Ethereum's Pied Piper - Vitalik Buterin recently gave a sermon entitled, "What in the Ethereum application ecosystem excites me" - let's dig into this and see if, indeed, any of this is exciting to anybody other than Mr. Buterin and his missionaries...
Fun fact: This time last year or two, Vitalik was championing the value of NFTs as a great "use case" for crypto. Notice there's nothing about them in his latest sermon...
Source: https://vitalik.ca/general/2022/12/05/excited.html
What in the Ethereum application ecosystem excites me
Ten, five, or even two years ago, my opinions on what Ethereum and blockchains can do for the world were very abstract. "This is a general-purpose technology, like C++", I would say; of course, it has specific properties like decentralization, openness and censorship resistance, but beyond that it's just too early to say which specific applications are going to make the most sense.
This is still, by far the standard narrative for all of crypto. "It's still early!" We are 14 years into the tech. Maybe not that long in Ethereum, but still, that's the main narrative for all cryptos. Ethereum has lots more functionality than Bitcoin, but it's still a solution looking for a problem... Let's see if anywhere in this diatribe there's an actual problem being solved by Eth technology, and most importantly, Is Eth's solution the best approach? Or is it merely just another "use case" that blockchain's square peg, is hammered into an application's round hole?
Today's world is no longer that world. Today, enough time has passed that there are few ideas that are completely unexplored: if something succeeds, it will probably be some version of something that has already been discussed in blogs and forums and conferences on multiple occasions. We've also come closer to identifying fundamental limits of the space. Many DAOs have had a fair chance with an enthusiastic audience willing to participate in them despite the inconveniences and fees, and many have underperformed. Industrial supply-chain applications have not gone anywhere. Decentralized Amazon on the blockchain has not happened. But it's also a world where we have seen genuine and growing adoption of a few key applications that are meeting people's real needs - and those are the applications that we need to focus on.
Notice more ambiguous un-qualifiable statements.
we have seen genuine and growing adoption of a few key applications that are meeting people's real needs
blah, blah, blah.... WHAT APPLICATIONS?
Hence my change in perspective: my excitement about Ethereum is now no longer based in the potential for undiscovered unknowns, but rather in a few specific categories of applications that are proving themselves already, and are only getting stronger.
What are these applications, and which applications am I no longer optimistic about? That is what this post will be about.
Hoooray! We might get some specifics so we can actually see whether or not any of these claims hold water?
Before we dive into this, it's important to note that blockchain and crypto is an incredibly convoluted technology that has yet to be proven to be even competitive with existing non-blockchain systems on virtually every conceivable system.
So the operative thing here is: Show us one solid example of something blockchain does that's better than a comparable non-blockchain solution?
This should be really simple. That question can be easily answered for virtually every disruptive technology that blockchain has been compared to, from "The Internet" to fax machines.
Money: the first and still most important app
When I first visited Argentina in December last year, one of the experiences I remember well was walking around on Christmas Day, when almost everything is closed, looking for a coffee shop. After passing by about five closed ones, we finally found one that was open. When we walked in, the owner recognized me, and immediately showed me that he has ETH and other crypto-assets on his Binance account. We ordered tea and snacks, and we asked if we could pay in ETH. The coffee shop owner obliged, and showed me the QR code for his Binance deposit address, to which I sent about $20 of ETH from my Status wallet on my phone.
There's a huge difference between an anecdotal happenstance of a random guy in a coffeehouse willing to trade you a coffee for some crypto, and actually claiming crypto is in any way, a form of "money."
Tiny, trivial purchases like coffee (or a t-shirt from Tesla) are minute enough to fall below the AML/regulatory/taxation radar, but transactions significantly larger are nowhere near as easy to pull off. This isn't a sign crypto is "money" any more than a child opening a lemonade stand in front of their house, is an example of an "Initial Public Offering."
This was far from the most meaningful use of cryptocurrency that is taking place in the country. Others are using it to save money, transfer money internationally, make payments for large and important transactions, and much more. But even still, the fact that I randomly found a coffee shop and it happened to accept cryptocurrency showed the sheer reach of adoption. Unlike wealthy countries like the United States, where financial transactions are easy to make and 8% inflation is considered extreme, in Argentina and many other countries around the world, links to global financial systems are more limited and extreme inflation is a reality every day. Cryptocurrency often steps in as a lifeline.
