigned at birth—then they're functionally useless.

Cis people hurting trans people because of the stereotypes of xenogenders is more a problem of cis people.

And xenics are causing more harm than help. Sure, they're not the largest threat that the trans community faces, but that doesn't take away from the harm they're causing, especially when it comes to reinforcing arguments used by transphobes like "being trans is a choice."

But xenogenders aren't meant to make sense to you, they just make sense to the people who define them. Xenos experience gender in a way that most others do not understand, and thus use labels that others think of as absurd, but makes perfect sense according to their own, unique experience. So why is that wrong?

So xenogenders should be validated by everyone because xenics validate them among themselves? And no one can possibly understand what a xenogender is unless they're already identifying with that gender? That's circular logic—a fallacy.

What's the point of all this? Why are you so hell-bent on invalidating xenogenders?

Because the arguments supporting xenogenders are flimsy at best and paradoxical at worst, and the fact that xenos are becoming more accepted by the day means that people are choosing to blindly accept them without question. Really, this isn't that unexpected—there's been more research over the last decade on gender and how we comprehend it, which means more fringe theories about gender identity are entering the mainstream. Couple that with the LGTBQ+ community's wide acceptance of queer identities, the idea that questioning a trans person's "transness" is a moral wrong, and the general acceptance of gender as a social construct, and the door is left wide open for xenogenders to step through.

Here's the thing: teens and tweens playing around with the idea of anything being a gender, because gender is a purely social definition, is not wrong in and of itself. Identifying yourself with animals, plants, pop culture, etc. isn't wrong in and of itself. It becomes wrong when those people demand acknowledgement and validation as part of the trans community. Teens are looking for an in-group to belong to, and let's be real, being LGBTQ+ has a certain allure of being "more interesting" or "more diverse" than the average person, not to mention, the community itself is radically inclusive. So it makes sense that it would be attractive for those that feel like social outcasts, misfits, or hell, just socially alone in genereal. But the arguments supporting xenogenders, even as a fringe gender theory, are weak. The young age of the people crafting such theories, and as a result, their developmental immaturity, explains the fundamental misunderstandings of neurodivergence, misreadings of peer-reviewed material, and so on. This is also why very concept of "xenogender" was developed on Tumblr in the mid-2010s—the site and discourse around identities was populated mostly by teenagers at the time.

We should not be expected to validate xenogenders when we literally cannot understand them without actually identifying as xenogender, and the xenogender community itself cannot agree upon a singular definition of what it means to be xenogender. The logic is cultish and demeans the entire trans community.


tl;dr, Xenogenders are simply social labels being pushed as gender identities, primarily used by teens and tweens, who are being influenced into using them through their social groups and online interactions as part of their own journeys of self-discovery (not unlike the "goth" and "scene" phases in decades before), and as a result, they feel less like social outcasts due to the radical acceptance and validation of trans identities by the LGBTQ+ community, which they are inadvertently harming by justifying what ultimately amounts to adjectives as gender identities.


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 09 '22

Trans Radicals' Motivations

14 Upvotes

As many have stated before, the hard-core minority pushing this movement is arguably the most vicious we have ever seen. The rest are mostly decent people who just want to live quiet lives. OTOH, dare to disagree with the fanatics on any point and they will try to destroy you.

One then has to wonder why they are treating their push for transgenderism like a jihad and attacking anyone who dares question the practice of allowing young children to determine their sex.

Here's my hunch:

The trans segment of the population is estimated by academics to be 1/400. Those are rookie numbers, as the saying goes. So they feel a desperate need to pump them up in order to have more clout. I think they also understand deep down inside that society is presently treating a mental illness as if were physical and that this will end soon.

So the strategy is get 'em while they're young.

As I have said before if an adult decides after years of dysphoria that they wish to undergo the surgery, fine. It's their call. Hopefully, they will have learned about the scary downsides too.

