r/CthulhuDark • • May 14 '25

Cthulhu Dark Creator's New Kickstarter: "Cosmic Dark"

23 Upvotes

Some of you may already know about this, but Graham Walmsley has just launched a Kickstarter for his new game "Cosmic Dark."

The game itself is sci-fi horror and, having had the extreme luxury of getting to play several of the scenarios with Graham at the helm, I can attest to their super fun playability. Graham is also just one of the absolute nicest guys out there.

More info at the KS link below.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/grahamwalmsley/cosmic-dark


r/CthulhuDark • • Aug 17 '21

Character sheets for Cthulhu Dark

21 Upvotes

So, I had a rare burst of motivation and made character sheets for my players if we maybe play the game one day in the future... Who knows?

Anyway in case you are interested, here they are in PDF.

Cthulhu Dark free rules belong to Graham Walmsley and can be found here.


r/CthulhuDark • • Aug 29 '25

Cthulhu Dark and Stealing Cthulhu are reprinting

15 Upvotes

In case anyone missed it, I'm reprinting Cthulhu Dark and Stealing Cthulhu as part of the Cosmic Dark crowdfunding.

So, if you want a hardback of Cthulhu Dark or Stealing Cthulhu, you can get it through that crowdfunder. I'd like you to order Cosmic Dark too, but you totally don't have to.

You can get Cthulhu Dark/Stealing Cthulhu through BackerKit:

https://cosmic-dark.backerkit.com/hosted_preorders

Or through the Kickstarter. You'll need to do a late pledge, then select Cthulhu Dark/Stealing Cthulhu as add-ons.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/grahamwalmsley/cosmic-dark

I'll close orders down within the next few days, so I can start printing, so I wanted to let everyone know before I did that.

(I think I'm good to post this here! I know people have been asking about hardback copies of Cthulhu Dark, so I wanted to answer those questions.)


r/CthulhuDark • • Feb 19 '23

I have been working on a simple CD System Module for Foundry VTT.

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/CthulhuDark • • Nov 16 '22

Miskatonic Shoreside Conservatory - A Campaign for Cthulhu Dark

Thumbnail
drivethrurpg.com
13 Upvotes

r/CthulhuDark • • Jun 12 '25

Cosmic Dark Preview

12 Upvotes

I was provided a preview copy of Cosmic Dark’s first couple of scenarios and quickly became obsessed with getting it to the table. I’ve written up how the mechanics work and my experiences with running the initial “Extraction” scenario a couple of times. There are some spoilers, but I warn when they’re going to start.

https://whodaresrolls.com/cosmic-dark-preview/

I hope you all enjoy, and if you’ve not checked out the campaign in these final days… what are you doing?


r/CthulhuDark • • Apr 14 '23

I love this game.

12 Upvotes

I have been running it quite religiously since the 1st edition 3 page rulebook.

And since then I have been only working on building and running more games within this system.

I firmly believe that Graham and the others who worked on this are inspired. So thank you to all of you.

My firm player group is expanding so the system is becoming more popular.

The main hack if you will excuse that term that I have implemented is how to learn and cast spells from Call of Cthulhu into this.

To learn the spell costs a insight or sanity level. I.e. 1 now becomes 2. To cast a spell simply forces an insight/sanity check.

Always happy to share thoughts or impressions with others.


r/CthulhuDark • • Dec 20 '25

COSMIC DARK has arrived

11 Upvotes

I got the hardback in the post. I've read a couple of the mysteries and I'm already thinking about some of the slower Mothership adventures I have that would benefit from the action being de-emphasised in favour of the slower weirdness that Cosmic Dark is pushing.

Who else has run it yet? Or have plans in the new year?


r/CthulhuDark • • Jul 05 '25

Are there any Actual Plays of the scenarios from the core Cthulhu Dark book out there?