First off, there's one big lie we have to expose:
Crypto is not "money"; most people are not using crypto as "money", and in those rare situations where you can use crypto in a material transaction, it's hardly easy, cheap and efficient
In addition to Binance, there is also an increasing number of local exchanges, and you can see advertisements for them everywhere including at airports.
So there are crypto ads in airports. The only thing this proves is that some people like to advertise their get-rich-quick schemes in airports.
The one issue with my coffee transaction is that it did not really make pragmatic sense. The fee was high, about a third of the value of the transaction. The transaction took several minutes to confirm: I believe that at the time, Status did not yet support sending proper EIP-1559 transactions that more reliably confirm quickly. If, like many other Argentinian crypto users, I had simply had a Binance wallet, the transfer would have been free and instant.
Ahhh, thank you for at least being honest. The coffee transaction was indeed, an inferior, more expensive, more time-consuming way than just using traditional non-blockchain methods.
A year later, however, the calculus is different. As a side effect of the Merge, transactions get included significantly more quickly and the chain has become more stable, making it safer to accept transactions after fewer confirmations.
Is this calculus really different? Note that there's no metrics or actual evidence here to make that comparison that things have significantly changed. Eth's movement from PoW to PoS probably has resulted in faster transaction processing, and due to Eth's larger block size and smaller block completion time, it is significantly faster than Bitcoin at this point, but still.... you're comparing Eth to Eth. You may have made your blockchain's transactions slightly more efficient, but in comparison to credit card processing, it's still not competitive, and laughably slow.
So now we're seeing what this theme really is about... it's about how Vitalik can see improvements in the Ethereum ecosystem, but that still doesn't prove that anything Ethereum's blockchain does, is still anywhere near as useful to everybody else in the real world. Credit card transactions are faster, cheaper, and most importantly, a lot safer with more consumer protections.
Scaling technology such as optimistic and ZK rollups is proceeding quickly. Social recovery and multisig wallets are becoming more practical with account abstraction. These trends will take years to play out as the technology develops, but progress is already being made.
In other words..."It's still early!"(tm)
Get used to hearing that overused talking point whenever somebody asks the obvious question, "What does this tech do that's better than what I've already been using for decades?"
there is an important "push factor" driving interest in transacting on-chain: the FTX collapse, which has reminded everyone, Latin Americans included, that even the most trustworthy-seeming centralized services may not be trustworthy after all.
Does that also include centralized systems like, say, The Ethereum Foundation? and Eth's core development team which is not put in place or regulated by any obvious amount of "consensus?"
Cryptocurrency in wealthy countries
In wealthy countries, the more extreme use cases around surviving high inflation and doing basic financial activities at all usually do not apply. But cryptocurrency still has significant value.
Ahhh, the 'ol "crypto has value" (because I say so) argument. It never gets old.
In reality, any 'value' crypto has is wholly extrinsic value - and most things that have extrinsic value only retain that value because of powerful centralized interests, like nation-states that mandate fiat as legal tender. In a de-centralized world, managing popularity and acceptance of something is exponentially more difficult.
For every crypto that 3 out of 10 people acknowledge has value, there's 1000 cryptos 0 out of 10 people acknowledge has value. This is not what I'd consider any reliable "sense of value."
Vitalik's "crypto has value" argument is like proclaiming the bumper from a 1971 Volkswagon Beetle has value because you found somebody who would pay you $500 for it. Good for you. But note that to the rest of the planet, whose needs don't align up with that cherry-picked, anecdotal scenario, really could care less. And once you start promoting your rusty bumpers outside of the La Jolla Volkswagon Collectors Club, your milage may vary.
As someone who has used it to make donations (to quite normal organizations in many countries), I can personally confirm that it is far more convenient than traditional banking.
More bullshit anecdotal evidence. Vitalik thinks it's super convenient to make donations in crypto. Therefore it should be the same for everybody? Meanwhile the vast majority of non-profit organizations don't accept crypto. But let's not talk about the real world... we're busy focusing on Vitalik's little anecdotal bubble...
It's also valuable for industries and activities at risk of being deplatformed by payment processors - a category which includes many industries that are perfectly legal under most countries' laws.