However, when you see mothers with Munchausen by Proxy coaxing their 4-year-old sons into wearing dresses and their daughters into playing with trucks, you can't help but be concerned for the children.

"A trans child is like a vegan cat. We all know who's making the decisions,"


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 09 '22

My wish for the Gay Community

11 Upvotes

Firstly, being gay today is no problem. I'm a boomer who knows gay people personally. I judge everyone on their character. If I saw Dave Rubin on the street I'd ask if I could give him a hug. I like him that much. Douglas Murray is a man I admire immensely but being English he's most likely not into hugging. Add Glen Greenwald and Andy Ngo to my list. There are many more.

None of my boomer friends has a problem with gays either.

There is only one change I ask of them. Please stop the Gay Pride Parades. They are disgusting with men running around naked and in an excited state. It's not uncommon to see them engaging in sex acts at these events.

Over the years I have heard multiple gay men deplore these parades as bad PR.

A few years ago Black Pigeon Speaks did a report on the gay pride parade in Tokyo. It consisted of regular people dressed civilly and behaving like decent human beings.

If the parades stopped they would win over the acceptance of the last holdouts in society.


r/CulturalDivide • • Apr 04 '22

What is the story behind LGB Alliance split from Stonewall?

11 Upvotes

Been hitting paywalls when I try to google about this topic as I have read some references to these two organisations.

Stonewall sounds like an extremist organisation who has been charging exorbitant fees and had mislead several organisations with regards to the law, and from which many companies has disassociated themselves. When I try to read up on LGB Alliance on wikipedia, it feels very biased (against them) but from what I understand, what they are merely doing is standing up for LGB rights (or the rights to be attracted to the same sex).

I may be wrong of course as I am unable to obtain more information on them.

Just want to know out of curiosity, what happened.


r/CulturalDivide • • Apr 27 '22

What does intentionally misgendering someone mean to you?

10 Upvotes

Just posing a question here after seeing it on Twitter.

Do you consider intentionally misgendering someone—that is, not using a trans person's chosen pronouns or referring to them as a different gender than the one they identify as—to be a political issue, a human rights issue, the equivalent of calling someone a mean name (or bullying), an act of truth-telling, or a non-issue?

Not gonna give my opinion on this one, I'm just curious as to what y'all consider it to be.


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 09 '22

Many of us were hoping long ago that feminism would put a stop to the use of victimhood as the only means of defense against attacks both real and imagined.

9 Upvotes

Decades ago, I was supportive of much of feminism. Then over the years I came to reluctantly realize that it only served to promote the use of the victim card to get the upper hand.

Exhibit A: WAPO reporter retweets a funny joke. Feminist coworker goes nuclear on him. Third reported tells her to chill out and stop the ugly attacks. She then adds him as a target.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tGC72p-EKZk

Why do women always pull out the victim card? Because it works.

Ever see those videos on YT where actors are hired to play a couple having an argument in public? In the first test the woman starts pummeling the man and everyone snickers. In the second the man yells at her while holding her arm. Everyone around them starts jumping over tables and what not to rescue the damsel. The crew usually has to stop filming from a hiding place and rush to save the guy from being beaten by the mob.

Yes it works, but if you always use the victim card you will not have my respect.


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 08 '22

Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria

9 Upvotes

A couple of years ago Brown University posted a paper online pointing to social media being behind the recent and otherwise inexplicable explosion in kids claiming to be in the wrong body.

The usual firestorm of rage was triggered and a day later the paper was removed but you can find it online on other sites.

Would this phenomenon even exist if there were no such things as facebook, TikTok, and Tumblr?


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 08 '22

Are parents who deem their kids to be trans and in need of sex reassignment de facto homophobes?

9 Upvotes

Douglas Murray as well as other gay people have said that if we just leave kids flagged as trans alone, most will either grow out of it or grow up to be perfectly fine gays and lesbians.

I can't help but agree.