11 Upvotes

I generally listen to AP podcasts and have run out of CD-based Ain’t Slayed Nobody episodes. I was wondering if anyone’s made an AP series with the scenarios from the main book.


r/CthulhuDark • • Jun 19 '19

A thought on Two Themes in Cthulhu Dark

11 Upvotes

I have played and ran Call of Cthulhu for quite some time but recently purchased Walmsley et. al.’s Cthulhu Dark. I must say that I am very much taken by it in several respects! One of my favorite aspects is how, in comparison to CoC, it turns “where” the horror lives on its head.

While Call of Cthulhu investigators are typically academics or professionals of some sort investigating horrors situated among “degenerates,” in Dark, the good guys ARE the thieves, prostitutes, the poor, “the savages,” and the backwater folk while the real stench, horror, and moral decrepitude always exists in the upper professional classes. The cool part is that at a deeper level this works perfectly with another tenet of the game -- your characters are doomed! The game is more deadly and sanity blasting than Call of Cthulhu, and you play to watch your character’s demise.

I find that these two themes tie together in a philosophically interesting way. The upper classes always win over the thieves, prostitutes, and degenerates that you are playing and in that respect you get a traditional happy ending to the story. But this result is doubly horrific, because it is a case where the “good guys” winning is a terrible thing. This takes cosmic horror to a whole new level when you realize that the real horror doesn’t exist at the disenfranchised edges of society, but instead it is weaved into the established roots of power that even define who the good guys are and what a happy ending is supposed to look like.


r/CthulhuDark • • Oct 31 '22

Actual Play: The Secret of Castronegro

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/CthulhuDark • • Aug 20 '25

Cosmic Horror Sale

9 Upvotes

DriveThruRPG is having a Cosmic Horror Sale

A few Cthulhu Dark items are included:


r/CthulhuDark • • Sep 19 '24

Hideous Truth, update

9 Upvotes

So, I finally fleshed out my Cthulhu Dark hack, Hideous Truth. It's a free game that ports fight-or-flight scenes (not combat) into Cthulhu Dark. It also includes rules for downtime and contacts as well as a character sheet and a worksheet for the fight-or-flight scenes. If you look at it, or try it, please let me know!


r/CthulhuDark • • Jan 29 '23

Against the Dark Conspiracy is great for running Nights Black Agents content!

9 Upvotes

I am running "The Harker Intrusion" with a group using Against the Dark Conspiracy. So far it is going great. The rules lend themselves really well to a Spy Thriller story.

I have been working on a Foundry VTT setup for Against the Dark Conspiracy. It's pretty fiddly to get set up, but so far it's working well for my group.

The setup requires:


r/CthulhuDark • • Dec 11 '22

Play Report & Lessons Learned: The Lightless Beacon

9 Upvotes

Hi! Yesterday, I played the free Call of Cthulhu one-shot scenario "The Lightless Beacon" using Cthulhu Dark. A few weeks ago, I had watched an actual play that used CoC rules, and I went through the scenario with CD rules on my own and had some great ideas for what might happen on a 6, so I decided to give it a try. This session was special for me because I ran it for a group of players I was unfamiliar with, and who usually play DnD 5e. We played on Discord (first time online for me), and we had a feedback session at the end of the scenario. We had to postpone the session for one week which made running the session a bit more difficult for me. The session was four hours long including pre- and post-game.

Characters

  • Johnny Screwdriver the Agent of the Bureau of Investigation

  • Harry Pierce the Antiques Dealer

  • Collin Epstein the Student

  • James Darion the Artist

Background

There is a storm on February 12th 1926 that causes a ship carrying gold coins from cultists to crash into the cliffs of Beacon Island, off the coast of Rockport, Massachusetts. One of the lighthouse keepers finds and collects the gold coins that are washed ashore. By reaching out to various experts, hoping to identify and assess the coins' value, he attracts the attention of the cultists who attempt to reclaim their lost cargo. The session starts at the same time as the cultists and their deep-sea Younglings kill the last of the lighthouse keepers and search the island for their coins.

Prep

We played on Discord, using rolldicewithfriends to roll dice and Whatch2Gether to listen to Cryo Chamber's Azathoth 1&2 in the background on loop.

First, I read through the scenario highlighting important parts. In future, I would highlight shorter passages or only a few words even to make this more useful during play. I had the annotated PDF on my screen next to the Discord camera feeds for quick reference.