This is another lie. Crypto can't protect you from being de-platformed. Blockchain wallets can and have been blacklisted. If you do something bad enough, and there's crypto involved, because of blockchain's transparent ledger, your "money" can be held hostage and you can be de-platformed at any place that would accept or convert your crypto. This has already happened with Ethereum and their network. More examples here and here.
There is also the important broader philosophical case for cryptocurrency as private money: the transition to a "cashless society" is being taken advantage of by many governments as an opportunity to introduce levels of financial surveillance that would be unimaginable 100 years ago. Cryptocurrency is the only thing currently being developed that can realistically combine the benefits of digitization with cash-like respect for personal privacy.
Now... this is just bullshit. If you're worried about "financial privacy" the last thing in the world you want to do is have every transaction you make codified in an immutable public ledger.
That Vitalik would even bring this up as any sort of solution to "financial surveillance" is so absurd, he must be trolling people.
But in either case, cryptocurrency is far from perfect. Even with all the technical, user experience and account safety problems solved, it remains a fact that cryptocurrency is volatile, and the volatility can make it difficult to use for savings and business. For that reason, we have...
Stablecoins
Oh sweet lord Jeebus, you are telling us you have any trust or faith in so-called "stablecoins?"
Dude... ?
Almost none of these so-called stablecoins have been properly audited. We have no evidence whatsoever that there's adequate liquidity backing up those coins. There's overwhelming evidence they're all a bunch of frauds. See: here for a classic example.
What's the biggest problem with stablecoins? Ask anybody. You know what they should say? "Lack of guarantee of liquidity." Stablecoins are supposed to represent fiat. Fiat is not on the blockchain. How can any blockchain-based "solution" for stablecoins guarantee where the actual liquidity backing up those stablecoins is? It's theoretically impossible. Blockchain cannot guarantee the existence/authenticity of anything off-chain. This is the "Oracle problem" that blockchain can't solve, and why so-called "solutions" are bogus. You still have to trust some central authority off-chain, and that authority is what matters -- not what's on blockchain.
Stablecoins issued on-chain have many convenient properties: they are open for use by anyone, they are resistant to the most large-scale and opaque forms of censorship (the issuer can blacklist and freeze addresses, but such blacklisting is transparent, and there are literal transaction fee costs associated with freezing each address), and they interact well with on-chain infrastructure (accounts, DEXes, etc). But it's not clear how long this state of affairs will last, and so there is a need to keep working on other alternatives.
He says stablecoins are censorship resistant, then he admits they can be censored, but it's ok because "such blacklisting is transparent?" Really? And how do you know these blacklists are transparent?
I wonder how many people tried to transact with blacklisted wallet addresses and the exchanges actually told them they were blacklisted? As opposed to the much more likely scenario of simply saying, "We're having problems with your account - can you send us more pictures of your passport and bank accounts?"
I see the stablecoin design space as basically being split into three different categories: centralized stablecoins, DAO-governed real-world-asset backed stablecoins and governance-minimized crypto-backed stablecoins.
Ahh, so this is more of the "It's still early" argument. Let's take all the good things we can fabricate and cherry pick about existing stablecoins that have not collapsed yet, and suggest that we can de-centralize them and make them better....despite no evidence this is true.
If you're following along at home, so far, there's not a single thing that has been de-centralized that's resulted in something better. But hey, try to kick the football... This time Vitalik promises he won't pull it away at the last minute.
Let's skip over this stablecoin blather... it's so full of flaws nobody who's paying attention to the market really would buy that blockchain can fix anything.
2. Defi: keep it simple
Decentralized finance is, in my view, a category that started off honorable but limited, turned into somewhat of an overcapitalized monster that relied on unsustainable forms of yield farming, and is now in the early stages of setting down into a stable medium, improving security and refocusing on a few applications that are particularly valuable.
Hmmm, so Vitalik is saying De-Fi is settling down into some valuable applications?
What are those applications? How con-veeeeenient you don't enumerate them.
Many of us would say De-Fi is settling all right. It's settling like a house of cards that will eventually crumble to the ground because, like other crypto securities, there is no actual value creation anywhere. It's just highly-leveraged gambling, in a casino that's un-regulated and often un-accountable.