I would much prefer a child of mine to become a happy healthy gay or lesbian than someone who undergoes horrific mutilation and spends their life as a patient with all manner of chronic health problems.

Am I wrong in seeing pushing children down this irreversible path as a particularly horrific form of child abuse?


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 24 '22

Roe v. Wade has been overturned. How do you feel about this?

8 Upvotes

Supplementary questions:

  • Do you think abortion is a constitutional right, or should ever be considered a constitutional right?

  • What do you think public opinion on abortion would be if it had been voted into law by Congress in 1973, instead of ruled a right by the Supreme Court?

  • How will this decision affect you, personally?

Please be respectful.


r/CulturalDivide • • Jan 19 '22

How can Equal Opportunity be discussed when Opportunity is never defined?

7 Upvotes

I have been reading the Equal Opportunity portions of the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy and I am dismayed with the way that Equal Opportunity is defined without even an introductory discussion about Opportunity in the first place.

I am hoping that someone in this subreddit will both agree and disagree with my view of Opportunity and how the use of the phrase "Equality of Opportunity" and the efforts that Stanford and others are putting towards this ideal would be much better suited for "Equality of Rights".

Without a working definition of "opportunity", I have only the dictionary definition which seems woefully insufficient. Requests to Stanford for disambiguation on the term have gone unresponded.

The foundation of Stanford's claim is that "Equality of Opportunity" is an ideal that society should strive for in order to ensure people are happy and healthy. An entire thesis could be written on the audacity to presume that this, more than say high crime rates, affects people in a society, but that's not my only complaint. In the Introduction to Equality of Opportunity, the author first claims that all people should be equal to have fair and just access to opportunities. Of course, later, that changes to all people should have equal and unfettered access to every opportunity. And even later, it changes to society should try to level the playing field to ensure universal access and benefit from every opportunity. The change is gradual but noticeable.

They suggest that it is the responsibility of society to compensate for every barrier that every person faces which might prohibit their participation in an opportunity. They naively cite the example of not letting racist homophobic companies express their racial animosity or homophobia in advertisements for jobs. We have sure come a long way, haven't we? They neglect to mention that it is more damaging to go to an interview as a gay person or a person of color when the interviewer hates you based on the intersection of at least two of their criteria: no gays and no coloreds. (borrowed voice)

Nothing has changed with their chances of getting the job, but the appearance of impartiality is heralded as a bonafide example of equal opportunity in action.

To describe how they hope to dismantle the barriers that people face in participating in an opportunity, they suggest that somehow we acknowledge the historical suffering, the cultural predisposition, and any other insignificant barriers that someone might have when participating. How to do this without psychic insight is beyond the scope of the discussion.

My feeling is that without a working definition of what Opportunity means, this entire discussion is useless. Their description of "Equality of Opportunity" hints at a kind of opportunity not covered by any current definitions of Opportunity.

In fact, Equal Opportunity seems, on its face, to claim that the Opportunity is Equal not that access to the opportunity be nondiscriminatory, that would be Equal Access to Opportunity. And part of what makes an opportunity valuable is its rarity or the fact that it is not accessible to all. When you make it equally accessible to everyone, one of the foundational premises of opportunity is voided.

It appears to me that this entire ideal is nothing more than liberal idealistic chest-beating in the name of social virtue. It eliminates any need for competition and destroys the value of the opportunities that are being offered. It hinders the desire to offer an opportunity to someone because you have to spend more time ensuring the ideal of equality of access than you do offering the opportunity. The logical progression of which is that we eliminate a lot of opportunities in the name of social justice.

Do you agree or disagree and how would you define opportunity in this context?


r/CulturalDivide • • Dec 10 '21

Another sub for Hat to moderate us lemmings in

7 Upvotes

Hopefully we wont find half the moderator team dead from suicide next week. That would be just hooorible.


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 29 '22

An old one from a different discussion sub: "Even if it's real, what would the harm of 'transtrending' be?"