I also made some very short notes while reading the PDF:

  • Player Characters: motivation, important items

  • NPCs: all friendly, neutral, evil or dead characters including monsters

  • Locations: rooms or points of interest categorized by building or area

  • Items: special items the characters need, can interact with or gather information from

  • Events: events or scenes that would likely happen either on a fixed time or that I could throw in

I used these notes as a checklist to remind myself of everything that was contained in the scenario during prep, trying to recall the details from memory and going over the hightlighted PDF if I felt like I missed something.

After reading through the scenario I worked out and wrote down the Themes, Creeping Horrors, what happens on a 5 and what happens on a 6. Themes: Sinking (i.e. rising water) and Force of Nature. Creeping Horrors: big eyes, being watched, predatory fish. On a 5: something about the gold coins, rumors of a ship that recently disappeared, something about Atlantis/R'lyeh/Lemuria. On a 6: exposed to the forces of nature, the building suddenly does not provide protection anymore (against elements, but not against monsters), realization that tales and conspiracies about Atlantis are true and the characters are in the middle of it. For the 5s and 6s these were just some ideas and I improvised a lot.

Lastly, I sent the playes the backgrounds of their pregenerated characters, summarized the information of Cassidy's Journal and made a screenshot of Turner's notebook.

On the night of our session I laid out the agenda for our session: set expectations using the CATS Method, rules introduction, play with a short break after two hours, epilog, feedback.

Session

  • PCs meet on a ship heading for Rockport, Massachusetts, on Monday, April 12th, 1926, the night of the new moon. A storm is growing and the PCs go below deck to find shelter from the rain. The ship crashes into the cliffs as the lighthouse on Beacon Island has gone dark. The PCs are put into a lifeboat and sent towards the island.

  • PCs follow the path to the house adjoining the lighthouse hoping to find help and investigate the study where they find disturbing drawings, and Cassidy's journal which ends abruptly, alerting the agent Johnny.

  • Johnny storms into the kitchen, noticing a pool of blood leading into the hallway. He briefly walks out of the kitchen into the rain and calls out for his NPC colleague, but no one answers. At this point all characters are on edge.

  • The PCs follow the blood into the hallway where they find three large gold coins and two bullets. They go up the stairs to the service room where they find a broken radio.

  • They walk up to the lamp room through a trap door in the ceiling where they find Cassidy's body, two Younglings that have been shot and a dead deep-one hybrid. They don't take it very well. Agent Johnny and dealer Harry look down from the lighthouse too see what's going on. The light in the study has gone off and the generator rumbling they could hear previously had subsided. They can only see that something below is moving. Student Collin rolls again including his Insight die and gets a 6! There are more than a dozen of those Youngling creatures moving around on the island and a group of them is headed for the house. They need to get off this island! But the sea is still too rough to make it over to the mainland.

  • The PCs go down, avoid the Younglings by exiting the house through the kitchen and make their way to the workshop where they fix the roof above the generator and equip themselves with tools and materials to barricade themselves. One Youngling tries to burst into the shed while the PCs gather their tools. They narrowly escape, setting the shed on fire and attracting a number of Younglings, but make it back to the lighthouse unscathed.

  • They barricade the entrance to the service room and start to repair the radio and the lightbulb and send out a call for aid. They have just enough time before the Younglings breach their defenses and are forced to retreat up to the light room. Artist James is last to get up, trying to hold off the Younglings that swarm the service room. I roll a 5 on the failure dice, and James rerolls a lot of times until he finally succeeds, narrowly making it up the ladder wounded by the Younglings' claws.

  • Epilog: Up there they manage to hold out until the coastguard arrives. Agent Johnny is involved in further investigations into the coins and the cult. Dealer Harry returns to London, rolls Insight once more and goes to 6, he disappears with only a pool of blood and one gold coin left to be found. Student Collin publishes his scientific discovery and artist James paints lots of disturbing pictures which fundamentally change is art-style.

Lessons & Feedback

Overall, I think, it went well but not great. We all had fun, but there were a few things that could be improved upon for future sessions.