Decentralized stablecoins are, and probably forever will be, the most important defi product
So, what we have here is, "Just wait, we're coming up with an application for blockchain..." and now it's "decentralized stablecoins"... but we've already seen systems like Terra-Luna collapse. There's no indication more decentralization or using a different blockchain would produce different results.
3. The identity ecosystem: ENS, SIWE, PoH, POAPs, SBTs
"Identity" is a complicated concept that can mean many things. Some examples include:
Basic authentication: simply proving that action A (eg. sending a transaction or logging into a website) was authorized by some agent that has some identifier, such as an ETH address or a public key, without attempting to say anything else about who or what the agent is.
Attestations: proving claims about an agent made by other agents ("Bob attests that he knows Alice", "the government of Canada attests that Charlie is a citizen")
Names: establishing consensus that a particular human-readable name can be used to refer to a particular agent.
Proof of personhood: proving that an agent is human, and guaranteeing that each human can only obtain one identity through the proof of personhood system (this is often done with attestations, so it's not an entirely separate category, but it's a hugely important special case)
The whole "blockchain can verify authenticity" argument is another lie. I fully debunk this in my video on the subject. In short, blockchain provides no verification. It merely parrots what centralized, third-party oracles decide is and isn't authentic. Blockchain adds absolutely nothing of value to such situations.
And enumerating the different things that can be authenticated is a distraction. In each of those cases, the actual authentication is done by central authorities - if those authorities make an improper authetication, then what's on blockchain is wrong. Blockchain has nothing to do with the process other than give certain tech-illiterate people, a false sense of security.
In Vitalik's article, he has a picture of a laminate with the caption: "An NFC card that contains my ENS name, and allows you to receive a POAP verifying that you've met me. I'm not sure I want to create any further incentive for people to bug me really hard to get my POAP, but this seems fun and useful for other people."
This NFC "authentication card" he carries around is a great example of the total false sense of security. Depending upon the type of NFC, it's trivially easy to walk up to him and scan his card with something like a handheld Flipper Zero, clone his ID card, and then begin to create my own totally false "authentication" on the blockchain that I am now Vitalik Buterin. AND, anybody who would argue otherwise saying his card couldn't be so easily cloned, is either wrong, or they're pointing to the inherent security in the encrypted NFC standard being used, and NOT in anything blockchain brings to the situation that aids in authenticity.
Again, if you sincerely believe blockchain can help verify authenticity, please watch this video - you are wrong. There is no ambiguity here. These people are lying. This is why all these so-called blockchain authenticity applications have completely failed.
4. DAOs
"DAO" is a powerful term that captures many of the hopes and dreams that people have put into the crypto space to build more democratic, resilient and efficient forms of governance.
Here we go... more ambiguous, flowery language that is utterly devoid of any quantifiable specifics. This is "par" for any and all crypto discourse: Be ambiguous. Always allude to grandiosity in vague terms so that nobody can specifically test anything you're saying as being true or false.
It's also an incredibly broad term whose meaning has evolved a lot over the years. Most generally, a DAO is a smart contract that is meant to represent a structure of ownership or control over some asset or process. But this structure could be anything, from the lowly multisig to highly sophisticated multi-chamber governance mechanisms like those proposed for the Optimism Collective. Many of these structures work, and many others cannot, or at least are very mismatched to the goals that they are trying to achieve.
If you've been following along, you'll note that we've already determined blockchain can't verify authenticity, so a smart-contract-based consensus system still suffers from the same "Oracle Problems" authentication apps inherit. But DAOs are even worse, because this so-called "democratic" system isn't really democratic. When you think of "democracy" what comes to mind? Usually: 1 person, 1 vote right? But that's now how DAOs work. It's 1-token = 1-vote. And typically in DAOs there's usually one entity that has enough tokens to unilaterally dictate what "consensus" means in that model. So it's hardly democratic. This is another farce.
Here's a slide from my documentary that compares DAOs to Stocks - which is one of the concepts crypto people try to borrow from (and make much worse):
https://i.imgur.com/872l2ur.jpeg
In short, DAOs are another sleazy mechanism that tries to copy the traditional stock market's system of shareholder influence, but reduce the actual amount of influence with little to no accountability and oversight.