5 Upvotes

Copying word-for-word because it's an interesting question and I think it can generate some equally interesting responses. Keep in mind, this was posted five years ago.

I've been trying to debate a friend who gets all of his information from anti-SJWs on YouTube. He recently introduced me to this term "transtrending" by using it as if it was proof that all the boys in his children's generation are going to become trans and get bottom surgery because it's trendy.

My immediate reaction is that there is probably a natural rate of trans people being born and then another small group of people who aren't too committed to their assigned gender who might be open to change because they suddenly live in a world where it's okay and their friends think it's cool. This still doesn't make me worry for the safety of children, as I don't think a trend is going to be enough to push people to drastic measures.

I came across this sub when I looked the term up and found a pretty decent thread where someone compared the recent tumblr trend of people finding the most unique gender expression just to stand out to the trend of fake bi-girls that I remember from highschool.

I only know trans people who are actually trans and are healthier and happier now that they are living their authentic identity. Of course, my age group doesn't use tumblr. It seems like the biggest harm of people going out of their way to find the most unique gender identity for themselves is annoying other people.

I'm wondering if there is any information on the following that would possibly back up his claims:

  1. Is being trans inherently unhealthy (I strongly think that it is not and that any harm is caused by not being accepted by society) (Edit: I was rushing to post this in the morning and failed to add that gender dysphoria is the other harm that is caused to the person)

  2. Are there so many millions of people choosing trendy gender expressions that parents need to worry about their kids getting swept up in a trend and eventually going through hormone therapy or surgery just for fun?

  3. Was lasting harm to society caused by trendy bi-girls?


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 15 '22

What’s the difference between culture appreciation and culture appropriation?

5 Upvotes

As someone who grew up surrounded by many people for different backgrounds (Mexican, Guatemalan, Native American, Indian, Japanese, Chinese, Vietnamese, etc.) I get nervous when trying to appreciate the different cultures because I’m scared to be accused of appropriating them. One time I made my uncles favorite meal(which happened to be wonton soup with potstickers and rice) and some guests blamed me for trying to be something I’m not and for “overstepping my boundaries as a white person.” It’s frustrating especially since my uncle’s then girlfriend helped me make the meal for him.


r/CulturalDivide • • Jan 20 '22

I feel that people arguing to "hear both sides" don't have any argument beyond that.

5 Upvotes

For example, on r/SocialJusticeInAction, they have this:

Aggravated by universities promoting "diversity, equity, and inclusion," but refusing to acknowledge a necessity for a diversity of viewpoints?

Now that is interesting because there, they prefer mockery and fallacious reasoning like tu quoque.

Instead of looking at the evidence for gender identity...they ignore it.

They ignore the massive amount of right-wing violence and act like only sjws are unique in that regard.


r/CulturalDivide • • Sep 08 '23

I can't believe people think the Barbie movie's message was female empowerment Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Before you come for me, hear me out. I think the Barbie movie tried to distract audiences with long winded feminism 101 monologues when ironically, the actual plot didn't leave me feeling empowered as a female at all.

Why didn't America Ferrera's character get a seat on the Mattel board at the end instead of just creating "normal woman Barbie" and dropping Barbie off at the gynecologist.

Speaking of which, it felt very reductive to have the movie end with Barbie becoming a human woman and her first move was going to the gynecologist. "she's a woman, first stop, is the gynecologist of course!" How many women contributed to the script? Why couldn't Barbie have taken a seat on the board of Mattel herself? Why couldn't she have taken the job that America Ferrera held and America Ferrera be on the board? Either of these types of ideas would have ended the movie with two very empowered women, and instead America Ferrera just dropped Barbie off at the gynecologist.

Another thing, if the Ken's treatment in Barbie land was supposed to reflect women's treatment in the real world, I get the joke towards the end when the president of Barbie land refuses to give the Kens a seat on the Supreme Court, but doesn't that serve as a sort of dark omen for women in the real world (even though we have had women on the supreme court for a long time now)?