  1. The first thing that I noticed by myself is that I forgot a lot of details because I did not spend additional time to prepare for the session again after we postponed it for a week. Also, my intro was weak - you really have to make this a good performance and know exactly what you are going to say.

  2. When it was time to bring the scenario to a conclusion, I told them so out of character and then they could tell me what they would do as their rough course of action. The players told me that this killed the tension for them and that I should just close the scenario while narrating. They already knew that there would be a point in the scenario at which we would go over to the epilog.

  3. The scenario felt too easy for the players and they had too much freedom. Everything they tried worked out and they even managed to survive. I should have found more complications, ways to split up the party, dilemmas and tasks. I even had some great opportunities: they set the workshop on fire where the generator and some fuel was stored; they narrowly escaped the Younglings a couple of times. I think, mechanically, it was not clear to me in which situations it was okay for me to hurt or kill a character, and so I was way too nice. It can be acceptable to kill a character suddenly and without indication because this creates shock and plays up the perils they face. In Call of Cthulhu, this is taken care of by the simulation through the game system. In Cthulhu Dark, this responsibility is on the Director and it's not as easy as it sounds. Or maybe, if there's a proper finale, it does not matter if the scenario is too easy because they'll end up dead, insane or scarred for life anyway. CD's premise is that the characters are doomed from the start. Now I appretiate this sentence a lot more.

  4. This is especially apparent in a situation from our session when Artist James tries to hold off the Younglings while the PCs escape to the lantern room through a trap door in the ceiling of the lighthouse. James could just reroll again and again until he either went insane (which was unlikely because he was at 4 Insight) or eventually succeeded. Of course, there is the optional rule that players have to justify narratively why they would be allowed to reroll. On one hand, this is great because a high risk situation might lead a player to push their character's Insight up a lot. But on the other hand, I (and my players) think that in certain situations, especially at the end of a scenario, the number of rerolls should be limited in some way (narratively) because otherwise the characters can just escape anything. Or you could increase the character's Insight by 1 every time they reroll to escape death.

  5. There was no Big Bad Evil Guy. That's in part due to the scenario, but it was also my fault. I did not want to bring the other deep-one hybrid over to the island, but have a horde of Younglings chase the characters up the lighthouse to be the final enounter. My characters made reasonable and effective preparations and rolled well, and so I ruled that they would survive. There was at least the possibility to kill a character or chase them down the side of the lighthouse (they had picked up a long rope) and make them hide on the island or try to make it to the mainland. The finale, especially in a one-shot, should be catastrophic and deadly. During play, keep a lookout for elements that could lead to catastrophy.

  6. The players found that they hardly ever rolled their Occupation die. One of them told me that he liked CoC better with all the attributes that make him feel more like he is actually playing a single unique character. That's a good point, I think, and it's something that's inherent to the system. I could make it more clear at the beginning of the session that the players should call whether or not they can roll their Occupation die. I will only accept or reject that call.

  7. It is super important to keep up the time pressure in-real-life when shit is going down. "Oh, you want to take anything else from the workshop? A creature bursts through the door as you reach into the toolbox!"

  8. At times, let the players describe what is going on their characters' heads! It's a fantastic way to set the mood.

  9. The pacing of the session was on point and the flow of the game was so smooth because it was not disrupted by looking up rules or calculating combat rounds or chases. There was so much room for the players to think, act and roleplay. Later in the session, though, I called for more rolls in order to get 6s and push the characters' Insight scores up.

I learned a lot from this session. None of it really is revolutionary and it is all obvious, but they are small things I will adjust for my future sessions. It's about experience and a feel for the system and scenario you only get through practice, but I hope this report helps some Directors identify areas of improvement in their own games. Thanks for reading!


r/CthulhuDark • • Feb 14 '22

Review Discussion: Cthulhu Dark is too railroad-y?

9 Upvotes

I found this review for Cthulhu Dark from 2018, here are some excerpts:

As much as I loved how well Cthulhu Dark captures the essence of Lovecraft’s works, I had some complaints of it as a game. Cthulhu Dark is extremely railroad-y. The game largely consists of moving the players along from point A to B and trying to unsettle them badly along the way.[...]