Decentralization for efficiency
Decentralization for efficiency is a different school of thought: decentralized governance structure is valuable because it can incorporate opinions from more diverse voices at different scales, and decentralized implementation is valuable because it can sometimes be more efficient and lower cost than traditional legal-system-based approaches.
This is more abstract, philosophical rambling.
To date, we have not been shown a single example of how de-centralizing anything using blockchain, makes it in any way, more "efficient." I continue to be open to examples, but still have never seen a single solid example. Here's the list of failed examples.
Vitalik's sermon goes on to talk ambiguously, philosophically about the so-called benefit of de-centralizing things.... but there are glaring problems in these implementations he either ignores, or doesn't want anybody to be aware of.
In a general sense, consensus mechanisms really can't work without some authority to enforce those mechanisms, and "code" is not adequate or capable of doing this -- especially regarding anything happening off-chain. Nobody is compelled to give creedence to what any blockchain entry says. So the only way that's enforced is through some sort of central authority. Vitalik keeps ignoring this obvious elephant in the room.
I have to assume Vitalik is a smart guy - he sometimes acknowledges the challenges and complexities of these applications, but he so often ignores such glaring problems that I have to assume it's intentional. You cannot be so analytical, yet oblivious to fatal flaws in your design. It just doesn't make sense, until you realize promoting a specific narrative is what makes you rich AF.
Case study: Gitcoin Grants
We can analyze the different styles of decentralization through an interesting edge-case: Gitcoin Grants. Should Gitcoin Grants be an on-chain DAO, or should it just be a centralized org?
This is more philosophical meandering... Any attempt to make a grant system efficient and legitimate would be a function, NOT of its use of a DAO or whether it was de-centralized, but the specific details of how consensus and decisions are made, and which entities have how much influence and power? We already know that in the world of blockchain, there is absolutely no facility that can stop singular powerful special interests from exerting control. De-centralizing something doesn't make it take-over-proof. The whole system revolves around a pay-to-vote scheme, favoring those who have more money & resources.
How would a DAO differ from say, a standard board of directors? The legitimacy of the body's decisions isn't a function of how decision makers make decisions. It centers around who's on the board, what their agenda is, and whether or not there's appropriate checks and balances. In blockchain, there really aren't any checks and balances. There's just tokens and whoever has the most tokens, has the most influence. You can vote for board members. You can't decide who has DAO tokens typically.
5. Hybrid applications
There are many applications that are not entirely on-chain, but that take advantage of both blockchains and other systems to improve their trust models.
That statement is a lie. There has yet to be any evidence that "blockchain improves the trust model." See here.
Voting is an excellent example.
No it isn't. Blockchain can't determine who votes for whom. It just records the votes a central authority/oracle dictates.
If you want to champion the value of online/digital voting and verifying your participation using cryptographic signatures, I'm totally on board with that and think it's a great idea.
But note.. nowhere in that sentence is there any mention of "blockchain." You don't need blockchain, nor de-centralization to achieve more reliable voting mechanisms. You can use traditional centralized databases with cryptographic signing to ensure peoples' votes are properly counted. That would be a good thing. Blockchain adds nothing to the application except more fault intolerance and less efficiency.
High assurances of censorship resistance, auditability and privacy are all required, and systems like MACI effectively combine blockchains, ZK-SNARKs and a limited centralized (or M-of-N) layer for scalability and coercion resistance to achieve all of these guarantees.
All this fancy technobabble is a distraction. ZK-SNARKS, M-of-N... blah blah... none of that matters. There are simpler, easier, more secure ways to digitally handle voting without blockchain. Just use a private/public keypair that can authenticate your vote. Done. The data can be stored anywhere. No need for SNARKS or M&Ns or whatever that stuff is that nobody cares about.
So how do we get there?
Many of these applications are being built today, though many of these applications are seeing only limited usage because of the limitations of present-day technology. Blockchains are not scalable, transactions until recently took a fairly long time to reliably get included on the chain, and present-day wallets give users an uncomfortable choice between low convenience and low security. In the longer term, many of these applications will need to overcome the specter of privacy issues.
These are all problems that can be solved
Translation: "It's still early!"
Sorry guys... we're 14 years into this. In less than that same time we went from putting some metal in orbit, to landing a man on the moon. It shouldn't take this long to come up with a single bona fide blockchain app that does something objectively better.