Would love to hear peoples thoughts, I'm open to changing my mind.


r/CulturalDivide • • Sep 08 '23

Sometimes people who identify as woke are the ones who need to check their privilege the most

4 Upvotes

I'll start by saying I am a fairly moderate liberal, and know that I am so privileged. I work from home for a decent paying corporate job that's fairly interesting and I get to work with some really nice people. I recognize that this is such a luxurious lifestyle in comparison to waking up super early to go to a more laborious job that pays less, or not having a job at all and needing one. I feel extremely lucky to be in my position and I'm aware that a lot of people don't get opportunities like this. While the salary doesn't compare with a tech company, it's more than fair and certainly livable for allowing the flexible work from home lifestyle, free of commutes and mandatory office time.

All this to say it absolutely boils my blood when people at work have the audacity to complain about things like not having a four day work week, the pay, having to occasionally work an extra hour or so on a day with a tight deadline, or even the more occasional weekend work. I think it's funny that the same people at least at my company are also the ones who talk the most about social justice and make a point to prove they're woke. In my opinion, those positions are fairly mutually exclusive, claiming to care about equality and complaining from an extremely privileged position about extremely privilege problems.

Does anyone else notice this or is it just me?


r/CulturalDivide • • Nov 30 '22

is black women styling edges cultural appropriation?

4 Upvotes

everyone knows that black women styling edges was to mimic european beauty standards since the time of slavery in america. but when they initially started laying their edges, it was slicked back into their hair to mimic the texture of their roots. josephine baker, an american born french and african american women, started a whole new look for the flapper women by styling their hair and edges into these crazy patterns and waves. she never grouped that into an only black community can do this type thing. it became a very important piece to many flapper women of multiple ethnicities. then in the 70s, i believe, that’s when african american women started styling their hair in swooping motions to give their fros more of a clean and interesting look. my question is, given the root of where styling your edges came from, who ended up styling these designs laying on the forehead first, the whole evolution pretty much, would it technically be cultural appropriation for african american women to style their baby hairs? they say white women cannot mimic their beauty standards by over lining their lips, getting butt implants, wearing 2 toned lipstick especially with lip gloss, but they can style their edges that was meant to mimic european beauty standards? it seems double standard to me. you can gatekeep a style for your race that mimics another race? but we can’t style edges that was meant to mimic european beauty standards?


r/CulturalDivide • • Mar 23 '22

At some universities, Affirmative Action officers are all about protecting the instutition by denigrating those reporting misconduct

4 Upvotes

The more Affirmative Action Officers or staff of divisions like inclusion & justice, the more resources the institution has to shut-up those seeking help for racism and discrimination with the goal of protecting the institutions reputation while appearing PC to the public.Those officers are all about PR and legal protection against those already harmed. Ironic! Has that been your experience or has yours been different?


r/CulturalDivide • • Mar 18 '22

What makes a conservative feel big brained and big hearted versus what makes a liberal feel big brained and big hearted. An explanation of where I think a cultural divide comes from, and why I think modern liberals need to make a few adjustments. Please read.

4 Upvotes

It seems to me like when a conservative sees somebody acting fairly weird compared to normal people, sees some evidence that this person might be hurting themselves or making things hard for their community to function, that's when they become an explosion of desire to correct a person for being what they are, because it feels tied to the need to keep society stable. And as such criticism of that vibe becomes nearly impossible. No matter how many times you tell conservatives to leave individual people alone, it will just harden their resolve because it reminds them of all the social bullshit they have to deal with that leads to their friends and neighbors getting along with each other ultimately.

To them, being conservative feels like an extension of the ability to make good out of difficult everyday conflicts.

They are motivated by the positive feedback that comes with guiding people to do painful things that benefit all parties ultimately. So it's really hard to tell them they're not helping modern society no matter how many times progressives win. They feel like somehow, someway, they just are more in touch with making things work despite how unreliable good efforts can be.