Another frustration I encountered was the level of control exerted by the Director role itself. The Director themselves is aptly named; there’s not a lot of room for player agency of the story itself. In a lot of ways, it functions like a standard video game narrative in this regard. Players might choose to make one choice or another, but ultimately, they’re being trotted along through a series of locations and scenes the Director came up with ahead of time towards an inevitable end.[...]

Had I been on the other side of the table, however, this sort of system would have driven me crazy. Generally speaking, if I’m going to play in someone else’s pre-built story, I’d rather just go play a video game.

What do you think about this? Is this a problem/feature of the game system itself or is it purely the way this particular scenario (Screams of the Children) was written?


On a related note, the Cthulhu Dark book says this about the intent of the system:

The Investigators are doomed from the start and the players should enjoy the journey as they slowly lose their minds. This isn’t a game about winning, but about having fun with losing. That’s the point.

Does Cthulhu Dark still work well when trying to create a somewhat more lighthearted and hopeful mood? For example if you run Call of Cthulhu scenarios like Blackwater Creek, Amidst the Ancient Trees or Crimson Letters. I understand that this is not what this system set out to do, but I would appreciate your input, if any of you have experience with this.


r/CthulhuDark • • Oct 23 '21

Stoked for Halloween

9 Upvotes

This past year I've taken up the role of Call of Cthulhu Keeper for my dnd group when we can't all make it for sessions since our group is so large and we have varying schedules.

The podcast Ain't Slayed Nobody was my introduction to Cthulhu Dark with the mini-arc Fairyland ran by the author himself, Scott Dorward (u/scottdorward) and I immediately fell in love with the simple yet effective game mechanics.

I'm excited for the opportunity to run this Cthulhu Dark scenario for my group, augmented by the Cthulhu Dark book which I still think is the single best book to learn how to write and re-write your horror stories.

Fairyland is one of the horror stories which has stayed with me for months. It can be purchased from https://thievesoftime.bigcartel.com/product/fairyland


r/CthulhuDark • • Oct 06 '23

On the 'Failure Die' and its place in the fiction

8 Upvotes

I recently watched Graham Walmsley running 'Miskatonic Shoreside Conservatory' which helped to finally cement in my mind one of the key roles of the Failure Die.

Many times in horror stories the protagonist will find themselves gripped by some inability to act normally — to do what they want to do, or to turn aside when that would seem sensible. The inability to just reach out and turn on the light switch; to cry out for help; to resist the tune of the pied piper. These are often quite mundane things. A story I read recently hinged on a spell cast over a town which hid the true horror from the townsfolk. Despite mountains of police evidence of murders going back decades, everybody who'd been there found it really hard to pull these facts to mind. A police officer sits down to write the case notes for a gruesome murder that has just happened and finds it hard to remember where the body was found, what the scene had been like.

I think it's moments like these which signal to the reader that something interesting is happening.

Often RPG advice for rolls hinges on only asking for a roll where failure is interesting. For horror, where being in control of yourself is increasingly in question, the fact that failure is possible is itself interesting. The manual touches on this briefly (p44 'Asking For Rolls'), but most often in the context of resisting the horror. I mean this explicitly in the context of creating tension by asking for mundane acts.

There is an actual play of Cosmic Dark, Graham Walmsley's new space horror system in development, where one PC says (from memory) "oh, we've only been here an hour" and Graham asks for a roll against the Failure Die. It was an inconsequential remark to make but suddenly the table tension ramps right up. It's possible to fail when casually estimating the time! And of course the delicious nature of the system is that you can also have "too much success", so even when the Failure Die is low the PC's dice can be very high.


r/CthulhuDark • • Jun 21 '23

Dark War - An adaptation of Cthulhu Dark focused on survival in war settings

8 Upvotes

Hi!

My name is Pablo López, an amateur ttrpg creator. I'm thrilled to announce the release of Dark War, a adaptation of the Cthulhu Dark system.