If you're a conservative sort of person, would you say that that describes you?

Is it a slightly innovate take?

The reason I disagree with your side of things, however, is because I think even people who don't give much of a shit about "the family unit" or "remembering to act like our forefathers" still have a lot of the stuff that holds society together. They can get past their own weakness, create relationships, and control their behavior just plenty for the most part.

While I believe the power of people to come together under a shared culture is pretty impressive, there are enough ways for a person on the outside of that to get good energy from other people, to not turn them into useless unhelpful jerks.

The people who stray far from their expectations of their sex, or come from a very strange culture, or don't respect any ancient traditions, are absolutely overflowing with the same "good vibes" that you perceive makes you so essential to America.

That doesn't mean they are pure and innocent and kind all the time or everything is great and wonderful about them, or that nothing is special and amazing about you, just that by and large, they care sincerely about not feeling like a terrible human and shouldn't be put down for going about that in a different way, especially in a way that places less emphasis on making sure things are like how they used to be before.

Because it's not like you disapprove of every liberal sort of change, do you?

Here's what a think about progressives or liberals, it's a bit less complicated, because generally I support them more in the culture war.

A liberal is more likely to look at an unfair situation, or a situation in which someone is exercising power in a very parental and condescending manner, and think, this is the chance to correct something utterly terrible inside of people.

They are more likely to feel an uptick of positive energy at the idea of a powerful feeling person watching the world crumble around them because they forgot to respect the people beneath them. They believe actions taken with the resolve for that purpose are apt to make human beings more generous and respectful, or at least, that people with more of a natural tendency not to exploit others will come out on top for these reasons.

Deep inside their hearts, as they wish for the rules to be changed about who is allowed to do what or say what, they really feel like they're destroying that part of a person that enjoys making someone else look stupid and nefarious for no good freaking reason.

And when I look at things like inclusiveness with race and gender, support for the economically downtrodden, and trying to be overall chill with a person's heritage, I feel like it only makes sense to lean liberal, and that America is almost certainly slowly shifting into being comfortably progressive.

But my primary disagreement with my progressive compatriots is how much they fail to not imitate to people on the other side of history.

All of the shifts in language that HAVE to happen immediately to make certain people feel validated, all the shrewd justifications for people being condemned for insensitive statements rather than getting a second chance , and the presence of strong emotional rivalry in support of economic choices that could go any freaking way, make me think that progressive America needs to find a way to become more chill without losing its moxie or zeal in general.

To me personally, the difference between a modern civilization and an old one comes from people being able to control themselves even when they feel like they're solving problems very boldly, fighting exploitation very shrewdly, and working very hard at being human rather than being too comfortable. In my view, those three things are what gives a person the sense that they are insightful, considerate, strong, and purposeful.

But we didn't get to where we are as a civilization by following that rich feeling in our hearts, we did it by learning how not to let it control everything, and make people suffer the least overall, in spite of the behaviors of people who feel motivated by their own positive energy.

Basically, I'm saying giving space and wiggle room in your progressive resolve is absolutely essential to making a better America and making cultures of the past even more outdated than they are.

And it's going to be gosh dang necessary if you want people who loathe the whole liberal vibe to finally come around, and for whatever walls holding up the bad vibes inside conservative pride to slowly crumble.

What I'm saying is, find that magic space where you're not pushing as hard you can against the conservatives, but are winning the most against them anyway. And it makes sense because only the most radically backward communities don't wish for things to genuinely transform into something else.

My only tl;dr is that I think that whatever the political equivalent of a really nice person is, is a liberal who empathizes with what makes someone from any walk of life feel strong and responsible, and can fight the baggage of traditional cultures while letting an individual's good sense of good vibes have its space to breathe.

So, centrist babble or respectful insight? You tell me.


r/CulturalDivide • • Feb 16 '22

What is gender?

3 Upvotes

Among humans, there is a huge diversity of sexual development. Sex and gender are complicated; many elements go into their making. The following pieces are all needed in the development/construction of complete femaleness or maleness:

Sex chromosomes – xx for a female, xy for a male

Primary sex characteristics – vagina, ovaries and uterus for a female, penis and testes for a male

Brain Sex – not masculinized for a female, masculinized for a male

Gender Identity – “woman” for a female, “man” for a male

Gender Expression – “feminine” for a female, “masculine” for a male

Hormones and secondary sexual characteristics – high estrogen and progesterone for a female, high testosterone for a male

At any point in the development process, one of these elements might swerve from the norm. A difference at any of these levels creates some form of “gender variance.” This applies to sexualities as well which are separate from gender.

Also, for each of these different sexually dimorphic traits, some people’s anatomies will fall “in between” or “outside of” what most people consider to be standard for female or male.

As one example, some people with androgen insensitivity have XY chromosomes, internal testes, and external female genitalia. Traits, including hormone levels, can also vary widely both within and across sexes. But people who fall outside of what’s considered normal face discrimination. Take South African runner Caster Semenya, who was recently the subject of a ruling that ordered her to lower her naturally high testosterone levels to compete with other female runners — even though studies have shown that because testosterone levels are so highly variable, there’s overlap between the natural testosterone levels of men and women.

Students are often inaccurately taught that all babies inherit either XX or XY sex chromosomes, and that having XX chromosomes makes you female, while XY makes you male. In reality, people can have XXY, XYY, X, XXX, or other combinations of chromosomes — all of which can result in a variety of sex characteristics. It’s also true that some people with XX chromosomes develop typically male reproductive systems, and some people with XY chromosomes develop typically female reproductive systems.

And this is just the tip of the iceberg.

http://aebrain.blogspot.com/p/transsexual-and-intersex-gender-identity.html

https://www.hawaii.edu/PCSS/biblio/articles/2015to2019/2016-transsexualism.html

http://theconversation.com/how-genes-and-evolution-shape-gender-and-transgender-identity-108911

http://theconversation.com/stop-calling-it-a-choice-biological-factors-drive-homosexuality-122764

https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/voices/stop-using-phony-science-to-justify-transphobia/

https://www.nature.com/news/sex-redefined-1.16943

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30247609

https://massivesci.com/articles/sex-gender-intersex-transgender-identity-discrimination-title-ix/

https://www.dovepress.com/gender-dysphoria-a-review-investigating-the-relationship-between-genet-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-AHMT

Now you may think these are just "genetic abnormalities" however: http://transascity.org/the-transgender-brain/

It’s common to hear the phrase “all babies start out female, and it’s only later that they become male,” and this is at least partially true. In fact, the influence of testosterone on a fetus has been described as a defeminization process, changing a fetus which was essentially predestined to be female into male. (Gooren, 2006) Testosterone production and the conversion of some testosterone to dihydrotestosterone between weeks 6 and 12 of pregnancy is critical for the initial development of male features, such as the penis, prostate gland, and scrotum. (Bao) In the absence of these male hormones, female genitalia develop instead. Brain development, however, does not occur in earnest until the second half of the pregnancy term, after the genitals have been developed, and the continued presence of male hormones results in a brain which has subtle, but critical physical differences from the female brain. (Bao)

The fact that the brain and the genitals develop at different times in the womb mean that a misalignment between the genitals and brain may develop, leading to either an intersex condition, or a transgender individual.

It is clear from all the complications and variations in sexual development that the ideas of male and female are not so simple for many people. Intersexed conditions are more common than once thought, with 1/1000 people having chromosomal intersexuality, and 1/100 having atypical body development. If being transgender involves an intersexed brain condition (and it does), then the fractions are even lower.

How, then, do we define male and female? Is it by chromosomes? But chromosomes are only the blueprint; the body can develop quite differently than planned. Is it by body structure? But the body’s physical development can be ambiguous, mixed, or in opposition to both chromosomes and gender identity. Is it hormones? But hormones can be unpredictable, and all they do is bring forth the already latent potential for masculinity or femininity. Is it by brain sex? For people who have transgender identities, determining their maleness or femaleness based on their brain sex or brain id makes the most sense, although others seem to think it delusional.

What some call "biological sex" depends on alot of factors going in a certain direction which we shouldn't take for granted. Otherwise, it comes off as special pleading, "yeah other sexually dimorphic traits are multifaceted, but not the one we use to identify sex with!"

Genetics confirm this further

Accordingly, "some people may cross-dress, some may want to socially transition," and others may decide to medically transition with hormone therapies or gender affirmation surgery notes the American Psychiatric Association.

History is already full of such people.

And those who do so are almost always shown to be in good health: https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/sex-reassignment-surgery-yields-long-term-mental-health-benefits-study-n1079911

https://www.transadvocate.com/clinging-to-a-dangerous-past-dr-paul-mchughs-selective-reading-of-transgender-medical-literature_n_13842.htm

https://web.archive.org/web/20180902070724/https://genderanalysis.net/2018/01/evidence-of-health-benefits-of-medical-transition-gender-dysphoria-body-image-sexual-functioning-and-quality-of-life/

https://genderanalysis.net/2015/09/paul-mchugh-is-wrong-transitioning-is-effective-gender-analysis-10/

https://genderanalysis.net/2019/12/quelle-horreur-parents-of-trans-kids-attending-gender-clinics-are-overwhelmingly-satisfied/

https://web.archive.org/web/20180902070639/https://genderanalysis.net/2018/08/transgender-surgical-reversal-statistics-a-clearer-picture-emerges/

https://www.forbes.com/sites/dawnstaceyennis/2020/12/29/study-transgender-children-recognize-their-authentic-gender-at-early-age-just-like-other-kids/

https://kathrynhgordon.com/2018/05/14/fact-checking-5-suicide-related-statements-from-a-viral-ben-shapiro-video/


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 16 '22

Gender is neither an identity, nor is transgenderism a mental illness

2 Upvotes

Woke adherents claim that gender is a social construct, that we are all taught our gender roles from birth, and that one "identifies" as a gender - that essentially anyone who identifies as a man/woman is a man/woman.

At the other end, we have right wing folks who claim that transgenderism is a mental illness, and that there is no difference between sex and gender, that one's gender is the same as one's biological sex.

Well, scientifically speaking, both are wrong:

MRI scans suggest transgender people’s brains resemble their identified gender: study. So according to this, gender is neurological. Likewise with sexual orientation: Gay brains structured like those of the opposite sex.

One cannot simply "identify" as the opposite gender. Either a person neurologically is one or the other gender (with the possibility of being a mix of both?). In almost all instances, being neurologically trans will result in gender dysphoria, as the brain's "sex" doesn't align with the body (thus perhaps those who do not experience gender dysphoria are not truly trans).

The gay study shows that sex is binary, because humans are innately aware of the differences between the sexes. Also, why would trans people want to transition if gender were just a social construct? Couldn't they just "snap out of it"?

What I don't understand is why MRI scans aren't used to help diagnose transgenderism. We could easily tell apart those who are trans from those suffering body dysmorphia, etc. It would end the child trans debate immediately.


r/CulturalDivide • • Jun 08 '22

Has there ever been a single father who was convinced that his child was in the wrong body and needed a sex change?

2 Upvotes

I follow this trendy trainwreck with a deep sense of horror about the kids who are gaslit into believing they need a sex change. It's always a single mom proclaiming her pride in having a trans child never a single father.

Some people with credibility have expressed the opinion that this is because women are far more prone to suffer from Munchausen By Proxy than men.

I do admit to seeing a few cases where the poor child had two parents but the father always looks uncomfortable with the project whereas the mother glows with a sense of sainthood.

PS Adults are free to do as they please.