Dark War takes the core elements of Cthulhu Dark and transforms them into a versatile system focused on survival in war settings. It offers a rules-light approach that allows players to fully immerse themselves in the narrative, making tough decisions and facing constant dangers.

I want to express my gratitude to Graham Walmsley, the mind behind Cthulhu Dark, for his collaboration and support in the creation of Dark War.

I invite you all to dive into the gripping world of Dark War and experience the intense and exciting gameplay it offers.

You can download Dark War for free at https://yopablo.itch.io/dark-war

I'd love to hear your feedback! If you have any thoughts, comments, or suggestions, please don't hesitate to reach out. Your input is invaluable in helping me improve Dark War and create even better RPG experiences in the future.

Thanks.


r/CthulhuDark • • Jun 01 '23

Symphony Entertainment Presents: Indie June! w/ Never Going Home, Cthulhu Dark, and Moonlight on Roseville Beach (All Run by Their Creators!!!)

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/CthulhuDark • • Apr 01 '23

Cthulhu Deep Green Foundry System

8 Upvotes

As a follow up to my Cthulhu Dark Foundry system, I created a Cthulhu Deep Green one. It's now available on the Foundry VTT package manager. Feel free to ping me if you find any bugs.

Foundry Link:

https://foundryvtt.com/packages/cthulhudeepgreen


r/CthulhuDark • • Mar 13 '23

My Cthulhu Dark Foundry System has been approved and added to the Foundry Package Manager

Thumbnail foundryvtt.com
8 Upvotes

r/CthulhuDark • • Sep 07 '20

So i ran Screams of The Children this past weekend for three long-time friends - it went great!

8 Upvotes

We had a blast. I'd DM'd once for DND doing the Wolves of Welton one-shot i rewrote and felt it went just as good despite being a different system and experience. My players were all inexperienced, though one played DND many many moons ago. Minimal character creation, the five minutes worth of rules read before the session, and i sent an introduction to set up the story the day before as well, and that was all really appreciated by them. The session went for about 4 hours.

"It's 1850 in London and Lily has just told you she's leaving the lodging house and the Old Nichol Rookery to live with her lover Jack. She's had nothing but positive things to say about him, stories of romance, and being swept off her feet to a better life on the West side of London, living a life of luxury mixing with the upper class.. You all sit at dinner and are wishing Lily well on her next adventure. As Lily goes to leave, you all smell the river Thames sickly sweet rotting smell and have a sense of foreboding regarding her departure, but don't say anything to her about it. You spend the entire year regretting not mentioning it, as you haven't seen or heard from Lily at all in the time since she left. It's 1851 now, and you're all returning from work to that same lodging house in the Old Nichol Rookery- this is where our story will begin at _______"

The Investigators were a mudlark, a pickpocket and one fellow wanted to be a fur trader. They all got to use their specialities somehow during the game which was grand. The book recommended during the intro to ask them how they spent their day, and i got to shoehorn the gentleman into each of their work day quite well. The mudlark saw one standing on the banks of the river, the pickpocket got an expensive pocket watch off him, and the fur trader was in the back of a shop and watched a transaction go down with one.

I felt i really stepped up the experience as we played late in the evening, and i brought three very warm dollar store battery operated light bulbs, and also used candles for the only lighting in the room. I used Micheal Ghelfi's and Graham Plowmans tracks from youtube for music, changing music during every scene. I also used RPG Mixer for a screaming sound when they hear the baby's wailing under the water.

We wrapped up around 1am and i got glowing reviews then, and more the following day. One of them of his own accord messaged me about us using the coloured lightbulbs he has in storage, and found a candle holder i can use next time i come over. Next up is Mumbai 2037!

I don't know if this breaks copyright, and i will take it down immediately upon being told to do so, but here are my notes for the session, including the tracks i used, my pre-session prep, etc. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1_MkosqiwjOF4tMV1vR-uAunLIQF3uNWQSHZkaUYGNo4/copy

Thank you Graham Walmsley! Your book is wicked.


r/CthulhuDark • • Nov 24 '19

Here's some people playing Cthulhu:Dark because I desperately want this sub to be alive

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes